This is one of the most useful reviews/tests I've seen on youtube. You're not defining a use case, you're simply testing and letting everyone reach their own conclusion
Love the test but the automotive and equipment rubber and plastics have much better compunds than the cheap rubber bands… I’m assuming the cheap rubber bands are made of natural rubber? Also would love to see the WD silicone spray!
@@crownator Most people don't know about silicone spray but actually this is the best option whenever different materials combine together such as rubber or plastic.
Try armorall if you prefer chemicals. I use 1:1 non-acidic liquid hand soap and glycerin combo in conjunction with 5-10% castor oil for lubricating rubber strands inside my rubber powered airplanes (many others have the same recipe).
I don't like the idea of a spray as it is hard to control. Yes I can spray a rag!LOL. A good paste product with silicone (since the new weatherstrip has silicone in it and not fully rubber at all) helps to restore the rubber. Next, I would have gone to the wrecking yard and picked up real rubber used in the cars, then made comparisons. Rubber bands are not the same composition:) At least not as much today. I am going to try the lanolin and see how that works, but on a sample first. Weather strip for my car is very expensive!:)LOL Hey, thank you for helping!
Hi. I put a pint of brake fluid in a crankcase with 5.5 quarts new motor oil. Do you think that will do anything bad for 5,000 miles? Brake fluid is mostly polymer based as polyglycol ethers.
@@TCSC47I wouldn't use it generally but I would *definitely* not use it for that if there's any aluminum in there. KY is mostly 3 just things with a few additives. The bulk of it is water + carrageenan. Carrageenan is a starch from red sea weed that's very commonly used as a thickening agent in food products. Once the water dries out, you just have starch, which isn't much of a lubricant. They cut it with glycerin as well, to give it the overall texture/viscosity/feel/whatever that they want. It's about 25%-33% glycerin. This is the only part with any staying power and you could just buy straight glycerin at any pharmacy if you want. Even then, in my experience, glycerin doesn't make a very good lubricant were you want it to work for very long. The rest of it is a cocktail of things that are in there to prevent bacteria and such from growing in the bottle and to balance the acidity. One of those things is lye. Aluminum really does not like lye. It's got to be pretty damn dilute, but still. I would definitely not be putting it on aluminum.
@@ColonelSandersLite Cheers CSL. Interesting and useful answer. My wife pointed out to me shortly after I posted my question, that the water base of KY would dry out after a shortish while and the lubricating properties would be lost anyway.
I am not a scientist but this seems like a bad test. If the rubber band snapped in place other than where you treated it, then it tells you nothing. I would first treat each rubber band and then stretched them over the pvc pipe. p.s. and ofc add control. This is also a test for this type of rubber and not every other kind. I would also repeat this experiment a few times to see if I would get consistent results.
So it seems gun oil is the safer bet. Which makes sense considering most modern firearms have either polymer furniture or even polymer frames like most handguns so you absolutely need oil that's safe for plastic. Some furniture is rubberized too. Looking for something safe for my airsoft gun the manual says to use silicone based oil. Most of what I have for lube is either automotive or gun lube. I have a couple cans of silicone spray lube but I hate using stuff from a spray can when a drop of oil will do.
Thanks I'm looking to condition some thick 8 guage 220 power cords to help protect them on jobsites, extend their usability and prevent them from cracking...was thinking about spraying them with either silicone spray or WD40 then wiping them down...but I wont be using WD40 now...any suggestions for conditioning and preserving 50 ft black rubber 3 wire 220 volt power cords ?
Just look at the ingredients. Some of these "silicone" sprays contain "ACETONE" which will destroy rubber. One such product is "PB Blaster Silicone Lubricant", NOT good for rubber door seals!
That's one thing I've noticed when buying Silicone spray lube. One product my say safe and great for rubber and plastic, while another says. do not use, will damage plastic. Pretty sure it's because of the different solvents used.
Testing on an unknown rubber compound gives no practical info. We don’t know what else is made from the same compound as those bands. Probably nothing that is designed to last more than a few days in someone’s hair.
Sorry bud, but this is ridiculous. The rubber (bands) you're testing is not the same rubber compound use where these products were intended for, such as auto window seals or home windows or doors. Your conclusions are faulty based on extremely bad testing methodology. At the very least, the tested material should be what the tested product is intended for. No one on earth would buy a product to lubricate a rubber band!
this explains a lot.
Thanks for such a nice side by side review for all these products.
This is one of the most useful reviews/tests I've seen on youtube. You're not defining a use case, you're simply testing and letting everyone reach their own conclusion
Love the test but the automotive and equipment rubber and plastics have much better compunds than the cheap rubber bands… I’m assuming the cheap rubber bands are made of natural rubber? Also would love to see the WD silicone spray!
There's more than one WD40 product, some of which are made to be safe on rubber and seals for example on door wall sliders etc...
should have maybe added silicone spray
Exactly, I was also wondering about silicone spray too
@@crownator Most people don't know about silicone spray but actually this is the best option whenever different materials combine together such as rubber or plastic.
Try armorall if you prefer chemicals. I use 1:1 non-acidic liquid hand soap and glycerin combo in conjunction with 5-10% castor oil for lubricating rubber strands inside my rubber powered airplanes (many others have the same recipe).
I don't like the idea of a spray as it is hard to control. Yes I can spray a rag!LOL. A good paste product with silicone (since the new weatherstrip has silicone in it and not fully rubber at all) helps to restore the rubber. Next, I would have gone to the wrecking yard and picked up real rubber used in the cars, then made comparisons. Rubber bands are not the same composition:) At least not as much today. I am going to try the lanolin and see how that works, but on a sample first. Weather strip for my car is very expensive!:)LOL Hey, thank you for helping!
Well I think he did a good job and it was a great idea and I learn not to use some of them but yeah I wondered about the silicone
Hi. I put a pint of brake fluid in a crankcase with 5.5 quarts new motor oil. Do you think that will do anything bad for 5,000 miles? Brake fluid is mostly polymer based as polyglycol ethers.
Great video thanks man!
-you should do another test with the 3 n 1 silicone
What about for cleaning parts?
Why not K-Y jelly, for use in situations where failure is not an option.
I wondered this. Have you used K-Y jelly for lubricating model airplane motors?
@@TCSC47I wouldn't use it generally but I would *definitely* not use it for that if there's any aluminum in there.
KY is mostly 3 just things with a few additives.
The bulk of it is water + carrageenan. Carrageenan is a starch from red sea weed that's very commonly used as a thickening agent in food products. Once the water dries out, you just have starch, which isn't much of a lubricant.
They cut it with glycerin as well, to give it the overall texture/viscosity/feel/whatever that they want. It's about 25%-33% glycerin. This is the only part with any staying power and you could just buy straight glycerin at any pharmacy if you want. Even then, in my experience, glycerin doesn't make a very good lubricant were you want it to work for very long.
The rest of it is a cocktail of things that are in there to prevent bacteria and such from growing in the bottle and to balance the acidity. One of those things is lye. Aluminum really does not like lye. It's got to be pretty damn dilute, but still. I would definitely not be putting it on aluminum.
@@ColonelSandersLite Cheers CSL. Interesting and useful answer. My wife pointed out to me shortly after I posted my question, that the water base of KY would dry out after a shortish while and the lubricating properties would be lost anyway.
@@TCSC47i wonder what would be the best lubricant if KY isnt an option
Wonderful experiment
I am not a scientist but this seems like a bad test. If the rubber band snapped in place other than where you treated it, then it tells you nothing. I would first treat each rubber band and then stretched them over the pvc pipe.
p.s. and ofc add control. This is also a test for this type of rubber and not every other kind. I would also repeat this experiment a few times to see if I would get consistent results.
I wonder how Fluid Film would have performed.
So it seems gun oil is the safer bet. Which makes sense considering most modern firearms have either polymer furniture or even polymer frames like most handguns so you absolutely need oil that's safe for plastic. Some furniture is rubberized too. Looking for something safe for my airsoft gun the manual says to use silicone based oil. Most of what I have for lube is either automotive or gun lube. I have a couple cans of silicone spray lube but I hate using stuff from a spray can when a drop of oil will do.
Yeah but those rubber bands have other things in it that your car bushings and rubber hoses won't
It would have been nice to also add mineral oil to the test.
Thanks I'm looking to condition some thick 8 guage 220 power cords to help protect them on jobsites, extend their usability and prevent them from cracking...was thinking about spraying them with either silicone spray or WD40 then wiping them down...but I wont be using WD40 now...any suggestions for conditioning and preserving 50 ft black rubber 3 wire 220 volt power cords ?
gracias
Just look at the ingredients. Some of these "silicone" sprays contain "ACETONE" which will destroy rubber. One such product is "PB Blaster Silicone Lubricant", NOT good for rubber door seals!
That's one thing I've noticed when buying Silicone spray lube.
One product my say safe and great for rubber and plastic, while another says. do not use, will damage plastic.
Pretty sure it's because of the different solvents used.
Rubber bands
Testing on an unknown rubber compound gives no practical info. We don’t know what else is made from the same compound as those bands. Probably nothing that is designed to last more than a few days in someone’s hair.
Sorry bud, but this is ridiculous. The rubber (bands) you're testing is not the same rubber compound use where these products were intended for, such as auto window seals or home windows or doors. Your conclusions are faulty based on extremely bad testing methodology. At the very least, the tested material should be what the tested product is intended for. No one on earth would buy a product to lubricate a rubber band!
You and the few who liked your comment have the common sense most people do not. -thank you.
Agreed, stupidest test Ive seen to date.
Fix a flat stuff saves rubber safely
The video is so confusing SMH
Rubber is not plastic.
Is this a high school project?
This is not a good review , the use of rubber bands is not telling me any thing please rethink your experiment and don't use those thin rubber band
Moral of the story, don’t smoke meth and post videos on RUclips of yourself doing some weird shit 🤦♂️
Practice not looking at yourself on the viewfinder and look at the camera