@@aardappel8450 i dont care. i want first person, thats how it always was. it kicked ass in BF3 and was perfect in BF4. no need to change something that just worked.
yup. remember when BF3 came out and you saw the first takedowns ? like you said, it was so personal. it was only a second, but felt like a movie scene when you looked the enemy in the eyes while killing them. In BF4 they were smooth as fuck, now we got this shit no real BF player ever wanted.
@@WLTRMOTTER I still remember my first fronatal takedown of a lying enemy. Was on the Back to Karkand urban map, on the top off the building overlooking the upper market. Just jamming that knife into a support players eye socket. Nasty. Awesome.
I did a takedown on someone laying down and it made them standup for a terrible animation, I think it was this animation in the video. Just why? Bring the BF4 takedowns back.
@@NorthernLaw_ yeh but that’s cod. Immersion isn’t cods thing. Battlefield is supposed to be immersive, and the first person takedown were a bf thing. Now it looks like DICE is trying to appeal to the cod fanboys.
@@CD-R828 Meh, I wouldn't say they're trying to appeal to the point that its annoying. Besides its still an Open Beta, Im sure theres a "First Person or Third Person" option for takedowns later on
Nothing about it works: -Camera snaps leading to disorientation -Same for the 3rd person view and turned camera -Way to quick to be gratifying or just looking impressive -Immersion breaking without functional purpose. -Suffering from the fact how f..ing awesome takedowns used to be -LIKE SERIOUSLY: Watch Bf3-4-1 takedowns. Those being 1st person was a feature, not a limitation.
@@houdini3_562 they could've made special melee weapons and make them in battle pass too, and make every melee weapon have its own animation like bf1 every melee weapon has its brutal style of animation
I agree. I dont know what they were on when they made the game. Its far to arcady for a Battlfield game. It feels like it's trying to be a twitch shooter INSTEAD if a semi realistic type of game. I dont know. I enjoyed what I've played of the beta but I'm still surprised that they made the game far too similar to Call Of Duty!!! Bfv wasn't this arcady. I'm not going to lie. I kind of feel like the priorities weren't straight. Take tornadoes and massive stuff out the game. Make the game 128 and give it destruction on a large scale. Every building every wall every Beam can be toppled. I think if they started there and also emchanced the graphics. Then maybe the next game could have crazy types of events but now. Fir the next Battlfield I honestly wanted a true next gen game. But this is a game between console cycles so I'll give them thwt but I donr know. The core game is off. I feel like some of it just isn't there.
I think it'd be great if Dice could add a first person animation option for people stuck in their ways with how good BF3/BF4 animations were, but I'll be glad to have the extra opportunity to see my personally kitted out soldiers
They only made it 3rd person so players would see eachothers cosmetics. And I'm sure you can buy those with real money. So in the end it's about money not your preferences 😐
They did this because now they've implemented specialists and you can customize them with different skins, probably took inspiration from WZ to give it that extra selling point along with customizable weapons and vehicles by means of cosmetics items. Honestly, I'm all for it if they can pull it off, but I prefer the 1st person takedowns from previous BF titles. Hopefully they add in an option on the final build to turn it off or something. Since most likely I'll be spending my time on Portal Mode, and only doing the regular Conquest Mode for ranking up and unlocking equipment I can use on Portal (assuming portal doesn't have a god mode feature where every weapon/vehicle add on is already unlocked for sandbox testing) since Portal is kind of like a pseudo-level editor, but more close to a mission/match editor since you can't edit the maps themselves
@@dinglemccringleberry9019 yeah my biggest concern is there will be too much to do so that the bulk of players will be split amongst the different game types leading to apparent low population.
Yeah, i know, looks bad af, but BF 2042 developers said Early access is for gameplay impressions, so its not finished work yet, if the finishers are still like this in november when the game comes out THEN i and everyone will be disappointed
@@hiwander Sadly, I agree. I say sadly because I don't see how anyone would enjoy 3rd person takedowns in the middle of a 128 players mayhem. Nobody will use takedowns unless you're in a completely open area, away from all trouble, with time to spare. And even then so what's the point...
I really hope battlefield devs listen to their fans and remove this 3rd person view from executions. Also, the whole operator skins thing is ridiculous. American operators playing on the Russian army team. Completely kills the immersion.
It could be okay, just think the camera positioning on this one didn't really... hehe... "pan out". That's actually a serious comment, btw. I'd say the bigger issue is how "great" and responsive are bots seen in this very clip :)
I think they're fine. A lot better than being insta-gibbed by some idiot with a club just because you had < 50 HP and they pressed F while in a certain range of you
It is closer to that much of a disaster because it takes you out of the action. Same with third person vehicle entering. Who's idea was it to make it an out of body experience!? Also the classic and iconic battlefield situation of being also stabbed right after you stabbed someone will never happen again, because you can see behind you when doing the takedown, and can react. So sneaking up to an enemy taking out a dude won't be be as possible and satisfying because they will see you coming. Battlefield was always first person only and that is what made it so immersive. For me, this is a huge deal because battlefield 4s takedowns was a big part of the game that got me into it. Immersion and team play mechanics is the battlefield formula and they completely ruined this game for me because they ditched both of those aspects. It is no longer class based, it is no longer immersive, the graphics are way too clean and not nearly as gritty enough. They copied Warzone in so many ways and I hate the fact that they did.
@@Jesse-oi2ly It has to be at least optional. And yes third person vehicle driving camera is there and it has its use cases and always has been. But this abruptly changing perspective would be a deal breaker for me if it's not something I can turn off.
At least let us choose between 3rd person or 1st person take downs. Love the immersive first person knife fights or the silent take downs. As for for the take down as what I've seen, it's nice and simple, and fast. But if it's gonna be fast, why is it 3rd person?? :c
i think 3rd person take downs are only good in halo. what hooked me on battlefield was that it was more immersive and 'realistic' than cod, the first person takedowns were a huge part of it, they were quick and clean i think 2042 should use first person takedowns, i think they will first look way better, and it would let me see my knife remember titanfall 1 first person animations? incedible, and while titanfall 2 is objectively the better game, the takedowns as pilot and in mech are disappointing. i got the same type of disappointment here
I must say i fucking HATE the punch melee. No way in hell you would let go of your gun to punch someone instead of smacking them with the butt of your gun or knifing them like in every other battlefield.
First person takedown is much more satisfying for Battlefield. I get that they're trying to go with cod and titanfall execution but atleast put some more effort on the animation
But but but if this is 1st person you wouldnt see your paid costume in action. This is bad news. They gonna microtransaction the hell outta this game...
Just a takedown compilation from BF1 (Open Beta)* ruclips.net/video/4PAV3rKLHpk/видео.html _*no need for a timecode, even skipping trough it should make a point._
I hope they ditch the 3rd person melee, or at least make it optional. It looks wack and takes you out of the action. Totally immersion breaking and not Battlefield at all... Oh and also, it breaks immersion even further when I can see what's behind me while doing the takedown. Like wtf!? Getting stabbed right when or after you are stabbing someone is a battlefield classic scenario.
They wanted to copy modern warfare takedowns, but instead they look so janky right out of a mobile game. Like honestly the first person animations were a staple of the BF franchise, why they would willingly remove them for this hot garbage is baffling. And it's also here to stay, even if the community hates them, they've already poured money and resources to animate them they won't replace them with first person ones later...
@@aussiehighlands2715 I assume you search for "Battlefield 2042 Beta" on the Xbox store? Hope that helps, I really don't know much about Xbox as I'm on PS5. Cheers!
They looked at war zone and said yeah let’s do that stuff nah G fuckin keep it real wid old battlefield stuff yano fucking this game looking fishy to me yano like
People also complained about shitty hitreg and netcode in BF4 that to this day is begging for ending its misery not to mention that people literally called BF4 a "worse copy of BF3" and guess what? this game is dope after 7 years Yall overreacting
@@ThePhilRobbProject well my specialist just start kicking the enemy, but not making a takedown, ofc while standing in the back of him. Ok thanks anyway;)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
That's sad. The old first person animations were so smooth and personal. Literally face to face with enemies.
It's still a beta, they might add some fancier takedowns in the real game
@@aardappel8450 i dont care. i want first person, thats how it always was. it kicked ass in BF3 and was perfect in BF4. no need to change something that just worked.
yup. remember when BF3 came out and you saw the first takedowns ? like you said, it was so personal.
it was only a second, but felt like a movie scene when you looked the enemy in the eyes while killing them.
In BF4 they were smooth as fuck, now we got this shit no real BF player ever wanted.
@@WLTRMOTTER I still remember my first fronatal takedown of a lying enemy. Was on the Back to Karkand urban map, on the top off the building overlooking the upper market. Just jamming that knife into a support players eye socket. Nasty. Awesome.
I grabbed a lady in bfv lying on her back by her collar and smashed her head off the ground lol
I did a takedown on someone laying down and it made them standup for a terrible animation, I think it was this animation in the video. Just why? Bring the BF4 takedowns back.
It seems like a placeholder.
Yep, completely stripped all the animations except the standing one, most likely to sell them as MTX, like COD does
@@AFriendlyThief Or its just a beta build that doesnt have all the animations yet
Or BF3's since they were faster and didn't have a stupid counter knife.
It will change. You can see a takedown animation while the enemy is laying in BF2042 Gameplay Trailer.
Not a big fan of 3rd person takedowns
I think you should be able to choose because after seeing what infinity Ward did with Modern Warfares takedowns, I think 3rd person is amazing
@@NorthernLaw_ yeh but that’s cod. Immersion isn’t cods thing. Battlefield is supposed to be immersive, and the first person takedown were a bf thing. Now it looks like DICE is trying to appeal to the cod fanboys.
@@CD-R828 Meh, I wouldn't say they're trying to appeal to the point that its annoying. Besides its still an Open Beta, Im sure theres a "First Person or Third Person" option for takedowns later on
@@NorthernLaw_ That was just so they could sell you new ones.
@@CD-R828 nope
The classic bf3/4 knife kills were the best
They look like shit though
Remember how sad the bf3 guys looked when you did a finisher?
Oh I dunno, bf1 had that brutality aspect.
@@analien4813 Yeah, agreed. BF1 takedowns were the best. I like BFV takedowns too.
I overall prefer the first person takedowns muuuuuuuch more.
Please don't lump BF3 with 4. They aren't comparable in terms of fun and skill based gameplay.
FIRST PERSON
Nothing about it works:
-Camera snaps leading to disorientation
-Same for the 3rd person view and turned camera
-Way to quick to be gratifying or just looking impressive
-Immersion breaking without functional purpose.
-Suffering from the fact how f..ing awesome takedowns used to be
-LIKE SERIOUSLY: Watch Bf3-4-1 takedowns. Those being 1st person was a feature, not a limitation.
These are all points I’ve been saying to my friends and they just say “who cares” and I’m like “literally every veteran bf knifer”
@@frozenclipz7453 i am not a bf veteran but i 100% agree with, plus they need to change the sliding cause it feels arcady asf
@@alix4306 yea I don’t understand why they didn’t just port over bf5’s movement
I hope there is something in the setting to disable this 3rd person shit
Yeah me too
It's not
Not a fan of this one, that COD-like approach; I hope they cut it along with the armor plates.
Yeah naw we need first person LOL.
I prefer the 1st person takedowns so much more fluid and authentic
I just love the BF4 kills in first person, even when the enemy can counter attack you... that "face to face" was so great
First person or nothing.
You: First person or I cry 😭
🤣
@@xpandahangoverx what
@@xpandahangoverx No, no. If you look, I said, "First person or nothing." Crying has nothing to do with it.
BF3/4 knife takedowns were great.
Why does the movement and gunplay look abit wonky?
BFV has a really smooth movement system and gunplay
It feels wonky too!!
@@ThePhilRobbProject
Wtf happened to them saying that 2042 will retain BFV's movement system?
V's movement was smooth
@@Jonas-ej7id no thay said that the gun play was going to be more like V
@@inflamedzero4994 i don't think that's true at all. I personally didn't think it played like V at all. It feels so... heavy and slow
Fuck this I play battlefield to get away from cod but this game just feels like cod it doesn’t have that battlefield feel
ye feels like a mix of warzone and battlefield hardline XD
@B J it is obviously to sell take downs or they are gonna have them in the battle pass. So disappointed they are going this route.
@@houdini3_562 they could've made special melee weapons and make them in battle pass too, and make every melee weapon have its own animation like bf1 every melee weapon has its brutal style of animation
In my opinion this battlefield gives me bf4/3 vibes and I’m lovin it 👍
I agree. I dont know what they were on when they made the game. Its far to arcady for a Battlfield game. It feels like it's trying to be a twitch shooter INSTEAD if a semi realistic type of game. I dont know.
I enjoyed what I've played of the beta but I'm still surprised that they made the game far too similar to Call Of Duty!!!
Bfv wasn't this arcady. I'm not going to lie. I kind of feel like the priorities weren't straight.
Take tornadoes and massive stuff out the game.
Make the game 128 and give it destruction on a large scale. Every building every wall every Beam can be toppled. I think if they started there and also emchanced the graphics. Then maybe the next game could have crazy types of events but now. Fir the next Battlfield I honestly wanted a true next gen game. But this is a game between console cycles so I'll give them thwt but I donr know. The core game is off. I feel like some of it just isn't there.
I think it'd be great if Dice could add a first person animation option for people stuck in their ways with how good BF3/BF4 animations were, but I'll be glad to have the extra opportunity to see my personally kitted out soldiers
I want dogtag yoinks back, hiring that call of duty joker was the biggest mistake dice have made
I just want to collect dog tags like I used to in BF3. No need for a triple backflip bigbangkamehameha executions for 15$
They only made it 3rd person so players would see eachothers cosmetics. And I'm sure you can buy those with real money.
So in the end it's about money not your preferences 😐
But that makes no sense. Why not just look at the cosmetics in the killed by cam?
they should just recycle the bf4's knife animations if they're too lazy to make new ones
DICE have made the same soldiers for both sides and sometimes, for example, Mackay knifes Mackay.
It's the beta, this only happens in the beta dude
@@sardineman7087 But not in the previous betas.
@@sardineman7087 specialists r here i doubt theyre scrapping in favor for skin selling. Stop feeding its a beta excuse.
They did this because now they've implemented specialists and you can customize them with different skins, probably took inspiration from WZ to give it that extra selling point along with customizable weapons and vehicles by means of cosmetics items.
Honestly, I'm all for it if they can pull it off, but I prefer the 1st person takedowns from previous BF titles. Hopefully they add in an option on the final build to turn it off or something. Since most likely I'll be spending my time on Portal Mode, and only doing the regular Conquest Mode for ranking up and unlocking equipment I can use on Portal (assuming portal doesn't have a god mode feature where every weapon/vehicle add on is already unlocked for sandbox testing) since Portal is kind of like a pseudo-level editor, but more close to a mission/match editor since you can't edit the maps themselves
Bet the majority will be playing portal and not the main game
@@codename1176 Also there's still Hazard Zone to add to the mix.
@@dinglemccringleberry9019 yeah my biggest concern is there will be too much to do so that the bulk of players will be split amongst the different game types leading to apparent low population.
One thing I dont like is how stiff it looks when ADS
I like the bf4 knife sticking up close and personal and dog tag ripping
bruh i am so excited when i takedown someone with the knife on bf4 on 2042 it just feel meh
I already wasn't a fan of the operators replacing generic soldiers in Battlefield 2042 but now with this 3rd Person Takedown it just feels wrong
Why does the bots have cooler apperance than the operators tho
I hope they listen, and give us, at least the option for first person
At least it doesn't look as goofy like the Modern Warfare takedowns. Simplicity is the key. Don't need Mortal Kombat moves in this game
i dont think this is what people meant when they said they wanted different...this isnt different this is just warzone
That is indeed awful. They gotta sort that out before launch. Also it works only if he is standing otherwise it looks horrific.
I like the first person animations much better
Can't they bring back the old BF takedowns? The ones in BF1 were a bit brutal but oddly satisfying
Yeah, i know, looks bad af, but BF 2042 developers said Early access is for gameplay impressions, so its not finished work yet, if the finishers are still like this in november when the game comes out THEN i and everyone will be disappointed
You have not learned yet that that this is the same excuse used in every beta? this is the final product. November is a few weeks from now.
If this was the halo technical demo I would have believed you but this is coming out in November I'm pretty sure this is it
3rd person takedowns arent going anywhere. Only thing that might change in the final product is that they might polish the animations a bit.
@@hiwander Sadly, I agree. I say sadly because I don't see how anyone would enjoy 3rd person takedowns in the middle of a 128 players mayhem. Nobody will use takedowns unless you're in a completely open area, away from all trouble, with time to spare. And even then so what's the point...
Battlefield is just COD now
Wonder where I've seen 3rd person executions from...
Man the AI get all these cool skins then we get these Call of Duty looking characters for the beta LOL
I hope in the final build they refine it
First person for sure the whole game is basically in First person
I really hope battlefield devs listen to their fans and remove this 3rd person view from executions. Also, the whole operator skins thing is ridiculous. American operators playing on the Russian army team. Completely kills the immersion.
Battlefield 2042 make fans nostalgian to battlefield 3
It could be okay, just think the camera positioning on this one didn't really... hehe... "pan out".
That's actually a serious comment, btw. I'd say the bigger issue is how "great" and responsive are bots seen in this very clip :)
It's the beta everyone chill please stop crying how bad it looks I bet it will get better when the game is out
Nope, never liked 3rd person takedowns. Bring back the classic 1st person takedown.
Animation looks taken from f2p game
This gave me whiplash
BF3 had better first person animations than this crap, its satisfying to see the dogtags being taken
The AI soldier is what they should sell.
The gameplay feels like warface
I think they're fine. A lot better than being insta-gibbed by some idiot with a club just because you had < 50 HP and they pressed F while in a certain range of you
I wished it was first person only, feel like there copying cod
Cod dev: interesting...
Helô my friend,eu joguei no PS5 e tá show de bola!!!!!❣️
People pretending as if BTF will die because of 3rd person takedowns. BF4 had better ones but it's not that much of a disaster...
It is closer to that much of a disaster because it takes you out of the action. Same with third person vehicle entering.
Who's idea was it to make it an out of body experience!?
Also the classic and iconic battlefield situation of being also stabbed right after you stabbed someone will never happen again, because you can see behind you when doing the takedown, and can react.
So sneaking up to an enemy taking out a dude won't be be as possible and satisfying because they will see you coming.
Battlefield was always first person only and that is what made it so immersive.
For me, this is a huge deal because battlefield 4s takedowns was a big part of the game that got me into it.
Immersion and team play mechanics is the battlefield formula and they completely ruined this game for me because they ditched both of those aspects.
It is no longer class based, it is no longer immersive, the graphics are way too clean and not nearly as gritty enough.
They copied Warzone in so many ways and I hate the fact that they did.
@@Cheesesalad You can also third person a vehicle so. Maybe you can turn on and turn off going third person? Could be a flexible solution
@@Jesse-oi2ly It has to be at least optional. And yes third person vehicle driving camera is there and it has its use cases and always has been. But this abruptly changing perspective would be a deal breaker for me if it's not something I can turn off.
The ai bot looks better than all the specialist combined.
not a single fucking real BF player wanted third person Takedowns.
At least let us choose between 3rd person or 1st person take downs. Love the immersive first person knife fights or the silent take downs.
As for for the take down as what I've seen, it's nice and simple, and fast. But if it's gonna be fast, why is it 3rd person??
:c
Do you have to hold the melee button down (pc) or not cause it canceled one of mine cause I didn't hold it .
The reason RUclips hide the dislike button
damn this game seems to run so smooth on the consoles
while i got a 2080ti and i9 and can barely get 80fps on medium
lmao
😀
I cant even get 30 on a gtx 1060 and r5 2600... Already refunded the preorder
Bring back first person
Its soooo bad. RIP Battlefield
i think 3rd person take downs are only good in halo. what hooked me on battlefield was that it was more immersive and 'realistic' than cod, the first person takedowns were a huge part of it, they were quick and clean
i think 2042 should use first person takedowns, i think they will first look way better, and it would let me see my knife
remember titanfall 1 first person animations? incedible, and while titanfall 2 is objectively the better game, the takedowns as pilot and in mech are disappointing. i got the same type of disappointment here
I must say i fucking HATE the punch melee.
No way in hell you would let go of your gun to punch someone instead of smacking them with the butt of your gun or knifing them like in every other battlefield.
First person takedown is much more satisfying for Battlefield. I get that they're trying to go with cod and titanfall execution but atleast put some more effort on the animation
But but but if this is 1st person you wouldnt see your paid costume in action. This is bad news. They gonna microtransaction the hell outta this game...
Yeah, it's time to copy CoD lol
BF3/4 takedowns were iconic, BF1/5 takedowns were brutal and satisfying - why do we need this garbage? Just why? Who asked for this?
Oh so turning it like COD
Can you share your sensivity options
All soldier stick sensitivity at 100%. I have backed it off to 90% now and it seems to be a little easier to control. Hope that helps!
@@ThePhilRobbProject thank you
How did u turn around so quickly on console? Did u amp up the sensibility?
Sensibility
Yeah I had it on 100%
fps takedowns were clearly better :(
Does not look like motion capture quality
Just a takedown compilation from BF1 (Open Beta)*
ruclips.net/video/4PAV3rKLHpk/видео.html
_*no need for a timecode, even skipping trough it should make a point._
I hope they ditch the 3rd person melee, or at least make it optional. It looks wack and takes you out of the action. Totally immersion breaking and not Battlefield at all...
Oh and also, it breaks immersion even further when I can see what's behind me while doing the takedown.
Like wtf!? Getting stabbed right when or after you are stabbing someone is a battlefield classic scenario.
Uff pls no 3d person kills with knife
That was fucking horrendous
yo they did took a lot of stuff from warzone and put it here
That animation looked kinda scuffed to me
Looks very scuffed
Oh…My…God… this is the end boys CoD will take over Battlefield, BF2042 is the first steps
Hur hur BF2042 must be realisitic
Everyone else: *Playing the game, providing meaningful feedback*
This comment section: "B-B-But mah fIrsT pErSoN takedowns??? This gAmE iS baD." 😂
It break immersion/pace
I want to play battlefield, not codshit
@JellyGhost__ lol didnt even buy BFV, DICE failed to deliver a good WW2 experience so I dodged it loool, nice assumption though.
@@alanalb1449 Then play the game, it's that easy lol.
@@AB-fr2ei Not so sure about that.
They wanted to copy modern warfare takedowns, but instead they look so janky right out of a mobile game. Like honestly the first person animations were a staple of the BF franchise, why they would willingly remove them for this hot garbage is baffling.
And it's also here to stay, even if the community hates them, they've already poured money and resources to animate them they won't replace them with first person ones later...
These shit devs can't help themselves but try to make a decent franchise look and play like Warzone in almost every aspect.
How do I play this
Pre-order the game or wait until 8th of October for the open Beta!
@@ThePhilRobbProject aight it's the 8th today where do I download the beta from? (I'm on Xbox)
@@aussiehighlands2715 I assume you search for "Battlefield 2042 Beta" on the Xbox store? Hope that helps, I really don't know much about Xbox as I'm on PS5. Cheers!
Battlefied: Modern Warfare 2049
Another "feature" nobody has asked for and few like... Give us back the 1st person takedowns!
A lot of people are overreacting. These animations are pretty lackluster though
They looked at war zone and said yeah let’s do that stuff nah G fuckin keep it real wid old battlefield stuff yano fucking this game looking fishy to me yano like
CELL from crysis?
They went COD fuck man its sad
meh
People also complained about shitty hitreg and netcode in BF4 that to this day is begging for ending its misery not to mention that people literally called BF4 a "worse copy of BF3" and guess what? this game is dope after 7 years
Yall overreacting
Well if bf4 was perfect at launch it would have been 10 times better plus I think people are tired of dice disappointing them
PVP ... first kill ... AI ... second .... AI :)
please stop with 3rd person takedown, do you think enemy team will let you do something that flashy in battlefield ????
What button have you press to make a takedown?
R3 on PS5. Not sure about the rest of the platforms?
@@ThePhilRobbProject well my specialist just start kicking the enemy, but not making a takedown, ofc while standing in the back of him. Ok thanks anyway;)
@@unnmmd yeah it seems you have to be right in a "sweet spot" for it to work. Ihope they change this.
@@ThePhilRobbProject thanks;)
Horrible
How did the guy you did the takedown on have a skin equipped
It's a bot. They don't have the specialist skins.
i hate it.
First person please!!
I hope this game doesn't end up being like warzone. Oh wait it has a fov slider on console, nevermind.