Bodycam video: Deputies detain Black mother, daughters at Castro Valley Starbucks.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 мар 2023
- Alameda County sheriff's deputies detain the Loggervale family at Castro Valley Starbucks in Sept. 20, 2019. Read the full story here. bit.ly/3ZGXtNs
We need a federal law that makes muting audio or otherwise tampering with body worn cameras illegal.
That is a huge part of policing that needs reform with consequential punishment for the officers who willfully participate in doing that.
Exactly!
Already a crime, it is evidence tampering/destruction......
Finger blocking, camera not pointing at the case and jiggling when it's no reason for it when vital evidence is occurring and the sound turn off is so blatant. Transparency lmao
Funny the footage didn't go far enough to show the women being released...But then again, just a laundry list of questions here....
Muting a bodycam should be a crime
It is called evidence tampering/destruction.
It’s a 30 second buffer period.
if you need to hear the muted portion of video im sure all the other officers cam caught it smh
It should be an immediate dismissal.
@@paulworth7638 Not the point
it's scary to think you can be sitting in your car minding your business and then getting arrested the next minute
For not Obeying
@Nova wrong 🤡 you have rights that don't come from the law. Then you have rights that are protected by laws of the constitution. Your ignorance of the law is no excuse
@Nova their was no pull over for an observed violation on traffic laws.. They were already parked. So no they dont have to provide ID nor even talk to the officers because no crime has been committed nor did the police accuse them of a crime. They need to articulate reasonable suspicion the person has committed, was in the process of committing, or will be committing a crime. None of that occured and only they didnt follow my commands that were not backed by law.. So unlawful commands will not be followed. The founding fathers would call u a red coat
@Nova she didn’t have to tell them anything. You know nothing about the law
@Nova is that why she won the lawsuit?
The most disgusting thing is that the police department did an internal investigation and found nothing wrong. Whoever was in charge of that investigation needs to be fired. How can anyone who knows the law find nothing wrong here?
And the two cops are both still employed by the department. They've both been promoted. Unbelievable.
This is what happens when you support public unions
This is what happens, when blacks and Hispanics are trolling for lawsuit money..fn criminals
This women conjured it up, like all blacks and Hispanics do ,to claim. Awlll no ,walmart, target, wawa, any bissness, that tired of bein ripped off by blacks and Hispanics. For looting in flash mobs,...thoze bissness are leaving or left because of black and Hispanic thievery.....pathetic people
@@lockandloadlikehell hey ASSHAT, did these black pos get 8million dollars OR NOT.
Do you know the names of those officers?
At some point, these setttlements should come out of the Sheriff's Department budget or pension.
Right on! There has to be accountability
Abolish qualified immunity. Make cops purchase insurance just like doctors have to for mistakes they make. Taxpayers should never be forced to shoulder the financial burden for cops who are negligent because they know mistakes don't cost them personally.
👏
At some point, it needs to come out of their family, even if they have to sell their organs.
Should come from the felons with sworn oaths committing the felonies.......
Sad part is he is not only dumb to the laws no other officer stops him. They should all be held accountable
"no other officer stops him"
That is the bigger problem IMO. The bad actors are never reigned in by others. So who is worse? The bad cop or the supossedly good cops who don't stop the bad cop but instead enable him. Where is the cop saying, "What is the genesis of this encounter?"
It takes 6-8 years to go through law school & graduate... then get your law license in order to be an attorney, so that you can interpret the law. Police go through 3 -6 months of training to enforce law that it takes an attorney 8+ years to be able to do. How is it that you can enforce laws and you don't know what the laws are.
@@jermainejaieworships And in many (most?) jusdiction a high school diploma is the only "education" needed
He is doing his job all she had to was to show id and what is the point of getting one if you ain’t using it he fell for her scam poor guy
@@mohaali8023 That's just it: he wasn't doing his job. He decided to randomly fvck with them for no reason and then leaned into his bs once they didn't instantly obey his illegal orders. Police can't pick someone "at random" and demand to see their papers. Eff him and everyone else involved in this altercation
“We’re detaining her for…uhhhh.”
“You don’t question what we do.”
That’s what won them the lawsuit. Two clear examples of them violating her rights. Having no actual reason for detaining/cuffing her. Then literally telling her that she can’t invoke her rights by asking for a supervisor and question why she’s being detained.
It should be illegal for then to mess with the body cams when recording
Death penalty sounds good!
Not illegal but against policy.
@LeinaVance that's why he said it should be illegal
@@LeinaVance it’s should be illegal for them to turn off audio, and video devices, especially when they force citizens to relinquish control of their recording devices during detainment.
@@xionxxx3359 I'm saying it shouldn't be illegal but it should be against policy.
Muting the audio should be an automatic dismissal!! This is truly insane!!
Ended up being a lot more then a case of dismissal, that lady was awarded $8.25 million.
@@Hollerboy931 excellent 👏
i saw no problem with it
@@Hollerboy931 wow amazing! Good thing she stood up for her rights!
I saw that @JM931. I just hope the judge doesn't reduce it. They deserve EVERY penny!! The officers should've been fired also.
What the fuck good are body cameras if they mute them or turn them off whenever they want?!
They do it because they have been doing it in years past and no one has been enforcing it.
Watch your mouth! You need to mute yourself.
how can officers be proved wrong in court... but not liable within the department? that's crazy!!
The system protects the system!
They didn't do anything wrong. Watch the OJ trial to learn about jury bias.
@@BareTheMark what crime did the women commit for the encounter? Did they detain these women for a crime? Is not giving your ID for not committing a crime a crime? Now let me introduce you to what is called the law and what officers can legally do because they did nothing legal in this. They searched without a warrant, detained without a crime, and basically violated all of these womens rights and their police department was actually investigated by the DOJ and found they violated folks rights.
As a Canadian who travels a lot to the states and stop to rest once in awhile this is scary. Too much power with these cops
@Ingrid Smithers• and things have gotten even worse in Florida, Ron DaSatan just allowed damn near everybody to walk around with concealed guns.
DeSatan is declaring open season in Florida if someone just sneezes wrong.
@@madmaximilian5783 guns owner has nothing to do with racisttt pigggs vs black family in a car
Scandalous. As a brown man watching from Europe, this is a worrying and scary insight into US justice. The internal affairs investigation found nothing wrong with theses tyrants violating those innocents. They’ are clearly proud of the actions of their officers by rewarding them with promotions for sub-standard policing and think there’s nothing to learn. The people thought differently
"Don't worry we have a lawsuit"
Indeed they do a $8 plus million dollar settlement awarded to this family.
It wasn't a settlement, it was a judgement by a jury... Which is even better. The settlement offer was $750k but she took it the whole way and got over $8 million.
@Sardissozo I know what it is i read the entire case not the news so I don't need you correcting me.
@@runitback5066 obviously you do, because it wasn't a "settlement." The more you know.
@Sardissozo Exactly what I thought read a few news articles picked choosed what appeared to your understanding. Just put it in park.
Did they pay them 8 million dollars settlement?
This happened in 2019, and the family was awarded 8.25 million dollars by a jury. Justice.
Good
I bet they already spent it all on cars and drugs!!!!
Good 🎉🎉🎉thank God
lawyers took 40% lol
@Try To Travel still a win. 5 mil is 5 mil
Muting the body cam video should be against the law..it's obvious they had something to hide. Understanding this family did win their lawsuit but all trust in the police system has been broken and no amount of money can replace that. Beyond humiliating, I can only imagine the trauma this family is still experiencing 🙏🏽🙏🏽
Did u you know cops were first called slave catchers from the beginning
Disgusting. I feel so bad for them. Totally uncalled for. They don't need this crap. And he knows he's being recorded! What?! Superiority complex. She's not calm and chill bc she knows how this could go. You just validated her reaction!!
Cop: it's not gonna go anywhere
Judge: 7.5 million, we went there
If that was the actual outcome that makes me so damn happy for that family.
Needs to have federal law mandating that these law suits are paid by the cops pensions, personal incomes, home liens etc until paid in full. Breaking them financially for life.
@@MA-wo5yk That my friend is a Brilliant idea! Should make it into a law for police and false accusers.
So shady how he can just mute his bodycam like that
This infuriates me! And they keep getting away with this mess!😡😡😡
It sucks. ..but justice prevailed in the end. Hopefully they fired this narcissist copper.
I know, blacks use racism to get out of everything. It's just an excuse to not listen. We're tired of them hiding behind their skin color.
I know it is TRULY DISGUSTING and unfortunately I don't see any change coming ESPECIALLY with people who defend these despicable interactions and poor performing law enforcement officers!
@@constancevillano4017 stop voting for public unions
This is just awful on how terrified she and her children were . And she was having a panic attack. .. I’m so happy that family won.
i have seen some black people ACT A Fool in front of the kids they have, with a cop doing his/her job...... you are like the judge you wanna "feel sorry for their race" so lets just give them 8million dollars
@@anamegoeshereI’ve seen whites do meth and smoke crack by a tree at a Carl’s JR.
@@anamegoeshere because having all their rights violated, being handcuffed and put in the back of police cars, having police go thru your things and humiliate you for no crime. You might want to watch that video for all the violations the officers committed?
@@anamegoesherebro you got brain damage
Terrified my ass! She was teaching her kids how to act against authority. Her kids will then teach their kids. Who needs a father figure in the family when they can behave like this in the face of a policeman trying to keep the neighbourhood safe.
That cop kept saying that's fine. Well they got suspended without pay and the lady won 8.5 million dollars. That's the most expensive cup of coffee the city had to pay.
Imagine the days before body cams and how many folks were beyond violated. Sickening.
So we’re in a time where you can’t sleep in your car at Starbucks.
Imagine life in the deep south 1963
If your black yes.
@@David.lovesU only ppl who lived it, parents lived it. Or us who watched Docs on PBS, History Ch know this. Millions don't know, care or angrily GAF. Cuff a gal going in to pee, or get coffee? This F'n cop ain't alone
Yeah! Especially in the South!!
Just read the update on the family taking this to trial and winning. So glad to hear that. Can someone please provide an update on what happened to the officers? I’m sure they obviously lost their job but were they charged?
The trump supporters of the Alameda police department promoted both of these officers to sergeant. This happened in 2019 under the trump regime!!!!
@@eeheath06 whattt
His parents must be so proud of him
This cop should be Fired and prosecuted..
They were promoted, according to what I read.....smh.
Promoted to what? Nazi soldier?
Qualified immunity as a certified slave catcher. Fat chance.
@@DarqEagle56 you read a comment saying that, or a confirmed source?
Get rid of QUALIFIED IMMUNITY and these cops would stop doing this stuff...they have no skin in the game and nothing to fear...that badge is nothing but a hunting license and WE are the prey...
Don't be a victim nor their prey....have you ever heard of "THE HUNTER IS NOW THE HUNTED"???? Payback is GOLDEN! These are nothing less than a bunch of cowardly thugs hiding behind a badge....or so they falsely think cause PAYBACK IS GOLDEN, enough said!
So did the two cops really get a promotion? If that’s the case then no amount of monetary compensation the family received will make it right.
I’m so sorry this happened to you I’ve experienced it once and will never trust a cop again it still disturbing to me in the end he had to let me go because he had nothing, it’s a very scary experience
2A BABY
Never trust a cop again ? Everyone is alike ?? So if I get robbed and he happens to be black.. does that mean all black men will rob me ? Of course not !! We're all just people. The majority of people, of police... are just trying to live their life.... Please don't lump people together, it's wrong.
UPDATE!!!!!! A jury awarded this family $8.25 million dollars for being violated the way they were. Alameda County offered the family $700k but they declined the offer and took their case to trial where a jury awarded the a huge sum of $8.25 million dollars.
Nice , did the officer “resign “ ? Get fired ? I would assume or guess if you just caused that amount of money
What an ignorant jury.
@@hadtocheathimtobeathim6549 STFU TROLL.
Thanks for the update. I seen so many violations by the officers in this video. They all need to be retrained and learn the California statues….hopefully, they were terminated
@@hadtocheathimtobeathim6549 the officer was ignorant 🙄 because the jury saw thru bs make it make sense.
Nice how he muted his audio recording when "conducting his Investigation" ( conspiring with his co-workers as to what false charges to make up).Looks like that whole department is corrupt. Hope those ladies get a huge settlement and take those officers qualified immunity.
@James gotfryd She got 8.25 million🤑the video is on the side "jury awards 8.25 million to black mother and daughters"
that to me is the most telling part of the entire debacle...he thinks she's got drugs or drug money and that's what he's after so he can get bragging rights and a promotion, she was already talking about getting a lawyer and filing a lawsuit so he knew he was in trouble out the gate but thought he was going to find something in the vehicle...he found something alright ~ a momma bear that knows her rights and stood her ground, good for her...
why did they turn off the audio on cameras off
@@marywhite2706 they turn off the audio when they know they messed up. They don't want to have a record of their conspiracy.
HECK YEA I SAW HIM TURN THAT CAMERA OFF. HE THOUGHT HE WAS SO SLICK....AZZ HOLE
ITS ALMOST TOO BAD THEIR ALLOWED TO MUTE THE AUDIO AFTER A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME OF DETAINMENT. BECAUSE THATS WHEN THE TRUTH COMES OUT AND THEY COMMUNICATE BACK AND FORTH AND GET THEIR STORIES STRAIGHT TO TRY AND WIGGLE OUT OF TROUBLE AND FIND AS MUCH DIRT AS THEY CAN.
they're
In NYS, you’re not required to show ID, although police would rather u to do so.
Lots of times when black folks randomly show their ID, police write a report for ANYTHING, just for whatever. When they could just have walked away. No. They want you to have something on your record, even if it’s the most minor thing. Which it would have to be minor since they took your ID, just to type in something. I’m glad this woman & her children won the Lawsuit. Period.
This is a PRIME EXAMPLE of why a lot of people don't like, don't trust nor respect the police ESPECIALLY THIS KIND! The way those BULLIES are talking to them is disturbing and rude!!
It's pretty much white police that do this type of shit, especially to blacks
If it is Wearing a Useless Costumed, it is to be Avoided at ALL COSTS ! WE ARE LIVING IN A POLICE STATE !
A police state. Stop being hyperbolic. You hear a bump in the night you immediately call the police. You have a domestic dispute with your spouse you immediately call the police and you expect them to fix your problem.
Your blind by fascism. Only the loud mouth driver was rude.
This is a prime example of why people hate the police and have no respect for them.
A federal jury awarded this innocent family $8.2 million for having their rights violated. Good for them. I'm grateful for the groundswell in police auditing, body cam footage, and social media posts of this kind, as of late. I have also experienced something similar to this, when I was a teenager, walking home from school. A deputy, who was extremely aggressive and rude, grabbed me. He handcuffed me, and put me in the back of his car. Drove me a few miles away, to a house, where a lady was standing outside. I repeatedly asked him "What did I do?" He said that I was seen trying to break into a house. He then brought me out, and asked her: "Is this him?" She nervously chuckled, and said "No...not even close!" You would think he would have been apologetic. Not a chance. He took me out of the cuffs, and told me I was free to leave. I asked him to dive me home, or at least where he picked me up. He was still being nasty to me, and would not even do that. Never been in trouble. I was just a regular kid who lived in a nice middle class neighborhood in the suburbs. I was 17 years old. I never told my parents what happened. I really don't know why. It makes sense that I should have. I really wish I did. Now I'm 48. And the adult me, realized that I was basically kidnapped, and traumatized. I'm not a crybaby, or anything like that. But that experience has stuck with me. And it just about brings me to tears when I think about it.
And they deserved every freaking penny. As someone who supports Law Enforcement, I also believe in Police Accountability. Hell, she should have sued the 911 Operator that hung up on her as well…
@andy, honestly, had you sued & been awarded millions, I wonder if the emotional damage would have been any less? The foul ugliness of being so violated runs so deep. I have huge difficulty getting my mind around such incidents. NOTHING will happen to the cops. Getting fired means nothing to them - they get a job in another state, keep their pensions by resigning before they can be punished (IF they do) & you live the nightmare of having been treated like an animal bound & hauled off as worthless meat. I never feel sympathy for cops who get a good smackdown. I feel for you & the millions who have sufered as you did, including this family.
Wow good for them!
How did u find out about the the monetary compensation?
@@Nanticoke It's been reported on Yahoo news.
You can’t tell me that these guys don’t get excited about causing fear and anxiety for no reason
"imma call the police" she says while talking to the police... says a lot about this country
Lawsuit, LAWSUIT, lawsuit. Where do they find these POS officers, that think they can harass citizens doing absolutely nothing.
They got 8.5 million!
It's called comply and give ID like a normal person then go on your way, but no momma needs that lawsuit, and she put her kids through trauma to get her lawsuit
@@Mike_Jones281 Thats sad, hand 8.5 mill to somone because they didnt comply, meanwhile innocent people starving on the streets all around us with no help.
@Munn34 If it were normal to hand cops ID on demand, a jury wouldn't have awarded the family 8.5 million for civil rights violations and excessive force. Your argument does not make sense.
@@munn3446 they didn't have to comply to unlawful orders
I love how they call us suspicious for not wanting to show id but they wanna turn of audio when they do the search are they trying to plant something that’s really suspicious behavior 🧐
i saw no problem with it
Indeed!
I agree. Being black and coming in contact with Americas police officers could become deadly.When a supervisor was requested, Is when her rights became violated. And she's with her kids also. Who and where do the black women turn to, when being violated... Who protects us?
@@sassimacintyre1091 How about u stop with the race baiting bullcrap? Not everything is because "Im black so I'm oppressed". Sometimes the cop is an A-Hole, sometimes, it's the person's own fault or whatever other variables.
@@Rochester92G If it was Bullcrap, it wouldn't be attached to this scenario. Last time I checked BS is healthy, fertile energy, none of what was seen here. But what I did see was 3 black woman getting violated by the white men who are supposed to be the protection for the community for which it serves. All skin folks aren't kinfolks, that statement fits perfectly, seeing your response to the way I responded to these Black woman's suffering. Can you are anybody else show me a situation where women of another race, get violated by the same people whose salary your paid taxes pays to protect you in some form???
I'm waiting...🤔❣💯
I disagree with everyone here. when a cop asks for your license, you give it to him. They should have the right to ask for that. This is why our country is so screwed up. If you're doing nothing wrong, then it shouldn't be a problem. I don't get why you are all on the family's side.
They were just awarded 8 million. Yes!
I don't see how it's legal for bodycams to be muted like this officer here did. Glad the jury ruled in the family's favor!!
Imagine how many times this has happened before bodycams. In the judicial system, the officer is always right.
Unfortunately, but it should be common knowledge that law enforcement officers are trained and paid to lie.
@@keithberry8917 YOU FORGOT KILL INNOCENT BLACK PEOPLE USING A MINORITY OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY TO JUSTIFY THE REAL TARGET. PROGRESSIVE WELL TO DO BLACK AMERICANS
@@keithberry8917 They are not trained and paid to lie. These cops are incompetent as hell, this is what you get for only 21 weeks of police academy. Most countries require 3 years or longer police academy before they get exam tests to see wether they get approved to get the badge or not.
Bodycams are saving police, actually. This video is an anomaly, and I laughed the whole way. For all the time police get unwarranted hate, this is only making matters fair.
@@keithberry8917 while people like this are born criminal
Don't let this distract you from the fact that the trump and desantis suppprters at the police station gave these heroes promotions and said they did nothing wrong!!!!
She literally just got a winning lottery
With a major side of PTSD
Funny how no crimes were committed until the police showed up and started issuing commands.
Exactly!!!
I’ve never seen a situation that can’t be made worse by the cops showing up.
i saw no problem with it
.
She knew her rights, and they did not. She did nothing wrong, so no ID is needed, and it is not required. She asked for a supervisor, and he said no. Then, an illegal search and detainment. There was no crime except for being black in Castro Velley. SMH
Obviously, this was racial profiling. But what strikes me as odd is how dumb the cops were. They mentioned she was parked in a handicap spot. I used to have a handicap plaque after an ankle surgery, and they specifically tell you at the dmv that cops have the right to verify any time I use it that I am the actually owner of that plaque. It's in the paper work you sign at the dmv. Verifying includes the handicap paperwork and your id. So the cop could have used that as justification to get her id and protected theirs butts.
@@heyaisdabombso you are giving cops tips on how to racially profile better, got ya 😉
Also these women got paid a bunch of money for being inconvenienced. I wish I got inconvenienced in the same way so I can walk away with 2 million dollars. Easiest 2 million I could ever make.
@@LazyCrazyGuy it wasn’t an inconvenience, it was a degradation.
@@Charmcity199 for 2 million dollars you can degrade me all you want. People are so sensitive, I'd be outraged if that happened to me and I didn't get a dime like many people who don't have the same knowledge or representation.
Obviously they were up to no good. As soon as the cop taps on the window she starts the car ready to drive off, but than states she was going in to the Star Bucks. 😂
They desperately search the car hoping to find something to justify their BS. Then after completing failing they stand around having a coffee klatch and making that family suffer a little longer. Of course the coward turns off his audio recording.
Racial profiling is real & frustrating as hell!!!!! Then yall wonder why black people have attitudes..
Not only do they it illegally arrest people but then they illegally searched their cars as well
They can search your car if they arrest you.
@@saturn722 ^ lawfully. they can search your car if they lawfully arrest you.
@@saturn722 That's why they were rewarded 8 plus million dollars. Because they Fd Up! Cops are PUNKS! They pick on innocent women to make themselves feel like men.
@@saturn722 It’s not even clear she was arrested.
@@saturn722 they were never arrested. They were detained.
Somebody needs to go to Supreme Court and stop them from turning off their camera phones
i saw no problem with it
.
@@koltred keep that energy when it’s you kkk
Just defund them
shes automatically goes to indignance.... comply, get it over with if youve done nothing wrong. shes behind the wheel, started the car that means you have to show your DL on demand
This is America. Do the police watch these videos? How on earth do they see nothing wrong with this encounter?
"YOU WONT LISTEN TO ME, YOU WONT SHUT UP!!!" Great de-escalation there officer. Glad someone that in check with their emotions has qualified immunity
Your job as a citizen is to don’t speak, listen to everything the officer says and acknowledge cops are never ever ever ever wrong about anything ever.
No. Fuck that. You fucking stand and you fight for your rights.
Found the cop. ^
For real man this is what dumbass cops try and do when they can’t handle their emotions so they just target the person in front or next to them even if they did nothing wrong, or even if they sit in their own vehicle parked!!🤔🤔🤔🤔😳😳😳😳🤬🤬🤬🤬 just wait until their attorney gets involved or hired, this dude is now JOBLESS!😂 what a POS PERSON/abuse of power
He muttered audio and turned the video camera up side down. Why would an officer (not violating a person's civil rights) need to obstruct potential evidence on his behalf? He
Knows that he is wrong.Iturned my phone up side down tocontinue watching.knows that he's gone too far
@@ellcoulber7270 a super easy to digitally correct there's nothing he said they were code four
The police told me always if u run away u hide something. Now a police officer muted his camera. Whats he trying to hide? Or turns it off
Refused to give ID while being caught red handed at the wheel of a motorized vehicle parked in a handicap spot. Like the panel says, this could have been an easy 250$ fine...
If you look carefully there is a handicapped sign hanging on her rear view mirror. He didn't say she was parked in that space illegally . I guess you're talking to hear yourself speak.
@@MrAiken71 Keep blaming absolutely everyone for all your problems, it's going really well for your people. As a white person, I've had to give over 2 hours of my time being investigated by the police just because I had a blue truck that fit a description. Did I chimp out? Did I scream and cry my lungs out like these animals. No. I just collaborated and after that they apologized. Try being civilized for once in your life.
Seems like most people here got it, but a few didn't, so read here: Officers may only detain and/or demand ID from an individual ONLY if they have a *REASONABLE and articulable* suspicion that they're in the process of committing a crime, have already committed a crime, or are about to commit a crime, or infraction. Sleeping in the car by itself is not reasonable suspicion. Maybe sleeping in the car with burglary tools in plain sight (window punch, prybar, etc) could fall under reasonable suspicion, or if the lady rolls her window down, and smells like alcohol, or is slurring her speech. The officers were in the wrong here.
Hell yea . Its called being brown is the crime they suspect us of. Weve been stopped so many times. And never given a ticket in Morgan Hill California. Its a dam shame.
Illegally parking in a handicap space.
Not following police orders is obstruction and resisting arrest.
Thank you!!! Don't even engage in bootlicker babble
@@pockeyway is not a crime. Who said it was illegal? No ID needed for a parking ticket anyways
He is on a fishing expedition, and she has no duty to give him her ID, he doesn't have reasonable articulable suspicion she has committed, or is about to commit a crime. These officers need to be fired and prosecuted. Their superiors and the prosecutor need to be charged as well for covering up the actions of these tyrants. All of them are culpable in a USC title 42, section 1983 and 1985 lawsuit for violating these ladies 4th amendment rights. And muting or Turning off body worn cameras is spoliation of evidence, and should be grounds for termination in itself.
Well said!
@grokroot They got promoted instead. But theIdiot got nothing like the "promotion" he just gave her. She 8 million for the whole sloppy mess he did
you're in the ghetto area, where corrupt officials are in tons...why are you suprised?
ABUSE OF POWER BY THUG COPS!
That is not a rest area. They have no right to take up space that may be needed by a paying customer.
Every single day. That's how often videos like this are posted. Policing in the US is out of control. I'm glad they got a huge settlement.
Exactly
Everything in this country is outta control 🤪
Praying to beelzabub that a these supremicist cops are deprived of o2 soon.
Stf up I'm in castro valley all the time and I'm mexican American. This case is messed up but doesn't happen often. I'm glad they're good and can now enjoy some vacation time plus everything else
So why did he have to mute the camera
Specifically, the jury found Deputy Steven Holland liable for $2.7 million to mother Aasylei Loggervale and $2 million apiece to her daughters, Aaottae Loggervale, then 17, and Aasyeli Hardege-Loggervale, then 19.
The jury also found then-Deputy Monica Pope liable for $750,000 to both daughters, and that Alameda County is liable for the actions of its deputies.
And that's how it's supposed to be done. And they should NOT have to wait 50yrs to get ALL of their money either. Thank you for your follow up on the situation. It means a lot.
And the internal investigation said the deputies did nothing wrong! When in fact they did everything wrong and NOTHING RIGHT!
Thank you so much for filling Us in, I had never even heard of this until I just watched this disturbing video. When are these idiots going to learn? They don't know anything about the law on the first amendment and the 4th amendment and the fifth amendment?
@@forsale313they will never see a dollar of that money, the courts found the cops individually responsible for the money - the cops file bankruptcy and it’s over. If the money was from the city they would get paid right away, this is an easy way to get out of paying. No problem.
That money will be gone in no time.
as soon as she stopped looking for her id and started questioning him I knew it was downhill from there. Why are blks so adamantly against being asked to show id? So many of their troubles start simply from refusing to show id, it is not an unreasonable request, their leaders need to tell their people to show id when asked and stop this nonsense!
There are other races that decline to show their id! You’re insane!
No crime was committed so it’s the officers who are in the wrong, bootlicker!
I was gonna say the same thing but she literally got 8 million dollars from this lmao she played the victim perfectly and it paid
Why do I need to give a ID if I have committed a crime. That cop had no reason to question her. It didn't make sense But I get it we should all comply because they are they police and they are in control. This country is full of sheep
@@acreatorsparadise i rest my case
The fact he got promoted is insane
How many of us have had a road trip with our families and pulled over to a rest stop to get some snacks, use the restroom, get coffee, etc. to hit the road again afterwards? Who needs to be harassed like this? This was absolutely ridiculous. Anyone who's being asked for id will, of course, become nervous especially with the way policing is getting out of hand these days. This is beyond disgusting. I don't believe this pig went through her purse. This is surreal.
Exactly
But when we are operating a motor vehicle and we're asked for our DL, we produce it. Did you not watch the video? She made a decision and that decision had consequences.
Yes leave families alone. Sweet Jesus
@@ambrr_lily The police officer made the decision to harass these women. And that decision brought consequences. So much so that both were compensated with 8 million dollars for the illegal detention.
@@ambrr_lily too bad that's not the law. Maybe go to law school or just STFU because you clearly have no idea the laws of this country and the reasoning behind them. We are not a nation ruled by men, we are a nation ruled by laws. The citizens have rights and one of those rights is to be free of harassment when we aren't doing anything illegal.
If I cost my employer $8,000,000, I'd probably lose my job
That's the problem it didn't cost his employer it cost the taxpayers that qualified immunity is a biscuit.
This particular incident don't fall under qualified immunity
The problem is the judicial system as a whole clearly clarify what is qualified immunity but the judges and the prosecutors just refuse to go and prosecute these people so if the prosecutors and judges are refusing to prosecute these police then we the people are supposed to stand up and hold them accountable.
No one is above the law
I wouldn’t dream of treating an officer that way. If he did something wrong, I would report it later to his supervisor. CRAZY!
So what. Individuals respond differently. They didn't get their payday because she got loud. They got paid 8 million because he violated her civil rights. If you knew the law and weren't biased you wouldn't have exposed yourself with such an illogical reply.
When a cop asks you for your ID you have to give it to them. That is the law.. Loitering in a lot where there have been break-ins in a rental is cause for the cop to ask for ID.
This is harassment at its best. What an abuse of authority smh. Then they wonder why nobody trusted them or respects law enforcement. I am so sorry this happened to you and your family 😮
The dipshit tyrant cop who started all of this earns the hate like a guy working overtime getting paid insane money trying to save up for balls enlargement surgery.
Nope, he was doing his job and they were uncooperative assholes.
Walter Hartman, you are the asshole! I hope you one day are approached by the police and unjustly accused of something you didn’t do. Or, maybe you DID do something wrong.
That's why WE say FTP!🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷
@@rickimhotep1236 were you raised by criminals?
This is beyond abuse of power!! I hope they sur them and get them all removed from the force! Sleeping in your car after driving 8 hours is not a crime! Being pulled out of your car forcefully when you have not done anything wrong would make anyone angry!! The fact he turned off his audio proves he is in the wrong and trying to cover his ass!
And after all this, the cops investigated themselves and found they did nothing wrong, and both deputies were promoted to sergeants. Luckily, the women won a civil lawsuit. But no consequences for the cops.
ALL SHE HAD TO DO WAS GIVE THEM HER DRIVER'S LICENSE! What is the big deal? She was disrespectful and could have avoided the whole incident. The police were very calm and polite and the family was suspicious, Poor cops get a bad deal. "We haven't did anything!"
Wow! This is horrible... "The jury ruled that the officer's conduct was 'unlawful' and that Holland and Alameda County together must pay $2.75 million to the mother and $2 million to each daughter, while Pope and the county must pay $750,000 to each daughter, according to the final order." The officers should be fired. Fortunately, they have to help pay the family.
Glad to hear that,...racism exists and it's used mainly against black people by those in authority...black people cannot sit in a car chatting OUTFUCKINGRAGOUS because this has happened to me in the UK but no one complains..
They should have gotten more 😡
Please end Qualified Immunity... This is just ridiculous.. These cops need to be terminated and fined..
Can you send me that 🔗 link....I wonna read the final judgement
The other cop that was also being a hole should of been fired also.
Mute buttons should be removed from all body cams. Period. Or at the very least, a law passed that states they cannot be muted until a suspect is released, or has been booked in completely. These officers are preparing a CYA report with those cameras muted. If I had the money or the pull I'd get them a lawyer.
They do that to Trump up charges on people everybody involved in this should have been fired
why would there even BE a mute button on body cams. just goes to show how their dishonesty is 100% facilitated and enabled. all the time.
This was 2019 I think the reason we’re seeing it right now is because they just won 8 million dollars in a lawsuit
They were probably saying all kinds of racist stuff which is why they muted the audio.
Illegal detainment, illegal search.
I get it from both sides but what I don’t understand is why people don’t just comply? It’s just showing your identification? Why did they make it such a big deal
This happened to my son when he was 18. In Jacksonville Florida at the WaWa on Beach Blvd. He was eating his Quesadillas he just got parked in front of the store and a cop said that same exact thing!! Being black is the real reason. We probably should have filed a complaint but I was just relieved that they didn’t kill him-he was by himself only 10 minutes from home.
I love how they illegally searched their car, violated almost every right possible, and I MORE THAN LOVE THEY GOT THAT LAWSUIT she was talking about!!
I know. They didn't even ask if they could search.
What was the purpose of turning off the audio
@@maryalston7462 to hide his lies
@🌸The Doors🌸 but what about other officers? They had badycam, too...
@@maryalston7462 the cop played himself. He knew he was in the wrong, knew they hadn't done anything, but couldn't let his ego make him walk away.
The fear in her voice is unsettling. They straight up kidnapped them with the cameras rolling. Prayers for all the people who never got to tell their story 🙏
The family won 8 million dollar judgement for this horrible disgusting incident horrible police this is insanity and humiliation I pray this never happen to anyone
@@Mike-gc2hm Both of those disgusting pieces of dog sh!t got promoted after this incident to Sargeants.
i saw no problem with it
@@koltred because you are a fool.
So your "feelings" are dictating how you respond to a transparent event?
Jeez , lady sitting with child in front of a Starbucks showing no criminal activity should be left alone. Cop knew he was in too deep and should have broke off but his ego wouldn’t allow it .
They turned off the sound, WHY 😮
"Jury awards $8.25M to Black mother, daughters handcuffed outside Castro Valley Starbucks" is all I needed to know as the outcome of this egregious encounter.
Just to let you know that would be $8.25 million of the Taxpayers money.
@@itsgreat7150 rather we get our money back than the pigs.
@@mosesagabon7152 So stop whining when your taxes go up and up and up because the Police Officers ain’t going nowhere.
@@itsgreat7150 i'm somewhat pro police but you have to admit that the sheriff in this video was on a power trip. One wrong doesnt make another wrong right. We need accountability from law enforcements and people should also cooperate with law enforcement. All giant corporations pay little to nothing in taxes. I dont know how taxes work(in that level) but even with a layman brain i know its unfair.
@@mosesagabon7152 Look, the Officers were “wrong” but a payout over a million just for being arrested. I would understand if the Officers assaulted these women but there didn’t.
Come on now, this is “not” a multi-million claim and you know it. And once again it the taxpayers who have to cough up the money for this payout.
I would have given these women $250,000 and that’s it. But not a multi million payout, no way.
This is sick and inhumane. Why do they still have jobs. They should be behind bars for what they did to this family.
Exactly all in their stuff!
I agree but what's going to happen is internal affairs will say they did nothing wrong and it was the lady's fault and the cops did exactly what they were supposed to.
@@kmkfan42069 they were awarded 8 million dollars in a lawsuit... the cop played himself, and let his ego get the best of him. He should of just walked away after she explained why she was in the car.
@@_indent
I’m so glad to hear that they got that much money. Good for them. That piece of 💩cop should have been fired!
Because of color lol
8 million $?! I was unlawfully arrested and they actually put me in jail for 2 days and haven’t got anything I want 100$?😂 black privilege seems to be present here I wish i were black sometimes.
She doesn't have to ID herself. She is not a suspect of a crime. Show me your papers... Nope!
This was not an encounter! This is harassment!! There is no reason to stop this woman in the parking lot ! She asked for his superior. Detained for what! This makes me sick.
She's walking away with 2 million dollars. I hope to have the same thing happen to me. Easiest money I'll ever make just for being inconvenienced.
Lazy crazy guy… don’t worry after taxes and the lawyers cut she will walk away with less than a million. And we all know how good black peoples are with money so she will be broke within 2 years and pulling the same shit 2 years from now!! And we winder why blacks act like animals every time they get pulled over!! Great way to go through life. And people wonder why blacks have the shortest life expectancy of all the races!! Keep up the good work my black peoples…lol.
Almost as sick as the dozen of murders committed by the thug community everyday
@@LazyCrazyGuy this is traumatic. This is not an inconvenience.
There no law that says you have to call a supervisor if someone asks you to.
Now he's going through her personals without her consent illegal search
COPS SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED to redact body cam audio or block the lens. Allowing cops to turn off audio is counter productive to the purpose for the body cams in the first place. Body cam footage is public domain, and the public is (entitled) to see and hear every frame of footage. The Supreme Court needs to intervene again, and outlaw the corruptive behavior, yet again.
The officers that conducted this fiasco cost the public 8 million dollars and they got promotions. What does that say about the quality of their command structure? No comment!
It Alameda County Sheriff's: the POS cunts of the bay area.
Why was she in a handicap spot?
@@keith1854 Should that warrant this type of treatment?
@@jimthompson3787 not giving your ID does. I can’t imagine being such a bitch to a cop who asked for my ID. but she was handicapped, most likely relating to a mental disability judging from her reaction
That's like another officer killed a driver, got promoted then fired bcse he was beating the hxll outta his gf. Which I think they already knew about. But he went too far.
Cop couldn't even tell his coworker what they are being detained for literally goes" they're being detained for...uh..10-4" and literally says nothing afterwards because he knows he doesn't have shit on them and is just another cop who's got a power trip issue.
@Brett O'Neal so you approve of immoral criminal oathbreaking behavior...got it.
@@UpAllNight325 If you don't want to be seen as a racist POS, don't act like a racist POS
FUCKIN PIGZ !
NPC cops
i saw no problem with it
These people are like crows they never shut up
The daughters acted out the way they did because the mother set an example. I don't think the officer did anything wrong asking for ID . She should have shown it to him. Perhaps the officer didn't have good reason for seeing it. I don't think he did. But he did so just show it ! These guys keep us safe so show some gratitude.
They won the lawsuit and awarded $8 million for unjust detainment and behavior
Those ladies knew their rights, these cops messed up
@@ddp5406but we taxpayers are the ones that paid her off.
@@NoNonsense30 our tax dollars bailed out the banks and other countries without our consent, dont get all macho about how state and federal branches allocate our tax $'s...how else are we gonna hold officers who outstep their boundaries and believe they dont have to follow the law accountable?
It goes both ways
WOMAN: "I asked for a supervisor"
COP: "You don't demand what we do!"
Unbelievable breach of Constitutional rights! Unlawful. Detainment, false imprisonment, violation of Fourth Amendment.
they’re satanic
Hearing a cop say you will be arrested for resisting arrest is priceless.
It’s only okay because they are black
You can request a supervisor but it's not a right or law. Most places it's not even a policy.
Deprivation of rights under color of law.
The id issue is so old. How officers still ask for ID is so frustrating.
Its the new form of "where are your papers" just now tis done to everybody not just the jewish
people refusing to hand over ids is so frustrating
@@jgwentworth6735 if there is no crime or no suspicion of a crime (the legal definition of suspicion not just being an idiot like this guy) there is no legal obligation to hand it over.
@@jgwentworth6735 smoke pole soyboy
Just ANY excuse to start something. so.... how did that de-escalation training do for you? you didn't receive it? then you need remedial training and no more street work for you until you complete a one year course
I Hope you took this all the way , they should be fired all of them , update on what happened please .
They should be fired but unfortunately these police officers were promoted
It has to change you did absolutely nothing wrong , we don’t live in North Korea , it’s so bad down there and I’m so sorry that happened to you . Pretty sad they got promoted , you need a better lawyer I think .
@@Greengiant1968 oh it didn’t happen to me. I know they got promoted from watching Audit the Audit here on RUclips.
So robbers sit In their car with their daughters and take take a nap
It kinda struck home, when the mother said "call the cops" and then realised, these were the cops, how vulnerable that must make you feel !
And when she calls, she will have to identify herself. And when "they come to investigate", she will need to provide her ID.
@@thomasluby1754 nope, they were in the right, this why they’re millionaires rn
you have to be pretty stupid to not realize it 1st but look at them.. not the brightest.
loudmouth uncivilized
@@thomasluby1754 why is she showing freedom papers no one called on her and she didn’t commit a crime so who the fuck is he to still try to shake her down for information
The officer was in the wrong witch is why he no longer has a job and the mother and daughter won their lawsuit and was awarded a shit load of money, and rightfully so.
This is absolutely disgusting. It's sad when we can't go and grab a coffee and take a break without being detained. Sad!!
The cop was completely wrong and he knew that but the ego of a police officer is so huge that it fuels the stupidity
Why does he get to block his camera and turn his mic off. That is total BS, and he keeps searching her vehicle and personal belongings without a warrant!
Wow she started off so polite and respectful, it should have ended immediately, she dispelled all suspicion immediately when she really didn't HAVE to.
Shows that his “mission” was to harass people as he went fishing.
I cant figure out why, when you are waiting for a store to open, that you park in a handicapped spot, at the far end of the building form the door you want to go in, and since they were there before the store opened, you can't say it was the only spot open. Definitely should have been given a handicapped parking fine, which, they had the right to ask for a ID for.
@@Internutt2023 She had a handicapped placard hanging from her rear view mirror, so she was legal to park there.
@@justthinkin5956 Yes. All of that talk about "why she parked away from the door" is irrelevant and it's how cops justify unlawful behavior.
she was suspicious the whole time and refused to hand over an id
These cops think they can do what they want to people with no consequences it's so disgusting 😒😤
Wrong !!
No consequences? Boy were they wrong! They got promoted!
These blacks think they can do what they want to people with no consequences it's so disgusting 😒😤. Fixed it for you.
@@Michael-fw6vk WTF did she do to these PIG???
@@Michael-fw6vk you're a clown.