I was quite disappointed when I asked my film buddies to watch the trailer of the movie to decide if they wanted to watch it with me. They decided it wasn’t for them and didn’t watch it. I, of course, was raring to watch it and I loved the film. It was a quiet but lovely film. Very realistic and very relatable - as someone who has moved to several different cities and countries. And although I sort of wanted it to end somewhat differently, the way it ended was the most realistic ending. Sigh. It was heartbreakingly true to life. I agree with your review. I hope it gets a film nomination.
I can definitely relate. I didn’t even show some of my friends the trailer because I knew they wouldn’t be interested whatsoever. I’m glad you loved it! Fingers crossed it gets some love around award season
When tears were running down your face and had no idea why…that was me! I’m like geeze… what’s happened right now! My best friend and I also just sat there for a minute, went to dinner and we just looked at each other and couldn’t believe how beautiful this film was… every aspect of it. Great review!!!
It’s always special when something flying under the radar like that can hit so hard! You don’t even realize how invested you are during the first two acts. When that emotional payoff hits, it’s wild! I’m glad you both loved it, and thank you !
I love your passion for this film. It is subtle and a slow burn but the deep connection and knowledge that their connection is in the past just keeps heaping on you until the end. The looks of longing... feels like a documentary.
I have seen this movie more than ten times, on Showtime, and plan to see it again in the future. The bond between the Past Lives and Now Lives, is incredible. The three main characters are all wonderful. As an African American woman, empathy was easy. Some of discussions between the characters, I have never, ever, seen in a movie. Yes, there will be tears. I just subscribed. I wish I had found you earlier.
Amazing film, and so excited to see what Celine does next. Excellent review man! I'd recommend In the Mood For Love, would love to see your reaction. 👍
It's my favorite movie of 2023 easy even though I haven't seen Poor Things yet, I already know Past Lives resonates with me more. I hope it wins all it is nominated for.
Yes this is one of the best films I have seen in my life too. It also brought me back to the "Before trilogy" with the depth and honesty of human interaction and emotion.
@@drewsaidthat DEFINITELY!!! The “Before” trilogy is amazing. Watching the evolution of the relationship between Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpys’ characters is beautiful. If you can’t stream it get the Criterion box set.
New subscriber,how the hell have you only got a hundred subscribers? And only 110 views for this video?? Excellent video mate, greetings from the UK 🙏🏼💪🏼🙏🏼
Yeaaa I think either Oppenheimer or Poor Things is gonna take Best Picture, but Original Screenplay could absolutely go to Past Lives. The writing is immaculate
Very nice review and I’ve read many. I agree with what you said about how moving this film is. A famous critic once said he doesn’t cry at sad movies, he does when it’s about goodness. That truly makes you think about the relationships herein. There is so much emotion in this movie even without words being spoken. I typically seek out movies like this. I do hope it gets nominated. Beautiful film all around.
I’m finding myself drawn to these more low key films. They’re surprising me more and more these days, and A24 is almost TOO consistent. Not to mention that this is someone’s directorial DEBUT! That’s crazy fresh out the gate. Also thanks for the kind words! I’m glad you enjoyed the review!
I loved your review as I also had the same reaction to the movie….but I literally lost it and cried my eyes out. So beautiful. I also will remember this film for years to come. So happy I found your channel…well done!!
Just saw it last night and loved it. Beautifully filmed, amazingly acted and so relatable. Everyone has the sense of nostalgia for a person or a place or even who they were at a certain time in their life. I’ve already urged one friend to see it and will let many more know they should watch it too.
I really enjoyed this movie. It’s a quietly devastating movie that demands your attention. Somehow reminded me of ‘Lost in Translation’ - both movies share a similar mood despite completely different stories. It’s not a movie for everyone- some may struggle with a movie that is character driven and where the most important things are sometimes not said.
I haven’t seen Lost in Translation but I’ve definitely heard about it You hit it perfectly. I could see my own friends watching this movie and saying it was boring or too slow, but for those that love character studies and powerful moods, it’s near perfection
I agree. The movie was so relatable, as someone who was born in Canada then had to move to the States. It felt like it was depicting my life. I also related to Hae Sung so much. I had a friend like Hae Sung. I met him 20 years ago. We were in the same class. The last time I saw him was when he was 12. He passed away from a car accident. When Nora says that she remembers Hae Sung as this kid, I could relate. It hits you outta nowhere. The ending made me think about the what if’s, like what if I coulda grown up with him. Best film I’ve seen.
I’m sorry to hear about your friend, but I’m happy to hear that the movie connected with you so much. It truly is something emotionally special and compelling. Hae Sung definitely felt like my spirit animal
@@drewsaidthat Truly is. My friend was also Korean and like Hae Sung, he also sat near the board at the right side of the classroom. My friend was bilingual; he knew English and Korean. I’m an artist who also writes. I agree. All the characters were so relatable. It was such a special film. I felt seen.
I love your review and agree on all counts. Teo Yoo showed everything in his eyes and like you, I can’t describe in words what he was expressing, maybe because it was multilayered.
Well, when I saw the movie trailer last summer, I inmediately knew this would be a great movie. It should came out in The Netherlands on September 7th, but in the end it only was Octber 5th. Since then, I saw this masterpiece 37 times in cinema. Well spend time, if you ask me! I like the review. It is all true.
37 times ????? Good lord! 😂🤦🏾♂️ Did you watch it every day? Did you wake up and go, “Time for my mornin dose!”? 😂😂😂 I applaud your passion for this great movie 🥂
Saw this film twice to catch each nuance- and didn’t notice the score first time around either was so engrossed in the characters and dialogue. Score magnificent too. A masterpiece.
I wonder if there will be an alternate ending where Nora gets in the taxi at the end 😂. Edit: Overall, I liked how interesting the film is, but I didn’t like the goodbyes throughout the film, which gives the film its name Past Lives. If you think about it, at the end of the film, mostly all the characters are kinda miserable minus the guy from Seoul because he found a sense of closing the door to be peaceful. But at the same time, he’s not with his first love. The 3 characters felt they were missing out on something. I liked the acting, camera work, character development, and the last scene which is super super refreshing in this age of films. And since I’m studying Korean language myself, I didn’t like how the husband knew little Korean. That’s just me. Also didn’t like in the opening scene of the people just guessing how the 3 characters know each other because their assumptions were kinda racist.
😂😂 I mostly feel where ya coming from. The characters at the beginning didn’t really bother me but then again I never thought about it that hard lmao I’m glad you dug the movie tho and learning Korean is dope! I’m planning to learn French myself
@@drewsaidthat yea French is awesome too. But yea man, the people at the beginning was like “c’mon now” and they called them tourists and the husband a tour guide, which I thought was very distasteful since I’m a minority born in America as well. And speaking of tourists, I thought the scene of when they went to the statue of liberty on the ferry was odd because it looked like (the background people were) locals going to see the statue instead of actual tourists from outside the state/country. What did you think of that ferry scene ?
I didn’t pay much attention to the background characters. I guess I was so engrossed in the story between Nora and Hae Sung that it was the only thing I was acknowledging. I guess I feel what you’re getting at, but I don’t know.
It was a very emotionally mature movie. The trailer led me to believe there would be some rift between the married couple, and initially there's a tiny bit, but it's refreshing that in fact there isn't and instead there's a level of maturity in how they navigate the situation. Many of us, myself included, can relate to that experience of meeting the love of your live and realizing it can't continue for whatever reason and how devastating that can be.
Yeaaa I love how Nora’s dude didn’t gaslight her or try to attack Hae Sung. He simply acknowledges what’s going on and tries to work with his wife to find the best direction going forward. Like you said, it’s very mature
I was quite disappointed when I asked my film buddies to watch the trailer of the movie to decide if they wanted to watch it with me. They decided it wasn’t for them and didn’t watch it. I, of course, was raring to watch it and I loved the film. It was a quiet but lovely film. Very realistic and very relatable - as someone who has moved to several different cities and countries. And although I sort of wanted it to end somewhat differently, the way it ended was the most realistic ending. Sigh. It was heartbreakingly true to life. I agree with your review. I hope it gets a film nomination.
I can definitely relate. I didn’t even show some of my friends the trailer because I knew they wouldn’t be interested whatsoever. I’m glad you loved it! Fingers crossed it gets some love around award season
When tears were running down your face and had no idea why…that was me! I’m like geeze… what’s happened right now! My best friend and I also just sat there for a minute, went to dinner and we just looked at each other and couldn’t believe how beautiful this film was… every aspect of it. Great review!!!
It’s always special when something flying under the radar like that can hit so hard! You don’t even realize how invested you are during the first two acts. When that emotional payoff hits, it’s wild! I’m glad you both loved it, and thank you !
I love your passion for this film. It is subtle and a slow burn but the deep connection and knowledge that their connection is in the past just keeps heaping on you until the end. The looks of longing... feels like a documentary.
Absolutely! I love how it takes it’s time to build to those last 30 minutes. The emotional payoff is nuts
That is a good critique. It did seem like a documentary at some points
I enjoyed the film, just not as much as everyone else
7/10
That’s understandable. There’s definitely been a bunch of films that I acknowledged their goodness, but I wasn’t hit the same way as other folks
Yup. I hope the movie gets nominated for Oscar and wins.
I definitely hope it gets nominated, but winner could still be up in the air but I feel you. This movie is excellent
That scene you’re talking about when the tears came was powerful! I won’t say more to not spoil it.
Absolutely. The buildup did the work and the moment leaves you stuck 😓
where the long dormant crybaby comes out again because of the one who knew that side the most
I have seen this movie more than ten times, on Showtime, and plan to see it again in the future. The bond
between the Past Lives and Now Lives, is incredible. The three main characters are all wonderful. As an
African American woman, empathy was easy. Some of discussions between the characters, I have never,
ever, seen in a movie. Yes, there will be tears. I just subscribed. I wish I had found you earlier.
I can’t get over how much y’all love this movie! And welcome to the channel! 🥂🥂
Agree completely. Overwhelmingly relatable.
Amazing film, and so excited to see what Celine does next. Excellent review man! I'd recommend In the Mood For Love, would love to see your reaction. 👍
Alright that’s a bet. I’ll check it out tonight. Thanks for the recommendation!
It's my favorite movie of 2023 easy even though I haven't seen Poor Things yet, I already know Past Lives resonates with me more. I hope it wins all it is nominated for.
Yeaa it’s still my favorite film of the year at this point. The only couple that could top it for me would be Poor Things or Wonka
Yes this is one of the best films I have seen in my life too. It also brought me back to the "Before trilogy" with the depth and honesty of human interaction and emotion.
I’ve heard a little bit about the “Before” Trilogy but I haven’t seen it. Worth checking out?
@@drewsaidthat DEFINITELY!!! The “Before” trilogy is amazing. Watching the evolution of the relationship between Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpys’ characters is beautiful. If you can’t stream it get the Criterion box set.
Aightt Bett. Max only has Before Midnight so I’m definitely gonna check out that Criterion set
New subscriber,how the hell have you only got a hundred subscribers? And only 110 views for this video??
Excellent video mate, greetings from the UK 🙏🏼💪🏼🙏🏼
Ayyye thank you man! I really appreciate that! 👊🏾👊🏾 Happy to have you
Woo how ! It’s up for best picture and best original screenplay. I think it really has a legitimate shot at best original screenplay.
Yeaaa I think either Oppenheimer or Poor Things is gonna take Best Picture, but Original Screenplay could absolutely go to Past Lives. The writing is immaculate
Very nice review and I’ve read many. I agree with what you said about how moving this film is. A famous critic once said he doesn’t cry at sad movies, he does when it’s about goodness. That truly makes you think about the relationships herein. There is so much emotion in this movie even without words being spoken. I typically seek out movies like this. I do hope it gets nominated. Beautiful film all around.
I’m finding myself drawn to these more low key films. They’re surprising me more and more these days, and A24 is almost TOO consistent. Not to mention that this is someone’s directorial DEBUT! That’s crazy fresh out the gate.
Also thanks for the kind words! I’m glad you enjoyed the review!
I loved your review as I also had the same reaction to the movie….but I literally lost it and cried my eyes out. So beautiful. I also will remember this film for years to come. So happy I found your channel…well done!!
🥂 Ayyye I’m glad you loved the film, and thank you!! Welcome to the channel!!
Love the review! Couldn’t have said it better myself! Nicely done! Like you, I LOVED Past Lives! Easily my favorite film of 2023!
Much thanks for the love, and I’m glad you loved the film ! 🥂🥂
Just saw it last night and loved it. Beautifully filmed, amazingly acted and so relatable. Everyone has the sense of nostalgia for a person or a place or even who they were at a certain time in their life. I’ve already urged one friend to see it and will let many more know they should watch it too.
I hope your friends are more open minded than mine 😂 This movie is honestly great, and it’s awesome that so many of you love it too
Movie of the year easily
Most definitely!
I really enjoyed this movie. It’s a quietly devastating movie that demands your attention.
Somehow reminded me of ‘Lost in Translation’ - both movies share a similar mood despite completely different stories.
It’s not a movie for everyone- some may struggle with a movie that is character driven and where the most important things are sometimes not said.
I haven’t seen Lost in Translation but I’ve definitely heard about it
You hit it perfectly. I could see my own friends watching this movie and saying it was boring or too slow, but for those that love character studies and powerful moods, it’s near perfection
I agree. The movie was so relatable, as someone who was born in Canada then had to move to the States. It felt like it was depicting my life. I also related to Hae Sung so much. I had a friend like Hae Sung. I met him 20 years ago. We were in the same class. The last time I saw him was when he was 12. He passed away from a car accident. When Nora says that she remembers Hae Sung as this kid, I could relate. It hits you outta nowhere. The ending made me think about the what if’s, like what if I coulda grown up with him.
Best film I’ve seen.
I’m sorry to hear about your friend, but I’m happy to hear that the movie connected with you so much. It truly is something emotionally special and compelling.
Hae Sung definitely felt like my spirit animal
@@drewsaidthat Truly is. My friend was also Korean and like Hae Sung, he also sat near the board at the right side of the classroom. My friend was bilingual; he knew English and Korean. I’m an artist who also writes.
I agree. All the characters were so relatable. It was such a special film. I felt seen.
Wowww sounds like this movie was personally made for you !
And it’s always dope to talk to another artist. I’d love to check out your work
@@drewsaidthat I had a show on White Columns called The Feeling of Things
curated by Colleen Grennan. I make receipts where I write.
I checked out your work. My favorite one was definitely Laduree New York.
I love the idea of the writing being on receipts ! Very unique !
A perfect film, and I don't say that lightly. 2023's best film and I will not be surprised if it is my favorite film of this decade.
It’s a tad early to place films of the decade 😂😂
But i feel you. This is definitely one of the best films I’ve seen in my lifetime
You nailed it...especially the fatigue from blockbusters...
Fantastic review! I adored this film and agree with you 100%! Subscribed. Keep up the great work!
Thank you thank you, welcome to the channel !
I love your review and agree on all counts. Teo Yoo showed everything in his eyes and like you, I can’t describe in words what he was expressing, maybe because it was multilayered.
Absolutely absolutely! There’s so much to pull just from their long stares at each other. It’s brilliantly executed
I got recommended to your channel by youtube, I really enjoy your opinion on this movie. Very genuine, heart-felt review. Subbing :)
I appreciate that ! Welcome to the channel !
@@drewsaidthat Thank you!
Loved your review.
For me its the best film of the year so far, and one of the best in the last few years, no 🧢.
I couldn’t agree more!
Really enjoyed hearing your thoughts on this film
Thank you thank you !
My favorite movie of the year.
This film is amazing. Just brilliant. ❤
I can’t wait to see what the director and actors do next
cant wait to actually watch it, looks beautiful
Definitely! It’s well worth the watch.
Lemme know what you think after you see it 🥂
"brutally relatable", yes, your review is on point!
I appreciate you 🥂
love this film and love your review!
The movie is freaking great !
Well, when I saw the movie trailer last summer, I inmediately knew this would be a great movie. It should came out in The Netherlands on September 7th, but in the end it only was Octber 5th. Since then, I saw this masterpiece 37 times in cinema. Well spend time, if you ask me! I like the review. It is all true.
37 times ????? Good lord! 😂🤦🏾♂️ Did you watch it every day? Did you wake up and go, “Time for my mornin dose!”?
😂😂😂 I applaud your passion for this great movie 🥂
I must admit - this film was so deeply moving me that I cannot remember the score. As you said, it is the best film of the year 2023.
Ohh definitely give that score a listen. It’s so beautiful that I added it to my Apple Music library 😂
Saw this film twice to catch each nuance- and didn’t notice the score first time around either was so engrossed in the characters and dialogue. Score magnificent too. A masterpiece.
It’s great sleeping/meditation music too
I wonder if there will be an alternate ending where Nora gets in the taxi at the end 😂.
Edit: Overall, I liked how interesting the film is, but I didn’t like the goodbyes throughout the film, which gives the film its name Past Lives. If you think about it, at the end of the film, mostly all the characters are kinda miserable minus the guy from Seoul because he found a sense of closing the door to be peaceful. But at the same time, he’s not with his first love. The 3 characters felt they were missing out on something.
I liked the acting, camera work, character development, and the last scene which is super super refreshing in this age of films. And since I’m studying Korean language myself, I didn’t like how the husband knew little Korean. That’s just me. Also didn’t like in the opening scene of the people just guessing how the 3 characters know each other because their assumptions were kinda racist.
😂😂 I mostly feel where ya coming from.
The characters at the beginning didn’t really bother me but then again I never thought about it that hard lmao
I’m glad you dug the movie tho and learning Korean is dope! I’m planning to learn French myself
@@drewsaidthat yea French is awesome too. But yea man, the people at the beginning was like “c’mon now” and they called them tourists and the husband a tour guide, which I thought was very distasteful since I’m a minority born in America as well. And speaking of tourists, I thought the scene of when they went to the statue of liberty on the ferry was odd because it looked like (the background people were) locals going to see the statue instead of actual tourists from outside the state/country. What did you think of that ferry scene ?
I didn’t pay much attention to the background characters. I guess I was so engrossed in the story between Nora and Hae Sung that it was the only thing I was acknowledging.
I guess I feel what you’re getting at, but I don’t know.
@@drewsaidthat I’m going to step into acting too, so I look at all that stuff
Ahhhhhhhh I see ! That’s dope, much luck to you!
I’m trying to be a filmmaker myself
There is a migration story here with so many layers to examine.
This movie has so much under the surface. The themes and messages, man
The last 30 minutes 🥺😭😭
I’m saying! Tears came so fast I didn’t even realize it
It was a very emotionally mature movie. The trailer led me to believe there would be some rift between the married couple, and initially there's a tiny bit, but it's refreshing that in fact there isn't and instead there's a level of maturity in how they navigate the situation. Many of us, myself included, can relate to that experience of meeting the love of your live and realizing it can't continue for whatever reason and how devastating that can be.
Yeaaa I love how Nora’s dude didn’t gaslight her or try to attack Hae Sung. He simply acknowledges what’s going on and tries to work with his wife to find the best direction going forward. Like you said, it’s very mature
great review, subscribed. real to life modern love story, heart pounding.... 😥😇🙏
Welcome to the channel! Glad you liked the review and loved the movie!
The movie I knew I needed. Excellent film.
Agreed! Glad you enjoyed it!
Good review, keep posting.
Thank you thank you !
" Why am I wet?" 😂 Yeah, Celine Song did that😊
I’m tryna tell y’all 💀
This film reminds me of Casablanca to some degree
I’ve never seen Casablanca before. It’s on the list for sure
Where to watch it? I am so excited and giddy scared to watch it bec of the reviews.
It’s not on streaming just yet, but it’s still playing in theaters
The movie was ok but damn frustrating
Express your feelings people
Take charge of your lives and destiny
I see where you’re coming from, but that’s a little easier said than done. Expressing to someone how you feel about them is scary for both parties
1:14 🧢
Who said im sorry at the end?
I think it was Nora
This movie was so captivating and made me feel so much
It seems to be good at that 😂🥂
I’m glad you enjoyed it!