i cant tell if your being sarcastic but there is a mail wagon or whatever its called somewhere in the map with mail in it and one of it says the girls name and if you give this girl a ride back to emerald ranch she gives you that girls name (i think) but its just suppose to be a mystery
Spoiler alert You got clickbaited yet again by MrBossFTW. He doesn't free her, or do anything particularly useful. Just wanders around emerald ranch talking nonsense as usual.
Thanks because this dude content is uber deceitful I usually find myself skipping through his videos to see if anything he said in the caption would happen and usually it never happens.
I actually did my own investigation after watching this video, and I'm adding one more note. If you go and antagonize the father, he'll point a weapon at you with this dialouge "you think I didn't kill anyone before? You're wrong".. And that's just more insane details in this game.
According to Wikipedia notes on Eugene Wegner : “The player can encounter a man at a campfire, who will tell them about the shenanigans of the ranch. The man also suspects Wegner to have killed Joshua Burgess” . This strongly implies that the person Wegner killed before is actually Joshua, and as the owner of the ranch, he had the power to keep everyone’s mouths shut, and falsify the reason for Joshua’s death who was definitely not “accidentally shot”
@@lexicassels2370 and fyi you can find Eugene Wegner standing on his house’s porch, where he will be hostile, or roaming across the ranch, not especially hostile anymore. His name is not specified at the bottom right, he’s basically the guy who attacks Arthur in the beginning of this video
Ok, I understand that click-baiting is just the way you get views, but using a couple screen grabs from a reddit post without even trying it yourself....super weak-sauce!!
Bruce Broussard Yeah that store one is kind of weird. I rescued the guy and he somehow gets captured again. I don't know what happened but apparently he died.
You didn’t even free her!!! The title was “what happens if you free the girl trapped inside emeralds ranch “ Yet you never did that. I love your videos but this one was disappointing
The way I interpreted this story during my playthrough was that Joshua ran the saloon and was entertaining some patrons with a good ol fashioned game of "shoot stuff off the top of my head" and it went awry. This would explain the multiple holes in the wall and their height. I think Miriam was either the shooter or at least a witness and this is what traumatized her.
Year late. But I really like this interpretation. If you murdered someone you wouldn’t put “accidentally shot” on their tomb. You would just dump them in a ditch or lake somewhere. It doesn’t have to be sinister, sometimes people just die for stupid reasons
This game made me start watching not only letters and documents to solve mysteries, but almost any room, tomb stone, painting, object, stain etc. The details they put in this game... I am overwhelmed. I did't even know you can actually see her throw the window. Damn, I tought this was going to be just a Western GTA. I was completely wrong. So many details and so many events that occur only on special occasions in the day or night... Rockstar really pushed themselves with this one. Great job!
@@billybeetroot8595 When she gets super pissed off of course. She’s way stronger than she looks, and if you were being held against your will for as long as she was, you’d throw off that window barrier keeping you trapped inside too!
There is a man in a tent north-West of beachers hope that Will tell you the story of the ranch. He basically comfirms everything you have Said in this video!
I love how deep the world and stories of rdr2 go. You can really get sucked into it. The world feels big. And during this pandemic I'm finding it a great getaway 🤠 🌎
I'm so glad i won't have to waste time trying to get something more out of this mystery. It's weird that they would put so much detail into this part of the story but have no payoff or collectable.
oh god 12 min video, im sure this could have been resolved in 2 min... I always check in the comment section for the answers when i have to go on MrBossFTW youtube videos since he is always clickbaiting me... attention seeking wh---
If you listen to the ghost woman (Agnes) in the bayou it sounds a lot like the daughter’s story. Obviously that’s a different name but the story of Miriam and her father murdering her boyfriend is quite similar. Anyone else think of this?
Have you by chance considered that maybe there was a scuffle and someone shot a normal sized person from the ground firing up at an angle and those are just the finished trajectories of the 3 shots? Love the videos, keep them coming.
Lumbago is an interesting disease. It's funny how it sound like it's quite a bit more intense than lower back pain. I've gone through lumbago recently.
There was probably supposed to be side mission where you have to free the girl but was scraped for whatever reason, hence why you'd be able to get inside and take her out.
So here's a theory. Joshua was the lover of Miriam, and may have been the owner of the saloon. Seamus also had a sweet spot for Miriam and Eugene noticed. Eugene didn't like either of them so paid Seamus to kill Joshua. Joshua may have survived the fight over because of a rivalry they've had in the past, so Joshua would expect it. Joshua fought back, but Seamus shot Joshua in the neck, which would explain the blood looking as if he fell and squirmed as a struggle of bleed out. Eugene did pay Seamus for the murder, but did not give his daughter to him. Miriam was heartbroken over Joshua and could not fall in love with another soul. Also, if Joshua was the owner of the saloon, and Seamus killed him, wouldn't that explain why he sells tons of moonshine?
August 1898- Death of Joshua and Miriam locks herself indoors. The game takes place between May until June 1899. That's 9-10 months after the death/murder. That is a long time to stay indoors.
Have you done a video about the Mayor of Strawberry? I remember NPCs talking about how he had a strange secret or something, but I never could find out what it was.
U kill him and after you loot him you find a letter from an old love that is now married or something... I don't remember (i ended up killing half the town... Typical strawberry 😂😊)
@NaNo Games Plus Wild West was dotted with closeted gay affairs and romances. BM is the only "serious" popculture rendition of such relationships, of course ppl say the mayor of Strawberry Town being closeted gay is reference to BM. Just because existence of homosexual cowboys and frontier men wasn't discussed openly, doesn't mean there weren't any...
Very interesting, I never knew about any of this at Emerald Ranch, I do remember finding a man's dog in another town, but he was very kind and appreciative to me and happy to see his dog. No, the only encounter I had with Emerald Ranch was in the mission "He's British of course" where I track down the male lion, shoot and kill him in self defense, then bring back one of his claws as proof. Considering that man's intensions with his dog (and that "aim weapon"" is your only available option, I would of shot him!
A well narrated video, nicely presented, about an interesting puzzle that totally fails to live up to the title you gave it. How hard would it have been to title it "What do we know about the girl trapped in Emerald Ranch?" Disingenous to published using a poster image of someone else's work.
Hey MrBossFTW, during the late 19th and early 20th centuries it was not uncommon for the way a person died to be put on their gravestone. Especially on the frontier. So “accidentally shot” might not be sarcasm, it could be the way he died. Also, the position of the shots on the wall looks to be about head high. I think he got drunk, maybe with some buddies, dared someone to do trick shots around him, as you do with the two brothers, and he was accidentally shot. Just my thought. Love your videos BTW!!
One time I was challenged to shoot on bottles on a fence, a random guy was working in the fields directly behind the bottles. The aim on my revolver automaticly moved to the person, so I accidently killed him and hell broke lose
I think there's a pretty easy explanation as to why those bullet holes are so far up the wall. It's possible the shooter was at a lower angle to his/her target. So the shooter was either in a sitting or lying position and was shooting up at their victim. Another likely scenario is that both the shooter and the victim were standing and the shooter fast drew their pistol and fired from the hip at a sharp 45 degree angle. Although this would require the both of them to be standing in close proximity to each other. Face-to-face as it were.
the detail situation that went in to a story for a video games that matter or dont matter to a player that is simply crafted out is simply amazing.. i havent even come across this situation at all yet and finnished the game..Rockstar is awesome.. it's the little things they put in that game that impresses me., ive finnished the game and i know theres still lots of reason to keep playing.
All these side stories seem to weigh less on you when you remember you've probably killed a few hundreds of cops, bandits and civilians during your play through.
Only thing I found missing is if you go to the gunsmith in Valentine or the clothes shop they talk of how she’s being trapped in the house by her father
While playing Red Dead 2 I came across an abandoned mail carriage in the Cumberland forest region and near Fort Wallace. In the carriage was a loot box and inside was a ginseng elixir and 5 or 6 letters. One letter is addressed to Miriam Weigner (The girl in the house at Emeral Ranch) and is written by Annabelle her cousin. In it Annabelle talks about living in New York City and about Miriam’s mental health. In the letter Annabelle also tells her uncle (Mr. Weigner/Owner of Emerald Ranch) that if he is intercepting the letters and not letting Miriam read them then she will be furious or something like that.
Miriam accidentally shot Joshua while drunkenly shooting around his head as he stood against the wall. Or maybe it wasn't entirely an accident. Maybe she was mad at him and was trying to scare him. She put three in the wall around his head and then one in his face. Eugene, being the head honcho around the place, passed it off to the law as an accident, and then forbade Miriam to leave the house.
Interesting to see if you can give the letter to the uncle. Also another fun theory in part with Eugene Wegner is he went William Tell on Joshua, instead of trying to shoot an apple of the guy's head he tried shooting a beer off his head.
No you didn't. You still have clothes and weapons. Oh and John got himself killed avenging you. You didn't win. I'm eating the buck you keep seeing and wearing its fur.
i think the bullet holes on the wall were not fatal. if so, those wouldve been some pretty powerful bullets if they went through and through. but..... if they did actually hit a human, wouldnt there be blood on the wall? i dont know just an idea. im not expert so i mightve got some of those wrong
I have issues when any plays forensic scientist. Saying the bullets holes are really high must mean it was a tall person. That's making the "Assumption" the bullets were shot from the same level they hit the wall at. What if the shooter was on the ground and shot up? That kind of changes things.
Tango Nevada so would the shooter be on the ground where the blood splatter is? im not disagreeing with you im just trying to make more sense of it. maybe they both had guns and only one person managed to hit the other🤷♂️. yea im no forensic scientist but i do find it interesting and what they do
@@hoot3780 I was referring less to the scene in the game then I was to what I see in real life on Crime Scene Shows and the media when they make assumptions about the positions people were in and then you can easily poke holes in it with something as simple as "Maybe the other guy was a midget"
Also "blood on the wall " because bullets go thru someone is movie narrative.. lottsa times in real life, IF a bullet goes thru someone and imbeds in an object behind the victim, the bullet is too fast and too small to produce blood splatter .. usually only head shots trigger that kind of "red mist"
my theory would be the father went into the saloon got a drink and shot joshua from outside and then falsely stated he got drunk and accidentaly shot his gun, then he locked his daughter inside the house so she wouldnt get out, he stays out side to make sure no lover can reach her and no one can know much about her and to make sure she doesnt go out from the front door, the girl likes to look out the window because she misses the outdoors and dreams one day to actually go outside and live free as joshua said in the letter, that shes a girl with big life (or something like that).
Ahmad idheileh failed it was her girl cousin that wrote the letter and how can the pops shoot Joshua from outside when the bullets hole are inside of the wall? Your forensics deducing sucks lol
I’m looking at the chat and im feeling some agressive vibes in the chat I might be the only positive chat but hey maybe your giving hints for other people to solve but either way good job dude! :)
What Happens If You Free The Girl Trapped Inside Emerald Ranch In Red Dead Redemption 2?
MrBossFTW you going do anything with The Feminist?
Hello
MrBossFTW 🤷♀️
MrBossFTW I might try this I’m playing right now
I found an Easter egg about time traveling in saint denis but I don’t know how to put it out there
"What happens if you free the girl?"
I don't know, because you didn't answer and instead chased a dog.
Lmao
Xd
We've been baited.
I gave you a 1000th like
Lmao thank you, you just saved me from watching the full video 😂
Are you Trelawny? Because you manage to talk so much yet say nothing at all.
Ahh kevin owens
Lmfao 💀💀
Leave him alone.. This is a great video
Samantha Tucker he’s just a clickbaiting parasite
@@Craftsbysamantha229 uh no it's not my dude
I haven't watched the video and I know that you didn't solve shit.
Corpus 😂🤣😂
Lmao
Dead ass
Same lmao
Corpus right 😂😂
You're the kid that mastered writing 500 word essays even though it could've been done in 100
Daniel Knoll Just 500 words? I wish I had such objectives. Last I recall, high school demands at least 1,200+ word essays.
Daniel Knoll 😄 got to do what you got to do!
He's older than you 2 year old
no not 100 word, a simple" I Don't Know." could've worked perfectly at the beginning of the video.
It's amazing how deep Rockstar went with developing a back story for a minor character that you can't even interact with.
i cant tell if your being sarcastic but there is a mail wagon or whatever its called somewhere in the map with mail in it and one of it says the girls name and if you give this girl a ride back to emerald ranch she gives you that girls name (i think) but its just suppose to be a mystery
EA can't relate (I'm looking at you The Sims 4)
It's also creepy
And how little effort they put into the online play lol
exactly!!
Spoiler alert
You got clickbaited yet again by MrBossFTW. He doesn't free her, or do anything particularly useful. Just wanders around emerald ranch talking nonsense as usual.
Never once claims he does. His title asks WHAT HAPPENS if you free her. Be sure to not get it twisted before you start slating people.
@@izeusi1728 He asks CAN WE? So he should try it, but he doesn't
Alec Rowan so what happens then?
Thanks man
Thanks because this dude content is uber deceitful I usually find myself skipping through his videos to see if anything he said in the caption would happen and usually it never happens.
Dutch has a plan to get her out of the house
Have some goddamn FAITH
I found both of these comments hilarious.
SlLENT RAGE I just need time and money!
He has a plan and it's a good one
HE JUST NEEDS THE MOHNEE
I actually did my own investigation after watching this video, and I'm adding one more note. If you go and antagonize the father, he'll point a weapon at you with this dialouge "you think I didn't kill anyone before? You're wrong".. And that's just more insane details in this game.
Where do you find him
According to Wikipedia notes on Eugene Wegner : “The player can encounter a man at a campfire, who will tell them about the shenanigans of the ranch. The man also suspects Wegner to have killed Joshua Burgess” . This strongly implies that the person Wegner killed before is actually Joshua, and as the owner of the ranch, he had the power to keep everyone’s mouths shut, and falsify the reason for Joshua’s death who was definitely not “accidentally shot”
@@lexicassels2370 and fyi you can find Eugene Wegner standing on his house’s porch, where he will be hostile, or roaming across the ranch, not especially hostile anymore. His name is not specified at the bottom right, he’s basically the guy who attacks Arthur in the beginning of this video
I found her dead next to black water
Who dead
U should be a politician.
Talk a lot , do nothing
Promise a lot, solve ZERO
You are a JOKE😂😂😂😂
BEERLORD 1 😭🤣🤣
BEERLORD 1 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Like trump 😭
@@b.k.bodybags9764 he did a lot actually i’m hispanic and he did a lot of my Community you just have to do research
Ok, I understand that click-baiting is just the way you get views, but using a couple screen grabs from a reddit post without even trying it yourself....super weak-sauce!!
You truly have the gift of gab. You say so much without saying almost anything of importance at all. Congratulations on the checks you're getting.
TeaNCoffee just like what Charles said about Trelawny. “He talked the whole way, but never actually said anything”
@@scorpionic3599 Nailed it
@@scorpionic3599 indeed
Finally someone who appreciates mrbossftw’s talent
I wish to have that gift
You are wrong! The mystery isn't solved. She is still in the house!!!
Chaos Afterlife naaah. There’s a process. Similar to how you investigate a store’ owner’s secret illegal business. No one has figured that out yet
Bruce!! Good to see you on here!
Mike Scott HEYYYYYYYYYYY!!!
Bruce Broussard Yeah that store one is kind of weird.
I rescued the guy and he somehow gets captured again.
I don't know what happened but apparently he died.
👏👏
This video gave me lumbago.
t e r m i n a l l u m b a g o
What is this xD?
Same ive got a serious case of da lumbago
This video gave me Takamuri 🤣🤣
Im at stage 6
The shopkeeper in the general store at valentine said that “she had been locked up there for years”
Fun fact: that NPC who mistreats his dog is one of the only NPCs in which you can kill and get no bad honor.
You can kill the racist in Saint Dennis and get no punishment
You can't even kill him
People like you are the reason I use adblock.
Pls no he dont get money plz why u do this
@@woptic8218 cause he doesn't deserve money
plz no i beg you
Kawaii Stefan you still gave him a click so jokes on you in the end.
@@woptic8218 why tf do u care
I feel bad for giving you a view..
waste my time...
All most always do
Lmao
Fact
I feel ya, I try not to also but total let down again.
You didn’t even free her!!! The title was “what happens if you free the girl trapped inside emeralds ranch “ Yet you never did that. I love your videos but this one was disappointing
Kenneth Carangelo but a glitch did
If you love his videos youre part of the problem
I love his videos too but u and i know he never ever solves anything he does
It was a question
Open your eyes this mans is an artist at fooling people for his own gain
The way I interpreted this story during my playthrough was that Joshua ran the saloon and was entertaining some patrons with a good ol fashioned game of "shoot stuff off the top of my head" and it went awry. This would explain the multiple holes in the wall and their height. I think Miriam was either the shooter or at least a witness and this is what traumatized her.
I think you nailed ir
I was also thinking along these lines.
@@munky_munk liar
@@aaronalden7122Prove it
Year late. But I really like this interpretation. If you murdered someone you wouldn’t put “accidentally shot” on their tomb. You would just dump them in a ditch or lake somewhere. It doesn’t have to be sinister, sometimes people just die for stupid reasons
5:03 anyone else gonna point out that he left a perfectly good cigarette card there?
Thank you comments you saved me 12:49 seconds of lies and shit
Very cool
No problem xD
Some super heroes dont wear cape. Like you!! Lol thanks!
Artur Martins seconds?
Dude, I stop at the exact same time. 12:49... 😮
I should have read comments,I did waste 12.49mins of my life.
The father killed a man the daughter saw and he's keeping her there so she doesn't tell.
How do u know just asking?
Thank you
@@rhiannamorrow-kakewash9409 he probably found out in the game did u think of that
smaaart
@@xx-apex-xxctw890 or something like this happened in real life and this is just a reference to it
“we dont know why she is in *_her own house_*”
lol
Hey Arthur big fan did you see ghost girl in swamp of alligators?
And if you seen her Then did you talk with her
I just talked to randome poeple in the game and they gave me some un asked for information they said that her father locked her in the house
This game made me start watching not only letters and documents to solve mysteries, but almost any room, tomb stone, painting, object, stain etc. The details they put in this game... I am overwhelmed. I did't even know you can actually see her throw the window. Damn, I tought this was going to be just a Western GTA. I was completely wrong. So many details and so many events that occur only on special occasions in the day or night... Rockstar really pushed themselves with this one. Great job!
When does she throw a window?
@@billybeetroot8595
When she gets super pissed off of course. She’s way stronger than she looks, and if you were being held against your will for as long as she was, you’d throw off that window barrier keeping you trapped inside too!
There is a man in a tent north-West of beachers hope that Will tell you the story of the ranch. He basically comfirms everything you have Said in this video!
Wait, mrbossftw is right?
@@thejudge.2745 Yeah seems so, but he's only right by proxy of a reddit poster who was right.
You ain't find nothing!
Arthur Morgan is Micah burning in hell
"You ain't find nothing!"
Ffs
where the mUnHeh
Your back from the dead!
@@imgandalf6319 "you're" but in your case ur would be justified
why don’t you just title this the mystery of emerald ranch
O: not a hater!
casey barrett i know because he doesnt even solve it
HE WANTS VIEWS
This should be renamed" How to solve bringing the man in Emerald ranch's dog back"
Way to mislead people. 👏👎
Draco your not a hater👍🏻
I love how deep the world and stories of rdr2 go. You can really get sucked into it. The world feels big. And during this pandemic I'm finding it a great getaway 🤠 🌎
Remember 6 feet apart
@@Spinwix even in the game?
I'm so glad i won't have to waste time trying to get something more out of this mystery. It's weird that they would put so much detail into this part of the story but have no payoff or collectable.
Roses are red
Violets are blue
We just got clickbaited so did you
(You didnt set her free)
oh god 12 min video, im sure this could have been resolved in 2 min... I always check in the comment section for the answers when i have to go on MrBossFTW youtube videos since he is always clickbaiting me... attention seeking wh---
So true bro
Just play it at 2x the play back speed you can still understand him
Oh btw you also are seeking attention
If you listen to the ghost woman (Agnes) in the bayou it sounds a lot like the daughter’s story. Obviously that’s a different name but the story of Miriam and her father murdering her boyfriend is quite similar. Anyone else think of this?
But what happens if you actually free her you did not free her 🤷🏽♀️
Have you by chance considered that maybe there was a scuffle and someone shot a normal sized person from the ground firing up at an angle and those are just the finished trajectories of the 3 shots? Love the videos, keep them coming.
You need to rethink the way you do things. Honesty still goes a long way in this world.
Not to Dutch. His is Loyalty, FAITH, TIME, MONEY!!
Not for Democrats. They’ve never tried it.
She gets
L U M B A G O
Fucks sake, every time *l U m B a G o*
ok she get herpes
How tf did I know you were gonna say that? Oh god it's the *L u M b A g O*
Lumbago is an interesting disease. It's funny how it sound like it's quite a bit more intense than lower back pain. I've gone through lumbago recently.
No
Ffs complete waste of my time
"What Happens"
You keep using these words.
I do not think they mean what you think they mean.
"Inconceivable!!"
😄
"It was all done through glitches."
Bye!
Hey how's going guys "MRclickFORthebait here
Shah Bilal he’s gotta make a living
Michael Lafferty or you could simply make 1000 a month off of RUclips
Or Mr Boss for the loss .
@@Rippedbadboy 1000 a month Is very low
@@bentomlins785 He earns 2800$ a day ;)
They were probably drunk and a guy was shooting around Joshua’s head as a game, then shot him
Scabs exactly what I thought. If he was balancing a bottle on his head it would explain the high shots.
That actually makes a lot of sense
your right cuz these shots were above head and they had to grab him .That why there blood stains
These videos are like solving the mysteries of broken pencils....
They're pointless.
Lol
There was probably supposed to be side mission where you have to free the girl but was scraped for whatever reason, hence why you'd be able to get inside and take her out.
2:48 That "Uhh" there was hilarious. Sounded like Boss didn't want to say something like "Ride her to Emerald Ranch"
What a waste of 12:49, only information of value here is that someone glitched in and got her out, which added nothing so totally useless.
So here's a theory. Joshua was the lover of Miriam, and may have been the owner of the saloon. Seamus also had a sweet spot for Miriam and Eugene noticed. Eugene didn't like either of them so paid Seamus to kill Joshua. Joshua may have survived the fight over because of a rivalry they've had in the past, so Joshua would expect it. Joshua fought back, but Seamus shot Joshua in the neck, which would explain the blood looking as if he fell and squirmed as a struggle of bleed out. Eugene did pay Seamus for the murder, but did not give his daughter to him. Miriam was heartbroken over Joshua and could not fall in love with another soul. Also, if Joshua was the owner of the saloon, and Seamus killed him, wouldn't that explain why he sells tons of moonshine?
The poor girl lost her lover, isolated, probably depressed.
Arthur: shoots window to see her reaction.
better yet, you can kill her dad when hes hanging out front
Throw dynamite or molotov cocktails at the house.
August 1898- Death of Joshua and Miriam locks herself indoors. The game takes place between May until June 1899. That's 9-10 months after the death/murder. That is a long time to stay indoors.
Weird...
I would've expected a full side quest related to this mystery... so much potential with the saloon too.
Lets get her out of the house now!
Dutch be like “i have a plan”
Have you done a video about the Mayor of Strawberry? I remember NPCs talking about how he had a strange secret or something, but I never could find out what it was.
U kill him and after you loot him you find a letter from an old love that is now married or something... I don't remember (i ended up killing half the town... Typical strawberry 😂😊)
Andrew same
I killed and looted him and got some letter as the one guy mentioned
@NaNo Games Plus
Who would've thought that the mayor of town named "Strawberry" in heteronormative macho-bullshit cowboy game is GAY! *gasp* 😨🙄
@NaNo Games Plus
Wild West was dotted with closeted gay affairs and romances. BM is the only "serious" popculture rendition of such relationships, of course ppl say the mayor of Strawberry Town being closeted gay is reference to BM.
Just because existence of homosexual cowboys and frontier men wasn't discussed openly, doesn't mean there weren't any...
I wanted my phone battery to die quickly, so I played this video because I knew there'd be nothing interesting in it.
Cheers for your services MrBoss!
"Well, surprisingly enough if you shoot at Merriam as shes is minding her own business, she will be scared off."
One time I was climbing that house and I hear him arguing with making her cry
This is actually pretty cool that a game would get this deep into story. I love this game and the fact that RUclips has so much info for it
Very interesting, I never knew about any of this at Emerald Ranch, I do remember finding a man's dog in another town, but he was very kind and appreciative to me and happy to see his dog. No, the only encounter I had with Emerald Ranch was in the mission "He's British of course" where I track down the male lion, shoot and kill him in self defense, then bring back one of his claws as proof. Considering that man's intensions with his dog (and that "aim weapon"" is your only available option, I would of shot him!
A well narrated video, nicely presented, about an interesting puzzle that totally fails to live up to the title you gave it. How hard would it have been to title it "What do we know about the girl trapped in Emerald Ranch?" Disingenous to published using a poster image of someone else's work.
I think the mystery is R* Cut out a side mission for Emerald Ranch
"She's choosing to stay in the house by choice."
Well that was a waste of time.
Hey MrBossFTW, during the late 19th and early 20th centuries it was not uncommon for the way a person died to be put on their gravestone. Especially on the frontier. So “accidentally shot” might not be sarcasm, it could be the way he died. Also, the position of the shots on the wall looks to be about head high. I think he got drunk, maybe with some buddies, dared someone to do trick shots around him, as you do with the two brothers, and he was accidentally shot. Just my thought. Love your videos BTW!!
The holes in saloon wall definetly look like "Wilhelm Telling with lead"
The point is there's three holes. If it were accidental, there would only be one.
read what you've written again - yeah, you may be right
I like this idea
One time I was challenged to shoot on bottles on a fence, a random guy was working in the fields directly behind the bottles. The aim on my revolver automaticly moved to the person, so I accidently killed him and hell broke lose
I literally just come to these videos for the comments 🤣🤣🤣
I think there's a pretty easy explanation as to why those bullet holes are so far up the wall.
It's possible the shooter was at a lower angle to his/her target. So the shooter was either in a sitting or lying position and was shooting up at their victim.
Another likely scenario is that both the shooter and the victim were standing and the shooter fast drew their pistol and fired from the hip at a sharp 45 degree angle.
Although this would require the both of them to be standing in close proximity to each other. Face-to-face as it were.
Joshua could have been standing on a chair
This man is the ImJayStation of Red Dead videos.
RDR2 is full of dark, scary and creepy details 😭 I'm not complaining though.
4:45 or they were shooting at an *aNgLE*
Drinking game: drink every time this fool says “actually”
MrbossfTW:a man by the name Eugene-
Me:EUGENE H KRABS
the detail situation that went in to a story for a video games that matter or dont matter to a player that is simply crafted out is simply amazing.. i havent even come across this situation at all yet and finnished the game..Rockstar is awesome.. it's the little things they put in that game that impresses me., ive finnished the game and i know theres still lots of reason to keep playing.
What if the little girl shot josh. it'll explain the bullet holes, gun was fired pointed up.
I think you are onto something
2:07 because it’s raining and the soccer ball poped
2:06 "we don't know, why she is in her own house...?" Really ? Maybe because she lives there XD
No she forced to be there by the owner of the ranch you can see the backstory of the ranch
This man is the king of clock bait
Thanks I heard about this while helping the lady with the dead horse back to emerald ranch and needed answers this helped clear things up
All these side stories seem to weigh less on you when you remember you've probably killed a few hundreds of cops, bandits and civilians during your play through.
You kill that many in like 4 missions
I almost took down the whole of Saint Dennis haha... Stood on a boat and just emptied my guns on every cop coming to bring me down.
Why didn’t you put “theories” in the headline?? Made me watch for nothing
Why don’t we try saving her and see for ourselves? 😂
I also find it interesting, that Joshua's grave, isn't among the rest in the small plot on the one road coming into the ranch.
Only thing I found missing is if you go to the gunsmith in Valentine or the clothes shop they talk of how she’s being trapped in the house by her father
"What happens when you free her" idk. You didnt free her and basically said you can't unless you glitch
I fell like all the titles of his vids starts with:What Happens...
She is being forced... TO WATCH JAKE PAUL
S,W,J B. That sucks
Wow.
*Save her*
Oh God, now we really have to save her, she's truly suffering in there.
While playing Red Dead 2 I came across an abandoned mail carriage in the Cumberland forest region and near Fort Wallace. In the carriage was a loot box and inside was a ginseng elixir and 5 or 6 letters. One letter is addressed to Miriam Weigner (The girl in the house at Emeral Ranch) and is written by Annabelle her cousin. In it Annabelle talks about living in New York City and about Miriam’s mental health. In the letter Annabelle also tells her uncle (Mr. Weigner/Owner of Emerald Ranch) that if he is intercepting the letters and not letting Miriam read them then she will be furious or something like that.
This game will never leave my library
Miriam accidentally shot Joshua while drunkenly shooting around his head as he stood against the wall. Or maybe it wasn't entirely an accident. Maybe she was mad at him and was trying to scare him. She put three in the wall around his head and then one in his face.
Eugene, being the head honcho around the place, passed it off to the law as an accident, and then forbade Miriam to leave the house.
I'd say your on the write track. Hasn't anyone seen some shoot a bottle off someone's head. That's what it looks like when you shoot to low
Someone was a good shot that's the broken bottles. She apparently is not a good shot
Great vid mr boss best part of the video is 12:49!😉
I SEE WHAT U DID THERE🤣
She's in the house 'cos it's pissin' down.
2:09
Mr Boss : Why she is inside the house ?
Me : May be because it is rainig outside.
Interesting to see if you can give the letter to the uncle. Also another fun theory in part with Eugene Wegner is he went William Tell on Joshua, instead of trying to shoot an apple of the guy's head he tried shooting a beer off his head.
Helllllo people of the internet have a nice dayy
Hi partner!
Allblackcat13 Lambert you to 😊
U too brother
I was the 60th like
Howdy.
I gave you all i had Dutch........
No you didn't. You still have clothes and weapons. Oh and John got himself killed avenging you. You didn't win. I'm eating the buck you keep seeing and wearing its fur.
i think the bullet holes on the wall were not fatal. if so, those wouldve been some pretty powerful bullets if they went through and through. but..... if they did actually hit a human, wouldnt there be blood on the wall? i dont know just an idea. im not expert so i mightve got some of those wrong
I have issues when any plays forensic scientist. Saying the bullets holes are really high must mean it was a tall person. That's making the "Assumption" the bullets were shot from the same level they hit the wall at. What if the shooter was on the ground and shot up? That kind of changes things.
Tango Nevada so would the shooter be on the ground where the blood splatter is? im not disagreeing with you im just trying to make more sense of it. maybe they both had guns and only one person managed to hit the other🤷♂️. yea im no forensic scientist but i do find it interesting and what they do
@@hoot3780 I was referring less to the scene in the game then I was to what I see in real life on Crime Scene Shows and the media when they make assumptions about the positions people were in and then you can easily poke holes in it with something as simple as "Maybe the other guy was a midget"
Tango Nevada yea i think i understand what youre saying
Also "blood on the wall " because bullets go thru someone is movie narrative.. lottsa times in real life, IF a bullet goes thru someone and imbeds in an object behind the victim, the bullet is too fast and too small to produce blood splatter .. usually only head shots trigger that kind of "red mist"
12:01 "she is choosing to stay in the house by choice". You just said the same thing twice.
I have done literally every single thing you're supposed to do to see the girl and I have not seen her even one time.
my theory would be the father went into the saloon got a drink and shot joshua from outside and then falsely stated he got drunk and accidentaly shot his gun, then he locked his daughter inside the house so she wouldnt get out, he stays out side to make sure no lover can reach her and no one can know much about her and to make sure she doesnt go out from the front door,
the girl likes to look out the window because she misses the outdoors and dreams one day to actually go outside and live free as joshua said in the letter, that shes a girl with big life (or something like that).
Ahmad idheileh failed it was her girl cousin that wrote the letter and how can the pops shoot Joshua from outside when the bullets hole are inside of the wall? Your forensics deducing sucks lol
Roses are red violets are blue i got click baited and so did you
Mystery solved, she's in the house because she lives there 🤣
I’m looking at the chat and im feeling some agressive vibes in the chat I might be the only positive chat but hey maybe your giving hints for other people to solve but either way good job dude! :)