La mayoría de los comentarios son respeto a la actitud de la gran Diva Monserrat Caballe pero ahí que recordar que ella es maestra que sabe lo que dice que piso un escenario es alguien probada no es una improvisada así que lo que haga es ley muchos de los que tienen el privilegio de asistir a un máster class creen o piensan que van a enseñar cuando es todo lo contrario uno va aprender se piensa que el maestro lo va llenar de elogios porque creen que tiene talento y eso no siempre es así algunos estudian pero eso no es todo la voz es un don con el que se nace y es más fácil entender lo que estos Divos piden lo que no se puede hacer es tener el don y ella fue una elegida por eso es muy difícil comprender a estos grandes por qué veces exigen lo que muchos no tienen aunque estudian en el conservatorio con maestros que nunca pisaron un escenario les hacen creer lo que no son pero la actitud de humildad debe ser departe de los alumnos no de la Diva
Of you course anyone get laughing if there a person screaming in front of you. I really dont why people on youtube think that opera is just high high notes. And a MasterClass is for someone that know how to use the voice whit property. The girl doesn't know how to cover voice, how does want to sing Opera?
Cette voix est en déjà en lambeaux, et c'est dommage car les moyens sont là, mais dans quel éta!!. Et c'est cruel de voir même la gentille Montserrat d'habitude patiente et pédagogue, ne pouvoir retenir ses réactions: je me trompe peut-être, mais elle ses rires semblent plus incontrôlables que chaleureux!!
Wow. I thought the vocalizing was pretty bad until she got into the aria. I always assumed that you had to have acquired a certain degree of mastery already in order to get into a master class, but this young woman seems to indicate quite the opposite. Apparently no one has had the heart to tell her where her deficiencies lie.
Being gifted by God with a great talent, and being lucky to have the chance to study and learn vey good about any technique doesn´t make you more valuable that others, laughing about somebody is a horrible attitude.
They trying really hard not to laugh. And she can hit some really great high notes she just needs to learn how to hit them better and gain more control.
her notes were sharp and harsh - breath support is unbalanced. That is why Montserat is so appalled. Her voice is out of control in many respects - tonal and support.
the girl doesn't have the discipline to sing with Caballe--there are far too many technical mistakes to correct because she is used to doing whatever she wants to do without any attention to technique or style. But she has guts to do this before Caballe and if she wants to learn from Caballe, it will be very difficult.
I wouldn't exactly say "fabulous." She has a big voice, and can hit some pretty impressively high notes, but she doesn't hit them particularly well. The sound, on the very top notes, even in the warm-up, is spread, not focused, and sounds like a squeal. Her middle register is a mess, and there is virtually no legato at all. What voice teacher allowed her to sing that aria, for which she is clearly unsuited, in front of Caballe, a master of line and of elegant, controlled singing?
Mark.....I'm more appalled at the horrible wobble. There is no support here she is pushing her voice, and that is not true singing. She needs to lighten up considerably and get ahold of those pitches. Here is an example of someone with the goods but no technique or control !
I have heard (although I cannot confirm it from many Google searches) that Ms. Caballe doesn't charge a dime for her master classes, she gives free classes in the interest of furthering the careers of young singers and the art of opera.
@@saxmexicano NEVER would Montserrat make fun of anyone, ,,she gave her time freely and would have spoken at length afterwards .She was a beautiful kind person 💕 ❤ 💖
aun no hay nadie que haya llegado a donde ha llegado mi maestro, el conociiento que se tiene hoy en dia de la voz,es tan pobre,que ni monserrat caballe ni el mas grande cantante,conocen de verdad el mecanismo del canto todos los grandes cantantes como monserrat caballe cantan por sus genes, no porque sepan de verdad como funciona el mecanismo¿y como convencer a todos los cantantes que la tierra es redonda y no plana?es lo que ha descubierto mi maestro,que mucha de las cosas que se dicensonfalsas
Monserrat looks like she is saying," girl what are you doing"? yet she is charmed by her as well! Priceless!
6:53 Her hand, I'm dying ahahahahah
If you're going to recoil 06:59 is the time for it
This girl was a diamond in the rough ❤️
I wonder where she is today...
Caballe had such a cimmedian personality 😭😭
Her voice is enormous, she should sing Valkyrie.
Girl is very positive, I liked the vocals))) Montserrat - 👍
Montserrat's reaction at 6:51 is CLASSIC!!!
She knew what was coming! Love her so much. ❤️
bravissimo Antonia, respect and love
La studente e parecchio convinta di essere fantastica .
Anche la maestra...
No sneering 😪
La mayoría de los comentarios son respeto a la actitud de la gran Diva Monserrat Caballe pero ahí que recordar que ella es maestra que sabe lo que dice que piso un escenario es alguien probada no es una improvisada así que lo que haga es ley muchos de los que tienen el privilegio de asistir a un máster class creen o piensan que van a enseñar cuando es todo lo contrario uno va aprender se piensa que el maestro lo va llenar de elogios porque creen que tiene talento y eso no siempre es así algunos estudian pero eso no es todo la voz es un don con el que se nace y es más fácil entender lo que estos Divos piden lo que no se puede hacer es tener el don y ella fue una elegida por eso es muy difícil comprender a estos grandes por qué veces exigen lo que muchos no tienen aunque estudian en el conservatorio con maestros que nunca pisaron un escenario les hacen creer lo que no son pero la actitud de humildad debe ser departe de los alumnos no de la Diva
Comenzemos con los signos de puntuación. Son el diafragma del idioma!!! :-)
agreed. The warm up was quite good. I have no idea what happened there after was it was almost like listening to another singer.
The warm up was not good at all😅😅
@machiikokyo ...¡Fue muy divertido! más por venir pronto
Can anyone tell me what is the high pitch that she reached.
I bet Montserrat is laughing because this giro cant control her voice.
Everything is TOO MUCH
La cara de Montserrat un poema!!! jajaja
Of you course anyone get laughing if there a person screaming in front of you. I really dont why people on youtube think that opera is just high high notes.
And a MasterClass is for someone that know how to use the voice whit property. The girl doesn't know how to cover voice, how does want to sing Opera?
She was one of he most promising students during her conservatory phase....Yes it was really a while ago.
@The - ABC - Celestial Surgery Centre Teaching singing, obtaining her phd.
montsy is really horrified
And interested...
Cette voix est en déjà en lambeaux, et c'est dommage car les moyens sont là, mais dans quel éta!!. Et c'est cruel de voir même la gentille Montserrat d'habitude patiente et pédagogue, ne pouvoir retenir ses réactions: je me trompe peut-être, mais elle ses rires semblent plus incontrôlables que chaleureux!!
Si Montsy applaudit à la fin, c'est parce qu'il voit quand même du talent.
Wow. I thought the vocalizing was pretty bad until she got into the aria. I always assumed that you had to have acquired a certain degree of mastery already in order to get into a master class, but this young woman seems to indicate quite the opposite. Apparently no one has had the heart to tell her where her deficiencies lie.
What aria did she sing?
Quel guardo il cavalier, from Don Pasquale.
Being gifted by God with a great talent, and being lucky to have the chance to study and learn vey good about any technique doesn´t make you more valuable that others, laughing about somebody is a horrible attitude.
They trying really hard not to laugh. And she can hit some really great high notes she just needs to learn how to hit them better and gain more control.
You’re actually confuse. It does make you indeed more valuable. That’s why the is only one Montserrat.
Habrás observado que no se ríe cuando la chica canta realmente mal. No parece en absoluto ser una risa de burla.
Girl had a bad wobble.
her notes were sharp and harsh - breath support is unbalanced. That is why Montserat is so appalled. Her voice is out of control in many respects - tonal and support.
Not appalled but fun because she felt this pupil got an incredible energy to work with but needs control.
The lady is screeching instead of singing while practicing her scales lol
Pobre Montserrat. Pensará: "Ay, Diosito mío, donde comenzar!"
Title should be caballe sneering at pupils vocalizing
Who is this?
Subtitulenlo
This could have been a comedy routine! Does the girl actually think she sounds GOOD?
l really thinks she deos....XD so sad for her
What piece did she sing?
Quel guardo il cavaliere...So anch'io la virtù magica from Don Pasquale -
Donizetti
Agree'd the warm up was fairly good. And then it went down hill o.O
She sounds like a wounded animal. Put her out of our misery, Montsy.
a crying vagina
Laughing is not helping. I think it´s better to stop her and teach or even ask her to sit and listen.
the girl doesn't have the discipline to sing with Caballe--there are far too many technical mistakes to correct because she is used to doing whatever she wants to do without any attention to technique or style. But she has guts to do this before Caballe and if she wants to learn from Caballe, it will be very difficult.
Ουάου
I wouldn't exactly say "fabulous." She has a big voice, and can hit some pretty impressively high notes, but she doesn't hit them particularly well. The sound, on the very top notes, even in the warm-up, is spread, not focused, and sounds like a squeal. Her middle register is a mess, and there is virtually no legato at all. What voice teacher allowed her to sing that aria, for which she is clearly unsuited, in front of Caballe, a master of line and of elegant, controlled singing?
Mark.....I'm more appalled at the horrible wobble. There is no support here she is pushing her voice, and that is not true singing. She needs to lighten up considerably and get ahold of those pitches. Here is an example of someone with the goods but no technique or control !
E allora??????????
There is a class, there is no master. This girl need some help, but I think Ms. Caballé is only interested in her bank account.
I have heard (although I cannot confirm it from many Google searches) that Ms. Caballe doesn't charge a dime for her master classes, she gives free classes in the interest of furthering the careers of young singers and the art of opera.
Yes, probably she´s there just to make fun about others, probably that´s priceless for her.
no xD
These master classes were free
@@saxmexicano NEVER would Montserrat make fun of anyone, ,,she gave her time freely and would have spoken at length afterwards .She was a beautiful kind person 💕 ❤ 💖
Oooooh......Montserrats Blicke sagen Alles!!!!!!This girl is soooo bad.....but very funny🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The whole voice is way out of focus. Not taking in the right amount air and then does not even support it. She is no coloratura!
aun no hay nadie que haya llegado a donde ha llegado mi maestro, el conociiento que se tiene hoy en dia de la voz,es tan pobre,que ni monserrat caballe ni el mas grande cantante,conocen de verdad el mecanismo del canto todos los grandes cantantes como monserrat caballe cantan por sus genes, no porque sepan de verdad como funciona el mecanismo¿y como convencer a todos los cantantes que la tierra es redonda y no plana?es lo que ha descubierto mi maestro,que mucha de las cosas que se dicensonfalsas
Podrías recomendarme a tu maestro? mi correo es pianosaxmexicano@yahoo.com
Ουάου