The Journey of Shehla Rashid-Left or Right? Part 1
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- We are honored to welcome Shehla Rashid Shora, a prominent Indian human rights activist and scholar in this episode of Indian This Week. Shehla served as the vice-president of the Jawaharlal Nehru University Students' Union in 2015-16. She has also been an active member of the All India Students Association.
Shehla recently garnered attention with her remarks praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi, stating, “What caused my change of heart is the realization that the Hon’ble PM Narendra Modi is a selfless man who is taking radical decisions to transform India. He has braved intense criticism but remained steadfast to his vision of inclusive development that leaves no one behind.”
In this episode, we delve into Shehla's early life and education, explore her experiences at JNU, and discuss the challenges and triumphs of being a woman in public life. Shehla also shares personal anecdotes about her friendships with fellow activists Kanhaiya Kumar and Umar Khalid.
Don't miss this captivating conversation as we uncover the journey and insights of one of India's most dynamic voices. Tune in now!
Subscribe to our channel for more thought-provoking discussions and stay updated with the latest episodes of Indian This Week by Amana and Khalid!
#indiathisweek #politics #activism
To support our work, please join the channel and access the perks:
Exclusive content
Early access to episodes
Members-only live chats
Behind-the-scenes updates
Subscribe now and be part of our community! Here is the link-
/ @indiathisweekbyamanak...
If you like our work, Please consider supporting us on
1. Gpay/Paytm Number :+91 91165 88224
2. UPI ID: khalidnazirbaig@okaxis
3. Our Patreon Account is
patreon.com/IndiathisweekbyAmanaKhalid
4. You can also become a Channel Member. The link for that is - youtube.com/@IndiaThisWeekByAmanaKhalid
5. You can reach out to us on indiathisweekbyamanakhalid@gmail.com
6. Please do like, share, and subscribe to our channel
7. The support of our subscribers, viewers, and especially our Members and Patreons keeps us going, we are ever so thankful. 🙏
I am really happy that she didn't go down the dark rabbit hole of communists,she spent time in a premier institute,she can give that knowledge to other students now.... There are many things to criticise the government about ,but to think revolution brings good, then ask middle East....in 2011 they thought that,ask Iraqis who thought America bringing down Saddam would bring change for the better .... Chinese brought change in 1949 and looked how many people disappeared in famines, Bolshevik thought of bringing a utopian world with them,ask Ukraine about that utopia .... Criticise the government but to think a revolution will bring all the good,its just pure insanity
Even though I’m huge fan of Chacha Nehru but I blame him for implementing socialism even if he did with good intentions. Now we youth will have to get rid of communism from Kerala and Bengal & it just makes me furious that even youth of now in these respected states are falling in the pit of communism.
Thousands or lakhs of youth were influenced by Shehla, Umar and Kanhaiya. Can that damage be reversed?
Umar kanaihya part of her guru
No. She HAS to be put up for accountability. She only supports modi now because her own father came before media and told that she embezzeled 3cr from donations her NGO received
Delhi is not whole India
it can ,but it'll take long time
That is not entirely correct, people usually latch on to the people with whom they feel aligned ideologically.
It is time for you to bring Sahil XM On your show to have different perspective on religion of peace
No do not bring xmuslims . This will be ruined .
Well articulated shaila....
Can't wait to see more like her in coming days
Smashing podcast tackling a very interesting guest with a very complicated, barely believable history and polar opposite change. Starting to get quite refreshingly honest and brave takes. Going from the islamist-communist toxic nexus to the more central and logical line is amazing. Very hard to unpick and you did brilliantly. Could be a very inspirational and prominent leader.
Khalid and Amana, you are both rockstars. Your clear and concise ideas is why I enjoy watching your discussions. Keep up the good work.
It is convenient to just claim that the students that raised the slogans were not JNU. Separatist speeches have been encouraged and have been voiced from the campus of JNU time and again. If you are organizing a rally, it is your responsibility that such things do not happen. One may argue post consequences and reactions to the slogans raised, it was consciously discouraged and stopped. An example is the Palestinian protests where now participants are asked not to talk about the protests to media or anyone else to expose their ignorance of the issue.
Sheila Rashid is being a bit disingenuous in claiming JNU campus was not a venue for separatist ideology. Folks such as Arundhathi Roy are platformed consistently at JNU. Indeed freedom of speech implies that we are allowed to hold views and speak our minds. However, encouraging separatism and divisions in social structures are detrimental to society and does not help anyone.
The left thinks they are intellectual but they are absolutely not. The lens of oppressor and oppressed resumes a socially motivated prejudgment of social structures into a binary category. Instead of calling out systemic discrimination, the left tries to impose a theory of sorts on the existing human condition of discrimination and protection of self interests. When resources are limited and first come first served, people in power are naturally incentivized to create systems that discriminate and preserve their privilege in society. Over time this becomes the norm. If the tables were turned, the so called Pasmandas would be as oppressive. They would engage in similar discrimination. It is not that somehow things would be different. What the left does is take an anecdotal situation an generalize it. It is not my claim that systemic social discrimination does not exist, it does. I am just objecting to the tendencies of the left. They determine what is discrimination. An great example is the men vs women binary. Fundamentally what the left presumes is that there exists some utopia of equality. That is exactly what has come about in modern times. The woke movement is essentially an outcome of this theology. The notion of equal outcomes. Unfortunately nature has a natural bias towards the fittest. One cannot artificially reduce standards or introduce barriers to enforce equality of sorts. This is exactly what has resulted in break down of family structures that is essential for human children. The extreme focus on women's equality and liberation that has resulted in women being force fed the idea that they are useless unless they participate in the Corporate world. Women are useless unless they are generating income is the direct result of such thinking. This idea completely ignores that many women if not most are more geared towards nurturing and raising a family and staying home. What the left does is distort and build an extreme theory that results in extreme social disruptions that are difficult to course correct once embarked upon.
When left comes to power, it is not anarchy. It is an anarchical dictatorship. Look at what the CPI-CPM and other communist parties have done. Look at the track record of the left wherever and whenever it has been in power. The genocides in the world have happened under the watch of the left.
As for Kashmir and BJP policy there. The Kashmir issue was not one of general discontent. It was an issue of secessionism both internal and external. It needed a heavy hand and BJP used it. The years of negotiations and mollycoddling that was motivated be misguided left ideology never worked. Imagine this Left does not shun violence if need be. However, given their anarchist lineage, they do not mind secessionist ideas. That is a natural outgrowth of their ideology. They are fundamentally anti-national. They will not tell you that directly, however the end result is the same. The left is really ant-national and anti-society. They are not interested in fixing problems. They are looking for new sources of division and oppressor-oppression mechanics.
Thanks!
A great, very respectful conversation. It was wonderful to listen to :)
please do an interview of Exmuslim Sahil.
They’d never 😂😂
Will Sheila Condemn Islam for the terror caused in kashmir?
Nope.
Very interesting! Thank you for giving her the platform to express her opinions.
Thank you
28:54 word of advice for Shehla the analysis you call amazing might actually be the biggest flaw of left ideologies. When you start looking at the world issues in terms of haves and have nots, Oppressors and victims you by default make an enemy faction. Pitting one part of society against the other. This is where Guru Nanak’s non duality could help left a great deal. It says there is no good or evil its all one and everyone has it in them to be either oppressed or oppressor. If we start focusing more on who needs help and not finding factions to blame for misfortunes of others we will stop alienating half the world and instead make everyone agree with what needs to be fixed and how. And I refuse to believe that unless you find someone to blame there is no way you can help people who need help 🤷🏽♂️
Left / Right, Opressor / Oppressed etc...... imported theories. Nothing from the native soil.😢
monotheism was the first imported theory.
Shehla im sanghi (called by my gf) but my views are same almost on the all topics you've discussed..
I've noticed that only Leftists/Islamists use the term Sanghi when they see someone putting nation above all or when they can't counter an argument. I wonder as to how a Leftists/Islamists is dating a Sanghi.
Brilliant job aamna and khalid 👍
This is a perfect debate. Thanks to Khalid.
This is not debate.
I was here first!! ❤
Amana and Khalid please improve production quality of videos you will get more views
Back with a bang 💥 ❤
"......there is Afzal Guru, there is aa aa aa Whatever....... ! Couldn't even think of a second example.
Well Said Sister Shehla Rashid your open remarks abt leftist so true 👍 👏
Interesting discussion. I am glad you guys are back with more interesting subjects & podcasts. 😅😅
She is such a manipulating conversationist...she is not so bold to speak what should be spoken...what a waste of time this podcast is...i except Better from amana and khalid ..guys get better ppl..have a podcast with j sai Deepak..we need a discourse with hindu and muslim side on sensitive issues
There's no lack of Sai's interviews in yt. But this interview is unique because theres a woman previously far left now centrist-ish coming to a right wing podcast. Why do you have to listen to the same thing over and over again?
I like shehla these days
34:20
I absolutely adore the question raised by the panelist .
On shehla's answer -
Why are Muslim men the mass base of left parties if not to overthrow the state.
Hence the arguments of far right about Muslim community( rather who view religion as their primary identity) can't be thrown out of the window , that's why they are getting votes
you are both top interviewers. Respectful but keep them accountable. She was BSing and ducking and diving, weaving around a lot of things like the tukde tukde social sciences department bit which she got defensive about. But you kept it calm and so it didn't go hostile or off track. But I'm so glad you didn't collude or cave in with soft ball. You are both Ms Amana and Mr Khalid real honest gems who the world needs a lot lot more of
Excellent show. Good to know Shehla is doing fine and go on confrontational path that can only ruin ones life. She didn't succumb to the destructive machinations of the leftists who instill the negative approach into the young minds.
38.40. congress is not in power in rajasthan.. its BJP.. when was this recording done?
As a practicing Muslim Indian, how do you suggest we navigate in India. Because Islamic laws and the country’s law may conflict!
@nemo-ru9vs around 20 lakh kids enrolled in Madarsa vs 6.6 Cr in schools. So statistically lets not generalise that we dont have education. Quality of education for 6.6 can be questioned. Being a good muslim or an Indian that statement is like saying 3rd world countries should curb their carbon emissions. Reforms are needed in community and in policies to increase inclusivity and not to further the divide. Freedom of Practicing your religion should be given to all.
Like which laws? Any specifics?
It is about time you give up Islamic laws and move on. Just like Hindus gave up old practices and accepted the regular Indian laws.
This is 2024.
@nemo-ru9vs to answer on increasing inclusivity. I suggest firstly the polarisation of residential areas needs to be dealt with. With communal tension caused by BJP. If you deny then i can’t say anything. Each community is now localised into specific area. Hindus dont get homes in muslim areas and same for muslims. In Vadodara a 38 year old Muslim lady who got a house in a development project was protested by the society and was not allowed to stay in that building. Tolerance will only increase if people live together, study together and hate speech propaganda stops. Where a women has an equal right to either wear or not to wear a Burkha ! If there are 3 more Muslim IAS this year compared to last its termed as UPSC jihad. And believe me these narratives stick with the Majority. Holocaust was not done in a day. It was a systematic attack my polarising the masses.
UCC is the name.
Super
Wts going on in India is not Bjp vs Congress
ITS Leftist vs Rightist
No, its leftist-communist-islamists vs normal people
Who knows? Next year, Rana Ayyub or Arfa Cartoon Biryani will be on your podcast explaining why she started loving BJP and Modi😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
why not?
@@bmniac I'm not joking. I'm serious. I really want to see those people change sides.
Good podcast
💞❤️ from Assam
positive mindset and aspiration for economic prosperity of the people are the top priority
Amana Khalid as regular viewer of your channel please don't fall for these tricks
Sheila bro I read ur tweet about the income distribution maths. What was your subject in NIT? Or brain cells starts dying after joining sangh.
It seems her approach towards the problem has changed. It signifies presence of brain. Change is constant.. does it ring a bell?
It's going to be fun
I normally like your discussions but giving any screen time to people who erstwhile wanted to country to be broken up is utterly disappointing. It’s too little too late. Everyone is allowed to protest but not the break up the nation. Sorry, wish this screen time was used better with someone else.
Bro she is an Computer science engineer completed her btech in cse fron NIT srinagar.
Then phd in social sciences from jnu
She is also an ex employee of wipro pvt ltd.. 😂😂😂
Kya zarurat padi hoga in mohtarma ji ko yeh sab karna ki...
@Shekhar9900 bhai yeh bandi dekhna mein bhi sundar hai, upper caste ashraf kashmiri muslim family sa iska taluk hai. Kya wajah rahi hogi hindu sa hatred ki , most probably if she is muslim a little bit iska bf bhi hindu nahi hoga, koi mulla ji ho hoga toh isko kisi hindu ladka na dhoka bhi nahi diya hoga toh yeh jo hatred hai pagan, idolaters, non Muslim etc sa yeh in built hai quran, sunnah hadith mein..
@@omprasad1944 gossip ye hai ki, jnu me iska bf hindu tha
@@anahita-bn6cy yes maina bahut case dekha hai muslim female kaa din bhar kafir hatred ka milkshake piyaga
Phir upper caste hindu bf baneygi...
I think they hate sc st and dalit Peculiarly...
Never trust this guest. She is chameleon. Selfish, self cenetred
Yeh gori ladki kon hai😂😂
Note-"Not a sexist or racist remark"
Good job buddies 🙌🏽👏🏻✌🏽
Being defensive on janu and slogans which everyone heard. She is faking half of it and the other half she wants to be on a the safer side
Her wing is oppurtunism.😂
Umar Khalid intelligent LMAO.
I dnt agree with sheila Rashid
The Nitish Kumar of political activists
REALLY LIKE THIS
Bhai isko assistant professor ban dia gya hai, she was always an opportunist.
silly.
ye kaali se gori kaise ho gayi 😂
I dont trust her.