i definitely agree, the album version to me seems more like a beautiful look at a manic adventure of loneliness if that makes any sense - this one is more raw, it feels more like a rollercoaster through emotions, it hits me as a crying song. this song helps me a lot :)
it reminds me of the long and winding road by the beatles. the version on the let it be album is pretty beautiful with the orchestra and stuff, but the simpler version on the let it be… naked album is so much more beautiful than the album version. just like this.
joe hawley's music (especially this ver of stranded lullaby) never fails to make me curl up into a ball on my bed and sob profusely until i fall asleep 4am on a monday morning
i can remember listening to this song while on a cruise. it was night, the moon was shining, and the waves were beating against the boat. this version feels like im looking back at those memories. the cruise was right after i got out of a serious depression, and then it felt like i was free. it was gone. but in reality it wasnt… life is cruel.
So weird how the internet does that to us. I went from listening to this highly emotional song to looking at a meme about naming your rival 'Ass' in Pokémon. It's like RUclips never wants us to let what we watch truly sink in or make a meaningful impression on us. I usually don't write ranty comments, but this is an exception. I really hope you're doing well rn, and remember that life is just ups and downs, and you'll get back to the place you were on that cruise ship if you hold on.
@@bean_eater1209 he wrote this song for his girlfriend after his girlfriend moved but they stayed together, and then they broke up and the meaning of the song changed completely and all the lyrics were changed :(
of course it says in the description so i believe they aren't getting money from it and the money that they do get goes to Joe Hawley and the other creators
This song reminds me of my friend, but we drifted apart, and I haven’t talked to them for months...I miss you man.. I hope we’ll see each other again some day
@@ratofthecity6351 thank you so much.. as of right now we do not talk anymore.. and tbh it’s for the best because they turned out to be toxic.. thanks for reaching out man
@@pedrobautista927 This song is a modified version of another song written by Joe Hawley, titled 'Our Lullabye'. It was written for his lover he had at the time. She had some obligation to go somewhere, and so he made this as a parting gift. Soon after, they broke up for unknown reasons, and stopped talking to each other entirely. If you want, I can research further, but that's the basic gist.
@@notto5937 that same girlfriend also filed a restraining order on Joe for no apparent reason and he had to go to court for it and missed a whole Tally Hall tour
This reminds me of how an old friend of mine did horrible things and slowly morphed to be a bad person. It was always there, in ways that I didn’t see or ignored because I was too young to tell that it was bad. I miss some memories with them, the part of them I liked, but now they’re all ruined because of how awful I know they can be. It’s sad to think on those good memories because they feel ruined and sad.
There's a still tension in the swell Of dreamt debris afloat amidst the waves and then dispel Aimless thoughts and papers blown around A million moments meant remembered rest in deep dark sound Game the mess I'd like to know why you are all alone while I'm lost at sea Maybe we'll be there when you want Anchorless and unmoored set amiss Awake would only prove the fantasy made lucid sense Sail on sail on I'd like to know why you are all alone while I'm lost at sea Maybe we'll be there when you want There's a still tension in the swell So given to the vast receiving emptiness of time Beyond beyond I'd like to know why you are all alone while I... You're unsure if I am A loose end or a strand That waits for you to mend or understand
@@angela22778 more than alright actually! my life has gotten a lot better since those times. i only commented this a month ago but the event took place a year ago.
its much better for you to learn stuff by ear, it's a good exercise and this song isn't the most complicated so i suggest taking it upon yourself as a challenge
I miss you, my shining 🌟. My highest intent is that you should be by my side, but perhaps that is merely the lying whispers of Hope. Even the ghost of you was more joy than I had ever known.
I absolutely love the original version that’s on the album. This is much better though and a lot more fitting and sells the feeling of Stranded out in the middle of Sea with no hope of being able to get back or discover an escape of the endless waves.
this song reminds me of my Girl friend harber... we where close freinds and we use to meet all the time in a game on steam called Gmod intil one day... she falled of a 10 room stair exit and falled all the way down... then she was never the same after that and we could'nt hang out and play anymore because of her problems... so we where never close after that...
idk we think the main character is called Simon who's girlfriend got killed by a tree that was cut down by a murder who thought they where *Murders* . Then he gets put on trail pleads insanity and gets electric shock therapy which is why we have the song *The Mind Electric* which is indeed to do with electric shock therapy. He gets sent to an asylum which he feels like its a *Labyrinth* and jumps the floors using trap doors he hallucinates and thinks he is being chased by his Ex-girlfriend (unknown to who she is) and sees the ghost of his dead girlfriend guiding him flying away as she made the asylum. (two endings with *Time Machine*) Ending 1: Simon escapes and finds a *Time Machine* in the asylum goes back in time. Ending 2:The asylum lets him out and he wishes he made a *Time Machine* to go back in time and does or doesn't do it. He then goes out in sea as he is a sailor then gets stranded at sea and dies by a siren who sounds like his girlfriend then he drowns in freezing cold water he becomes a ghost and sings *Stranded Lullaby* to remember his girlfriend which is why in the demo he sings "I was made for you... you where made for me" I would use the demo version or this version for stranded lullaby as it is sadder then put the original one after or before isle to thyself. Simon sails to the edge of the universe humming the tune of *Stranded Lullaby* he then makes the reference to *The Introduction To The Snow* the start of his life. The siren promised him before he died endless apologies of paradise as she is a goddess. Simon then sails off and goes together in flight as its now or never. Simon says "Believe me darling the stars where made for falling..." as his girlfriend reunites with him. Simon thinks it feels like flying but maybe his dying and was actually alive and is now dying. His life from birth to death flashes before him in a cosmic pyramids hologram. He sees the siren who I shall call the goddess of death is singing her staging music murder. Simon knows they are all on the beyond and above and its perfectly clear they are. Simon's girlfriend tells him she was guiding him through the asylum as much as she could. Simon then realise how everything looks so divine under the lights of the vibrant lights of the beyond and above. The whale sails through as the pure delight from Simon surrounds him as they sail through the beyond and above known as the rising kingdom come as known one can be the last person there due to their existence no longer existing. Simon and The Whale sails and sees what new things they can make along their journey they have a party on the boat with his girlfriend, the whale, the goddess of death and himself. A lining of any finale song is so long and so far that they all will be turning a last turning as they last internal through the past of blinding star. They then all separate again. Simon floats high and higher as he realises he never meant to part the blinding line or light after all one life might as well float higher and higher than the sun. He goes back to earth and finds out he is invisible to some until its time for them to also *Dream Sweet In Sea Major* . Also dream sweet in sea major lasts 7:00 minutes which is also the time left before fully dying so another version of that long paragraph can be Simon's last 7:00 minutes before death and stranded lullaby could be representing his death .
This is the same guy who made a rap song about all the facts that support the argument about your mother being a basketball
yes
And the same one to rant about absurd combinations of food; amalgamations of the culinary scene.
i know. it's really surprising how he can make one of the most beautiful, hauntingly gorgeous songs of all time, and also make Stranded Lullaby.
@@Echo-tl7whHELPPP
@@Echo-tl7wh LMAO
I love how his real singing voice sounds just like his published versions. No auto tune needed, no pre-recorded piano, nothing. Spectacular.
chipmunk joe is real see how the brain plays around
@@annaranha and you fall inside a hole you couldn't see
@@yuiopqwert2172 a whole what
@@JoeBirthMother oh shit, i didn't notice tha
@@yuiopqwert2172 and You fall inside a hole inside a
joe hawley DOES NOT need autotune💯💯
real autotune needs him🙏🏻🙏🏻
I agree mostly but Have you seen him at sonic lunch
@@skystrike9807he was just depressed. He still is
Does not need a physical body
I will say it now, this version of Stranded Lullaby is way sadder than the original I wanna cry whenever I hear it
It reminds me of an empty house. With only the memories of what once was
i definitely agree, the album version to me seems more like a beautiful look at a manic adventure of loneliness if that makes any sense - this one is more raw, it feels more like a rollercoaster through emotions, it hits me as a crying song. this song helps me a lot :)
Rome sucks, but we're here for it.
This and the 1st demo man, on verge of tears
it reminds me of the long and winding road by the beatles. the version on the let it be album is pretty beautiful with the orchestra and stuff, but the simpler version on the let it be… naked album is so much more beautiful than the album version. just like this.
somehow, he managed to make it sadder
Resident Simon, how do you plead?
@@LemonPartIIguilty
@@LemonPartII gultysin nongulty urm can I have my phone call?
@@Mr.happy689 🌳
@@LemonPartII Hun thats a tree
joe hawley's music (especially this ver of stranded lullaby) never fails to make me curl up into a ball on my bed and sob profusely until i fall asleep 4am on a monday morning
excuse me, you have described an exact experince i have had and now i need to know if you're either my clone or spying on me
**Cries self to sleep to **_Black People White People_****
Even his Joe Hawley Joe Hawley songs?
@@imrantube747
"sobbing in corner"
"you good?"
"yeah, I'm just listening to your mother is a basketball"
I want to be held by this song
me after minor inconvenience
real
this is so me
ong
Um that's dark . . . Do you want to talk about it?
That commentary really aged well
in every version of stranded lullaby, I will always obsess over the accentuation of the line "a loose end or a strand"
i can remember listening to this song while on a cruise. it was night, the moon was shining, and the waves were beating against the boat. this version feels like im looking back at those memories. the cruise was right after i got out of a serious depression, and then it felt like i was free. it was gone. but in reality it wasnt… life is cruel.
why am i commenting this after watching horrible mobile game ads
whatever
So weird how the internet does that to us. I went from listening to this highly emotional song to looking at a meme about naming your rival 'Ass' in Pokémon.
It's like RUclips never wants us to let what we watch truly sink in or make a meaningful impression on us.
I usually don't write ranty comments, but this is an exception. I really hope you're doing well rn, and remember that life is just ups and downs, and you'll get back to the place you were on that cruise ship if you hold on.
@@keilankand I thought I couldn't get deeper than the bottom (help me)
I can’t believe joe died
He resurrected time after
@@untalvictor8206did he deserve to be revived?
@@rubytaxicabidk man.
It’s just a sad feeling
He went after a bad stage from his life
This song was inspired on the love he lose and drift him away
im pretty sure he continued his relationship with his gf for years after this was made initially. she just moved away for school.
@@bean_eater1209 who?
@@wash8533 joe hawley
@@bean_eater1209 he wrote this song for his girlfriend after his girlfriend moved but they stayed together, and then they broke up and the meaning of the song changed completely and all the lyrics were changed :(
aw hell naw they kilt joe
bora.
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
fifteen seconds of bora is my favorite anime
lol
Sorry 4 bad English. Where were you when Joe was ghost? I was at house eating dorito when phone rang
joe is kil
no
anime profile picture lmao
wat
In the mountains of the north east US.
Joe Hawley attack
i am cry
stranded lullaby is underloved :(
Bro I see you everywhere
lemon demon stan stating facts
@@tally_hal your words hurt me, hal from megamind
COME WITH ME FELLO ILLEMONATUS FOR SHALL WE WILL DO RITUALS WHILE LISTINING TO TWO TRUCKS
I wish i could hear joe
ghosts can't sing.
@@residentsimon9921 he do got a point
😳
Who's joe?
@@movedaccounts5764 joe mama
There will never be a song that invokes the same feeling in me as this one does.
But if there is one I am more than happy to listen to it
Try “Echoes” and “Brain Damage” by Pink Floyd and let me know what you think!
Euthanasia by Will Wood always does it for me.
@@TheRealJToasteryes
Fucking yes
@@Thestuffdoer tsd in the wild
oliver buckland espial??
To be fair, neither tallyall or magic 8 bird...y'know...actually made the video.
True. I apologize to this whole comment section for my actions.
of course it says in the description so i believe they aren't getting money from it and the money that they do get goes to Joe Hawley and the other creators
This song reminds me of my friend, but we drifted apart, and I haven’t talked to them for months...I miss you man.. I hope we’ll see each other again some day
reach out if you can!! if you want to keep a relationship then you should let that person know! i believe in you!
@@ratofthecity6351 thank you so much.. as of right now we do not talk anymore.. and tbh it’s for the best because they turned out to be toxic.. thanks for reaching out man
i would vent but im too tired and i dont want to bring anyone down and i dont even feel anymore so theres no need to vent
@@senilerodentAs little as it may mean coming from a random RUclips commenter one month after your comment was posted, you can if you want.
i have seen this dude rapping about food, alone with a face on his finger, on an empty mall parking lot
Very powerful when you *learn* this song's origins.
What is the origin
@@pedrobautista927 This song is a modified version of another song written by Joe Hawley, titled 'Our Lullabye'. It was written for his lover he had at the time. She had some obligation to go somewhere, and so he made this as a parting gift. Soon after, they broke up for unknown reasons, and stopped talking to each other entirely.
If you want, I can research further, but that's the basic gist.
@@notto5937 that same girlfriend also filed a restraining order on Joe for no apparent reason and he had to go to court for it and missed a whole Tally Hall tour
@@sillylittledrummerrecent evidence has now made it debatable as to whether or not it was for no reason, unfortunately
This reminds me of how an old friend of mine did horrible things and slowly morphed to be a bad person. It was always there, in ways that I didn’t see or ignored because I was too young to tell that it was bad. I miss some memories with them, the part of them I liked, but now they’re all ruined because of how awful I know they can be. It’s sad to think on those good memories because they feel ruined and sad.
same. i experienced the same thing.
This comment hits harder with the recent joe hawley drama
this hurts alot !
do i have a story to tell you
How tf a ghost playing piano
Don't worry about it
he peed ectoplasm on it first
Ghost piano
the piano is also a ghost
It’s simple the answer is ✨S C I E N C E✨
I want you all to play this on my funeral
OK
If i can i will be there catbite
why don't you play it at your funeral, you'll be a ghost
This is so calming
Probably my favourite song from Hawaii Part II
CRYING.
There's a still tension in the swell
Of dreamt debris afloat amidst the waves and then dispel
Aimless thoughts and papers blown around
A million moments meant remembered rest in deep dark sound
Game the mess
I'd like to know why you are all alone while I'm lost at sea
Maybe we'll be there when you want
Anchorless and unmoored set amiss
Awake would only prove the fantasy made lucid sense
Sail on sail on
I'd like to know why you are all alone while I'm lost at sea
Maybe we'll be there when you want
There's a still tension in the swell
So given to the vast receiving emptiness of time
Beyond beyond
I'd like to know why you are all alone while I...
You're unsure if I am
A loose end or a strand
That waits for you to mend or understand
incredible music video for stranded lullaby
nice username and pfp
@@CH-1060forEel I enjoy your name and profile picture greatly.
I love you all
I love this version of stranded lullaby
crying and throwing up rn
you're unsure if i am....
a loose END OR A STRAND...
that waits for you to mend or understand.
om ori!!!!
i am crying a river
Nice voice.This my favorite song of the album of Hawai.
Joe Hawley
1:35 this part hurts
Still my favorite version of this song
You alright?
@@angela22778 more than alright actually! my life has gotten a lot better since those times. i only commented this a month ago but the event took place a year ago.
@@mapleshadeeatscats 🫶
im cry
hit like a truck
two trucks, even
Three trucks, even
Four trucks even. And mayhaps, two of these for trucks are engaging in intercourse…
Four trucks, even
Five trucks, even
"gay the mess"
I felt that...
GAME the mess
i was on the outskirts of an episode & approaching but this song has firmly buried me under the ground good eavens joseph
this part of the story (Hawaii part ii) is when he already died, maybe thats why he is a ghost.
This song is so beautiful and sad
This gives me the impression of a ghost haunting a piano. You can hear the piano clearly, but the ghost's voice is barely audible.
You have songs like this and Ruler of Everything
And then you have the entirety of Joe Hawley Joe Hawley excluding Rotary Park
Floating whale's deep through the stars above my friend...
cool
Wow...
man it would be great if there was sheet music for this or something
its much better for you to learn stuff by ear, it's a good exercise and this song isn't the most complicated so i suggest taking it upon yourself as a challenge
@Kyle The Bean that too, but moreso when sheet music isn't available
i could transcribe this for u
@@giocosovelasco can you do this
@@lordmicrowave2928 me moment
this is my new favorite video
Before being a Tally Hall fan I was a fan of the metal band Ghost (and admittedly still am) so the title really confused me
So is this technically the Stranded Lullaby music video?
Very atmospheric
Does anyone know where to find the sheet music for this?
An app called "tabs", i think
Maybe on musescore? If you even still need it
@@kokonuei need it
I miss you, my shining 🌟. My highest intent is that you should be by my side, but perhaps that is merely the lying whispers of Hope. Even the ghost of you was more joy than I had ever known.
This is only music video from hawaii part ii part ii
how interesting
1:36 joe hawley???
OH MY GOD I NEVER NOTICED THAT
it kinda looks like andrew-
@@Thestuffdoer true, i cannot tell
Beautiful
SHEET MUSIC PLEASE
Joe ate the sheet music :(
@@Thestuffdoer I mean how else is he a ghost in the video? He died by internal bleeding via paper ingestion.
it's just one of them days, man
It really is
This compared to The final version is like the comparison between the half life 2 demo and half life 2
nice
I absolutely love the original version that’s on the album. This is much better though and a lot more fitting and sells the feeling of Stranded out in the middle of Sea with no hope of being able to get back or discover an escape of the endless waves.
i miss them
How in the hell i didn't watch this beforeee!!!!
there used to be a piano tutorial for this song on RUclips, anyone knows what happened to it?
this song reminds me of my Girl friend harber... we where close freinds and we use to meet all the time in a game on steam called Gmod intil one day... she falled of a 10 room stair exit and falled all the way down... then she was never the same after that and we could'nt hang out and play anymore because of her problems... so we where never close after that...
im so sorry for you
L
@@genderfluidandverysad You sir, have no respect for human life. I hope you get therapy or GO TO HELL
Woah, 666 subscribers 0-O
wierd_ kid oh shit I see 777
My favorite song on the project. Remarkable :)
I swear, this entire album is a creepypasta in the making?
idk we think the main character is called Simon who's girlfriend got killed by a tree that was cut down by a murder who thought they where *Murders* .
Then he gets put on trail pleads insanity and gets electric shock therapy which is why we have the song *The Mind Electric* which is indeed to do with electric shock therapy.
He gets sent to an asylum which he feels like its a *Labyrinth* and jumps the floors using trap doors he hallucinates and thinks he is being chased by his Ex-girlfriend (unknown to who she is) and sees the ghost of his dead girlfriend guiding him flying away as she made the asylum.
(two endings with *Time Machine*)
Ending 1: Simon escapes and finds a *Time Machine* in the asylum goes back in time.
Ending 2:The asylum lets him out and he wishes he made a *Time Machine* to go back in time and does or doesn't do it.
He then goes out in sea as he is a sailor then gets stranded at sea and dies by a siren who sounds like his girlfriend then he drowns in freezing cold water he becomes a ghost and sings *Stranded Lullaby* to remember his girlfriend which is why in the demo he sings "I was made for you... you where made for me" I would use the demo version or this version for stranded lullaby as it is sadder then put the original one after or before isle to thyself.
Simon sails to the edge of the universe humming the tune of *Stranded Lullaby* he then makes the reference to *The Introduction To The Snow* the start of his life. The siren promised him before he died endless apologies of paradise as she is a goddess. Simon then sails off and goes together in flight as its now or never. Simon says "Believe me darling the stars where made for falling..." as his girlfriend reunites with him. Simon thinks it feels like flying but maybe his dying and was actually alive and is now dying. His life from birth to death flashes before him in a cosmic pyramids hologram. He sees the siren who I shall call the goddess of death is singing her staging music murder. Simon knows they are all on the beyond and above and its perfectly clear they are. Simon's girlfriend tells him she was guiding him through the asylum as much as she could. Simon then realise how everything looks so divine under the lights of the vibrant lights of the beyond and above. The whale sails through as the pure delight from Simon surrounds him as they sail through the beyond and above known as the rising kingdom come as known one can be the last person there due to their existence no longer existing. Simon and The Whale sails and sees what new things they can make along their journey they have a party on the boat with his girlfriend, the whale, the goddess of death and himself. A lining of any finale song is so long and so far that they all will be turning a last turning as they last internal through the past of blinding star. They then all separate again. Simon floats high and higher as he realises he never meant to part the blinding line or light after all one life might as well float higher and higher than the sun. He goes back to earth and finds out he is invisible to some until its time for them to also *Dream Sweet In Sea Major* .
Also dream sweet in sea major lasts 7:00 minutes which is also the time left before fully dying so another version of that long paragraph can be Simon's last 7:00 minutes before death and stranded lullaby could be representing his death .
@@Phighter_15 this isn’t a collage essay
@@Gone._. Collage essay go brrrrrrrr
This will be my send off song
Very pretty song :))
It started raining
1:35 GHELP????
how was this not filmed in the 1800s?
haha im sad now
Why does it feel like Simon singing to me
Nice to see ENA enjoys Tally Hall
this is why i think the protagonist from mm dies at time machine
What is mm?
miracle musical?
@@leticiao yes
God
Bruh it's a enemy stand
Stand Name: 「Stranded Lullaby」
Stand User: 「joe mama」
@@mangaprofilepicture5820 i hate jojo but i cant stop laughing help hlep
hory shieet
hold up. I DID I JUST SEE ANDREW HUH
I don’t think so because Andrew didn’t work on miracle musical
@@inchman7063 o h h h
@@wahwahster this is one of the weirdest accusations I’ve ever seen why would he steal a close friends work that would know instantly
@@wahwahster the
I love u ❤
it's okay, all you need to do is buy a new one
Is this the real music video or fan made?
is there any sheet music for it?
:)
:(
:|
:|
ill love you til youre goonnee
Joe Hawley >:(
Joe Hawley :)
Yes Joe Hawley =]
):< yelwaH eoJ
Joe Hawley
Hoe Jawley 😳
WHAT?
Where did he upload this originally? Never seen it before.
I like to know why you are all alone while im lost att sea
Can we call this one the trampoline one?
who's the guy playin the piano?
joe hawley
It’s Joe Hawley