I own the most Trumans between all these brands. Just goes with my style, they are a nice blend of casual but rugged. The last is a good all around. Not too bump but not too slim.
Oak Street for me. I have a pair of Trench Boots and some WIngtip Oxfords that are both great. Also they do NOT exclusively use Horween leather. They have new releases all the time with special leathers. Their advantage is they can just drive over to Horween and pick out the perfect hides.
@@kosta2177 I bought the Grant Stones in the D width and they are slim comfortable boots. If you are interested in a wider fit, you can get E and EEE widths.
I'm really impressed with Parkhurst. I got a pair recently and their 602 last is very stylish without compromising on confort. Now I want all their other variations, rip wallet.
Of the four, I only have Truman boots. I was so impressed with the materials, build quality and everything on my first pair that I turned around and ordered a second pair as soon as I had the spare cash again.
I have three of the four. Truman is hands down the best construction, the Oak Streets I am selling because the last just doesn’t work for me. I think the Parkhurst are an excellent boot at a fair price though. They’re also a bit dressier than the Truman’s.
I have the Truman’s Java waxed flesh and they are really comfortable with no break in period. My redwing moc toes still hurt after a year in. I do want a pair of the GS in Badalassi tan leather though. Never really looked into PH but they have a similar look to the Truman’s, so they look great. I prefer the like the look of the Truman’s though, I just love their shape. I get complements in them all the time.
Truman is old af and they’re able to price gouge because of it. Grant Stone has much better quality leather and because it’s made in China in a well trained facility, you’re getting better for less
@@NotTrolling399 Truman Boots are just 9 years old, I wouldn't class that as "old af".. I have all, and prefer Truman boots, better built, better aesthetics, better leather..... Well I had all, I sold the GS and Parkhursts as I don't like the look... I find GS and Parkhurst neither dressy nor Rugged, somewhere stuck in between..... If I want dressy casual I go Northampton Boots, (CJs, EGs, etc), if I want rugged I go White's, Wesco, Truman....... Thats my preference..... I actually think Truman are a good price, as are GS, but i like Trumans and do not like GS......
I lean slightly to Parkhurst but have more GS than any other. Oakstreet has been doing some beautiful, unique leathers lately. You can't go wrong with any of them.
Grant Stone Diesel just seem more versatile. It’s almost a dress boot but not quite. You can wear them to job interviews, dinner, vacations, or daily wear. I got a Diesel and a Chelsea, between them and my Red Wing work boots I’ve got all bases covered.
If you look at a lot of Oak Street's boot they don't seem to be able to get their welt to upper stitching right. There seems to always be exposed stitching between the upper and welt around the toe box area. It seems like the their lasting process isn't as refined as it should be. I have seen this on multiple pairs of their boots. No other manufacturer in this range seems to have this problem this consistently.
First off thanks for the comparison and covering what does and doesn't have a gusseted tongue! Secondly Oak Street's Elston last is a modified Boondocker last used in WWII with the Navy. It is not a modified Munson! Although the effect might be similar, they increased the width through the ball of the foot twice. Should you ever revisit them you might be better off going with their Lakeshore last, it's far and away more your style and is built more akin to the 602 last from Parkhurst. One other recommendation is I would aim for a special edition should you pick up something else from OSB, made out of a firm veg tan like Carlo Badalassi. Horween CXL has its fans but when it is split thinner it tends to have a lot of stretch which plays havoc with sizing. CXL prefers to strech instead of mold unless your dimensions to that last are ideal. I have boots made out of CXL that have blown out. And yet have perfect volume and sizing in the exact same make and model 2400+ hours down the road out of a different leather.
I'm mostly Truman by default for now. I'm reluctant to venture too much into GS territory for reasons, but the other two the fit just looks like they'd be way off which may work better for someone else.
Yes, I do like consistency, but if they last long enough, then you won't be on the hunt for the exact same thing until long after they don't exist anymore anyway??? We'll see.
Oak street should lower there price to 400 or 350.00 the top 2 for me also is GS and truman although the 79 lasts on truman has a weird snug fit to me I haven't tried the 20 lasts. Don't know how in today's present time how nicks and whites can stay in business with there outrageous prices which worked in past years but today's inflation and economy they will get left behind. Awesome video please do more like this and I like the votes scheme . Homerun on this video
I would put Truman at #1 followed by Grant Stone. I have many from both but started my boot collection years ago with Iron Rangers and Blacksmith boots. The Trumans have the same basic looks of Red Wing and have greatly improved those designs with better options, materials and construction. Truman to me is what Red Wing should have improved on to stay more competitive in this price range. Still like my Red Wing heritage boots, but they have not upped their game with the new competitors out there now. I also like my Grant Stone boots, but they are a different kind of boot compared to Truman.
I voted for Grant Stone only because they have more different styles to fit most of the needs. Trumans are glorified Iron Rangers, they don’t have anything for the office or similar occasions. Grant Stone line just more versatile. But I love my Truman’s Coach Rambler
I'm always waiting for Grant Stone B-Grade. Their B-Grade is great and you can get them around $250. Which is why i will stick with grant stone since i want a full leather boots while i'm on budget.
I am an Aussie, I have no nationality bias, but Truman is the winner for me. Out of those four brands, only two are an option for wide feet. Truman and Grant Stone. I have both brands and whilst I thoroughly enjoy my Grant Stone, now I have a few pairs of Trumans I have become hooked on the incredible leather options and variants they offer. Not to mention, the Trumans uppers are as thick and beastly as my Whites and I still pick my Trumans over Whites dollar for dollar.
@@kosta2177 They still do MTO's and they just close the most recent (single leather option) public one only a few days ago, it was listed on their site for around a week I think? An olive green horse rump option you could choose your sole, welt or toe options on it etc. I am actually glad MTO's aren't their focus moving forward, keeps costs down on their main production line offerings and still gives them the option to release more MTO's if they find availability on their core lines is increasing. I guess they didn't want to ramp up costs and compete more directly with all the other big names already doing MTOs.
@@awdtw I believe the main issue with MTO were returns. If people who don’t know their size yet start customizing the order, and then simply exchanging it, that is pain in the ass to sell to return the investment. That’s why some MTO were made for customers who already have a few pairs.
Love my Trumans, but they lean away from dress. I only have Grant Stone chelsea boots, but they are really great, and a bargain for what I paid. My current favorites, though, are my Parkhurst Allens in Dublin reddish brown. They look amazing. I haven’t tried Oak Street yet.
Well too deep into boots. I have 2 grant stones, 2 parkhust, 2 oakstreet and 1 truman. Additionally several other pairs. Why am I still looking for that 1 boot that is just right?
The gusseted tongue on the Truman made it difficult for me to get my foot past the "pass through". I wish they would modify the gusset. Grant Stone is becoming my main source for my collection. I wish they would make some in a bit more casual skins.
Damn! I was all in on the Grant Stones and then found out they don't stock any boot larger than a 13. My foot is closer to a 15 so the half size down would be a 14 for me. I guess I will pony up the extra $100 for the Trumans.
Oak Street in my experience is #1 including structural. I purchased the Field Boot Nemesi Cotto 360 Goodyear Welt Storm Welt with Dr. Sole. Absolutely superior to other 3 in your review. Sorry.
Old vid but I vote Truman because of it's impeccable build quality plus they are made in the US for only a few more $'s. It's the better boot and your supporting home. I guess the only reason I'd go GS is if the 79 last doesn't work for you for some reason.
I own all 4, and OSB is probably the most overpriced of them. Don't get me wrong, i love my trench boots, but the details are lacking compared to my 3 Grant Stone, 3 Truman, and 2 Parkhurst. Stuff like obviously exposed welt stitching, the worst leather clicking of any of my boots, more celastic and less leather materials, use of foam and felt GYW filler instead of cork, just stuff you do not want out of a boot that costs almost $500. I will stick with the other 3 before i buy anything from Oak Street again.
I don’t really like the look of Grant Stone, plus I don’t think I could bring myself to buy a $400 pair of boots that are made in China, even if they are good quality. That’s like paying $70k for a Kia or $2k for a made in China suit. 🤷🏼♂️
I own all the brands except OSB, the large toe box isn't my style. Truman's are my favorite for comfort, fit, and uniqueness. GS and Parkhurst are great quality as well and have more versatility.
I prefer Truman’s - but in the 55 last, which is almost never available. Recently got the Grant Stone Diesel and this is a weird nit to pick but I feel the welt looks too wide. I prefer my Higgins Mill even though the construction is so clearly inferior
Has to be Parkhurst for me. I own their Niagara (blue veg tan calf) and Allen (in green kudu) and they just fit so well. I've tried the Diesel, Ottawa, and Brass boot from GS and only the Brass boot fit well. I do love Truman but I don't feel they dress up as well as Parkhurst.
Grant Stone doesn’t sell any size above 13. Dude can you ever mention that to others here? You talk about them over and over but a disclaimer would be nice.
I have a pair of Grant Stones and a pair of Oak Street boots and between the two I prefer the Grant Stones. I suspect I would feel the same way about them against the Trumans and Parkhursts. They're all excellent boots, but the Grant Stone boots are the best.
I wish truman had boots on stock like grant stone , i dont own a pair because i refuse to wait 6 weeks or 2 months , when i can wait 4 days for grant stone , i guess thats why i own like 5 pairs from them.i wanted whites also but the wait , nah not for me.
I have a bunch of Grant Stone and I love them. Loafers to long wings to boots and boots and boots. One pair of Parkhurst, the Niagara in Seidel natty retan, incredible boot, and a Oak Street camp moc. If I had to pick one maker, Grant Stone due to quality and range.
damn that was an amazing rundown. lots of condensed information in a concise and useful manner. you have accumulated a lot of knowledge! thanks for sharing and keep it up.
I'll stick with what's best for my hard earned money quality and comfort don't care where it's from . It's funny that people don't really think , usa number business trade is with China but yet an individual would say I buy American only lol where America don't care really about who they do biz with and don't care about there own people , it's about the money and production that's it. Grant stone is the best in its class and above , all day I'll take grant stone for my earned money.
@@andreamantovani5354 breaking old news over 60% of China goods are already here , no need to move there , there's 80% chance of people here have China made product in there homes knowingly or not , that's a fact.
@noveldune4092 yeah sure.... you've no idea what we're talking about here. This is luxury industry we're discussing. 500usd+ shoes are luxury items. Do you think people would buy Swiss watches for such orenium if they were manufactured in China? Waste of my time to discuss with such newbie 🙄
Oakstreet also doesn’t use a leather heel counter. It does have nailed on heels they are in those holes on the heel stack. The other brands all use leather heel counters
One of the best short reviews for all of these boots. I've seen plenty of review videos, but this one gets to the point without getting too into the finer details.
Has anyone got any Truman boots in an EE width? My branock size is 8.5E (UK). I have a pair of Grant Stone Diesel in 9E (US) that fits me perfectly so was wondering how a 9EE in a Truman boot would ft me.
Great video. To me the Parkhust boot is the best for several reasons. The construction is as good as the others but the look and fit are way ahead of the others. The Grant Stone but is nice but a little plain. Parkhurst is much more inventive than the others. A big plus also is the price. You do the best job of anyone in informing potential boot buyers.
I’m curious, is Oak Street boots are wide enough to consider them E width? Is there anyone who usually wears E width but feels comfortable wearing just a regular Trench boots?
@@JRRob3wn thank you for the response. Once I had a deal that I couldn’t resist with 3E Grant Stone diesels, that appeared to be too wide for me as well. So adding a thin flat insole solved the problem and mad boots are even more comfortable
Just got my first pair of Trumans (rough out coyote) and love it. Been staring at Pankhurst boots for awhile now and its probably only a matter of time until I have something from them.
I bought that same truman boot dark coyote roughout in 79 lasts and it was to snug and my toes was clamped together with no wiggle room , didn't like the fit maybe I needed the 20 lasts . Grant stone diesel boot with Leo lasts fitted like a glove but not tight, love the fit so I have 5 pairs .
I am 85% certain i have read or heard during an interview from Svisco that the Rust Waxy Suede Parkhurst use, in fact comes from C.F. Stead. Entirely possible that i might be mixing leathers and interviews though.
I think they’ve switched. Basically, production had to switch to Spain (actually improving QC a tiny bit more, though it was already high), and when they did, they started to use at least one Spanish tannery. The rust-colored waxed leather they have right now is said to be “like” waxy commander. (I have a pair, and I do think that’s accurate.)
@@BootSpy Yeah, surely they would say C.F Stead if it was C.F Stead, do you know if some tanneries dont want their names shared? or is it a business secret? i just mean if they developed a type of waxed suede with a local spanish tannery why not stand and shout about it, i'd think as long as it's a good product it'd be a win-win situation.
I agree all day, I'm american and don't care where the product is from as long as I like it and it's great quality and price grant stone fits that bill. People makes no sense when say American only no China lol , when America number one trade partner is China, so usa do biz with China and other countries .
Bought Truman and Grant Stone boots because of your videos. Was surprised at how comfortable Truman boots are. Minimal break-in time too. Now thinking of getting the other two to complete the quartet. Great comparison video, as always!
Personally I think that if this hipster boot trend ends, which is inevitable, just when is the question, that Truman and Parkhurst will be hurting and I won’t be surprised to see them disappear. Grant Stone is into shoes so I think they survive and maybe thrive. Oakstreet might make it, but would be surprised to see them get bought. Origins is another maker that I dint think survives.
Hipster boots? A lot of people grew up wearing boots, especially northern Midwest folks 😂. There’s a reason a lot of brands the brands have been around for decades - 100 plus years.
Yea whites and nicks will struggle now to soon because there prices are the same as yesteryear when all was good with economy and no inflation , people not looking to spend 6 to 700 , so I see them struggling soon.
I own 2 pair of Grant Stones. They're like works of art honestly, I put them on par quality wise with my Vibergs. I don't own any Truman's but that's probably what I'll be buying next.
I own the most Trumans between all these brands. Just goes with my style, they are a nice blend of casual but rugged. The last is a good all around. Not too bump but not too slim.
Oak Street for me. I have a pair of Trench Boots and some WIngtip Oxfords that are both great. Also they do NOT exclusively use Horween leather. They have new releases all the time with special leathers. Their advantage is they can just drive over to Horween and pick out the perfect hides.
They’re last just does not work for me so I’m selling mine. Beautiful boots though!
They're good boots: I have a pair of the Field Boots and I like them a lot. However, I still prefer the Grant Stones. It's a matter of taste, I guess.
Is their width close to the E width on other brands?
@@kosta2177 I bought the Grant Stones in the D width and they are slim comfortable boots. If you are interested in a wider fit, you can get E and EEE widths.
Good video 😊 I have all 4 boot brands and I totally agree 👍
I'm really impressed with Parkhurst. I got a pair recently and their 602 last is very stylish without compromising on confort. Now I want all their other variations, rip wallet.
Rip wallet indeed
602 last is fab!
Of the four, I only have Truman boots. I was so impressed with the materials, build quality and everything on my first pair that I turned around and ordered a second pair as soon as I had the spare cash again.
Makes sense to me
I have three of the four. Truman is hands down the best construction, the Oak Streets I am selling because the last just doesn’t work for me. I think the Parkhurst are an excellent boot at a fair price though. They’re also a bit dressier than the Truman’s.
Well you should try the others , how would you know if there's something so much better . But the boot game can become addictive.
I have the Truman’s Java waxed flesh and they are really comfortable with no break in period. My redwing moc toes still hurt after a year in. I do want a pair of the GS in Badalassi tan leather though. Never really looked into PH but they have a similar look to the Truman’s, so they look great. I prefer the like the look of the Truman’s though, I just love their shape. I get complements in them all the time.
Parkhurst has a slimmer look and pointier toe giving them a slightly dressier look than Truman’s.
Truman all day every day....... then Oak Street, can't split Grant Stone and Parkhurst at the bottom of the list
Truman is old af and they’re able to price gouge because of it. Grant Stone has much better quality leather and because it’s made in China in a well trained facility, you’re getting better for less
@@NotTrolling399 Truman Boots are just 9 years old, I wouldn't class that as "old af".. I have all, and prefer Truman boots, better built, better aesthetics, better leather..... Well I had all, I sold the GS and Parkhursts as I don't like the look... I find GS and Parkhurst neither dressy nor Rugged, somewhere stuck in between..... If I want dressy casual I go Northampton Boots, (CJs, EGs, etc), if I want rugged I go White's, Wesco, Truman....... Thats my preference..... I actually think Truman are a good price, as are GS, but i like Trumans and do not like GS......
I lean slightly to Parkhurst but have more GS than any other. Oakstreet has been doing some beautiful, unique leathers lately. You can't go wrong with any of them.
Grant Stone Diesel just seem more versatile. It’s almost a dress boot but not quite. You can wear them to job interviews, dinner, vacations, or daily wear. I got a Diesel and a Chelsea, between them and my Red Wing work boots I’ve got all bases covered.
So hard to pick. Have all but OSB and I'm planning on them soon. Since GS does loafers I pick them as a brand overall! Love my loafers when it's warm!
GS needs to offer 12.5 ....I find myself stuck between sizes.
If you look at a lot of Oak Street's boot they don't seem to be able to get their welt to upper stitching right. There seems to always be exposed stitching between the upper and welt around the toe box area. It seems like the their lasting process isn't as refined as it should be. I have seen this on multiple pairs of their boots. No other manufacturer in this range seems to have this problem this consistently.
First off thanks for the comparison and covering what does and doesn't have a gusseted tongue!
Secondly Oak Street's Elston last is a modified Boondocker last used in WWII with the Navy. It is not a modified Munson! Although the effect might be similar, they increased the width through the ball of the foot twice. Should you ever revisit them you might be better off going with their Lakeshore last, it's far and away more your style and is built more akin to the 602 last from Parkhurst.
One other recommendation is I would aim for a special edition should you pick up something else from OSB, made out of a firm veg tan like Carlo Badalassi. Horween CXL has its fans but when it is split thinner it tends to have a lot of stretch which plays havoc with sizing. CXL prefers to strech instead of mold unless your dimensions to that last are ideal. I have boots made out of CXL that have blown out. And yet have perfect volume and sizing in the exact same make and model 2400+ hours down the road out of a different leather.
OSB for me. I would like to see more Cap Toe Trench boots in different leathers though. Not sure why there are so few options in that style.
I'm mostly Truman by default for now. I'm reluctant to venture too much into GS territory for reasons, but the other two the fit just looks like they'd be way off which may work better for someone else.
I already have some other brown, standard boots which may not be as "good" as theirs but will surely do for now.
Yes, I do like consistency, but if they last long enough, then you won't be on the hunt for the exact same thing until long after they don't exist anymore anyway??? We'll see.
Oak street should lower there price to 400 or 350.00 the top 2 for me also is GS and truman although the 79 lasts on truman has a weird snug fit to me I haven't tried the 20 lasts.
Don't know how in today's present time how nicks and whites can stay in business with there outrageous prices which worked in past years but today's inflation and economy they will get left behind.
Awesome video please do more like this and I like the votes scheme .
Homerun on this video
I would put Truman at #1 followed by Grant Stone. I have many from both but started my boot collection years ago with Iron Rangers and Blacksmith boots. The Trumans have the same basic looks of Red Wing and have greatly improved those designs with better options, materials and construction. Truman to me is what Red Wing should have improved on to stay more competitive in this price range. Still like my Red Wing heritage boots, but they have not upped their game with the new competitors out there now. I also like my Grant Stone boots, but they are a different kind of boot compared to Truman.
I voted for Grant Stone only because they have more different styles to fit most of the needs. Trumans are glorified Iron Rangers, they don’t have anything for the office or similar occasions. Grant Stone line just more versatile.
But I love my Truman’s Coach Rambler
Truman’s my mate called poor man’s Vibergs ! Which made me laugh .
Yeah I was upset he's talking down on red wings, but anything that is the best selling version, always loses something when mass produced.
I'm always waiting for Grant Stone B-Grade. Their B-Grade is great and you can get them around $250.
Which is why i will stick with grant stone since i want a full leather boots while i'm on budget.
Grant Stone is my favourite of these as now. Bonus points that they now offer free shipping to Canada.
Forget about the boots. What jacket is that? I need it in my life.
He shoukd have separate videos for jackets 👍
Parkhurst for some reason doesn’t do international returns
I am an Aussie, I have no nationality bias, but Truman is the winner for me.
Out of those four brands, only two are an option for wide feet. Truman and Grant Stone. I have both brands and whilst I thoroughly enjoy my Grant Stone, now I have a few pairs of Trumans I have become hooked on the incredible leather options and variants they offer. Not to mention, the Trumans uppers are as thick and beastly as my Whites and I still pick my Trumans over Whites dollar for dollar.
I just wish they would keep their MTO option foe everyone. I would buy a Java waxed flesh, but I need the 20 last and the Eugene (or similar) sole
I have the Eugene sole on my moss waxy Mohawks and those soles got me thinking about putting them on every night for work... lol
@@kosta2177 They still do MTO's and they just close the most recent (single leather option) public one only a few days ago, it was listed on their site for around a week I think? An olive green horse rump option you could choose your sole, welt or toe options on it etc.
I am actually glad MTO's aren't their focus moving forward, keeps costs down on their main production line offerings and still gives them the option to release more MTO's if they find availability on their core lines is increasing.
I guess they didn't want to ramp up costs and compete more directly with all the other big names already doing MTOs.
@@awdtw I believe the main issue with MTO were returns. If people who don’t know their size yet start customizing the order, and then simply exchanging it, that is pain in the ass to sell to return the investment. That’s why some MTO were made for customers who already have a few pairs.
Truman for me i have a pair of charcoal grizzlies on the 20 last and i love them
Love my Trumans, but they lean away from dress. I only have Grant Stone chelsea boots, but they are really great, and a bargain for what I paid. My current favorites, though, are my Parkhurst Allens in Dublin reddish brown. They look amazing. I haven’t tried Oak Street yet.
Some of the specials at grant stone are god tier value . Shockingly low prices for what you’re getting
I'm always stuck choosing between my MP-shermans (brown wf) and moss waxy Mohawks on the 79 last
Well too deep into boots. I have 2 grant stones, 2 parkhust, 2 oakstreet and 1 truman. Additionally several other pairs. Why am I still looking for that 1 boot that is just right?
Which brand do you like the most of out those 4?
The gusseted tongue on the Truman made it difficult for me to get my foot past the "pass through". I wish they would modify the gusset. Grant Stone is becoming my main source for my collection. I wish they would make some in a bit more casual skins.
That's a bummer to hear, especially now that they're going mostly ready to ship, and they no longer include a pull tab in the backstay.
Awesome video , I love when someone can put top brands against each other .
Glad you liked it!
Damn! I was all in on the Grant Stones and then found out they don't stock any boot larger than a 13. My foot is closer to a 15 so the half size down would be a 14 for me. I guess I will pony up the extra $100 for the Trumans.
You might want to reach out to them and see what they say just in case. Their customer service is really helpful and responsive.
Same. I'm a 13.5E Bannock, and that basically knocks GS out of the picture. So disappointing...
Which one has the most arch support?
I’m gonna say all equal
Oak Street in my experience is #1 including structural.
I purchased the Field Boot Nemesi Cotto 360 Goodyear Welt Storm Welt with Dr. Sole.
Absolutely superior to other 3 in your review.
Sorry.
Truman boots for me bro
Trustone Hurstreet
Old vid but I vote Truman because of it's impeccable build quality plus they are made in the US for only a few more $'s. It's the better boot and your supporting home. I guess the only reason I'd go GS is if the 79 last doesn't work for you for some reason.
I own all 4, and OSB is probably the most overpriced of them. Don't get me wrong, i love my trench boots, but the details are lacking compared to my 3 Grant Stone, 3 Truman, and 2 Parkhurst. Stuff like obviously exposed welt stitching, the worst leather clicking of any of my boots, more celastic and less leather materials, use of foam and felt GYW filler instead of cork, just stuff you do not want out of a boot that costs almost $500. I will stick with the other 3 before i buy anything from Oak Street again.
I don’t really like the look of Grant Stone, plus I don’t think I could bring myself to buy a $400 pair of boots that are made in China, even if they are good quality. That’s like paying $70k for a Kia or $2k for a made in China suit. 🤷🏼♂️
I own all the brands except OSB, the large toe box isn't my style. Truman's are my favorite for comfort, fit, and uniqueness. GS and Parkhurst are great quality as well and have more versatility.
I prefer Truman’s - but in the 55 last, which is almost never available. Recently got the Grant Stone Diesel and this is a weird nit to pick but I feel the welt looks too wide. I prefer my Higgins Mill even though the construction is so clearly inferior
Has to be Parkhurst for me. I own their Niagara (blue veg tan calf) and Allen (in green kudu) and they just fit so well. I've tried the Diesel, Ottawa, and Brass boot from GS and only the Brass boot fit well. I do love Truman but I don't feel they dress up as well as Parkhurst.
I own all except for Parkhurst. Great boots. Hope to snag a pair when they put out a leather I'm more interested in.
Grant Stone doesn’t sell any size above 13. Dude can you ever mention that to others here? You talk about them over and over but a disclaimer would be nice.
I don't like when the lugs on the sole are recessed away from the edge of the boot. It maks the boot look awkward and tippy.
Does anybody agree?
I’m up to 3 pairs of Truman boots. I prefer them to my Vibergs and my Grant Stone pairs. I didn’t see the poll, sorry.
I have a pair of Grant Stones and a pair of Oak Street boots and between the two I prefer the Grant Stones. I suspect I would feel the same way about them against the Trumans and Parkhursts. They're all excellent boots, but the Grant Stone boots are the best.
I wish truman had boots on stock like grant stone , i dont own a pair because i refuse to wait 6 weeks or 2 months , when i can wait 4 days for grant stone , i guess thats why i own like 5 pairs from them.i wanted whites also but the wait , nah not for me.
Another 5 STAR review William....! Excellent Greg
I have a bunch of Grant Stone and I love them. Loafers to long wings to boots and boots and boots. One pair of Parkhurst, the Niagara in Seidel natty retan, incredible boot, and a Oak Street camp moc.
If I had to pick one maker, Grant Stone due to quality and range.
Has is the arch in all? I can’t wear higher arched boots. Basically I don’t really want to feel the arch insole at all.
damn that was an amazing rundown. lots of condensed information in a concise and useful manner. you have accumulated a lot of knowledge! thanks for sharing and keep it up.
I'll stick with made in America so it's Truman boots for the win!
I'll stick with what's best for my hard earned money quality and comfort don't care where it's from . It's funny that people don't really think , usa number business trade is with China but yet an individual would say I buy American only lol where America don't care really about who they do biz with and don't care about there own people , it's about the money and production that's it. Grant stone is the best in its class and above , all day I'll take grant stone for my earned money.
@Angel-AbC9 poor old America 🤦♂️ just move to China then and enjoy their awesome products 😂
@@andreamantovani5354 breaking old news over 60% of China goods are already here , no need to move there , there's 80% chance of people here have China made product in there homes knowingly or not , that's a fact.
@@andreamantovani5354Quality of a product has nothing to do with the country where it was made.
@noveldune4092 yeah sure.... you've no idea what we're talking about here. This is luxury industry we're discussing. 500usd+ shoes are luxury items. Do you think people would buy Swiss watches for such orenium if they were manufactured in China? Waste of my time to discuss with such newbie 🙄
Try the Oak Street field boot instead of the trench. I bet you'd love it.
Hey man! Great Video! That's a really nice jacket you got there! Can ya share the link or where you got it?
Missed the poll but love Parkhurst. Great choices overall.
Oakstreet also doesn’t use a leather heel counter. It does have nailed on heels they are in those holes on the heel stack. The other brands all use leather heel counters
What’s the brand of your jacket ?
One of the best short reviews for all of these boots. I've seen plenty of review videos, but this one gets to the point without getting too into the finer details.
I am a Truman fan and i will only buy Truman boots
Your camera or light is a bit dark
Has anyone got any Truman boots in an EE width? My branock size is 8.5E (UK). I have a pair of Grant Stone Diesel in 9E (US) that fits me perfectly so was wondering how a 9EE in a Truman boot would ft me.
Should fit you perfectly in my opinion
Great video. To me the Parkhust boot is the best for several reasons. The construction is as good as the others but the look and fit are way ahead of the others. The Grant Stone but is nice but a little plain. Parkhurst is much more inventive than the others. A big plus also is the price. You do the best job of anyone in informing potential boot buyers.
Please send one of them to me as gift
Great video as always. I’m from the uk and love American made boots. Truman are the best for me.
Thank you sir!
I’m curious, is Oak Street boots are wide enough to consider them E width? Is there anyone who usually wears E width but feels comfortable wearing just a regular Trench boots?
Their last is insanely wide imo, which is why I’m selling mine. Mileage may vary though.
@@JRRob3wn thank you for the response.
Once I had a deal that I couldn’t resist with 3E Grant Stone diesels, that appeared to be too wide for me as well. So adding a thin flat insole solved the problem and mad boots are even more comfortable
Just got my first pair of Trumans (rough out coyote) and love it. Been staring at Pankhurst boots for awhile now and its probably only a matter of time until I have something from them.
That rough out coyote looked incredible. And yeah, my Parkhursts are awesome
I bought that same truman boot dark coyote roughout in 79 lasts and it was to snug and my toes was clamped together with no wiggle room , didn't like the fit maybe I needed the 20 lasts . Grant stone diesel boot with Leo lasts fitted like a glove but not tight, love the fit so I have 5 pairs .
I am 85% certain i have read or heard during an interview from Svisco that the Rust Waxy Suede Parkhurst use, in fact comes from C.F. Stead.
Entirely possible that i might be mixing leathers and interviews though.
I think they’ve switched. Basically, production had to switch to Spain (actually improving QC a tiny bit more, though it was already high), and when they did, they started to use at least one Spanish tannery. The rust-colored waxed leather they have right now is said to be “like” waxy commander. (I have a pair, and I do think that’s accurate.)
I’m pretty sure this is spot on - at least that’s the impression I’m under
@@BootSpy Yeah, surely they would say C.F Stead if it was C.F Stead, do you know if some tanneries dont want their names shared? or is it a business secret? i just mean if they developed a type of waxed suede with a local spanish tannery why not stand and shout about it, i'd think as long as it's a good product it'd be a win-win situation.
😊
American here, Grant Stone all day.
I agree all day, I'm american and don't care where the product is from as long as I like it and it's great quality and price grant stone fits that bill. People makes no sense when say American only no China lol , when America number one trade partner is China, so usa do biz with China and other countries .
I'll stick with American boots like Truman, Iron Rangers, and Americana's.
I’ll stick with well made Chinese boots.
Good for you?
@@mattp6992 and good for you ? See my point?
@@mrjvee2597tell em bro
Bought Truman and Grant Stone boots because of your videos. Was surprised at how comfortable Truman boots are. Minimal break-in time too.
Now thinking of getting the other two to complete the quartet. Great comparison video, as always!
Personally I think that if this hipster boot trend ends, which is inevitable, just when is the question, that Truman and Parkhurst will be hurting and I won’t be surprised to see them disappear. Grant Stone is into shoes so I think they survive and maybe thrive. Oakstreet might make it, but would be surprised to see them get bought. Origins is another maker that I dint think survives.
Hipster boots? A lot of people grew up wearing boots, especially northern Midwest folks 😂. There’s a reason a lot of brands the brands have been around for decades - 100 plus years.
Yea whites and nicks will struggle now to soon because there prices are the same as yesteryear when all was good with economy and no inflation , people not looking to spend 6 to 700 , so I see them struggling soon.
I own 2 pair of Grant Stones. They're like works of art honestly, I put them on par quality wise with my Vibergs. I don't own any Truman's but that's probably what I'll be buying next.
I have two truman's, the java on the 20 last, I looove them!! And the black waxed flesh on the 79 last.