You put 66 convoys on the market before the civil war. You only got 17 back from the market after the civil war started. Don't think this cheese works anymore, Dave.
@@wilfredwong624 I dont think he reads comments. Tbh, neither would I. Working with the public is bad enough, but give them anonymity and a direct line to you 24/7 and i bet it is quite literally hell on earth.
@signoguns8501 yeah nah, people online are toxic af. I actually almost never look into comment section anywhere at all. Thus is rare occasion. And I'll tell you, my mental health got way better once I stopped using social media and stopped looking up comments. So it's a real advice actually.
@@蔡林翰-v2m sometimes he does play fair, just using the meta build and path, with very controlled micro-management he's one of the HOI4 RUclipsr that holds ridiculous amount of videos that talks and discuss about stats and micro-management in this game in my knowledge (please correct me if I'm wrong) but yeah, he uses exploits often too
The railway artillery have become really broken, putting them on an general either make them stuck or endlessy go by sea and gets sunk. Used to work but now really broken sadly...
Historacally had usa a huge advantage due to they could use their extra manpower to invest in factories rather than making a large army. According to (The War Economies of the major combatants during WW2 WW2Tv) Germany had mobilized 18 of 80 million people or 22.5 % of their population comparitaly to Usa 16.5 of 135 million or 12.2 %. Usa had a bigger population and smaller army making them able to produce even more equipment. This allowed Us to supply the allies even more. So it would make sense in hoi4 to make manpower to either used as soilders or to help industry. Furthermore in the video its told that having more than 10 % of countries population would havevilly hamper a country economically. You need a certain amount of people just to staff bakeries and hospitals for example. It would be good to make hoi4 more of a economic game but not to high level becuase that could raise the bar for newcomers. It could be a option to if u mastered the basics for veterans. To a extent making more paywalls if this is made a dlc and further complicating the game could make it hard for new people to jump. Thanks for reading Be sure to comment what you think
100%, some people act like focus shouldn't be put on the industry and economy side of this and should focus on things like combat, but forget that this is a grand strategy game, where industry and economicsis war. It would massively increase the depth of the logistical side of the game, instead of a tab you push that makes you a totally mobilized nation
The US before the war already had a much larger industrial base than Germany, which makes sense because it had more population, more land and more natural resources. The Germans knew that they would need to conquer Europe and fortify the coastline (Atlantikwall) before the Americans joined the war and they raided the supply convoys on the Atlantic heavily. What they did not account for was the invention of sonar (See: Das Boot) and Alan Turing's effort to crack the Enigma machine. That, and Japan attacking Pearl Harbor against the Germans express advice. And Italy being trash. And the Soviets not surrendering. Mistakes were made.
@TheSuperappelflap mostly correct, but Germany was elated when Japan attacked the US, as they thought they would be able to bog down the US Navy while they wrapped things up in the east. Germany had infact been hoping that Japan would take some action against the US and the allies for some time by the point it attacked Pearl Harbor, so it's not like it took Germany by surprise, even if they didn't know the exact day or means of attack
I still want you to try this playthrough: 😇🇬🇧 Good Guy UK where you decolonize but stay democratic just before Germany invades Poland and essentially stay on the historic path. You challenge yourself by lacking the resources, but still get the buff of extra PP and manpower.
@@CPT85 Even during it though, decolonizing before WW2 means no North African theatre, no East Asian theatre, no African theatre, etc. Thus your entire fleet is concentrated around your home waters which combined with the fact that the AI is incompetent basically means you’re sitting on your island doing nothing until Germany attacks the soviets, and then you steamroll everything effortlessly
Not at all. Fundamental research can be in any field, it's research to produce and explain knowledge, with no concrete application. It is opposed to applied research where you're doing research to produce something useful. In the case of nuclear physic (IE physics about the nucleus of an atom), when Enrico Fermi got a Nobel prize for discovering new elements by bombarding them and for discovering the neutrino, he was doing fundamental research, he was just making new knowledge. When he worked on the Manhattan project to create an atomic bomb, he was doing applied research' the goal was to create a bomb.
@krankarvolund7771 I agree that fundamental research by itself does not imply physics. I was just answering his implicit question how fundamental research was related to nuclear physics.
@@peperoni_pepino Yeah, but you're answering it wrong ^^ You said that fundamental means "researching the smallest parts that can be combined to make anything bigger", but it's not. When Einstein was working on gravity and relativity, it was fundamental research. Even though, he's studying space, the biggest thing known to us XD
@@krankarvolund7771 I can't tell how much physics you know, so this might be mansplaining: As far as we know, gravity cannot be constructed out of anything smaller. Although gravity affects huge objects, it is still a small part in this sense. In physics we indeed use 'fundamental' for the most basic building blocks that we are aware of, such that anything else can be build from them. This means that gravity, the electroweak force (which at our energy splits into the electromagnetic force and the weak (nuclear) force), and the strong (nuclear) force are currently considered fundamental interactions. The latter was of course still unknown during the period of this video, as it was discovered in the 70's.
Stop making 2 width horse divisons, they take longer to make than infantry divisons. Just look at the training time stat at the right, for horses its 120 and for inf its lower so they train faster
@@mike-yd4py Best for garrison is full cavalry, the whole thing fillrd out, equipped with a military police support unit. it uses the least ammount of manpower and equipment, for the suppression it provides. edit: or are we talking about coastline protection?
Hey Dave, just wanted to say that I enjoy your videos. Wanted to bring something I have noticed, seems like your microphone volume is a bit lower than usual, I have been needing to hire up my TV more to hear you clearly. Not too much of problem, just something I noticed. Great video as always.
Artillery Brigade has negative movement modifier for the following terrain: forest, hills, mountain, jungle, marsh, and river. Since artillery movement on mountain has a -20% the +15 would mitigate it to just -5%.
Amazing! the only downside is that the remaining 2 wars you can never win - against Great Britain and Japan you'd need a fleet as big as theirs. Still, pretty impressive considering you started as an English puppet.
Hey feedback ❤ You know if you choose germany at the national focus tree, you won't have to fight the Pakistanis 😂😂😂 Because it will remove the two nation theory modifier ❤❤❤ Just to let you know
Dave why so many on trains all game? 3 feels like a lot when you'r ejuggling artillery/guns. Just curious why once you have 65+ armored trains you kept them (eventually it got reduced but curious why so long).
i only ever produce war austerity trains and keep them at 1 per day production. yes, it's a ridicilous amount, but it means the troops will always have supplies no matter what.
But the problem is that the Indian hoi4 community is very small. As an Indian I haven't seen any Indian who plays hoi4. So clickbaiting doesn't work with Indians at least in hoi4 based videos.
Dave, infantry trains faster than cavalry. It takes 90 to train one infantry battalion, while it takes 120 to train cav. Plus, cav uses more guns than infantry. I get that you make divisions with only one cavalry battalion for garrisons, but if it's only for training, then infantry is sighlty better.
Well actually British raj simply meant British rule, it was called india back in those days since the times of ancient Greeks but the indian called india under British as British Raj (British rule) as opposed to Mughal raj (Mughal rule). Btw its weird seeing Muslim marginalised in before independence because the demand for Pakistan wasn't because they were marginalized but because of two nation theory made them believe they were more pure and martial than the dirty hindu population. It can be observed during the 1971 bengladeshi genocide, where Pakistani clerics ans military considered bangladeshis muslim as too hindu thus impure.
You put 66 convoys on the market before the civil war. You only got 17 back from the market after the civil war started. Don't think this cheese works anymore, Dave.
There were a lot of comments telling him about this in the last video, he just never listens😪
@@wilfredwong624 I dont think he reads comments. Tbh, neither would I. Working with the public is bad enough, but give them anonymity and a direct line to you 24/7 and i bet it is quite literally hell on earth.
He just isn't very good at the game, and his videos are getting lazy, I think I'm finally unsubbing
@@flamingeskimo1136 he's good when you're new but yes, very much this hahaha
@signoguns8501 yeah nah, people online are toxic af. I actually almost never look into comment section anywhere at all. Thus is rare occasion. And I'll tell you, my mental health got way better once I stopped using social media and stopped looking up comments. So it's a real advice actually.
Dave, if you put all of your equipment in the market before the civil war, it still gets halfed (or even worse sometimes)
他就是一直用遊戲的漏洞，不是嗎?
@@蔡林翰-v2m lol yeah but sometimes I need them to win so I love watching his vids
@@蔡林翰-v2m sometimes he does play fair, just using the meta build and path, with very controlled micro-management
he's one of the HOI4 RUclipsr that holds ridiculous amount of videos that talks and discuss about stats and micro-management in this game in my knowledge
(please correct me if I'm wrong)
but yeah, he uses exploits often too
Question is will the Ai take stuff off the market?
The railway artillery have become really broken, putting them on an general either make them stuck or endlessy go by sea and gets sunk. Used to work but now really broken sadly...
我也遇到了這種情況，就跟飛機很相似，跟隨能力從來都是破碎的
為此也只能手動
Agwarian society 👉👈
@@marshallseverson6152 yeah why is he saying it like that lmfao
Aquarian society🐟
Bro put 11k guns on the market and got not even 4k out 🙏🏻
i miss the blue guy…please show more of him Dave
BlueBallGaming 🔵😏
Interesting Norway timestamps
Still cooking
@@FeedbackGaming where is your reaction to german inner circle.
Historacally had usa a huge advantage due to they could use their extra manpower to invest in factories rather than making a large army. According to (The War Economies of the major combatants during WW2 WW2Tv) Germany had mobilized 18 of 80 million people or 22.5 % of their population comparitaly to Usa 16.5 of 135 million or 12.2 %. Usa had a bigger population and smaller army making them able to produce even more equipment. This allowed Us to supply the allies even more. So it would make sense in hoi4 to make manpower to either used as soilders or to help industry. Furthermore in the video its told that having more than 10 % of countries population would havevilly hamper a country economically. You need a certain amount of people just to staff bakeries and hospitals for example. It would be good to make hoi4 more of a economic game but not to high level becuase that could raise the bar for newcomers. It could be a option to if u mastered the basics for veterans.
To a extent making more paywalls if this is made a dlc and further complicating the game could make it hard for new people to jump.
Thanks for reading
Be sure to comment what you think
Totally agree mate
100%, some people act like focus shouldn't be put on the industry and economy side of this and should focus on things like combat, but forget that this is a grand strategy game, where industry and economicsis war. It would massively increase the depth of the logistical side of the game, instead of a tab you push that makes you a totally mobilized nation
我相信，人力在徵兵政策上就有了相應的減益，不需要DLC
The US before the war already had a much larger industrial base than Germany, which makes sense because it had more population, more land and more natural resources.
The Germans knew that they would need to conquer Europe and fortify the coastline (Atlantikwall) before the Americans joined the war and they raided the supply convoys on the Atlantic heavily.
What they did not account for was the invention of sonar (See: Das Boot) and Alan Turing's effort to crack the Enigma machine.
That, and Japan attacking Pearl Harbor against the Germans express advice.
And Italy being trash. And the Soviets not surrendering.
Mistakes were made.
@TheSuperappelflap mostly correct, but Germany was elated when Japan attacked the US, as they thought they would be able to bog down the US Navy while they wrapped things up in the east. Germany had infact been hoping that Japan would take some action against the US and the allies for some time by the point it attacked Pearl Harbor, so it's not like it took Germany by surprise, even if they didn't know the exact day or means of attack
Would love to see Indias tree get a bit of a rework
I'm not 100% sure but I think it was mentioned somewhere that it will get some attention in Geaveyard of Empires dlc. Don't quote me tho.
X2
I think the devs probably working their way through all of the focus trees. Once theyre updated, HOI5?
They did an update for agrarian focuses which gives them manpower
@@Nocturno-vu6zs 4 real all the commonwealth nations. Especially South Africa and the Raj
I still want you to try this playthrough:
😇🇬🇧 Good Guy UK where you decolonize but stay democratic just before Germany invades Poland and essentially stay on the historic path. You challenge yourself by lacking the resources, but still get the buff of extra PP and manpower.
Sounds extremely boring
@@bruhbruh-us6gl Never said there weren’t any options with what to do afterwards. 😂
@@CPT85
Even during it though, decolonizing before WW2 means no North African theatre, no East Asian theatre, no African theatre, etc. Thus your entire fleet is concentrated around your home waters which combined with the fact that the AI is incompetent basically means you’re sitting on your island doing nothing until Germany attacks the soviets, and then you steamroll everything effortlessly
9:30 'Fundamental' as in 'fundamental physics'; physics research into the smallest part that can be combined to make anything bigger.
(Quarks etc.
Not at all. Fundamental research can be in any field, it's research to produce and explain knowledge, with no concrete application. It is opposed to applied research where you're doing research to produce something useful.
In the case of nuclear physic (IE physics about the nucleus of an atom), when Enrico Fermi got a Nobel prize for discovering new elements by bombarding them and for discovering the neutrino, he was doing fundamental research, he was just making new knowledge.
When he worked on the Manhattan project to create an atomic bomb, he was doing applied research' the goal was to create a bomb.
@krankarvolund7771 I agree that fundamental research by itself does not imply physics. I was just answering his implicit question how fundamental research was related to nuclear physics.
@@peperoni_pepino Yeah, but you're answering it wrong ^^
You said that fundamental means "researching the smallest parts that can be combined to make anything bigger", but it's not.
When Einstein was working on gravity and relativity, it was fundamental research. Even though, he's studying space, the biggest thing known to us XD
@@krankarvolund7771 I can't tell how much physics you know, so this might be mansplaining: As far as we know, gravity cannot be constructed out of anything smaller. Although gravity affects huge objects, it is still a small part in this sense. In physics we indeed use 'fundamental' for the most basic building blocks that we are aware of, such that anything else can be build from them. This means that gravity, the electroweak force (which at our energy splits into the electromagnetic force and the weak (nuclear) force), and the strong (nuclear) force are currently considered fundamental interactions. The latter was of course still unknown during the period of this video, as it was discovered in the 70's.
1:13:38 The factions need to be renamed to Oceania, Eurasia, and Eastasia.
39:33 you have enough aluminum to make spoons and forks, but you'll have to import the knives
You can get rid of marginalised community if you do two nation theory before the civil war.
Stop making 2 width horse divisons, they take longer to make than infantry divisons. Just look at the training time stat at the right, for horses its 120 and for inf its lower so they train faster
Overall faster movement of horses means a faster capitulation tho
@@K162-y1b you can change templates. But for training horses are really slow
Horses also good later for garrison.
@@mike-yd4py Best for garrison is full cavalry, the whole thing fillrd out, equipped with a military police support unit. it uses the least ammount of manpower and equipment, for the suppression it provides.
edit: or are we talking about coastline protection?
@@Q9wihsioa good catch
Hey Dave, just wanted to say that I enjoy your videos. Wanted to bring something I have noticed, seems like your microphone volume is a bit lower than usual, I have been needing to hire up my TV more to hear you clearly. Not too much of problem, just something I noticed. Great video as always.
The Spanish voice sometimes fades out. 🥺, and thanks for enabling that option👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
4:50
You dont need to say sorry
Indians hate mohandas to some extent
Hes a sham
Artillery Brigade has negative movement modifier for the following terrain: forest, hills, mountain, jungle, marsh, and river. Since artillery movement on mountain has a -20% the +15 would mitigate it to just -5%.
I love this blue Emoji!!!!
Isn't the new DLC gonna have bit of rework for India?
Either way, nice one Dave. If they do rework I will be keeping an eye on your channel 👀
31:50 "and now we're making a breakthrough and i can feel the push coming ooaoaoaoaoaoahhhhh there we go"
- feedbackgaming, 2024
9:31 it is fundamental research as in studying the fundamentals, the atom, not as in the more common usage of the word
"As you can see, you have a lot of steel, and a decent amount of tungsten."
Literally has 10x more tungsten lol.
Dave playing Railroad Tycoon in HoI4! Noice!
Market trick doesent work anymore :*
9:40 it is essential as nuke Ghandi Civilization meme easter egg.
Feedback gaming in Spanish fucking jumpscared me.
20:20 "Agwawian"
One would expect Gandhi to give ticking autonomy...
Dave this is one of your patrons. I need my link to buy the expansion through your channel
Amazing! the only downside is that the remaining 2 wars you can never win - against Great Britain and Japan you'd need a fleet as big as theirs. Still, pretty impressive considering you started as an English puppet.
Fundamental research means into the "foundations" of reality, so atomic research was absolutely that in the 30s through to the 60s.
Sir! We have finally researched Nuclear Bombs! Excellent...now to research the conventional bomb so we know how to drop this thing.
Out of curiosity, doesn't anyone else get the issue with the focus generals where they don't get traits?
Yo Dave, your cheese trick with int. Market doesn’t work anymore, they get halved anyways. I noticed that on a Germany run I had.
The video audio is a lot lower than what it used to be Dave
Only OGs remember when this was members only
The Chinese Indian Dream team
Yesssss this is what this channel needs
Hey feedback ❤
You know if you choose germany at the national focus tree, you won't have to fight the Pakistanis 😂😂😂
Because it will remove the two nation theory modifier ❤❤❤
Just to let you know
No Iron man, no challenge, its a cheat
Fyi 2-nation theory just gets rid of the breakaway problem. At least i never experienced it though i waited too long to have the civil war 😅
16:00 老天...所以她，只用了一個部隊，的一個步兵，光靠訓練就拿到了280的經驗點數??
不可能...為甚麼? 部隊的數量才是增加經驗的關鍵，才一個部隊一天頂多加0.001，但他兩年的訓練就有0.5 每天*幾乎*
It’s multiplied by total army size, I believe.
Is it just a dave thing or are the research bonus not worth it with only 3 slots for the most time?
Really "Life of Brain"ing the word agrarian, aren't we Dave?
Actually at that time your India has the world largest population as it includes Pakistan and Burma while China is splintered.
At 28 min. Alternatively, if you release Pakistan as a puppet right away, Burma will never declare independence.
I just found this 10 mins after it was posted
Dave why so many on trains all game? 3 feels like a lot when you'r ejuggling artillery/guns. Just curious why once you have 65+ armored trains you kept them (eventually it got reduced but curious why so long).
i only ever produce war austerity trains and keep them at 1 per day production. yes, it's a ridicilous amount, but it means the troops will always have supplies no matter what.
why does your game has that repair priority feature? i cant find it on mine
thats not corn,it is wheat or rice
34:11 ur Pakistani.viewer is here.
Iguanodon society is my favorite society!
hey, why your videos appear automkatically in Spanish?
Emmmm porque tienes audio en español? Why you have spanish audio?
Enjoy the bot comments. Any video with "India" in the title tends to get a lot of them!
More engagement for the algorithm, I suppose.
Not just India. But you know, that's what we gotta cope with nowadays
But the problem is that the Indian hoi4 community is very small. As an Indian I haven't seen any Indian who plays hoi4. So clickbaiting doesn't work with Indians at least in hoi4 based videos.
Love me some "aguarian" societies.
Atp you should get a vtuber model of the blue emoji
Putting army in factory is this usa😂😂😂
Where all my spreadsheet enjoyers at?
East Pakistan? You mean England?
Dave, infantry trains faster than cavalry. It takes 90 to train one infantry battalion, while it takes 120 to train cav. Plus, cav uses more guns than infantry. I get that you make divisions with only one cavalry battalion for garrisons, but if it's only for training, then infantry is sighlty better.
Good idea bro
INDIA NUMERO 1!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 SUPERPOWER BY 1945!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Personal opinion on doctrines: don't change the cost, but still make them take time to stop doctrine rush
DO NOT REDDEM THE CARD😡😡
@@KoxenMB SAAAAAR
I guess with those new intros he tries to aim a people that don't have/just got the game ? Hence the weird emojie generic thumbnails and all that idk
i dont get it, whats with the blue emojis?
where is my ratte video, comon do something
Akhand Bharat 😂😂😂😂😂
Why are you so quiet? :P
Ms las bacterias tiene 200 diviones😂mm
no views? hmm
Blueball is op
kinda cool
u keep speaking about agwhewian what is that? i know what agrarian is but not agwhewian
Well actually British raj simply meant British rule, it was called india back in those days since the times of ancient Greeks but the indian called india under British as British Raj (British rule) as opposed to Mughal raj (Mughal rule). Btw its weird seeing Muslim marginalised in before independence because the demand for Pakistan wasn't because they were marginalized but because of two nation theory made them believe they were more pure and martial than the dirty hindu population. It can be observed during the 1971 bengladeshi genocide, where Pakistani clerics ans military considered bangladeshis muslim as too hindu thus impure.
44:44 He lore
👍
Play as tanzania for the lols
Agrarian is pronounced (Ag-rare-ian) not Ag-wear-ian.
You speak like a Spaniard.
India mentioned 🎉🎉🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🎉🎉🎉
India is a potenial superpower irl!
so much unnecessary yapping
India No. 1 !!!!
Do not redeem!!!! 😡