Historians Review Ancient Rome in I, CLAUDIUS By Robert Graves (w/

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 янв 2025

Комментарии • 47

  • @tumblyhomecarolinep7121
    @tumblyhomecarolinep7121 Год назад +8

    I read this back in the 1970/80s. I knew nothing about the history of this but it really inspired me. I managed to understand all the people and the story. Robert Graves was such an accomplished writer and a wonderful poet too.

  • @All_Tomorrows_Parties
    @All_Tomorrows_Parties Год назад +3

    I somehow missed this when it came out! This and Claudius the God are two of my favorite novels ! YAY!

  • @Emanonerewhon
    @Emanonerewhon Год назад +5

    This is one of my favorite books, definitely my favorite work of historical fiction without a doubt. It is extremely readable, well researched, and eminently well written. It's just a pleasure to read if you love the history of the Roman empire, especially if you're a fan of Tacitus, Suetonius and other great personages of history.

  • @matthewedwards6025
    @matthewedwards6025 Год назад +7

    I've never read the book, but I've seen the excellent BBC series with Derek Jacobi as Claudius many times.

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  Год назад +1

      I’ve heard it’s WONDERFUL!

    • @matthewedwards6025
      @matthewedwards6025 Год назад

      @@MoAnInc Somebody asked for a link in the comments below of where to see it free, so I added one (assuming YT allows that to show).

    • @helenberrington
      @helenberrington Год назад

      I'd recommend the audio books. Unfortunately the version of Claudius the God I have is highly abridged but it's still enjoyable.

    • @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633
      @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633 10 месяцев назад

      @@MoAnIncIt is wonderful. But they tried to make an epic I, Claudius with Charles Laughton, Merle Oberon, etc. produced by Alexander Korda, but it was never completed. This is a tragedy, as fragments exist that show it could have been one of the greatest film epics ever. It was abandoned when Merle Oberon had a car accident. Laughton was even better than Jacobi, who was terrific. It can be seen on YT, The Epic that Never Was.

  • @SeanRCope
    @SeanRCope Год назад +5

    One of the best historical fiction books ever written. Not a bad soap opera either by the BBC.

  • @debramaldonado9809
    @debramaldonado9809 Год назад +2

    Thanks for posting ❤ do you know where I can watch the series I Claudius?

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching! I actually don’t, but if you find out do let me know because I want to watch it, too!!

    • @matthewedwards6025
      @matthewedwards6025 Год назад

      @@MoAnInc I keep trying to post a site to view it on, but YT keeps deleting the posts. TBH, this site is "on the high seas," if you get my meaning. Well, if you know of some of these sites, I suppose you can search for yourself.

    • @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633
      @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633 10 месяцев назад

      @@MoAnIncLook it up in the internet.

    • @miltonberle1594
      @miltonberle1594 5 месяцев назад

      I Clavdivs is currently available to watch on BBC Iplayer

  • @archie6945
    @archie6945 11 месяцев назад +1

    I was surprised to hear the Graves had Herod born in Bethlehem & I've heard that some historians think that Caligula behave so badly because he too wanted a Republic.

  • @amylynn7868
    @amylynn7868 Год назад +3

    I loved the book and tv show much!! I have to say Germanicus was my all time favourite!! He was an amazing character

    • @eveyoser268
      @eveyoser268 Год назад +4

      My mom read the book and watched the TV series a long time ago. She convinced my sister and I to watch the series on DVD and let's just say it was amazing since I'm a big history fan!!!

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  Год назад +2

      Oh Germanicus is a great choice for favourite character 👀

    • @helenberrington
      @helenberrington Год назад +1

      I actually cried when germanicus died when Claudius says something like "of my own sorrow I cannot bring myself to write."
      Both of these books just draw you in completely I also love the audio books narrated by Derek Jacobi.

    • @lexiwilson9501
      @lexiwilson9501 11 месяцев назад

      Yes! A true hero and without this book he would've past most of us by.

  • @MacScarfield
    @MacScarfield 21 день назад

    The BBC Adaptation has BRIAN BLESSED(!) as Augustus: Something that really should not work at all, given the rather stern, stoic and slim public image of Augustus do no quite square with the gregarious, loud and buff BLESSED, but he really did show us a master class of acting! 🎭
    Also George R R Martin has named the depiction of Tiberius as a major inspiration for his own Stannis Baratheon!
    Derek Jacobi («Gladiator») as Claudius, John Hurt («1984», «Alien» & «V for Vendetta») as Caligula, Patrick Stewart («Star Trek: TNG») as Sejanus and both John Rhys-Davies and Bernard Hill («Lord of the Rings») show up as members of the Pretorian Guard!

  • @robgau2501
    @robgau2501 Год назад +3

    You should review Graves' The White Goddess.

  • @Dylankiwi1
    @Dylankiwi1 Год назад

    Fantastic Review Moan Inc, I'm just curious would you be reading or review Augustus by John Williams? I've recently finished it and I reckon you would very love it.

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  Год назад +2

      I’ll certainly go an add it to the list if it’s something you’d like to see!! ❤️

  • @abraxaszee8953
    @abraxaszee8953 Год назад +2

    You should review The Changing of the Gods by Anthony Miano.

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  Год назад

      I’ll check it out!

    • @abraxaszee8953
      @abraxaszee8953 Год назад

      @@MoAnInc You said you were sick of Hades stories where he owns a club or something like that. In this story, he’s firmly in the Underworld.

  • @bugsby4663
    @bugsby4663 4 месяца назад

    The BBC adaptation is easily one of the best dramas ever shown on TV. The quality of the acting is so far and above acting you see today shows that good writing and acting matters far more than budget. George RR Martin based Stannis Baretheon on George Baker's austere Tiberius.

  • @taker68
    @taker68 6 месяцев назад

    I'm watching the great BBC adaptation from 1976. How does it compare to the novels? Anything cut out?

    • @MoAnInc
      @MoAnInc  6 месяцев назад +1

      You’ll have to read the book! 🤓

    • @JamesMurphy-ry2mx
      @JamesMurphy-ry2mx 4 месяца назад +1

      Very similar to the book. There is a bit about religion left out of the BBC series. Probably because it’s a bit boring.

  • @bugsby4663
    @bugsby4663 4 месяца назад

    I urge people to read the short book on Caligula by Sam Wilkinson. It points out that moat of the stories were exaggerations or lies. Senators wrote the history and Caligula despised them and saw no point in pretending they had power, which Augustus and Tiberius had done. Caligula was a young, arrogant autocrat, very much like Domitian and both men shared the same fate. In the end, Caligula was a terrible politician but not mad and quite a good emperor.

  • @TheLucas2205
    @TheLucas2205 Год назад

    OH BOY HERE WE GO
    🍿🍿🍿

  • @jannarkiewicz633
    @jannarkiewicz633 5 месяцев назад

    Listening to a review of a book written in 1934 that I read before Erica was born. Works for me.

  • @donnapee8402
    @donnapee8402 Год назад

    I read this book long ago. It was great I couldn't wait to read the next chapter.hiw could human beings possibly live like this.

  • @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633
    @elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633 10 месяцев назад

    Roman Empire was pretty horrible. Very cruel.