@@unstoppable4rce It just a general assumption as the bird is always there. A buck probably wouldn't come near them and they would chase away a coyote. Also, according to a quick google search, Bluebirds represent a spiritual realm that brings signs of loved ones from the heavens. They may be a physical incarnation of an angel that was sent to watch over you.
@@mrcaesar3123 - "God helps those that help themselves" - Ancient Greek Saying John has the right idea...you can only do so much. People need to learn to stand on their own. If not...then let nature take it's course. Aka...Natural Selection Which is the issue with altruism vs compassion... Altruism is basically enslaving yourself in the act aiding others who eventually take advantage of you kindness. (Too many people in the west are like that. I just let nature work her magic and rid our society of the fools) Compassion has limits and one can only be so compassionate when they realize they've been used.
In this case however, Fizhy coulda stretched it to 10 mins convincingly. Unlike MrBoss, where he literally rambles on and on about nothing for 6 of those minutes
Jenny's faith is what a perception of what some people think faith is, being magic. Most christians would've taken john as a sign of help and would have gone, its chilling that jenny doesn't have enough common sense to even see that
This story reminds me of the story of a man who turned away rescuers 3 times because he thought God would save him but he died and asked God why he didn't save him but those 3 rescuers were sent by God
She mentions in one of the early missions that she overheard John talking with Ross and Fordham, hence why she was so keen to find out what he was out in the Wild for. Regardless its a neat detail.
@@lisaashby1547 Have you seen the storms in RDR2? They’re absolutely beautiful, even the blizzards in the online version, which literally happens only about a month every year are worth seeking out.
I always interpreted it as the preacher and Jenny weren't traveling together, she just found out he was a preacher and started to talk to him because she's a nut.
the stranger missions in this game are actually far more interesting than those in 2. They’re all mysterious and have elements of eeriness to them. Like this mission, how did this woman end up in this situation? Why is she so far away from Armadillo? What’s her credence in faith? It’s all mystery and open for interpretation, which I appreciate.
imo I think the reason the strangers missions in 1 are more eerie than 2 is because 2 takes place more in the eastern states. Plenty of big cities and people around, but in 1 it’s down west, where there are very little people down there who have also probably not seen anyone else too. Deteriorating their health and their mental state to act around other people, or I’m wrong and it’s just intentional game design. This is just what I think though.
Dunno, most of RDR 1 side quests are kinda wack. "I Know You" has genius writing though. In RDR 2 I felt there were much more variety in side quests: funny, scary and sad ones; - not just "strange" like in the first game. But that's just me.
@@ВладиславБулаев-л3э I agree there’s more variety in 2 but 1 also has a few different and sort of comical side missions too, like the guy with the horse for a wife which was both, bizarre and hilarious. But I also find the ones in 2 don’t really leave with you questions because they end in a way that’s satisfying. I never got the feeling of “what was that about? What did that guy mean when he said that?” and I feel as tho 1 has more philosophy behind it’s side missions than 2 does. But I still enjoy the side missions in 2 as well.
I think Jenny was doing where Jesus walked the desert for 40 days to show Faith. I guess she waited for an Angel to come and save her by trusting the lord. After an Angel saves Jesus from completing God work for showing Faith to him. It's possible she got lost and try to head the priest.
Just today I was watching a short film on RDR 1 and there was this scene in the film. After watching here die in the hill, I was wandering what happened to her and you've made this video mate. Thanks ! Keep 'em coming.
This side mission actually made me think that there's people who take faith in a whole level also no one aside from her will ever be left out in the desert because who knows what might kill her it's just creepy
I always thought this mission was really dark. I think the preacher “did” something to Jenny, whom Jenny misplaced her faith in. So it breaks her, and the only thing she has faith in now is god. She knows full well she’s gonna die out there, but she believes her god will rescue her. Which is why we don’t see the preacher.
Why? I think if anything from what we see on the train the priest more likely has a bad habit of making things up on the spot to not seem like he doesn’t have answers. He seems to like the idea that people think he’s wise. And doesn’t really think through how people will interpret what he says. I’m more likely he said something just silly but Jenny trusted him and decided to go to the desert. Even on the train we see that Jenny will just believe any said to her if she thinks it’s a respectable source. Her fault is naivety and his fault is not understanding people rely on him for guidance and he should be more concerned with giving good advice that seeming smart in the moment. Like a big but often forget about value in Christianity is contemplation and mindfulness of how one effects people.
I think it's a reference to the old story about the guy on the deserted island. It goes, the guy is alone and prays to god for help. A boat comes by and the sailors offer to take him aboard, but the guy says "no, I have faith that god will save me". Unsurprisingly he dies on the island, and when he goes to heaven he says "why didn't you save me?" to which he's told "I sent you a boat".
I thought so too at first but it seems the way to play that out would be to have her turn the medicine down and say she was waiting on her god to save her instead. Then she would die, ask god about it, and he’s say he sent John with medicine.
It really is. It’s kind of why I have trouble viewing RDR2 as canon to the first game. There’s just so much outlandish things that happen in RDR2 like the Guarma chapter where the characters conveniently end up on an island together, Micah massacring a whole town without repercussion, Dutch and Arthur surviving the steep fall into water, Arthur surviving the shipwreck, John surviving getting mauled by a bear and wolves, and John bumping into Sadie, Uncle, and Charles after nearly a decade. I won’t lie and say that RDR1 was entirely realistic, but the action felt more grounded and restricted and the fate of the characters was far less romanticized. No one in RDR1 had a happy ending. Everyone was forced to pay for their sins. John, Abigail, Ross, Uncle, Fordham, Irish, Bill, Javier, and Dutch all suffered the consequences of their misdeeds, whether it be fair or not. The idea of Charles, Sadie, Mary-Beth, Tilly, Swanson, and Pearson all getting to live a happy ending after their bloody past just didn’t feel right to me at all after the message RDR1 had.
@@jinxthatsme2317 Maybe the story of RDR2 is like a romanticised retelling of the events told to Jack Marston by John or Uncle to make it sound cooler than it actually was. It would explain some of the retcons the game made to what was established in the first game and why it seems to have almost GTA levels of absurdity at times
This reminds me of that one joke where a guy is drowning and turns away all rescue attempts because "God will save me" and when he drowns he's like "God wtf you just let me die" and God says "I sent all those rescues and you turned them away, what was I supposed to do?"
Exactly. She wasn’t really praying to be saved she just wanted to see an extravagant, flashy, and ultimately pointless miracle. And put herself willfully in danger to do so. Like the line “thou shalt not tempt the lord” from the Bible is about this kind of thing
Yeah, when you release a hogtied person after a set amount of time, they're not spooked or aggressive. They'll find activity markers in the vicinity and begin behaving, "Dynamically," as per their programming. I figured this out through two instances at Beecher's Hope: - I hogtied and kidnapped a Blackwater police officer and dumped him in the barn before leaving to mess around in the house for a few minutes. When I came back, he was still tied up in the barn and I decided to cut him loose and go back to messing around in the house again. Before I departed Beecher's Hope, I saw that cop doing farm chores, having seemingly accepted his new life as a ranch hand. - I loaded a save file that placed me in Jack's room. It's important to mention that this was just after completing The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed. I looked out the window and noticed a United States Marshal, in the middle of a thunderstorm, casually sweeping the porch.
If you start this mission after the main story, oddly Jack will still ask if he's seen her somewhere before to which she will just reply "no I don't think so" even more oddly if you start this mission as John and finish it as Jack, Jack will still start by saying he "felt kinda worried about her" even though he's never met her before, not to mention this would mean she stayed in the same spot sitting in the desert with no food or water for 3 years only for the son of the man that met her before to somehow magically be aware of her circumstances and come to provide her with medicine. Making her faith seem a lot more legitimately powerful.
Seeing all these stories again will be interesting since I haven't played RDR1 since I was a kid, and in my childhood I just remembered these mission as "the cannibal guy who gives me the cool outfit pieces" or "that randomly lady on the on ground"
Thanks again for the help moving my fridge freezer fizhy mate appreciate it and remember youtube still isn't sending me notifications for your videos Roadhouse
This reminds me of a story Once there was a flood, and a man was stuck on his roof. A man in a raft came by, and offered to save him, the man said "God will save me" and stayed. Later, the water had risen, and a man in a rowboat came over, and offered to save him, the man once again said "God will save me" and stayed. Later, the water had almost submerged the roof, and the coastguard came in a helicopter, and offered to save the man, once more, the man said "God will save me" and remained. The man soon after drowned, and in heaven he asked God why they didn't save him. God said "I sent a raft, a boat, and a helicopter, what more did you want?"
I understand why Jenny believed John was "instructed through God" to bring her medicine. I was a JW growing up(I left), but the devotion thing was out there often times.
Please, could you be more specific about their dialogue that suggests or hints the Priest could be a predator & how Jenny would kill him? I'm just genuinely interested and would like to here more on your story. Take your time writing, I'm all ears.
If they remake this game with rdr2s physics and graphics, with altered dialogue that makes more references to 2 it would be my favorite game of all time
In the RDR1 Short Film, "The Man From Blackwater", Jenny lies dead close to the rock where she was found suggesting that she never made it out of the desert.
Feel so sorry for the ppl who haven’t (and some now can’t) experience RDR. RDR2 is by far the best game I’ve ever played but RDR was a “game changer” & ground breaking when it came out. Still my favourite game of all time!! Just wish they’d remake it & give it the RDR2 treatment just to “modernise” it. Incredible game!!!!
As someone who still swears RDR 1 is a better game than RDR 2 I am absolutely loving the RDR 1 videos! keep em coming man there’s surprisingly not very many good videos about Red Dead 1, all the videos I can find just show you the same Easter eggs over and over again
It’s dumb but I always take her to Las Hermanas and pretend john convinced her to live her life with the nuns and not die in the wilderness haha. I’m glad other people also did that.
@@phil7144 Yeah i watched it earlier and realised, But what got me was when u do it in story mode its locked till u unlock it then it locks again, Where i found it while playing online and it was open all time and confused me lol
Came here to check out all the Red Dead 1 videos since im replaying the game for the first time nearly 10 years and forgot that itself easily one of my favorite games of all time. Ever since first playing this game as a kid, ive roleplayed while playin these kinds of games , and i would always hogtie Jenny and drop her off in the doctors office in armadillo. Just me? Okay
Jenny has some goddamn faith.
She just needs a Plan and Moneh!
She just needs to make allot of money, make allot of noise, and get the hell out!
Now all she need is a PLAN and some Moneh to go to Tahiti.
That was honestly perfect
Unlike Arthur and the rest of the gang :I
"only angels can fly"
*remembers Arthur coming in on an air balloon to look for John*
And the bluebird that appears in the house building mission, supposedly Arthur returning to keep an eye on John :)
@@lisaashby1547 why would he be a blue bird???? That makes no sense he would a Bulk or a Coyote
@@unstoppable4rce It just a general assumption as the bird is always there. A buck probably wouldn't come near them and they would chase away a coyote. Also, according to a quick google search, Bluebirds represent a spiritual realm that brings signs of loved ones from the heavens. They may be a physical incarnation of an angel that was sent to watch over you.
@@unstoppable4rce i think that in some cultures spirits can come in different forms regardless of who they were
@@lisaashby1547 Or maybe Hosea is the blue bird, more likely.
I like how John always tries to help but when people prove to be beyond saving hes just like "fuck it i dont have the time" and leaves them
No point in wasting time on people who won’t help themselves
@@mrcaesar3123 God Marston 😇
@@mrcaesar3123 - "God helps those that help themselves" - Ancient Greek Saying
John has the right idea...you can only do so much. People need to learn to stand on their own. If not...then let nature take it's course.
Aka...Natural Selection
Which is the issue with altruism vs compassion...
Altruism is basically enslaving yourself in the act aiding others who eventually take advantage of you kindness.
(Too many people in the west are like that. I just let nature work her magic and rid our society of the fools)
Compassion has limits and one can only be so compassionate when they realize they've been used.
Always better to do them as Jack.
Mrbossftw is shivering in his boots as you didn't stretch it for 10 minutes
No he's taking about red dead redemption 3 for ten minutes
@@Emma-Queenofhell All he talks about is gta 6
In this case however, Fizhy coulda stretched it to 10 mins convincingly. Unlike MrBoss, where he literally rambles on and on about nothing for 6 of those minutes
Red dead redemption 1 is just so nostalgic, I remember doing this encounter at my friends house 7 years ago.
I remember watching my dad play it when I was little and I get so many memories when I play it
@@mukwa2326I was 10 in 2010 and my dad bought us this when we first heard about it's release. We had Revolver in 2007 or 8
Something tells me that Jenny would get along very well with Dutch.
She has faith lmao
what???
I was about to comment the same thing that if only dutch found her
Dutch would pimp her out
I mean there was also a gang member we never saw in rdr2 named Jenny so theres that
Jenny's faith is what a perception of what some people think faith is, being magic. Most christians would've taken john as a sign of help and would have gone, its chilling that jenny doesn't have enough common sense to even see that
Yep. She was so naive and foolish and young that she took the preacher's words at face value, took them literally instead of figuratively
With her gender and what faith was at those times, it’s not too surprising
This story reminds me of the story of a man who turned away rescuers 3 times because he thought God would save him but he died and asked God why he didn't save him but those 3 rescuers were sent by God
Omg I saw that vid to
I just realised in the back of the train in the first mission you see Bonnie Macfarlane
performed by Bill Williamson's Actor
She mentions in one of the early missions that she overheard John talking with Ross and Fordham, hence why she was so keen to find out what he was out in the Wild for. Regardless its a neat detail.
If your a first time player if Red Dead you have to be an eagle eye person to notice that detail
It's interesting to think that she switches seats presumably because she didn't want to listen the ladies' nonsense, or maybe to sit closer to John.
@@burnthetrolls5971 they literally showed her face taking up alot of the screen
Jenny: Faith can move mountains
John: Has Dutch flashbacks
Faith can move mountains !!
Strangely enought I actually enjoy watching these. Knowing I can't get the Game makes it more surprising
Why can’t you get the game?
@@Sully2001 maybe no consoles, only pc. I had to borrow a 360 to replay rdr recently because it's emulation on pc is pretty buggy and abhorred.
@@TheHomiePit even to play it on my PS5 I need to buy a separate service (PS Now)
@@TheHomiePit There is a backwards compatible version for 360.
@@TheHomiePit but there is red dead for pc
Man rdr1 had some insane graphics for its time
But of course. It doesn't have to be fancy. It just has to look presentable.
Especially the thunderstorms! My lord those things are amazing and make RDR2 storms look pitiful in comparison.
@@lisaashby1547 Have you seen the storms in RDR2? They’re absolutely beautiful, even the blizzards in the online version, which literally happens only about a month every year are worth seeking out.
I always think that when I see these videos. Very effective and definitely hold up for the most part
And then you see the horse animations boy those haven’t aged well
Jenny seems to like Dutch's words.
If you had some damn faith we would be rich john
What do you mean by that ???
dutch words have power to the point that even young woman follow his words
I would've told her that god told me to save her from dying... Then she would've listened, good going John lol.
A real hero of the West.
*God
Finally the whole Red Dead franchise gets the treatment of fallout, so much lore and backstory, those games are beautiful indeed
“ So you’re trying to move a mountain? “
- John Marston
John: I brought you some medicine
Jenny: Oh thank you lord, you’ve saved me
John: Am I a Joke to You?
I always interpreted it as the preacher and Jenny weren't traveling together, she just found out he was a preacher and started to talk to him because she's a nut.
Sometimes I can’t believe how high quality your videos are sometimes, love it.
the stranger missions in this game are actually far more interesting than those in 2. They’re all mysterious and have elements of eeriness to them. Like this mission, how did this woman end up in this situation? Why is she so far away from Armadillo? What’s her credence in faith? It’s all mystery and open for interpretation, which I appreciate.
as much as i love red dead 2, red dead 1 really is just one of the most atmospheric and immersive games ever. its storytelling is unrivaled.
I prefer the side missions in 2 but 1 truly has more atmosphere
imo I think the reason the strangers missions in 1 are more eerie than 2 is because 2 takes place more in the eastern states. Plenty of big cities and people around, but in 1 it’s down west, where there are very little people down there who have also probably not seen anyone else too. Deteriorating their health and their mental state to act around other people, or I’m wrong and it’s just intentional game design. This is just what I think though.
Dunno, most of RDR 1 side quests are kinda wack. "I Know You" has genius writing though. In RDR 2 I felt there were much more variety in side quests: funny, scary and sad ones; - not just "strange" like in the first game. But that's just me.
@@ВладиславБулаев-л3э I agree there’s more variety in 2 but 1 also has a few different and sort of comical side missions too, like the guy with the horse for a wife which was both, bizarre and hilarious. But I also find the ones in 2 don’t really leave with you questions because they end in a way that’s satisfying. I never got the feeling of “what was that about? What did that guy mean when he said that?” and I feel as tho 1 has more philosophy behind it’s side missions than 2 does. But I still enjoy the side missions in 2 as well.
I think Jenny was doing where Jesus walked the desert for 40 days to show Faith.
I guess she waited for an Angel to come and save her by trusting the lord. After an Angel saves Jesus from completing God work for showing Faith to him. It's possible she got lost and try to head the priest.
I thought the same.
Good observation eren, cool to think about
Just today I was watching a short film on RDR 1 and there was this scene in the film. After watching here die in the hill, I was wandering what happened to her and you've made this video mate. Thanks ! Keep 'em coming.
Like a wise man once said “Have some faith Arthur!”
We need a remastered version of rdr1
With the Graphics and Mechanics of Rdr2
Or remake
I heard they're making a remake i think
@Croizzants Are great mostly because of the graphics
@Croizzants Are great why not 😂
Really?? You had to do the mission at night? Lol love your videos Fizhy
Just how the cookie crumbled
I brought her to that location in Mexico she didn't pray she just screamed and ran away once I released her from the horse and from being hogtied
Madlad
So the list that you can bring her to number of places in RDR wiki was bogus?
Red Dead 1 is my absolute favorite game to 100%. A classic & so much nostalgia
This side mission actually made me think that there's people who take faith in a whole level also no one aside from her will ever be left out in the desert because who knows what might kill her it's just creepy
The Lord send John to help Jenny. But her blind faith in him, doom her.
I always thought this mission was really dark. I think the preacher “did” something to Jenny, whom Jenny misplaced her faith in. So it breaks her, and the only thing she has faith in now is god. She knows full well she’s gonna die out there, but she believes her god will rescue her. Which is why we don’t see the preacher.
Why? I think if anything from what we see on the train the priest more likely has a bad habit of making things up on the spot to not seem like he doesn’t have answers. He seems to like the idea that people think he’s wise. And doesn’t really think through how people will interpret what he says. I’m more likely he said something just silly but Jenny trusted him and decided to go to the desert.
Even on the train we see that Jenny will just believe any said to her if she thinks it’s a respectable source. Her fault is naivety and his fault is not understanding people rely on him for guidance and he should be more concerned with giving good advice that seeming smart in the moment. Like a big but often forget about value in Christianity is contemplation and mindfulness of how one effects people.
I think it's a reference to the old story about the guy on the deserted island.
It goes, the guy is alone and prays to god for help. A boat comes by and the sailors offer to take him aboard, but the guy says "no, I have faith that god will save me". Unsurprisingly he dies on the island, and when he goes to heaven he says "why didn't you save me?" to which he's told "I sent you a boat".
I thought so too at first but it seems the way to play that out would be to have her turn the medicine down and say she was waiting on her god to save her instead. Then she would die, ask god about it, and he’s say he sent John with medicine.
She's a second wave Chelonian
What ?? No
After seeing all these videos I’ve just realized that rdr1 is really dark
It really is. It’s kind of why I have trouble viewing RDR2 as canon to the first game. There’s just so much outlandish things that happen in RDR2 like the Guarma chapter where the characters conveniently end up on an island together, Micah massacring a whole town without repercussion, Dutch and Arthur surviving the steep fall into water, Arthur surviving the shipwreck, John surviving getting mauled by a bear and wolves, and John bumping into Sadie, Uncle, and Charles after nearly a decade.
I won’t lie and say that RDR1 was entirely realistic, but the action felt more grounded and restricted and the fate of the characters was far less romanticized. No one in RDR1 had a happy ending. Everyone was forced to pay for their sins. John, Abigail, Ross, Uncle, Fordham, Irish, Bill, Javier, and Dutch all suffered the consequences of their misdeeds, whether it be fair or not.
The idea of Charles, Sadie, Mary-Beth, Tilly, Swanson, and Pearson all getting to live a happy ending after their bloody past just didn’t feel right to me at all after the message RDR1 had.
@@jinxthatsme2317 Maybe the story of RDR2 is like a romanticised retelling of the events told to Jack Marston by John or Uncle to make it sound cooler than it actually was. It would explain some of the retcons the game made to what was established in the first game and why it seems to have almost GTA levels of absurdity at times
This reminds me of that one joke where a guy is drowning and turns away all rescue attempts because "God will save me" and when he drowns he's like "God wtf you just let me die" and God says "I sent all those rescues and you turned them away, what was I supposed to do?"
Exactly. She wasn’t really praying to be saved she just wanted to see an extravagant, flashy, and ultimately pointless miracle. And put herself willfully in danger to do so. Like the line “thou shalt not tempt the lord” from the Bible is about this kind of thing
That one dislike must be from Jenny herself
Exactly.
Yeah, when you release a hogtied person after a set amount of time, they're not spooked or aggressive. They'll find activity markers in the vicinity and begin behaving, "Dynamically," as per their programming.
I figured this out through two instances at Beecher's Hope:
- I hogtied and kidnapped a Blackwater police officer and dumped him in the barn before leaving to mess around in the house for a few minutes. When I came back, he was still tied up in the barn and I decided to cut him loose and go back to messing around in the house again. Before I departed Beecher's Hope, I saw that cop doing farm chores, having seemingly accepted his new life as a ranch hand.
- I loaded a save file that placed me in Jack's room. It's important to mention that this was just after completing The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed. I looked out the window and noticed a United States Marshal, in the middle of a thunderstorm, casually sweeping the porch.
Where did you dump the person in the barn? Every time I dump them they disappear when I get back
@@harrisn3693 A horse stall? I can't remember very well.
This was a while ago and I could've just been lucky.
That's SUPER COOL! I want to try that sometime 😂
The preacher dude always rubbed me the wrong way for some reason...
He probably dumped her out there
If you start this mission after the main story, oddly Jack will still ask if he's seen her somewhere before to which she will just reply "no I don't think so" even more oddly if you start this mission as John and finish it as Jack, Jack will still start by saying he "felt kinda worried about her" even though he's never met her before, not to mention this would mean she stayed in the same spot sitting in the desert with no food or water for 3 years only for the son of the man that met her before to somehow magically be aware of her circumstances and come to provide her with medicine. Making her faith seem a lot more legitimately powerful.
Well her fait doesn't care if the player does side missions or whatever
Seeing all these stories again will be interesting since I haven't played RDR1 since I was a kid, and in my childhood I just remembered these mission as "the cannibal guy who gives me the cool outfit pieces" or "that randomly lady on the on ground"
May the father of understanding guide us
@Angelo Castillo I’m a goddam onion Mason 🧅
I literally just played this mission and then was like “I wonder if Fizhy has a video on this”
Thanks again for the help moving my fridge freezer fizhy mate appreciate it and remember youtube still isn't sending me notifications for your videos
Roadhouse
Fizhy has supernatural powers. I started This is Armadillo USA as he said it
Good video Fizhy
I like your channel's vids and it's content. Greetings from Ireland 🇮🇪
I like how john says even illness it seems like they planned that but they probably didnt cus when he said that I thought about arthur immediately
ABSOLUTE SIRS "Colton the Creampie King" That one made me chuckle.
She doesn't doubt
This reminds me of a story
Once there was a flood, and a man was stuck on his roof. A man in a raft came by, and offered to save him, the man said "God will save me" and stayed. Later, the water had risen, and a man in a rowboat came over, and offered to save him, the man once again said "God will save me" and stayed. Later, the water had almost submerged the roof, and the coastguard came in a helicopter, and offered to save the man, once more, the man said "God will save me" and remained. The man soon after drowned, and in heaven he asked God why they didn't save him. God said "I sent a raft, a boat, and a helicopter, what more did you want?"
3:28 'you trying to move a mountain?!
Has anyone successfully hogtied Jenny and got to make her live at beecher’s hope or McFarlane’s ranch?
I understand why Jenny believed John was "instructed through God" to bring her medicine. I was a JW growing up(I left), but the devotion thing was out there often times.
I think the Priest was a predator and she killed him. Both the Priest and Jenny's dialogue performance suggests that is the case in my opinion.
Please, could you be more specific about their dialogue that suggests or hints the Priest could be a predator & how Jenny would kill him? I'm just genuinely interested and would like to here more on your story. Take your time writing, I'm all ears.
Why would Jenny kill him? She doesn't come across as a murderer or psycho
@@ant.rileyss8840 That's what I'm trying to figure out, I want to hear him out first before I say anything.
Imagine right red dead redemption 3 based on jack marston
No thanks
If it was from Jack’s POV it would likely be jack fighting in ww1, besides the west was basically done by 1914
@@biggoggy7991 maybe it takes place in the 1920s and he gets involved in a bootlegging business. Call it a post-western.
One based on Hosea is better
@@sherwingonsalves8821 no thanks, going backwards in time again Is just dumb.
If they remake this game with rdr2s physics and graphics, with altered dialogue that makes more references to 2 it would be my favorite game of all time
We have the same name
The Rise of Jim-
Two Jims in one place-
Who am I ought to follow?!
@@kairi7097 the one using my face
@@RandomOne1999 do u watch call me Kevin
@@jimpickens3343 did you just ask the dear leader if he watched Kevin
Two opposite sides of a dice will always add up to 7. That isnt related to this I just think that's cool
In the RDR1 Short Film, "The Man From Blackwater", Jenny lies dead close to the rock where she was found suggesting that she never made it out of the desert.
Me, a roman catholic: ...ma’am that’s not how faith works...
I'm safe because I have faith so faith can move mountains That's all the whole point.
The preacher, trelawny and the strange man walk into a bar. He orders a whiskey
*F A I T H*
I remember this encounter. Haven't played RDR on forever
Feel so sorry for the ppl who haven’t (and some now can’t) experience RDR. RDR2 is by far the best game I’ve ever played but RDR was a “game changer” & ground breaking when it came out. Still my favourite game of all time!! Just wish they’d remake it & give it the RDR2 treatment just to “modernise” it. Incredible game!!!!
I remember getting pissed I wasted medicine on her so I hogtied her and took back the medicine
She kinda reminds me of the girl from that whole braithewaits and whatever that other families name is
I just came across your videos and I love them. I am a huge fan of RDR 1 and you make me want to play this game again
Its kinda sad here seeing someone so corrupted and poisoned by religion. Especially knowing people in real life not as much anymore.
Get a life bro no need to hate on Christianity for no reason
Just realised somethin from rdr2 is that if nc carry deadeye things like cigs and other chewing things, then they have deadeye
i respect him so much more than mr boss cause he actually fills the video with content
As someone who still swears RDR 1 is a better game than RDR 2 I am absolutely loving the RDR 1 videos! keep em coming man there’s surprisingly not very many good videos about Red Dead 1, all the videos I can find just show you the same Easter eggs over and over again
Can you do a video on the California Stranger mission?
Show some GODDAMN FAITH!
It’s dumb but I always take her to Las Hermanas and pretend john convinced her to live her life with the nuns and not die in the wilderness haha. I’m glad other people also did that.
I love this series! Please keep em coming!
Who’d like to see a remastered Red Dead with graphics from RDR2
Oh i never realised that jenny from the train was jenny from the stranger mission
Tried to catch her with the robe to bring her back to the city but she ran away and a snake got her…
The Wright Brothers are angels according to the priest.
Bonnie McFarland is like kill me now lol
Great video as always!
I like these kind of videos. Keep up the good work
old fizhy is back
Fizhy, Whats with the destroyed building under the A in Valentine Its got a basement with a load of bodys in it
That's the serial killers hideout
@@phil7144 Yeah i watched it earlier and realised, But what got me was when u do it in story mode its locked till u unlock it then it locks again, Where i found it while playing online and it was open all time and confused me lol
This is a sadder version of the three whale joke
Tahiti?
Pretty sure the priest is outside the Armadillo saloon
I ended up leaving her on the railroad tracks and getting the dastardly achievement
That 1 dislike is Micah
Nice video keep up the good work fizhy
The preacher is in armadillo
Hey fizhy make a video on the ghost of tumbleweed in rdr 1 next if you can
I'm building up to it
Biggest F.U. Rockstar gave the fans was not allowing us into the house in RDR2
This is the earliest I've ever been
Came here to check out all the Red Dead 1 videos since im replaying the game for the first time nearly 10 years and forgot that itself easily one of my favorite games of all time.
Ever since first playing this game as a kid, ive roleplayed while playin these kinds of games , and i would always hogtie Jenny and drop her off in the doctors office in armadillo. Just me? Okay
What you can bring her places? For 8 years I just left her (and he's yes you find her dead later)
Yaaayi love the rdr2 vids
Then your God has finally deserted you
The priest kind of gave me the creeps. Anyone else thought there was more to this story?
Oh I thought we where talking about Jenny Kirk,
Everyone talking at the train.
John
Please just shut up.
Yo. Have you done anything about the Soothsayer that appears at night in the Bayou Nwa in RDR2?
You are epic Ethan