My ranking. The Vanishing Express 3 9.5 The Yellow Engine 1 10 Stanley’s Stalker 2 9.5 Whispers in the Woods 4 9 Id also add points for kinda making some stories connected(possibly)
Interesting how the little shunter got destroyed by a v1 flying bomb 4 years before the bombs were put into service, but the story is well put together. 10/10 do more horror stories if you can, they are very AND i say VERY entertaining, well done👍
Now they blame Stanley, yet the crew set the brakes on. How would he cause his own derailment? If anything they would blame the crew thinking they didn't secure his brakes properly.
Although I do think the stories in Volume 1 were better, which of course makes sense because those are the first stories written, I still loved it this year and every Friday night I was looking forward to a new instalment of the series. Thank you for bringing us this volume Rhen.
The true story behind "The Vanishing Express" is really sad and I like that Gordon who was always vain paying respect to the truth, the ambiguity of the Yellow Engine, the Stalker and the Whispers in the Woods and people who know of them like Arry & little Engine Bert are what truly spooky, I wonder do the Stalker and the Whispers in the Woods have any connection.
The Vanishing Express and Whispers in the Woods are my favorite stories from Sudrian Stories From Hell Volume 2. I would like to see a prequel to The Vanishing Express about George's Backstory and a sequel to Whispers in the Woods with James as the Protagonist titled James and the Whispers.
I’m rewatching this again just because, and I just thought about how the passengers on Gordon’s train would have definitely heard him scream in “the vanishing express”.i just found it kinda funny.
Ok but why was jinty smiling when he was telling the story at the first part I love how edward interferes with everything and if george was still alive Gordon could've been his friend and let him express 15:43 victor!!! The fact Stanley failed to get reepect
not Lying He deserves it for not believing Stanley also why didn't He ask His crew what happened that night I mean He could've let Stanley and His Crew explain what Happened that night to why He collided into that passenger train
What is with that weird chanting? Where did the yellow engine go? Who did that to Stanley and who was surrounding Edward? And the most important question of all, why do every single one of them know the chant? I really wish I had answers to all of those questions!
Honestly the manager is such a jerk, he should’ve been fired after insulting Stanley right at the last minute before he was turning into a pumping engine. If there was a guy, he would’ve said to the manager like hey don’t you insult him, he is telling the truth.
If I was the manager Who asked for the "yellow Engine" and it was suspicious and instead of following Him I swear I'd Sell that Engine For Scrap !!! also at 15:16 did Anyone notice that Duke was passing a signal that was displaying a "stop aspect" not a "clear aspect" if Duke was allowed to leave the station the signal should've displayed a "clear aspect" not a "stop aspect" the signal was displaying A "stop aspect" because the track Duke was using was already occupied by another train
That's a bit confusing. Like they have drivers yet they don't stop them when they do things they shouldn't be doing. but in Magic Railway they seem to be able to move on their own.
My theory for the yellow engine is when he leaves and chants the engine is going to rituals while going to one of them the mine he went through was unstable and collapsed while he was still inside he eventually came back and started haunting the line anyone who told the story would begin the same chanting and leaving to mysterious places at night
I know this is like creepy and stuff, more ambiguous, but it didn't hit like last years. I like your style of story telling where spooky thing then ghosts rather thn the reverse. I honestly didn't like them this year, liek its cool they were connected but still, not very scary. I was also expectimg like an extra story like last years but there wasn't and it feels like there wasn't a conclusion. I dont feel any horror, more thriller. We dont know what the chant is and dont know what there goal is and I don't feel the horror from it
Honestly, I think the Stanley story and the yellow engine story was the worst ones out of all. I won’t bother going into details for now, but I think it’s pretty obvious why
The fact that the entire Mid Sodor Railway failed to treat Stanley with proper respect for his entire service life was nothing short of disgraceful.
Digusting, Despicable finished James and Henry.
@@claytonveno3710 We cannot allow it.
Distasteful. Distressing. Disingenuous.
It would never suit his grace
@@henryrevan1998 Deplorable! ...What?
The Yellow Engine takes "Blue Mountain Mystery" to another level
Having Victor's original model for the demon engine was unsettling to say the least
The whispering/chanting is heard in 3 of the storys possibly meaning the yellow engine and the man and those ppl must be connected in someway
I have a theory for the last 3 story’s. There’s a cult in the woods who warship engines and possess them. And or sabotage them so they crash
Poor Stanley nobody will believe him:(
Strange things are occurring on the Northwestern Railway.
Very Strange....
My ranking.
The Vanishing Express 3 9.5
The Yellow Engine 1 10
Stanley’s Stalker 2 9.5
Whispers in the Woods 4 9
Id also add points for kinda making some stories connected(possibly)
HAPPY HALLOWEEN
@@vaclavmacgregor2464 is there a 3rd volume soon
What is that voice with old bailey? 😂😂😂 "Well howdy partner" 🤠, but Fr he sounds far more, erm, cryptic and mysterious.
Question: Will you EVER reveal who that strange whisperer is who sent Stanly to scrap, appeared as a yellow engine and scared Edward?
Interesting how the little shunter got destroyed by a v1 flying bomb 4 years before the bombs were put into service, but the story is well put together. 10/10 do more horror stories if you can, they are very AND i say VERY entertaining, well done👍
I’m glad this series is not over!
Now they blame Stanley, yet the crew set the brakes on. How would he cause his own derailment? If anything they would blame the crew thinking they didn't secure his brakes properly.
Yeah put [s] in the comments if you feel bad for Stanley
@@juliefowler9384 S
stanleys stalker sounds like a griefer imho
Although I do think the stories in Volume 1 were better, which of course makes sense because those are the first stories written, I still loved it this year and every Friday night I was looking forward to a new instalment of the series. Thank you for bringing us this volume Rhen.
The true story behind "The Vanishing Express" is really sad and I like that Gordon who was always vain paying respect to the truth, the ambiguity of the Yellow Engine, the Stalker and the Whispers in the Woods and people who know of them like Arry & little Engine Bert are what truly spooky, I wonder do the Stalker and the Whispers in the Woods have any connection.
I think the people who circled Edward were part of some kind of cult
The Vanishing Express and Whispers in the Woods are my favorite stories from Sudrian Stories From Hell Volume 2. I would like to see a prequel to The Vanishing Express about George's Backstory and a sequel to Whispers in the Woods with James as the Protagonist titled James and the Whispers.
CAN YOU MAKE A SEQUEL TO THE YELLOW ENGINE STROY. THAT ONE WAS MY FAV.
21:35 the funny thing here is that jock has the thousand yard stare
oi
Could there be a anti-train cult on the island?
~~carbrains~~
Wouldn't surprise me
I think there is a cult that warships and possesses engines that’s why the yellow engine went missing
Worships*
Poor Stanley :(
I’m rewatching this again just because, and I just thought about how the passengers on Gordon’s train would have definitely heard him scream in “the vanishing express”.i just found it kinda funny.
Someone give Stanley a series where he snaps
21:35 THE BEST PLOT TWIST EVER SINCE USUAL SUSPECT
Why did Stanley have to suffer?
This is so awesome and it makes me happy 😊 and it makes me laugh 😂 and now my stumt hurts right 👉 now.
That man that did that to the engine that was disgraceful disgusting and Despicable
Arry being nice is scary
At the end of the second story was crazy, because did the yellow engine just curse or take over Bert?
NAH. Bert is DEAD the Guard from hell KILLED HIM !!! so I think the Yellow Engine now takes on His appearance
Ok but why was jinty smiling when he was telling the story at the first part
I love how edward interferes with everything and if george was still alive Gordon could've been his friend and let him express
15:43 victor!!! The fact Stanley failed to get reepect
Nah, Bert IS the yellow engine. Remember? He died in "The Guard From Hell"
I agree and I two had that Theory I am now Terrified
Great now theres Demon cultist foamers on sodor, along with another demon engine
1:22
Bro really got hit with a bomb 💀
Is knownwhat the yellow engine is chanting?
Satanic chanting to Lucifer
That manager should be fired
not Lying He deserves it for not believing Stanley also why didn't He ask His crew what happened that night I mean He could've let Stanley and His Crew explain what Happened that night to why He collided into that passenger train
Fog phantom part 3 ?
What is with that weird chanting? Where did the yellow engine go? Who did that to Stanley and who was surrounding Edward? And the most important question of all, why do every single one of them know the chant? I really wish I had answers to all of those questions!
Maybe they are apart of a cult and maybe the yellow taught them the chant
It’s obvious old Bailey and airy know something about the chant, but where did the chant come from?
what does the chance translate to in English?
I wonder what language the chat is in ancient Arabic Greek Egyptian Sumerian Gozerian Mesopotamia just don’t know?
Who was Old Bailey talking to at the end of the video?
Honestly the manager is such a jerk, he should’ve been fired after insulting Stanley right at the last minute before he was turning into a pumping engine.
If there was a guy, he would’ve said to the manager like hey don’t you insult him, he is telling the truth.
YESSS!!!!
Fantastic stories, will there be a part 3? Because thats one major cliffhanger
In the beginning I noticed it says "Sudrian Stores From Hell"
Instead of
"Sudrian Stories From Hell"
ooooo i am a very scary overpriced loaf of breaaaaaaaaaaad
Bert is the yellow engien ? 😮
YES. remember Guys Bert is DEAD !!! because the GUARD from hell KILLED Him and think the yellow Engine takes on Bert's appearance
I feel bad for Stanley it's so not fair on him they say he lied when he clearly didn't lie
If I was the manager Who asked for the "yellow Engine" and it was suspicious and instead of following Him I swear I'd Sell that Engine For Scrap !!!
also at 15:16 did Anyone notice that Duke was passing a signal that was displaying a "stop aspect" not a "clear aspect" if Duke was allowed to leave the station the signal should've displayed a "clear aspect" not a "stop aspect" the signal was displaying A "stop aspect" because the track Duke was using was already occupied by another train
Hmm, are the engines able to control themselves?
(Edit) If so, is it a like a control part or is it just standard with all non-faceless vehicles.
That's a bit confusing. Like they have drivers yet they don't stop them when they do things they shouldn't be doing. but in Magic Railway they seem to be able to move on their own.
😅😅 Gordon has some chunk loss
Poor Gordon 😔
Are you making a part 2 for sod or mist because trover is in the cgi series
RIP King George.😌
The most missunderstood enginge of the war.😔
(Hope you pin that. Would be lovely.)😉☺
I still hate the fact that People accused Him for being responsible of the disappearance of the express train that was running that night
@@alvit123 Yeah. It sucks. Stanley was unrightfully framed too...
Okay, the manager of the MSR was an a$$. Not fitting to the gauge WILL result into accidents! HE of all shall know that!
Where’s Edward go?
Are we gonna get this continued by next year?
Apparently not sadly
What kind of whispers did you use?
Poor george
please tell me their is more to the demon engine story yes?
40:52 he sounds like Edward from DieselD199‘s videos
The Fog Phantom: part 3
What I wanna know is what he is actually chanting.
Are you Mike next story Percy ghost
My theory for the yellow engine is when he leaves and chants the engine is going to rituals while going to one of them the mine he went through was unstable and collapsed while he was still inside he eventually came back and started haunting the line anyone who told the story would begin the same chanting and leaving to mysterious places at night
In that story Author made victor ghost 😢
Rhen prod can you please make some videos about christmas please
🎉❤❤😮😅😅
Or Thomas ghost bus
That whispering is illegal
15:26 Victor???
I think that Engine is a "clone" of Victor because the real Victor would never do this
I know this is like creepy and stuff, more ambiguous, but it didn't hit like last years. I like your style of story telling where spooky thing then ghosts rather thn the reverse. I honestly didn't like them this year, liek its cool they were connected but still, not very scary. I was also expectimg like an extra story like last years but there wasn't and it feels like there wasn't a conclusion. I dont feel any horror, more thriller. We dont know what the chant is and dont know what there goal is and I don't feel the horror from it
Is it just me or when old bailey is on the phone. Do i see a My Hero Academia poster. Just a odd thing to see
Or Terence see ghost tractor abducted home
E
MAMMA MIA❤😚😚😚😚😚😘😘😘😘😘😎
Honestly, I think the Stanley story and the yellow engine story was the worst ones out of all. I won’t bother going into details for now, but I think it’s pretty obvious why
🎉❤❤😮😅😅