Support our Guest in the Links ABOVE! Support this CHANNEL BELOW! To my dear subscribers, thank you all. You have my love and appreciation. Check out our store! History Merch: ruclips.net/user/TheStudyofAntiquityandtheMiddleAgesstore Become an Ancient Origins PREMIUM MEMBER: members.ancient-origins.net/referral/2f6e132a THE ABOVE LINK IS OUR AFFILIATE LINK WHICH MEANS WE WILL EARN A SMALL COMMISION FROM YOUR MEMBERSHIP AT NO ADDITIONAL COST TO YOU. To my dear subscribers, thank you all. You have my love and appreciation. Check out our store! History Merch: ruclips.net/user/TheStudyofAntiquityandtheMiddleAgesstore Get your history magazines here: www.karwansaraypublishers.com?tap_a=88561-7cbe2d&tap_s=1562085-46f5e5 Enjoy history merchandise? Check out affiliate link to SPQR Emporium! spqr-emporium.com?aff=3 Get a subscription to Ancient Origins and get access to awesome books, webinars and etc! Link : members.ancient-origins.net/referral/2f6e132a *Disclaimer, the above three links are affiliate links which means we will earn a generous commission from your magnificent purchase, just another way to help out the channel! Facebook Page: facebook.com/THESTUDYOFANTIQUITYANDTHEMIDDLEAGES/ Twitter: twitter.com/NickBarksdale Instagram: instagram.com/study_of_antiquity_middle_ages/ Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/164050034145170/
Minoans weren't Greek. Palace is the word we have, because it's the word we use, lol. Btw, my former student Brent Davis is a leading expert on Linear A
@@louisehitchcock6438 You have no evidence of this. Why this stubborn stance, you decide first and then go out and about to pick and choose evidence to suit your thesis!? SAd.
@@gs032009 language is not Indo European. One piece of evidence is that the script is not well suited to writing Linear B which is Greek and Indo-European. Where is your evidence?
I deciphered the jade Cretan Hieroglyphic inscription (only seen in the thumbnail?) several years ago. It is a warning to a neighbor, and says: "I'm am watching you! I have seen you throw three stones and two sticks at my cat. If you mess with my cat again, I will cut off your head."
They where all looking for gold... We call them in Greece common thieves... Anglo Saxons common thieves... There is no Indo-European languages.The Greek language needs thousands of years to reach such levels, and this is evident from the flexibility of the Greek language and its etymologies, the Greek language is a complex language and needs explanation, and it is not easy to grasp its meanings, the Greek language it gives us the cause and the effect. (principle of causality)
*Mlk stones? Sacrifice stones. Interesting. Now would that be the **_smooth stones from the brook_** typically iron meteorites were which shaped into a 'pillow' or base for an idol?* *Alternately there is the Arland Tash amulet with the earliest Canaanite dialect inscription circa 7th century BC.*
ΑΝΟΙΧΤΗ ΑΚΑΔΗΜΙΑ ΠΡΑΚΤΟΡΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΑΣ ΨΕΥΤΙΚΩΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΩΝ ΑΝΑΚΑΛΥΨΕΩΝ" ΕΝΝΟΕΊΤΕ. ΜΕΛΕΤΗ "ΠΡΟΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΩΝ" ΠΟΛΙΤΙΣΜΩΝ ΠΟΥ ΕΧΤΙΣΑΝ ΤΑ ΤΕΛΕΥΤΑΙΑ 100 ΧΡΟΝΙΑ ΞΕΝΟΙ ΔΗΘΕΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΟΙ" ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΓΙΑ ΝΑ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΙΖΟΥΝ ΟΤΙ ΟΙ ΕΓΓΛΈΖΟΙ ΟΙ ΓΕΡΜΑΝΟΙ ΟΙ ΣΗΜΙΤΕΣ κτλ ΖΟΥΣΑΝ ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΠΡΙΝ ΑΠΌ ΤΟΥΣ ΕΛΛΗΝΕΣ.
ΑΝΟΙΧΤΗ ΑΚΑΔΗΜΙΑ ΠΡΑΚΤΟΡΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΑΣ ΨΕΥΤΙΚΩΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΩΝ ΑΝΑΚΑΛΥΨΕΩΝ" ΕΝΝΟΕΊΤΕ. ΜΕΛΕΤΗ "ΠΡΟΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΩΝ" ΠΟΛΙΤΙΣΜΩΝ ΠΟΥ ΕΧΤΙΣΑΝ ΤΑ ΤΕΛΕΥΤΑΙΑ 100 ΧΡΟΝΙΑ ΞΕΝΟΙ ΔΗΘΕΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΟΙ" ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΓΙΑ ΝΑ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΙΖΟΥΝ ΟΤΙ ΟΙ ΕΓΓΛΈΖΟΙ ΟΙ ΓΕΡΜΑΝΟΙ ΟΙ ΣΗΜΙΤΕΣ κτλ ΖΟΥΣΑΝ ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΠΡΙΝ ΑΠΌ ΤΟΥΣ ΕΛΛΗΝΕΣ.
Yeah, if I didn't hear "third year PhD student", I would have thought that he was a two pack-a-day smoker of four decades dying from tuberculosis and throat cancer. He was very informative between the dying sounds, however.
In any decipherment of a script, one first needs to determine if it is alphabetic, syllabic or conceptual. Even hieroglyphs uses a similar format. As sealstones would be pictorial but syllabic especially as a qualifier noun ( name). From there a syllabic interpretation can be assessed. Of course, therein lies the problem of the pronunciation of such syllables as originally spoken. So assuming that h7mans will attempt the easiest possibility, the first person modifiers may be deciphered. Such as a symbol indicating (I) instead of the syllabic name. And from there to a second person reference of the first person ( Me) in many cases, this can lead to a combination of alphabetic and syllabic. The final difficulty comes with the conceptual. This has been inscribed as far back a Nineveh where the use of the word for a Date Palm was used to denote a water raising device. Much as in today’ idioms, we speak and contextually write of a mouse to mean a computer control device as proposed to a small furry rodent. Or as in the Chinese characters, the symbols for two women under one roof, is the symbol for trouble. If one can draw a parallel from a local pronunciation it is better, as has been used for the translation of Mayan hieroglyphs back to a spoken language. As from such usage, contextual usages can be derived. As can grammatical influences.
One thing I’d really love to see in future videos would be maps that show the locations being discussed in that moment. The maps shown don’t usually match up. I can’t overstate how this would enhance the experience of these videos and the quality of learning they provide. Thank you for the work you’re doing.
Awesome Explanaitions! I hope he will explain more in future videos. But since the Tawagalawa-letter mentions a war between Ahhijawa and Hatti, there was at least one Trojan War.
Perhaps using chronology would help. When did the Greeks come to Crete and from where? Indo European? No such thing. Its Proto Slavic that was used in Crete 7000 BC.Vinca script, Danube civilisation, was living in the Balkans and from Black Sea to the Baltics. I know it’s hard to turn the "truth" around and admit that Barbarians as Greeks called them, where the Civilization long,long,long before Greeks, Etruscans, Latins had any script .
Rent a car: we made to 26 sites/museums in 11 days. The most important sites besides Knossos are Malia, Sissi, Gournia, Petras (outside Sitia), Palaikastro, Phaistos and Hagia Triada, Tylissos, Diktaian Cave. If you have more time: there are a lot more sites. If you can get ahold of the Blue Guide, it has excellent info; also my book Aegean Art and Architecture. Most important museum is Herakleion.
What are your toughts about Vinca script being the oldest.Etruscan was decifered using Vinca sript. www.ancient-origins.net/ancient-places-europe/danube-valley-civilisation-script-oldest-writing-world-001343
Fascinating and intelligent without gee-whiz distractions. Decades ago my Greek professor taught us, for fun one sunny day, how to do sums in Linear B.
Thanks for the interesting video. I am so fascinated with writing systems of the world. I've even made some. You already commented about there not being graphics to see the writing systems.
Support our Guest in the Links ABOVE! Support this CHANNEL BELOW!
To my dear subscribers, thank you all. You have my love and appreciation.
Check out our store! History Merch: ruclips.net/user/TheStudyofAntiquityandtheMiddleAgesstore
Become an Ancient Origins PREMIUM MEMBER:
members.ancient-origins.net/referral/2f6e132a
THE ABOVE LINK IS OUR AFFILIATE LINK WHICH MEANS WE WILL EARN A SMALL COMMISION FROM YOUR MEMBERSHIP AT NO ADDITIONAL COST TO YOU.
To my dear subscribers, thank you all. You have my love and appreciation.
Check out our store! History Merch: ruclips.net/user/TheStudyofAntiquityandtheMiddleAgesstore
Get your history magazines here: www.karwansaraypublishers.com?tap_a=88561-7cbe2d&tap_s=1562085-46f5e5
Enjoy history merchandise? Check out affiliate link to SPQR Emporium!
spqr-emporium.com?aff=3
Get a subscription to Ancient Origins and get access to awesome books, webinars and etc!
Link : members.ancient-origins.net/referral/2f6e132a
*Disclaimer, the above three links are affiliate links which means we will earn a generous commission from your magnificent purchase, just another way to help out the channel!
Facebook Page:
facebook.com/THESTUDYOFANTIQUITYANDTHEMIDDLEAGES/
Twitter: twitter.com/NickBarksdale
Instagram: instagram.com/study_of_antiquity_middle_ages/
Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/164050034145170/
This video was recorded a while back - don't judge my old style to harshly! Regardless of the lack of graphics, Theo did awesome!
One of my favorite subjects. Glad you decided to publish it!
Glad to see it with only relevant pics and not fancy "pretty" graphics.
Minoans weren't Greek. Palace is the word we have, because it's the word we use, lol. Btw, my former student Brent Davis is a leading expert on Linear A
@@louisehitchcock6438 You have no evidence of this. Why this stubborn stance, you decide first and then go out and about to pick and choose evidence to suit your thesis!? SAd.
@@gs032009 language is not Indo European. One piece of evidence is that the script is not well suited to writing Linear B which is Greek and Indo-European. Where is your evidence?
I had a good lunch today, food for the body and mind. I hope I'm around when you guys crack the language. Thx
I deciphered the jade Cretan Hieroglyphic inscription (only seen in the thumbnail?) several years ago. It is a warning to a neighbor, and says:
"I'm am watching you! I have seen you throw three stones and two sticks at my cat. If you mess with my cat again, I will cut off your head."
Interesting and worthwhile video. Thank you, Theo, for posting a link to the open access book on your Twitter page.
This the one i’ve been waiting for.
I like the visuals that are used along with the verbal information.
Great approach! Loved it 💚💚💚
Vinča culture symbols-letters similarity to Linear b..?
Dispilio Tablet..?!
Please cover more writing systems! Indic writing systems such as Brahmi, Vatteluttu and many others!
Interesting. But it seems like vocal fry to that extent would be damaging to the vocal chords
.
Thanks for this, fun listen
Give this dude a Ricola.
Evans could have the title of the last Minos! he resurrected her from Mythology, and revealed her again to the world!
I wonder if there is a relation between these and the dispilio tablet!?
hey what happened to the video that he is debunking? The guy from nebraska?
Would greatly appreciate if you made the ads visible ;) in all videos like this one.
They where all looking for gold... We call them in Greece common thieves... Anglo Saxons common thieves...
There is no Indo-European languages.The Greek language needs thousands of years to reach such levels, and this is evident from the flexibility of the Greek language and its etymologies, the Greek language is a complex language and needs explanation, and it is not easy to grasp its meanings, the Greek language it gives us the cause and the effect.
(principle of causality)
*Mlk stones? Sacrifice stones. Interesting. Now would that be the **_smooth stones from the brook_** typically iron meteorites were which shaped into a 'pillow' or base for an idol?*
*Alternately there is the Arland Tash amulet with the earliest Canaanite dialect inscription circa 7th century BC.*
This is an amazing talk, but the delivery in the vocal fry register is driving me slightly crazy...
This man’s vocal fry is out of control, would have loved this without this man’s voice.
TH 208 X
EO 515 N
NA141 F
SH 198 1:17
This guy has an interesting voice
Natural vocal fry. Young for a whiskey and cigarette baritone.
ΑΝΟΙΧΤΗ ΑΚΑΔΗΜΙΑ ΜΙΝΩΙΚΩΝ ΜΕΛΕΤΩΝ at RUclips
ΑΝΟΙΧΤΗ ΑΚΑΔΗΜΙΑ ΠΡΑΚΤΟΡΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΑΣ ΨΕΥΤΙΚΩΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΩΝ ΑΝΑΚΑΛΥΨΕΩΝ" ΕΝΝΟΕΊΤΕ. ΜΕΛΕΤΗ "ΠΡΟΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΩΝ" ΠΟΛΙΤΙΣΜΩΝ ΠΟΥ ΕΧΤΙΣΑΝ ΤΑ ΤΕΛΕΥΤΑΙΑ 100 ΧΡΟΝΙΑ ΞΕΝΟΙ ΔΗΘΕΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΟΙ" ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΓΙΑ ΝΑ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΙΖΟΥΝ ΟΤΙ ΟΙ ΕΓΓΛΈΖΟΙ ΟΙ ΓΕΡΜΑΝΟΙ ΟΙ ΣΗΜΙΤΕΣ κτλ ΖΟΥΣΑΝ ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΠΡΙΝ ΑΠΌ ΤΟΥΣ ΕΛΛΗΝΕΣ.
ΑΝΟΙΧΤΗ ΑΚΑΔΗΜΙΑ ΠΡΑΚΤΟΡΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΑΣ ΨΕΥΤΙΚΩΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΩΝ ΑΝΑΚΑΛΥΨΕΩΝ" ΕΝΝΟΕΊΤΕ. ΜΕΛΕΤΗ "ΠΡΟΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΩΝ" ΠΟΛΙΤΙΣΜΩΝ ΠΟΥ ΕΧΤΙΣΑΝ ΤΑ ΤΕΛΕΥΤΑΙΑ 100 ΧΡΟΝΙΑ ΞΕΝΟΙ ΔΗΘΕΝ "ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΟΙ" ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΓΙΑ ΝΑ ΠΡΟΠΑΓΑΝΔΙΖΟΥΝ ΟΤΙ ΟΙ ΕΓΓΛΈΖΟΙ ΟΙ ΓΕΡΜΑΝΟΙ ΟΙ ΣΗΜΙΤΕΣ κτλ ΖΟΥΣΑΝ ΣΤΗΝ ΕΛΛΆΔΑ ΠΡΙΝ ΑΠΌ ΤΟΥΣ ΕΛΛΗΝΕΣ.
Lift your voice up out of the glottal.
sadly enough I can not listen to that voice, it hurts my throat
Yeah, if I didn't hear "third year PhD student", I would have thought that he was a two pack-a-day smoker of four decades dying from tuberculosis and throat cancer. He was very informative between the dying sounds, however.
Keep learning Theo before you try and teach
Sunscript -Vinca sript-Slavic today
🤡🤡🤡🤡
Mr Nash's vocal fry is annoying af, but I guess that's the price you have to pay for historical knowledge...
In any decipherment of a script, one first needs to determine if it is alphabetic, syllabic or conceptual. Even hieroglyphs uses a similar format. As sealstones would be pictorial but syllabic especially as a qualifier noun ( name). From there a syllabic interpretation can be assessed. Of course, therein lies the problem of the pronunciation of such syllables as originally spoken. So assuming that h7mans will attempt the easiest possibility, the first person modifiers may be deciphered. Such as a symbol indicating (I) instead of the syllabic name. And from there to a second person reference of the first person ( Me) in many cases, this can lead to a combination of alphabetic and syllabic. The final difficulty comes with the conceptual. This has been inscribed as far back a Nineveh where the use of the word for a Date Palm was used to denote a water raising device. Much as in today’ idioms, we speak and contextually write of a mouse to mean a computer control device as proposed to a small furry rodent. Or as in the Chinese characters, the symbols for two women under one roof, is the symbol for trouble. If one can draw a parallel from a local pronunciation it is better, as has been used for the translation of Mayan hieroglyphs back to a spoken language. As from such usage, contextual usages can be derived. As can grammatical influences.
what?
Very interesting presentation. Pin-Yin as a syllabary for Mandarin is a good example of the creation of a system for a specific language.
Why is this guy croaking?
One thing I’d really love to see in future videos would be maps that show the locations being discussed in that moment. The maps shown don’t usually match up. I can’t overstate how this would enhance the experience of these videos and the quality of learning they provide. Thank you for the work you’re doing.
Awesome Explanaitions! I hope he will explain more in future videos. But since the Tawagalawa-letter mentions a war between Ahhijawa and Hatti, there was at least one Trojan War.
Perhaps using chronology would help.
When did the Greeks come to Crete and from where? Indo European? No such thing. Its Proto Slavic that was used in Crete 7000 BC.Vinca script, Danube civilisation, was living in the Balkans and from Black Sea to the Baltics. I know it’s hard to turn the "truth" around and admit that Barbarians as Greeks called them, where the Civilization long,long,long before Greeks, Etruscans, Latins had any script .
Thanks!👍 Get him on again!⚱
Great video. I’m planning a trip to Crete. What are some places I should definitely visit beyond the tourist locals for historical and visuals?
Rent a car: we made to 26 sites/museums in 11 days. The most important sites besides Knossos are Malia, Sissi, Gournia, Petras (outside Sitia), Palaikastro, Phaistos and Hagia Triada, Tylissos, Diktaian Cave. If you have more time: there are a lot more sites. If you can get ahold of the Blue Guide, it has excellent info; also my book Aegean Art and Architecture. Most important museum is Herakleion.
What are your toughts about Vinca script being the oldest.Etruscan was decifered using Vinca sript. www.ancient-origins.net/ancient-places-europe/danube-valley-civilisation-script-oldest-writing-world-001343
Fascinating and intelligent without gee-whiz distractions. Decades ago my Greek professor taught us, for fun one sunny day, how to do sums in Linear B.
More about this please
I'm going to travei
ook ook
Why are you wearing a hat indoors? Weird
Thanks for the interesting video. I am so fascinated with writing systems of the world. I've even made some.
You already commented about there not being graphics to see the writing systems.