I absolutely love watching people react to Disterbed’s version. That wow moment when they first realise that it’s not what they expected. His vocals and the instrumental arrangement, just an amazing work of art in every way.
You are such perceptive young man. It's been a joy watching you work your way through the various types of music. You picked up on the imagery on the video so quickly. I'm 67 and always loved, and still love, Simon and Garfunkel, but this Disturbed version just touches seems to touch the core of the meaning of this song. It's amazing and just reaches in and grabs your heart. You know what he's saying is true and his anger opens your eyes and you also feel the sadness as you sense what he's saying is true. The video adds hope as the musicians are coming to the silent people with the sheet music. Just beautiful!
65 and a huge S&G fan but this version...it touches a deeper place than the original ever did. Do you think the young ones will heed the warning this time?
David Draiman is a classically trained singer. He was the son of a cantor in a synagogue in Brooklyn, NY. When Disturbed did the live version of this on the “Conan” show in March 2016, Paul Simon happened to catch this cover of his masterpiece (which it is!). He called Draiman to say it was the BEST version he’d ever heard, and it fulfilled his original vision-when Simon wrote it in early 1964. Draiman as (understandably) stunned to get a phone call like that from the songwriter himself!
You are correct about your information except for one thing. David is not trained classically trained. David is trained as a Cantor. He stated that in a interview after his cover of Sound of Silence was released. I love both versions of the song but prefer Disturbd's version more. So powerful !
I think I heard (and this is me trying to remember a comment I read on someone else's reaction video, so take it with a grain of salt) that Paul Simon told David Draiman that when he wrote and recorded the song back in the 60s, it was intended as a warning, and that Disturbed's version updated it to be rage at the people who ignored the warning. I believe he told Draiman, "This is YOUR song now." And yes, I can imagine that Draiman would have been blown away by that conversation!
Back in the day, I thought this song represented people being caught up in the flashiness of trivial pursuits while failing to break the silence about all of the larger injustices in the world. I still do. This cover, to me, brings out the anger that is felt when, some 50 years later, nothing has changed. Thanks for doing this powerful song. ✌❤🌻😷🎶
Oh I can believe it...I feel every one of those years. ...I remember the original well...... the sad part is that it's still relevant. While 50 years ago we were warned...... now we have not headed the warning and look where we are.
i am now 75 y/o. I watched Simon and Garfunkel perform this song in 1969 and loved it so much..... but now I feel just like Dave Draimen feels. What was in 1969 a much-ignored warning has now become an almost too-late call to arms! Wake up, people. Talk to one another! Speak. Restore broken relationships!
I've had this come up on my recommendations a few times and ignored it - being an old hippie and thinking any cover would ruin S & Gs song......but I'm absolutely blown away by what Disturbed did. The song and video are amazing. I loved it!
Isn't that incredible?? I'm old enough to have been a kid when this song came out and was a hit on the radio in the '60s. So, of course, Simon & Garfunkel's original has been, like, THE standard for all of my life ... until I heard this version by Disturbed. It's been very rare in my 60+ years that I can honestly say I felt a cover version of a song was better than the original. I believe I can say so about this. Chilling!
This is the finest cover I have ever heard. Of anything. Breathtaking. Paul Simon posted this cover on his social media after it appeared. He, too, loved it.
Live version on Conan got nominated for a Grammy! I love that live performance. I've seen Disturbed in concert and I have to admit that their performance of this song on Conan's show beats everything I've seen if them....but they are amazing in concert too!!🤘🎸☺
Have to admit, Disturbed did a freaking great take on this song - love the S&G original, love this one. And his voice?! Agree - amazing, powerful and clear as a bell. From melancholy to anger and back again. Love it. Beautiful song interpreted beautifully.
The Simon and Garfunkel version is a struggle against disfunction and isolation. The scenes in this version are an expression of dystopia. This is the Mad Max cover of the original. The Disturbed version is a war to reclaim a broken Earth.
Glad to be back to see/hear you Daniel:) That said, I love Love LOVE that you have chosen to share a music Video, and to be fair, this is one I am so thrilled you chose to experience; as sometimes a visual can bring a song, something else so extraordinary, that it becomes an entirely different experience altogether. When an already recognised, much loved, respected song is covered by a band sharing their interpretation, so often the resulting opinions are mixed, or worse, derided. For one to 'cover' a well revered song is exceptionally brave; to then create a video with it, one meant to challenge, and explore a significantly deeper message, watching as it evolves almost effortlessly is surreal. When one such as this, becomes so powerful, an all encompassing experience that reaches even further than we've already felt when hearing it, and beyond a depth of emotion that we didnt realise existed, or even imagined could be any deeper, is extraordinary. To feel this newly discovered, fathomless level of emotion, viscerally grabbing you, wringing even more, straight from your guts, heart, body and soul in its entirety, only then do we recognise how rare our music treasures are. As such when found, it is an moment in our world of music, worthy, deserving of recognition and to be cherished, shared, preserved. History smiles favourably on extraordinary artists/works, but it is the public NOW who choose, and demand which of those are deemed that honour. That said Daniel, Thank YOU for doing your part in exploring, sharing and preserving our music of this era, as whilst Bach, Beethoven and Brahms had their music installed in the annuals of history, with infinite amounts of pieces created since, only the best, loved, respected deserve a place alongside them...and you are an amazing 'music historian curator' for our times:) well done, and as always, the warmest of regards to you and yours, be safe and stay well. Cheers, Ladybudd
@@cz-27love44 - Finally, a string of people who really watch the video instead of getting stuck in the "warning/anger" cliché that everybody and their mother is repeating. This video relays a message that 90% of the viewers miss or overlook. I've been saying the same thing as you guys since the first time I watched this video (I already knew the original).
They’re a Metal band, that most people tend to dismiss as some of their music is kinda rage-y. But, they’re not afraid to touch some taboo subjects, be it political, social, or religious. The singer, David Draiman, is a classically trained Jewish Cantor. So, a lot of their music touches on a lot of religious meanings. If you would like to hear some of their music, I suggest you check out Remember, Voices, Stupify, Stricken, Down With the Sickness, Prayer, Inside the Fire, The Vengeful One, Who Taught You How to Hate, The Light, Hold on to Memories, If I Ever Lose My Faith in You, A Reason to Fight, Save Our Last Goodbye. David Draiman also has a side band, Device, that’s a Metal band. A couple from that band to check out are Vilify and You think You know. Happy listening. Stay healthy and a Safe. ✌🏻
I grew upknowing the original Simon and Garfunkel version of Sound of Silence. When I saw Disturb's music video of it, I was blown away. Then, I watched/listened to Pentatonix' music video, and I really, really it. It is one of the few songs I know of that has three very different versions and I truly, LOVE all three! Each is hauntingly beautiful in its own way.
Felt the same way, the first time I heard the song. Thankfully I wasn't in a moving vehicle. I'm 65 and loved the original but Disturbed's version gave me chills, goosbumps and brought me to tears. And, still does. My son & grandkids heard this song for years before I did. I tried to share it with them and they all told me I was late to the game. :) They didn't get me listening to the song on a regular basis, lol. Heard it about 5 years ago and am mind blown everytime I hear it! I love to watch reactions of this song in particular. Don't understand people who don't like it.
The first time I listened to it my thought was yeah who do they think they are remaking this classic. After I sat with my mouth open and thought. What the f did I just hear. It has truly become my favorite. My chest still gets tight very time I listen to it.
Classic example of”Never say Never”!!! As a youngster, I Adored S&G,& thought Nobody could Ever make better versions of their songs-it actually never occurred to me, that anyone would try!!! The first time I heard this Cover🤯 and I really Love this better than S&G, even tho I still adore their older works together.
Speechless is the most common first reaction to this song because it brings out the emotion of any living person! Nicely done young man! Thanks for sharing.
For me it's the video that makes this better. The Conan version is still impressive, especially since he was really sick that day, but they added auto tune against his wishes.
I've said this before and I'll say it again... A 1965 song (1964 actually; a story for another time) written by Paul Simon re-imagined by Disturbed in 2015; datz 50 years!! For me, this is by far the best song and cover these past 5 years!! This song literally ambushes you... catches everyone by surprise! The powerhouse vocals, amazing imagery and arrangement, etc... just a great song re-imagined by a Heavy Metal band... done right.
It captures the darkness and foreboding of the original, and his anger that they are not heeding his warning. Paul Simon was so impressed that he put it on his website
He's holding a HELL of a lot back.....LOLOL...ya think??? Incredible voice!! ....from deep,warm and velvety to tenor to rasp ON A DIME and back!!! Unbelievable control !!
"Wow! The frick? Wow! Hmm. Hm. Wow." Exactly the correct reaction. :D The "cover that is even better than the original" thing makes me want to request a couple of MandoPop songs that do that. But, of course, you focus on lyrics, and don't speak Chinese, so I won't do that. And I won't fall back on Dramarama (this time). Instead, we'll go with Guns 'n' Roses' "Sweet Child O' Mine". If you don't know the original, then do that, and follow it with the cover by Taken By Trees. (ruclips.net/video/6dqVDQ-lF4Q/видео.html)
I took your suggestion and listened to your recommendation. As a rocker but lover of all types of music the Taken By Trees cover does not compare to the original by Guns n' Roses. It's an okay, watered down version of a rock song. Disturbed's version of the beloved song Sound Silence is at the very least just as good if not better than the original because of the haunting, powerful tone of David Dramain's voice. Nothing about Taken by Trees version of Sweet Child O' Mine makes it special to me. I do understand though why some people would like it though.
@@emmef7970 In my view, the best way to do a cover is to bring a different take to it. Taken By Trees' version is not intended to be a rock song the way the original was, but to bring out the longing emotion in a different way. The tough part of that is that people come in wanting the original. It didn't work for you, and fair enough. You could be right that it's "watered down", or that view could reflect your preference for rock and "hard" sounds, as implied by your view that Disturbed's take on Simon & Garfunkel is superior to the original. It is, after all, a harder, more "rock" sound, and closer to your stated preferences; whereas Taken by Trees moved away from a rocking sound in their cover. I will say that I didn't mean to imply that Taken By Trees' version was better, simply that the idea of a cover improving on the original brought it to mind as a song Daniel might want to compare; that was a mistake on my part, and I ought to have been clearer.
I'm with you, Daniel. I grew up with S&G's original, which I love. But this interpretation is so much more powerful. I do prefer it over the original. I also agree that this video is better than the live performance on Conan; it hits more powerfully with the images they chose to portray. But, I feel now you're ready to watch the live performance. It is also a fantastic performance. After seeing this, and learning that David Draiman was trained and ordained as Jewish Cantor/liturgical prayer leader, I did look up some of their other tracks. Metal just isn't for me. But, I do like their cover of Land of Confusion, and feel their video has aged much better than Genesis' video (which focuses on Ronald Reagan) has. I would love to see a comparison of both. I don't think I've reached your reaction to Land of Confusion in my viewing of your back log yet; I'll have to see if you reacted to an audible version, or the official video for it.
I always wait for the wow when watching reactions to this cover. Never disappointed! Your analysis was insightful compared to most on this video. Grew up with Simon And Garfunkel's version, and absolutely love it! But this version is so much more moving. Each great in their own way.
I'm old so I will always have a soft spot in my heart for the amazing classic Simon and Garfunkel version, but I have to admit Disturbed does a fantastic cover of their song. Both songs are great! Thank you for your reaction!!
Amazing reaction, you were so sceptical to this I just loved seeing you going . Both versions are perfect in their own way, S&G really friggin saw the future. Since you liked this you should watch their live version from Conan I believe. Super hugs from Sweden
Great reaction, Daniel! A friend of mine from Great Britain turned me on to this cover; she's a metal head (so to speak), and I was leery of hearing ANYONE covering this masterpiece. Well, color me stunned- took my breath away. Disturbed did an unreal job of expressing the emotions this song evokes, so highest kudos to them! Thanks, Daniel!
Disturbed, David delivered the message to me. S and G never couldn't. Their version was background noise all those years. David MADE me listen to the lyrics and it's beautiful and so so true. I cried my eyes out......the anger.......we don't listen...... We need to really communicate, speak and listen. No tv, no phones, laptops, tablets...... Face to face.........soeak....LISTEN.....
Great reaction...I would love to hear u react to Dimash...I think youd do it justice. This was an amazing song to react to & u did it justice. Thank u.
Bad Wolves did an excellent cover of the Cranberries song Zombie. Disturbed: Try Stricken first. Most will drive you to Down With the Sickness, but that one is heavy subject matter and may be better for a second song. At least look at the lyrics before. Just FYI, I am not saying this because your young either. I have seen other reactors react to that song and the shock value overrides getting to know the band because they get caught up in what he is saying. They also did a nice cover of Genesis's Land of Confusion.
@Mirikka Yes, the bad wolves cover of Zombie was't bad, but I can't see it without crying when you learn that Delores O'Riordan (Cranberries) was supposed to be there and record with them, but she chose that day to depart the earth.
Sound of Silence is one of my favorite songs all time (though there are times when I cannot bear to listen to it). I was worried when I first heard of this cover (not being a Disturbed fan), but I think they did a fantastic job, and I like it almost as much as the original. There is a live video around of them performing this live (on Conan O'Brian I think) and his is almost perfect live.
I think the Sound of Silence this is one of the great lyrics of the 60s. In some ways it's enigmatic, but it's poetic, introspective and the part about people failing to communicate resonates powerfully to this VERY DAY. I don't think America has been as polarized as it is today since the Civil War. What is it about human beings? Why can't we LISTEN to what other people are saying. Paul Simon captured that so beautifully in this lyric. I was excited when I saw your were going to listen to this song because I knew you would pick up on what a monumental piece of artistry it is. The blend of lyrics and music is perfect. I can't wait for you to listen to BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER by Simon and Garfunkel. It's their signature masterpiece, with Art Garfunkel singing the lyrics. At first almost at a whisper and ending with thundering vocal power. Simple lyrics conveying profound compassion.
Love this song. Been around live and studio music for 50 years and have never come across a song as great as this one. I love how they use Silence in the opening scene and that in itself is powerful. I like how when the get to the scene with the music being written they even made sure the note being written is in the upward moving direction just as is his voice too so that was a nicely added touch. I doubt that was a random fluke , feel it was meant to add the visual equivalent of his voice going up. A Stellar song this is.
I love that this version left you speechless and gave you a goose bump sweater!!! That is a person that truly loves music!!! Keep up the great job my friend!!
I agree. This cover is one of the few that actually top the original. Well, the visuals help. So does the trained voice. And the instrumentation. From a gentler time - here we are 50+ years later, in a place where silence is impossible to achieve. Yet so much in need of music.
Powerful visual to the song ..One shore has the sheet music...the other shore has the instruments...and they were separated by the sound of silence....until they built a boat and crossed to meet.
- loved your genuine reaction. most reactors are listening without hearing and talking without speaking -Draiman covers roughly two-and-a-half octaves from bottom to top. His vocals are so distinctive. -Disturbed had been nominated for a GRAMMY for Best Rock Performance for their rendition of "The Sound of Silence" while appearing on Conan. -David Draiman: "The fact that I was sick as a dog (laughs). I remember I was definitely fighting something off, but it was a cool experience. It was cool performing with an actual orchestra. It was really vibing and the mood helped, I think, enhance the delivery. The stars just aligned that night and everything went right." - How Paul Simon Felt To Have Disturbed Transform Classic Song to Heavy Metal ruclips.net/video/ntNfwoKD0XA/видео.html -
I loved the original; still do. Disturbed's version gave me chills, and brought tears to my eyes. They stayed true to the original while giving it their own spin. And, David Draiman has an incredible voice; you can hear the training...and, practice! As you said, I listen to both now.
I have always been a huge Simon and Garfunkle fan. I love everything of theirs I ever heard. This cover is the first time I have ever liked a version as well as the original. I can't compare them. I like them differently and equally in different ways. I enjoyed watching your reaction as he took it up a notch at the end. When you stopped the video to discuss right before they got to that part, I thought "NO KEEP GOING YOU ARE ABOUT TO GET BLOWN AWAY!"
Loved this song forever, the original is so haunting. When a band like Disturbed offered up a cover, I said NO, but I had to listen. I was blown out of the water when I first heard this, and every time since. I grew up with the original, so it still gives me goosebumps, but this one makes me wanna change the world!
This version is so powerful and profound!!! His voice is angelic!!! The video is amazing... the Instrumentals are wonderful... this song speaks to your soul!!
What struck me (a first listen to this version myself) was the juxtapositions between the high voices of S&G vs. the lower, quiet beginning of this; the guitar vs. the piano; but most of all his older, wiser, weathered face next to your bright, innocent one. Your expressions moved together and opposite during the whole song, age and youth, cynicism and hope. Absolutely powerful and breathtaking. I hope the band sees this!
I enjoy both the versions... I grew up listening to Simon and Garfunkel... and Disturbed is one of my favorite bands. Disturbed's version gives me the chills. If you are going to delve into Disturbed... My personal favorites are Fear... and Inside the Fire... which from the stance of a mother kills me when I hear it.
I've watched over a dozen of these response videos from other professionals(I just love watching the transition from mildly skeptic to outright hostile at the very thought that someone could attempt to cover such an iconic song, myself included.) and there is always the "WOW" moment sometimes at the very first notes, the third verse, and or the end. This is one off the most evocative songs I've ever heard. It goes straight to the heart and left me in absolute awe. Beautiful song Amazing cover
You're the best! I really like the way you get the full meaning of the music and the lyrics. My favorite part is when you look up the song facts. I usually learn something new from you even if I'm really familiar with the song and artist!
Great reaction, enjoyed watching and hearing you comments. The drums really gave it that depth and haunting... wonderful combination of instruments and timing.
Your state of speechlessness was the perfect reaction to this cover! It hits me every single time I hear it. Both S&G and Disturbed's versions are so powerful, but in different ways. I grew up with the original, and love both versions, but I think the raw emotion and intense energy of the cover resonates a bit more for me.
Hey, Daniel. Loved the comparison. There truly is something to appreciate about both versions. Being born in 1964, the original is one of the earliest songs I remember from childhood, but Disturbed succeeds - as you pointed out - in making the song their own. This seems to have resonated with Paul Simon himself - always a good sign when the songwriter endorses a cover. I was hoping you would realize that the "Words of the prophets..." line was picked up and rephrased by Neil Peart for the Rush song "The Spirit of Radio." Neil was always using literary references in his lyrics and found Simon's lyric an appropriate passage to adapt to the theme of a music industry that sometimes refuses to listen and is governed frequently by their own "neon gods." Peart's lyric says, “For the words of the profits are written on the studio wall, concert hall - Echoes with the sounds… of salesmen.” I always loved the connection between two of my favorite (though very different) songs. Some other great covers you might review: Mr. Soul (Buffalo Springfield, Rush), Higher Ground (Stevie Wonder, Red Hot Chili Peppers), (I Know) I'm Losing You (Temptations, The Faces), Black Magic Woman (Fleetwood Mac, Santana - make sure to do the full version with Gypsy Queen for Santana), All Along the Watchtower (Bob Dylan, Jimi Hendrix - might have to use a live version of Hendrix to avoid blocking), Hazy Shade of Winter (Simon & Garfunkel, The Bangles), You Better Run (The Rascals, Pat Benatar), or for a laugh, how about Crazy Train (Ozzy Osborne, Pat Boone). That last one should make your head spin. Enjoy!
Over a month since my last comment, but Daniel, loving music is one thing, loving music and being able to share our emotions and feelings about it is such an extraordinary healing thing...if more people were able to know and share like you do, they would understand how music sharing impacts MH issues. Love you and your sharing!:) XXX
Such a departure for Disturbed, and David Draiman's voice shines in this. The live version from one of the late night shows (can't remember which) is amazing. So powerful.
I first heard Disturbed’s Down With the Sickness years ago, when my son played it for me. He was startled when I burst into tears and asked why I was crying. How can you not cry at that brilliant, gut wrenching song? It walks you through the destruction of a child’s soul from years of abuse until he’s devoured whole. This cover of Simon & Garfunkel’s beautiful and important song has the same depth. David Draiman is incredible.
It is almost apocalyptic, with the anger building, raindrops? An ark at the end, saving the instruments of sound. Live this version, love the arrangement and the video production, so haunting, sad and powerful.
![FIRST EVER REACTION - Disturbed - The Sound Of Silence [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YOHPvfaRoSU/mqdefault.jpg)
I absolutely love watching people react to Disterbed’s version. That wow moment when they first realise that it’s not what they expected. His vocals and the instrumental arrangement, just an amazing work of art in every way.
Loved it when you said “it sounds like he’s holding so much back” because I knew what’s to come, great reaction
I was thinking the same thing.
Even then he held back.
My first thought was 'buckle up buttercup! you are in for an emotional ride!'
You are such perceptive young man. It's been a joy watching you work your way through the various types of music. You picked up on the imagery on the video so quickly. I'm 67 and always loved, and still love, Simon and Garfunkel, but this Disturbed version just touches seems to touch the core of the meaning of this song. It's amazing and just reaches in and grabs your heart. You know what he's saying is true and his anger opens your eyes and you also feel the sadness as you sense what he's saying is true. The video adds hope as the musicians are coming to the silent people with the sheet music. Just beautiful!
I'm 74 years old. I get chills every time listening to this version.
No kidding!!!!!goosebumps lol
Can you play Janis Joplin's songs. Thanks👍
64 here is yes we most certainly do
65 and a huge S&G fan but this version...it touches a deeper place than the original ever did. Do you think the young ones will heed the warning this time?
I can’t stop watching it 👍♥️
David Draiman is a classically trained singer. He was the son of a cantor in a synagogue in Brooklyn, NY. When Disturbed did the live version of this on the “Conan” show in March 2016, Paul Simon happened to catch this cover of his masterpiece (which it is!). He called Draiman to say it was the BEST version he’d ever heard, and it fulfilled his original vision-when Simon wrote it in early 1964. Draiman as (understandably) stunned to get a phone call like that from the songwriter himself!
You are correct about your information except for one thing. David is not trained classically trained. David is trained as a Cantor. He stated that in a interview after his cover of Sound of Silence was released. I love both versions of the song but prefer Disturbd's version more. So powerful !
I think I heard (and this is me trying to remember a comment I read on someone else's reaction video, so take it with a grain of salt) that Paul Simon told David Draiman that when he wrote and recorded the song back in the 60s, it was intended as a warning, and that Disturbed's version updated it to be rage at the people who ignored the warning. I believe he told Draiman, "This is YOUR song now." And yes, I can imagine that Draiman would have been blown away by that conversation!
Showing that both men had a huge amount of class and respect.
@@LoriPeace Not only That, But Paul Simon put this on his PLAY List!!!
@@tinapatterson5022 Amazing!!
Simon and Garfunkel's version was a warning , Disturbed version is the anger that we didn't listen.........
Excellent
Yes @Michael Rice ! You said it so much more succinctly than I did. 👍
Perfect
..and Pentatonix offers a challenge to make a better world. Listen to them for the trifecta.
@@michaelmichalski1818 if they're not using computers to alter their voices then they're not human. NO CLUE how they sing like that.
I grew up on the original. But this version puts the full meaning of the song into it. The video made it even more intense.
This cover got Paul Simon's stamp of approval and he really likes Disturbed's take on it.
Exactly wow...so many emotions.great reaction.
Back in the day, I thought this song represented people being caught up in the flashiness of trivial pursuits while failing to break the silence about all of the larger injustices in the world.
I still do. This cover, to me, brings out the anger that is felt when, some 50 years later, nothing has changed. Thanks for doing this powerful song. ✌❤🌻😷🎶
AMEN I couldn't agree more.
Exactly
50 years after the Simon & Garfunkel's version. Who can believe it's 50 years?
Makes me feel old!
It's more relevant now than when it was written.
Oh I can believe it...I feel every one of those years. ...I remember the original well...... the sad part is that it's still relevant. While 50 years ago we were warned...... now we have not headed the warning and look where we are.
i am now 75 y/o. I watched Simon and Garfunkel perform this song in 1969 and loved it so much..... but now I feel just like Dave Draimen feels. What was in 1969 a much-ignored warning has now become an almost too-late call to arms! Wake up, people. Talk to one another! Speak. Restore broken relationships!
I've had this come up on my recommendations a few times and ignored it - being an old hippie and thinking any cover would ruin S & Gs song......but I'm absolutely blown away by what Disturbed did. The song and video are amazing. I loved it!
watch the live version they did on Conan... his voice !!!!!!!!!!!! WOW.
I have to excuse you, you're Canadian and do not know any better. Altho you should, you people gave us Rush for gods sake!!!!
@@prprod Sorry, eh.....lol
Isn't that incredible?? I'm old enough to have been a kid when this song came out and was a hit on the radio in the '60s. So, of course, Simon & Garfunkel's original has been, like, THE standard for all of my life ... until I heard this version by Disturbed. It's been very rare in my 60+ years that I can honestly say I felt a cover version of a song was better than the original. I believe I can say so about this. Chilling!
Me also!
I'm right there with you E. Daniel. This is a phenomenal cover!
SAME!
Same here! I can listen to this version over and over and over.
I'm as old as you are Daniel, and I had the very same reaction to this cover when I heard it.
I'm 62 years old and this is my first time hearing this version. Absolutely Awesome!
This is the finest cover I have ever heard. Of anything. Breathtaking.
Paul Simon posted this cover on his social media after it appeared. He, too, loved it.
Covers of hits often fall short. This one stands on its own.
Live version on Conan got nominated for a Grammy! I love that live performance. I've seen Disturbed in concert and I have to admit that their performance of this song on Conan's show beats everything I've seen if them....but they are amazing in concert too!!🤘🎸☺
David has one of the most beautiful powerful voices ever ❤️🌹
Have to admit, Disturbed did a freaking great take on this song - love the S&G original, love this one. And his voice?! Agree - amazing, powerful and clear as a bell. From melancholy to anger and back again. Love it. Beautiful song interpreted beautifully.
The Simon and Garfunkel version is a struggle against disfunction and isolation. The scenes in this version are an expression of dystopia. This is the Mad Max cover of the original. The Disturbed version is a war to reclaim a broken Earth.
Glad to be back to see/hear you Daniel:) That said, I love Love LOVE that you have chosen to share a music Video, and to be fair, this is one I am so thrilled you chose to experience; as sometimes a visual can bring a song, something else so extraordinary, that it becomes an entirely different experience altogether. When an already recognised, much loved, respected song is covered by a band sharing their interpretation, so often the resulting opinions are mixed, or worse, derided. For one to 'cover' a well revered song is exceptionally brave; to then create a video with it, one meant to challenge, and explore a significantly deeper message, watching as it evolves almost effortlessly is surreal. When one such as this, becomes so powerful, an all encompassing experience that reaches even further than we've already felt when hearing it, and beyond a depth of emotion that we didnt realise existed, or even imagined could be any deeper, is extraordinary. To feel this newly discovered, fathomless level of emotion, viscerally grabbing you, wringing even more, straight from your guts, heart, body and soul in its entirety, only then do we recognise how rare our music treasures are. As such when found, it is an moment in our world of music, worthy, deserving of recognition and to be cherished, shared, preserved. History smiles favourably on extraordinary artists/works, but it is the public NOW who choose, and demand which of those are deemed that honour. That said Daniel, Thank YOU for doing your part in exploring, sharing and preserving our music of this era, as whilst Bach, Beethoven and Brahms had their music installed in the annuals of history, with infinite amounts of pieces created since, only the best, loved, respected deserve a place alongside them...and you are an amazing 'music historian curator' for our times:) well done, and as always, the warmest of regards to you and yours, be safe and stay well. Cheers, Ladybudd
Finally someone understands it.... You get it.. All the ones I've viewed on the first time watching , You understand it.. Love it!!
To me, the boat at the end is an ark whose passengers are bringing sounds to the silent and to rebuild the world.
Exactly my thoughts too!!😷🇬🇧
I’m seeing one side has the music and the other side has the words. At the end they bring them together.
@@cz-27love44 - Finally, a string of people who really watch the video instead of getting stuck in the "warning/anger" cliché that everybody and their mother is repeating. This video relays a message that 90% of the viewers miss or overlook. I've been saying the same thing as you guys since the first time I watched this video (I already knew the original).
Exactly, well stated .
S&G said it's about people not communicating anymore. It was a warning...this version is anger no one is listening!
Honestly I had never heard of this guy, but this version kicks ass
It's not a "guy", it's a band.
@@Module79L Never heard of this band either, but the guy’s voice is the feature
They’re a Metal band, that most people tend to dismiss as some of their music is kinda rage-y. But, they’re not afraid to touch some taboo subjects, be it political, social, or religious. The singer, David Draiman, is a classically trained Jewish Cantor. So, a lot of their music touches on a lot of religious meanings. If you would like to hear some of their music, I suggest you check out Remember, Voices, Stupify, Stricken, Down With the Sickness, Prayer, Inside the Fire, The Vengeful One, Who Taught You How to Hate, The Light, Hold on to Memories, If I Ever Lose My Faith in You, A Reason to Fight, Save Our Last Goodbye. David Draiman also has a side band, Device, that’s a Metal band. A couple from that band to check out are Vilify and You think You know. Happy listening. Stay healthy and a Safe. ✌🏻
I grew upknowing the original Simon and Garfunkel version of Sound of Silence. When I saw Disturb's music video of it, I was blown away. Then, I watched/listened to Pentatonix' music video, and I really, really it. It is one of the few songs I know of that has three very different versions and I truly, LOVE all three! Each is hauntingly beautiful in its own way.
Paul Simon said this is how the song should be song. He called Dave and told him David the song belongs to you now!
The wonderful thing is that you don't have to pick one version. Enjoy all versions for what they are. I love the passion in his voice on this version.
He sang i listened, then i said thank you...
I remember driving down a winding road the first time I heard this version, literally almost crashed, tears in my eyes. Absolutely mind blowing!
Felt the same way, the first time I heard the song. Thankfully I wasn't in a moving vehicle. I'm 65 and loved the original but Disturbed's version gave me chills, goosbumps and brought me to tears. And, still does. My son & grandkids heard this song for years before I did. I tried to share it with them and they all told me I was late to the game. :) They didn't get me listening to the song on a regular basis, lol. Heard it about 5 years ago and am mind blown everytime I hear it! I love to watch reactions of this song in particular. Don't understand people who don't like it.
@@emmef7970 Emme all you can do is shake your head. I love this version, and the original too. The power of this version is awesome!
The first time I listened to it my thought was yeah who do they think they are remaking this classic. After I sat with my mouth open and thought. What the f did I just hear. It has truly become my favorite. My chest still gets tight very time I listen to it.
Classic example of”Never say Never”!!! As a youngster, I Adored S&G,& thought Nobody could Ever make better versions of their songs-it actually never occurred to me, that anyone would try!!! The first time I heard this Cover🤯 and I really Love this better than S&G, even tho I still adore their older works together.
Speechless is the most common first reaction to this song because it brings out the emotion of any living person! Nicely done young man! Thanks for sharing.
the people on the other side of the river are holding sheet music! the band is sailing over with their instruments.
I am so happy you did this versus the Conan version this is so much better. I enjoy it a lot
For me it's the video that makes this better. The Conan version is still impressive, especially since he was really sick that day, but they added auto tune against his wishes.
I've said this before and I'll say it again... A 1965 song (1964 actually; a story for another time) written by Paul Simon re-imagined by Disturbed in 2015; datz 50 years!! For me, this is by far the best song and cover these past 5 years!! This song literally ambushes you... catches everyone by surprise! The powerhouse vocals, amazing imagery and arrangement, etc... just a great song re-imagined by a Heavy Metal band... done right.
This is probably the greatest cover version in the world, absolutely stunning.
Loved watching your reactions Dude😌
"Simon and Garfunkel's version was a warning. Disturbed's version is rage because the warning was ignored."
He does rage really well.
"The Best" explanation of the true difference- said with the fewest words, "perfectly".
also, Paul Simon wrote a pretty, quiet, sad song. Careful. Most indicative of the style and sounds of the 60s. David Draiman blows the doors off.
What a voice. Yes powerful.
It captures the darkness and foreboding of the original, and his anger that they are not heeding his warning. Paul Simon was so impressed that he put it on his website
He's holding a HELL of a lot back.....LOLOL...ya think??? Incredible voice!! ....from deep,warm and velvety to tenor to rasp ON A DIME and back!!! Unbelievable control !!
"Wow! The frick? Wow! Hmm. Hm. Wow."
Exactly the correct reaction. :D
The "cover that is even better than the original" thing makes me want to request a couple of MandoPop songs that do that. But, of course, you focus on lyrics, and don't speak Chinese, so I won't do that. And I won't fall back on Dramarama (this time). Instead, we'll go with Guns 'n' Roses' "Sweet Child O' Mine". If you don't know the original, then do that, and follow it with the cover by Taken By Trees. (ruclips.net/video/6dqVDQ-lF4Q/видео.html)
I took your suggestion and listened to your recommendation. As a rocker but lover of all types of music the Taken By Trees cover does not compare to the original by Guns n' Roses. It's an okay, watered down version of a rock song. Disturbed's version of the beloved song Sound Silence is at the very least just as good if not better than the original because of the haunting, powerful tone of David Dramain's voice. Nothing about Taken by Trees version of Sweet Child O' Mine makes it special to me. I do understand though why some people would like it though.
@@emmef7970 In my view, the best way to do a cover is to bring a different take to it. Taken By Trees' version is not intended to be a rock song the way the original was, but to bring out the longing emotion in a different way. The tough part of that is that people come in wanting the original. It didn't work for you, and fair enough. You could be right that it's "watered down", or that view could reflect your preference for rock and "hard" sounds, as implied by your view that Disturbed's take on Simon & Garfunkel is superior to the original. It is, after all, a harder, more "rock" sound, and closer to your stated preferences; whereas Taken by Trees moved away from a rocking sound in their cover.
I will say that I didn't mean to imply that Taken By Trees' version was better, simply that the idea of a cover improving on the original brought it to mind as a song Daniel might want to compare; that was a mistake on my part, and I ought to have been clearer.
I'm with you, Daniel. I grew up with S&G's original, which I love. But this interpretation is so much more powerful. I do prefer it over the original.
I also agree that this video is better than the live performance on Conan; it hits more powerfully with the images they chose to portray. But, I feel now you're ready to watch the live performance. It is also a fantastic performance.
After seeing this, and learning that David Draiman was trained and ordained as Jewish Cantor/liturgical prayer leader, I did look up some of their other tracks. Metal just isn't for me. But, I do like their cover of Land of Confusion, and feel their video has aged much better than Genesis' video (which focuses on Ronald Reagan) has. I would love to see a comparison of both. I don't think I've reached your reaction to Land of Confusion in my viewing of your back log yet; I'll have to see if you reacted to an audible version, or the official video for it.
I always wait for the wow when watching reactions to this cover. Never disappointed!
Your analysis was insightful compared to most on this video.
Grew up with Simon And Garfunkel's version, and absolutely love it! But this version is so much more moving. Each great in their own way.
Love the way this builds. Probably the most powerful version I've heard. Very impressive. Great reaction thanks for sharing
I'm old so I will always have a soft spot in my heart for the amazing classic Simon and Garfunkel version, but I have to admit Disturbed does a fantastic cover of their song. Both songs are great! Thank you for your reaction!!
Amazing reaction, you were so sceptical to this I just loved seeing you going . Both versions are perfect in their own way, S&G really friggin saw the future. Since you liked this you should watch their live version from Conan I believe. Super hugs from Sweden
Great reaction, Daniel! A friend of mine from Great Britain turned me on to this cover; she's a metal head (so to speak), and I was leery of hearing ANYONE covering this masterpiece. Well, color me stunned- took my breath away. Disturbed did an unreal job of expressing the emotions this song evokes, so highest kudos to them! Thanks, Daniel!
The explicit version of 'down with the sickness' from Disturbed is one of their most iconic songs. Great reaction here!
Disturbed version was more disturbing. (Pun intended) You can do Hazy Shade of Winter by S&G and cover by The Bangles.
I know you from your Dimash's reaction and I subscribe because of this reaction.. keep continue young man...
Disturbed, David delivered the message to me.
S and G never couldn't. Their version was background noise all those years.
David MADE me listen to the lyrics and it's beautiful and so so true.
I cried my eyes out......the anger.......we don't listen......
We need to really communicate, speak and listen.
No tv, no phones, laptops, tablets......
Face to face.........soeak....LISTEN.....
I've watched so many of these reactions to this version of the song but this chap really gets it. There is one note and most don't notice it. He did.
Great reaction...I would love to hear u react to Dimash...I think youd do it justice. This was an amazing song to react to & u did it justice. Thank u.
Bad Wolves did an excellent cover of the Cranberries song Zombie.
Disturbed: Try Stricken first.
Most will drive you to Down With the Sickness, but that one is heavy subject matter and may be better for a second song. At least look at the lyrics before. Just FYI, I am not saying this because your young either. I have seen other reactors react to that song and the shock value overrides getting to know the band because they get caught up in what he is saying. They also did a nice cover of Genesis's Land of Confusion.
@Mirikka Yes, the bad wolves cover of Zombie was't bad, but I can't see it without crying when you learn that Delores O'Riordan (Cranberries) was supposed to be there and record with them, but she chose that day to depart the earth.
Agree, he really should do this as well!
Like both versions too... Disturbed so powerful! BTW nice Yes Shirt :)
The imagery is so haunting and beautiful
Sound of Silence is one of my favorite songs all time (though there are times when I cannot bear to listen to it). I was worried when I first heard of this cover (not being a Disturbed fan), but I think they did a fantastic job, and I like it almost as much as the original.
There is a live video around of them performing this live (on Conan O'Brian I think) and his is almost perfect live.
Simon and Garfunkel told him that it was his song now. Even they knew....
I think the Sound of Silence this is one of the great lyrics of the 60s. In some ways it's enigmatic, but it's poetic, introspective and the part about people failing to communicate resonates powerfully to this VERY DAY. I don't think America has been as polarized as it is today since the Civil War. What is it about human beings? Why can't we LISTEN to what other people are saying. Paul Simon captured that so beautifully in this lyric. I was excited when I saw your were going to listen to this song because I knew you would pick up on what a monumental piece of artistry it is. The blend of lyrics and music is perfect. I can't wait for you to listen to BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER by Simon and Garfunkel. It's their signature masterpiece, with Art Garfunkel singing the lyrics. At first almost at a whisper and ending with thundering vocal power. Simple lyrics conveying profound compassion.
The Disturbed's version set my emotions on fire. Simon and Garfunkel's version left me feeling at peace. When I should not have felt such a way.
Hi..I’m new..this is my favourite version of this song as well..it’s so powerful n his voice is amazing..love ur reaction.
Love this song. Been around live and studio music for 50 years and have never come across a song as great as this one. I love how they use Silence in the opening scene and that in itself is powerful.
I like how when the get to the scene with the music being written they even made sure the note being written is in the upward moving direction just as is his voice too so that was a nicely added touch. I doubt that was a random fluke , feel it was meant to add the visual equivalent of his voice going up.
A Stellar song this is.
I love that this version left you speechless and gave you a goose bump sweater!!! That is a person that truly loves music!!! Keep up the great job my friend!!
This is a powerful interpretation of the song. I do love it, but S&G's version will always be my favourite, mostly because I grew up with it.
I agree. This cover is one of the few that actually top the original. Well, the visuals help. So does the trained voice. And the instrumentation. From a gentler time - here we are 50+ years later, in a place where silence is impossible to achieve. Yet so much in need of music.
I'm so glad you had previously reacted to the original version. Most reactors do it backwards, and miss out on so much.
Powerful visual to the song ..One shore has the sheet music...the other shore has the instruments...and they were separated by the sound of silence....until they built a boat and crossed to meet.
Bingo! Exactly!
- loved your genuine reaction. most reactors are listening without hearing and talking without speaking
-Draiman covers roughly two-and-a-half octaves from bottom to top. His vocals are so distinctive.
-Disturbed had been nominated for a GRAMMY for Best Rock Performance for their rendition of "The Sound of Silence" while appearing on Conan.
-David Draiman: "The fact that I was sick as a dog (laughs). I remember I was definitely fighting something off, but it was a cool experience. It was cool performing with an actual orchestra. It was really vibing and the mood helped, I think, enhance the delivery. The stars just aligned that night and everything went right."
- How Paul Simon Felt To Have Disturbed Transform Classic Song to Heavy Metal ruclips.net/video/ntNfwoKD0XA/видео.html
-
Best reaction !! Thank you for listening.
Watching your face as you experience this masterpiece might be the best part of my day.
You really hit it all. Thank you for a thorough and enjoyable reaction. Appreciate your unique approach and can’t wait to see more
I loved the original; still do. Disturbed's version gave me chills, and brought tears to my eyes. They stayed true to the original while giving it their own spin. And, David Draiman has an incredible voice; you can hear the training...and, practice! As you said, I listen to both now.
I so enjoy watching young adults appreciate music like the way you do!!!!!! It gives me faith for the future!! xoxoxo
I have always been a huge Simon and Garfunkle fan. I love everything of theirs I ever heard. This cover is the first time I have ever liked a version as well as the original. I can't compare them. I like them differently and equally in different ways. I enjoyed watching your reaction as he took it up a notch at the end. When you stopped the video to discuss right before they got to that part, I thought "NO KEEP GOING YOU ARE ABOUT TO GET BLOWN AWAY!"
Loved this song forever, the original is so haunting. When a band like Disturbed offered up a cover, I said NO, but I had to listen. I was blown out of the water when I first heard this, and every time since. I grew up with the original, so it still gives me goosebumps, but this one makes me wanna change the world!
This version is so powerful and profound!!! His voice is angelic!!! The video is amazing... the Instrumentals are wonderful... this song speaks to your soul!!
Your reaction was beautiful
I really love your innocent prospective …. It’s so nice to see. 🤍
What struck me (a first listen to this version myself) was the juxtapositions between the high voices of S&G vs. the lower, quiet beginning of this; the guitar vs. the piano; but most of all his older, wiser, weathered face next to your bright, innocent one. Your expressions moved together and opposite during the whole song, age and youth, cynicism and hope. Absolutely powerful and breathtaking. I hope the band sees this!
I enjoy both the versions... I grew up listening to Simon and Garfunkel... and Disturbed is one of my favorite bands. Disturbed's version gives me the chills. If you are going to delve into Disturbed... My personal favorites are Fear... and Inside the Fire... which from the stance of a mother kills me when I hear it.
I've watched over a dozen of these response videos from other professionals(I just love watching the transition from mildly skeptic to outright hostile at the very thought that someone could attempt to cover such an iconic song, myself included.) and there is always the "WOW" moment sometimes at the very first notes, the third verse, and or the end.
This is one off the most evocative songs I've ever heard. It goes straight to the heart and left me in absolute awe.
Beautiful song
Amazing cover
You're the best! I really like the way you get the full meaning of the music and the lyrics. My favorite part is when you look up the song facts. I usually learn something new from you even if I'm really familiar with the song and artist!
A REASON TO FIGHT by DISTURBED !! i have no words
Great reaction, enjoyed watching and hearing you comments.
The drums really gave it that depth and haunting... wonderful combination of instruments and timing.
The Reaction from you is so similar like mine i heard this Version for the first Time.It can be seen you are so touched by this Song.....WOW!!
I can't pick one.They both give you emotions and that's what a good song does.Love both for different reasons.
Your state of speechlessness was the perfect reaction to this cover! It hits me every single time I hear it. Both S&G and Disturbed's versions are so powerful, but in different ways. I grew up with the original, and love both versions, but I think the raw emotion and intense energy of the cover resonates a bit more for me.
Oh my good sir, please listen to this on repeat....this song both fuels my soul, and heals it at the same time.
So glad you as a young person actually took the time to listen to the original! Great job!
Hey, Daniel. Loved the comparison. There truly is something to appreciate about both versions. Being born in 1964, the original is one of the earliest songs I remember from childhood, but Disturbed succeeds - as you pointed out - in making the song their own. This seems to have resonated with Paul Simon himself - always a good sign when the songwriter endorses a cover. I was hoping you would realize that the "Words of the prophets..." line was picked up and rephrased by Neil Peart for the Rush song "The Spirit of Radio." Neil was always using literary references in his lyrics and found Simon's lyric an appropriate passage to adapt to the theme of a music industry that sometimes refuses to listen and is governed frequently by their own "neon gods." Peart's lyric says, “For the words of the profits are written on the studio wall, concert hall - Echoes with the sounds… of salesmen.” I always loved the connection between two of my favorite (though very different) songs. Some other great covers you might review: Mr. Soul (Buffalo Springfield, Rush), Higher Ground (Stevie Wonder, Red Hot Chili Peppers), (I Know) I'm Losing You (Temptations, The Faces), Black Magic Woman (Fleetwood Mac, Santana - make sure to do the full version with Gypsy Queen for Santana), All Along the Watchtower (Bob Dylan, Jimi Hendrix - might have to use a live version of Hendrix to avoid blocking), Hazy Shade of Winter (Simon & Garfunkel, The Bangles), You Better Run (The Rascals, Pat Benatar), or for a laugh, how about Crazy Train (Ozzy Osborne, Pat Boone). That last one should make your head spin. Enjoy!
This is so much more passionate and deep! The FEELS and vibes are beyond.
Love your REACTIONS REAL
Goosebumps. Every damn time. I love the original, but the power and raw emotion of this version takes my breath away.
Yes, GENESIS
Over a month since my last comment, but Daniel, loving music is one thing, loving music and being able to share our emotions and feelings about it is such an extraordinary healing thing...if more people were able to know and share like you do, they would understand how music sharing impacts MH issues. Love you and your sharing!:) XXX
see that CONAN on your screen... hit that one and feel the voice on loan from God... good reaction thx
Such a departure for Disturbed, and David Draiman's voice shines in this. The live version from one of the late night shows (can't remember which) is amazing. So powerful.
I first heard Disturbed’s Down With the Sickness years ago, when my son played it for me. He was startled when I burst into tears and asked why I was crying. How can you not cry at that brilliant, gut wrenching song? It walks you through the destruction of a child’s soul from years of abuse until he’s devoured whole. This cover of Simon & Garfunkel’s beautiful and important song has the same depth. David Draiman is incredible.
It is almost apocalyptic, with the anger building, raindrops? An ark at the end, saving the instruments of sound. Live this version, love the arrangement and the video production, so haunting, sad and powerful.