Guitarist REACTS!! First time hearing Disturbed- The Sound of Silence! AND I LOVED IT!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 янв 2025

Комментарии • 192

  • @digginupthecarolinas9870
    @digginupthecarolinas9870 24 дня назад +19

    Simon and Garf version of this song was meant to be listened to,Disturbed version was meant to be FELT!!!

  • @crypto2487
    @crypto2487 10 месяцев назад +18

    You should do the live Conan O'Brian version of this song. It literally brought me to tears. I'm a grown ass man too

    • @SweetPolly36
      @SweetPolly36 4 дня назад +1

      I have seen many a grown ass man openly weep while listening and reacting to this song.

  • @dragivasilev6795
    @dragivasilev6795 6 дней назад +4

    A brilliant recording of this song vocally and musically. Disturbed simply made you feel every word of the song.

  • @rollotomassi6232
    @rollotomassi6232 Год назад +97

    Listened to this song for 50 years without ever understanding the message, David made me listen and get the meaning. I will say to me it's better than the original because the message is dark and foreboding and Paul & Art sang it like a folk song. Taking nothing away from the writing, that is still masterful, but this brought tears to my eyes and that never happened with the original.

  • @suzyjohnson3122
    @suzyjohnson3122 17 дней назад +6

    Be BRAVE, It's phenomenal !

  • @StaceyHunt-tl9bu
    @StaceyHunt-tl9bu 10 месяцев назад +9

    No better, ❤ excellent❤❤😊

  • @Grumpy_Rabbit
    @Grumpy_Rabbit Год назад +91

    David Draiman was classically trained as Jewish Hassan / Cantor. Phenomenal vocalist.
    And the line, "The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls, and tenement halls" is one of my favorite verses in any song, ever.

    • @moriganna67ify
      @moriganna67ify Год назад +8

      I get chills up and down my body. So powerful! 😊

    • @kennethcook9406
      @kennethcook9406 Год назад +9

      His father and grandfather were also Cantors, so it runs in the family.

  • @Melly01
    @Melly01 Год назад +109

    Disturbed's version spoke to me in a way that the original didn't. (Sorry! I feel guilty saying that knowing how special it is to you. 😳) I felt the weight of the lyrics and actually listened to the words. I was little when I heard the original and the folk style music didn't pull me in, it never did for anything. I was too young to comprehend the lyrics and by the time I was old enough to understand, I'd already pigeonholed it into the "Mom and Dad's music" box. My brother listened to Alice Cooper, and I grew up on classic rock, so I never circled back around. I feel like Disturbed brought the brilliance of the words and meaning to an audience that wouldn't have listened before. I think it's a perfect marriage. And David's vocals are everything ... (I might have a little crush. Don't judge me! Lol) Seriously, so glad you enjoyed this. It's wonderful to see someone who loves the original be able to appreciate a different take. Nicely done! I'll be back for more Disturbed. :)

    • @oliviarose5030
      @oliviarose5030 Год назад +8

      Same here. The original had this whimsical instrumental with the voices filled with melancholy. Disturbed’s version feels like it goes from a hopeless whisper to a frustrated scream, then almost ends in melancholy. For me, he shows and emanates every line and every emotion that goes with it. Like you said, it makes the listener actually listen and feel absolutely everything with him.

    • @SuddenRain777
      @SuddenRain777 Год назад +8

      Paul Simon, upon hearing Disturbed’s version, said the song now belongs to Disturbed. Simon also put a link to the Disturbed version on his page. What a compliment!

    • @avanae
      @avanae Год назад +6

      same here. This version just touched my soul. I love the build up and emotions. I still have chills when listen to it.

    • @schavez5656
      @schavez5656 Год назад +2

      Same

    • @verapena9465
      @verapena9465 9 месяцев назад +2

      I agree 💯

  • @royreynolds108
    @royreynolds108 Год назад +25

    The shot of the hand writing the music has an old-time cuff or something of metal to keep the hand and arm off the page to not smear the ink. I am 77 and grew up with Simon & Garfunkel and never understood the song until about 4 years ago heard Disturb's cover. Then I understood the song.
    The Conan Show performance was nominated for a Grammy and the audience commented on some videos that they gave them a 10-minute standing ovation.

  • @ruthiewohlforth5464
    @ruthiewohlforth5464 Год назад +58

    ... David Draiman has one of the best voice's I've ever heard imho. He's got it all... stunning voice in either tenor or baritone (range), distortion (vocal fry), control, emotion, vibrato ... can even put vibrato on the distortion which is incredibly difficult to do! David is amazing! Love your reaction.

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Год назад +3

      Thank you- great singer!

    • @savvymegs675
      @savvymegs675 Год назад +1

      ​@@phishfan check him with myles Kennedy on this song

  • @reggiefokes6677
    @reggiefokes6677 Год назад +41

    I was gobsmacked the first time I heard David sing this song. The video is impeccable.

    • @JoyceHirano
      @JoyceHirano 22 дня назад

      Gobsmacked perfectly describes most reactions to this version😊

  • @susanrichardson5568
    @susanrichardson5568 Год назад +34

    He (David) is just an amazing singer...I am glad you got to see this video...wonderful and fabulous. Paul Simon said that David now owns this song

  • @donnafraser8797
    @donnafraser8797 Год назад +33

    I can't hear this song enough! The emotions I feel while I'm listening to this are over-whelming!

  • @lindamccraw2366
    @lindamccraw2366 Месяц назад +3

    OMG, Loved your reaction and critique. I cannot get enough of the Disturbed version. I saw the lyrics in a different way. So well done.

  • @Shan04268
    @Shan04268 Год назад +41

    Agreed. Intense and emotional. One of the best remakes ever done. I also agree...some songs you just don't mess with. But sometimes... you get a result like this. Amazing stuff.

    • @verapena9465
      @verapena9465 9 месяцев назад +1

      This song changed my mind on covers

  • @StephanieLangley-to6ph
    @StephanieLangley-to6ph 7 месяцев назад +5

    Best cover ever... Listened to this many many times and still get blown away every time 🤗

  • @DrJ4712
    @DrJ4712 2 месяца назад +2

    🐱🐱I felt the same way you did about not wanting to listen to metal version of S&G, but in this version, David's vocals drove home Paul Simon's message! Great reaction! Thanks for sharing 😊❤

  • @lyndainnis9035
    @lyndainnis9035 Год назад +9

    This is rhe last song my husbabd & I listened to & fell in love with before gwe passed away. I listen to it daily. He was a fan of heavy metal. I have this version on my play list at my funeral as a tribute to us as a couple & as a thank-you to both S&G and Disturbed. Love it. Makes me cry everytime I it.❤😢😂😂😢❤

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Год назад +2

      So sorry for your loss- thank you for sharing your thoughts. Peace.

    • @pamelacairns289
      @pamelacairns289 9 месяцев назад

      😢❤

  • @hannieloooo
    @hannieloooo 6 месяцев назад +3

    This version made me appreciate the original even more. It’s like a continuance of the feeling the original gives you. This version brings me to tears almost every time I hear it. It’s just gorgeous.

  • @moriganna67ify
    @moriganna67ify Год назад +13

    Paul Simon said it himself. This is the best rendition, even his own. David Draman is one of the most invoking and powerful but also classical educated. He has the most versatile voice in history.

  • @leslieyarnall4822
    @leslieyarnall4822 9 месяцев назад +5

    Aww come on! Listen to the song and stop commenting on the shots. This is one of the songs ever remade that gave me chills! Just listen.

  • @tinapatterson5022
    @tinapatterson5022 Год назад +41

    Paul Simon Loved this Version so much, He put this song on His Playlist.🥰

    • @erniedevries2356
      @erniedevries2356 8 месяцев назад +1

      He didn't put this video on his playlist but the life performance on Conan

    • @jaxinevolner8003
      @jaxinevolner8003 8 месяцев назад +2

      Thank you! I was just wondering how Simon & Garfunkel reacted to Disturbed's rendition of their classic song.
      I truly love and can watch for hours, people reacting to this awesome rendition of the sound of silence. They are all blown away, as I am each and every time I watch and listen. I never tire of listening to David Dramon's voice.

  • @nessienessie8798
    @nessienessie8798 Год назад +15

    This version grabs your soul and shakes the shit out of it. I love it ❤

  • @thomaswingate6333
    @thomaswingate6333 10 месяцев назад +3

    Please look the live version they did in 2016 I believe

  • @lucyFV
    @lucyFV Год назад +11

    This is so Epic!! I have listened to this at least a hundred times! A great tribute to the original! So much meaning and emotion!! ❤

  • @aaronhommel4615
    @aaronhommel4615 Месяц назад +3

    Amazing Song. You nailed it!

  • @rockyroad64
    @rockyroad64 Год назад +10

    I cry almost every time. This rendition is amazingly powerful. Its like the cover of Hurt that Johnny Cash did. They made the songs their own and brought the meaning to the next level.
    Thanks for your reaction! I enjoyed you watching this, especially with the initial skepticism.😊 I was pretty sure youd be blown away.

  • @laurasetley6696
    @laurasetley6696 Год назад +6

    You are amazing! You explain everything so well, and I loved how you mentioned the scenes and instruments and what an amazing voice David has. It all came together to produce a masterpiece ❤

  • @anitadecreton9519
    @anitadecreton9519 7 месяцев назад +8

    Nobody talks about the video!!!

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  7 месяцев назад +1

      It's so good- I really like it.

    • @JanetSiegel-py5ic
      @JanetSiegel-py5ic 18 дней назад +3

      I’d like to know who came up with the concept. It’s spot on.

  • @betchieharrison5526
    @betchieharrison5526 6 месяцев назад +3

    Very good reaction ❤
    My dad's favorite song of all time. He passed away 6 years ago. I miss him so much

  • @ceejay2633
    @ceejay2633 9 месяцев назад +5

    This is the way the song should have always been sung, based on the words and the message...

  • @infodotcom4012
    @infodotcom4012 4 месяца назад +2

    His voice...... Worth dying for ❤️ Love it!

  • @shihtzumom7209
    @shihtzumom7209 Месяц назад +2

    Loved your reaction video and so glad to watch a review where the person actually knows of the original iconic song! So disheartening to see how many other reaction reviewers thought this version might be the original, and had never heard of Simon and Garfunkel. Sigh. I grew up with the original and love it, but Disturbed's version is my favorite for the incredible passion and power it exudes. His voice is amazing. Thank you for your reaction video. I agree with your comparison of the tone and style of the two song versions. Great review!!

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Месяц назад

      Thank you for the kind words!!

  • @davewetering7554
    @davewetering7554 Год назад +4

    Dude! You are good at this❤ i would have choose the live version of this

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Год назад

      Thanks for the kind words!! 😁

  • @melissatopham4018
    @melissatopham4018 Год назад +16

    I heard a great explanation comparing songs..Older version was the Warning... New version was the rage for not listening.

  • @JackieJames-fk7st
    @JackieJames-fk7st 2 месяца назад +1

    Absolutely great

  • @genilandry4436
    @genilandry4436 4 месяца назад +1

    I am 78 can’tGit enough of this song the do have a fast version heait on k9 dog training and. He looks so cute with

  • @suzyjohnson3122
    @suzyjohnson3122 17 дней назад +1

    The less interpretation will take you somewhere you have NEVER BEEN. Y😂 can always listen to it again!

  • @lobo3928
    @lobo3928 Месяц назад +2

    David draiman is such an amazing singer AND human being. I’m so glad you listened. It took me a long time to cave and listen too but Simon and Garfunkel’s was to me a warning and disturbed’s was more a you’re still not listening vibe, decades later.

  • @karlbecker8775
    @karlbecker8775 Год назад +9

    Easily one of the best covers I've ever heard, regardless of genre. David even impressed Paul Simon with it!

  • @Bulldog306
    @Bulldog306 5 месяцев назад +3

    Glad you decided to react to this video, great reaction!

  • @randystalnaker6700
    @randystalnaker6700 25 дней назад +2

    Hadn't heard much from you in awhile...praying you are ok...Merry Christmas 🎄

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  23 дня назад +1

      Happy holidays! Thanks for the well-wishes, everything is cool. Just busy working on another channel that I hope to launch on January 1st; it's taking a lot of time and work. I will get back to this one at some point, maybe a different focus to some extent. The last 13 reactions I did had copyright concerns on 12 of them so it got a bit discouraging.

  • @KarenOEngland
    @KarenOEngland Год назад +11

    When he did this on Conan. Paul called him (David) It's your song now.

  • @mort58
    @mort58 5 месяцев назад +2

    Love it. No wonder this one is called "The king of covers" But then again it´s not a cover. Paul Simon posted this and said: It´s their song now. The only other cover/tribute that can compete with this one is: Nightwish High hopes (Pink Floyd) Oh and btw I am a HUGE Simon and Garfunkel fan

  • @kathywedding3040
    @kathywedding3040 Год назад +3

    LOVE IT ❤️

  • @debbiethomasson2709
    @debbiethomasson2709 Год назад +6

    Paul Simon says the song is theirs now and includes their web site in his comments.

  • @marinechristensen728
    @marinechristensen728 Год назад +7

    Love it. I can`t help but shed a tear.

  • @sheribrougham4863
    @sheribrougham4863 4 месяца назад +1

    Thank you for your reaction. Your face said it all.

  • @94520shatto
    @94520shatto Год назад +4

    The Sound of Silence by Simon and Garfunkel is sad resignation.
    The Sound of Silence by Disturbed is Dammit, LISTEN!
    ***** The Warning *****
    "And the people bowed and prayed, to the neon god they made." ~ Paul Simon
    "And the people bowed and prayed, to the golden calf they made." ~ Old Testament

  • @miraculousladybug713
    @miraculousladybug713 Год назад +4

    I view the original with a Haunting sadness but hopeful, and this one is hauntingly angry, but still hopeful 💜💜💜

  • @connierauscher5583
    @connierauscher5583 11 месяцев назад +3

    Loved it then, love it now

  • @mariajapon9334
    @mariajapon9334 5 месяцев назад +1

    Trasformadora, araña el alma humana y la hace más humana. Voz ÚNICA en el mundo, maravillosa musica, debe ser escuchada en todo el mundo.

  • @stephanieshoupp5027
    @stephanieshoupp5027 7 месяцев назад +2

    Watch their A Reason to Fight and Hold on to Memories both live versions.

  • @verapena9465
    @verapena9465 Год назад +6

    Felt that way also but this song was written for David ❤

  • @emilybulanski2896
    @emilybulanski2896 Год назад +5

    Great analysis! Unbelievably indescribably powerful rendition!!! The original was very good, no doubt, but even Paul Simon himself is quoted as saying that Disturbed now "OWNS" the song - and that is a compliment beyond all compliments!

  • @luannedaley5117
    @luannedaley5117 2 месяца назад

    Awesome reaction! I felt the same way you did! I was insulted that someone thought they could improve on a classic. I’ve learned they weren’t trying to improve it, just express it in a way that speaks to them! Nicely done!

  • @brendawebb3231
    @brendawebb3231 Год назад +5

    You have got to hear the live version on Conan O'Brian. His performance crashed every communication the studio had. Miles Kennedy also played guitar then.

  • @darcitrettin4855
    @darcitrettin4855 Год назад +3

    I’m so happy you enjoyed it ! I was worried it would ruin it for you. Your face showed such truth

  • @tinapatterson5022
    @tinapatterson5022 Год назад +3

    If You Have not seen The Live Version From Disturbed on Conan O'Brian Show 3/2016, It's a Must ! David was a Little under the weather and Still nailed the Song!✌

  • @Dollywood623
    @Dollywood623 Год назад +4

    Disturbed with “Down with the Sickness” official video. 🔥🔥🔥

  • @kaybail1878
    @kaybail1878 Год назад +3

    Masterful.

  • @tammyhill3798
    @tammyhill3798 Год назад +10

    Loved your reaction. People will probably tell you to check out this on Conan O’Brian. They will also tell you he was sick with the flu, but I just watched an interview with David and he actually had a bleeding lesion on his vocal cords. I think that makes it even more amazing. There is another group that does a cover of this. Pentatonix . They are known worldwide, have been together since 2011. 20 million subscribers and over 6 BILLION views. Have 3 Grammys. A star on the Hollywood walk of fame. Platinum records. About 4 thousand Christmas albums 😂 If you watch 1 video their fan base known as Pentaholics will flock to your channel. If you do decide to do this I recommend that you read Alan Freeman’s comment. He will give you their ENTIRE history. Oh, one more thing. They are an a cappella group. If you already know who they are, then Nevermind. 🤭Also just subscribed.

  • @kathywedding3040
    @kathywedding3040 Год назад +3

    LOVED YOUR COMMENT & AGREE WTH YOU 100%❤️🙏🥰😘

  • @g.iantamongtitans
    @g.iantamongtitans 11 месяцев назад +3

    The original was a warning, the remake is admonishment. Also, was fun watching you going in like "respect for the classics", and then saw that it was absolutely respected.

  • @terryherrick9784
    @terryherrick9784 12 дней назад

    Disturbed songs are written to touch the people and with such meaning and insight. Their "Hold on to Memories" will be played at my funeral. But another cover they have done is Sting's songs "If I Ever Lose My Faith in You" in which they change the meaning of the song after Covid. They touch everyone in every walk of life.

  • @verapena9465
    @verapena9465 Год назад +4

    ❤S&G MASSIVE RESPECT FOR THEM ,BUT THIS VERSION IS AMAZING MAKING YOU FEEL IT

  • @GaryLBlakeley
    @GaryLBlakeley Год назад +1

    They also did this song live on Conon O'Brien. Paul Simon was watching that night. After hearing Disturbed's cover, he sent David a message stating that this is now their song.
    I've seen them do this live and it was amazing. You could feel the energy in the venue.

  • @Caeleachdog
    @Caeleachdog Год назад +3

    Check out Disturbed Hold on To Memories, The Light, and especially A Reason To Fight. All beautiful uses of David's fantastic voice.

  • @drosmel3116
    @drosmel3116 Год назад +3

    This version move me to tears. Given what is going on in the US today, it makes me cry and I want to do something

  • @marablemorgan8292
    @marablemorgan8292 5 месяцев назад +2

    ⚡⚡⚡⚡🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥⚡⚡⚡⚡

  • @savvymegs675
    @savvymegs675 Год назад +2

    Disturbed is phenomenal. They and system of a down are some of my fave bands from that era. Their covers are amazing, try land of confusio.

    • @savvymegs675
      @savvymegs675 Год назад

      And if I ever lose my faith in you.

  • @KerryNelsonART
    @KerryNelsonART Год назад +5

    Great reaction! Hope you dive into more Disturbed ... they have many, many great and worthy songs. Here are a few of their harder fare,
    *Down With The Sickness
    *Stupify
    *Stricken
    *Indestructible
    *Ten Thousand Fists
    *Inside The Fire
    *Asylum
    Ok, i could keep going, lol.😅
    PS, disregard the nay sayers. Your reaction style is just fine! 😊

  • @Paula-sw2tt
    @Paula-sw2tt Год назад +4

    In addition to being one of the best vocalists of the century, David is an advocate for mental illness and an awesome individuals. I love his interviews. Btw I am not a heavy metal fan. Paul Simon contacted David and told him that The Sound of Silence was his now. There is no greater praise for a cover! I grew up with and love the original, but this is my fav version.

  • @BerraLJ
    @BerraLJ Год назад +1

    Just look at the number of views of the song and you can tell it will not disappoint

  • @michaelpierson7256
    @michaelpierson7256 Год назад +1

    Warning, this is unlike anything else that disturbed does, everything else is very heavy😊

  • @karencollins2661
    @karencollins2661 2 дня назад

    You're going to love this

  • @MicaelaKooiman
    @MicaelaKooiman Год назад +3

    I like this version better than the original. Please stop commenting until after the song. First time hearing this group and I am not a Metal fan but this was OUTSTANDING!!!

  • @stevecranmer2845
    @stevecranmer2845 Год назад +14

    Great reaction, you should definitely check out the live version of this from the Conan O'Brien show it's pretty incredible

    • @helenastuhec4941
      @helenastuhec4941 Год назад +1

      I totally agree!!! The live version is on a completely different level ❤️

    • @metalcubana3004
      @metalcubana3004 Год назад +1

      Another vote for the Live version on Conan! 🔥

    • @sharischindler9843
      @sharischindler9843 Год назад +1

      I agree! I like the live version on Conan more. 🩷🩷🩷

  • @dukeness01
    @dukeness01 Год назад +2

    Thank you for bringing your knowledge of The Sound of Silence and for doing some research into Disturbed. Nothing worse than watching a review from someone that has no clue about the band or song.

  • @kennethcook9406
    @kennethcook9406 Год назад +1

    Another rock band to check out is Ramstein.
    It's in german, but if you understand the German language, the songs take on an entire new depth of meaning.
    Also, lead singer Till Lindemann was supposed to be an Olympic swimmer for East Germany, and he's a fully licenced pyrotechnician (explaining all of the fire/explosives in their shows)

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Год назад

      I saw them in Berlin in 1998!

  • @shezarae8827
    @shezarae8827 11 месяцев назад +3

    I think the beauty of the way Simon and Garfunkel was great, but the lyrics of this song are dark and edgy, and Disturbed brought that emotion to the song.

  • @jameskidd6122
    @jameskidd6122 Год назад +2

    David Draman called Paul to see if he wanted money for the song rights. Paul said "No it's your song now."

  • @coffeeandtatuaje
    @coffeeandtatuaje Год назад +8

    The comments are interesting. You don’t stop too often. I watch reactions for reactions! Stop as much as you need. You’ve probably heard their Down With the Sickness. Their range is phenomenal. I’ve seen them live multiple times. Best concerts I’ve ever attended.

  • @_allthatjazz_8667
    @_allthatjazz_8667 Год назад +2

    Fantastic no more no less

  • @Idontwanttochange
    @Idontwanttochange 5 месяцев назад

    feel, don't talk, listen don't intellectualise. How can you speak so much through such an experience?

  • @equinatordarkhorn2088
    @equinatordarkhorn2088 Год назад +3

    Many has stated the original was a warning. This version was the warning wasn't headed. You REALLY need to look into their "A Reason To Fight".

  • @karencollins2661
    @karencollins2661 2 дня назад

    And us old people love Disturb's Sounds of Silence. Paul Simon said the song now belongs to Disturb

  • @clf8668
    @clf8668 Год назад +2

    I agree…😂❤

  • @shadmccarty3452
    @shadmccarty3452 Год назад +2

    To see the extent of David Draimans abilities...I would suggest checking out the Disturbed songs "Stupified" and "Down with the Sickness" for starters. Two of their best known songs.

  • @wallflowerj6013
    @wallflowerj6013 Год назад +2

    Great reaction thank you

  • @MarlaBlankenship
    @MarlaBlankenship Год назад +1

    Paul Simon loved this version more than the original.

  • @IlonkaSims
    @IlonkaSims Год назад +2

    Lots of people saying to listen to the live version on conan, instead I suggest the live version featuring Myles Kennedy which brings in some of those harmonies that you're used to from the original!

  • @pls6247
    @pls6247 Год назад +1

    "...and the people bowed and prayed to the neon gods they made..."
    When this song came out that "neon god" was television. Today it's the almighty smartphone.
    As the "neon god" has evolved and become more powerful, the people still don't heed Simon and Garfunkles' warning.
    Does David seem mad about that?

  • @muvosveucluka
    @muvosveucluka Год назад +1

    Das beste Cover dieses wunderbaren Songs, sagt auch Simon. Aber höre die Live Aufnahme bei Conan an, dort war David Draiman krank. Alles wunderbar.
    Danke für die Beurteilung

  • @darcitrettin4855
    @darcitrettin4855 Год назад +2

    I love you

    • @phishfan
      @phishfan  Год назад

      Haha thank you for the kind words!!

  • @kathywedding3040
    @kathywedding3040 Год назад +2

    👍

  • @TheSpokenSpatter
    @TheSpokenSpatter Год назад +1

    Live version on Conan is a must see.

  • @dianefellows9191
    @dianefellows9191 Год назад +2

    Ck Out hold on to the memories by Disturbed

  • @marablemorgan8292
    @marablemorgan8292 5 месяцев назад +1

    Not a cover... It's an upgrade!!! It got two thumbs up from Paul Simon!

  • @PoliticallyPink
    @PoliticallyPink Год назад

    One of the few, possibly only cover that I love perhaps more than the original. You spoke of the harmonies Simon & Garfunkle created, I think Ren and Chinchilla are more magical. Lots of couples sound good together, a few make magic. Check out "How to Be Me" (Live version.) Please.
    You also mentioned the original of this song is "sparse" (or similar). When did you last listen to it? I listened after hearing this version of "Sound of Silence," and found the opposite. S&G's felt cluttered and pop-py. (And I love them together and also Paul solo.)