It is interesting that someone from india know all this accurate information about Sudan , Thank you for this precise explanation , greetings from sudan 🇸🇩
Why not ? People here don't think that whole Africa is one country. You may feel like you are not significant but you are pretty important for us. I hope you achieve stability and thereby economic development.
@@preetamyadav7952 why the partition and later- repercussions not considered as civil wars? Infact our victims census are sky-high, almost a percent of world's population died that day and the days after that, later.
As a Sudanese Citizen i’m glad that there are still people who rely on facts and truth instead of blatantly calling what is happening as a proxy war between America and Russia
" When two elephant are fighting, the grass suffers most" - African proverb My heart goes out to the civilians especially women, children and the elderly. War is terrible!
@@salihuabdur-rahman7282 It was an excellent summary in such a short timeframe and was simple enough for anyone to understand. However,I had to mention the two major weopons suppliers to Sudan. More questions need to be answered on the role of the Wagner mercenary group.
Well its cause he is a teacher for exam oreparation so he is teaching current affairs for exam in india i m sure not in indian news we will get such chrisp info except from teachers
Mr. Amity, excelldnt, you have worked hard to prepare this programme and provided detailed information to the World and who are interested in history and politics. We nit only enjoyed but educated either Sudan History of past 30 years. Thanks.
with the added desperate insertion of the narrative that the USA is the enemy pretty sure even the history of ice cream he'll be able to conclude that with USA is the enemy. 100% Amit, excellent! No bias at all
Dear Amit Sir, I just wanted to take a moment to express my sincere gratitude for considering my request/comment on your previous video to do a video on the current crisis in Sudan. As someone who follows your channel closely, I have always been impressed by the level of care and attention you bring to the issues you discuss. Your decision to take on this important topic is truly appreciated, and I know that your video will not only inform and educate many of us, but also help to raise awareness about the urgent situation in Sudan. Once again, thank you for your dedication and commitment to creating informative and impactful content. Your efforts are truly making a difference in the world. Warm regards,
Wow. If anyone had told me I was going to watch this video today, I wouldn't have believed. My uncle came visiting a few minutes ago,and we got talking about the conflict in Sudan. Just as we were discussing, I came across this video on my RUclips feed. After watching the video, we became more enlightened. Thank you.
Looks like SAUDI UAE will support DAGALO because he is from a poor background supporting poor people, and these ARABS are interested in the GENETIC exploitationof DARKSKIN TALL SUDANESE as they have done for centuries, but AFTER the SOUTH BROKE OFF< obviously that will present a LONG TERM problem of GENETIC EXPLOITATION by SAUDI and UAE. SO to support a more BLACK president and even a MORE BLACK SUDAN, might bring back SOUTH SUDAN and in the whole provide a MORE BLACK UNTED SUDAN< that the SAUDI and UAE can EXPLOIT GENETICALLY for the preservation of their own ARAB Race in the entire UAE. SOUTH SIDAN and BLACK SUDANESE even in the SUDAN should BE AWARE of this MANIPULATION and REJECT all attempts to be EXPLOITED as a GENETIC "common well/common oasis to WATER the ARAB world!"-these are ARAB & OCCIDENT, RUSSIAN, SOUTH & EAST European GENETIC EXPLOITATION INTERESTS in these politics of BLACK GENES as their "BLACK GOLD", their "BLACK OIL" to "oil" their RACIAL POLITICS! Theyre doing this thing all over Africa with BIAFRA, SWAHILI NATION in EA, LOVE ISLAND in SA etc...none of these COLONIZINF poltics are lost on people!
@@janice2992 Religious intolerance has been a problem in India since last 1200 years and it is mainly from self proclaimed peacefuls, they've always been the instigating it. As you can see from this video as well, they just can't maintain peace.
I could watch useless news on the tv for weeks and still not have a clue. I watch this awesome guy explain it in 20 minutes and im like an expert. Thank you so much.
Best explanation of the Sudan issue I've come across.... anywhere. Only 2 other things to add: (1)when south Sudan seceded, over 75% of the crude oil went with it. This put Sudan under a lot of economic pressure (2) COVID & Ukraine made things even worse. Covid could have been the impetus for the coup.
@@V8-br7flSo what? Doesn't discredit him being knowledgeable. You had an opportunity to provide substance but instead you've provided an ad hominem 🤦🏾♂️
Very well explained sir about the crises I have seen so much videos of different people on the Sudan crisis But they couldn't explain even 1% what you have explained Your analysis are spot on and very informative The other people just spoke about Russia base and gold No want talk about the history That's what make you a great geopolitical expert sir
Thank you very much sir for this precise, informative, comprehensive and factual summary. Much respect to you for taking the time to simply educate and report. A lot of people do not know or might not understand exactly the cause of this heartbreaking war, The constant violence is horrific and escalates daily. So everyone please, Pray for, and help in anyway you can for Sudan. It is very very dangerous and unsafe right now. It has been over the years but now it is exceptionally unsafe. Thank you all 🙏🤲 🇸🇩 ❤
I am confident that Amit will address the Sudan crisis in his video, and I am eagerly anticipating its release. Many thanks to Amit Sengupta for shedding light on this important issue.
it is not like he is an intelligence expert or in the intelligence of white western countries....he just do basic research.............we all could do that
@@eltonlewis4979 but you couldn't do that That's what he did Rather that praising you came with a negative thought If you would have corrected facts or added some value or guided on approach to explain better I would have appreciated you But just a random thought in anyone could do Then go and watch those uneducated RUclips shorts of those faltu people
I don't know what to say, but this is the best and more authentic news than the mainstream media. You deserve more than a medal. Thank you for the truth and the news.
To be honest, I never cam across such a clear analysis of a country's complex position in just 20mins. If you have not taken up lecturing I kindly urge you to consider😊. Nice video!!
Well done! Great presentation and lots of information. Despite myself being from South Sudan, I couldn’t have provided such an extraordinary explanation as you have done. Thank you for your contribution. Hopefully, you won’t mind me sharing your works. 🙏🏾
Feudalism, Feudal lords and FUDALISTIC, Tribalistic MIND SET prevailing in societies seems to be the basic faults ARAB WORLD been prone to giving rise to so much internal conflicts, internal struggling, gender discrimination.Large, Strong middle class with equal distribution of wealth and high literacy can be solution to minimise disturbances such like conflicts and bloodshed.
@@varunv8403 like it does in India right now? no thanks, do You know what hindu indians are doing in India to Muslim Indians on media, politics, and so many other levels?
NO-ONE in power seems to have any interest in what is best for the citizens of Sudan!! Thank you for this easy to understand summary of the Sudan situation.
Very good summary and analysis, better than what you will find in most media publications. I initially discovered this channel and Mr. Sengupta when looking up more information about India, and stayed on for everything from geography to history and geo politics. Always a thumb up!
Excellent video Sir - thank you. As South Africans living in a country with so many internal challenges we sometimes forget the other challenges happening on our continent. This was a very insightful and useful video to watch and learn from. Well done.
I had found a lot of indian news updates and current affairs..but still then due to my lag of Hindi ..i couldn't understand with their word and wht they r talking about but after watching ur videos it makes me understand everything about the topic...i really appreciate it..❤ Keep sharing such information in a understandable way so that we could easily know everything..love u from Northeast ❣️
One of the BEST videos I have EVER watched. Very informative, clear, detailed enough to be concise. Fantastic. I will share it for you on my Facebook etc with some professors of IR! 👏
Undoubtedly very informative, if anyone wants to know and understand what is happening in Sudan today, ya've very much explained it from the beginning to the present, beautifully and precisely, well done brav.
Looks like SAUDI UAE will support DAGALO because he is from a poor background supporting poor people, and these ARABS are interested in the GENETIC exploitationof DARKSKIN TALL SUDANESE as they have done for centuries, but AFTER the SOUTH BROKE OFF< obviously that will present a LONG TERM problem of GENETIC EXPLOITATION by SAUDI and UAE. SO to support a more BLACK president and even a MORE BLACK SUDAN, might bring back SOUTH SUDAN and in the whole provide a MORE BLACK UNTED SUDAN< that the SAUDI and UAE can EXPLOIT GENETICALLY for the preservation of their own ARAB Race in the entire UAE. SOUTH SIDAN and BLACK SUDANESE even in the SUDAN should BE AWARE of this MANIPULATION and REJECT all attempts to be EXPLOITED as a GENETIC "common well/common oasis to WATER the ARAB world!"-these are ARAB & OCCIDENT, RUSSIAN, SOUTH & EAST European GENETIC EXPLOITATION INTERESTS in these politics of BLACK GENES as their "BLACK GOLD", their "BLACK OIL" to "oil" their RACIAL POLITICS! Theyre doing this thing all over Africa with BIAFRA, SWAHILI NATION in EA, LOVE ISLAND in SA etc...none of these COLONIZINF poltics are lost on people!
Dear Amit, thank you for such a clear and educational video. I will be sharing this video with my English students in our next open discussion, about current affairs lesson. Kindest regards.
Is so annoying when people think Africa is one big village. Well is not.I’m from Africa I don’t even know what the story In Sudan,but this Guy did a wonderful job to explain it. I say thank you Sir . I wish everyone in Sudan 🇸🇩 peace
And south sudan is the oil rich part of Sudan so American foreign policy neocons knew splitting it off would weaken and sink the GDP to hurt and fragment Sudan so that it could could be turned into a U.S. client state, hence the push for diplomatic recognition during the Bush administration and accomplished by the Obama administration in 2011 The horn of africa became very important at the beginning of the 21st century, largely unexplored untapped gas and oil reserves in Somalia and Sudan “We’re gonna take out 7 countries in five years, starting off with iraq, then Lebanon, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and finishing off with Iran” -NATO Supreme Allied Commander General Wesley Clark (2007)
@@ChrisNewman-ie6qd she is from india and she referring to getting information from The hindu newspaper which follow ideology of mainly Chinese communist
@@rankingresearchdata what a BS reply, u think, a reply to foreigner about the newspaper and they believe it. The reason is (most probably) this newspaper is only from the few ones who still writes articles (critical analysis) about ur beloved leader who still in power and who controls the majority media. Have u any idea what’s the condition of indian journalism and degrading ranking year after year..? Also this newspaper doesn’t run on government ads, but on public subscription (which means alot )
@hydra king jst five days ago, 5 soldiers of military natives of punjab martyred in jammu kashmir for the sake of india. those sikh personals also be khalistanis for u bloody sick man. The difference is punjabis are not or never be the slaves of khaki kacha goons like u are. That is why last year your beloved master made an nationwide apology in front of whole india. I feel your pain, cry hard and loud, may be your master listen you.
A very crucial history point you left out.Daglo originally was trader and used to protect those who pass through the desert and then he headed the paramilitary troops called janjaoid in 2003 in Darfour war against the rebels and defeated them. He never had a formal military education.
THIS is by far, the best video I've watched in years! I have been wondering what the heck is happening in Sudan and that video made things cristal clear. Excellent! I like the fact that it felt balanced and fact based. Not the usual propaganda from Western media. Very good job my friend! I will share it to ALL my friends and contacts !
When i was in the Legion i served in Africa. Rwanda, we were there in Blue Beret's as UN peace Keepers. There was really bad violence between the Hutu's and Tutsis. I have been in other war zones but Rwanda takes the win for the most shocking sites. I get flashbacks thinking about it. Lets hope this Sudan crisis doesn't go that way.
@@shivamkumarshrivastava5182 There is a podcast by one of the Indian army generals who was posted in Sudan as UN Peace Keeper in The Ranveer Show podcast by Ranveer Allahabadia. He describes few horrific incidents he witnessed over there, they were brutal to say the least.
This is a very good, concise summary of the war in Sudan. The news media did not carry the background history that has started the conflict and I always wanted a better understanding of it. This is an excellent presentation.
This commentary is very concise, comprehensive, contained-easy to learn background, and above all, it lacked biases. As a history teacher, I can request students watch it as a background to the underlying conflict; because it's very educative in precision; due to its impartial feature, Thanks you.
It lacks biases? When his opening remarks was about USA controling the UN and his ending remark about the military base of Russia? Is that how a historian explain history?
Sudan, like many African countries, has a complex ethnic and tribal makeup. However, the country was artificially created by European colonial powers, who drew its borders without regard for these existing divisions. The result was a country with deeply rooted ethnic tensions that have simmered for decades. Documentaries about Africa often fail to provide proper details about these divisions, which are crucial to understanding the country's complex history and current state of affairs. The Sudanese government has often favored one ethnic group over another, exacerbating these tensions and leading to violent conflict. It's clear that the worst thing the colonizers did was force these groups with historical tensions together, creating a recipe for conflict and division that has plagued Sudan and other African countries for generations.
My friend we've been waring and killing each other hundreds of years way before colonial times yes they drew boarders but we'll always be tribal waring and there's never any compromise stop with the pointing fingers you can decide yourself if you want to pick up a gun and kill people, my family moved away long ago have nice day.
Colonial powers have nothing to do with. Before they even got involved if you weren't in the same tribe/religion you'll be killed off. Been that way since the beginning of time
Edited some spelling mistakes/Typos & added a bit more context for clarification. You missed a few key contexts that also led to this situation: 1. The government of Sudan signed the 2005 peace agreement in exchange for the hopes of lifting the sanctions, they weren't. 2. In 2003, during the negotiations of this agreement, an uprising/revolt happened in Darfur, threatening a dual civil war & crumbling of the peace talks at the time. 3. The RSF was formed during the aftermath of the Darfur revolt using deadly means to suppress it, during that time the army didn't want to be looked as the aggressor they supported & hired warring tribes as a Militia which came to be known as the Janjaweed which later became the foundation of the RSF in 2013. 3. The 1980 civil war is the second one, the first was over by signing the Addis Abba Accords in 1972, at the time an agreed version of the 2005 peace agreement in this video, it was sabotaged by the Islamist party, which took a radical & religiously motivated racist approach. 4. President Nimeiry survived a coup That lasted (3 Days) launched by the communist party, he became fearful of further attempts and sought to secure his position as president by aligning himself with the Islamists in Sudan, who slowly poached him & even tempted him with the bestowal of the title "Amir al-Mu'minin" which loosely translates to the supreme leader of the Islamic community". In 1983 President Gaafar Nimeiry Unilaterally declared All of Sudan to Fall under sharia Law as part of his broader political strategy to consolidate power and address various internal challenges. This Obviously Angered the South & directly resulted in the eruption of the Second Sudanese Civil War. 5. The Islamist movement, later forming a political party, lost Sudan's last democratic elections in 1985 but still managed to stage a coup four years later in 1989 by infiltrating the army and filling its ranks with loyal soldiers rather than properly trained ones. This infiltration marked the beginning of the movement's deep and wide control over the military. Their dominance became evident when they initiated a mysterious, bloodless coup in 1989, a premonition of their near-total control over most of the army. This control was solidified through the purging of top-ranking generals (in 1990), many of whom were better trained, educated, and free from hidden associations with foreign entities like the Muslim Brotherhood. Those who stood in the way were executed in secret, instant military tribunals, leading to one of the most devastating impacts on the Sudanese army in its history. 6. With the army in their control, the Civilian members of the Islamist movement formed a party under Hassan al Turabi, who was later confirmed to be the true mastermind behind orchestrating the coup & plan origin, formed a government backed by the newly reformed army under their total control became the sole political player in the country for 29 years. The Coup dissolved the Democratic Government, The National Assembly, All Political Parties, suspension of All Civil Liberties & dissolution of all Trade Unions and Professional Associations. 7. Omar Al Bashir was nominated by Hassan al Turabi to lead the coup and subsequently became the Chairman of the Revolutionary Command Council for National Salvation, Prime Minister of Sudan (later president of Sudan when the position was abolished), Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces which gave him ultimate power to run the country allowing him to govern Sudan with little to no opposition from other branches of government.
we can all go read up on that information if we want to find out more. Most people don't want to.make it too long. That would make it a 40 minute video and I'm.sure.he didn't want to make it that long
Mo Za. Ty for the very interesting background story. So many questions for a complex history of a culture of tribes and intricacies unrelatable by westerners.
Thank you Amit, your Explanation of current events in Sudan, was, is, so very much appreciated. Also, your lesson of Sudan's history last twenty years, was extraordinarily through in helping us understand over here in America, Why and how this Civil War has come about. Thanks Amit, Peace and blessings to you Sir. 🌎💕🎼🍀
Merci beaucoup. This video, along with others, gave me a better understanding of this conflict. I'm hoping for a fast resolution of this conflict, for the Sudanese people's sake.
i just watched mahipal rathods video a while back and i can say your analysis throws his video out of the window !!! satva triumphs over rajas i.e ones passion and honesty towards teaching defeats people who sell courses for a living because they make videos on hot topics and you make videos because of your passion towards geo politics and teaching.
i feel so sad what now happening in sudan. i had lived in Sudan 14 years ago for almost 4 years , at that time Khartoum was fully peace, we were drinking some coffee from mama ( haja) on the streets , enjoining some Sudanese music comes across the restaurants (matam) . I have good memories. I hope and pray for Sudan, all peace come.
Thank you for these information, an African from Nigeria to be precise, this piece of info worth much for me, I pray for peace in those areas, including Ukraine/Rusia and across the glob🙏
Thank you for the well condensed short history on Sudan. Two days ago, CBS news published an article stating that Pentagon is considering sending American troops to Sudan to rescue American citizens. I interpret it to mean that some American troops are already on the theater in Sudan.
Darfur is a rich region in terms of mineral and gold and there is a proof (pictures) that Wagner is operating in Sudan and various other places in Sahel region. Darfur is inhabited mostly by native African tribes and wanted get separated or autonomous but dagalo who is Sudanese Arab brutally crushed rebellion and gets tag of paramilitary. You explained very clearly and detailed and about tribes will helpful in upcoming exams
Look at you. And US has not tried to interfere in Sudan at all. Riiiight. Point fingers at Wagner but leave US, Israel, England and France out of the picture? Ha. They try to meddle in Sudan as well. Also for Gold, and Uranium, water and agriculture. It is well documented. Don’t forget to right that down in your exam. We as Sudanese hate interfering in ANY nation’s internal affairs. And we certainly don’t like any nation interfering in ours. We welcome constructive advice. That’s where the interference starts and ends.
Very well described. About Sudan and other African countries, Indian people know less. But as an Indian, Sir, you have described so easily which means that Your knowledge about Africa is vast.
Wow !! I tried Diplomatic DIspatch of Sansad Tv ,"start Here" of Al-Jazera and a couple of international articles. But no one could explain this issue in a simplistic manner as you. It is so simple yet comprehensive. Thank you, sir ☺
For me it's still a big mess i don't understand their strategies and plans so many names this come from there he from here they say same think different. I wipp follow this longer so i can make conclusion.
@@фене sure learn more..but don't make conclusion right now..just observe ..as it's ongoing civil war. It might be suffice for me as I followed 2019 sudan Prostest ,so I had some idea of past
Are you a college history professor??? If not, you should be...I have never heard a more concise, simple, and to the point explanation of an event...I now understand completely what is going on in Sudan...unlike the news medias that use bias and omit facts...
It is interesting that someone from india know all this accurate information about Sudan , Thank you for this precise explanation , greetings from sudan 🇸🇩
Why not ? People here don't think that whole Africa is one country. You may feel like you are not significant but you are pretty important for us.
I hope you achieve stability and thereby economic development.
Indians suffered as African so that's why we know they tricks... and well understanding of western strategy
@@hawahshawaalkachapa1522 No we never suffered civili war after independence
@@preetamyadav7952 because you don't have much resources like Africa do. Coz the Civil War that African countries facing it source our colonizers.
@@preetamyadav7952 why the partition and later- repercussions not considered as civil wars?
Infact our victims census are sky-high, almost a percent of world's population died that day and the days after that, later.
As a Sudanese Citizen i’m glad that there are still people who rely on facts and truth instead of blatantly calling what is happening as a proxy war between America and Russia
5tt5
And let me guess America is arming the Arabs? Racist scum
Thats what i thought until i watched this video
I never heard that, now i kind of believe it...
Kenyan here... most people aren't interested in fact. They just believe every war has to do with US, Russia, West
" When two elephant are fighting, the grass suffers most" - African proverb
My heart goes out to the civilians especially women, children and the elderly. War is terrible!
@@eepien like the children suffer when the parents argue.
You sir should be an instructor, teacher or lecturer!
You know how to explain things in simple terms indeed. Kudos sir.
He is
He teaches for the toughest exam in India and other exams
@@Kamet58 No wonder!
He is very good.
@@salihuabdur-rahman7282 It was an excellent summary in such a short timeframe and was simple enough for anyone to understand. However,I had to mention the two major weopons suppliers to Sudan. More questions need to be answered on the role of the Wagner mercenary group.
they want the southern hemisphere empty so they can go in and strip the resources from the land without a fight
@@bobshagit-io8lq Please stop clogging up the internet with repeated nonsensical gibberish. Thank you.
You deserve an award. Great short documentary explaining what's going on in Sudan. I feel sorry for the innocent lives in Sudan.
they want the southern hemisphere empty so they can go in and strip the resources from the land without a fight
@FGoogle and youtube Great
Yes short brief,complete,beautifully thoroughly explained in detail,thank you,syukranjazilan amen.
Thank you so much for helping me to understand!
A Mexican soap opera wouldn’t be so convoluted.
Thank you Sir for your comprehensive report! In the U.S. we rarely get this type of in-depth coverage.
Thats bcos you only watch regular news network.. US Literally invented social media & RUclips..
Because it doesn't matter. Not to the US anyway.
@@black10872 The U.S. has facilitated negotiations there before.
@@stephangarcia1804 Let me put it bluntly. The US citizenry.... DON'T CARE! Nobody in the US really cares what goes on outside the US.
Well its cause he is a teacher for exam oreparation so he is teaching current affairs for exam in india i m sure not in indian news we will get such chrisp info except from teachers
Mr. Amity, excelldnt, you have worked hard to prepare this programme and provided detailed information to the World and who are interested in history and politics. We nit only enjoyed but educated either Sudan History of past 30 years. Thanks.
with the added desperate insertion of the narrative that the USA is the enemy
pretty sure even the history of ice cream he'll be able to conclude that with USA is the enemy. 100% Amit, excellent! No bias at all
Dear Amit Sir,
I just wanted to take a moment to express my sincere gratitude for considering my request/comment on your previous video to do a video on the current crisis in Sudan. As someone who follows your channel closely, I have always been impressed by the level of care and attention you bring to the issues you discuss.
Your decision to take on this important topic is truly appreciated, and I know that your video will not only inform and educate many of us, but also help to raise awareness about the urgent situation in Sudan.
Once again, thank you for your dedication and commitment to creating informative and impactful content. Your efforts are truly making a difference in the world.
Warm regards,
Chat GPT
@@mahatmagaand lmao, was just about to say the same. Too obvious
funny
@@mahatmagaand 😁thats obvious but the words are from my heart
As always on the point. No BS just facts. We love him in Serbia 🤗
As a Sudanese,I really thank you for the brilliant explanation.
Wow. If anyone had told me I was going to watch this video today, I wouldn't have believed.
My uncle came visiting a few minutes ago,and we got talking about the conflict in Sudan.
Just as we were discussing, I came across this video on my RUclips feed.
After watching the video, we became more enlightened.
Thank you.
Your phone is listening to you. That's how they know the video to recommend to you
The phone listened to your conversation and thus recommended a video relating to it.
@@raloed.363 That's scary
Lmao. I’m totally into listening to HOW did this happen. Great video.
@RALO Ed. Correct they are always listening
I was waiting for Sudan analysis.. I am from Kenya 🇰🇪
Looks like SAUDI UAE will support DAGALO because he is from a poor background supporting poor people, and these ARABS are interested in the GENETIC exploitationof DARKSKIN TALL SUDANESE as they have done for centuries, but AFTER the SOUTH BROKE OFF< obviously that will present a LONG TERM problem of GENETIC EXPLOITATION by SAUDI and UAE. SO to support a more BLACK president and even a MORE BLACK SUDAN, might bring back SOUTH SUDAN and in the whole provide a MORE BLACK UNTED SUDAN< that the SAUDI and UAE can EXPLOIT GENETICALLY for the preservation of their own ARAB Race in the entire UAE. SOUTH SIDAN and BLACK SUDANESE even in the SUDAN should BE AWARE of this MANIPULATION and REJECT all attempts to be EXPLOITED as a GENETIC "common well/common oasis to WATER the ARAB world!"-these are ARAB & OCCIDENT, RUSSIAN, SOUTH & EAST European GENETIC EXPLOITATION INTERESTS in these politics of BLACK GENES as their "BLACK GOLD", their "BLACK OIL" to "oil" their RACIAL POLITICS! Theyre doing this thing all over Africa with BIAFRA, SWAHILI NATION in EA, LOVE ISLAND in SA etc...none of these COLONIZINF poltics are lost on people!
Like someone said. You deserve an award for explaining what’s going on in Sudan. Thank you
You might have just provided enough information to National Dailies for next 1-2 weeks in these 20 mins.
Respect n Love from Himalayas 🇮🇳🚩
0
India is the powerful peace and powerful country 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🪖🔥
@@noothanp6781 India has its problem's as well. From power mad leader's, to religious intolerance. These evils pop up all over the world.
@@janice2992 Religious intolerance has been a problem in India since last 1200 years and it is mainly from self proclaimed peacefuls, they've always been the instigating it. As you can see from this video as well, they just can't maintain peace.
@@janice2992 religious intolrence is due to islam ....until this exist you can not expect peace
I am from sudan and this video is 100% right , to the point and simply clarified the situation in sudan.
As a Sudanese, what would you like to see happen?
Hey how are you doing?
What's condition now
I hope you are well.
As a Sudanese 🇸🇩 watching this video here all I can say everything is on point n Tnx for letting the world knw the facts kudos 🙌✍️
I could watch useless news on the tv for weeks and still not have a clue. I watch this awesome guy explain it in 20 minutes and im like an expert. Thank you so much.
This was a excellent video.
The situation that is going on in Sudan 🇸🇩 was explained in its simplest terms.
Thank you!
Geopolitics feels like a pie when it's explained by Amit Sir!
Best explanation of the Sudan issue I've come across.... anywhere. Only 2 other things to add: (1)when south Sudan seceded, over 75% of the crude oil went with it. This put Sudan under a lot of economic pressure (2) COVID & Ukraine made things even worse. Covid could have been the impetus for the coup.
Lol.., its the Maericans behind it.
@@bishalburathoki8468 russia is taking the gold in sudan (wagner)
@ST0N3 X K1LL3R you're entitled to your opinion. Covid & Ukraine have put a lot of economies in trouble.
US wants to stop Russia Red Sea port for shipping oil to India.
@@bishalburathoki8468 of course.
The comprehensive and unbiased information concerning Sudan issue I've watched so far. ❤
An Indian man with excellent knowledge
He said 55 countries in Africa its 54
@@V8-br7flSo what? Doesn't discredit him being knowledgeable. You had an opportunity to provide substance but instead you've provided an ad hominem 🤦🏾♂️
Very well explained sir about the crises
I have seen so much videos of different people on the Sudan crisis
But they couldn't explain even 1% what you have explained
Your analysis are spot on and very informative
The other people just spoke about Russia base and gold
No want talk about the history
That's what make you a great geopolitical expert sir
ruclips.net/video/ZMhSvzU25fs/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/1aA_S4M3U5Q/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/u9lKQGOfUIQ/видео.html
These are all good
Prayers for Sudan! 🇸🇩 ❤
These Muslims love violence
Hey how are you doing?
Thank you very much sir for this precise, informative, comprehensive and factual summary. Much respect to you for taking the time to simply educate and report. A lot of people do not know or might not understand exactly the cause of this heartbreaking war, The constant violence is horrific and escalates daily. So everyone please, Pray for, and help in anyway you can for Sudan. It is very very dangerous and unsafe right now. It has been over the years but now it is exceptionally unsafe. Thank you all 🙏🤲 🇸🇩 ❤
Africa too many dictators wanna overstay in power
I am confident that Amit will address the Sudan crisis in his video, and I am eagerly anticipating its release. Many thanks to Amit Sengupta for shedding light on this important issue.
Operation Kaveri is already underway
With his deranged spin mixed in.
it is not like he is an intelligence expert or in the intelligence of white western countries....he just do basic research.............we all could do that
@@eltonlewis4979 Man Marrying Man Is Not Intelligence
@@eltonlewis4979 but you couldn't do that
That's what he did
Rather that praising you came with a negative thought
If you would have corrected facts or added some value or guided on approach to explain better
I would have appreciated you
But just a random thought in anyone could do
Then go and watch those uneducated RUclips shorts of those faltu people
Very good explanation. We all hope peace comes soon in Sudan. Very good people of Sudanese. God help you to understand the problem amen. ❤
I don't know what to say, but this is the best and more authentic news than the mainstream media. You deserve more than a medal. Thank you for the truth and the news.
This guy needs an award!!
To be honest, I never cam across such a clear analysis of a country's complex position in just 20mins. If you have not taken up lecturing I kindly urge you to consider😊. Nice video!!
Amit never dissapoints in his analysis. Well done!!!
Thorough, comprehensive, well-done explanation. I understood things the first time without having to rewind. Thank you.
Well done!
Great presentation and lots of information. Despite myself being from South Sudan, I couldn’t have provided such an extraordinary explanation as you have done.
Thank you for your contribution. Hopefully, you won’t mind me sharing your works. 🙏🏾
Hope for peace for you and ur country 🇮🇪
Feudalism, Feudal lords and FUDALISTIC, Tribalistic MIND SET prevailing in societies seems to be the basic faults ARAB WORLD been prone to giving rise to so much internal conflicts, internal struggling, gender discrimination.Large, Strong middle class with equal distribution of wealth and high literacy can be solution to minimise disturbances such like conflicts and bloodshed.
Sudan definitely needs Hinduism to spread and advocate for peace.
@@varunv8403 like it does in India right now? no thanks, do You know what hindu indians are doing in India to Muslim Indians on media, politics, and so many other levels?
My boyfriend went silent after the fight started,,I don't know,,no communication now confused and alone
NO-ONE in power seems to have any interest in what is best for the citizens of Sudan!! Thank you for this easy to understand summary of the Sudan situation.
Very good summary and analysis, better than what you will find in most media publications. I initially discovered this channel and Mr. Sengupta when looking up more information about India, and stayed on for everything from geography to history and geo politics. Always a thumb up!
Please make a video on the plight of Indians living in Sudan and steps taken by the Indian Government for their evacuation.
Yes precisely, beautifully explained
@@user-jn6bs2hq3u are you an Indian
Excellent video Sir - thank you. As South Africans living in a country with so many internal challenges we sometimes forget the other challenges happening on our continent. This was a very insightful and useful video to watch and learn from. Well done.
Thanks sir for the factual information
From South Sudan 🇸🇸🇸🇸🇸🇸
Thanks for highlighting us...I fully understand what's going on in Sudan right now...I am from Nigeria
I had found a lot of indian news updates and current affairs..but still then due to my lag of Hindi ..i couldn't understand with their word and wht they r talking about but after watching ur videos it makes me understand everything about the topic...i really appreciate it..❤ Keep sharing such information in a understandable way so that we could easily know everything..love u from Northeast ❣️
One of the BEST videos I have EVER watched.
Very informative, clear, detailed enough to be concise. Fantastic. I will share it for you on my Facebook etc with some professors of IR! 👏
Quite informative. It's interesting to understand how these wars starts from an independent observer.
Undoubtedly very informative, if anyone wants to know and understand what is happening in Sudan today, ya've very much explained it from the beginning to the present, beautifully and precisely, well done brav.
Looks like SAUDI UAE will support DAGALO because he is from a poor background supporting poor people, and these ARABS are interested in the GENETIC exploitationof DARKSKIN TALL SUDANESE as they have done for centuries, but AFTER the SOUTH BROKE OFF< obviously that will present a LONG TERM problem of GENETIC EXPLOITATION by SAUDI and UAE. SO to support a more BLACK president and even a MORE BLACK SUDAN, might bring back SOUTH SUDAN and in the whole provide a MORE BLACK UNTED SUDAN< that the SAUDI and UAE can EXPLOIT GENETICALLY for the preservation of their own ARAB Race in the entire UAE. SOUTH SIDAN and BLACK SUDANESE even in the SUDAN should BE AWARE of this MANIPULATION and REJECT all attempts to be EXPLOITED as a GENETIC "common well/common oasis to WATER the ARAB world!"-these are ARAB & OCCIDENT, RUSSIAN, SOUTH & EAST European GENETIC EXPLOITATION INTERESTS in these politics of BLACK GENES as their "BLACK GOLD", their "BLACK OIL" to "oil" their RACIAL POLITICS! Theyre doing this thing all over Africa with BIAFRA, SWAHILI NATION in EA, LOVE ISLAND in SA etc...none of these COLONIZINF poltics are lost on people!
Very informative...praying in Papua New Guinea for peace in Sudan and for democratically elected government for the people and by the people in Sudan.
I like indian guys explaining things in youtube, simple and informative unlike western media who themselves dont know what they talking about.
Dear Amit, thank you for such a clear and educational video. I will be sharing this video with my English students in our next open discussion, about current affairs lesson. Kindest regards.
Such a great way of using media.
@@Himachali_Protagonist yes
so u gonna steal his analysis for ur own....
@NinZA.203 passing the message/information around is not a bad thing.
@@PAPA.PARDESI , there is a SHARE aspect in YT.
Is so annoying when people think Africa is one big village. Well is not.I’m from Africa I don’t even know what the story In Sudan,but this Guy did a wonderful job to explain it. I say thank you Sir . I wish everyone in Sudan 🇸🇩 peace
Amit this really clarifies a lot of questions I had about the western narratives on Sudan. Thank you for all your tremendous work!
Which narratives?
West remains in west and there narratives along with them 😂
Theres no narrative in the West. Two Generals are fighting for power after a coup.
@@michaelx3419 Indeed. What narratives?
An excellent & very well explained synopsis of the present situation & past events in Sudan. MANY THANKS!
For a lay in politics and military affairs you have made it so easy to understand 👍🏼 great job
Fun fact - South Sudan which separated from Sudan in 2011 is youngest country in the world.
Fun Fact:
There's is no fun in the fact
another fact: Sudan was the largest country in Africa until 2011.
@@zorro5235 now that's some crazy thing
And south sudan is the oil rich part of Sudan so American foreign policy neocons knew splitting it off would weaken and sink the GDP to hurt and fragment Sudan so that it could could be turned into a U.S. client state, hence the push for diplomatic recognition during the Bush administration and accomplished by the Obama administration in 2011
The horn of africa became very important at the beginning of the 21st century, largely unexplored untapped gas and oil reserves in Somalia and Sudan
“We’re gonna take out 7 countries in five years, starting off with iraq, then Lebanon, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and finishing off with Iran”
-NATO Supreme Allied Commander General Wesley Clark (2007)
@@BluemoonSpaceRock This sounds like a part of US war Machine franchise effort
Just 10 minutes back I read an article linking Wagner Group to Sudan in The Hindu. you cleared a lot of things. Thank you!
A lot of people like to spread misinformation involving russia
God bless you, well it's not easy for we the military here, but we have to safe life's, where are you from?
@@ChrisNewman-ie6qd she is from india and she referring to getting information from The hindu newspaper which follow ideology of mainly Chinese communist
@@rankingresearchdata what a BS reply, u think, a reply to foreigner about the newspaper and they believe it. The reason is (most probably) this newspaper is only from the few ones who still writes articles (critical analysis) about ur beloved leader who still in power and who controls the majority media. Have u any idea what’s the condition of indian journalism and degrading ranking year after year..? Also this newspaper doesn’t run on government ads, but on public subscription (which means alot )
@hydra king jst five days ago, 5 soldiers of military natives of punjab martyred in jammu kashmir for the sake of india. those sikh personals also be khalistanis for u bloody sick man. The difference is punjabis are not or never be the slaves of khaki kacha goons like u are. That is why last year your beloved master made an nationwide apology in front of whole india. I feel your pain, cry hard and loud, may be your master listen you.
Very well explained. I had a different perception based on other media reports, but thank you very much for a candid explanation
Wow this probably one of the best explanations I have ever heard of this conflict.
Sir I'm your huge fan of geopolitical analysis. Hats off . All love from Nepal.
Pray for your country !!! A huge earthquake is coming!!
Brilliant fact gathering and great narration! Comprehensively put together, will be on the lookout for more from your channel 👍
Excellent analysis, journalism at best practices.
A very crucial history point you left out.Daglo originally was trader and used to protect those who pass through the desert and then he headed the paramilitary troops called janjaoid in 2003 in Darfour war against the rebels and defeated them. He never had a formal military education.
THIS is by far, the best video I've watched in years! I have been wondering what the heck is happening in Sudan and that video made things cristal clear. Excellent! I like the fact that it felt balanced and fact based. Not the usual propaganda from Western media. Very good job my friend! I will share it to ALL my friends and contacts !
When i was in the Legion i served in Africa. Rwanda, we were there in Blue Beret's as UN peace Keepers. There was really bad violence between the Hutu's and Tutsis. I have been in other war zones but Rwanda takes the win for the most shocking sites. I get flashbacks thinking about it. Lets hope this Sudan crisis doesn't go that way.
If you're comfortable, could you please describe a few sites? I'm curious.
@@shivamkumarshrivastava5182it was another US REGIME CHANGE OPERATION, which resulted in GENOCIDES.
@@benisrood Yes
@@shivamkumarshrivastava5182 Sorry Shivam, i'd rather not, it was pretty horrific. It's all I can do to not remember those things.
@@shivamkumarshrivastava5182 There is a podcast by one of the Indian army generals who was posted in Sudan as UN Peace Keeper in The Ranveer Show podcast by Ranveer Allahabadia. He describes few horrific incidents he witnessed over there, they were brutal to say the least.
Oh my god you have tremendous knowledge, I learnt geopoliticals of sudan region in single video
Thank you sir
Gifted one 🎉🎉😊😊❤
This is a very good, concise summary of the war in Sudan. The news media did not carry the background history that has started the conflict and I always wanted a better understanding of it. This is an excellent presentation.
Amit is always gem, clearly express the geopolitics
Appreciation for Sengupta Amit channel🙌🏽 Ty so much for simple explanation of foreign political events.
Thank you so much for elaborating this well. Prayers to Sudan.
This commentary is very concise, comprehensive, contained-easy to learn background, and above all, it lacked biases.
As a history teacher, I can request students watch it as a background to the underlying conflict; because it's very educative in precision; due to its impartial feature,
Thanks you.
It lacks biases? When his opening remarks was about USA controling the UN and his ending remark about the military base of Russia? Is that how a historian explain history?
Facts are bias for some.
Sudan, like many African countries, has a complex ethnic and tribal makeup. However, the country was artificially created by European colonial powers, who drew its borders without regard for these existing divisions. The result was a country with deeply rooted ethnic tensions that have simmered for decades. Documentaries about Africa often fail to provide proper details about these divisions, which are crucial to understanding the country's complex history and current state of affairs. The Sudanese government has often favored one ethnic group over another, exacerbating these tensions and leading to violent conflict. It's clear that the worst thing the colonizers did was force these groups with historical tensions together, creating a recipe for conflict and division that has plagued Sudan and other African countries for generations.
Same with Nigeria, hence her regression since independence.
Facts! The “Arabs” in the north are also black
My friend we've been waring and killing each other hundreds of years way before colonial times yes they drew boarders but we'll always be tribal waring and there's never any compromise stop with the pointing fingers you can decide yourself if you want to pick up a gun and kill people, my family moved away long ago have nice day.
@@tbos. I would say ur correct but what about a country like Somali which has same people same language, same beliefs and still kinda fucked it.
Colonial powers have nothing to do with. Before they even got involved if you weren't in the same tribe/religion you'll be killed off. Been that way since the beginning of time
Simple, clear and coincise explanation. Thank you Amit!
Edited some spelling mistakes/Typos & added a bit more context for clarification.
You missed a few key contexts that also led to this situation:
1. The government of Sudan signed the 2005 peace agreement in exchange for the hopes of lifting the sanctions, they weren't.
2. In 2003, during the negotiations of this agreement, an uprising/revolt happened in Darfur, threatening a dual civil war & crumbling of the peace talks at the time.
3. The RSF was formed during the aftermath of the Darfur revolt using deadly means to suppress it, during that time the army didn't want to be looked as the aggressor they supported & hired warring tribes as a Militia which came to be known as the Janjaweed which later became the foundation of the RSF in 2013.
3. The 1980 civil war is the second one, the first was over by signing the Addis Abba Accords in 1972, at the time an agreed version of the 2005 peace agreement in this video, it was sabotaged by the Islamist party, which took a radical & religiously motivated racist approach.
4. President Nimeiry survived a coup That lasted (3 Days) launched by the communist party, he became fearful of further attempts and sought to secure his position as president by aligning himself with the Islamists in Sudan, who slowly poached him & even tempted him with the bestowal of the title "Amir al-Mu'minin" which loosely translates to the supreme leader of the Islamic community". In 1983 President Gaafar Nimeiry Unilaterally declared All of Sudan to Fall under sharia Law as part of his broader political strategy to consolidate power and address various internal challenges. This Obviously Angered the South & directly resulted in the eruption of the Second Sudanese Civil War.
5. The Islamist movement, later forming a political party, lost Sudan's last democratic elections in 1985 but still managed to stage a coup four years later in 1989 by infiltrating the army and filling its ranks with loyal soldiers rather than properly trained ones. This infiltration marked the beginning of the movement's deep and wide control over the military. Their dominance became evident when they initiated a mysterious, bloodless coup in 1989, a premonition of their near-total control over most of the army. This control was solidified through the purging of top-ranking generals (in 1990), many of whom were better trained, educated, and free from hidden associations with foreign entities like the Muslim Brotherhood. Those who stood in the way were executed in secret, instant military tribunals, leading to one of the most devastating impacts on the Sudanese army in its history.
6. With the army in their control, the Civilian members of the Islamist movement formed a party under Hassan al Turabi, who was later confirmed to be the true mastermind behind orchestrating the coup & plan origin, formed a government backed by the newly reformed army under their total control became the sole political player in the country for 29 years.
The Coup dissolved the Democratic Government, The National Assembly, All Political Parties, suspension of All Civil Liberties & dissolution of all Trade Unions and Professional Associations.
7. Omar Al Bashir was nominated by Hassan al Turabi to lead the coup and subsequently became the Chairman of the Revolutionary Command Council for National Salvation, Prime Minister of Sudan (later president of Sudan when the position was abolished), Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces which gave him ultimate power to run the country allowing him to govern Sudan with little to no opposition from other branches of government.
we can all go read up on that information if we want to find out more. Most people don't want to.make it too long. That would make it a 40 minute video and I'm.sure.he didn't want to make it that long
Mo Za. Ty for the very interesting background story. So many questions for a complex history of a culture of tribes and intricacies unrelatable by westerners.
If you leave out the fact that the US pulled thee strings, in spite of all that valuable information -- the heart of the story is missing.
I'm from Canada, and I didn't know ANY of that.
It puts the violence in Sudan into a far sharper perspective.
Aaaaaaaa
So clear and lucid !!! You would make a great teacher
Very well explained. Thanks
“When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace,” Jimi Hendrix.
Thank you Amit, your Explanation of current events in Sudan, was, is, so very much appreciated. Also, your lesson of Sudan's history last twenty years, was extraordinarily through in helping us understand over here in America, Why and how this Civil War has come about. Thanks Amit, Peace and blessings to you Sir. 🌎💕🎼🍀
Great explanation about Sudan history politics, economics, govt. and the present crisis.
Merci beaucoup. This video, along with others, gave me a better understanding of this conflict. I'm hoping for a fast resolution of this conflict, for the Sudanese people's sake.
Missing on UAE involvement
@@skp8748 Elaborate?
@@SagarRawat-bt3ig they fund the rsf and used them in yemen
Very fine presentation ! I had no clue about the situation in Sudan. Now I'm well informed. Thank you !
This is the first comprehensive and informative video I've met in RUclips I'd watch it over and over
This is very much informative🎉Thank you sir..... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Now I have no confusion about SUDAN and IT'S CIVIL WAR..... 😊
i just watched mahipal rathods video a while back and i can say your analysis throws his video out of the window !!! satva triumphs over rajas i.e ones passion and honesty towards teaching defeats people who sell courses for a living because they make videos on hot topics and you make videos because of your passion towards geo politics and teaching.
Well researched and explained. A bird's eye view of recent history. Thanks, Amit
Amit sir*
This couldn't have been explained in a better and crisp manner..kudos to Mr Amit
Wow thank you so much for your in-depth analysis . You certainly put a lot of work into this report . It helped me see why all this is happening.
Mr. Sengupta , U have set an example to the Western media how neutral investigative reporting should be done.
Thank U.
Thank you for the concise, nuanced explanation of the crisis in Sudan and the role that Western nations and global NGOs play in this conflict.
I must say I’m really impressed by your documentary, you did a great job just perfect
It was really informative.Thank you for telling all the pros and cons about Sudan.
i feel so sad what now happening in sudan. i had lived in Sudan 14 years ago for almost 4 years , at that time Khartoum was fully peace, we were drinking some coffee from mama ( haja) on the streets , enjoining some Sudanese music comes across the restaurants (matam) . I have good memories. I hope and pray for Sudan, all peace come.
DAMN! This is like listening to "The Story of Nigeria".
Hey how are you doing?
No way, not related in any way
This video helped me to understand what’s going on. thanks a lot
Damn, This was one of the more informative videos ive ever seen , keep up the good work man!
This video lays the facts bare and clear for everyone. Thank you for this!!!
Thanks for your indepth analysis. It is highly educative.
Highly bias is more like it.
When an educational video gets 3 million❤ it clearly shows how informative it is❤
But this video doesn't have 3m views
Thank you for these information, an African from Nigeria to be precise, this piece of info worth much for me, I pray for peace in those areas, including Ukraine/Rusia and across the glob🙏
Thank you for the well condensed short history on Sudan.
Two days ago, CBS news published an article stating that Pentagon is considering sending American troops to Sudan to rescue American citizens.
I interpret it to mean that some American troops are already on the theater in Sudan.
Waiting for your video on Sudan. Very informative input as always. Thank you so much, Amit sir.😇❤️
Although I'll have to watch this a few times over this is very good at explaining things
Great job 👍
Darfur is a rich region in terms of mineral and gold and there is a proof (pictures) that Wagner is operating in Sudan and various other places in Sahel region. Darfur is inhabited mostly by native African tribes and wanted get separated or autonomous but dagalo who is Sudanese Arab brutally crushed rebellion and gets tag of paramilitary. You explained very clearly and detailed and about tribes will helpful in upcoming exams
Look at you. And US has not tried to interfere in Sudan at all. Riiiight. Point fingers at Wagner but leave US, Israel, England and France out of the picture? Ha. They try to meddle in Sudan as well. Also for Gold, and Uranium, water and agriculture. It is well documented.
Don’t forget to right that down in your exam.
We as Sudanese hate interfering in ANY nation’s internal affairs. And we certainly don’t like any nation interfering in ours. We welcome constructive advice. That’s where the interference starts and ends.
When you give studip mans a rifle, than they turn to became a God base on their books😅
@@malumuon't ever give a studip man a rifle!
@@satti80 cry more
@@satti80 17 years old account😮
Thanks for your "tell it all" analysis. Bravo!
Very well described. About Sudan and other African countries, Indian people know less. But as an Indian, Sir, you have described so easily which means that Your knowledge about Africa is vast.
Wow !! I tried Diplomatic DIspatch of Sansad Tv ,"start Here" of Al-Jazera and a couple of international articles. But no one could explain this issue in a simplistic manner as you. It is so simple yet comprehensive. Thank you, sir ☺
For me it's still a big mess i don't understand their strategies and plans so many names this come from there he from here they say same think different. I wipp follow this longer so i can make conclusion.
@@фене sure learn more..but don't make conclusion right now..just observe ..as it's ongoing civil war. It might be suffice for me as I followed 2019 sudan Prostest ,so I had some idea of past
Are you a college history professor??? If not, you should be...I have never heard a more concise, simple, and to the point explanation of an event...I now understand completely what is going on in Sudan...unlike the news medias that use bias and omit facts...
Agreed. If only I had teachers like him at school and college, I would have been more knowledgeable.