Yulianna Avdeeva is a marvellous pianist! And this one and a half hour long uptaking is a wonderful gift to all of us. Thank you, Teodor Currentzis and SWR Symphonieorchester!
Je ne connaissais pas pour ma part cette merveilleuse pianiste qui domine magnifiquement ce concerto n° 3 de Prokofiev, c'est brillant. Quand au chef Theodor Currentzis, il est comme a son habitude parfait et doué d'une écoute et d'une direction remarquable.
Yulianna Avdeeva for being Yulianna Avdeeva! All her performances always connect composers - this is the one that she has distinguished for herself as a musician. I hope we can continue to listen to her genuine sound.
It is strange - there was a long stretch of several decades in which it seemed that no pianists had any new ideas at all about how to play this concerto. You totally knew what to expect, which was a lot of blunt force and maximum speed with just an occasional touch of grace and nuance, and certainly nothing very original. Now, in the last few years, with fantastically detailed and thoughtful performances like this, is almost as if it is a brand new piece instead of an old warhorse. I love it! It makes me wonder - was I just not listening very closely for all those years, or was it really like that? Congratulations to Avdeeva, Currentzis, and the wonderful orchestra on a remarkable performance!
For me this revolution came when I bought my relatively expensive head phones. Yes, it is as simple as that. Suddely I was sitting in the audience, noticing all on stage, and also all in the audience. Like if I were there, really.
Just incredible beautiful!!!! Thank you so much!!!! Πολλά Συγχαρητήρια και Μπράβο σε όλη την υπέροχη ορχήστρα και στον μοναδικό υπέροχο Μαέστρο!!!! 💖 💖 💖
Благодарю!💐 Мой вечер сегодня наполнился радостью и хорошим настроением от встречи с произведениями величайших музыкальных классиков С. Прокофьева и Ф. Шопена и их первоклассной интерпретацией оркестром под руководством Т. Курентзиса! Спасибо)))👏
Pure Prokofievan magic! Ms Avdeeva's playing is immaculate. Her tempi in the 2nd movement are a bit faster than I have usually heard, but her version is good. Maestro Currentzis conducted a very pleasant and refined 5th symphony, and I think that this performance will be my first choice for a long time.Before this I listened to Gergiev with the Mariinsky on Euroarts (part of the complete symphonies as the orchestra's "Easter gifts to Russian people"). Thank you!
This performance is both electric and reflective. It breathes, it has a clarity, especially by the pianist (new to me, and astonishingly good), in which the piano doesn't overpower the orchestra, nor vice-versa. I've been listening to this, recorded, for 55 or 60 years, starting with an LP in a "Recording of the Century" series (Angel? London? Decca? DG?) in which Prokoviev was the soloist. After a bit, I came to feel that his performance was not the best; or maybe the sound quality was noticeably deficient--I was less discerning then. But in all the other recordings I've heard since, no matter how well played, it came to seem (as "alkanist" says below) a warhorse. Now it lives again to my ears. Brava! to Ms. Avdeeva.
Исполнение концерта Прокофьева, считаю, вполне можно назвать хрестоматийным. Пианистка очень грамотно играет, пианистические движения все очень точные (мне очень понравилось работа с весом), в общем, приятно и слушать, и смотреть. Оркестр отработал великолепно. Спасибо за удовольствие!
Σε τι κόσμους μας ταξιδεύει ο κ. Κουρεντζής! Για να μπορείς να διατρέχεις την "κλασσική " μουσική από τον Πέρσελ έως τον Προκόπιεφ με τέτοια αποτελέσματα σημαίνει το λιγότερο ότι είσαι βαθύς γνώστης- μελετητής. Η κ. Avdeeva ΕΞΑΙΡΕΤΙΚΉ. Υπέροχο κλαρινέτο, υπέροχα πνευστά.
The excellent Y. Avdeeva proves that even a woman and musician who, unlike the always half-naked Yuja Wang, who, unlike the always half-naked Yuja Wang, appears serious and without glamour, can offer a wonderful interpretation of Prokofiev's 3rd Piano Concerto.
That's how it supposed to be: selection of the masters of all kinds should be made by their talent and skills no matter which social group they represent. Not the opposite way, when THOSE try to be "fair" artificially creating the quotas ...
I can't quite identify what makes this so, but this performance seems especially open and accessible compared to other performances of the same piece. Truly enjoyable!
It is always a privilege to hear Yulianna Avdeeva in concert. The closing of this Prokofiev concerto suggests that the soloist must have fingers, knuckles, wrists, forearms, elbows, shoulders of steel. Really amazing. And speaking of this symphony, isn't the second movement one of the most remarkable in the 20th Century? And played so well here by SW German Radio. Thanks for sharing via your YT channel! All the Best from Washington, DC.
Hallo SWR. Ich möchte mich noch einmal ganz herzlich für dieses Video bedanken. Was für ein wunderbarer Dirigent Teodor Currentzis ist! Er, das Orchester und der Solist bringen uns die Geschichte, die der Komponist mit Noten erzählte. Das ist einzigartig. Herzliche Grüße von Ihrem Nachbarn in Ihrem Nachbarland, den Niederlanden. 🌷🌷🌷🎹🎼🎶 (Das ist meine Deutschschule! 😊)
И как всегда у Теодора Курентзиса замечательный концерт! Юлия прекрасна! Теодор- СЕРДЦЕ МУЗЫКИ! ОН как главный Инструмент Оркестра, всем телом своим, всей душой передаёт Звуки музыки!!! СасиБо !Спасибо! СпасиБо !
Currentzis allège le final de la 5e en lui donnant un ton plus haletant que triomphal. Il compense avec la Danse des Chevaliers en bis. Choix intelligent. Tout le concert est bien.
Julianna ("Y") played the 2nd movement like a meditation. It's a beautiful and genius piece of music. Besides that: one of the guys on cello looks a little bit like Barenboim....😀
Θοδωρη μου εισαι συγκλονιστικος δεν ξερω εαν θα δια βασεις ποτε τα ποιηματα που σου στελνω αλα ελπιζω αυτο το εγραψα μετα απο την παρακολουθηση της συναυλια σου στο στελνω Μεσα σε αυτον τον λαβυρινθο της γνωσης γιατι δεν γνωριζουμε τιποτα συναντιομαστε στα νεκροταφεια της συνηδεισης και ανταλαζουμε σκεψεις με ερωτηματικα ασυνηδειτα η ομορφια ενα τοσο φευγαλεο ψεμα γινεται αληθεια στο αιωνιο τωρα οταν μας ερωτευεται ο φακος της υπαρξης προβαλουμε την εικονα μας στο απειρο μας συνεπερνει ο ηχος του μυστηριου σε χορο πρωτογονο ανοιγουμε φτερα στο ρυθμο ειναι η μαγια της εμπνευσης που μας συντριβει αναταση μια επελαση φωτος λευκου ακτιστου ολες οι μορφες σε μια εμφανιζονται στο παρον ο χρονος σαν πουλι μεταναστευει στο μελλον κτιζει φωλιες στα ονειρα εκει που νομιζεις πως επιασες το νοημα ολο σου ξεφευγει τι περιεργη αληλουχια καθως τα φωτα του δρομου σβηνουνε ανατελλει ο ηλιος απο την ψυχη αυτη η πτωση μας σημαδεψε μας εριξε στου Υφαιστου τη φωτια στον παραδεισο των αισθησεων γεννηθηκε ο πονος
Yulianna Avdeeva is a marvellous pianist! And this one and a half hour long uptaking is a wonderful gift to all of us. Thank you, Teodor Currentzis and SWR Symphonieorchester!
Note Yuliannas smile at 17:03. Evidently she and Teodor are working good together.
Невероятный, любимый Теодор. Прекрасная Юлия. Потрясающий оркестр. И - гениальный ПРОКОФЬЕВ. Всё совпало. Забыла дышать. БРАВО!!!
Music is love and happiness! Magic! Thank you!👏🏼👏🏼💐💐🥰😍
This should be on record - ideally as a box-set with all Prokofjew piano concertos. Brilliant! Inspiring! Uplifting!
Ноктюрн Шопена - просто до слез: и музыка, и исполнение. Браво! И оркестр выше всяких похвал.
Thank you very much!
Я влюбилась в этого юношу сегодня на программе Энигма и с удовольствием слушаю и смотрю все его работы
Great pianist with power and personality, amazing how she sitting so high at the piano with maximum comfort.
Je ne connaissais pas pour ma part cette merveilleuse pianiste qui domine magnifiquement ce concerto n° 3 de Prokofiev, c'est brillant. Quand au chef Theodor Currentzis, il est comme a son habitude parfait et doué d'une écoute et d'une direction remarquable.
Большое спасибо!!!Прекрасный концерт! Браво оркестру! Браво, Юлианна! Браво, Теодор!!!
Yulianna Avdeeva for being Yulianna Avdeeva! All her performances always connect composers - this is the one that she has distinguished for herself as a musician. I hope we can continue to listen to her genuine sound.
Absolutely beautiful
The nocturn almost made me cry. Well It's Yulianna playing Chopin. It is so hard to cope with this combination.
Congratulations for a brilliant performance! Thank you for sharing it with us!
It is strange - there was a long stretch of several decades in which it seemed that no pianists had any new ideas at all about how to play this concerto. You totally knew what to expect, which was a lot of blunt force and maximum speed with just an occasional touch of grace and nuance, and certainly nothing very original. Now, in the last few years, with fantastically detailed and thoughtful performances like this, is almost as if it is a brand new piece instead of an old warhorse. I love it! It makes me wonder - was I just not listening very closely for all those years, or was it really like that?
Congratulations to Avdeeva, Currentzis, and the wonderful orchestra on a remarkable performance!
Beautiful! Refreshingly lyrical, accurate and the bravura is very well contained. Loved it!!
You said it all, alkanista! I feel exactly the same about this concerto and this performance
Your comment reads as if you had preferably heard Yuja Wang. Listen to the work with D. Trifonov, he is also convincing.
For me this revolution came when I bought my relatively expensive head phones. Yes, it is as simple as that. Suddely I was sitting in the audience, noticing all on stage, and also all in the audience. Like if I were there, really.
Fabuleuse et un orchestre merveilleux !
Sergej Prokofjew and Yulianna Avdeeva are a perfect match!
Incredible pianist! Incredible Orchestra!! Incredible Currentzis!!! OUTSTANDING!!!
Замечательный Прокофьев, волшебный оркестр, изумительная Юлия, восхитительный Маэстро! Всем огромное спасибо!!!
Just incredible beautiful!!!! Thank you so much!!!!
Πολλά Συγχαρητήρια και Μπράβο σε όλη την υπέροχη ορχήστρα και στον μοναδικό υπέροχο Μαέστρο!!!! 💖 💖 💖
Bravo, graceful and playful! A true delight
Благодарю!💐 Мой вечер сегодня наполнился радостью и хорошим настроением от встречи с произведениями величайших музыкальных классиков С. Прокофьева и Ф. Шопена и их первоклассной интерпретацией оркестром под руководством Т. Курентзиса! Спасибо)))👏
Очень чувственно,экспрессивно,ярко!Браво,Маэстро,браво,Солисты,браво, Оркестр!
Несмолкаемые овации💫💫💫💫💫💫💫сложнейший Прокофьев в полёте 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻etc
Best conductor today!
Passionate and beautiful performance！
Magnifico concerto e una superba quinta sinfonia!
С каким огромным удовольствием я смотрю записи swr classiс. Обожаю Курентзис а и все, что он делает
Pure Prokofievan magic!
Ms Avdeeva's playing is immaculate. Her tempi in the 2nd movement are a bit faster than I have usually heard, but her version is good.
Maestro Currentzis conducted a very pleasant and refined 5th symphony, and I think that this performance will be my first choice for a long time.Before this I listened to Gergiev with the Mariinsky on Euroarts (part of the complete symphonies as the orchestra's "Easter gifts to Russian people").
Thank you!
Какой подарок!!! Восторг полный🙏🙏🙏
This was far far the best interpretation of Prokofiev no. 3 I´ve ever heard. Pure music.
Hi @endo1987! Thank you, we are glad that you like it! 😊
This performance is both electric and reflective. It breathes, it has a clarity, especially by the pianist (new to me, and astonishingly good), in which the piano doesn't overpower the orchestra, nor vice-versa. I've been listening to this, recorded, for 55 or 60 years, starting with an LP in a "Recording of the Century" series (Angel? London? Decca? DG?) in which Prokoviev was the soloist. After a bit, I came to feel that his performance was not the best; or maybe the sound quality was noticeably deficient--I was less discerning then. But in all the other recordings I've heard since, no matter how well played, it came to seem (as "alkanist" says below) a warhorse. Now it lives again to my ears. Brava! to Ms. Avdeeva.
Наслаждение и восторг!Браво!
very nice!! thank you!
Браво, маэстро😍 и в ушах
Great concert! ❤👏👏👏
Музыка , чудесный язык ,который понятен всем, вне зависимости от места . ..пусть она объединяет...
I’m loving this and Teodor.
Исполнение концерта Прокофьева, считаю, вполне можно назвать хрестоматийным. Пианистка очень грамотно играет, пианистические движения все очень точные (мне очень понравилось работа с весом), в общем, приятно и слушать, и смотреть. Оркестр отработал великолепно. Спасибо за удовольствие!
有機的で血潮たぎり、かつ高度に知的、驚くべきプロコフィエフ。次元の違う演奏だ。巨大な音量でも驚くほどクリアーでピュア。ピアノも同質で見事。
Brava Avdeeva!!!!
Σε τι κόσμους μας ταξιδεύει ο κ. Κουρεντζής!
Για να μπορείς να διατρέχεις την "κλασσική " μουσική από τον Πέρσελ έως τον Προκόπιεφ με τέτοια αποτελέσματα σημαίνει το λιγότερο ότι είσαι βαθύς γνώστης- μελετητής.
Η κ. Avdeeva ΕΞΑΙΡΕΤΙΚΉ.
Υπέροχο κλαρινέτο, υπέροχα πνευστά.
Thank you so much! 🥰
The excellent Y. Avdeeva proves that even a woman and musician who, unlike the always half-naked Yuja Wang,
who, unlike the always half-naked Yuja Wang, appears serious and without glamour, can offer a wonderful interpretation of Prokofiev's 3rd Piano Concerto.
That's how it supposed to be: selection of the masters of all kinds should be made by their talent and skills no matter which social group they represent. Not the opposite way, when THOSE try to be "fair" artificially creating the quotas ...
I can't quite identify what makes this so, but this performance seems especially open and accessible compared to other performances of the same piece. Truly enjoyable!
Their musical phrasing are more clear than normal performance of the pieces.
BRAVA!!!!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Brilliant concert and also one of the best recorded live concerts I've heard in a while. Thank you!
Enchanted!
Великолепно..Теоооо моя любовь.))
It is always a privilege to hear Yulianna Avdeeva in concert. The closing of this Prokofiev concerto suggests that the soloist must have fingers, knuckles, wrists, forearms, elbows, shoulders of steel. Really amazing. And speaking of this symphony, isn't the second movement one of the most remarkable in the 20th Century? And played so well here by SW German Radio. Thanks for sharing via your YT channel! All the Best from Washington, DC.
Hallo SWR. Ich möchte mich noch einmal ganz herzlich für dieses Video bedanken. Was für ein wunderbarer Dirigent Teodor Currentzis ist! Er, das Orchester und der Solist bringen uns die Geschichte, die der Komponist mit Noten erzählte. Das ist einzigartig. Herzliche Grüße von Ihrem Nachbarn in Ihrem Nachbarland, den Niederlanden. 🌷🌷🌷🎹🎼🎶 (Das ist meine Deutschschule! 😊)
Ganz herzlichen Dank für das Lob und den ausführlichen Kommentar! Wie schön, dass dir unsere Videoproduktionen so gefallen!
🙏🙏Συγχαρητήρια!!!💖
И как всегда у Теодора Курентзиса замечательный концерт! Юлия прекрасна! Теодор- СЕРДЦЕ МУЗЫКИ! ОН как главный Инструмент Оркестра, всем телом своим, всей душой передаёт Звуки музыки!!! СасиБо !Спасибо! СпасиБо !
Holy S. This is insane 🎉🎉🎉
Гениально. Шквал энергии
Avdeeva is simply brilliant 👏
Высочайший уровень исполнения! Как хотелось бы послушать в исполнении этого оркестра Мясковского или Скрябина. Спасибо огромное!
Bravissima !! ❤️
Es sin duda una de las mejores pianistas actuales luego de Yuja Wang. Técnica perfecta y mucho sentimiento
Excelente!!!!
Currentzis allège le final de la 5e en lui donnant un ton plus haletant que triomphal. Il compense avec la Danse des Chevaliers en bis. Choix intelligent. Tout le concert est bien.
Απλά Υπέροχο!
Que bonito bailas Currentzis
Yulianna 님,한국 방문을 환영합니다.❤❤❤❤ 😊😊😊😊
BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!
Отлично
Julianna ("Y") played the 2nd movement like a meditation. It's a beautiful and genius piece of music. Besides that: one of the guys on cello looks a little bit like Barenboim....😀
Браво!!!
❤yulianna ❤
ROMEO und JULiA sind großartig
Отмечена субъективно особая красота на 5-ой минуте/
The soloist's name is not seen in the video until the very end of the concert and is buried in the description; it's Julianna Andeeva.
Thank you for your comment - we have changed the title.
AVdeeva *
❤❤❤ 😊😊😊
Θοδωρη μου εισαι συγκλονιστικος δεν ξερω εαν θα δια βασεις ποτε τα ποιηματα που σου στελνω αλα ελπιζω αυτο το εγραψα μετα απο την παρακολουθηση της συναυλια σου στο στελνω Μεσα σε αυτον τον λαβυρινθο της γνωσης γιατι δεν γνωριζουμε τιποτα συναντιομαστε στα νεκροταφεια της συνηδεισης και ανταλαζουμε σκεψεις με ερωτηματικα ασυνηδειτα η ομορφια ενα τοσο φευγαλεο ψεμα γινεται αληθεια στο αιωνιο τωρα οταν μας ερωτευεται ο φακος της υπαρξης προβαλουμε την εικονα μας στο απειρο μας συνεπερνει ο ηχος του μυστηριου σε χορο πρωτογονο ανοιγουμε φτερα στο ρυθμο ειναι η μαγια της εμπνευσης που μας συντριβει αναταση μια επελαση φωτος λευκου ακτιστου ολες οι μορφες σε μια εμφανιζονται στο παρον ο χρονος σαν πουλι μεταναστευει στο μελλον κτιζει φωλιες στα ονειρα εκει που νομιζεις πως επιασες το νοημα ολο σου ξεφευγει τι περιεργη αληλουχια καθως τα φωτα του δρομου σβηνουνε ανατελλει ο ηλιος απο την ψυχη αυτη η πτωση μας σημαδεψε μας εριξε στου Υφαιστου τη φωτια στον παραδεισο των αισθησεων γεννηθηκε ο πονος
Like 800😉
Низкийпоклонкурентзтзису
Ιδιοφυΐα! Ξεχνάω να αναπνέω και εγώ.
Простите: какаой оркестр? Штутгартский?
Да, оркестр Югозападного радио из Штутгарта.
ゲルギエフになりたいのかな。
6:08
Спасибо. Исполнение хорошее. Не потрясающее. Авдеева не Крайнев. Оркестр прекрасен и нихе "очень хорошо" играть не умеет.)))
◑ 🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊 ◐
Sotnikova robbed yuan's gold medal in Sochi. Juliana stoled Trifnov's first prize in Warsaw. Ashamed on Russia decayed refree.
Everything is perfect, except for the music.
????.... explain !