what if the F1 CHAMPION was BANNED like F2? (Part 2)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- Watch Part 1: • what if the F1 CHAMPIO...
Last week we asked the question "What if you could only win the F1 Driver's Championship once?".
How would the history of the sport be different when greats like Senna, Schumacher and Hamilton can only win 1 title? Who has the most wins all time? Does Nico Hulkenberg still have 0 podiums?
Part 2 takes us from 1990 to today, let's find out...
Support on Patreon: / mrvsgarage
Twitch: / theoriginalmrv
Follow the Channel: / mrvs_garage
Follow Mr V: / samroberts.v
Follow Mr V: / samroberts_v
#f1
00:00 I recalculated the entire history of F1
01:18 1990s
06:36 2000s
12:38 2010s
18:30 2020s
21:06 New Records
23:14 Posthumous Champions 
Авто/Мото
David Coulthard crashing into the pitlane to hand the championship to Johnnny Herbert is the most Johnny Herbert way you can win a world championship.
Truly one of the most bizarre ways to win a championship
@@RandomGuy37 Similar to how Makinen was going to go home after he thought Sainz would easily win the title, but then a friend came on the phone saying the Toyota Corolla Sainz was driving had blown up. Makinen thought the friend was kidding him, but then some reporters started telling him as well and he realised it was true. Probably the most dramatic title deciders in motorsports. The WRC equivalent of Man City vs QPR.
@@potatogirlcultist19 one in a million of a corolla blowing up he was unlucky
And the most DC way to lose a championship
😂😂😂
Shoutout to Phil Hill, the only person in this to actually lose his 1 championship
Wait what?
Lost it to our first posthumous champion, Rest in Power Wolfgang von Trips
@@ri0916That has to be the coolest name for an f1 driver
61 is an interesting year, in this version Hill gets more points over the season but bc of the pick the best 5 out of the 8 races, Von Trips gets the title
And we get the controversy way earlier than in reality
Honestly fairly well deserved seeing as he wasn't particularly impressive in any of the other seasons
I love how 2012 is STILL the greatest season even in this universe
A 5 way-title fight with HULKENBERG winning?
Absolute heaven
I wanna live in this universe!
Hulk still gets his podium curse, winning with the lowest ever podium rate for a champion
Vettel's memory would seriously be put to the test trying to name all these champions 😂
Yuki Tsunoda got his first F1 win today at the 2024 Miami Grand Prix! Crazy how it's a first win in both parallel universes.
Yeah, doing a google sheet of this season without world champions and the fact that the Alpine cars are in the podium.
The Verstappen jumpscare made me choke on a tangerine
How ironic if you were taken out by something orange 🍊
@@MrVsGarage2012 should be Grosjean not Hulkenberg, and 2013 should be Hulkenberg not Grosjean
Which are you LGBTQIA or +?
@@jcoxdjcould you show some context? I don’t understand how that question is relevant here
Be careful, tangerines are very dangerous when scared and cornered in your mouth!
It's absolutely insane that Massa wins the final race in Brazil and loses the championship at the same time - just in 2006 and 2007 instead of 2008!
just Felipe baby things.
2006: A strange rookie no one ever heard about called Arnando Felonso appears.
Crazy that Ollie Bearman was able to jump in a random car halfway through the weekend and somehow get a miraculous P2.
As both Sainz and Leclerc already won their championships, the only race that Ferrari has entered so far was the Saudi Arabia GP with Ollie
@@dudagladuosinteresting decision from Ferrari to enter their only race of the season with an academy driver halfway through a weekend
@@robertlatta2019 Crazy how good a car they built for not entering a race in several years!
finally, i couldn't live without this conclusion
tbh I was thinking about this 2 years ago
can massa win a cahmpionship ?yeaa
@@o.faruksavaf he is legit Champions of 2008 I Hope justice will be made and he can get credit as he should
@@russonauta totally agree ,I want a Ferrari champion in the year I was born also he is King of Istanbulpark (home city)
Nico Hulkenburg winning a title while Nick Heidfeld does not is brutal. But at least those 8 2nd places became 8 wins for him :')
Fun fact, Heidfeld and Heinz Harald Frentzen come from the same City in Germany called Mönchengladbach. And thats the city where i live.
@@bemolp7498 How this is fun? Interesting maybe for someone, but fun......?
@@mirvan23oh c'mon nobody says " interesting fact" it's always "fun fact" let them have it
@@mirvan23 fun fact being pedantc is boring
I love this genre of Mr. V being our tour guide into the parallel universes of F1.
This has been the best use of Microsoft Excel in F1 since being Williams' enterprise resource planning platform.
I mean, I would argue I'm having a bit more success with it than Williams... 👀
I’m gonna need a community post at the end of the year announcing Piastri (probably) as this years champion without any context
Red Bull just knew about this alternative timeline and thats why they kept switching their #2 driver
Other teams playing checkers while Red Bull is out here playing 4D chess
Me: if some fast cars are banned, surely Hulkenberg will get a podium or two
Hulkenberg: GETS THE TITLE
Crazy how Lance Stroll did not win a single championship in this weird but amazing universe.
I'm guessing Piastri will win the 2024 season. I'm also surprised Kubica didn't win a championship.
@@CrusardModding he did in the alternative 2008 season
@@matteo_lll_di_sveviadid you watch the video? No he didn’t
@@CrusardModdingI think stroll would win the 2025 championship assuming that drivers like Lawson, Bearman and Antonelli would be placed in backmarker teams
Edit:either way he might be considered one of the greatest to never win a championship(TBF in this world he’s gonna have a lot of wins)
@@matteo_lll_di_sveviamate watch the video 😂😂
I love the storytelling you bring to this. It could so easily have been a simple rundown of the champions, but you bring the real life events into this parallel timeline to weave compelling narratives that would be the talk of the F1 World. That Massa stretch from 2006-2008 is especially compelling, particularly considering the real life 2008 Brazil GP. Bravo, Mr V!
F1 is all about the stories, it's what makes the sport magical. And so it was only right to look into the numbers and figure out the new stories
Nico Hulkenberg winning the championship made me hope for his first podium IRL
I like how in even this alternate reality max is a record breaking god
And even in this universe Hülkenberg has a very bad podium rate
Because he's an extremely consistent driver and has been pretty much since before he was 20.
In 2017, whenever he finished a race without severe mitigating circumstances (strategy at Monaco and Massa terrorism at Monza), he never finished behind a slower or equal car.
In 2018, whenever he finished a race without a skill issue (Australia spin, China crash, and Monaco FP3 crash), he never finished behind a slower or equal car. [This is the only time I have to exclude skill issues - the six race stretch to start the season is almost inarguably his worst stretch of races in his career, especially when considering races he finished. Hilariously, in this alternate timeline, he wins three of the four races he finished during that stretch, only finishing behind Ocon and Gasly at Monaco.]
In 2019 and 2020, whenever he finished a race without severe mitigating circumstances (Vettel terrorism at Silverstone 2019, engine penalty and Perez terrorism at Monza 2019, Bottas terrorism at Mexico 2019, and an asymmetrical front wing at Turkey 2020), he never finished behind a slower or equal car.
In 2021, he finished a race without severe mitigating circumstances (Bottas terrorism in Hungary) behind an equal car once (Hamilton at Bahrain) and behind a slower car zero times.
In 2022, whenever he finished a race without severe mitigating circumstances (Perez Q3 red flag at Monaco, blocked Venturi tunnel at Silverstone, qualifying strategy blunder at Singapore, setup issues at Brazil), he won.
In 2023, he finished a race without severe mitigating circumstances (Q2 engine failure at Jeddah and setup issues at Singapore) behind another car once (Perez at Baku).
So far in 2024, whenever he's finished a race, he's won.
the Massa winning in 2008 and losing emotionally in Brazil before jokes, the Hulkenberg podium jokes.....unbelievable
I think the metrics used to rate the goat in this timeline would be:
1. The fewest seasons to take the championship
2. Win percentage
3. Podium percentage
I am very curious who that is
Max. At least that is what it said at the end
@@MrRono19 you read that wrong.
1. Fewest seasons would be 1. This puts Stewart, Regazzoni, Villeneuve, and Hamilton tied
2. Win percentage for rookie winners.. CR was 75%, JV was 68%, LH was 52%, and JS was 40%
Don't forget that Clay Regazzoni also won F2 the same season he won F1 and only drove in 8/15 F1 races that year. Surely he has to be the GOAT
The weirdest part of this timeline: 19:46 Michael Masi follows all procedures correctly!
It's actually way funnier (and way worse) than real life - the safety car mistakenly picks up the nearly lapped Lando Norris, putting Sainz nearly a whole lap ahead of Lando (as well as Esteban Ocon), and the race director fails to wave the two cars through, which would be the standard procedure. Only after fierce lobbying from McLaren team principal Zak Brown did the race director finally order the safety car to give Norris and Ocon the wave through - but with only two laps until the checkered flag, and the fast pace of the safety car, Norris and Ocon were utterly unable to catch back up to the queue, with Norris finishing 55 seconds behind Sainz, never having an opportunity to attack for the win and the championship.
It took a while, but I found out who the GOAT of f1 is. Obviously, it's Mr. V
it's RPM actually
Yes RPM is the GOAT
Drivers who survive due to getting banned:
Peter Collins: 2 years before death
Luigi Musso: 1 year before death
Harry Schell: 2 years before death (likely)
Jim Clark: 5 years before death (likely)
Jochen Rindt: 4 years before death
Ronnie Peterson: 7 years before death
Gilles Villenueve: 3 years before death
Elio de Angelis: 2 years before death
Ayrton Senna: 7 years before death
I only added the ones who died in F1 events/testing specifically but yes, there's lots 😔
13:46 is where the men cried tears of joy
All it took was a chance to the space-time continuum and Hülkenberg finally got his podium
@@MrVsGarageyou a doctor who fan?
I love the idea that Mercedes wouldn't compete for multiple years and then comeback with Russell to immediately win the championship and leave the sport again
About time. stuck on this cliffhanger for a bit.
Based on this video, it'd be interesting if F1 took the Vendee Globe model (the Vendee Globe is a 4-yearly round-the-world sailing race), where the reigning champion is forced to sit out the next edition, but can then freely compete after that. Unless they win again, in which case they are again forced to sit out a race.
Very good idea, looks like I'm busting out a new excel sheet! Don't expect any videos from me on the subject like this one though. I can't edit
gotta love that 2017 has a close title fight between current teammates Perez and Verstappen. Especially with Perez managing to pick up the title.
Agree 👍🏻 Vamos Checo 🇲🇽
Also It’s amazing to see Lando,Alex,Carlos,George and Charles Winning a title
Hope in real life,we will see a championship fight
what 2017/18 Renault engine does to a mf
If real life applies this system, I think it would be great to have a higher series, maybe Formula Legacy where only World Championship driver battle each other
but it would just become the new f1. It would be the same as only F2 champions can drive in F1.
I was thinking about it but I believe it would turn to be the new F1 Championship. Unless there was a twist like equal machinery for all drivers, less races, also the need for elimination because, remember, there would be a new retiring champion every year! In general it would be suitable as a ceremonial championship and not a really competitive one
@@panossavvaidis6086 OH THAT is great idea
Makes a point that maybe only drivers who have won F2 should be allowed to compete and they are then guaranteed a seat, by enforcing a rule that the driver who's been in F1 the longest must retire to make way.
@@samueldorrington8990 this rule would not apply to Alonso
I can easily live in this universe. Nico, Checo, Mark Webber, DC and Daniel win the WDC, Max breaks records, Schumacher doesn't do illegal things and most importantly Phil Hill doesn't win the title. Mr V, thank you for this amazing universe, where Danny Ric, Checo and DC become Champions.
It's funny - in a universe where Phil Hill probably *wouldn't* be the worst driver to become champion, he doesn't become champion.
Just realized Jules Bianchi would finish 2nd at Monaco in 2014
Yes, Marussia would have actually had a podium
Someone who hasn't scored a real life podium actually wins a championship? Legendary!!
Don’t mind me. I’m just here to celebrate the Grosjean WDC!
This really shows how good Martin Brundle was in real life, and even here he still could not win a WDC. At least we had George Russell carrying the flag for King's Lynn 30 years later.
Brundle was a good driver but he spent his whole career in the shadow of greats
Also in this timeline, Massa would not have his accident in hungary 2009 and thus not get injured and lose his form.
And 2012 is still a banger!! Best season ever.
In this reality all the drivers would still be there, but the former champions would be racing for fun without gaining any points.
I like to think of it this way. They're still on the grid and still get prize money etc. but the championship is more "ceremonial" like a Hall of Fame type thing
Or maybe: former WDC still there without points, but their car still get WCC points, so teams would still want former WDC in their car to score WCC points
@@MrVsGarage That would make sense with things that can't be accounted for - like Felipe Massa wouldn't be able to terrorize Max Verstappen at the 2017 Italian Grand Prix if he was banned, but you obviously can't simulate the race if that hadn't happened, so Massa is still on track and competing just as hard as in our timeline.
As an Aussie fan, this gave Webber and Ricciardo victories, and seems likely to give Piastri one this year.
So I'd say that makes these videos all worth it.
That 90s shirt straight outta Saved by the Bell. Respect 😅
It's a nice shirt! I wore it to an engagement party a few days after filming 😅
Seeing kvyat winning the title in 2015 feel satisfying tbh
Honestly he was a very good driver at the time, just inconsistent and also not many people liked him which didn't help
Facts, 2015 was basically his only shot at it, and he got it
@@MrVsGarage Plus Ricciardo fell off an absolute cliff after comprehensively outperforming Vettel the year prior.
We need a race by race rundown of that elite 2012 season, man that’s insane
I love how you included a bit of narrative and storytelling to make things interesting. Keep up the great work!
Petition for Mr V to change his about to "really likes spreadsheets"
Spreadsheets are cool
Even removing dominance, SuperMax dominates all the records lol
Tbh he nearly won in 2016 and so wouldn't have had as many wins. But great driving is great driving and that shows up however you look at it
The little verstappen tune when scrolling over Max :p
Mate that's Jos
@@MrVsGarage Ugh had that in my mid but i screwed up HAHA
Not just good content but also AMAZING STORYTELLING!!
The way you talk about F1 in an alternate world is so interesting.
i was just watching first part and came to see if second part was released and i see posted 3 mins ago
mate, I've been waiting all week for you specifically to watch the first one so I could drop part 2
Same bruh
Didn't think I'd be welling up watching an alternative history Felipe Massa redemption arc when I woke up this morning but here we are.
It definitely produced some dud seasons but you've done really well picking storylines out of this data; brilliant work.
haha who would have thought you could make people emotional just by moving some numbers round on a spreadsheet. Glad you enjoyed! :)
LANDO!!!!! GET IN THERE MY SON!!!!
Lando goes & wins Miami 2 weeks after realised 😂😂
watching this after the miami grand prix and can't stop smiling at 22:03 🙈
'Will fans get bored of McLaren dominance?' I'M SOBBING
Loved this series man. One of the most original ideas, if not the most, in the whole F1 content niche.
I've been waiting for this video for days, thx!!
Aaaaaaaand now Lando has an extra podium.
its gonna be a few more before he wins. he's set to take every record max cannot 😅
Watched all of your videos over the past 7 months or so, seriously good stuff
amazing job man, you have put some hard work into this and it turned out super satisfying
These videos were done so well. dread to think how much time went into them but genuinely the most interesting and entertaining videos I've seen for a long time, thanks :)
Simply simply lovely! Thank you for the amazing videos.
Props with the effort in making these vids, V. Makes for some compelling viewing - thanks a lot!
Even in this reality BMW abandoning development of their car in 2008 fucks Kubica over
But hey we get a Hulk championship, that makes me happy
Yeah Kubica just can't catch a break 😔
Finally, a timeline in which Ricciardo wins a world championship! 🏆
Amazing work done here, loved both parts!
The good work never comes easy, that's why it's so rewarding when you finish it. You did a good work mate, both videos are excellent and it even raise some awareness about other drivers that didn't had the attention at the time but can have their talents recognized. Really good job, thank you for the effort to put it online
incredible idea and videos, one of the best f1 content creator out there
This is one of the most amazing videos I’ve ever seen! Keeping the excitement up all the time! Well done 🎉😊
Good news, Lando didn't invalidate this statistic in Japan ...
Great work, well done man!
I really enjoy your videos, your ideas, your humour. a refreshing take on f1
Replaying the 2021 Abu dhabi scenes with Norris and Sainz is the best 😂😂
i am watching this just after the 2024 Miami grand prix and boy oh boy does that Lando comment at the end feel now
this is awesome, my dude
i think if the champion did get banned for 2 consecutive seasons like in f2, AND with the current f1 points, trust that got complicated, but i figured out G. Hill would win 1 extra would champion in 1965, cause clark being suspended, and Schekter winning the championship as Lauda is suspended, but this is only championship as his only title in real life is during is his banned period, i'm currently in 1979. and also you can still compete just you won't score points but are allowed to do so for the constructor they race for so at least there aren't low numbers of drivers.
Post your working so far!
Yeah I think it would be much more likely that drivers stay and score Constructors points but just can't score Driver Championship points anymore. It becomes like a "Hall of Fame" thing to add one new person each year
@@MrVsGarage exactly and i figured out that schekter would the championship in 1977 and then be banned for 1979 which gilles Villeneuve won
@@d9zirable file:///C:/Users/callu/Documents/Alternative%20Timeline%201.pdf i think opens up my pdf file
Great vid. Fun watch. Love the content my dude
thank you! more coming soon
This makes me wanna travel to the alternate reality where the F2 champ rule is applied to F1 the whole way, just seeing the new stories that would've unfolded, each driver having their own mini eras and the pure magical silly seasons that would've occurred by one driver being guaranteed to retire as well as the storylines between people who consistently make it P2 in WDC finally clinching their titles makes this super duper interesting as a case study that I'm now starting to wish actually happened
it's interesting, but having only 8 cars in F1 is definitely not good. I like the idea that this is a sort of Hall of Fame championship. The normal championship still happens and everyone is still racing, but there's a second leaderboard just for people who aren't in the Hall of Fame and one new person is added each year like this.
@@MrVsGarage Kind of like the F1.5 championship, which removes the two (or more) teams which are able to compete for podiums.
Max is a reccordbreaker even here😂
@MrVsGarage I have an other idea for a long time:
Drivers are not connected to teams. Instead, they do the first 12 races in each teams. Then, the pilots with the most points will do the rest 12 races in the top 3 teams.
This way, no pilot will dominate for 5 years just because a team got one technical rule better than the rest. And we get to find out who is the best pilot. And the best team still wins.
I’m so happy this is out, I love this series
Lando Norris did as you asked....he waited until Miami to prove you wrong 😂😂😂😂😂
I started watching the first part of this the minute this was uploaded. Great timing
i absolutely love the idea of the two videos and i only (gladly) found your channel because of part 1. The way that F1 has turned out since 1950 with all its storylines (i. e. Lauda/Hunt with the movie Rush) and legendary drivers (Senna, Prost, Schumacher,....) still feels right. Of course it would be a great piece of history with the likes of Senna (or for me as an Austrian Jochen Rindt) still talking about the sport and racing of the old days but on the other side we wouldn't know if they would be legends they are today or if the sport would be as famous as it is today.
I WANNA SEE ALL OF THE STATS FOR THIS
HIGHEST WIN PERCENTAGE
PODIUM PERCENTAGE
and more things that i cant think about rn
Someone with more time can verify theses, but I think its:
Win Percentage - Clay Regazzoni with 75%
Podium Percentage - Lewis Hamilton with 82%
Points Percentage - Lewis Hamilton with 94%
Rookie Winners - Jackie Stewart, Clay Regazzoni, Jaques Villeneuve, Lewis Hamilton
You should allow champion to come back after 2 years if in real life they are driving that year. I think it would be interesting 🤔
I agree, or maybe just 1 year away? It would still make the sport super weird and makes you wonder if drivers would intentionally avoid winning the title
Took him an extra couple of races, but Norris couldn't let that fact stand
Hahaha, at 0:22, Introducing yourself as the guy who likes Exel too much is a nice touch, these types of details just further my amazement for your effort! Keep it up big guy ! your content scales mountains of quality !
It's nice to know someone notices. I actually missed that out on the first render so had to cancel 15 minutes of work to add it back in 😅
@@MrVsGarage woah, still on the bright side, it was only 15, could have been a lot more !
Hmm... maybe a follow up video, some time down the line, of course, where a Champion is indeed able to reenter the sport after 2 seasons break? I wonder how that would've played out.
Pretty sure Schumacher just dominates every season he comes back. Prost and Lauda still have quite a few titles. Hamilton has a lot but maybe not as many as Schumacher. Verstappen has just returned looking for #3
Woww...great video...Good work mate!!!!
Finally, I've been waiting for this like the rains of may
Shoutout to Lando, making that reference wrong
I just love what you are doing, keep up the great work Mr V.🏎🏎🏎🏎👍👍👍
Awesome part 2. The safety discussion at the end was really strong - I also loved the storytelling from 12:05 about how well WDC winners are doing in other series, and whether the rule should be changed to allow them back in 😂 really enjoyed these.
I wanted to show that as much as people complain about dominant eras, when you take them away it makes the sport feel... wrong.
Also, I think lots of newer fans aren't really aware about the amount of on track fatalities in early F1 and the reasons why the sport needs to be so strict on safety
I loved these video. Great job and super fun.
Thank you!
I guess no matter which alternate universe you visit, Jules Bianchi always dies
The only timeline in which he lives and probably becomes champion is the one where Ferrari put him straight in one of their cars after graduating from the academy since Massa and Alonso have retired a long time before
@@claudiomichieletto9874 Eh. He still pushes through the double yellows at Suzuka.
The timeline in which he lives is the one where either drivers are held accountable for their own safety, or preemptive measures are taken to save drivers from themselves. (And we even saw at Japan in 2022 that the latter isn't entirely effective, with multiple drivers driving dangerously fast for the conditions under safety car and Gasly even doing so under red flags.)
Lovely to see the Twitch quartet getting world titles
Could still happen IRL 👀
Love the Max Verstappen tune at Jos' victory. Nice easter egg!
Thank you for an awesome video
Wow. Thank you & very well done. Best of all was your summary.
.... On 2nd thoughts, best of all was proving Excel Spreadsheets can be useful.
This was an absolutely amazing video two-part series. I am glad my two favorites (still) managed to snatch a WDC in Alonso and Norris.
Good work !