Jack Didn't Have To Die
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 мар 2016
- Arguers: People who have seen 'Titanic'
Argument: Jack didn't have to die (because he could have floated on that debris with Rose).
Counter-Argument: Jack didn't have to die (if Rose hadn't jumped out of that lifeboat).
Arguers' Fault: Not giving Jack and Rose even less credit.
Tweet: / counterarguing
Post: / counterarguments
Buy: teespring.com/stores/countera...
Donate: www.paypal.me/counterarguments
Email: countertheargument@gmail.com
Jack Wouldn't Have Died If He Had Just Lost That Poker Game In The Beginning Of The Movie.....
he also wouldnt have mmet rose and this movie wouldnt rlly have a purpose
@@leah201 And Rose would have died
simple n clear
@@Semnome-jg6oj She was on a lifeboat.
@@jp3813 She would have commited suicide
They knew the ship was going to sink hours before it did, within that time she could have put Jack in a corset and convincing makeup and they'd both get on the lifeboats
God bless this comment omg 😂😂😂😂
Why doesn't this comment have likes? 😂😂😂😂
BEST COMMENT EVER
***** legit though he could have just done that
😂 Freaking genius
Basically the video:
*Roasting Rose for 600 seconds straight*
He sounds like he’s prosecuting her in court
You mean 6000 seconds
IDK, I think she's kinda spoiled. She has a rich family and wants to commit suicide. Oh please, spare me the drama. I know people who are homeless and have absolutely nothing, yet they still want to live.
@@rainbowunicorngirl2187 6000 seconds would be 100 minutes, or an hour and 40 minutes. this video is only 10 minutes long, so 600 seconds is right because 60 x 10 = 600
@@ketaminepoptarts help im so stupid thanks for telling me
I just want everybody to remember that not only did Rose jumping back onto the ship get Jack killed, but that she used a spot on the lifeboat that someone else could have taken...like....wut?
Thats messed up
If you look closely when Rose jumps off, a man jumps on to the boat,
@@PelsckoPelesko A fair trade.
I thought that i was the only one who's thinking about that 😂
I mean, the boats were never filled anyways but she was the last person on that boat, had she not been right there some other woman could have taken that spot, so you're right.
If i go on titanic II, im bringing a heater, big damn door and my own jack.
Lmao
Only if it sinks in ice water
Lmao
Someone volunteer to be my jack 😂
xox ashley 😂😂
Rose-
Fallsdown: " JACK"
Gets lost: "JACK!"
Gets lost again: "...blblblbll... JACK"
IM LAUGHING TOO HARD AT YOUR COMMENT 😭😭😭😭😭😭😂😂😂
Lmao
Nearly drowned again: JACK!!
WHY DID U MAKE ME LAUGH THIS HARD IM CRYIGJFJBFBF 🤣🤣
Tell rose......SSSSSHHHHHUUUUUTTTTT UUUUUPPPPP
“Jack and rose would’ve reunited tomorrow morning” then realise it is tomorrow morning 😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
So True Titanic Sank At 2:30am So That Means Its The Next Day 😎
Jack;lET ME ON I HATE MORNINGS I WANT ON THE DOOR
Not Funny I Hate That Jack died 😭😠 you guys are idiots I love jack!..😭😭😭 But he is dead 😠😭😠😭😭😠😠😭😠😭😭😠😭😠😠😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭!!.!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!😭😠😭😠😭😠😭😠😭😠!!
1:02 Video: Romeo dies ...
Me: I know that Titanic is a “Romeo + Juliet Lovestory”, but its even more ironic that a year before Leo acted as Jack in Titanic, he played Romeo lol
Better yet DiCaprio was Romeo in the movie “Romeo + Juliet”
Damn i just read the comment I just said what you said
I watched that in school it’s kinda funny how it all comes full circle
It's ironic how everyone thinks of Leonardo DiCaprio playing Jack when the movie Titanic is mentioned, yet he is the only one who didn't get an Oscar. The movie received many Oscars but none for Leo. Even that iceberg was probably nominated before Leo.
@@gerardwells2945 are you dumb or are you dumb
@@gerardwells2945 dum fuck
Lol
Well as we all know, Leonardo got the icebergs back. The jokes on them. They’re all melting now
@@whawha8808 well..it is true jqck pretended to be the real jack but the movie actually like di happen in real life
Gets lost: *”JACK”*
Gets lost again: *”JACK”*
Nearly drowned again: *”JACK”*
That made me wheeze
@@moon-ssi5705 am dyeingggg
Underrated
To much Jack...
Even the Older Rose points it out that Jack saved her in every possible way a person can be saved.
Imagine if he had lived... and they both would have went to new york together.. she would have became an actress like she did.and being into art as much as she was.. she would have inspired jack to become a even greater artist..i know theyre not real people but its heartwrenching all the same... RIP to everyone who was lost..
She would have dumped him in a week.
@@margaretgarside5617 Not in those days (no internet, no social media, no influencer to lead ppl to cheat) she would love him all her life probably.
@@soumen8624 Didn't Rose cheat on her fiancé? (Like people have all through history).
The famous phrase ‘never let go’ means that rose will try to live because she didn’t use to want to . Jack died for rose and rose lived for jack. It was really sad that jack died but it was the right decision in my view.
It's just hard to take it seriously when there is this plothole.
Soo Sorry to OBLITERATE
Your "DELUSIONS of GRANDEUR "
And DESTROY YOUR
MISPLACED Faith in
True Love and Honor and Value of The Female Species ...
But ...
I Believe That Jack AND Rose's Ex - Fiancee SHOULD Have BOTH Taken Turns And
Simultaneously ,
Mouth ,
Kitty , Eye ,
Ear , Nostril
And Butt - Banged The SH#T OUT Of Rose ! ...
Then ...
TOSSED Her Overboard to Drown and Meet Her FRIGID AND ICY DEMISE ... In the Freezing and Bone Chilling Ocean .
Then ...
They INSTANTLY VOW COMPLETE LOYALTY AND BRO CODE
FAITHFULNESS to Each Other And Become BEST FRIENDS AND
" Tunnel - Buddies " FOR LIFE !
! ! ! ...
Then They Split Up and ENJOY The Family Money ,
Gold ,
And Jewelry FORTUNE Between ONLY The Two of THEM ! ...
And THEY LIVE ON HAPPILY EVER AFTER WITH MONEY AND RICHES BEYOND THEIR WILDEST DREAMS ! ...
ALL the While ,
Basking in THEIR EQUAL TRIUMPH AND GLORY Of the COMPLETE AND TOTAL SEXUAL VIOLATION AND DOMINATION OF EVERY ORIFICE ROSE HAD TO OFFER ! ! ! ....
INCLUDING HER RIGHT EAR ! ...
AS
A VERY
WISE
MAN ,
ONCE SAID ....
ABSOLUTELY ,
NO
WOMAN
AND HER
SNATCH ...
IS
EVER
WORTH
DYING
FOR ! ! ! ...
A
CLEANER ,
SWEETER ,
TIGHTER ,
AND
WETTER
PUSSY ...
YOU
WILL
HAVE
LATER ON IN
LIFE ... ! ! !
I CAN
PERSONALLY
TESTIFY
TO
THIS ! ! ! ...
HE
WAS
SOO
RIGHT ... ! ! !
@@Groggle7141 it's not a plot hole because he's saying that the characters should have had knowledge that we only have because it's a movie. Rose would have had to have been psychic to know ahead of time how things played out.
@@MrEffectfilms Wrong. Her decision was irrational... especially because she wasn't a psychic
Ugh... of course a woman would say that 😄
"wait you tried to kill yourself by jumping off the Titanic?" *Laughs* "you could have just waited two days" me:😭😭😂
That shit killed me so hard XD
Anna Monkey even that dude thought she was dumb 💀💀
Anna Monkey was that a cut I swear I didn’t see that part
@@sleepless9994 3:56
Lol
Title: Jack didnt have to die
Me: *in tears* NO SHIT
Female Bakugou YES
LMAO
Female Bakugou LMA0
this is my favorite comment ever. 😭
ye but didnt that happen in the real titanic??
14th april 1992
It makes me sad because with Rose's status I think he might have been allowed to get onto a life boat with her. They bump into the ship's architect Thomas Andrews together at one point; I kind of imagine that he would have had the social status to get all three of them to safety and onto a life boat together, had Rose only insisted. That was one solution
Excellent point! Never had thought of it that way. But I guess even Thomas Andrews couldn't make special arrangements anymore, concerning the building panic and chaos at that point.
Mr Andrews probably thought that as everyone wasn't able to survive the sinking, the ship designer couldn't take the lifeboat. Much like Captain Smith.
When Jack died, I actually didn't cry because I was expecting it. When that elderly couple are dying in bed and when that mother is tucking her kids into bed.... breaks me every time:(
OMG yes! Those scenes hit me and I wasn’t even prepared for it!
@@letshuman8985 Ida & Isidor Strauss were the ones laying in bed. Based on a true story. Contrary to Jack & Rose. Also, the mother telling her kids a bedtime story was probably something that happened as well. Concerning there were many mothers and kids in 3rd and 2nd class that did *not* make it out alive. Interesting fact, the actress playing the Irish mother telling the story about Tear Na Nog was also in Cameron's Aliens movie.
Reason why jack died: I blame the writer
same
Better than that super hero kid writer
the writer wanted jack to die no matter what it couldn't be a happy ending even though I wish it was it just couldn't be
I’m just happy the actor of jack is alive and safe that’s how I got over his death
Hanna Banana me too! i always look up actors whose characters die in movies or tv shows to make sure they’re alive in real life. that makes me feel better
James Cameron said that Jack needed to die so that his viewers would fully feel the tragedy behind the Titanic.
James Cameron made people argue that Jack should not die after realizing a problem?!
1 like= RIP Jack
snorkel 511 then they both should’ve died
snorkel 511 I think that rose dying would be a funny tragedy 🙃
Well it worked😭
nadia nazari but who would have told the story then if Rose died too? Rose and Jack are just fictional characters, they weren’t real, but Rose represent those who survived but lost their loved ones and Jack represent those who died with the ship, it’s simple and it worked out really well in my opinion
i love how we are all so sensitive and sad about this movie
People fail to realize when Jack was handcuffed to the pole his feet were already in the cold water along time till rose got him out. He was already having hypothermia issues before rose un cuffed jack. 🤔 . Very surprised people dont know this. It is even more obvious when they are on the top of the stern with the cheif with whiskey. When jack is hugging rose and they about to go into the water his shaking isnt the fear of the water it is the shaking from hypothermia.
I imagine this is an eye opener for many.
If Rose hadn't gone back to Jack then Jack probably would have died saving another passenger. Probably a child
Finally someone has the same opinion with me. He's a gentleman and who knows if he would survive saving himself or sadly die giving someone else the room on the door
so by jumping back she inadvertently kills a child.
But her jumping back to him creates more problems because he has to keep himself from drowning and her i would have been better if they had just reunited on the carpathia ship and had a happy life and she killed jack because she couldnt move over just a little to keep him from dying of hypothermia from that freezing cold water. OMG THIS MOVIE TRIGGERS ME IT MAKES ME SO MAD
And they also could have taken turns on the door BuT.......NNNNOOOOOOOOOOO
@@MrSquishles LOL!!!
What would’ve happen if Jack didn’t win the ticket
1.He would’ve never met Rose
2.Rose would’ve became more suicidal
3.Rose would jump of the titanic and freeze to death or get killed by the spinners (drowned)
Izzy LovesGaming after she’s killed herself? Good one mate
Dan Southwell 😎👌🏻
@@dansouthwell8899 Probably before, only just making Rose even more suicidal.
cal was cute but i wanted to punch him in the throat the entire time
Jack would not of died
Rose represents the people that survived and Jack the people that died on Titanic. There was another Titanic movie called "A night to remember" but after watching it you wouldn't be that affected. The point of these movies are to make people realize that this actually happened and that people lost their lifes, in "A night to remember" you see the tragedy, while in Titanic(1997) you live it. Cameron wanted everyone to realize that there was women out there that lost their Husbands, mothers that lost their sons so that's why Jack had to die, to make us realize that it's not just a movie, it's a life story.
@cristinabarbalau5922 So you're saying Rose *represents* the ego-consumed Cal Hockley and her self-absorbed mother Ruth who made it out alive as well? You probably don't, but I have to disagree with that take as a consequence.
The only reason Rose visibly survived in the movie is due to the fact that she was the *sole* protagonist. The elder Rose was there to tell to the story of the Titanic to the audience on the MV Keldysh, to the crew of Brock Lovett, a treasure hunter, and then, the audiences in the movie theaters of course as well. This was Cameron's way of wrapping the 1912 tragedy in a present day (1996>) format and make the significance of the sinking and the lives lost relevant to this day.
Cameron would have achieved this with or without Jack apparently dying in the freezing water. Due to the fact that Cameron did an amazing job in bringing the 884 ft long ship back to life, including rebuilding the Grand Staircase and 1st Class Diner etc. as the two huge set pieces. This made the sinking and destruction of the ship all the more tragic. Add the visible lives lost of Thomas Andrews, but also the fictional ones, like Jack's best pal Fabrizio, Tommy Ryan, Helga, Cora and their families etc., it further made the tragedy of Titanic more relatable to the present day. Concerning we value life and the preciousness of life much more today than we did in 1912.
He sounds like he’s prosecuting Rose in court
*casually watching Titanic with my girlfriend*
Girlfriend: "This is so sad and romantic. I bet you would do the same for me, honey."
Me: "Nope, never."
Girlfriend: "Omg you're so mean! Why not??"
Me: "Because we're both not stupid and I would rather find a way for us both to survive."
Girlfriend: "Yeah, you're right. Let's watch Saw."
King Gangrel This killed me 😂💀
This is fake no girl want see saw instead if titanic but at least u try
@@gtx-808 i wanna watch saw lol
@@gtx-808 Are you sure?
Spoderman I want to watch saw.
the title should actually be “rose getting dragged for 10 minutes straight”
FRRRR 😂😂😂😂
Yup🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😑😂😂😂😑😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Fr
RIGHT you are👍....And Ooo so TRUE...ITS VERY FUNNY 🤣..Poor JACK..DONT trust a woman on a sinking ship..Causes she's a God DAM lier.
I think by this point i've watched most if not all of your videos 3/4 times at least. I still get a smile every time the algorithm recommends one of them just pure gold
Jack had to die. Jack was the missing piece in Rose’s life that helped her become who she was truly meant to be. He was like a stepping stone or a ladder helping her reach the top. When jack died she left behind Rose from titanic and became Rose Dawson her true self. Without jack, she would have never realised the true possibilities and continued suffering in a isolating marriage. Plus all the promises they made together Rose fulfilled them by being independent and doing them on her own without Jack. This shows she became stronger, more confident and saw the true meaning of life❤️
_" and continued suffering in a isolating marriage."_ You mean a cold-hearted marriage and made braindead by all the endless charades and chit-chatter. The same narrow-minded people.
Rose made all her promises come true by staying *true* to herself. You know, like going to Santa Monica Pier and ride the horse, become an actress and end up with someone she would spent the rest of her life with in full joy and meaning, including having a lovely granddaughter in the name of Lizzie. Rose was her own and she found her match, but by embracing her true feminine strengths and qualities.
Titanic didn’t have to sink if it weren’t for jack and rose busy kissing their heart out in front of the two guys controlling the ship XD
Correct. Jack loses the game of poker-->Sven becomes a millionaire in the States, White Star buys Cunard, Rose marries Fabrizio, Cal still shoots himself.
Omg I was thinking that
XD
Oops, forgot that Fabrizio wouldn't have boarded either...
Yeh your right but there is a another way if the controllers is just conscentrating in the ocean and even if a person is kissing so if theyre litearally conrating in their bussines then they could have told the capatain to saild away from the ice burg then that wont happen 🤦🏼♀️
My name is Jack.
I'm staying away from any roses I find.
Edit: I come back to this comment like a year later and I notice all these likes. What did I miss?
Jacko1234wdd lol
Me to
My name is jack......short for jacqueline but I will still stay away from any roses
Jacko1234wdd hello
*Yodel of fear* Get out of here you thorned flower.
Well, I had thought the same thing as well, but considering how much Cal HATES Jack, he might've taken the advantage of being alone with him, to hurt him, or worse, kill him. I mean, he did almost try and kill Rose and Jack the scene after, but it could've happened. I do think that Rose wasn't being particularly selfish, she just wanted to make sure her love was okay, but that jump could've costed her life, but it costed Jack's.
This doesn’t only prove that jack didn’t have to die but it also proves that rose killed jack by accident
This whole video makes Rose look bad😂😂😂😂
isn't that the point?
Mohammed Khan it’s showing how she was actually a bad person and a hypocrite
@@moelester7600 True, but when you watch the movie it doesn't feel that way
Ye
Mohammed Khan it may not feel that way but when you look at it it makes sense
Imagine that jack was just unconscious and she let him drown when she was floating on the door in the ocean
F
Omg 😱 and she looks back down and he can’t move become he is ice but he opens in eyes so wide and she’s like SHI$
he didint even have a lot of symptoms of hypothermia!
That is what basically happened since she is so ruthless and selfish and all above a bad human being to me I think it should of been her in the water and jack floating.
Man was just having a hella deep sleep
Im gonna be honst, I really miss Counter Arguments uploads, one of those youtubesr you know puts in so much more effort without getting the love his channel deserves.
I can imagine how Jack being on that door by himself would've worked out. In the movie, people were fighting over the smallest things to stay afloat. Jack would've gotten swamped for sure, just like if the lifeboats had come back too soon. Let's face it, Jack's chances were slim, one way or another.
Actually, Jack says "I figured life's a gift and I don't intend on wasting it". The point of the movie was to show viewers how short life is, anything can happen at any time. If Jack didn't die, the movie wouldn't have had the same effect. He was there to teach Rose love and life.
Nicole Ramoutar thank you! Finally someone who understands. Just because jack could fit on the door doesn’t mean it would have made a good ending. They had to let jack die because it creates more of emotional connection the characters. If they both would have survive the movie wouldn’t have the same impact. So like I said just because jack could have fit on the door doesn’t meant it would have made a good ending!
The movie would've been pointless if they both survived. He wanted Rose to be alright and he got really mad when Rose couldn't get to safety, he always took her before himself and saved her. Even if they hadn't known each other for long, they truly loved each other. I love the ending, when Rose dies and her soul is finally reunited with her long lost love, Jack.
Nicole Ramoutar no it wasn’t. It’s not every die a ship sink. Of course people would die bc of that, but not all. The point of the movie is to recreate the Titanic tragedy and show people how it must be like to be on the ship and how awful it was in the time after it hitting the iceberg.
iconic what do you mean, Rose didn’t die.
Emma Mosekjær exactlyyy
Rose:I’ll never let go Jack,
Two seconds late
Also Rose:*lets go of Jack*
Jar Jar Binks okay but he died he frozed do you think that she will carry him all time like HE ALREADY DIED ITS NOT HER FAULT
She meant that she won't let go of the promise because Jack made her promise that she would survive and he said to not let go of that promise
Benjamin lol
people still don’t understand that line years later. she said she’ll never let go of the promise she made to jack
😂😂🤦♂️🤦♂️
Yes, Jack may have been a lot more likely to have lived if Rose had just stayed on the boat. But she knew darn well that there was no boat for him to catch and no way or means for him to save himself with or without her.
My gosh. I loved the timing of the humor that you used on her choices. I do agree that he should have lived.
“By the time they get back to the deck, all the lifeboats are gone, FANTASTIC. So the make a break for the stern, Rose slows them down.
“Wait, wait, wait, wait” Falls down, “Jack!” Gets lost, “Jack!” Gets lost again, “Jack!” Nearly drowns again, “JACK!”” ....... 🤣
*plays jingle bells* jacking bells, jacking bells, jacking all the way!
Less fireworks and slowmotional 😂😂😂
I basically lost it during all the video😂
That Ashy Wolf JACK
Unless they swim to one
Wow they really wanted jack to die in this, every scene of jack was him either in danger or about to be in danger
You should read what this movie is all about.
You know Jake dint have to die bc...MAYBE THE THING ROSE WAS ON MAYBE WILL FLOT WHITE HIM GET A BRAIN GUIS!! BRAIN BRAIN !
That's true
I totally agree but the thing is they can’t have a movie based on something tragic when hundreds of people died and have Rose and Jack both live
I just realized that your videos all end at a perfect time
3:40
Rose: *You jump, I jump right?*
Voice: *WRONG!*
Rose: *Dammit!*
😂😂😂
RIGHT
Aha this is so funny, my name is rose 😅😂
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOL 😂😂😂
Rose:YOU JUMP I JUMP Right?
Jack:hell no
Rose:screw you go die
aaaaaa One meam
When he said “ you were gonna attempt to commit suicide all you had to do was wait 2 days “ I lmao like it went from sad to that 😂😂😂😂
Mikenna Varso lol
Ok?
I don't even remember seeing that in the movie but I LOL'd at that part
Ikr lol
Lmao
"here we find the king of the world handcuffed to a pipe" 🤣😂😅
What is overlooked is the fact that being in near freezing water, the skeletal muscle will fail. She got on the door, but by the time he was able to climb on the door he could not be caused of the freezing water.
This is where the lifejacket comes in handy.
Jack didn't die.
When he drowned, he was frozen for almost a century, and was washed up on a beach. When he woke up, he gained the ability to enter people's dreams, and used this ability to perform the world's most perfect crime.
Wh-what?...
You're funny
whats that from
Inception
Wow, im surprised someone doesn't believe a joke.
The Shade toward Rose during this video though lmao
Asinnnn
I know to Jack as well for not seeing through her as well
They both deserve the shade they receive!!!!
Lol
It’s not really shade if he’s not just casting her in shadow, but drenching her in tar...
The audience had to feel the weight of all the deaths that occurred on the Titanic, and Jack represented that. Also, if Jack and Rose had both survived, it would have romanticised a real life tragedy
Also, if Rose had stayed in the lifeboat, Cal would have know Rose was still alive and then would marry her, meaning Rose had to go back to her old life again. Meanwhile, If Jack survived, it would be likely that Cal would have arrested Jack for the framed stealing of the diamond
Yeah, because the audience would never feel any empathy for real people who actually died on that ship.
@@margaretgarside5617 Talk about your Mr. Andrews indeed .... I mean, it was so heartbreaking to see the responsbility he felt for *not* building Titanic strong enough and to have enough lifeboats to save everyone on board.
The enormous amount of guilt and pressure on his shoulders must have been huge back in 1912. Above all, no one ever said a wrong thing about the real Thomas Andrews as well. Concerning his kindness, hospitality and big heart. Meaning, the way Victor Garber depicted Mr. Andrews in the movie, including giving the lifejacket to the fictional character of Rose to save herself, was something he would have done in reality in 1912.
@@ughasif7908 _"Also, if Jack and Rose had both survived, it would have romanticised a real life tragedy"_ That would have been of *no* concern, because, neither Jack *nor* Rose ever existed or were on Titanic in 1912 for that matter. Their characters and their lovestory was and remains fake/fictional to this day.
Yes, Jack could have made it out and likely even has when you read the signs, but him and Rose surviving would have not overshadowed a real-life tragedy. It would have brought hope instead. Concerning starting from scratch and choosing love over material wealth as the source of all being.
She would have dumped him in a week. @@victorsamsung2921
Do you know how both Jack and everybody else could've survived? By having the actual crew trained and having more Lifeboats. Literally, there was an actually document saying how untrained the crew was.
Facts. The incompetence of everybody on the ship was too hilarious to believe it's real. From agreeing to speed up the ship in Iceberg infested waters, to not having having enough life boats, to not listening to Iceberg warnings from a near by ships radio signals. To not having mature watchman with better telescopes 😂 ect. The list goes on
@@dn8443 I’m pretty sure those were the best telescopes back then.
The incompetence of the crew and the captains decisions are the main cause for the titanic sinking. The captain changing the crew at the last moment before voyage, none of the crew having access to binoculars, no lifeboat test was carried out prior to the voyage (and there were only 16 of the damn things), the captain deciding to go full speed in a known iceberg area despite all the warnings they received. The list goes on but had some of these terrible decisions not been made they could have saved more lives that night
They didn't have many lifeboats because they thought the boat was unsinkable. They only needed enough boats to go back and forth getting people from the titanic onto another ship. They had more than enough in their mind
The thing is, the crew were told the ship was "The Unsinkable" so why would anyone need training when they were told nothing bad at all would happen? And if by the smallest chance that something were to happen, there'd be lifeboats right? A whole 20 lifeboats for 2,000+ people. The ship was just jinxed before it even went to sea.
The sad thing is, the ship was originally going to have about 60 lifeboats attached which would've ensured nobody would die if something happened, but they wanted the rich passengers to have a good view of the vast nothingness of the ocean so they got rid of more than half of the lifeboats.
Jack: "Why did you do that?! WHY?!" Rose: "You jump, I jump, right?!"
Narrator: "WRONG."
Rose: "dammit."
What's the point of this?
Jack would have survived if she hadn't jumped back onto the ship lol
@@mw1838 what if Kal killed him?
@@saturn6563 Well, cal was going to get on a boat.
@@mw1838 cal was actually planning on killing jack as soon as rose left
Rose: I didnt, i just realized i already knew
*shes a god damn liar*
*laughs quietly*
Ushio Wratten I genuinely laughed out loud at that. Was so unexpected yet perfectly timed 😂😂😂
I replayed that so many times. I also laughted.so hard at "wrong choice, Damnit, and stopped them, fell down, got lost,Jack, got lost again,Jack. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m not even going to lie but I didn’t like rose at all in this movie. Sorry not sorry🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
Funny how the one who "WROTE" the story told it and everyone went "No you told it wrong!"
To me that is dam good story telling. Not one film has that impact on people like the ending of TITANIC did.
Even in that situation, I would see it as obvious that running back to my boyfriend would drastically decrease his chances of survival. Also, now there is an empty space on the lifeboat which is super selfish.
That being said, I wouldn't judge the real people who died on the Titanic like this, because of course the whole experience is beyond traumatising.
Harry Goodwin if you look closely, you can see another person take Rose's place in the lifeboat
I don't think Jack and Rose were real people though
Harry Goodwin right ?? Because all his efforts would be on trying to help you survive and not himself. Rose was selfish
DUHHH,He said the FICTIONAL CARACTORS Rose and Jack.
My mom told me when she saw this in theaters, there were these 16 year old super fans who legit thought Leonardo Decaprio died when Jack did...
Bet they were surprised when he came in for his next movie
Hahahhhha😂😂
Chicken Nugget Waifus it’s called special effects
Pfft idiots
Well Titanic was the first time I was with my buddy and our "girfriends" out in the cinema. We where 13 at that time and cheered and clapped, when stupid Leonardo sunk into the ocean. The girls where not amused...well stupid bi**ches...
Lmao girlfriends
Thanks for the chuckles. I didn't laugh very often during the movie, but *this* definitely had me laughing more than once.
Wow that was put so bluntly thank you 😊
"Here we find the king of the world handcuffed to a pipe"
Am I the only one who laughed so hard
How did that happen lost my shit
SAME
Ujjwal Mehra say that in a mirror to your self 😄
Ujjwal Mehra are you fucking dumb? We’re the stupid ones when you can’t even type properly lmao, get a life!
Ujjwal Mehra bruh your funny 😂
I love how the picture of Jack on the thumbnail is him like "wait a minute... _I didn't have to die?"_
I- true
Why wouldn't a fictional character like Jack Dawson love that idea of being kept alive? Perhaps DiCaprio has always been a bit of sour about that with Cameron.
It turns out, and scientifically proven on Mythbusters if Rose had been less busy crying and more busy thinking, she could have tied her life jacket to the bottom of the plank and kept them both afloat.
I was only thinking about this last night.
I decided that Jack would not have died if he had not had to worry about Rose.
He was bright, quick witted and a survivor on his own.
Omg I died at “she’s goddamn liar!” Being cut in. 😂
Fleurs Sv 😂😂😂😂💀
Sandy Love ❤️ It’s 6 💝 9
6:32
Yes there are many ways Jack could have stayed alive but you’re missing the point. Jack HAD to die because it was the point of the movie. Titanic was a tragedy where hundreds of people died and lost their loved ones, so it doesn’t seem right to end such a tragedy with a good ending, it doesn’t make sense. Jack represents all the people who died that night, and rose represents all the people who had to lose their loved ones. If Jack hadn’t died you would miss the whole point and we wouldn’t realize how much that night impacted people.
Yes this is true... But I even think... That jack had all possible ways to live. Like that only, jack was a great human being and he had to suffer a great for rose. As at last, he was blamed he stole the blue diamond from rose but actually not. And for that also he was trapped in a room and they all tortured him. Even they beat him.... Not so much but whatever... But rose didn't trust him. So, it's rose also who is blamed.... But whatever happened nothing can be done
sarakban 9 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
I agree, and also one of the main messages from the movie was to live life to the fullest, cos you never no whats going to happen and you should make each day count. It changes rose to be more adventurous and it shows this when old rose goes to bed and we see all of the pictures of all of the adventures shes been on.xx
@@myself2241 Can I just remind you she is only 17 there?
sarakban 9 no its just that it’s annoying how close he was to surviving
The captain should've just hit the iceberg straight on.
I’m defence of rose, the shock of losing jack after she realises she loves him more than cal, she didn’t want to leave him, and be responsible for a possible death. Of course, Rose should have been a bit more trustworthy of jack and his judgement, but she, like many others on that ship, was petrified enough to lose him. After being slightly traumatised by Cals minor abuse, and being disowned/not accepted by her mother, she’s going to feel that way! Especially as she tried to commit a few nights before. Personally, I do think that they could’ve BOTH fit on that door (idk if it’s a door - maybe just a wall frame or something). I mean, if they’d enough buoyancy to hold each other, they would’ve survived! But back in 1912, and on a sinking ship, they’re not going to think about that! Remember, people didn’t always have the best education back then - even thought jacks survival skills are IMMACULATE! The solution to this could’ve been solved if rose had maybe put her life jacket underneath the floating thingy, and possibly the physics might line up, or in other words they’d have both fit on it without it sinking / one of them dying.
Rose: "I trust you"
Rose:"I trust you!"
Rose:"I TRUST YOU"
Then again she didn't trust Jack when he said to get on the boat?
SHE DIDINT WANT TO LEAVE JACK
@@delanieTallan Not an excuse for a stupid decision. By doing that she endangered both of their lives.
@@anitaremenarova6662 i get what your saying but rose saw how the dads was saying goodbye to their children and wives and she thought that was the last chance she would get to see jack, by there are only a few boats and they are letting women and children in first out of 2200 (or more) people on it, on top of the fact that people are panicking.
@@-toxically1355 Not an excuse for a stupid decision. By doing that she endangered both of their lives.
@@dechubasco830 clearly the point just flew right over yo head
Jack dies because of Rose
Romeo died because of Juliet
Stay single like me if you wanna live
P.S - Its a joke
Tapas Mondal loll
the girl who played Juliet with Dicapro in that other movie was actually considered for Rose in Titanic
think of the memes there would be had she been chosen lol
@Time Lord You realize it was a joke ryt?
@Time Lord The way you wrote it, you didn't sound like you realized what a joke is lol
Exactly 👏👏
This was too much! I had to subscribe!
You makes some really good points! :)
I love how in the film Rose says "I will never let go" to Jack and then immediately let's go.
eli eli :D she means she won’t let go of him in her heart. who in their right mind would carry a dead body around with them
a woman who would jump off the lifeboat to die with her lover...her actions before and after were kinda confusing tbh..
eli eli :D what is she supposed to do? Leave him there frozen?? Or take his frozen body onto the lifeboat??
I know funny
I will never let go of my comments in the first place and the promise was that she was about the Titanic sinking
Rose: you jump I jump right?
Narrator: WRONG!
Rose: DAMMIT!
XD
3:40
LOL!
I’m more mad about the necklace she threw in the ocean . Like girl just sell it and use the money for charity for poor people. Jack would’ve be happier that way too lol
Very rarely do I laugh out loud repeatedly at a RUclips video. Bro...fucking fantastic 👏
Jack : you trust me ?
Rose : i trust you
the door : she is goddamn liar
Jack flooded...
Right she lied he said get on the boat and u didn't trust him dumb azz
Omg young Leonardo DiCaprio was so hot....
Ruquia but you can call me Roqella ikr I want another one ffs it’s been so many years
Ikr.. HE WAS HAWT >:3
Ruquia but you can call me Roqella ever seen him in the Romeo and Juliet one? He looks good af in that
ikr, but when he grew up he became a hot mess....yikes
Gay
Holy shit... this opened my eyes
The music makes this amazing
This video is roasting rose so much 😂
200th like
I'll be like this
*Rose is on the door*
*Pushes off Rose*
Me: Bitch, it's my turn
NyanKittyCat Jr lmao
MyJellyFaceSelf Jiggles 😂
MyJellyFaceSelf Jiggles lel
MyJellyFaceSelf Jiggles same
MyJellyFaceSelf Jiggles wouldn't work hypothermia kills you within 90 seconds
This is the smartest video I’ve ever watched over my 16 years on RUclips
9:22 whom I'm gonna meet...jack gets a punch from lovejoy gets me Everytime😂
3:40 "you jump I jump right!"
Wrong
"Damn it"
😂😂😂
Kerem Tezcan
lol I like that part too
Kerem Tezcan XD right??
Very funny 😁😁😁😁😁😂😂😂😂😂
Kerem Tezcan that was my favorite part 😂
Try’s to hold in the laughter, mind implodes when SUDDENLY................HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAJAHHAHAHAH
i think he became jack frost
PrincessCat 3900 that pun tho
XD
BOTTOM TEXT
Yep totally
the door could have supported both of them
The _stupid_ algorithm may've landed me here 6 years late, but it's about time someone else said what I've been thinking for YEARS.
2:38 - 3:00HAD BE CRYING IN TEARS OF LAUGHTER NO JOKE
“rose slow them down, falls down, gets lost, gets lost again, nearly drowned again and and in every single case jack saves the day”
Yeah no kidding
JACK
JACK
JACK
JACK
Im still laughing at 3:54 please watch🤣🤣🤣
Both Of Them Ended Up Getting Shot At, Trapped In The Flooded Hallway, Shove Against A Gate, Trapped Behind Another, Nearly Drowned, By The Time They Get Back To The Deck All Of The Lifeboats Are Gone. Fantastik." I laughed so hard 😂😂
@@khelia1550 ikr
6:32
Jack had to die because the plot required him to. End of story 💁♂️
JelloHazzard this is a true story though
@@familytabasuhitguh9169 The sinking of the Titanic was based on a true story. Most of the characters shown in the movie were real, however, Jack and Rose's characters were made up by James Cameron because he wanted to give the viewers a realistic experience of the tragedy.
@AnnieRose X_X I have and ik its based on a true story however, the romance between Jack and Rose wasn't. Go look it up urself if u don't believe me 🙄.
But what a stupid way to die. There are so many other ways to die that make sense than this.
AnnieRose X_X it’s not realistic to fall in love with someone in 48 hours
06:32 ... ROFLMAO... very creative editing right there. Well done. Too funny. :P
Jack actually had to die in order for the Movie to be as Bittersweet at the end! The director of Titanic said he HAD to die. Hey its a movie. We need a story..and sad endings are also awesome!
what people don't realise, if rose got on the lifeboat, Jack may not have been able to get the door because other passengers may have grabbed it, it just depends on where Jack was when the ship sunk .
Isabella Bedford if he did not have rose with him he still would have been in the same place but one person to save there for he could have survived
Isabella Bedford but wouldnt he think of his self nxt after rose just got on the life boat? so he could also find that door himself or he can find another object to stay on. right?
Jack is a tough, smart and resourceful guy it's been shown a lot of times in the movie, he wouldn't have died if only he's by himself.
It doesn’t matter if he wasn’t with Rose in the water. He would’ve grabbed that door, lie on it and survive. Happy ending.
Hed have stayed on the ship as long as he could hes pretty smart walking through life pennyless but jack was the most richest person on the boat.
this pisses me off because it so true lol.
Its not true. This movie is perfect.
@@smarthydra061 I wouldn't say that-
Did you know jack actually had to die in real life
@@gerardwells2945 u are so dumb like seriously
@@gerardwells2945 fucking 7 year old with a royal name
If the script said Jack dies
Then Jack HAS to die!
Jack needed to die. He was Rose’s hero. He needed to die young & be told through legend. He also needed to be the example of how 3rd class passengers were treated on the Titanic & why so many of them died.
1:37 should I stay or go now
It had me dying of laughter 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Awesome Gamerzxe omg I was dead 🤣🤣🤣👌
Saaame
Stranger things fans where ya at?
Awesome Gamerzxe same
@@kcbriones2783 I'm here :)
1:02 He played Romeo though:( PLEASE tell me i'm not the only one obsessed with Leonardo DiCaprio
yess omg i watched romeo and juliet JUST because leo was in it and i watched titanic JUST because leo was in this too 😂
YESSS
EVERYBODY knows he played Romeo
Haha yes! Go girl🤣
@@hrafnagud nope
Lmao the title should have been if we put should I stay or should i go now when rose jumps off the tiny boat
Jack: lets get on that door! There spaces for both of us!
Rose: no dont get on the door if you love me