If Flamenco Guitar Originally From INDIA , Why We Lost This Art ??????

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 17

  • @sanjeevshri7352
    @sanjeevshri7352 4 года назад +6

    Rupam.. I myself am flamenco guitarist in India and pursuing this art forms from many years ....I went to spain as well to learn this art form.
    .I differ with you politely on your title for video...This is true that Gypsies (Gitano)went from India to Spain(and other parts of world) and also they carried a major influence and contribution to Flamenco,,,..But Flamenco evovled as a art in soil of Spain over the years...also over the contributions from many other parts of world like Africa, Latin America as well as folklore of Spain itself - Along with massive contributions from Gypsies..
    Theory being apart , Art belongs to those who devote themselves to it ...who burn thier life ,spend time /energy to pursue and master it...Why to say it belongs to Spain or India....rather it belongs to all those artists around the world who have dedicated their life to pursue this art.
    BTW ,above is beautiful Guajira Palo played by the flamenco guitarist. (palo is similar to indian classical ragas and flamenco contains many different palos).
    Why to be sad ??..rather be happy that this art form has a soul of Indian classical music and dance as well and flourishing beautifully by loving artists

    • @prreettz
      @prreettz 3 года назад

      Can u suggest flamenco guitar in india around 10000 inr

  • @AmanFlamencoGuitarist
    @AmanFlamencoGuitarist 3 года назад

    Not yet I know many flamenco guitarists from india including me 😉😉

  • @prinxeannsprinceprince5126
    @prinxeannsprinceprince5126 3 года назад

    🤔😂😂 First time I've ever heard "Flamenco" is originally from (India) 🤦‍♂ (Really) ?????? 🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂

  • @samirsokoli259
    @samirsokoli259 8 лет назад +2

    gypsy is egypsion not Indian.is one culture in world the egypsion culture.

    • @mridulsharma3418
      @mridulsharma3418 7 лет назад +1

      Samir Sokoli idiot dont type when you know nothing about this😂

    • @mridulsharma3418
      @mridulsharma3418 7 лет назад

      Samir Sokoli all those techniques which are specific to flamenco like rasgueados they came from indian classic instruments for example: rasguedos came from tabla

    • @samirsokoli259
      @samirsokoli259 7 лет назад +1

      Mridul Sharma gi tarav gi -till to tarav-burn 🎸 gitara flamenco flame 🔥 the gitara is the instrument not some tabla

    • @mridulsharma3418
      @mridulsharma3418 7 лет назад +1

      Samir Sokoli i am talking about techniques. that technique came from tabla

    • @prateekbhardwaj9943
      @prateekbhardwaj9943 6 лет назад +2

      they are Rajasthani(Indian) its proved by DNA testing. and they look like Rajasthani. watch movie "Latcho drome"

  • @sidjones_46
    @sidjones_46 7 лет назад

    You know why? Because we got lost in casteism(varna), poverty and all shit that followed..