- Видео 119
- Просмотров 94 814
Marks Astro Journey
США
Добавлен 17 мар 2022
Come along on my journey learning about astronomy, astrophotography and the many skills/techniques involved.
Skyshed Pier - Join Me As I Install It In My 2nd Floor Observatory
In this video, I install a Skyshed Pier in my 2nd Floor Observatory. Enjoy!
Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup:
Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount:
agenaastro.com/catalog/product/view/id/7523/s/sky-watcher-eq6-r-pro-computerized-goto-telescope-mount-s30300/?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD_aP9LP_IOzky9xBW9v1kqZqoMHB&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqanznc2shwMV1En_AR1ongIuEAQYAiABEgK2_vD_BwE
Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it helps support my channel.
Optolong 2" Filter Set of 7 - LRGB, H-Alpha, OxygenIII & SulpherII
www.highpointscientific.com/optolong-2-filter-set-with-lrgb-h-alpha-sii-and-oiii-filters-lrgb-hasiioiii-200
ZWO 7-Position Electr...
Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup:
Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount:
agenaastro.com/catalog/product/view/id/7523/s/sky-watcher-eq6-r-pro-computerized-goto-telescope-mount-s30300/?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD_aP9LP_IOzky9xBW9v1kqZqoMHB&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqanznc2shwMV1En_AR1ongIuEAQYAiABEgK2_vD_BwE
Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it helps support my channel.
Optolong 2" Filter Set of 7 - LRGB, H-Alpha, OxygenIII & SulpherII
www.highpointscientific.com/optolong-2-filter-set-with-lrgb-h-alpha-sii-and-oiii-filters-lrgb-hasiioiii-200
ZWO 7-Position Electr...
Просмотров: 101
Видео
Skyshed Pier - Product Unboxing, Example Photos and Helpful Info
Просмотров 153День назад
In this video, I present my unboxing, example photos and helpful info for a Skyshed Pier. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount: agenaastro.com/catalog/product/view/id/7523/s/sky-watcher-eq6-r-pro-computerized-goto-telescope-mount-s30300/?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD_aP9LP_IOzky9xBW9v1kqZqoMHB&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqanznc2shwMV1En_AR1ongIuEAQYAiAB...
Roll Off Roof Observatory Build - 2nd Floor - Pole Barn - Part 3 - Will this project break Amish?
Просмотров 14814 дней назад
Join me as I share my plans for building a 2nd floor roll off roof Observatory as part of a Pole Barn. I've been doing amateur astronomy for a couple years now. I'm always having to setup/tear down my astronomy gear. I'm looking forward to having an observatory to reduce some of the setup/teardown time. I'm having an Amish contractor do the build as they've done work for me before. Will this cr...
Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount - Product Unboxing & Basic Assembly
Просмотров 18121 день назад
In this video, I present my unboxing and basic assembly of the Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Sky-Watcher EQ6-R Pro Telescope Mount: agenaastro.com/catalog/product/view/id/7523/s/sky-watcher-eq6-r-pro-computerized-goto-telescope-mount-s30300/?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD_aP9LP_IOzky9xBW9v1kqZqoMHB&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqanznc2shwMV1En_AR1o...
Roll Off Roof Observatory Build - 2nd Floor - Pole Barn - Part 1 - Will this project break Amish?
Просмотров 15421 день назад
Join me as I share my plans for building a 2nd floor roll off roof Observatory as part of a Pole Barn. I've been doing amateur astronomy for a couple years now. I'm always having to setup/tear down my astronomy gear. I'm looking forward to having an observatory to reduce some of the setup/teardown time. I'm having an Amish contractor do the build as they've done work for me before. Will this cr...
Roll Off Roof Observatory Build - 2nd Floor - Pole Barn - Part 2 - Will this project break Amish?
Просмотров 12621 день назад
Join me as I share my plans for building a 2nd floor roll off roof Observatory as part of a Pole Barn. I've been doing amateur astronomy for a couple years now. I'm always having to setup/tear down my astronomy gear. I'm looking forward to having an observatory to reduce some of the setup/teardown time. I'm having an Amish contractor do the build as they've done work for me before. Will this cr...
Polar Align Comparison - iPolar versus NINA versus Sharpcap
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.Месяц назад
In this video for amateur astronomers I go through an exercise of comparing Polar Alignment done first with iPolar, then NINA and lastly Sharpcap. At the end I share from my recent imaging sessions the Pelican Nebula and the Elephant Trunk Nebula. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it he...
Are you new to Astrophotography? I have 15 time saving tips just for you.
Просмотров 6903 месяца назад
In this video for amateur astronomers interested in making the most of the time they have for imaging sessions, I share 15 tips for saving time. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it helps support my channel. William Optics RedCat 61 WIFD f/4.9 Petzval Refractor Telescope amzn.to/48bDmeI...
Total Solar Eclipse April 8 2024 from Nineveh, Indiana USA
Просмотров 1463 месяца назад
I traveled to a place very near the center of the path of totality to view and capture images of the total Solar Eclipse on April 8th, 2024. I stayed at a campground in Johnson County, Nineveh, Indiana. It was an awesome experience. In this video I show both a Timelapse of the solar eclipse and some individual images, which I thought were impressive. I show them both in a more natural color and...
Making a low cost Solar Finder for your telescope
Просмотров 2 тыс.5 месяцев назад
In this video for amateur astronomers interested in observing or photographing the Sun, I present a brief overview of how to create a Solar Finder and possibly save yourself $40-50 dollars. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it helps support my channel. William Optics RedCat 61 WIFD f/4....
Removing Noise Comparison in Pixinsight - EZ Denoise versus NoiseXterminator
Просмотров 1905 месяцев назад
In this video for amateur astronomers newer to Pixinsight, I present a brief overview of removing noise from a stacked H-Alpha image using 2 options in Pixinsight: NoiseXterminator and EZ Denoise. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it helps support my channel. William Optics RedCat 61 WI...
Tutorial for Equalizing Backgrounds in Pixinsight Using Linear Fit
Просмотров 2325 месяцев назад
In this video for amateur astronomers newer to Pixinsight, I present a brief overview of using Linear Fit in Pixinsight to equalize backgrounds before channel combination. Towards the end I also show my final processed image of an LRGB imaging session on the California Nebula. Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon li...
Removing Gradient in Pixinsight - ABE and DBE
Просмотров 2666 месяцев назад
In this video for amateur astronomers newer to Pixinsight, I present a brief overview of removing gradients from some stacked LRGB images using 2 options in Pixinsight: Automatic Background Extractor (ABE) and Dynamic Background Extraction (DBE). Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my setup: Note: I am an amazon affiliate. If you follow any of the amazon links and make a purchase, it hel...
First Light-Williams Optics RedCat 61 Telescope & ZWO ASI 2600 mm Pro Camera & Pixinsight Processing
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.6 месяцев назад
In this video, I present my first light of the Williams Optics RedCat 61 Refractor Telescope and ZWO ASI 2600 mm Pro Camera. I go over my Pixinsight workflow for LRGB post processing and share the final images from seven targets (Rosette Nebula, Horsehead Nebula, Heart Nebula, California Nebula, Jellyfish Nebula, Seven Sisters, and Soul Nebula). Enjoy! Here's some equipment I'm using for my set...
Product Unboxing - Optolong 2" Filters Set of 7 - LRGB, H-Alpha, OxygenIII & SulpherII
Просмотров 1156 месяцев назад
Product Unboxing - Optolong 2" Filters Set of 7 - LRGB, H-Alpha, OxygenIII & SulpherII
PegasusAstro Power Box Provides DC Power, USB Hub & Dew Heater Controller in One Convenient Unit
Просмотров 2067 месяцев назад
PegasusAstro Power Box Provides DC Power, USB Hub & Dew Heater Controller in One Convenient Unit
ZWO 7-Position Electronic Filter Wheel for 2" or 50.4mm Filters-Product Unboxing
Просмотров 1827 месяцев назад
ZWO 7-Position Electronic Filter Wheel for 2" or 50.4mm Filters-Product Unboxing
ZWO EAF Electronic Automatic Focuser - Advanced (New 5V Version) Product Unboxing
Просмотров 4277 месяцев назад
ZWO EAF Electronic Automatic Focuser - Advanced (New 5V Version) Product Unboxing
Williams Optics RedCat 61 Refractor Telescope - Product Unboxing
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Williams Optics RedCat 61 Refractor Telescope - Product Unboxing
Stellarium - How to Create a Custom Landscape
Просмотров 8718 месяцев назад
Stellarium - How to Create a Custom Landscape
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #10 Not to Buy It - Optional Stepper Motor
Просмотров 3288 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #10 Not to Buy It - Optional Stepper Motor
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #9 Not to Buy It - Adjusting Allen Screws
Просмотров 2338 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #9 Not to Buy It - Adjusting Allen Screws
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #7 Not to Buy It - Eye Pieces
Просмотров 4038 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #7 Not to Buy It - Eye Pieces
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #8 Not to Buy It - Finder Scope
Просмотров 2658 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #8 Not to Buy It - Finder Scope
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #6 Not to Buy It - Tripod Not Steady
Просмотров 2018 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #6 Not to Buy It - Tripod Not Steady
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #4 Not to Buy It - Slow Motion Ctrl Knobs
Просмотров 4338 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #4 Not to Buy It - Slow Motion Ctrl Knobs
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #5 Not to Buy It - RA/DEC Axes Set Screws
Просмотров 2258 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #5 Not to Buy It - RA/DEC Axes Set Screws
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #1 Not to Buy It - Not a True Newtonian
Просмотров 5 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #1 Not to Buy It - Not a True Newtonian
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #3 Not to Buy It-Mounting Plate Undersized
Просмотров 3888 месяцев назад
Celestron Powerseeker 127EQ Reflector Telescope - Reason #3 Not to Buy It-Mounting Plate Undersized
This was very interesting video. Can’t wait to see the stars at night! Lots of them I hope.😊❤
thanks for watching Sharon! I hope to have some images soon from the new setup!
LOL my very first thoughts when I came across the title of your video was "my friend are you sure that second floor observatory will be solid and stable enough for your pier and mount etc??"...then the first thing I see in the video is a reassuring concrete block base going all the way up from ground floor earth! 👌
I understand your initial reaction. I’m happy to report it is very solid and stable. I hope to share some imaging session results soon. Clear skies!
@@marksastrojourney Yes you are doing a very professional well planned out job on that observatory my friend! I look forward to seeing your imaging nights! Clear Skies!
Looking forward to seeing more.
Thanks for watching!
Good work.
Thanks!
Looking good. I take it you are happy with the stability of that tall block base. I sent a pier enquiry to SkyShed about a week ago and haven't heard back from them; must be busy. I've had the same weather in S. KY. Hopefully some dry air is coming.
I watched the movement of the mount very closely while slewing. I could not see any vibrations or shuddering. Grabbing a hold on the pier and mount, they are very solid and don’t budge any. I have a 1/2” gap between the floor and the concrete pier. The first session or two of imaging should reveal any issues with stability or confirm none exist - the proof will be in the guiding and image quality. Regarding SkyShed, I got the impression they are short staffed and it adds some delays. Also, they seem to process orders in batches. So the timing of your order placement in relation to their next batch seems to determine if you wait for several weeks or 2-3 months. I ended up missing a batch, thus had to wait longer to receive the pier.
Great video Mark!!! Enjoyed watching the building process.
glad you enjoyed it Delores!
Shared these videos with others. Very interesting. Looking forward to seeing it all set up and in use.
thanks for sharing them Virginia! I’m getting closer to getting it all together.
Makes much more sense now. I was thinking the room would be enclosed like an office with the roof sliding open. I thought you were moving all photography up there also. now I understand. Everything came out great. Congratulations, your builders did a great job and best of luck on your continued journey and much enjoyment with your new Observatory.
Thanks for the encouragement!
Thanks for some beautiful footage! Can't wait to see more
Imaging the eclipse was an awesome experience! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
More to come!
Yes I could tell in the first video at the other camera angle there was a large slope to the property. You do what you have to do. I'm sure you two will be glad to have the camper under cover. I was a little surprised, it didn't appear they had plastic around the lower walls for splatter during the pour? Maybe your concrete crew was better than the ones I have seen! Will you be able to have insulation in the roof since it is a rolling roof? I know your area gets hot in the summer and cold in the winter. I love watching the fast movement of the clouds behind the structure when the video is sped up, looks amazing.
I saw them put plastic for splatter on the front and side for the walk and apron, but not on the inside for the main floor. But it doesn’t seem to have any splatter. They did insulate both roofs.
Hello Mark. Sherri said on the quilting show this morning about your building project. I enjoy building project and watching buildings going up and seeing all about the construction aspect. Nice you are getting your Observatory. You two have a nice country property as far as I can tell. Nice open skys for you hobby. I'm sure the Observatory will be a great advantage with the height improvement and rolling roof for your photography.
Thanks for watching! Yes, I think the observatory will definitely improve my experience.
Cool Mark!
Thanks for watching SkyShed POD Team! Feel free to include a link to my unboxing video within your site/channel/content if you feel it would be helpful to others who may be interested in getting a pier. Clear skies!
@@marksastrojourney I'm about to do that Mark! For Jon, who's pier shipped yesterday. I'm here as needed. ;)
Perhaps this will be covered in a future video, but I'm wondering how you will attach the pier to your 2nd story footing.
There are j-bolts in concrete in the top of the concrete footing. The metal pier will be secured to those.
Nice pier.
looking forward to trying it out!
Unfortunately I have no view of Polaris so I can’t use SharpCap. Lately I have been using my UV IR cut filter with N.I.N.A. so I can use shorter exposure times and do the alignment earlier in the evening. I think PHD2 has a drift alignment tool but I never tried it.
It’s fortunate N.I.N.A. is working well for you. I played around some with PHD2’s drift alignment tool. I think it would take a little more time to master as it doesn’t seem as intuitive as some of the other tools and their user interface. I’ve read that using bookmarks as you go along with the PHD2 drift align makes it easier to use. Clear skies!
Thanks, unfortunately by carrying out step 12 I get a purple image. I use Stellarium version 23.4 and the image was obtained following all the previous steps.
I opened Stellarium on my laptop and under the Help About section it displays my version as follows: Stellarium 1.1 Version 1.22.4 Based on Qt 6.4.0 I suppose it is possible that they've modified the Landscape feature and adding a custom landscape requires one of the steps I did to be performed slightly differently or the requirements for the custom image are different. I hate to hear it's not working out for you. It's really nice to have your own landscape displayed within Stellarium.
@@marksastrojourney I found Stellarium 23.4 version 23.4.0 based on Qt: 6.5.3. Thanks anyway, I solved it: the name of the landscape in the .ini file was not the same (capital letter) with that of the folder containing the files. Thank you.
I'm glad to hear you figured it out. Sometimes it's those pesky little details like casing or spelling that trip us up. Clear skies!
Looking good.
Thanks 👍
When i've tried sharpcap with ipolar i've found that they are consistent both with each other and with seconf measurements with themselves. I did a run with nina after running sharpcap, and was 6 minutes off. After adjusting to under 30 arc seconds i ran nina agsin, snd was 6 arc minutes off again. The best thing about ipolar is thet i can usually polar align about 30 minutes earlier than i can with anything else.
Thanks for sharing your findings!
Nice.
Thanks!
Hey Mark well the EQ6 is certainly a solid reliable mount, so should help. Very surprised your ioptron is not handling above 3 mins subs, especially with something like only the Redcat on. You may want to look at posting your PHD2 log files on cloudy nights some folks might be able to help you work it out.
I’ve read several threads on there, it seems like a good forum for getting suggestions. IOptron had me send them the phd2 logs before they had me send it in for servicing. But they didn’t recommend any course of action or different settings aside from the service they did on it.
What sort of building permits and code inspections regarding the building plans did you have to go through or did the builder take care of those issues? Amy Astro started an observatory and she had to keep resubmitting her building plans because the sliding roof design was unusual and they felt a garage door type track system wouldn’t work in windy conditions. After two episodes of her observatory build her RUclips channel content ends with no updates in over a year.
this builder is Amish and doesn’t handle the building permit process. So I did the building permit online. In our area, they prefer online submission. I had to attach my plans, which clearly indicate the observatory and the roll off roof. The building inspector gave the final inspection approval. He came for several inspections. Regarding the electric, my electrician did that permit separately. The final electrical inspection is still pending as the electric meter is getting hooked up today. I feel all roll of roofs involve some risks from storms due to the nature of their design and not being permanently attached. But I believe building standards and tolerances vary by state, city and county to a certain degree.
What were your PHD2 RMS errors reported with your iOptron. What guide camera and main camera. Focal reducer? Focal length? I’m surprised because I have an AVX mount and if I can keep the RA and DEC under 1” I can shoot up to 5 minutes I once tried a 10 minute exposure with success. I’m using a C8 SCT with OAG at 1442mm. I thought iOptron were solid mounts. It’s on my list as a possible mount upgrade, CEM40 or GEM45. The EQ6 has a good reputation. Good luck with it. Didn’t want to go strain wave?
I just checked the log folders for PHD2 and noticed no log is getting created because I don’t have that checkbox enabled. So I can’t check history from a recent session to give a precise statistic. However, my recollection is that for the most part the line on the graph in PHD2 stays between -2¨ and +2”. However, there are spikes out to -+4 and even -+6. I have the mounts PEC disabled and have the Predictive PEC enabled in PHD2. I found PHD2’s PEC works better than that of the mount. Also, I’ve been getting my polar alignment down to under 1 arc minute. Usually, I’m able to get that down to around 20 arc seconds on both alt/az. Guide camera is a ZWO 120mm mini guide camera. Main camera is a ZWO ASI2600MM Pro. Telescope is a WO Redcat61 with focal length of 300 and f4.9. No focal reducer involved with this scope. I have seen many positive reviews of the CEM40 and GEM45. But I’ve found several people’s threads facing similar guiding issues as mine with the GEM28. Unfortunately, I didn’t find those threads until after I had it a while. In no way am I trying to cast a negative light on iOptron. As long as I stick with 3 minute or less exposures, the mount does well. It is also quite portable and I’ve taken it on multiple trips to other sites//states. I did multiple attempts at 5 minute exposures and just got tired of discarding so many bad subframes. I can still get decent results at 3 minutes even with narrowband. That being said, I’d still like to do 5 minute exposures. As a side note, I did send my GEM28 back to iOptron early on to have them service it. This resulted from a series of support communications. They replaced a drive belt, replaced the grease in the gearbox and adjusted it and said it was fine. Regarding strain wave or harmonic, I guess I might try that in the future for a grab n go mount. But in this case, I’m going to put this EQ6-R Pro on a pier. I don’t plan to be swapping out mounts on the pier or using this at other sites. Thus as a personal preference I like this mount for this use case. For now if I travel, I’ll take the GEM28. Thanks for the interest and watching - clear skies!
Looks heavy.
yes, heavier than my Gem28 mount for sure! But once I get it on the pier, i don’t plan on moving it from there.
That's a cool idea Mark cheers.
thanks, clear skies!
Looks like an epic build Mark.
I’m really looking forward to being able to use the observatory! Thanks for watching!
Neat.
Thanks for watching!
Good work.
thanks for the encouragement!
Making great progress. What are you doing for power? BTW, love the barn quilt star; there's one about a mile away from me that I use to align my finder scope.
Unsure which power you mean? If you mean power in the new observatory: I'm still waiting for the electric company to hook up the meter on the building as I had to have a new service installed for the building separately. If you mean power management for my telescope mount, I've been using a Pegasus Advanced Powerbox. I made that barn quilt some time back. It is made from wood and then hand painted. I made a 2nd one and only painted the solid background color. I'm still trying to think of a cool pattern to use that would be appropriate for the observatory building.
@@marksastrojourney Electricity to the building us what I meant. Of course, the Pegasus Powerbox is a strong choice for the management. I'll dig through some of my quilt block pattern books to see if anything screams observatory at me and let you know. Hundreds of star variants of course, yours looks like a simplified mariner's compass. It's a good one
The electricity to the building situation has me a little stumped. It's been almost 2 weeks since the inspector gave the go ahead for REMC to connect the meter/line. I called them to ask when it might be done. They said, it's not on the schedule yet and sent me to the voicemail of one of their engineers. But no call was returned to my message. I thought they'd be eager to hookup anything that would start making them money. I guess they don't have enough workers or they sent them all out of state to work on storm damage repair and have nobody to do local work. I doubt they'd be here more than 30-60 minutes. The line is already installed and just needs to be connected on both ends.
Nice work mark looking awesome
Thanks for the feedback and for watching! Clear skies!
I’m in the southern hemisphere (Sydney, AU) and mobile (and mostly image within a 40 min drive from the centre of the city so around SQM 19.9 to 21). Setting up each time, you want something simple and fast. I like the PoleMaster camera as it just clicks into place on the mount’s body, in the centre of the RA rotational axis and you don’t have to worry about focusing. The polemaster app is a pain so don’t use it. I use sharpcap polar alignment routine with the Polemaster camera. All this can be done just when stars appear. The setting up NINA, main camera, focus etc is all done next after polar alignment is finished. I think it would be interesting to use a drift alignment method (as you suggested) and compare others to that. I’ve been told an app such as PemPro would speed that up.
it sounds like you’ve worked out a great solution for your grab and go setup. I was looking at phd2 guiding’s drift align, but could tell right away it will take some experimentation to get the hang of it. Clear skies! It’s great to hear from the Southern hemisphere!
Any of them are fine, they all will easily get you within what is needed for proper guiding for pretty lengthy exposures with a decent mount. Even if you run the same application twice your going to get slightly different results on each run.
thanks for sharing your observations! I also think if the mount is on a tripod instead of a pier, one of the tripod legs can shift ever so slightly and throw it off after it’s polar aligned. The equipment cools and warms over time and it seems like that’s a factor as well. Clear skies!
Very nice. I would like to see how and where you hung the barn quilt.
I will take a photo and send to you. Thanks for watching!
"New to Astrophotography? Why aren't you plate solving???" Since I am new to astrophotography, I don't even know what plate solving is... 😉
I totally understand! I too was in the same spot at one time. But after starting to use it, a person realizes it is a great tool! Clear skies!
SharpCap is the best. It was checked on 10 micron mount after 30-point sky model.
Is that a published test/finding you're referring to or your own? Feel free to post the URL if it was a published article. Clear skies!
I've had great results with it. Can believe I wasted money on that QHY polar camera system.
Thanks for sharing that - it might save some others wasting their money. Clear skies!
With no sight to the north and limited sight to the rest (Have only my balcony in a urban region), NINA is the best solution for me. It take a bit to bring it down to ~1 Arcmin, but I get great results with 5 min exposures.
That’s a pretty good outcome considering the limitations of your site! Clear skies!
Thank you 🖖🏼
You’re welcome! I hope you found something useful to save a little time. Clear skies!
Thanks for making this video. This is exactly what i was looking for, i especially appreciated the closeup of the information by the focuser. I found a scope losted but it doesnt say the model and i wanted to see of this was it!
Glad it was helpful!
I've been doing polar alignment for almost 4 years, and iPolar is BY FAR the best. <1 arcmin polar alignment error in <1 min of real time. By the way, that circle is not supposed to be blinking. If you are doing your polar alignment when it's not exactly dark, maybe try increasing your iPolar exposure time to 750ms for better SNR (unless it's so bright that it would saturate the pixels.) Another tip: for those with adapters and not a built-in iPolar from the factory, I do 5 calibrations back to back, then average the x,y center positions and enter the averages manually in settings. That calibration will be super precise and lasts for at least a year.
Thanks for sharing your experience and some helpful suggestions for getting the best results! Clear skies!
Hey Mark - We pretty much have to use software down here in Australia. I've always found Sharpcap a great tool for this. Nice comparison video very useful 👍
It's great to hear from someone in Australia! I can see why you like Sharpcap's Polar Align feature - overall Sharpcap gives a lot of options to allow us to control the different tools. Thanks for watching and wishing you clear skies!
I find the better my polar alignment, the better my guiding is. my best alignment was at 1 arc sec, using asi air. but I bet if I had repeated the polar alignment again, it would have shown a different error
That’s a good outcome, only 1 arc sec! I’m finding once I get down to around 30 arc seconds or less for polar alignment, it’s challenging to adjust without over correction. It might have something to do with how the mount bolts and adjustment mechanism is designed. Thanks for sharing your experience!
Interesting vid. You could have tested each alignment by doing a exposure for the duration of your worm period to see the drift.
I’ll have to look up the duration in the specs. I seem to recall it being something like 10 minutes. But that sounds like another interesting twist I could do for this exercise. Clear skies!
@@marksastrojourneyThe GEM28 is indeed 600 secs. Should be more than long enough to show any Dec/RA miss alignment. I use a CEM70 and iPolar. I try my best to get the cross concentric to the circle and the Dec tracking is pretty good. No consistent adjustments in 1 particular direction. I tried the 3 star alignment on APT and got terrible results so I stick to iPolar.
It's good to hear that some people are having good success just using iPolar! I've never owned a CEM70, but guessing that name means it can support a 70 lb payload. If that's right, I'm thinking your mount is heavier duty than mine. Do you see issues on the CEM70 with tightening the mount screws down affecting your polar alignment and having to do another final minor adjustment to correct that? Clear skies!
@@marksastrojourney The CEM70 does carry 70lb of load. There's no bolts to tighten down on the mount really. The azimuth is adjusted by 2 push bolts and I move the altitude with threaded feet on my home made tripod. There are 2 clamps on the mount to secure the altitude adjustment (which could shift the alignment) but they're always clamped down on my rig.
@alanjs1 That sounds like a good setup!
Good thing that nina and sharpcap were saying roughly the same deviation. this is reassuring. I have recently re calibrated my ipolar (changed the x-y values) after I performed a drift alignement . The circle and cross were close but not right on. I am planning to compare also with nina and that similar routine in APT. Let's keep in mind here that PHD will give the polar error of the guide scope , which may not be perpendicular to the mount's axis. Thanks for the video.
it’s good to hear your experience and I’m glad you enjoyed the video! Clear skies!
I do 5 calibrations back to back, then average x,y positions of the center of rotation and enter those averages in settings. This way, the polar alignment is as good as it could be with respect to the hardware limitations.
Thanks for watching and sharing what you've learned to work well with Polar Alignment! Clear skies!
Many possible issues here. First, the ipolar must be perfectly installed, flush against the mount with no tilt for best results. Second, try nina and sharpcap thru the ipolar. Using the scope to polar align setups up possible cone error unless the scope is properly pointing straight using adjusting rings instead of the clamshell clamps. Personally I use ipolar but a good possible test of your alignment is to leave ipolar open on green after your alignment. Then slew 90 degrees east and then west to see if the alignment stays green, or close enough, thru the entire slews. Thanks for the tests.
Thanks for sharing some ideas! The polar scope came installed from the factory and I never have assessed whether or not it might not be installed properly. But it does appear to be fully flush to the mount as you mentioned. Interesting suggestion regarding slewing. Clear skies!
maybe you could test with the PHD2 guiding see which method is the best
thanks for watching! I may give that a try to see what it shows. Clear skies!
That 5mm looks a lot like the old tmb burgess planetary series, which has been sold under many brand names. The 25 is just a fancy dressed up plossl like the vixen NPL line, and all in fact are made by the same company, synta. This scope is also available for more money as a vixen 100ed, and of course the orion 100ed. When these first came out, the 5mm had the same looking cosmetics as the 25. It was a longer eye relief than 5mm plossl, but I don't think it was as nice or as wide angle as the one you just got. Those are actually pretty decent. It would be nice if more scopes came with those instead of the usual small plossls or MAs for the high power. Also.note that the twist up eyeguards don't Indicate what the eye relief of the eyepiece actually is, nor does it adjust the eye relief. Buy yes it does get the eyecup out of the way for eyeglasses, but more importantly you can keep them all the way up to minimize the chance of other people getting eyelash grease or mascara on your eyepieces. Scopes like that usually destroy the common, sometimes slightly out of collimation SCTs and Dobs that many astronomy club members bring to outreach events, on planets, which is the most common outreach target other than showpiece dsos on the larger aperture scopes. And the views of open clusters are best in refractors, even in light pollution. I'm sure you love it by now
thanks for all the great details shared in your comments! I do still enjoy this telescope. I’ve since added a wo redcat61 for wide field imaging. So now I end up using one for a month or two and then switching to the other one. I have to admit, since I’ve learned more of the basics of astrophotography I’ve barely done any visual astronomy. Clear skies!
@@marksastrojourney that's where a dob comes in handy, something to look through while your rig is integrating.
Why are you using the HA filter in NINA to PA @ 30 second exposure? This is far too long, change to the luminance and use 5 second exposures. I also find that no matter which PA app I use they always tend to differ which PHD2 when running Guiding Assistant
that’s a good catch on the filter, I didn’t even notice it - thanks for pointing it out! Thanks for mentioning the discrepancy you usually see between these PA utilities and PHD2 guiding assistant as well. Clear skies!
30 seconds for platesolve?lol
Not in my case. To avoid people having to wait through while the software is imaging/working, I didn’t show the entire wait time. It usually takes a few minutes in my case as I have to break down my equipment each time and set it all back up the next time.
Your screen shows 30s exposure in Nina , for platesolving ... 15s on sharpcap
I used to have an EQ6 Pro with a polar scope that try as I might to adjust the internals, was always 10 arc minutes of the pole. It guided fine for 3-5 minute exposures. Now I'm bummed if Sharcap only grades me as "Good"alignment, like 35 arc seconds of the pole.... lol. Ignorance is sometimes bliss. I always use Sharcap now. My new Nyx 101 mount does not give you a choice.
that sounds frustrating about the polar scope not being able to be adjusted to be aligned with the mount itself. Do you find the nyx 101 mount to be superior to the eq6 pro?
Hi Mark, great video! I have an iOptron GEM45 and have been satisfied with the iPolar allignment when using NINA to capture images. The thing I really do not like with this mount is the fact that when you tighten down the mount your alignment shifts a little and you have to correct it again. I love my GEM45, but there has to be a better way to lock down the mount after you have aligned. Clear skies!!!!
I agree with you about the screws used to tighten down the mount. Mine requires an Allen wrench. Also, just as you said and as was obvious in my video, tightening them down slightly undoes some of the your polar alignment adjustments. this probably could be better engineered so that the locking mechanism doesn’t shift the mount any. Clear skies!
same with my cem40, so I tighten the screws a little, realign then tighten fully.
I have an AVX mount with a C8 SCT, focal reducer, ASI071MC Pro. My AVX has a polar scope with a pattern showing the NCP and using an app on my phone, PS Align Pro, I get a better starting point for NINA polar alignment. I use NINA for polar alignment. I can usually get below 30” but sometimes below 10”. I’ll then run the polar alignment a second time. Once it finishes the slews and plate solves, it never reports the same. I make sure after tightening the Alt/Az screws to verify the polar alignment hasn’t changed or if it did it’s just a few seconds off prior to the tightening. Another verification check for polar alignment is in PHD2 Guiding Assistant the polar alignment error is reported. It’s usually way off from the NINA results. My understanding is the reason to get great polar alignment is for better guiding and I guess with my mount there is still too much drift and PHD2 somehow can figure out how far I’m off. I don’t bother with Guide Assistant anymore just to save time. Despite these issues I can usually use 3 minute exposures successfully enough to get, for me, decent galaxy images. Have you been satisfied with your iOptron. I’m researching an upgrade to a new mount. I’m not sold that strainwave mounts are the best choice for an SCT at 1442mm and 2032mm due to their periodic error. Thanks
Thanks KJ for sharing your experience! With my Gem28 ioptron mount, I feel that 3 min exposures are about the most I can push it. If I try to go for 5 mins, I usually have too many issues with distorted stars. If you want to step up to 5 min exposures, I wouldn’t recommend the Gem28. Clear skies!
I’d probably look at a GEM45 or CEM40. The EQ6 mount has a great reputation but the mount head is too heavy. I’m not sure strainwave mounts are good for higher focal length guiding. Thanks.
It'll be interesting to hear how one of those works out for you once you have it. Hopefully, the tracking will be better to help you get the longer exposure time you're after!