Garrulous Goldmask
Garrulous Goldmask
  • Видео 57
  • Просмотров 4 214 505
How FromSoft Botched the Elden Ring DLC Ending | A Narrative Critique
Even by the standards of FromSoft storytelling, which is deliberately vague and ambiguous, the Promised Consort Radahn storyline in Shadow of the Erdtree is deeply disappointing.
Now there is a clear distinction between narrative and lore. And in this narrative critique, I specifically focus on the narrative shortcomings of having Radahn be Miquella's Promised Consort in the Elden Ring DLC. Unfortunately, there is a complete lack of build-up to finding out the identity of Miquella's promised consort. And Radahn is disconnected from so much of the Shadow of the Erdtree, with his story completely isolated from Messmer, Romina, and other bosses in the DLC.
I can't be the only one who saw that...
Просмотров: 25 773

Видео

What was Marika's Original Sin? | Elden Ring Lore EXPLAINED
Просмотров 43 тыс.21 день назад
Godhood is not all it's cracked up to be. Marika's original sin is one of the most important events in Elden Ring. But what was it? This video will cover Marika, the Secret Rite Scroll, Miquella, the Shaman Village, the Hornsent practice of divine invocation, and the Elden Beast. To better understand Marika's original sin, I also delve into the writings of Augustine, who popularized the doctrin...
Miquella's Great Rune was Mistranslated | Elden Ring DLC Lore
Просмотров 52 тыс.Месяц назад
Here’s what it actually says. Elden Ring is a massive game that weaves together so many different mythologies and traditions, some things are just bound to end up lost in translation. Most infamously, Ranni's Age of Stars ending had very different implications between the English and Japanese versions. Unfortunately, the Elden Ring DLC Shadow of the Ring has another mistranslation for another D...
So, Was Melina the Gloam-Eyed Queen? Or Her Vessel? | Elden Ring Lore
Просмотров 54 тыс.Месяц назад
Even though we didn't get official confirmation about the Gloam-Eyed Queen, the Elden Ring DLC still gave us plenty of new clues about her identity. That includes new lore from Messmer and even the Putrescent Knight, which is labelled in the internal game files as "GloamEyedKnight." In this video, I offer two theories for why Melina has that gloam eye in the Flame of Frenzy ending. I also make ...
What Happened with Miquella and Torrent in the Elden Ring DLC?
Просмотров 76 тыс.2 месяца назад
In an interview before the DLC came out, Hidetaka Miyazaki did confirm that it was Miquella in the announcement image. But I have seen some folks dismiss the image as just concept art. So is there anything in the game that connects Miquella with Torrent? We do get answers in Shadow of the Erdtree, but In typical FromSoft fashion, it's only after a lot of digging. In this video, I make the case ...
Wait, is Godwyn in the Elden Ring DLC?
Просмотров 231 тыс.2 месяца назад
Godwyn has a surprising amount of new lore in the Elden Ring DLC. In this video, I go over the tragedy of Godwyn the Golden and his relationships with Miquella, Godfrey, Marika, Fortissax, Fia, and his Death Knights. I also make the case for why Godwyn was born with Deathblight, why Godwyn is still alive (and not braindead), and why Miquella may have rejected Godwyn for the DLC's final boss. Sp...
Metyr, the God that Fled Placidusax | Elden Ring DLC Lore
Просмотров 93 тыс.2 месяца назад
Man, Elden Ring really is Bloodborne 2... One of the biggest lore revelations from the Elden Ring DLC involve Metyr, who we learn is the daughter of the Greater Will itself and the mother of all Two Fingers and the Fingercreepers. But I think Metyr is an even more important figure than we might have realized. In this video, I make the case for why Metyr, the Mother of Fingers, was also the myst...
Why is Radahn Miquella's Consort? | Elden Ring DLC Lore EXPLAINED
Просмотров 137 тыс.3 месяца назад
It's not as random as you might think. Massive spoilers for Shadow of the Erdtree. When I finished up the Elden Ring DLC, I had so many questions: Why is Radahn the final boss in the Elden Ring DLC? Why is Radahn Miquella's consort? Did Radahn agree to make that vow with Miquella? Or is there something much more sinister going on? After scouring both the DLC and the base game with a fresh pair ...
ALL of the Cut Lore from Elden Ring’s 1.00 Version
Просмотров 117 тыс.3 месяца назад
I doubt you could even imagine how much got cut. The Elden Ring 1.00 version is effectively an official rough draft of the game's lore. To access the unpatched 1.00 version of Elden Ring, all you need is a disc copy of the game and a console that isn't connected to the Internet. FromSoft also has a history of reusing cut content, which is why I wanted to get this video out before Shadow of the ...
How a Tweet Helps Solve a Huge Mystery about Miquella | Elden Ring Lore Theory
Просмотров 22 тыс.4 месяца назад
How a Tweet Helps Solve a Huge Mystery about Miquella | Elden Ring Lore Theory
Marika and the (Literal) Birth of Grace | Elden Ring DLC Story Trailer Analysis
Просмотров 7 тыс.4 месяца назад
Marika and the (Literal) Birth of Grace | Elden Ring DLC Story Trailer Analysis
A Huge Clue for Shadow of the Erdtree was Hiding in Cut Content | Elden Ring Lore
Просмотров 7 тыс.4 месяца назад
A Huge Clue for Shadow of the Erdtree was Hiding in Cut Content | Elden Ring Lore
9 NPCs & Bosses with Cut Dialogue in Elden Ring 1.00
Просмотров 5 тыс.4 месяца назад
9 NPCs & Bosses with Cut Dialogue in Elden Ring 1.00
Is Fallout: New Vegas Still Canon After the Amazon TV Show?
Просмотров 4,4 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Is Fallout: New Vegas Still Canon After the Amazon TV Show?
Shadow of the Erdtree is a Giant Evergaol | Elden Ring DLC Lore Theory
Просмотров 8 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Shadow of the Erdtree is a Giant Evergaol | Elden Ring DLC Lore Theory
Why is Radahn Required for Shadow of the Erdtree? | Elden Ring Lore Theory
Просмотров 113 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Why is Radahn Required for Shadow of the Erdtree? | Elden Ring Lore Theory
What Miyazaki Confirmed for Shadow of the Erdtree | Elden Ring DLC Lore
Просмотров 6 тыс.7 месяцев назад
What Miyazaki Confirmed for Shadow of the Erdtree | Elden Ring DLC Lore
Morrowind Shows Starfield is Worse than Outdated | A Girthy Retrospective
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Morrowind Shows Starfield is Worse than Outdated | A Girthy Retrospective
Elden Ring Lore: A Girthy Critique
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Elden Ring Lore: A Girthy Critique
Was Godwyn Also Born Cursed? | Elden Ring Lore
Просмотров 17 тыс.9 месяцев назад
Was Godwyn Also Born Cursed? | Elden Ring Lore
Why Did Marika Shatter the Elden Ring? | Elden Ring Lore
Просмотров 21 тыс.10 месяцев назад
Why Did Marika Shatter the Elden Ring? | Elden Ring Lore
Armored Core 6 is an Allegory for Alchemy
Просмотров 23 тыс.11 месяцев назад
Armored Core 6 is an Allegory for Alchemy
FromSoft Hid One of its Best Voice Actors in Armored Core 6 NG++
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.11 месяцев назад
FromSoft Hid One of its Best Voice Actors in Armored Core 6 NG
Understanding Ayre & Coral in Armored Core 6
Просмотров 23 тыс.Год назад
Understanding Ayre & Coral in Armored Core 6
Who is Handler Walter? | Armored Core 6 Story & Lore Explained
Просмотров 43 тыс.Год назад
Who is Handler Walter? | Armored Core 6 Story & Lore Explained
Wait, Was Aldia in Dark Souls 3?
Просмотров 156 тыс.Год назад
Wait, Was Aldia in Dark Souls 3?
Is the Greater Will Even Alive? | Elden Ring Lore EXPLAINED
Просмотров 26 тыс.Год назад
Is the Greater Will Even Alive? | Elden Ring Lore EXPLAINED
Elden Ring Lore is Surprisingly Queer
Просмотров 18 тыс.Год назад
Elden Ring Lore is Surprisingly Queer
Radagon is Elden Ring’s True Antagonist
Просмотров 81 тыс.Год назад
Radagon is Elden Ring’s True Antagonist
Gnosticism: The Philosophy Behind Elden Ring’s Frenzied Flame
Просмотров 17 тыс.Год назад
Gnosticism: The Philosophy Behind Elden Ring’s Frenzied Flame

Комментарии

  • @altarf2582
    @altarf2582 10 часов назад

    Admittedly there is one piece of foreshadowing for Radahn being Miquella's consort, but it's so obscure i hardly count it. Both ends of the Lion Greatbow have a golden carved Miquella's Lily as its tip and there are golden, crown-wearing lions also carved on the bow. That, combined with the fact that Radahn's swords and bow are made of the same material as the black knights' armor and weapons (and maliketh's armor) too, does imply it was always planned. It's just really, really stupid foreshadowing

  • @TheSinsOfAvarice97
    @TheSinsOfAvarice97 13 часов назад

    Ehhh idk now that ive had time to sit with it it just leaves the game open for a 2nd game. Which theyve already hinted at having interest in doing so its really not that bad it wraps up what it needed to wrap up and leaves the fun things still a mystery.

  • @SMac86
    @SMac86 16 часов назад

    The problem is you take out a God BEFORE you take out a God. It kinda outshines the main story by looking like it's no big deal to slay a God. I wish for once a DLC would take place after the main quest. Being an actual Elden Lord and confronting Miquella and Radahn would have been fantastic.

  • @waltermolinski
    @waltermolinski 17 часов назад

    The game mistranslates “…”. The Kanji for “…” is actually “…”, not “…”

  • @StarlitMoss
    @StarlitMoss 17 часов назад

    Would like to mention that nonbinary people can still use he or she as a pronoun. And intersex people can be very diverse in body parts. Personally I doubt the gods really need to care about biology. Especially considering Marika/Radagon, and Miquella/st Trina Also queer people can be villains. I feel like as long as it is done well, and this game does as long as you look into the lore.

  • @t1m0rp
    @t1m0rp 19 часов назад

    wasn't ds3 lothric supposed to be a merged world comprising of different dimensions.... one could hypothesize that drangleic was one of those worlds

  • @4heedhaaahahahaha282
    @4heedhaaahahahaha282 20 часов назад

    You have to understand the SOULS DLCs don't have endings. Bloodborne ended with Orphan, no ending credits, just a small cutscene. Dark Souls 1, the same, Dark Souls 3, the same. But, the Elden Ring's DLC ending is still bad, because it leaves you vacant, there is something uncomplete in this ending, like it doesn't conclude. It's not the cutscene, it's not that there are no credits or whatever. You see, the endings in SOULS DLCs, in each one of them, were THE FINAL BOSS BATTLES THEMSELVES, in Dark souls 3 the DLC's ending WAS THE FIGHT WITH FUCKING GAEL HIMSELF at the END OF THE FUCKING WORLD, THAT was the ending, no cutscene needed. In Bloodborne the ending was FIGHTING A GREAT ONE WASHED UP IN A FUCKING SHORE ON TOP OF THE CORPSE OF ITS MOTHER, THAT was the ending. This is where Elden Ring's DLC is lacking, the ENDING is ASS because the FINAL BATTLE is ASS, pointless, meaningless, awful. Know the difference.

  • @Samply-put
    @Samply-put 23 часа назад

    A beefed up Metyr mother of fingers, or bayle the dread would have made for a cooler final boss if the game actually acknowledged you for becoming the elden lord

  • @Nobody32990
    @Nobody32990 День назад

    Even with Ansbach quest, the build up or set up to Radhan is almost none existent both in DLC and base game. To quote Gordon Ramsay: "It's fuqing raw!"

  • @sebastian6650
    @sebastian6650 День назад

    Why do people always have on mind incest or sex when it comes to Radahn and Miquella? Its such a pointless thing to say that doesnt get you anywhere. Fromsoft used the word "consort" in this game not in a sexual manner, but in a ruling manner. Godfrey was to Marika the same thing Radahn was to Miquella: a law/order enforcer. You can even see it in Radahns stomp attack and his long braid, both reminescent of a figure he admired so much, and basically even became: Godfrey.

  • @DontKnow-hr5my
    @DontKnow-hr5my День назад

    Should have been Malenia instead of Radahn

  • @Melody51433
    @Melody51433 День назад

    What if ... Ranni and Godwyn were already conspiring before his death? If Godwyn knew about his curse and possibly impending "death", and was aware of the problems with the Golden Order, maybe he conspired with Ranni to have her steal the rune of death and kill him in order to bring about the end of the Golden order?

  • @p.istvan8744
    @p.istvan8744 День назад

    I just don't like the fact that you are not given a choice. Sure, make Radahn his consort, but like, the Tarnished is pretty morally grey, so why can't you accept their order as an ending? It wouldn't even be the worst morality wise, in one ending you literally destroy the world, and it's not like Dung Eater's ending is any better. Or if they really want a fight, they could have still given a way to return Trina to Miquella and have an ending that way or something (I personally like this idea the best, because even she feels like a waste). I enjoyed the fight, it's fun, it's hard, but I'm still salty with the lack of ending choice.

  • @JPMgeo
    @JPMgeo День назад

    Radahn is a bad choice no matter what. And for those that say Godwyn couldn't be the final boss for lore reasons, ANYTHING can happen in these games! It's a fantasy world.

  • @senator_pancake1603
    @senator_pancake1603 День назад

    Or it is merely his body protecting itself instinctively...

  • @braedenaldridge8452
    @braedenaldridge8452 День назад

    I’m always absolutely shocked when people say Godwin looks like a fish. Am I the only one who sees this as the dragon flesh he would have consumed in Dragon Communion.

  • @Mr.Starlight_gaming
    @Mr.Starlight_gaming День назад

    Nah dis peak

  • @waveburner1254
    @waveburner1254 День назад

    As someone who jumped into Elden Ring earlier this year, i was so incredibly confused, frustrated and annoyed by From hiding bits and secrets in the earliest story trailers. Yes, the story trailers that aren't even in the actual game! Malenia who says that Miquella awaits Radahn when fighting him in that one trailer and then there's just that stupid end Cutscene you get for fighting the probably most unbalanced (by the time at least) boss in the entirety of From history. Bed of Chaos doesn't even hold up to this abomination imo. Yes I know I sound salty but imo I have a good reason. The whole plot with Radahn and Miquella was so poorly explained, it's some weird incest thingy I personally don't like (but that may just be me) and Radahn has NOT A SINGLE WORD TO SAY! Seriously, they made him an empty husk just for Miquellas vow. That btw was actually explained in one of the item descriptions. And there it is specifically said that Miquella had a wish. A heartfelt wish to make Radahn his consort. Nowhere is it stated that Radahn had any saying in the matter nor that he actually agreed. It's such a horrible ending. Starting the DLC I thought Messmer kidnapped Miquella and we had to free him. I never thought of Miquella as the antagonist but man do I hate him. Anyway, this DLC was a thing with lots of ups and downs.

  • @GeorgeKelgiorgis
    @GeorgeKelgiorgis 2 дня назад

    It’s a common trope in fromsoftware games dlcs that have no endings, ds3 has no ending, ds1 has no ending, blood borne has no ending. The fact that they added a post fight cinematic with miquella is the most they have ever done. The dlc is never a true ending in fromsoft games but a complimentary to the main game story and ending

  • @Herr_Gamer
    @Herr_Gamer 2 дня назад

    I’d like to note that Elden Ring, being such a breaker of FromSoft conventions, could always recieve a second DLC based on what was missing here. Also the maingame hint to Rad and Miq’s relationship is in the design of the former’s greatbow

  • @czupryndaniel
    @czupryndaniel 2 дня назад

    I think you missed one hint. There is some place with big lore reveal, that stated what Malenia whispered to Radahn before the Aeonian bloom. For me it cleared a lot of lore theories.