Solace in Scrutiny
Solace in Scrutiny
  • Видео 6
  • Просмотров 71 990
Asus PG32UQX vs Samsung Odyssey Neo G8 - IPS vs VA mini-LED HDR Comparison
1152 vs 1196 mini-LED zones, HDR1400 vs HDR2000, IPS vs VA. Which is superior when it comes to HDR?
In this video I explore how the complexity of modern monitors requires more than just objective measurements to properly evaluate.
Links to some of the monitors I've discussed or shared videos of:
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Asus PG32UQX - amzn.to/3VNJ2rL
Samsung Odyssey Neo G8 - amzn.to/45QMfdL
Samsung Odyssey OLED G8 - amzn.to/3VQsI9D
LG 32GS95UE - amzn.to/3Xyewn3
Thank you
0:00 - Intro
0:49 - Contrast measurements
1:04 - Measurements don't always correlate
1:20 - Gsync module carries
1:46 - Judging local dimming can be deceiving
2:17 - Real world tells a different story
2:3...
Просмотров: 4 299

Видео

Samsung Odyssey OLED G8 G80SD vs Asus PG32UQX - 32" QD-OLED vs Mini-LED HDR ComparisonSamsung Odyssey OLED G8 G80SD vs Asus PG32UQX - 32" QD-OLED vs Mini-LED HDR Comparison
Samsung Odyssey OLED G8 G80SD vs Asus PG32UQX - 32" QD-OLED vs Mini-LED HDR Comparison
Просмотров 39 тыс.3 месяца назад
Sorry, had a cold while recording this and sound really stuffy. Comparison between the Samsung G80SD 32" QD-OLED and Asus 32" PG32UQX Mini-LED along with my opinions after using the two for a while. I would love to do more comparison videos. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Asus PG32UQX - amzn.to/4aYrqOn LG 32GS95UE - amzn.to/4b4rDQc Samsung G80SD - amzn.to/3yVyVIq 0:00 ...
LG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE - HDR is a messLG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE - HDR is a mess
LG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE - HDR is a mess
Просмотров 1,8 тыс.3 месяца назад
As of 6/6/2024, LG has released a firmware update that corrects the horrible black crush in HDR using Gamer 1. The over brightened highlights of Peak Brightness set to High remain though. It's now usable. *Reuploaded with some EOTF measurements and further findings. LG 32GS95UE's current HDR performance is a complete mess. EOTF tracking is poor, it crushes blacks, and accessing the service menu...
Samsung Odyssey OLED G8 32" G80SD - All Menu & Service Menu OptionsSamsung Odyssey OLED G8 32" G80SD - All Menu & Service Menu Options
Samsung Odyssey OLED G8 32" G80SD - All Menu & Service Menu Options
Просмотров 2 тыс.3 месяца назад
Walk through of the menu for the Samsung 32" QD-OLED. Included is the service menu which seems to have been changed from the prior G8 34" QD-OLED as there are no options for tuning HDR Tone mapping. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Remote used to access service menu: AA81-00243A - amzn.to/4cg5kIi 0:00 Standard Menu OSD 2:17 Game bar 2:35 Service Menu
QD-OLED vs WOLED VRR Flicker & Image Retention ComparisonQD-OLED vs WOLED VRR Flicker & Image Retention Comparison
QD-OLED vs WOLED VRR Flicker & Image Retention Comparison
Просмотров 6 тыс.3 месяца назад
Testing the severity of VRR flicker between the Samsung G80SD QD-OLED and LG 32GS95UE WOLED. Also tested to see how they fare when it comes to recovering from image retention. 0:00 Alan Wake 2 Flicker 1:31 CP2077 Flicker 2:02 CP2077 Flicker 2 2:31 Starwars Flicker 2:51 Shader Compilation Flicker 3:06 Image Retention Setup 3:21 Image Retention Results 1 4:38 Image Retention Results 2
LG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE vs Samsung 32” 4K 240Hz OLED G80SD - HDR ComparisonLG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE vs Samsung 32” 4K 240Hz OLED G80SD - HDR Comparison
LG 32" 4K 240Hz OLED 32GS95UE vs Samsung 32” 4K 240Hz OLED G80SD - HDR Comparison
Просмотров 19 тыс.3 месяца назад
Samsung G80SD QD-OLED (left) vs LG 32GS95UE WOLED (right). A comparison between the two in HDR. Sorry for the poor quality, I am trying to get a hold of a better camera to do more comparisons. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. LG 32GS95UE - amzn.to/4b4rDQc Samsung G80SD - amzn.to/3yVyVIq 0:00 City 2000nits 2:00 Metal Working 2:50 Real HDR 6:00 LG Demo 8:45 R&C HDR400 & HD...

Комментарии

  • @Magnisus
    @Magnisus День назад

    2000e mini-led vs 1200e oled. my wallet is telling me not to be stupid because oled is not the thing, plus far cheaper than anticipated.

  • @phamdinhtuong
    @phamdinhtuong 4 дня назад

    Wao, great work. like

  • @venomtailOG
    @venomtailOG 4 дня назад

    Shame the price of these mini LEDs has shot up to atmospheric levels. I can ejther buy 3 32" 4K oleds for $1300 each or 1 Asus mini LED for $4000...

  • @gunstargizmo
    @gunstargizmo 4 дня назад

    For the price of the G8, you’re better off to pay extra for the Asus. No point in spending that much just to go half way in terms of performance and quality.

    • @barryjones2366
      @barryjones2366 3 дня назад

      The G7 is more comparable (165 vs 144Hz) and that is almost half the price. Personally i'd rather the much higher quality, accuracy and much brighter ASUS! There are alot of similar options coming though for much cheaper from BenQ, Philips, FFalcon, etc...with 1152 zones and 1400+ nits. There are already some reviews out for them. But none are showing them in real content like this, mainly just the numbers and graphs....I hate when they just do that. I want to see what those numbers mean, how does it translate to real content (after tone mapping...tone mapping can really change the overall picture compared to the measurements depending on the manufacturer). 😄

  • @mantistobogganmd5231
    @mantistobogganmd5231 6 дней назад

    At 1:08 if you look towards the top right where the sky is you can see how washed out the MiniLED is. You can even see what's in the sky it's so white and too bright. OLED you can actually see everything in the distance

  • @randyleeson8572
    @randyleeson8572 7 дней назад

    I own the UQX and I absolutely love it. QD-Oled has its perks but so does a Mini-LED. Just get what is best for you.

  • @mohamedahmed1023
    @mohamedahmed1023 8 дней назад

    I cannot relate to this video at all. This person clearly has a strong like for high APL and peak brightness and isn't bothered by blooming. The assertion that miniLED's flaws don't appear often is wild. Blooming is obvious in nearly all environments when not gaming. It's especially obvious when browsing the web or moving the mouse cursor. I have owned several OLEDs and miniLEDs: *Alienware QD OLED monitor *Sony OLED TV *Asus MiniLED laptop I have also tried the Asus MiniLED he is using along with the Samsung Neo G8. They all have the same problem; *Obvious blooming -in windows, with subtitles, etc. *Terrible viewing angles *Limited micro contrast- 1000 dimming zones is just not enough *More input lag The list goes on. As long as you can mitigate the risk of burn-in, OLED's weakness is a lack of brightness above 20% window sizes. That doesn't happen often outside of high APL scenes in games and films.

  • @Ceejays69
    @Ceejays69 9 дней назад

    one question? who is better the last LG OLED 32 240 hz or Samsung OLED G8 32 for gaming and works with photoshop thanx !!

  • @bryanmejia3498
    @bryanmejia3498 11 дней назад

    OLED is definitely not a perfect technology. But I prefer gaming and watching content in a very dark room. So for me OLED is king because of its deep blacks.

  • @ployth9000
    @ployth9000 11 дней назад

    now you should see odyssey neo g9 57 vs these oleds since it can reach 240hz its nice and very bright for peak hdr brightness

  • @Alauz
    @Alauz 11 дней назад

    You should play AAA E-sports titles, they easily hit 240fps and more even at 4K. Then you'll see a ton of smearing and ghosting on the Mini-LED. This is the main reason I choose OLED.

  • @MrGunner121
    @MrGunner121 11 дней назад

    You said you tried the Innocn 32m2v and it didn’t compare to the Asus, could you elaborate more on how the Asus was better? I have the 27m2v which is significantly brighter than the 32m2v and has a lower response time, so maybe the 27m2v would better compare to the Asus in your video?

    • @MrGunner121
      @MrGunner121 11 дней назад

      Also, why didn’t you compare w-OLED to the Mini-led at all? The w-OLED usually beats qd OLED in contrast and has less saturated colors. Could you show another video comparing your w-OLED to mini-led? Thanks

  • @ErikHalaska
    @ErikHalaska 13 дней назад

    Oled

  • @deepSilent0
    @deepSilent0 17 дней назад

    Is this console 120hz?? G80SD barely flickers at 120hz. You should repeat this test at 240hz with Gsync ON, and you will see how atrocious the Samsung is. Almost unusable….

    • @User-ys7cb
      @User-ys7cb 9 дней назад

      I don't know what you mean, the G80SD already flickers much more than the LG in this comparison. The G80SD is my main monitor for now, but QD-OLED is kinda annoying, not gonna lie. I'm looking for something more reliable and consistent. I've also tried two WOLED monitors and didn't like them either.

    • @deepSilent0
      @deepSilent0 9 дней назад

      @@User-ys7cb i meant that it’s even worse at 240hz

  • @laggmonstret
    @laggmonstret 18 дней назад

    I never understood the fetish for more brightness? I mean I am using like 75 brightness now and if more I would feel like I am burning my retinas. OLED for me has never been too dimm. But with that said, HDR in Windows overall doesn't feel good yet for a set-and-forget usage. It's still buggy and sometimes not switch automatic or working at all for some games. I am gonna stick with my LG 32GQ950 that I know isn't even a Mini-LED but still got a very good picture imo. It's Nano IPS so very fast still and comes with a ATQ Polarizer that helps removing any IPS Glow (mine got none!) that you are used to. Still no deep OLED Blacks but I think I can wait bit more since burn-in is still also a factor if you're gonna use the monitor for anything else then just gaming and movies. I want Micro-LED now!

    • @Yoga_Tv_buying
      @Yoga_Tv_buying 18 дней назад

      Check out -- ADS Pro screen 📺 by American Company BOE . 2X cp react ratio . 600hz screen refresh rate . Brand new tech . Gamming TVs r using it .

    • @Yoga_Tv_buying
      @Yoga_Tv_buying 18 дней назад

      It’s dim . If ppl work at home , n have to use day time it’s def dim. especially nice big window in office :):) or living room .

  • @Coolhand69
    @Coolhand69 19 дней назад

    The price is stupid for that miniled. Just plain stupid.

  • @theyojo1656
    @theyojo1656 20 дней назад

    the asus is nearly double the price, how is this even a comparison?

    • @Yoga_Tv_buying
      @Yoga_Tv_buying 18 дней назад

      It’s not about the price . The video is trying to De bunk the Myth that (oled best ) in science program , our pHD professor spend last lecture explain the Plasma/OLED best is lie . They r inferior than LED. 😮 human eyes do NOT see things -- 3D by how black , but brightness n SHADEs of Color Density for survival . In jungle n animal . U need light ! Oled has dim n cloudy day visual , in real life , eyes will NOT pick up image as fast as LED if constantly moving , due to lack of brightness n peak highlight . Things appear -- zoom OUT further , vs come to eyes closer (POP) . That’s why evey iPhone pro release , there is huge Brightness Jump on screen . U see better .

  • @deepSilent0
    @deepSilent0 20 дней назад

    too me the colours on the LG look more "correct".

  • @amariel3310
    @amariel3310 21 день назад

    1 Month later, there is finally a new king on the block in EU, and a true competitor to the Asus PG32UQX. TCL just released their new line of miniLED monitors, the 27R83U and the 34R83Q. Both are HDR 1400 VESA Certified, and can get over 2000 nits bright in 50%-75% windows, and even up to 2000 nits peak in 100% windows! They do go down to 1200 nits after 30 minutes of full white HDR images, while also having great pixel response time and they cost 800 euro. Has the PG32UQX finally been dethroned?

    • @Eusebiugh
      @Eusebiugh 7 дней назад

      Maybe.. just the tcl get too hot actually it turn off..

  • @guttalexandrumihai9564
    @guttalexandrumihai9564 21 день назад

    I have a question, because something is strange. Samsung seems to have also dimmer colors, I think something is wrong with your calibration. That can;t be right for the sole reason thhat regarding colors volume and color vibrance, nothing beats SAMSUNG's 3rd GEN QD OLED's and especially SAMSUNG ONE's monitor which is the most over saturated.

  • @guttalexandrumihai9564
    @guttalexandrumihai9564 21 день назад

    LG more depth, more sharpness. AMAZING. I have the SAMSUNG G80 SD in front of me, and don't know what to do.

  • @93ChayZ
    @93ChayZ 21 день назад

    I personally leave VRR off on my Alienware 34DW because of the flickering, none the less the monitor is still AMAZING, only upgrade from this would be ROG's 240hz 34 or 39" WOLED

  • @deepSilent0
    @deepSilent0 22 дня назад

    I mean yeah, the only step up from the UQX are those reference grading monitors that go for 30k+ If only the response time was decent, it would be the perfect monitor…

  • @crowntotheundergroud
    @crowntotheundergroud 22 дня назад

    wow the Asus absolutely destroyed the g8. If you ever have the opportunity, can you give us a side by side comparison of the Innocn m2v vs the pg32uqx?

  • @Dmwntkp99
    @Dmwntkp99 24 дня назад

    Asus PG32UQX cost $3200 vs Neo G8 is $980. CAD...... lol

  • @barryjones2366
    @barryjones2366 24 дня назад

    Just realised you didn't use much game footage on this one compared to the Samsung QD-OLED comparison. Could you include more game footage like that video would be great! Like Dead Space, the Jedi one, Cyber Punk, etc...to show how much shadow detail and highlights gets crushed on the Neo G8.

  • @NinjaGaijinn
    @NinjaGaijinn 27 дней назад

    One thing nobody seems to comment on is Samsung's inability to display orange correctly, its comes off as a pinkish red like at 6:17. I have both a QLED and an LG OLED and the issue is clear as day when comparing those too.

  • @andrewkamoha4666
    @andrewkamoha4666 Месяц назад

    *UFO TEST !!!!*

  • @d.3671
    @d.3671 Месяц назад

    Hi, thanks for this comparison, which one would you recommand overall ?

  • @LextraGaming
    @LextraGaming Месяц назад

    Password for unlocking Advanced service menu on firmware 1641 is "0038" All credit goes to Subzero0 on the avsforum

  • @killab5304
    @killab5304 Месяц назад

    Your right channel is out in this recording.

  • @q2forever778
    @q2forever778 Месяц назад

    Left one has less brightness. Anything else?

  • @arkama67
    @arkama67 Месяц назад

    I should have bought the PG32UQX when it priced at 2500. Mini led is the way to go for HDR.

    • @stagm3
      @stagm3 Месяц назад

      It’s $1599 if you have a local MicroCenter

  • @salehabdulla9177
    @salehabdulla9177 Месяц назад

    can you recommend your top 4k monitor to me please? and did u test Samsung oled g9? I test Samsung g8 oled: it was not very bright ( darkish) but colour and black looks good, return it because text clarity was not so great and limited game mode 175hz.

  • @drayth9076
    @drayth9076 Месяц назад

    Thank you for going in depth on the PG32UQX properly. The Hardware Unboxed review was so disappointing. They got hung up on the hdmi port not being 2.0, and the price of course then barely ever mentioned it again. You never see it in their comparison charts for brightness or what not. Yeah, there's still nothing else like it on the market. I'll be using mine till it dies. NV's new auto-hdr AI filter makes even SDR games look incredible, so it's gotten even more legs to it since buying it.

  • @abearah9255
    @abearah9255 Месяц назад

    Only if they weren’t matte

  • @User-ys7cb
    @User-ys7cb Месяц назад

    I received the monitor a few days ago and I'm satisfied for the most part, but there is a weird issue. It has coil whine. Nothing new for Samsung, yeah. But what's weird about it is that the coil whine vanishes when I open the OSD or when I use the smart features. It's still there if I display a completely black screen, so it's not related to what's being displayed on the monitor, although the OSD makes it stop for some reason. HDMI or DP, lower brightness, VRR on or off, 240hz or 120hz, all of that makes no difference whatsoever. The coil whine seems to come from the lower middle part of the screen.

    • @SuperBlackGuyV2
      @SuperBlackGuyV2 5 дней назад

      I returned mine with coil whine, might want to do the same, new unit doesn't have it

  • @barryjones2366
    @barryjones2366 Месяц назад

    Is there any chance of getting the ASUS PA32UCXR (an upgraded UQX for dimming zones!) in for a comparison between the PG32UQX and also maybe a brighter ASUS OLED than the Samsung G8 OLED? I would really like to know how blacks and brightness compare! Great videos btw keep them coming, you have great potential! Maybe you could get one from ASUS in for review to take a look at? It looks incredible for specs, double the dimming zones 2304, dolby vision maybe not quite as bright and 60Hz panel only! For HDR movies/series and games though it should improve the picture quality a decent amount maybe, even less blooming with more detail to the picture?

    • @hasanrazza1
      @hasanrazza1 Месяц назад

      Same man. I just want to know if anything has beat this monitor or come close lol

    • @barryjones2366
      @barryjones2366 Месяц назад

      @@hasanrazza1 Has the Red Magic One came out yet? 5088 dimming zones! Insane! 😛 He said he is going to get that one in when it gets released....hopefully it's not vaporware.....I hope they use an IPS black or ADS Pro panel for even better blacks! I don't want an OLED for a monitor. 😁

  • @11Icazo22
    @11Icazo22 Месяц назад

    I agree with you that Mini-LED has a place in the market absolutely, but what is mini-LED better at? As far as I can tell the main difference is brightness and text clarity. I don’t know if those two factors alone are enough

    • @Yoga_Tv_buying
      @Yoga_Tv_buying 29 дней назад

      Color Volume. Mini LED has significant higher color volume than ANYTHING else. WOLED is DEAD in 2024. Anything pale on pale on pale at same time. MINI LED looks more 3D. --color Volume/Density of TVs--- ---- color volume /Density -- Sony A80L , LG C3 C4 G3 G4-all WOLED S90D, S95C, A95L--QD-OLED Hisense U8K U8N UX, Samsung QN90D , SONY X95L Bravia 9, X90L -Mini LED> 😊 Red Luminance = A80L 92 cd/m² C4 104 cd/m² G4 140 cd/m² G3 140 cd/m² S95C 272 cd/m² HisenseUX 530 cd/m²--2023 Bravia9 551 cd/m²--2024 U8N 381 cd/m² U8K. 318 cd/m² Bravia7 356 cd/m² X95L 225 cd/m² X90L. 272 cd/m² S90D 281 cd/m² Green Luminance= A80L 317 cd/m² C4 333 cd/m² G4 426 cd/m² G3 420 cd/m² S95C 882 cd/m² HisenseUX. 1,656 cd/m²-2023 Bravia9 1,130 cd/m²--2024 U8N 1,433 cd/m² U8K 1,157 cd/m² Bravia7 . 834 cd/m² X95L 781 cd/m² X90L 778 cd/m² S90D 856 cd/m² Blue Luminance= A80L 33 cd/m² C4 38 cd/m² G4 49 cd/m² G3 53 cd/m² S95C 65 cd/m² HisenseUX 166 cd/m²--2023 Bravia9. 155 cd/m²--2024 U8N 127 cd/m² U8K 96 cd/m² Bravia7 127 cd/m² X95L 62 cd/m² X90L 91 cd/m² S90D 62 cd/m² Cyan Luminance= A80L 344 cd/m² C4 365 cd/m² G4 464 cd/m² G3 456 cd/m² S95C 950 cd/m² HisenseUX 2,001 cd/m²--2023 Bravia9 1,519 cd/m²--2024 U8N 1,532 cd/m² U8K 1,240 cd/m² Bravia7 1,265 cd/m² X95L 878 cd/m² X90L. 869 cd/m² S90D 919 cd/m² Magenta Luminance= A80L 120 cd/m² C4 134 cd/m² G4 179 cd/m² G3 177 cd/m² S95C 336 cd/m² HisenseUX 783 cd/m²-2023 Bravia9 698 cd/m²-2024 U8N 480 cd/m² U8K 398 cd/m² Bravia7 483 cd/m² X95L 294 cd/m² X90L 364 cd/m² S90D 342 cd/m² Yellow Luminance= A80L 405 cd/m² C4 425 cd/m² G4 546 cd/m² G3 546 cd/m² S95C 1,151 cd/m² HisenseUX 2,140 cd/m²-2023 Bravia9 2,427 cd/m²-2024 U8N 1,776 cd/m² U8K 1,475 cd/m² Bravia7 1,547 cd/m² X95L 1,154 cd/m²-2023 X90L 1,046 cd/m²-2023 S90D 1,133 cd/m²

  • @stagm3
    @stagm3 Месяц назад

    Can’t really see the difference because the video isn’t in HDR 🤦🏾‍♂️ missed opportunity, as it stands there isn’t a huge difference that can be concluded from this SDR vid

  • @Nonspecies
    @Nonspecies Месяц назад

    Thats the Evidence thats VA is totaly Scrap! This Brown Cast of the Samsung VA Mini LED is very disgusting and the Colors are total excessive. By the Scene with the Forest 0:24 on the VA can see nothing treetops anymore. And by Scenery with the Mountain in the Back 3:24 on the VA can nothing seen of the City in front of the Mountain and the white Clouds are green, disgusting.

    • @barryjones2366
      @barryjones2366 3 дня назад

      He mentioned in the video that's only because of Samsungs decision to crush blacks alot for more of an OLED look. Nothing to do with the type of panel used. The UXQ with a really fast and high contrast VA panel with a good wide angle layer (making it look like IPS from straight on) would be even better than the IPS UQX for deeper blacks and less visible bloom but probably wouldn't have as good colour brightness....without significant optimising. But overall could be an improvement for the next version. I wonder if it's possible to replace the panel for a VA one or if the panel and back-light system come together as one piece.

    • @Nonspecies
      @Nonspecies 3 дня назад

      @@barryjones2366 Black crushing is only a VA Panel Problem! So.....

  • @MA-jz4yc
    @MA-jz4yc Месяц назад

    Its kind of a shame how the manufacturers limit the monitors when QD oled TVs can get alot brighter. The 10 percent window performance is very important for hdr gaming

  • @TheMidwestbear
    @TheMidwestbear Месяц назад

    I couldnt agree more. I bought the corsair flex oled and was shocked at how bad it was for most of my needs. Maybe for gaming and media consumption of dark scenes its great but overall its not good. I "upgraded" to a $400 no brand hdr1000 mini led and I love it so much more.

  • @xtinct16
    @xtinct16 Месяц назад

    I do not get the appeal of HDR. I set my monitor brightness to 101 cd/m². Anything higher and the monitor becomes eyestrain it is like you are looking directly at the sun burning your eyes. I would rather have the significantly better pixel response time and deep blacks of OLED.

  • @Bitedown140
    @Bitedown140 Месяц назад

    Bro that’s not qd oled at all.. that gs80 is woled

  • @rinzler777
    @rinzler777 Месяц назад

    what about talking about the matte finish over glossy which i will not accept matte finishes

  • @Oguzhan34
    @Oguzhan34 Месяц назад

    I have samsung one for 2 years and its very cheap comparing the asus one only bad side is hard coating its too hard to clean

  • @wizardd
    @wizardd Месяц назад

    you have convinced me to sell my aw3423dwf and get a pg32uqx in the near future

  • @razor2049
    @razor2049 Месяц назад

    Shit that samsung is really crap

  • @JavierDiaz-zh2jo
    @JavierDiaz-zh2jo Месяц назад

    Do you think is better to get the PG32UQX ? I'm in the market for a new 32 monitor.