"That's a lot of Lieutenants." "There will be a quiz." That's the kind of humor this sort of serious entertainment needs. Nothing to on the nose, not forced, just some throwaway lines that make you smile.
How about focus on some great smart enlisted crew like petty, chief petty and master chiefs on the ship. They always feature ensign and Lts. I'm glad they featured chief obrien on tng and d's 9.
One of those moments that really endeared me to this series. It really encapsulates the essence of exactly the kind of engineer Scotty was both in canon and out: capable of pulling extremely clever solutions out of his arse at a moment's notice and completely unafraid to kitbash something together when the situation calls for it. There's a reason he's THE engineer of the Enterprise, the standard by which the likes of Geordi, Trip, Torres, and O'Brien are judged. The captains of the Enterprise may be a pantheon, but amongst their engineers, there is but one god: Montgomery Scott.
I kinda wish he hadn’t tried to hide it. I think it would be totally in character for Scotty to have lost a finger, perhaps being careless as a young cadet, and he never regrew it to remind himself not to be careless again, and plus, as a Scotsman, a missing finger would be a grand story to tell strangers at the pub.
I haven't watched the episode yet, but damn they just nailed Scotty. Considering how larger than life the original Enterprise crew is, the casting department is really doing insanely great job getting these younger versions. No complaints here.
@@purefoldnz3070 Depends on where you are in the world,,,,, in the UK this comment is correct,, in this content "nailed it" means they have the younger Scotty character correct in comparison to the origional
Its an exaggerated Scottish accent. As an actual Scot myself it sounds like someone impersonating James Doohan's version of the character. Odd as this actor is ACTUALLY Scottish.
@@markdillon5494 Thas explains why he sounds as Scottish (with exaggerated accent) but still SCOTTY IS BACK PEOPLE. To me Only James Doohan would always be Scotty but still, its nice to see character in new age:) One of my good friends is Scootish, darn each time we have conversation i need a bloody english dictionary:):) But try speaking with Vietnamese or Thailandese oh boy.
@@markdillon5494 Exactly. I think he's been ordered to ham it up a bit for American audiences. But they nonetheless get props for actually hiring a Scottish actor. There are few more excruciating things than hearing a faked Scottish accent.
I love that this Scotty is using the British pronunciation of "Lieutenant". Which is funny since neither Doohan (a Canadian) nor Pegg (an Englishman) ever did.
@@Ostermond yes, and Simon Pegg is English, meaning both are British. And the Canadian Army (in which James Doohan served in WW2) officially uses the British pronunciation. Funny enough, Doohan even held the rank of Lieutenant during the war.
I would cautiously guess that would be because both previous versions of Scotty were scripted and directed to pronounce it that way. The impression I get is that Simon Pegg was so enamoured with Star Trek and Trek lore that he would have mispronounced the word "Lieutenant" if it meant he got to play Lt Montgomery "Scotty" Scott in anything other than a fan-film.
Martin Quinn who plays Scotty is Scottish,,, and as much as I love James Doohan I think the character works a lot better with the correct accent, as does any character,,,
@@JamesT6043 yeah James Doohan's scottish was basically what he learnt from his squad mate when he was serving in WW2. It's not the best but it worked but after seeing 'Still game', I am loving what t hey did with Scotty here
@@Pintheshadows Which is ironic, because in Lower Decks, Chief O'Brien is regarded as the most important person in Starfleet history. But the thing that everyone needs to remember is that the general rule of thumb with Star Trek is that only the movies and television shows are considered canon. Thus, non-televised media, ranging from books, comics, games (especially video games), etc., are not canon, unless stated otherwise. And even then, that can be overwritten by the movies or TV shows (like how the Star Trek Countdown comic that served as a prequel/tie-in to the 2009 film was retconned with Season 1 of Picard, changing the Hobus star going supernova and destroying Romulus to the Romulan's own sun going supernova).
I'am not. I'am quit tired of this. Ever Shown does that Today,everyone has to meet everyone or have some connection. Why must the whole crew of the Orginal Crew appear in SNW? It is a show about the Crew before the original Series.
When I watch TOS, one of the things I notice is that, for all of Scotty's eccentricities, when it comes to getting the job done nobody is more professional than him, not even Mr Spock. Young Scotty seems a bit ... distractible, but he's still young. I look forward to this Scotty working with Pelia. They'll bump heads for sure, because Scotty is still a bit of a wild card (albeit a brilliant one), while Pelia sees the big picture in ways that nobody else does. This Scotty has the makings of being the finest engineer the Enterprise has ever seen, but he's not there yet; he doesn't quite have the discipline. But he can learn that under Pelia.
Supposedly when it came to the Kobayashi Maru test, Scotty was an absolute beast, destroying numerous ships deployed against him. However, he was using battle tactics that worked in theory - and therefore the computer acted accordingly when it did the math - but not in practice. For this, Scotty was bounced out of the command track and into the engineering track, which is where he wanted to be in the first place.
I want him to get into an accident where he loses a finger and has to have it grown back, as a nod to Doohan's missing finger that he went to great effort to hide throughout all of TOS.
@@JF-tt6wy After the landing. He and a partner were on a patrol and a particularly jumpy sentry lit them up with a Bren gun. If I remember right, Doohan took one in the hip, one took off his finger, and a third that got caught by the cigarette case in his breast pocket.
@@tanall5959 According to Doohan's autobiography (which I read parts of in a library once) they could have put the finger back on, but he wouldn't be able to move it. He said it was tempting to give a permanent middle finger salute to Hitler, but removing it was more practical.
I'm almost unreasonably happy that they finally got someone playing a British person to use the correct pronunciation of Lieutenant. I know Stewart wanted to but the producers of TNG thought audiences would be too confused by it.
Except it's not a pronunciation thing at all. It's literally spelled Leftenant. They do that so they don't use the French word for the rank. You find a lot of that with the UK. They do stuff just to spite the French, and in Starfleet, it was based on the US Navy structure and customs, so Scotty saying Leftenant here is actually completely incorrect.
@@ImpendingJokerI'm a veteran and, it's spelled the same way, just pronounced the way Sub Lieutenant (as it would be if he were using Royal Navy ranks) Scott did.
Finally, a character from this "Sceptred Isle" uses the correct British pronunciation for Lieutenant. I could always forgive Patrick Stewart not doing it because the character he was playing was French but I always tutted at Lt Reed in Enterprise for doing it.
If any other random character made these wild claims, everyone in the audience would be convinced they were secretly working with the Gorn. But because this was said in a thick Scottish accent, everyone instantly trusts him
Well I think the fact that he had an anti-gorn trap and survived a journey of several light years over, at fastest, a few months without giving birth to several horrifying lizard babies should tip people off to him being trustworthy
@@eskanda3434well, thr latter part is because most of the main cast are of the same rank, so there is no need to speak down upon them or up to them, and even when they speak to pike, who is a laid back captain, they still do so respectfully... For the tone, well, then you definitely have not seen any of the tos trek, or first few seasons of Tng...
I didn't care for the horror in this episode, way too much blood spilled everywhere. But it wouldn't be Star Trek if some episodes weren't way better than others lol.
What's especially cool about this is that they finally got a real Scotsman to play Scotty. James Doohan, as iconic in the role as he was, was Canadian. Simon Pegg is English. But Martin Quinn is actually Scottish, having been born in Paisley. Now they just need to make a new Star Trek series that takes place after Season 3 of Picard, and have David Tennant play a descendant of Scotty. But instead of being an engineer, he's a doctor (as a nod to his role as the Tenth and Fourteenth Doctors in Doctor Who), but still honoring his ancestor's legacy by seeing the human body as a form of organic machinery.
@@maj2813 As I said, he would be a doctor, not an engineer. He would not need as much muscle as his ancestor, especially since he would be using advanced tech to do most of the work for him. And James Doohan wasn't the only one who gained weight since TOS. William Shatner also gained weight, to the point where he allegedly had to use a girdle (although there's no concrete evidence to support this) This was actually referenced in an episode of The Simpsons, where Comic Book Guy dressed as Captain Kirk and wore a corset, which rapidly loosened on him before breaking completely. He cycled through several of the movies (Star Trek I, II, V, and Generations) before ending at Boston Legal.
@@JnEricsonx Well, I do know he was in Harry Potter, where he played Barty Crouch, Jr. in The Goblet of Fire, so there is that, too. But I would absolutely love to see him in Star Trek, that much I know.
I'd be cool with David Tennant playing a character on Star Trek but it might be better for him to play an alien. He should be a half human from that planet in the Sub Rosa episode - without the Sub Rosa plot. I think they were descended from Scottish settlers.
So that's Spock, Uhura, Kirk, and now Scotty. We may now commence bets on whether Bones or Sulu will show up next. (Probably not Chekov; he's still a kid by this point.)
My vote (more like hope) is that next seasons finale will involve some sorta medical pandemic on some planet and enterprise will be sent to help and bones will be there in all his greatness.
I would love to play Dr. Leonard McCoy, in all seriousness. Got experience. A man can dream, anyways. This is the show to do it in. It's raw and balanced.
Remember when Admiral April excused not fighting the Gorn because the colony was not technically a federation member. Well, the Sundiver, while a research ship, was definitely Star Fleet and its crew were definitely Federation citizens.
For some reason I want to see more interaction between Scotty and Ortegas, I think they would be comedy gold! the engineer and the pilot arguing and causing chaos for the poor captain.
Need to check this series out. But I do have a question: how does a Star Fleet officer NOT know what a CME is? That’s akin to a naval officer, or even an enlisted personal, not know what a rogue wave is. I’m going to go on a limb that if you’re sailing, even as a civi, you damn well know what a rogue wave is. I’d have to assume any space faring civilization is going to know what a CME is as general knowledge. Unless it was done as the producers assumed the audience were idiots.
I hear you. I wondered a bit when we first see him. At this point I assume this show's James T Kirk is nerfed on purpose (I could be wrong). If we had a full-tilt-boogie _young_ Captain Kirk, that might bump into the main characters, particularly Pike. Still, you make a very fair point. Pike is the one we heard about and saw immobilized in a wheelchair in TOS, except for the two episodes in TOS before he's injured. The reboot movies -- which I like, particularly the first two -- have Captain Pike yet that's a different timeline _and_ he's not one of the main characters.
I keep wondering why Scotty and Uhura didn't recognize Pike in "The Menagerie"? And if the Gorn were already known to the Federation, why did they build Cestus III in Gorn space?
So I don’t watch Star Trek and I’ve just been watching clips and I thought I recognised the voice of Scotty. Turns out he also voices a character in one of the Ninth Doctor Adventures from the Big Finish’s Doctor Who audio stories. He’s got a very distinct voice!
It was pretty short on the Enterprise-D too until they settled on Geordi in season 2. They had like two or three people in season 1 who were only there for an episode or two.
@@SpiralSine6 Were any of those developed? Yeah one episode appearances. This isn't an issue of they just haven't picked the right actor. They had establish actors for both characters.
@@cb-gz1vl I think it was a creative decision (to not have a Chief Engineer in TNG S1), which they rectified in S2 when they realized how important that role could be. But yeah, it was a strange creative choice given how prominent Engineering is.
That leaves Mark Piper and Sulu, wanna bet they'll find an excuse to meet a certain gentleman physician from Georgia at some point? and when Pike says his name I expect him to say... Mr. Scott, you're hired, and have you seen any of the Cayuga survivors? ;)
She probably couldn't give a fart in the wind about the science side of things but could recite the complete wiring diagram of a phaser as well as the frequency of every power setting from memory. If this were "Enterprise" she'd be a MACO.
@@OptimusWombat Isn't she Chief of Security? Something tells me Chiefs of Security don't need to know as much about the science of space like a Science Officer or Engineer.
Gonna be honest, I don't think ortegas is making it to the end of this two parter. I kinda think they're going to kill off someone every season and slowly replace them with the TOS crew until finally pike has his accident and it ends with the start of the five year mission.
@@milanplayer95 That alternate timeline wasn't created by the lack of the tragedy, it was caused by the letter pike was going to write at the end of season one. While avoiding the accident was part of the result of the letter, there could have been any number of other smaller effects which lead to Erica's surviveal. The key thing for me was the way pike told Erika she was "meant for this" as she was landing the shuttle. Something about that just screamed "she's not making it back from this one"
So are they really going to put all the original characters in this show? Funny how in TOS Spock was the only one who actually served with Pike, now it’s the whole damn crew.
It was never actually said in TOS that only Spock served with Pike it was just mentioned he had. The only explicit change so far is that Kirk has met him more than once. It actually makes more sense that more have served with him as most of the crew when Kirk took command would've been made up of people already assigned to the ship. If they appeared in "Where No Man..." they probably served with Pike even if it was at the end of his captaincy.
Too bad this Scotty is the wrong rank. The Enterprise was the first ship he served as Chief of Engineering and held the rank of Commander. This is the first 5 year mission of Enterprise that gets cut short due to Pike's injury and Kirk takes over, and there is no way that a LtJG would be promoted to Cmdr. in the span of a few years. Time in rank is still a thing in Starfleet as are promotion boards. He'd have to go through LT, LTCMR, then Commander. Even Geordi only went from LTJG to Lt.Cmdr during TNG as he never took the command test like Troi did to get promoted to CMDR. So this just doesn't track. He should be at least a LT here to make the rest of it work.
actually scotty served on 9 ships prior to the NCC_1701. from 2244 to 2259 (SNW) he holds the grade of lt jr grade 2259-2265 he gets promoted to LT and finally to LT commander his rank in TOS 2265 scotty holds the rank of LT commander to 2272 2273 he gets promoted to commander in terms of other officers we see in trek scotts promotion is much more in line with regular officer rank promotions. 29 years to go from ensign to commander.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
It's like they found somebody who is halfway between James Doohan and Simon Pegg. I think this is going to work.
Aye
And he's actually Scottish.
Pike didn’t have even one really cool episode this season.
I freaking love this guy
Can we please get Bones in season 3
Or Sulu.
Notice how Scotty straightened up when he heard Pike was a captain.
Well, it's an appropriate reaction.
As he should have...
As somebody who was in the Navy he damn well better of lol.
In Scottys defense, i cant see any rank insignias anywhere on the tactical uniforms
scotty always had respect for the captain
"That's a lot of Lieutenants."
"There will be a quiz."
That's the kind of humor this sort of serious entertainment needs. Nothing to on the nose, not forced, just some throwaway lines that make you smile.
If you watch and listen carefully you can see the doc smile, and snort. I wonder if that line was an accident
Thank you so much , I don't usually pay too much what's people saying
But if you do it's kind amusing
How about focus on some great smart enlisted crew like petty, chief petty and master chiefs on the ship. They always feature ensign and Lts. I'm glad they featured chief obrien on tng and d's 9.
It’s what Discovery is missing
@@Wayouts123 It's also what that abomination Lower Decks is missing.
One of those moments that really endeared me to this series. It really encapsulates the essence of exactly the kind of engineer Scotty was both in canon and out: capable of pulling extremely clever solutions out of his arse at a moment's notice and completely unafraid to kitbash something together when the situation calls for it. There's a reason he's THE engineer of the Enterprise, the standard by which the likes of Geordi, Trip, Torres, and O'Brien are judged. The captains of the Enterprise may be a pantheon, but amongst their engineers, there is but one god: Montgomery Scott.
i think you mean prime and Kelvin more than canon and non canon. I do love his scene with Pellia as well though
@@jameswg13if you think film and television Scotty is OP, Comics and Novels Scotty is even more OP
His pronunciation of Lieutenant as "Left-tenant" correctly as per Her Majesty's service is the best thing about this scene. He's awesome.
Pretty sure she carked it last year matey. Youse gotta bow down to king sausage fingers these days.
His Majesty's. King Charles uses he/him pronouns.
@@DS9TREK You just opened a can of worms for the pronouns crowd. It'll be "Their Majesty's" before it's all said and done. Just watch.
@@DS9TREK it's 2024 bro
@@DS9TREK Why does royalty speak in third person then? (we / our)
If you notice, he does the similar hand mannerisms that James Doohan did during TOS to hide his missing digit on his right hand.
I kinda wish he hadn’t tried to hide it. I think it would be totally in character for Scotty to have lost a finger, perhaps being careless as a young cadet, and he never regrew it to remind himself not to be careless again, and plus, as a Scotsman, a missing finger would be a grand story to tell strangers at the pub.
The original Black Power Ranger also had a missing finger.
@@daltysmilthhow would he regrow a finger? They couldn't even regrow lost limbs/digits in the 24th century
@@DS9TREKthey made spines from scratch...
@@TroyConvers5000 And kidneys. From a pill, no less.
I haven't watched the episode yet, but damn they just nailed Scotty. Considering how larger than life the original Enterprise crew is, the casting department is really doing insanely great job getting these younger versions. No complaints here.
I wonder if we'll see Bones in season 3.
@RampantFury925 My personal theory is he'll replace Chapel at least for a little bit while she's at the Fellowship.
@@hyrinshratuHe's a Doctor, not a nurse!
I dont think nailed means what you think it means.
@@purefoldnz3070 Depends on where you are in the world,,,,, in the UK this comment is correct,, in this content "nailed it" means they have the younger Scotty character correct in comparison to the origional
Glad they finally gave us a Scotsman to actually play a Scotsman.
james doohan was scottish. what r u talking about?
he was Canadian@@darthvirgin7157
@@darthvirgin7157 He was Canadian.
@@darthvirgin7157He was Canadian whose parents came from Northern Ireland
God forbid they hire an actor to act.
Actually just spoke to this Chap today, really nice guy.
Strong Scottish Accent and Funny Behavior!!
Scotty is back!
Its an exaggerated Scottish accent. As an actual Scot myself it sounds like someone impersonating James Doohan's version of the character. Odd as this actor is ACTUALLY Scottish.
@@markdillon5494 Thas explains why he sounds as Scottish (with exaggerated accent) but still SCOTTY IS BACK PEOPLE. To me Only James Doohan would always be Scotty but still, its nice to see character in new age:) One of my good friends is Scootish, darn each time we have conversation i need a bloody english dictionary:):) But try speaking with Vietnamese or Thailandese oh boy.
@@markdillon5494 Exactly. I think he's been ordered to ham it up a bit for American audiences. But they nonetheless get props for actually hiring a Scottish actor. There are few more excruciating things than hearing a faked Scottish accent.
@@DrOneOneOne I can't bare it when I see a woman being played by a man or vice versa, so I know what you mean.
_"I tried stickin' a hot dog in the warp drive, but it dinna waerk. By the way, would ye have a wee bit o' mustard?"_
I love that this Scotty is using the British pronunciation of "Lieutenant". Which is funny since neither Doohan (a Canadian) nor Pegg (an Englishman) ever did.
I mean, this actor’s actually Scottish!
@@Ostermond yes, and Simon Pegg is English, meaning both are British. And the Canadian Army (in which James Doohan served in WW2) officially uses the British pronunciation. Funny enough, Doohan even held the rank of Lieutenant during the war.
Doohans son voices scotty in star trek online
@@peteramaranth85 that's pretty cool, I didn't know that. Is he any good?
I would cautiously guess that would be because both previous versions of Scotty were scripted and directed to pronounce it that way.
The impression I get is that Simon Pegg was so enamoured with Star Trek and Trek lore that he would have mispronounced the word "Lieutenant" if it meant he got to play Lt Montgomery "Scotty" Scott in anything other than a fan-film.
Finally we get an authentic Scottish accent.
Martin Quinn who plays Scotty is Scottish,,, and as much as I love James Doohan I think the character works a lot better with the correct accent, as does any character,,,
@@JamesT6043 yeah James Doohan's scottish was basically what he learnt from his squad mate when he was serving in WW2. It's not the best but it worked but after seeing 'Still game', I am loving what t hey did with Scotty here
Dr. Beckett from Stargate Atlantis would be proud to toast this bloke
Scottish guy here😅 finally got scotty with an actual accent honestly caught me off guard but very much welcomed 😊
You are full of shit. Stop pandering to the woke tards.@@JamesT6043
the greatest engineer of all time
I have been reading The Q Gambit and he even manages to out engineer Chief O'Brien.
@@Pintheshadows Which is ironic, because in Lower Decks, Chief O'Brien is regarded as the most important person in Starfleet history.
But the thing that everyone needs to remember is that the general rule of thumb with Star Trek is that only the movies and television shows are considered canon. Thus, non-televised media, ranging from books, comics, games (especially video games), etc., are not canon, unless stated otherwise.
And even then, that can be overwritten by the movies or TV shows (like how the Star Trek Countdown comic that served as a prequel/tie-in to the 2009 film was retconned with Season 1 of Picard, changing the Hobus star going supernova and destroying Romulus to the Romulan's own sun going supernova).
@@astrofan1993 Oh. I know it isn't canon, it just made me chuckle.
When he showed up, I legitimately shouted "FUCKING SCOTTY?" and woke up my entire house
But did you shout it in a Scottish accent?
What i love about Ansons Captain Pike is he's alot like Jeffrey Hunters Pike. And it's great to see the miracle worker in SNW. Montgomery Scott.
I cried when he said he was Scotty. I was so happy to see this character. Edit: insert words _"to see"._
The Scottish accent wasn't enough of a giveaway?
@@NetMoverSitan Also being an engineering genius...
@@perturabo420That requires more talking, the accent is a more immediate giveaway.
You cried because a fictional character appeared in a tv show? We are truly doomed as a culture.
I love M'Benga's snort of amusement following Erica's "Quiz" comment. 1:33.
I am so glad they are slowly introducing everyone into the storyline.. uhura, scotty, spock.. and hopefully sulu soon.
I'm not.
@@xetaprime I'm sure you have your reasons as much I have mine:) Have a nice one .. Live long and prosper:)
Sulu is star of the show. Other guys just along for the ride.
I'am not.
I'am quit tired of this.
Ever Shown does that Today,everyone has to meet everyone or have some connection.
Why must the whole crew of the Orginal Crew appear in SNW?
It is a show about the Crew before the original Series.
@@Leondegrance2 BING BONG
When we first met Geordi La Forge he was a Lieutenant Junior Grade. It'll be nice to watch his pips grow as well.
When I watch TOS, one of the things I notice is that, for all of Scotty's eccentricities, when it comes to getting the job done nobody is more professional than him, not even Mr Spock. Young Scotty seems a bit ... distractible, but he's still young.
I look forward to this Scotty working with Pelia. They'll bump heads for sure, because Scotty is still a bit of a wild card (albeit a brilliant one), while Pelia sees the big picture in ways that nobody else does. This Scotty has the makings of being the finest engineer the Enterprise has ever seen, but he's not there yet; he doesn't quite have the discipline. But he can learn that under Pelia.
She was his instructor at the academy. He was one of her best students
@@joshuaplotkin8826One of her most brilliant students, with some of the worst grades. That tells me he had trouble sticking to assignments, probably.
Just wait until you see how much he changes once he falls madly in love.
With the Enterprise, of course.
It's that bit of shore leave he's been having 😁
Supposedly when it came to the Kobayashi Maru test, Scotty was an absolute beast, destroying numerous ships deployed against him. However, he was using battle tactics that worked in theory - and therefore the computer acted accordingly when it did the math - but not in practice. For this, Scotty was bounced out of the command track and into the engineering track, which is where he wanted to be in the first place.
I want him to get into an accident where he loses a finger and has to have it grown back, as a nod to Doohan's missing finger that he went to great effort to hide throughout all of TOS.
He had a missing finger ?
@@grumblewoof4721Yeah. He fought in WW2 and lost it during the invasion of Normandy.
@@JF-tt6wy After the landing. He and a partner were on a patrol and a particularly jumpy sentry lit them up with a Bren gun. If I remember right, Doohan took one in the hip, one took off his finger, and a third that got caught by the cigarette case in his breast pocket.
@@JF-tt6wy Do you think it's still there?
@@tanall5959 According to Doohan's autobiography (which I read parts of in a library once) they could have put the finger back on, but he wouldn't be able to move it.
He said it was tempting to give a permanent middle finger salute to Hitler, but removing it was more practical.
I'm almost unreasonably happy that they finally got someone playing a British person to use the correct pronunciation of Lieutenant. I know Stewart wanted to but the producers of TNG thought audiences would be too confused by it.
Except it's not a pronunciation thing at all. It's literally spelled Leftenant. They do that so they don't use the French word for the rank. You find a lot of that with the UK. They do stuff just to spite the French, and in Starfleet, it was based on the US Navy structure and customs, so Scotty saying Leftenant here is actually completely incorrect.
@@thesnesman5235and Picard is fucking French lol
@@cpte3729played by a Yorkshire man. 😂
@@ImpendingJokerI'm a veteran and, it's spelled the same way, just pronounced the way Sub Lieutenant (as it would be if he were using Royal Navy ranks) Scott did.
@@ImpendingJoker Incorrect. Commonwealth spelling is also lieutenant - it is just pronounced differently.
Not a bad Scotty, Can't wait to see what else would happen.
So... Pike has met both Jett Reno and Montgomery Scott.
I wonder if Reno was also one of Pelia's students.
if Reno was an engineering student at the academy, she would have been one of Pellias students
Finally, a character from this "Sceptred Isle" uses the correct British pronunciation for Lieutenant. I could always forgive Patrick Stewart not doing it because the character he was playing was French but I always tutted at Lt Reed in Enterprise for doing it.
Gotta admit, this brought a smile to my lips and a tear to my eye...
If any other random character made these wild claims, everyone in the audience would be convinced they were secretly working with the Gorn.
But because this was said in a thick Scottish accent, everyone instantly trusts him
Well I think the fact that he had an anti-gorn trap and survived a journey of several light years over, at fastest, a few months without giving birth to several horrifying lizard babies should tip people off to him being trustworthy
I don't think "working with the Gorn" is possible, the Gorn don't work with humans they eat them or lay eggs in them.
Love this show… so much range… from silly to heartwarming to horror…
Its garbage no consistent tone at all and characters that don’t speak like actual officers to each other.
@@eskanda3434Yup.
@@eskanda3434well, thr latter part is because most of the main cast are of the same rank, so there is no need to speak down upon them or up to them, and even when they speak to pike, who is a laid back captain, they still do so respectfully...
For the tone, well, then you definitely have not seen any of the tos trek, or first few seasons of Tng...
exactly@@eskanda3434
I didn't care for the horror in this episode, way too much blood spilled everywhere. But it wouldn't be Star Trek if some episodes weren't way better than others lol.
I love how the colony looks like the old 1950s city sets they using in the original show
Pike finds a brilliant engineer who survived the destruction of their ship and wonders why this is familiar.
That little bit of tune before scotty appeared. That was so like alien.
And they modeled the Gorn to look like the Alien's Xenomorphs.
What's especially cool about this is that they finally got a real Scotsman to play Scotty. James Doohan, as iconic in the role as he was, was Canadian. Simon Pegg is English. But Martin Quinn is actually Scottish, having been born in Paisley.
Now they just need to make a new Star Trek series that takes place after Season 3 of Picard, and have David Tennant play a descendant of Scotty. But instead of being an engineer, he's a doctor (as a nod to his role as the Tenth and Fourteenth Doctors in Doctor Who), but still honoring his ancestor's legacy by seeing the human body as a form of organic machinery.
And both Tennant and Peter Capaldi for that matter are too skinny for the well built Montgommery Scott who was at least muscular before he bulked up.
@@maj2813 As I said, he would be a doctor, not an engineer. He would not need as much muscle as his ancestor, especially since he would be using advanced tech to do most of the work for him.
And James Doohan wasn't the only one who gained weight since TOS. William Shatner also gained weight, to the point where he allegedly had to use a girdle (although there's no concrete evidence to support this)
This was actually referenced in an episode of The Simpsons, where Comic Book Guy dressed as Captain Kirk and wore a corset, which rapidly loosened on him before breaking completely. He cycled through several of the movies (Star Trek I, II, V, and Generations) before ending at Boston Legal.
Why not, let David complete Fandom Bingo! Star Wars, Marvel, hell, if he's done a DC role I have no idea, then toss in Star Trek.
@@JnEricsonx Well, I do know he was in Harry Potter, where he played Barty Crouch, Jr. in The Goblet of Fire, so there is that, too. But I would absolutely love to see him in Star Trek, that much I know.
I'd be cool with David Tennant playing a character on Star Trek but it might be better for him to play an alien. He should be a half human from that planet in the Sub Rosa episode - without the Sub Rosa plot. I think they were descended from Scottish settlers.
I love how he uses propper English ranks not lieutenant but leftenant.
Of course, as soon as we heard a genius engineer with a Scottish accent, it's not like we had to be told his name. :-)
Very true. Yet I still liked hearing it.
Wow they actually nailed Scotty
When I saw him I shrieked and started yelling, "Scottie! Scottie! Scottie!" Still kinda want to do that.
I cried! I couldn't help it!
I'm liking this Scotty very much.
Scotty being a lieutenant JG here has the same vibes with the Lower Deckers, nerding out about science and engineering.
"They aren't being careful enough"
"You shouldn't have walked into my Gorn trap"
Yup, its Scotty.
2:20 M’Benga: “Sounds resourceful”.
You have no idea.
1:34 La'an memorized the crew manifest of the U.S.S. Cayuga.
I'm willing to give this actor playing Scotty a chance to prove himself, and now we'll need a good McCoy, Sulu, And Chekov.
P.S. Paul Wesley has proven himself as James Kirk.
Just saying this now: Steven Yeun as young Sulu 🙌
Good choice
I think at this time Sulu is still at the Academy and Chekov is probably still in high school.
sulu is barely 22-23 years old as of snw season 2
chekov is only ... 14/15 years old as of SNW season 2
mccoy is at starfleet medical on earth
So that's Spock, Uhura, Kirk, and now Scotty. We may now commence bets on whether Bones or Sulu will show up next. (Probably not Chekov; he's still a kid by this point.)
My vote (more like hope) is that next seasons finale will involve some sorta medical pandemic on some planet and enterprise will be sent to help and bones will be there in all his greatness.
I would love to play Dr. Leonard McCoy, in all seriousness. Got experience. A man can dream, anyways. This is the show to do it in. It's raw and balanced.
That scanner sounds like..... "That's inside the room man!" "Game over!"
Yup. Same vibe.
So glad the actor has an Edinburgh accent.
*We are THREE away from getting the ENTIRE T-O-S crew! We just need Sulu, McCoy, and Chekov.*
Considering we didn't get Chekov until season two of TOS I'd be surprised if he got more than a mention.
And Rand.
@@gawainethefirst *Who?*
@@Brettbren Yoman Rand,, Kirks aid in TOS,,, she was the one who would hand him the clip board to sign something
@@JamesT6043 *Was that the character that Sisko was superimposed over for "Trials and Tibble-ations"?*
Is it just me or is Martin Quinn playing the most adorable version of Scotty?
He better because the actor is Scottish.
Remember when Admiral April excused not fighting the Gorn because the colony was not technically a federation member. Well, the Sundiver, while a research ship, was definitely Star Fleet and its crew were definitely Federation citizens.
AND they werent on known gorn territory to round it out. But then again it looks like NOBODY knew about the sundiver having gotten attacked.
Finally, a real Scot
For some reason I want to see more interaction between Scotty and Ortegas, I think they would be comedy gold! the engineer and the pilot arguing and causing chaos for the poor captain.
Need to check this series out. But I do have a question: how does a Star Fleet officer NOT know what a CME is? That’s akin to a naval officer, or even an enlisted personal, not know what a rogue wave is.
I’m going to go on a limb that if you’re sailing, even as a civi, you damn well know what a rogue wave is. I’d have to assume any space faring civilization is going to know what a CME is as general knowledge. Unless it was done as the producers assumed the audience were idiots.
😅to be fair, shes security, her job is to shoot things, not science things
They need a reason to explain what a cme is, and they pick the security chief to ask the question
I was really surprised and thrilled to see Scotty make an appearance in this episode. Perfect casting as well, I'd say. 🙂^.^
Ready for S3 and more Scotty. Also: Took me until recently to realize Capt. Batel is also Mrs. McMurray from Letterkenny!
This is the new scotty we are looking for
They also paid homage to the actor James Doohan with his missing finger from D-Day.
Well he is a genuine Scottish.
Thus, not CRAP!
We have almost all of the crew recast and the sets are still being used. They could end SNW and give us a version of TOS if they were brave enough.
Whooped and hollered when he started talking and said his name.
I like this guy! Let’s see how he handles Scotch Whisky.
As long as it's not green
I wish the casting had been this good with Jim Kirk.
I hear you. I wondered a bit when we first see him.
At this point I assume this show's James T Kirk is nerfed on purpose (I could be wrong). If we had a full-tilt-boogie _young_ Captain Kirk, that might bump into the main characters, particularly Pike. Still, you make a very fair point. Pike is the one we heard about and saw immobilized in a wheelchair in TOS, except for the two episodes in TOS before he's injured.
The reboot movies -- which I like, particularly the first two -- have Captain Pike yet that's a different timeline _and_ he's not one of the main characters.
Was he missing a finger? because that would be a great carry over from TOS. Even Scotty missing a finger was never address and rarely shown.
Yes James Doohan did have a missing middle finger due to his time in the Canadian miltary.
It looks like the finger is not there. They do a focus on Scotty’s hand two times in the video.
yes, he's a method actor so he chopped off his finger for the role.
Love this Mr Scott hope he's got gift of the gab like the 1st one.
Netflix should do a season of back stories for each character and how they met, would be awesome!
I don't know if it was intentional but they mention Scotty wasn't on the ship's roster. The Enterprise D crew said the same thing to him in Relics.
I like how the communicator has become a sort of multi-app smart phone.
Captain Pike was in the original Star Trek in 1966 ( Jeffery Hunter ) its called the Menagerie. With Susan Oliver.
As disappointed as I was that we didn’t get bones this season this Scotty is very cute
I don't think we'll see McCoy in this show, Sulu is possible, but Mark Piper was CMO before McCoy, and he's not aboard yet.
@@MarkStevens-fh3wb I mean he doesn’t have to be cmo, atleast not for enterprise, to be seen. Just one episode would fill my need for him.
I keep wondering why Scotty and Uhura didn't recognize Pike in "The Menagerie"? And if the Gorn were already known to the Federation, why did they build Cestus III in Gorn space?
not sure about Uhura ad Scotty but Cestus 3 was suppose to be an accident due to the lack of how big gorn space was! Bones talks about it!
Ericas quiz remark is so funny, and Scotty so resourceful.
Oh how I loved Scotty! Old or young!
He really does sound halfway between James Doohan and Simon Pegg.
So I don’t watch Star Trek and I’ve just been watching clips and I thought I recognised the voice of Scotty. Turns out he also voices a character in one of the Ninth Doctor Adventures from the Big Finish’s Doctor Who audio stories. He’s got a very distinct voice!
How quaint. I want more of him as Scotty.
So basically the tenure for chief engineer on the enterprise is pretty darn short.
It was pretty short on the Enterprise-D too until they settled on Geordi in season 2. They had like two or three people in season 1 who were only there for an episode or two.
@@SpiralSine6 Were any of those developed? Yeah one episode appearances. This isn't an issue of they just haven't picked the right actor. They had establish actors for both characters.
@@cb-gz1vl I think it was a creative decision (to not have a Chief Engineer in TNG S1), which they rectified in S2 when they realized how important that role could be. But yeah, it was a strange creative choice given how prominent Engineering is.
Until Scotty became Chief Engineer and basically held the position for the next almost-30 years (including the -A).
That leaves Mark Piper and Sulu, wanna bet they'll find an excuse to meet a certain gentleman physician from Georgia at some point? and when Pike says his name I expect him to say... Mr. Scott, you're hired, and have you seen any of the Cayuga survivors? ;)
What i wanna know is why laan not using f for Lieutenant being british 😂
So when are they going to give us a teaser for Chekhov, Sulu, and Bones?
So we will see Bones in the next season delivering Gorn octuplets?
Pike: "Mister Scott"
I'm going to Scotland in 3 months. It's obvious now that I am going to have to study up on "The Scottish Language" ;)
The language is English. You'll be fine 😄
@@Steve-gc5nt There is a Scottish language, Scot's Gaelic, which is an offshoot of Irish.
@@jedsithorand hardly anyone in Scotland can speak it
Differently a young scotty
How the hell does a Starfleet officer not know what a CME is??
She probably couldn't give a fart in the wind about the science side of things but could recite the complete wiring diagram of a phaser as well as the frequency of every power setting from memory. If this were "Enterprise" she'd be a MACO.
I was wondering the same thing. But I guess they needed the exposition for the audience.
@@OptimusWombat Isn't she Chief of Security? Something tells me Chiefs of Security don't need to know as much about the science of space like a Science Officer or Engineer.
@@OtakuMan26 I work in finance, and even _I_ know what CME is.
@@OptimusWombat Ahh you work in finance do you.That explain why you know what a CME is. Crappy Money Expert. LOL
Gonna be honest, I don't think ortegas is making it to the end of this two parter.
I kinda think they're going to kill off someone every season and slowly replace them with the TOS crew until finally pike has his accident and it ends with the start of the five year mission.
She was alive in the season 1 finale so we know she should live until pike's tragedy at least no?
@@milanplayer95 That alternate timeline wasn't created by the lack of the tragedy, it was caused by the letter pike was going to write at the end of season one. While avoiding the accident was part of the result of the letter, there could have been any number of other smaller effects which lead to Erica's surviveal.
The key thing for me was the way pike told Erika she was "meant for this" as she was landing the shuttle. Something about that just screamed "she's not making it back from this one"
Aye, my acting..if I give it any more Capn, I will blow !!!. I canna change the laws of fizzicks.
Man, everybody except Kirk has been expertly cast. He's a great scotty.
I like Paul Wesley as Kirk, other people do as well. He's not trying to do a William Shatner impression which is probably for the best.
We need bones McCoy with his words for Spock.. Ya Green Blooded Goblin.
Wait, I thought Subspace Rhapsody was the final episode of the season?
It's what most websites were saying.
nah, Rhapsody was episode 9, this one is episode 10.
Who else knew from Martin Quinn's first line that he was playing Scotty?
To add to the above: I'm keen on seeing how/when/if they will introduce Sulu, McCoy and Chekhov.
If in season 3, We hear the words "Pish" or "Jobbie", "Sleekit"
I know they have a true Scot aboard the good ship enterprise,
Or ".....'mon then, ya radge Klingon bastart!" lol!
So crazy seeing Martin in a role this big it’s class 😂
The Enterprise you say. That's one lad that I wish I could get my hands on!
Lass
I like Pike more than Kirk.
It just needed to be said.
Scotty pronouncing lieutenant correctly made my day!
So are they really going to put all the original characters in this show? Funny how in TOS Spock was the only one who actually served with Pike, now it’s the whole damn crew.
It was never actually said in TOS that only Spock served with Pike it was just mentioned he had. The only explicit change so far is that Kirk has met him more than once.
It actually makes more sense that more have served with him as most of the crew when Kirk took command would've been made up of people already assigned to the ship. If they appeared in "Where No Man..." they probably served with Pike even if it was at the end of his captaincy.
First decent Star Trek show since TNG. Nice job.
I think James Doohans son would be a excellent choice for scotty
His son did play Scotty on the fan series Star Trek Continues I think.
@@thomasnettles989Yes, Chris Doohan has voiced Scotty on both _Star Trek Continues_ and _Star Trek: Online._
"...from the Stardiver"
David Brin reference?
Sam is just like his brother Jim. Smart as a whip!
Too bad this Scotty is the wrong rank. The Enterprise was the first ship he served as Chief of Engineering and held the rank of Commander. This is the first 5 year mission of Enterprise that gets cut short due to Pike's injury and Kirk takes over, and there is no way that a LtJG would be promoted to Cmdr. in the span of a few years. Time in rank is still a thing in Starfleet as are promotion boards. He'd have to go through LT, LTCMR, then Commander. Even Geordi only went from LTJG to Lt.Cmdr during TNG as he never took the command test like Troi did to get promoted to CMDR. So this just doesn't track. He should be at least a LT here to make the rest of it work.
actually scotty served on 9 ships prior to the NCC_1701.
from 2244 to 2259 (SNW) he holds the grade of lt jr grade
2259-2265 he gets promoted to LT and finally to LT commander his rank in TOS
2265 scotty holds the rank of LT commander to 2272
2273 he gets promoted to commander
in terms of other officers we see in trek scotts promotion is much more in line with regular officer rank promotions. 29 years to go from ensign to commander.
Incorrect. Pike completes both of his five missions in full. Pike's accident happens after Kirk takes over the Enterprise.