This will be the only Kulture Study this week. I know there's a lot of new releases, and I'll definitely get to them but I just wanted to see people's responses and reactions to the new format so I can make tweaks and adjustments. If you have any critique and input, feel free to share! Don't like something or want to see more of something? Let me know! But stuff like Treasure, Chungha, Epik High, Oneus and a whole ton of other releases are definitely on my to-do list. I'll be filming this week and they'll all be released later next week. Thank you all for your enthusiasm for my return (not that I was even gone that long). I feel refreshed and almost happy because I feel no longer bound by "views". I just want to make great quality video experiences for everyone. Also, if your Internet can handle it, the Kulture Study is now available in 4K! So if you want to see an even prettier, change your quality settings with the "gear" icon!
Welcome back PD! Happy to see you in my feed again. I've been looking forward to your return. :) I love the new setup (ditto Sarah H in the comments). One mention about the setup is the lighting. I feel like there are too many shadows on your face. (It makes it a little bit harder to see you especially not in the highest definition). I love the edit notes, added insight! I appreciate the time you take to give us such great content --- Thank you!
@@СашаМилошевић I use that analogy because that is the one that pops up first to mind. In that context, no matter where Handong participated, I will still call it "temporarily train in a cave". So as you can see, it never was my intention to look down on certain country or survival show. My humor has always been about spontaneity and it is also true for my comment. At the same time I cannot control what people think of my comment, and they have a right to feel various things about it. So if somehow it came across that my comment does not sit right with you, I apologize.
Short haired Siyeon did NOT come to play! At this point I’ve lost track of how many biases I had each comeback. Also, insomnias let’s help our girls get their first win.
I would say Odd Eye is a successful attempt at keeping with their signature sound while expanding their target listener, as shown by greater public acceptance and extraordinary record sales. I love that they keep on growing and experimenting.
I feel personally that this trilogy has been energetically so much more successful than most kpop groups’ multi-album projects. All of it has been great!!!
Don PD is back. I wouldn’t mind if you only did Kulture Study videos for the comebacks you’re interested in, that way your workload will be more manageable. And you could check out other comebacks in your own time (no videos), and at the end of the month make a video sharing your opinions on said comebacks, hopefully that way everyone would be satisfied. Either way, glad to see you back, keep up the great work. Also I’m loving your set
The stickers on Gahyeon’s face reminds me of Sunmi’s Noir, which is a song talking about social media. I’m not sure if those those stickers represents emojis🤔️
Scream, Boca, and odd eye are a trilogy. Dystopia: the tree of language. Dystopia: Lose Myself. Road to utopia. Which from the lyrics of each are kind of like a rise up type of anti bullying anti hate.
i swear i had to do a double take when i first saw handong in the mv, just to make sure it was actually her bc i was so happy she’s finally back for an ot7 comeback😭
For someone who loves fantasy, RPG, dystopian and futuristic themes, and rock..Dreamcatcher is a very satisfying group to follow. Love the way they blend in other sounds with rock. Great breakdown, you put a lot of what I felt watching this comeback into good words. Also hope they go back and forth a bit with the rock sound in the future, but even if they dont, they will surely find ways to always keep it interesting and fresh, like they have done until now.
In the comeback showcase they mentioned in the interviews that it was inspired by cyberpunk, so i do think all those references you mentioned were intentional
Welcome back! Something I noticed about the shots of red drink is that they are framed similarly to the shots of the tree of language turning red from the scream and boca mvs. That combined with the shots in this video of the tree being surrounded by technology (cables) makes me think that the tree they had been trying to protect/restore represents the false utopia they find.
The Tree of Language represents the internet which is itself a false utopia. It promises so much in the form massive amounts of information, 24 / 7 entertainment, a way to stay in contact with friends and relatives all over the country (or even planet) and so on, but when you dig a little deeper, especially into social media, you discover that it has a very dark underbelly to it. You'll remember that the Tree of Language went from alive, bright and blossoming to dark and corrupted in the beginning of the Scream video. That shows how the internet, which had so much good potential, went from a 'utopia' to a dark and ugly place full of lies, hate and cyber bullying.
Hi. Please remember that PD prefers they/them pronouns. I know right, of all the react videos I watch, I was waiting for this one the most. PD is true insomnia.
Dreamcatcher is a genre ! Frankly, the best song and album of year 2021. You must check their comeback showcase ! It is the amazing and crazy live performance. Thanks. From N.Y.
Glad to see you back, and I'm glad you want to go back to feeling like making things for you. I care for you and ty for being the best k-content creators out there
I love this new format for the Kulture Study! I love your diving deep into the meaning behind the visuals (and I appreciate the notes on screen whenever you want to add something, makes it even more accurate cause you actually put effort into analysing the whole MV and not simply reacting)! Looking forward for more! Please take care though!
PD is back!!! Thank you for the video, I actually learned some new things that I definitely wouldn't have known. That detail about the red drink was particularly interesting. A note about the traditional Asian element in this video: if you listen to the album intro, it starts with a drum(?) and flute sound that you really only hear in traditional Asian music! I initially wondered why the producers put that in there -- not that it doesn't go with the intro, I just thought it interesting considering the modern vibe they had for the rest of the album. Considering what you said about cyberpunk historically leaning into Asian elements, now I'm wondering whether that was intentional lol.
Honestly, I'm waitin' for it from you since they cameback. I love the whole album too and I'm glad their ODD EYE MV reached over 15M views. But,in Myanmar,our country, I and all the people who wanna genuine democracy are suffering from unacceptable military coup. Could you all please help and trend in twitter with #save_myanmar hashtag.
so glad to see you back pd this song is so damn good dreamcatcher really get better and better with every comeback i hope they can get their first win this time also love this thumbnail style
Scream- hear no evil Boca- speak no evil Odd eye- see no evil Odd eye is the last song of this dystopia trilogy. So the next comeback is going to be a new thing
Welcome back PD! Just do what you feel like doing. Don’t feel pressured to bite more than you can chew. Mental and physical health are important. And of course - DREAMCATCHER 1ST WIN COME ON!
I say it every new comeback, but their art director deserves a raise. Their a-side videos are hypnotic, the combination of timeless archetypes with evocative imagery and subtext, the results are sublime. The b-sides are a good too, but they really step it up with videos like this.
I for sure agree with your ranking of the three songs. I like the melody-driven chorus/guitar riff in this one, but the Scream chorus really hit me harder because of the more electronic elements & how the song is structured overall. I'm a metalhead, so because it hits harder in that way, I consider Scream the most "metal" of the trilogy. Hope they continue this experimenting in future, but never lose the metal elements that drew me to them in the first place!
Yayy glad to see u back pd love the editing and ur reaction to odd eye!! This continues on from scream and boca which respectively are 'hear no evil' and 'speak no evil'. This installment in the dystopia series has the message of 'see no evil'! Loved the song and the concept their whole album is amaaazing
Ayyy welcome back PD, been waiting for your reaction :) Great commentary as always. I definitely agree about the mixing of Scream and Boca elements, I know there were some purposeful throwbacks to both in the choreo too. 2020 was for sure a good year for Dreamcatcher with their increase in sales and they've already sold over 64k in this first week of the comeback! :3 So proud of them and their growth, SK still doing them dirty but that's why we keep on fighting for them. Anyway hope you're doing okay PD and taking care of yourself, also our set looks DOPE.
i saw a lot of ppl commenting the same meaning for the dystopia seried down here so i have to add a few details into it: firstly, yes, it also referes to "hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil" but theres more than that. the triology is based on haters and hate comments in the internet, the "new" medium for haters to take others down anonymously without the fear to get personal, direct backlash. its telling and teaching us how powerful this medium is and how fastly it can take a bad turn. scream: scream was the first title track of this "triology". its about hear no evil, but also about the inner feeling to scream all the pain, you as a bully victim received, away. but you cant. you cant, are too numb, too weak, to sad. scream is about the pain you feel and the thoughts which constantly loop in your head about how it happened, why you and how you can get outta there. mv references which are good examples for what ive explained: "one day suddenly the light did not come people forgot how to say good things", the destroyed nature, statues - maybe their utopia?, the fire combined with codes (cyberpunk aesthetic influence), black gowns as there are at a funeral - again maybe of utopias "funeral"?, how the mask entered their utopia and they fled etc boca: boca tells about say no evil, tells about how bad words can hurt. even when they stay unsaid, only written in a small comment somewhere in the internet. they hurt. in the bridge it goes "too many angels dying now" - a direct reference to kidols and also to normal humans like you and me who where murdered by the hate they got, the messages and the hate. how they decided to end their lives because they couldnt take it any longer. but it also referes to the point where you finally have enough hope, have enough strengh to stand up and get the will to fight against it. the moment where you want to actually react. mv references which underline the ideas and theories i explained: the girls seem very confident, talking directly at the mask/haters, asking them were the love is, they shall not open their mouths anymore (also complimented by siyeons solo scene with all the statues taped), dami saying that they shall stop playing hide and seek et cetera, the nature inspired place where the flowers and trees are blooming again, also the circle in which yoohyeon is sitting which is - in boca - made out of water but also a few hints to a bad ending, that they just hoped for a good end, an utopia, were dropped: after the arrow which was shot by yoohyeons not-utopia-self hit her, the watery circle around her utopia-self almost exploded and does look very familiar to the red burned circle jiu is standing in in odd eye while flower pedals were leaving her body and also how gahyeon started to cry this glittery gold liquid, also got it into her hands - maybe it refers to tree resin, the "blood" of the tree in their utopia? odd eye: odd eye is the last one out of this row and besides its meaning of "see no evil" it also went to a point (you can clearly see it in the end) where you realise: you cant change it. although we got a lot of cyberpunk references and scenes, it talkes about the brutal reality and that it wont end regardless how many times ppl tell haters to stop, how many good ppl are here; there will always be mad ones, ppl who wanna see someone to break on it (good example is yoohyeon taking the "red pill", the siyeon dropping the thingy where you have control over the tvs, gahyeon holding her head/shaking it after she touched the display of her computer and how it tried to soak her in or get her). odd eye shows us the side of the haters, how they hide behind their mask, how they keep going. it takes a bad ending, saying that we couldnt find the upotia weve dreamed of, a peaceful environment (in the mvs it was showed as natural habitat, trees, pretty light colors, the princess gowns etc - i mean. the tree was captured in this big manmade hall out of steel and stuff and jiu in her gown with the flowers was literally burning.) and that the digital "world", the technologic reality will stay and will still be used to harm too. i know that there are probably way more and extremely detailed explanations and im sorry if i made any grammar mistakes bc ye girl is not a native english speaker but i tried to take down one of the biggest "side" meanings and ideas for the triology beside the "hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil" to make sure that theres, besides the fact that alone would still be an amazing concept, more to see and interpret than that :) have a good day / evening / night yall, stay safe, see ya around ♡
I wonder what was the intent behind there being way more flashing lights in this MV compared to Scream and Boca, mostly during the chorus/dance portions. I had to rewind the MV a couple times to figure out what was happening behind the stuttering flashes. :(
@kim namjoon made me straight again thank you so much for the info, they are really charismatic during stage performances, plus their b-sides are lit and I’d love to join the fandom
The fact that Handong is so much more confident and powerful with both her vocals, her dance attitude, and just overall, makes me SO happy. SHE GOT PART IN THE CHORUS AND BRIDGE. LIKE REALLY POWERFUL PARTS. I AM SO PROUD OF DONGDONGIE
I think most people will be fine with you not making a reaction video for every single new release and producing high quality ones for the songs that you enjoy. Though PD maybe you could make a short video at the end of each month briefly going through some of the comebacks that didn't have a dedicated video and just sharing some quick thoughts on them. Excited to see you back and not feeling forced to produce content for us.
Gosh, the stages/ performances for this comeback is out of this world. Everyone catches my eye and everyone is screaming confidence. EVERYONE OWNED THIS ERA.
This is probably the best Kulture Study I've ever seen. Your comments were pertinent, your reactions felt natural, and the editing made the video even more pleasant to watch. I'm really happy to see you back, happier, and healthier than before. Also, don't worry too much about not uploading daily. I personally prefer few high quality videos like this, than a bunch of videos you didn't like to make and therefore your viewers will not like to watch.
The amount of times you said Cyberpunk in this video...I think Dreamcatcher is going to cyperpunk aesthetic. Lol it's all in good fun. Glad to see you back PD. Missed you and your reviews :)
Honestly I watch different reactions to a lot of videos but this channel is the only one I love and have to watch!! Love how he watches in full then breaks down afterwards!! Class act and keep up the amazing work
Long time sub first time commenting considering the last video thanks for even doing this.As far as other content do as you wish we'll be here.Also if no one has told you this today simply I love you again thank you.
15:30 I didn't notice that! Do notice a lot of flash between black and red outfit, that's really cool! And actually they're not putting away rock elements but like adjusting the portion, and there will always be a few b-sides inherit from their real heavy, rock sounds since their debut. So more and more color on the title track (and b-sides as well), but always keeping some heavy rock sound on the b-side (at least), I can't be more satisfied!
This will be the only Kulture Study this week. I know there's a lot of new releases, and I'll definitely get to them but I just wanted to see people's responses and reactions to the new format so I can make tweaks and adjustments. If you have any critique and input, feel free to share! Don't like something or want to see more of something? Let me know! But stuff like Treasure, Chungha, Epik High, Oneus and a whole ton of other releases are definitely on my to-do list. I'll be filming this week and they'll all be released later next week.
Thank you all for your enthusiasm for my return (not that I was even gone that long). I feel refreshed and almost happy because I feel no longer bound by "views". I just want to make great quality video experiences for everyone. Also, if your Internet can handle it, the Kulture Study is now available in 4K! So if you want to see an even prettier, change your quality settings with the "gear" icon!
Loving the new setup. Thanks for all your hard work PD!!
Victon
no need to rush! we're glad you're back and I can't wait to see the other type of content you'll be making!!
Welcome back PD! Happy to see you in my feed again. I've been looking forward to your return. :)
I love the new setup (ditto Sarah H in the comments).
One mention about the setup is the lighting. I feel like there are too many shadows on your face. (It makes it a little bit harder to see you especially not in the highest definition). I love the edit notes, added insight! I appreciate the time you take to give us such great content --- Thank you!
Good to have you back PD! Please consider interviewing ollounder and leez on the channel in the near future.
Scream:hear no evil. Boca : speak no evil. Odd eye : see no evil.
Goosebumps
The holy trinity
smell no evil next?
@@steftsoul6079 pls😭
I've heard there's a fourth monkey, that represents "do no evil"
Handong really said. "Remember me?" in this comeback.
With self love
I am so glad she got a good amount of lines! A perfect return
Jade Shepherd yes! I think lines were so fair. Plus let’s not forget she looked gorgeous
SIS CAME TO SLAY PERIOD
Handong got mad lines in this song~ So grateful~~
THE MOMENT we all have been waiting
Yep
Yep
Waiting for so long
Yep
Definitely, glad he's feeling okay to be back
I think scream was implying the ear element so you have like a hear no evil, speak no evil and see no evil theme going on in the the dystopia triology
wait that makes a lot of sense lol
Also the MV concepts for the 3 MVs is from different eras
Scream = past (Medieval)
BOCA = present (Modern)
Odd Eye = future (Cyberpunk)
Girl why does it say your comment is from 3 days ago LMAO
HOW IS YOUR COMMENT 3 DAYS OLD
@@pinklemonaze9982 patreon access?
Handong is that one side character who temporarily disappears to train in a cave (the China survival show) then comes back OP (this comeback)
IKR
Luffy after Training
Literary or unliterary u just called china survival show cave like
@@СашаМилошевић I use that analogy because that is the one that pops up first to mind. In that context, no matter where Handong participated, I will still call it "temporarily train in a cave".
So as you can see, it never was my intention to look down on certain country or survival show. My humor has always been about spontaneity and it is also true for my comment.
At the same time I cannot control what people think of my comment, and they have a right to feel various things about it. So if somehow it came across that my comment does not sit right with you, I apologize.
And that one year of training (combined with the power of friendship) will allow her to easily defeat a villain with centuries of experience
Short haired Siyeon did NOT come to play! At this point I’ve lost track of how many biases I had each comeback.
Also, insomnias let’s help our girls get their first win.
Let’s pray for win🙏
How is yo comment a day old
@@D04444 patreon users get early access to the kulture study videos
dystopia series
i: scream (hear no evil)
ii: boca (speak no evil)
iii: odd eye (see no evil) !!!!
Next: sense no evil
I wish they go for the "do no evil"
@@inasible Sameeeeee ❤️
*i don't know why but when PD said "Hi" i instantly smile :)*
Same :D
Siyeon with that orange coat is the .GIF that keeps on giving.
Blonde Siyeon is all sorts of hot
@@opheliaeyiah4313 Agreed. Long or short, Blonde Siyeon RULES. I equate this to Purple-Haired JiU. Absolute BOSS. :)
We all clicked immediately huh 😂
x2
As soon I have seen it. No questions asked lol
He's one of the channels I automatically hit like on too.
fancy seeing you here! lol
Dreamcatcher did it again: saved a complete year with a comeback.
YES!!!
Scream was my go-to song of 2020 alongside Déjà Vu with how both of them were aesthetically pleasing and such beautiful songs.
i knew that pd's comeback is reaction to dreamcatcher.
Handong, Haseul and PD are all back, thanks 2021
TWICE Jeongyeon too!
And Wendy 🥺
HASEUL IS BACK?
@@ilmzac yup
oh the cyberpunk aesthetic was clearly intentional. one set of teaser pics for the album was actually named "cyberpunk"
JiU Silverhand: “Wake the fuck up, Insomnia. We have an industry to burn”
I would say Odd Eye is a successful attempt at keeping with their signature sound while expanding their target listener, as shown by greater public acceptance and extraordinary record sales.
I love that they keep on growing and experimenting.
dreamcatcher definitely is the genre itself because they always giving us something new but still sound "dreamcatcher", if you know what i mean.
yes. I agree
Can we talk about miss Kim bora like IM LIVING FOR THAT KICK
also dc must be so happy to have handong back
Yes! And YES!!! :)
I feel personally that this trilogy has been energetically so much more successful than most kpop groups’ multi-album projects. All of it has been great!!!
Don PD is back. I wouldn’t mind if you only did Kulture Study videos for the comebacks you’re interested in, that way your workload will be more manageable. And you could check out other comebacks in your own time (no videos), and at the end of the month make a video sharing your opinions on said comebacks, hopefully that way everyone would be satisfied.
Either way, glad to see you back, keep up the great work. Also I’m loving your set
How does it say your comment was made say 3 days ago?????
@@reinerspersona right?!
Nice Polaris profile picture good album :)
@@reinerspersona Patreon has early access to vids :)
@@shime1956 oh ok. Thanks :)
The stickers on Gahyeon’s face reminds me of Sunmi’s Noir, which is a song talking about social media. I’m not sure if those those stickers represents emojis🤔️
actually, yes! gahyeon mentioned it in the making video
Oh. Cool. I thought it was inspired by Hyuna. That's okay though. All three are tops! :)
Scream, Boca, and odd eye are a trilogy. Dystopia: the tree of language. Dystopia: Lose Myself. Road to utopia. Which from the lyrics of each are kind of like a rise up type of anti bullying anti hate.
i swear i had to do a double take when i first saw handong in the mv, just to make sure it was actually her bc i was so happy she’s finally back for an ot7 comeback😭
There talking about social media , television don’t believe everything you see , don’t believe the sweet words
For someone who loves fantasy, RPG, dystopian and futuristic themes, and rock..Dreamcatcher is a very satisfying group to follow. Love the way they blend in other sounds with rock. Great breakdown, you put a lot of what I felt watching this comeback into good words. Also hope they go back and forth a bit with the rock sound in the future, but even if they dont, they will surely find ways to always keep it interesting and fresh, like they have done until now.
In the comeback showcase they mentioned in the interviews that it was inspired by cyberpunk, so i do think all those references you mentioned were intentional
when i heard pd only recorded 1 vid for this year i had a feeling it was DC well played pd well played
Just a thought: the ending shot (and thumbnail) of blindfolded Jiu really emotes lady justice for me.
it looks like they were going for that
Welcome back! Something I noticed about the shots of red drink is that they are framed similarly to the shots of the tree of language turning red from the scream and boca mvs. That combined with the shots in this video of the tree being surrounded by technology (cables) makes me think that the tree they had been trying to protect/restore represents the false utopia they find.
The Tree of Language represents the internet which is itself a false utopia. It promises so much in the form massive amounts of information, 24 / 7 entertainment, a way to stay in contact with friends and relatives all over the country (or even planet) and so on, but when you dig a little deeper, especially into social media, you discover that it has a very dark underbelly to it.
You'll remember that the Tree of Language went from alive, bright and blossoming to dark and corrupted in the beginning of the Scream video. That shows how the internet, which had so much good potential, went from a 'utopia' to a dark and ugly place full of lies, hate and cyber bullying.
Matrix
scream - hear no evil
boca - speak no evil
odd eye - see no evil
PD's COMEBACK. THIS IS NOT A DRILL
Gahyeon's smiley face sticker I feel like is a nod to their company, Happyface
Them: Hi *pauses*
Me: Screams of joy🥳🥳
I knew this would be one of his first videos when he came back. A true Insomnia😭
Hi. Please remember that PD prefers they/them pronouns. I know right, of all the react videos I watch, I was waiting for this one the most. PD is true insomnia.
Dreamcatcher is a genre ! Frankly, the best song and album of year 2021. You must check their comeback showcase ! It is the amazing and crazy live performance. Thanks. From N.Y.
Couldn't wait for your reaction and review to this!!!
Glad to have you back PD. Finally, I have the chance to be one of the early commenters. 😁
Glad to see you back, and I'm glad you want to go back to feeling like making things for you. I care for you and ty for being the best k-content creators out there
I love this new format for the Kulture Study! I love your diving deep into the meaning behind the visuals (and I appreciate the notes on screen whenever you want to add something, makes it even more accurate cause you actually put effort into analysing the whole MV and not simply reacting)! Looking forward for more! Please take care though!
PD is back!!! Thank you for the video, I actually learned some new things that I definitely wouldn't have known. That detail about the red drink was particularly interesting.
A note about the traditional Asian element in this video: if you listen to the album intro, it starts with a drum(?) and flute sound that you really only hear in traditional Asian music! I initially wondered why the producers put that in there -- not that it doesn't go with the intro, I just thought it interesting considering the modern vibe they had for the rest of the album. Considering what you said about cyberpunk historically leaning into Asian elements, now I'm wondering whether that was intentional lol.
they wouldnt accidentally record something of course lol so yeah its intentional
@@jadeshepherd8627 I meant whether the traditional Asian element was intentional
3:52 yes, Handong is back.💖🥰
LISTENING PARTY WHEN! Another amazing album from them
Anyone here in touch with koreans pls remember them the live voting is in their hands now and to stream from Korean platforms such as Bugs and Genie
Honestly, I'm waitin' for it from you since they cameback. I love the whole album too and I'm glad their ODD EYE MV reached over 15M views. But,in Myanmar,our country, I and all the people who wanna genuine democracy are suffering from unacceptable military coup. Could you all please help and trend in twitter with #save_myanmar hashtag.
Please stay safe. I'll try to use the hashtag and will pray for you
@@chrisr5996
Thank you guys...
@@o.ot.t_5076 stay safe. I hope things get better soon for you and everyone in your lovely country
so glad to see you back pd this song is so damn good dreamcatcher really get better and better with every comeback i hope they can get their first win this time also love this thumbnail style
I’m so glad I’m not the only one who saw the Matrix inspiration!!
Yassss yasss
Not gonna lie I SCREAMED when I saw the notification for this video....
#Scream (hear no evil)
#Boca (speak no evil)
#OddEye (see no evil)
Thanks again for all of your Dreamcatcher reactions 💖
Scream- hear no evil
Boca- speak no evil
Odd eye- see no evil
Odd eye is the last song of this dystopia trilogy.
So the next comeback is going to be a new thing
The Album is called Road to Utopia so that might mean that we are getting a Utopia Series after the Dystopia Series
don’t know what to comment so i’m gonna just write random stuff for the algorithm
thank you
Welcome back PD! Just do what you feel like doing. Don’t feel pressured to bite more than you can chew. Mental and physical health are important. And of course - DREAMCATCHER 1ST WIN COME ON!
Yeeeesss!!!! I’ve been waiting for it!!
Also, we really appreciate that you are back and please take it easy on yourself. We will be here for you!
I say it every new comeback, but their art director deserves a raise. Their a-side videos are hypnotic, the combination of timeless archetypes with evocative imagery and subtext, the results are sublime. The b-sides are a good too, but they really step it up with videos like this.
I for sure agree with your ranking of the three songs. I like the melody-driven chorus/guitar riff in this one, but the Scream chorus really hit me harder because of the more electronic elements & how the song is structured overall. I'm a metalhead, so because it hits harder in that way, I consider Scream the most "metal" of the trilogy. Hope they continue this experimenting in future, but never lose the metal elements that drew me to them in the first place!
So excited PD glad you were able to make your return at your own time we are excited to see what’s coming up from you
I've loved this trilogy so much, I can't wait to see what Dreamcatcher will do next
dreamcatcher came back as a threat and i for one welcome our deukae overlords
i thought my monitor was broken but it was the effects of PD's editing thank god
I just KNEW that the first video you’d comeback with was gonna be Dreamcatcher.
Handong's back and PD's back. What a great start to 2021 indeed.
Yayy glad to see u back pd love the editing and ur reaction to odd eye!! This continues on from scream and boca which respectively are 'hear no evil' and 'speak no evil'. This installment in the dystopia series has the message of 'see no evil'! Loved the song and the concept their whole album is amaaazing
Always looking forward to PD's reactions. Glad to see you back!
PD comeback with the Dreamcatcher comeback. Perfection💜
Ayyy welcome back PD, been waiting for your reaction :) Great commentary as always. I definitely agree about the mixing of Scream and Boca elements, I know there were some purposeful throwbacks to both in the choreo too. 2020 was for sure a good year for Dreamcatcher with their increase in sales and they've already sold over 64k in this first week of the comeback! :3 So proud of them and their growth, SK still doing them dirty but that's why we keep on fighting for them. Anyway hope you're doing okay PD and taking care of yourself, also our set looks DOPE.
The writing on Sua’s face reminds me of The Mummy (the more recent one with Sofia Boutella)
i saw a lot of ppl commenting the same meaning for the dystopia seried down here so i have to add a few details into it:
firstly, yes, it also referes to "hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil" but theres more than that.
the triology is based on haters and hate comments in the internet, the "new" medium for haters to take others down anonymously without the fear to get personal, direct backlash. its telling and teaching us how powerful this medium is and how fastly it can take a bad turn.
scream:
scream was the first title track of this "triology". its about hear no evil, but also about the inner feeling to scream all the pain, you as a bully victim received, away. but you cant. you cant, are too numb, too weak, to sad. scream is about the pain you feel and the thoughts which constantly loop in your head about how it happened, why you and how you can get outta there.
mv references which are good examples for what ive explained: "one day suddenly the light did not come
people forgot how to say good things", the destroyed nature, statues - maybe their utopia?, the fire combined with codes (cyberpunk aesthetic influence), black gowns as there are at a funeral - again maybe of utopias "funeral"?, how the mask entered their utopia and they fled etc
boca:
boca tells about say no evil, tells about how bad words can hurt. even when they stay unsaid, only written in a small comment somewhere in the internet. they hurt. in the bridge it goes "too many angels dying now" - a direct reference to kidols and also to normal humans like you and me who where murdered by the hate they got, the messages and the hate. how they decided to end their lives because they couldnt take it any longer. but it also referes to the point where you finally have enough hope, have enough strengh to stand up and get the will to fight against it. the moment where you want to actually react.
mv references which underline the ideas and theories i explained:
the girls seem very confident, talking directly at the mask/haters, asking them were the love is, they shall not open their mouths anymore (also complimented by siyeons solo scene with all the statues taped), dami saying that they shall stop playing hide and seek et cetera, the nature inspired place where the flowers and trees are blooming again, also the circle in which yoohyeon is sitting which is - in boca - made out of water
but also a few hints to a bad ending, that they just hoped for a good end, an utopia, were dropped:
after the arrow which was shot by yoohyeons not-utopia-self hit her, the watery circle around her utopia-self almost exploded and does look very familiar to the red burned circle jiu is standing in in odd eye while flower pedals were leaving her body
and also how gahyeon started to cry this glittery gold liquid, also got it into her hands - maybe it refers to tree resin, the "blood" of the tree in their utopia?
odd eye:
odd eye is the last one out of this row and besides its meaning of "see no evil" it also went to a point (you can clearly see it in the end) where you realise: you cant change it. although we got a lot of cyberpunk references and scenes, it talkes about the brutal reality and that it wont end regardless how many times ppl tell haters to stop, how many good ppl are here; there will always be mad ones, ppl who wanna see someone to break on it (good example is yoohyeon taking the "red pill", the siyeon dropping the thingy where you have control over the tvs, gahyeon holding her head/shaking it after she touched the display of her computer and how it tried to soak her in or get her). odd eye shows us the side of the haters, how they hide behind their mask, how they keep going. it takes a bad ending, saying that we couldnt find the upotia weve dreamed of, a peaceful environment (in the mvs it was showed as natural habitat, trees, pretty light colors, the princess gowns etc - i mean. the tree was captured in this big manmade hall out of steel and stuff and jiu in her gown with the flowers was literally burning.) and that the digital "world", the technologic reality will stay and will still be used to harm too.
i know that there are probably way more and extremely detailed explanations and im sorry if i made any grammar mistakes bc ye girl is not a native english speaker but i tried to take down one of the biggest "side" meanings and ideas for the triology beside the "hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil" to make sure that theres, besides the fact that alone would still be an amazing concept, more to see and interpret than that :)
have a good day / evening / night yall, stay safe, see ya around ♡
it literally amazes me how observant pd is like how tf didn’t i catch that the chair was a reference to the mask in scream
Finally, someone's telling me what's the red drink is for! And it's make sense too!!! Thank you so much
I wonder what was the intent behind there being way more flashing lights in this MV compared to Scream and Boca, mostly during the chorus/dance portions. I had to rewind the MV a couple times to figure out what was happening behind the stuttering flashes. :(
distorted reality. that's what i've been thinking
Love your aesthetic of the studio! It's so nice and comfortable and that coloring for video...ah, so pleasing)
I love that whenever PD reacts to Dreamcatcher they're SPEECHLESS lol. Honestly same
I’ve noticed Dreamcatcher since Scream era and Odd eye is definitely a sign that I should stan them lol
@kim namjoon made me straight again thank you so much for the info, they are really charismatic during stage performances, plus their b-sides are lit and I’d love to join the fandom
FINALLY 2 MONTH I WAIT THISS🥺LOVE U SO MUCH..TAKE CARE PD
And the industry STILL won’t give them their first win, also glad to see your back!
Wasn’t scream ears? Or am I misremembering 😅
Glad to see you back, (please take care).
This was great!!
The fact that Handong is so much more confident and powerful with both her vocals, her dance attitude, and just overall, makes me SO happy. SHE GOT PART IN THE CHORUS AND BRIDGE. LIKE REALLY POWERFUL PARTS. I AM SO PROUD OF DONGDONGIE
I think most people will be fine with you not making a reaction video for every single new release and producing high quality ones for the songs that you enjoy. Though PD maybe you could make a short video at the end of each month briefly going through some of the comebacks that didn't have a dedicated video and just sharing some quick thoughts on them. Excited to see you back and not feeling forced to produce content for us.
Gosh, the stages/ performances for this comeback is out of this world. Everyone catches my eye and everyone is screaming confidence. EVERYONE OWNED THIS ERA.
You are literally the only youtuber that I give a like on their videos💜
PD choose Odd Eye for his comeback, the only Kulture Study this week. WOW
glad this is what got me out of bed, also waiting for you to listen to this album the beginning of new days is an anime intro fight me
Welcome back PD! Looking forward to new content on your channel and dreamcatcher was a great one to come back to!
Pd you're back finally!!!! I missed you soo much!!!! Hope you're doing well and taking care of yourself❤
This is probably the best Kulture Study I've ever seen. Your comments were pertinent, your reactions felt natural, and the editing made the video even more pleasant to watch.
I'm really happy to see you back, happier, and healthier than before. Also, don't worry too much about not uploading daily. I personally prefer few high quality videos like this, than a bunch of videos you didn't like to make and therefore your viewers will not like to watch.
The amount of times you said Cyberpunk in this video...I think Dreamcatcher is going to cyperpunk aesthetic. Lol it's all in good fun. Glad to see you back PD. Missed you and your reviews :)
I love the cozy vibes
AYYY THEY’RE BACK :D
Now I will paciently wait for the album reaction (if we have one) because Poison Love is your song
Scream was hearing Boca was speaking and Odd Eye was seeing so technically the trilogy was a pattern for the storyline that now has ended
Honestly I watch different reactions to a lot of videos but this channel is the only one I love and have to watch!! Love how he watches in full then breaks down afterwards!! Class act and keep up the amazing work
He's back, now this is pog moment
Pd's comeback with dreamcatcher!
Wow🔥🔥🔥
Long time sub first time commenting considering the last video thanks for even doing this.As far as other content do as you wish we'll be here.Also if no one has told you this today simply I love you again thank you.
omg the combination of the pretty thumbnail with the totally aesthetically pleasing and calming background/ music is so good!
Back with a BANGER I see
15:30 I didn't notice that! Do notice a lot of flash between black and red outfit, that's really cool!
And actually they're not putting away rock elements but like adjusting the portion, and there will always be a few b-sides inherit from their real heavy, rock sounds since their debut.
So more and more color on the title track (and b-sides as well), but always keeping some heavy rock sound on the b-side (at least), I can't be more satisfied!
I was just watching your last video and this appeared BRUH
I've been frckn waiting for your reaction for this PD.
INSOMNIAS PLEASE VOTE ON MUBEAT! WE'RE ON THE LEAD WITH 50K VOTES! DONT TAKE IT FOR GRANTED! VOTING ENDS IN FEB 5 AT 11PM KST!
loved this comeback, from PD and Dreamcatcher