Why is Islam so Sensitive to Criticism? by Dr Zakir Naik
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Dr Zakir Naik answers a Question posed by Muslim Sister on behalf of Non-Muslim Brother.
Why is Islam so Sensitive to Criticism?
Lecture Name: Ask Dr Zakir (Chennai)
Video Code: ADZN_CH_09
PLEASE VISIT OUR OFFICIAL WEBSITES
www.irf.net
zakirnaik
www.plus.google.com/+Drzakirchannel
zakirnaikirf
/ drzakirchannel
Nothing is above criticism...nothing. When you find something that someone says is not allowed to be criticized, then you immediately do so and you keep doing so until there is no longer a reaction from that criticism. Once you've reached that point, then you can sit down and have a truly open discussion.
Smart comment
@@orangesoul4289 what does ur username means??
Stuff that being a part of a movement where you have to believe it unquestionably, especially if the men running the show are only accountable to themselves.
Close minded
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Criticising Islam is our duty.
Criticizing islam is our right. Like we have the right to criticize everything else. No duty. Only muslims have the duty to criticize islam, at least to show inner coherence. But they don't do it.
our duty. How can we tolerate a religion that tells people to kill people that do not believe in that religion.
He didn't even answer the question. She asked about 'criticism', he talked about 'insulting' or 'offending the prophet/Allah. If Muslims think criticism = hate, then we got a problem.
He did answer it as most of the time Allah and his messenger (PBUH) are targeted, and in response many Muslims show aggression and as he said Muslims love Allah and his Prophet (PBUH) more than themselves, that's why they become insensitive towards any kind of bad language that is used.
@@stephanyschneider5144
Sure that's your personal choice to like or dislike anyone.
khalid alvi
Since I really love him, my feelings are hurt. The world should stop criticizing him and his ideology, cause you know, it may hurt someone’s feelings.
@@stephanyschneider5144 That's one personal choice if he or she wants to criticize someone if your choice of liking someone is respected then you should also respect others choice to criticize anyone.
khalid alvi So you agree that religions should be criticized and Islam also?
I don't know why I expected an intelligent answer when I clicked on the video..
+Fisal Aman : It's like those lurid Tabloids: Elivis was a Demon Devil Child From Alien AntiChrist. You know its utter rubbish but you are intrigued : I wonder if there is going to a serious rebuttal but instead you get the Benny Hinn of the Islamic world -slick, glib and tailor made for the 'masses"
+Fisal Aman nailed it .......my thought
+Fisal Aman It was a very logical answer actually. He cult had given many many answers but he chose the wisest one, maby you should analyse why he chose that answer.
Also to a non intelligent question can't be given an intelligent answer. (every muslim has his own perosonality, you cant just go and say why muslims are sensitive to criticism because some may not be sensitive)
+p Simon Noel My response was right on point and if you can't understand why then maybe you should reading more about islam and then start judging.
To all Moslems coming Here and to ZAKIR the JOKER ------
Very good news. See several videos made by JAY Smith to demolish ISLAM / QURAN , and to prove that MO was a false Prophet . JAY smith provided all evidence .
see the following videos.
The PARIS attacks - who and what is responsible ? part 2 Jay smith.
Debunking the history of ISLAM - Jay Smith.
What is radical Islam? Jay smith.
what is ISIS ISIL ? Islam is peace? Education - Jay Smith.
after seeing& reading, come back and write your ideas , here. ZAKIR ZOKER IS welcome.
When I ask questions about, or make criticisms of, Islam on YT, what I get back 99% of the time is hate, insults and threats.
Islam HAS to be constantly criticised, or it will never develop out of hateful, medieval ideology that is.
+Geno Bot Finally someone that makes sense !! thank you !
+Geno Bot It will be criticised until it has oil tho
Don't judge islam by action of people. Read the Quran for yourself. Read and think.
It's not hateful, people who say that don't even read the Qur'an. They just believe the media without thinking.
yous sef Poor brainwashed fool :(
It´s kind of how Nazis reacted in a murderous way when somebody criticised Adolf Hitler. That´s how fascism works and obviously also how Islam works.
+Tony Maccaroni Fascism is a state that is controlled by private interests, mostly in the form of businesses. Kind of what we have in the west now.
Dim Fre4kske You clearly have no clue about what fascism really means. Ask the people from the ex communist countries how it was like when private interests were shut down completely while the interests of the state were imposed with nor regard for people´s opinions, properties or lives.
Tony Maccaroni Well the people I could ask (Moldovans) are not old enough to remember, but I can and have previously asked them about when priv interests returned. Under communism they got some meager help from the government and pensions were about 150$/mo, Now they get nothing, pensions are 25$/mo, the only reason why they have not starved yet is because next to their house is a field where they can grow their own food and half of the year they simply do not have electricity because they can't afford it.
And he still has the title of 'Dr'. What a world we live in if everyone can get a title like that.
What do you disagree with about his response
He has that title because he finished med school
Unbelievable. "Islam allows free speech" he says and then says "as long as there is proof and there is no maligning". So, there is no free speech at all- you are not allowed to criticise whatsoever. And the justification given is that Muslims love God and the prophet more than themselves. I'm interested about this. Was the prophet not just a mere mortal? Why does the prophet have this special veneration?
well, if it is not because of the prophets people wouldn't know religion. and they are the one who suffers a lot when spreading them. this is why the muslims love muhammad (pbuh), christians love jesus christ (pbuh), and the jews love moses (pbuh). and yes, prophets are mortal human beings. they are chosen people by God Almighty Himself so that He can spread his messages to human beings. long story short, what made the prophets so special to their own people is because they are the one who spread God's messages to them and suffers a lot when spreading the messages. i hope i can answer your question
If Muslims do not criticize other religions then others will also not criticize Islam. Muslims criticize other religions by calling them kafirs, criticizing other religion way of worship, so naturally people will also criticize Islam. So solution is Muslims should respect other religion and not criticize others faith, then others will also not criticize Islam. Fault is with Muslims. so I appeal all Muslim brothers and sisters respect others faith they will respect you, then there will be peace in the world.
Read Surat-al Kafiroun first.
No you are wrong, the quran says that a Muslim cannot disrespect any other religion.
Fiyad Khan You do not need Quran to tell you that and that is simply common sense. Just know that there are the existence of other group of humans and this is no longer the medieval perioid, no one now have any intention to do harm or wage war against you.
Fiyad Khan Yet they do it all the time.
If you read more Islam historic, you will know. In the past the other religion can't respect Islam too
Intolerance to criticism clearly shows weakness of Islam.
The classic Muslim responses to criticism are:
- Denial & Lying
- Diversion
- Projection & Blaming others
- Playing the "victim" & calling the critic a "hater"
- 'Ad Hominem' attacks, bullying, bluster, abuse, threats & violence
sounds like christians,who call us terrorist when losing a debate lol
muslim police is banning accounts on youtube funny that bible is the one which teach about rapist when not any single verse in quran talks about rapist,no wonder your hanged in coconut tree god so proud of you.
This is a terrible answer.
Regardless how much you love someone or something. This person should not be above criticism and criticism to this person.
Because critics know EVERYTHING.
Black Out What? You don't have to be omniscient to make a legitimate criticism. Simple logic is enough.
Kiran Maktoum
It was a good answer you just heard what you wanted to hear
and ignored what you didn't
vicachcoup May be you can elaborate instead of just making hot air ? what did i miss ?
Kiran Maktoum
I can't remember.
It would have helped if you replied around the time when I made the comment.
Thanks
He basically dodged the question....
How secure you must be in your own beliefs if the criticism of infidels/atheists/heathens would drive you into a murderous rage. That is the problem with Islam and the vast majority of its followers
Regardless how much you love someone or something. This person should not be above criticism and criticism to this person.
Conrad Reid
He didn't say they were.
He said that the criticism should be based on intellect and logic rather than just plain bitchiness and backbiting.
*****
It depends on what you say and how you say it.
Bitching is calling someone a bloodthirsty war-monger and a paedophile.
Understandable criticism is when you say he had many wars and that he had sex with a 9 year old and that you find that reprehensible.
The first can't be debated since you are just expressing your emotional prejudice/opinion/taboo and the second can be debated.
So really it depends on whether you express views with emotion and prejudice or with logic.
There is nothing wrong with genuine criticism but simple bitchin is not useful.
*****
Yes I understand your viewpoint.
It is one that you have based on our current values.
It is not based on logic but attitude based on current taboos.
You prove yourself to be a follower rather than a thinker.
Hence I can understand you many misguided criticisms about Islam and the quran and the prophet, peace be on him.
What you will find my friend, is that all your criticsms are without any OBJECTIVE rational support.
They are all based on your personal prejudices and emotions.
In other words you have a poor grasp of logic
*****
You can't ask a series of serious questions and expect a decent answer.
These are not minor issues for quick soundbite replies.
*****
I see you do want dumbed down answers. Sorry pal you need to find someone who enjoys your low level of discussion.
I hope you aren't desperate for someone to talk to.
Are you?
In his defence, he's clearly not sensitive over criticism of his suit.
YES, HE CERTAINLY NEEDS A BETTER TAILOR,
He can wear whatever he wants , u r nothing in front of him , to judge him...
Billions of people like him , he is the probably the most intelligent person on earth at this point of time...
@Waut Dooghe Alhamdulillah 💓
@@mohdwarid6101 Dude, world population is around 8 billion people, so more like thousands. And he's just a common televangelist, a crook. This is just a way for him to make money off the gullible. And yeah, there are people way smarter than him, like physicists and mathematicians.
@@mohdwarid6101 did you seriously say this dude is the most intelligent person on earth? Bruh. Even his argument is nonsense. Criticizing≠insulting
How to answer a question by not answering it.
The words "Smart man" and "Zakir Naik" should never be used in the same sentence.
Agreed.
Zakir naik is not a smart man....
"I am a medical doctor" should be a meme
7:01 you just contradicted yourself. the whole point of free speech is to protect the rights of those who have e opinions that are either unpopular, very controversial or both. what that man said was pretty much since criticizing the prophet Muhammad controversial because it might anger people we shouldn't go there.
LITERALLY
This man is saying absolutely nothing.
You understand absolutely nothing.
Fiyad Khan Even zakhir did not undrestand what he said . ha ha ha
Stephen Pichurski he knows more than you will know in your entire life you fool
A1 He knows more lies than Stephen,. what you said is hundred percent true. He has already told lots of lies in this life, and continuing to lie for his next life too
Subramani M
which lies? i did not find any lie in what he said, you keep saying "he's lying, he's lying.." but you can't tell me what is the lie he said, answer this, what lie did you hear coming out from his mouth?
Sensitivity comes from insecurity fear and ignorance, if religion is to be valid then it should elevate us not make us violent. How can you love your God that you have never seen and violently hurt you brother who is here in the flesh with you ? Islam is a weapon not a religion Jesus’s doctrine was based on telling us this
Critisicm is necessary in order to succeed, you learn from it.
I don't get how he can say muslims love Muhammed more than their own children, that's just sick, I doubt any sane Muslim truly thinks that, Mohammed was rather vile.
Personally, I think Muslims could learn from the phrase, 'turn the other cheek'
Would make life a lot easier for everyone.
Daniel Thompson
I think humans should just learn to be a bit moral.
Your idea that people should tolerate gratuitous insults is wrong.
I am all for intellectual critique and criticism just as Naik said too.
The problem is that many think that humiliating minorities is an acceptable way to go.
If you want to foment hatred then of course that is a wonderful strategy.
But if you valye a civilised world that it clearly isn't.
It is also funny how people like you love the freedom to insult and humiliate others more than anything else
You could learn from the phrase, 'turn the other cheek'
vicachcoup frankly my dear, I couldn't give a damn. Islam isn't a minority, and if you read the Quran you will see why it is insulted, its nonsense, but I'm saying, Muslims shouldn't get in such a flap about it.
Life is full of critique, doesn't mean I have to attack and insult back, just, let it go :)
vicachcoup islam is most moral religion in that instance, however tolerating insult no one do this, if i insult your mother and make a rude joke, you will be mad and turn to anger. as mr Naik said we put God ahead of all loved relative, so it is better not to criticize Allah.
but people ask why can islam criticize minority such as jew or gay, but this is ok because Muslim are better and Allah hates those who sin, like the gays, and the disbelievers as well, they will burn for eternal.
vicachcoup "I am all for intellectual critique and criticism" then why in the dozens of comments I have read of yours have you totally failed to engage in such? All you do is find a comment you disagree with and call that person "blind and prejudice"You're making Islam look silly.
+Mohammed Dawood Abyad What a primitive logic. "You steal my cow, it's bad, I steal Your cow , it's good". It seems there is no place for empathy and own thoughts in Your culture. Sad.
May Allah reward you Zakir bhai...I have learn a lot from your lectures from last so many years..
Will Allah reward to liars ? Be honest
Sad...His answer was exceptionally weak.
that's how he confused his followers. Nothing better
not very convincing at all
Its simple.. God and all the Prophets are more important than Ourselves and our Parents.. so its one thing to Insult us or our Parents, its another thing to Insult God and the Prophets.
This was a great response it shows that he cannot discern between a criticism and an insult.
Because it can not digest truth.
if your "merciful" god wants to torture me for an eternity for not loving him more than my children that god is not worthy of my worship. how petty is that?
Jennai Shirow the creator the almighty god , the one who has given you life and goodness in this world, deserves to be worshipped only him and no one else, so yes your ass can roast if you do not accept that!
@@fuzzwuzz6541 dude you can't force someone to love you that's ridiculous just because he created me why should I praise him
It’s like holding someone at gunpoint to love you
I thought 💭 I was going to get an intelligent and comprehensive answer to this question. I guess I was “deceived” 😞
Well what would you expect from religions which are based on deceiving people
@Shayaan Qaiser the question was good. But the answer was not convincing enough
Expecting intelligent answers from Zakir Naik is like expecting Acche Din from Modi
In his first parable of monkeys trying to save it's children he says we must protect God. My dear fellow being, is your God so powerless to be protected by you?
Even the women who asked the question looked amazed by the ridiculousness of the answer and by the look on his face I am not convinced he believes his own words
you dont understand why he said those... its not logical to you but it is for us. We would do anything for god and the prophet. Just dont be surprised if we fought back if you talk shit about our lord and prophet. If youre not a muslim you will not understand.
@@saklotas9718 fuck child rapist mohammad
@@43rajvardhanchavan66 you have no respect at all. If you don't like our religion then don't bark about it. Just remain quiet.
@@43rajvardhanchavan66 your very dump and ignorant open your eyes and Brain. Fun fact you guys are racist to muslims more then Muslim are to you.
If you have no respect for other religion then don’t talk about them stay ignorant. Learn some respect and then talk about other religions.
How can you love anyone more than your own children? I'd sacrifice myself without thought if it would save my children. I was shocked when a muslim co-worker, one I actually thought was an example of a well integrated muslim, said he'd save himself over his children. So I ask all you muslims out there: If you had the choice to save yourself or your children from death. Who would you save?
People who don't like their beliefs being laughed at shouldn't have such funny beliefs
I love my child more then myself, if you criticize my child I'd want to know why, my sensitivities might provoke anger or will provoke me to walk away, at most devolve in to insults and cutting that person out of my life, never tho will I lay my hands on that person, promote legal action, murder, or promote my community to seek retribution because that is just some assholes opinion or perhaps its legitimate, point is that person has the right to criticise what ever is sacred to me, I've had my velues and my culture criticised numerous times but not once have I demanded force, rarely if ever have I even taken it personally I will debate them on it because I believe the values I live under will survive the criticism and if they don't its because I have been convinced they are wrong, make no mistake about it, values of liberty and freedom of speech and expression are cherished just as much by myself as Islam is to any Muslim, I would die in the name of such values as my forefathers generations did, but I will never strike a man for speaking against them, I will fight them with my words but I am not afraid of their criticism, having hurt feelings is no excuse for murder, prosecution, or physical force of any means.
It's okay to be sensitive. It's not okay to kill people over a joke or a comic strip.
@@HTHAMMACK1 agreed
A child and a religion is different. A child is a human being a religion is an idea and ideas should be able to be criticized?
A child is a physical being, religion is an idea/belief. Totally not comparable at all
I think it's hard for non-muslims to understand & relate with why Muslims love Allah SWT & prophet Muhammad pbuh so much!
Yes, enough to kill any who critize the religion. Very peaceful.
But if smone gives up totally,after facing constant multiple shocks,tragedies,lost family,kids,Bank Vp grade job,home,wealth,,etc,,fallen frm top to zero,,practically these lectures work if you remain little normal,but if you are alone n no one is taking care then Practically you need a true strong caring person to take you out from this situation when u r stuck in room for a year,can,t change,can,t manage anything,can,t go in day light,health going worse,always live n die every second,no hope,no goal,no one comes to c u,then Even Doctors Counsellers say that you need a strong caring guardian to recover you....Respected Bro..Will you truly help,, ... Can u take me away,keep me along for few days to follow ur normal routine...😭😭😭😭😭😭😭Waiting 4 ur Positive replPractically..No pakistani muslim is supporting a muslim who is finding 100%helpless to recover from crisis. He will b recovered if someone truly takes ownership,keep him for few time,make him motivate,make up routine,as no one is taking care f him after loosing family,kids,wealth,home,etc..How belief will b stronger if he is becoming mad,mentally sick,then people pass only dialogues ,make fun,pass time,...Where is God for a person who cudn,t afford brain shocks,become mentally severe sick?? Only hear usual typical lectures...Practically,who will help??Is there any single person who cud take away,keep me along to recover from so worse helpless state to a healthy lively mind if an alone has lost confidence,decision power,then why people give artificial lectures rather supporting practically to bring back into normal life..If one will b normal then he can himself follow lectures otherwise need a strong support to recover..For God sake,,for God sake,,Is there anyone???
@MostHonorableVeryNoble
You really should stop lying about how islam forbids killing, you just look like a fool.
Bro we understand, islam is a cult, in all cults the leaders always ask their followers to love them more then their familly, in that way the cult leader can ask for anything and they will get it, Mohamed had 13 wifes, he told his followers that hr deserves the 5th of all war booties, he had sex slaves and instructed people to kill anyone who criticised him, t’s so obvious that Mohamed was nothing but a cult leader!
There is no concept of Heresy or Blasphemy in Hinduism.
Vaibhav C Anil Wrong
Aitzaz Basra prove it.
Read your Veda.
@@umairfarooq2466 what does the Veda say? Kill those who don't believe in Hinduism? Punish and put to death those who speak against Hinduism or Hindu Gods or scriptures? That Hinduism is the only right religion?
@@123Ambarish you are implying the Quran permits these things. You are wrong. Read the Quran and understand it, instead of just listening to hearsay.
One word. Insecurity.
I am a pakistani muslim and i agree
You could say the same about anyone so the point is moot.
@@aurancrash4654 You can't since Islamic states doesn't allow critic but other religions do.
@@chrischow9085 We are talking about individuals not states so yes, it is a moot point but nice strawman.
@@aurancrash4654 it isn't a moot point since it is what is happening. Islam still prosecutes apostates and atheists in the 21st century. It is unsecured since it's invention in the 7th century.
So you reject what you experience, what you can see and what you created with your own hands, to ''love'' someone you never met, something you have no good reason to believe in, other than that your parents told you to?
Wow, every criticism IS justified.
AJOR
Instead of acknowledging your response to criticism is excessive, he justifies your unethical response to criticism with this ridiculous explanation.
Yet this is a man who says Jesus is not a God. A comment that would have gotten him burned at the stake in Europe 500 YEARS ago.
This mentality right here is why so many people look at Islam as being backwards.
How pityful and lame one can be for loving an imaginary dictator and his puppet warrior more than its own children?
*****
Muslims are so confused by their retarded religion. They think fear of God is love of God. They think fear of hell is love of death. They think submission is peace. They think this reality is an illusion and this world is a shithole put there to test their faith. No wonder why they care so little about improving and caring for this world and for others. Sickening. Islam along with its sympathisers and apologists is the biggest threat humanity has ever faced in history. I think the future years will more and more be characterized by a war between Retardation and Decency. May Humanity prevail!
And here we see the idiots in their natural habitat.
Because Allah created us and our children.
yous sef Oh. I see. Care to provide evidences?
+KemAMP care to provide evidences that God doesn't exist.
Francis Bacon has said
Little knowledge of Science makes a man an atheist but in depth study of science makes him a believer in God.
You don't believe, alright. But you're not either supposed to hurt the feelings of others.
the truth always hurts the most, that is why they are so sesitive
Maybe all those people mocking and ridiculing Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un should also stop, since they are offending those men's respective hordes of loyal fans. Or maybe all public figures should be fair game for mockery and ridicule.
Seriously, Naik is such a rotten debater.
Dr Zakir Naik I love your explanations they are very clear and I like that you use proof from the holy book Quraan. May Allah bless you. Ameen
The Quraan is not a holy book
his answer was stupid.
May Allah SWT bless us all
You need to realise, that not everything works like the way you think... Even if someone insults my dearest lovead ones or whatever, I may be angry, but I will not grab an AK47 and shoot up a public institution next door!
What on earth are you talking about?
@@umairfarooq2466 Muslims being sensitive
its so funny about you guyzz where the hell are u living u guyz we are 1.8 billion community and still growing
just search in google brother “which religion is fastest growing “.
if u believe we will tale ak47 because we are sensitive we wont be the larger community
use your brain and read the muslims scriptures not by googling u fools
myself iam a doctor a
@@drshabazali1066 May peace be with you, brother
@@drshabazali1066 Because of fertility rates
Why is Islam so sensitive to criticism ?
Because Mohammad himself knew that he wasn't sent from any god and his ideology was corrupted therefore he didn't tolerate any criticism !
@Tennesee Testostreone
By himself
2:40 epic cinematic cuts in time to his speech
Coming in like a avengers film
@@MRLCSisamazing Dr Zakir man 😂
Omfg
Egoism is not religion. So many bigots are too ignorant to understand that God is the universal super-conscious soul present No religion can claim exclusivity to this universal infinite soul. No scripture can claim exclusivity to this universal entity. Egoistic thinking that my religion is true and your is false is not really religion but just egoism which is just an extension of matter and is not spiritual.
He looks like the 60 year old LeBron James.
You never answered the question. Being sensitive is one thing. Blowing up buildings and killing people because of a joke is extreme fanatacism. Many jokes are made about other religions, be it Christianity or Catholocism, and you don't see them issuing death threats and killing people.
Today no, but they have killed people in the past .
@پاکستان اور فلسطین زندہ باد then wtf muslim do? Practicing christianity? Lmao. Just admit it that your religion promotes violence, stop lying to people and saying it was self defense or taken out of context. Islam is what muslim do, especially ISIS, Al-Qaeda, Taliban, etc, they're a true muslim.
11 “Blessed are you when others revile you and persecute you and utter all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account.
12 Rejoice and be glad, for your reward is great in heaven, for so they persecuted the prophets who were before you.
Matthew 5.11-12
This is a very dangerous position islam put itself in, because it releases the prophet and God from moral agency.
So lets accept for sake of argument that we love Muhammad more than ourselves and close family (although loving a ghost of a long time ago dead man more than close family alone already screams abysmal and destructive mindset to me). Would you not want to correct your loved ones when you see them do wrong?
So let's say I have a son, who is an adult. I see him rape a nine year old girl, and the girls family comes out to demand justice. With an islamic thought approach, I should get angry to the family for criticizing my sons actions, which are clearly immoral?
Ianassa91 Your analogy doesn't hold since your son's actions (rape) are wrong and doesn't mirror prophet Mohammed's actions (legal consensual marriage).
Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him married his best friend's daughter when she was seven years old..but only consummated the marriage when she became of age i.e. had her first period (9 years old).
This happened more than 1400 years ago in a different climate. girls back then mature faster than nowadays, in which the age is typically 13-16 yrs, Non-religious boys and girls of this age group start experimenting and even have sex.
The legal age of 18 to have consensual sex is simply set by the laws of a particular country( U.S.A), some countries set the age of 16 (Canada: note that it used to be 14 before 2008), other countries do not have a set age as long as the female had her first period and the male had his first ejaculation or "wet dream", which is the condition in Islam that must be met in order to consummate the marriage, which is why Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him did not have sexual intercourse with his wife when she was 7 and waited until she had her first period.
In no way it is immoral for a man or a woman, who are of age, to mutually agree to marry and have consensual sexual relations, regardless of any age difference. whether the woman is older than the man or vice versa.
In conclusion, to answer your question, no you shouldn't be angry of the family for criticizing your sons actions since they are clearly immoral (Rape= no consent= forceful abuse).
A rose is a rose is a rose. Are you telling me that Aisha wanted to have sex as a nine year old? You also you a double standard: first you point out that Mohammed's marriage was legal, then say that modern legal ages are just made up. All laws are just made up, morality is universal. And taking someone without his/her consent is immoral, whenever or not done inside the magical boundaries or legal marriage.
However, I didn't specifically say that Mohammed raped. You made that connection. I just said that muslims defend immoral actions (in this case those made by loved ones, i.e. the Prophet), and gave an example. I could have said that my son killed his rival, or that he abused a kitten. It doesn't matter.
Ianassa91 Do you have evidence to the contrary? Never has Aisha described the prophet peace be upon him in a negative light, and always described him as the loving husband who never complained or asked why someone did this or that.
I never used a double standard, I simply pointed out that there are different "legal" ages set by different societies regardless of religion-never have I said they are made up-. In Prophet Mohammed's society, which uses Islam as law, the legal age to have consensual sex under marriage is when the female has her first period or the male has his first wet dream, regardless of their specific age at the time.a female who is 18 and did not have her first period is not allowed to have sex in Islam since she didn't meet the prerequisite.
You never explicitly said that the prophet peace be upon him raped, but you heavily implied that he did do "immoral actions" which muslims defend since he is their "loved one". it is very logical to conclude that in your analogy, your beloved son who did an immoral action is the prophet, and you, the loving father, are the muslims.
I heavily implied in my response that my prophet has never done any immoral action, my above response was in regard to an example action that misinformed people consider immoral when it's not for the provided reasons above.
If you still believe you can find other immoral actions committed by Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him, please do your research and put it forward. I'll do my best to do proper research and provide you with a clear response.
If you are going to insist that Aisha is going to be a unicorn exception within nine year olds and despite her age be mentally mature enough to willingly have intercourse, then there is nothing I can say further.
Again, heavily implying is not saying, you are putting words in my mouth. Let's move on.
Okay I'll accept that you believe that the Aisha case is not immoral. Didn't the prophet also self proclaim to be the messenger of god? At least he accepted to be the prophet, conveniently gaining a moral authority over entire humanity. God is a deity, and deities are self contradictory beings and thus cannot be confirmed to exist. So his claim to this higher status within humanity is based upon a blatant lie at worst, or a hallucination at best (the angel Gabriel spoke to him). This lie gave his immediate grandchildren (was it sayyids they are called?) Claim to be emperors and have special honorific status in society.
The prophet also killed those who opposed him or did he not? In that case too, at the very best he did not stop others for killing in his name. How is that not immoral?
Ianassa91 I never insisted that Aisha is an exception, I'm saying that just as the legal age to have sex in Canada is 16, and was 14 before 2008, more than 1400 years ago in the Islamic society females mature faster, so numerical age doesn't necessarily reflect mental age. You are having a hard time with this since your applying today's standards in regards to 9 year olds to a society that existed more than 1400 years ago. today's 9 year olds typically don't even understand what sex is, while back then they knew mentally and were physically ready. The beauty of Islam is that it's suitable for changing times, that's why a specific age for consummation of marriage was never set, instead a general rule was set, which is a woman having a period or man having a wet dream.
again I never accused you of saying. I only said that you heavily implied. I never put any words in your mouth.
I didn't respond to you so that you accept that I believe Aisha's case is not immoral. You mistake my intent, I'm not here to convince you to approve of my belief. I responded and provided logical evidence that it is a fact that 1400 years ago is different than now. a 9 year old now is not legally, in Islam or otherwise, ready to have sexual relationships. so essentially I provided a counter argument in which you wern't able to counter with sound logic.
The Prophet never raised himself above anyone, if he did please provide evidence from the scripture. in The quran, the prophet was spoken to by Gabriel, yes, and the prophet, who used to be illiterate suddenly had the ability to read, so I would rule out learning by hallucination.
The part where you mention his grandchildren having power and rule d the earth as emperors, with all due respect, showed me that your knowledge on Islam is severely lacking, or you got misinformation from the media and/or websites that also lack the proper knowledge on the topic. So I highly suggest that you seek a moderate scholar on Islam-in a local mosque, or certified website- and actively learn all the compiled history on the life of the prophet Peace be upon him and his virtues.
As for the prophet Killing who oppose him, I would rephrase by saying the prophet fighting back against who are trying to kill him and his followers, starve them, make them forsake their beliefs forcefully, etc.
I highly suggest that you read the actual history that was compiled by the bulk- not the minority- of moderate-not extremist- Islamic scholars. Inform yourself on the matter, then formulate your arguments either for or against. Until then this debate is on hold since it will be one sided and fruitless always because one side doesn't have the facts about the History of the Prophet or Islam in order to formulate relevant and meaningful arguments.
I will part with you with this fact from the Prophet's history: when profit Mohammed peace be upon him was in the beginning of spreading god's message, alot of people insulted him, hurt him, etc. one such person was his Jewish neighbor, who through garbage in front of his house and in his spikes in his path. One day the prophet didn't see any garbage or spikes or any form of harassment for a while, so he inquired about the whereabouts of the Jewish person. He was told that he was ill. The prophet personally went to his house and visited him with good intent, and the person accepted the message.
This man talks like a politician. Doesn't really answer the question. Never a straight answer with these people. I'm dizzy from all this spin going on
You have to be a believer in order to understand the value of spirituality, subhanAllah
What a great explanation 😊
yes, it's not because of theirchild rapist or his associate, demon alla
it's because it is not;
great explanation again by gay naik
So, what the answer is?
It's not love! It's Stockholm syndrome!
Marky Mark Ali
That is not a comment. That is wishful thinking and sour grapes.
vicachcoup LOL Sour grapes about what? Seriously, you're a troll yes?
Fnord Prefect
Bye.
More of that and I gain peace by blocking you.
vicachcoup You engaged me you fool.
vicachcoup Anyhow, noticed again you didn't answer my question.
The question wasn't 'why are muslims so sensitive?' but, 'why is the Islamic world so sensitive to criticism?' which includes historical and textual criticism... I've found this to be the case in mormonism, JWs, and other outside 'christian' groups as well...
It is totally deluded to love the Allah concept and his messenger more than oneself. Such fanaticism leads to the justification of the oppression and atrocities committed by "Muslims" in the name of Allah. Is the Allah concept so weak that it cannot take criticism? Seems not.
*****
That is rubbish.
People in secular countries have the same programming to live and die for country etc
Why else would young men go off to die for unjust causes.
The issue is the same but the programming more sophisticated that is all - flag, country, nationalism etc.
You contradict yourself. You are in fact agreeing with me but say that it is equally true when some goes to war in the name of king and country. Agreed. Secular humanism is superior to the nonsense found in texts such as the Koran as it values individual human well being above brutal dogmatism. This is why there are no Islamic countries in the top 10 most happiest countries on earth. In fact the dominate the least happiest countries on earth.
*****
The suicide rates are highest in the same secular democracies my friend
Cleary suicide rates are not a measure of a country's happiness. But back to the point. The reason why Islam is so sensitive to criticism is that it it re-labels truth about Islam as insult when the only insult to humanity is Islam itself as it is against all who reject it.
*****
_Cleary suicide rates are not a measure of a country's happiness._
Hmmm
Now there is something interesting to reflect on . . .
Don’t act like terrorist if you don’t want people to think you are terrorist
Haha simple 😆
May Allah keep you safe from any problem and have justice for you Dr. Zakir naik
Barakalahufikum Dr. Naik may Almighty Allah reward you Amiin
Any religion (or idea, opinion, ideology...) that cannot stand critisism is at best a weak religion.
At worst, it becomes fascist and oppressive. You know... pretty much like much what's the Islamic world today.
"Why is Islam so Sensitive to Criticism?"
It doesn't matter. No one has a right to not be offended. If you think your beliefs are going to be criticized and you don't want them to be criticized, keep your beliefs to yourself.
Islam is so sensitive to criticism because its very brittle with it inconsistence and contradictions.
Hahaha nice one
﴾Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best.﴿
I love how in this one there's a load of doubletalk to justify the fatwa on Rushdie, and to the right there's another video by the same Muslim talking about how it's forbidden to kill in Islam. Uh huh.
sausageman
Secular democracies have ways of silencing people without fatwas.
Hence Snowden had to go into hiding.
People die in mysterious circumstances.
Dr Kelly supposedly commited sucide.
The actions are the same or arguably more sinister.
The spin on it very different.
Learn to use your brain or do you just think with your prejudice?
vicachcoup Snowden committed a major crime and now he's wanted to face the consequences which are yet to be determined. Comparing that with a death sentence via fatwa for 'insulting' Islam is absurd and dishonest. You're not even addressing my post. Defenders of Islam are a complete joke.
sausageman
Major crime?
I could call it freedom of speech.
The absurdity is in the hypocrisy.
I don't need to address your post.
You are a complete joke.
vicachcoup Tell me where the 'Snowdens' from Muslim countries are. They don't seem to exist. They can't in countries that chop heads off for insulting Islam and accept no challenge to power. ie. when there's no freedom. Learn how to wash your own ass first. Then you can criticize.
sausageman
Interesting choice of words.
It would be a true kindness if someone could translate this down and share it!
Why do muslim women have more mustache than me? I'm a 30 years old man.
FRiKiJDM
Because you will be suffering from impotence in about a decade or two
Because you're not a real man
All right, let's concede that such is the reason why muslims are so sensitive to criticism of Islam. The actual question that I believe we need to address here, is why does this sensivity give Islam the right to stand above and censor all criticism of it? Why shouldn't it be treated as any other idea deserving of being challenged? Freedom of speech is not about avoiding talking ill of others' beliefs, quite the contrary, is about the right to question any and all ideas, and many muslims want to stand above that.
StickFigure
It's about consistency.
France supported Hebdo.
Around the same time they banned the comedian Dieudonne because he spoke out against the government of France.
The simple fact is that Islam is a minority in most non-middle east countries and they are discriminated against with regards to free speech.
There are many examples of this.
such a sensitive question.... but sadly... reply is again crazy one... Alas! I wasted time.
n Dr Zakir Naik bro , so please keep these kinds of policy also when you talked about other religious or any other personality, they are sensitive to them.
Dude u don't get really
Dr. Naik couldn't answer this one appropriately
Maybe their faith is stronger than others, but responses are primal. Not to mention the prefaced question is an assertion. The population of Muslims is pretty massive.
That would be better with subtitles!
Please tell me 10 invention invented in Islam Since Islam form. There is only two condition. One is invention should be before 19th century.( Nowadays people shifting to any where in the world for education, research and jobs.) Second is this invention should be useful for any one. ( Nuclear bomb is not useful for me as a individual I'm not denying fact that this will save my nation but still not useful for me on daily basis.)
Invention should be in any form. Like, Art, Science, Economy, Maths, Astronomy, Weapons etc.
For Example. 1) Zero invented in India without it we can't live a single day. 2) Glasses (spectacles) invented in Northern Italy once in life time every one have to use. If you don't need in this age you have to use when you cross 80. ect.
I did lots of research on this I could found only one invention that is Algebra. That person from Greek not from Arab.
Islam is very rigid, orthodox, not allow you to explore, as per Islam womens are just for production and sexual satisfaction.
Islam is very cruel and corrupt religion in sura 4.34 said that strike on women if they dont listen you. Muhammad said in sura 9.40, Give bribe to people to change others religion.
What a messenger.
Muslim know that they can not win this world on basis of technology. So they entered in europe by begging and now they are demanding for MOSQUE not for education. They just want to spread Islam all over the world. After that they will fight between them in Shia and Sunni Cast like now days are fighting in seria.
Because of Quran entire world is suffering. [ 26/11(India), 9/11(US) ]. Quran is just written in random way. Their is no deep thought. This religion is only for whose IQ is below 90. Most poor population found in Muslims because they following Quran. In India 80% Muslims are below poverty line. 68% criminals are Muslim in India.
When ordinary Muslim become more religious he/she become terriorist and when Hindu becomes more religious he becomes Sanyasi ( He/she left everything and just start chanting of GOD ). Nobody can't defeat Alexander but Indian Yogi defeats him. In India Muslim rural applied so much extra tax on Hindus because of this survival question aries and then lower cast Hindu converted in Islam.Because they were so poor. This Tax called " Jijiya kar".
If you ask each and every Hindu, what is Hinduism ? You will get different answer from everyone. That is called Hinduism.
I'm not saying follow Hinduism. Just read 10 Pages of Bhagavad Gita and if you found something interesting then continue reading. Otherwise leave it. I could read Quran 80% because after that I can't found anything new. If you did this Allah will punish you. If you not done this then also Allah will punish you. Nothing else is talk in Quran. There is not written anything that get even little difficult to understand other hand hinduism is very difficult to understand. And difficult things make your life easy and interesting.
Please google yourself and see what kind of king happen when Muslims are ruling India. Muslim king are killed their own father and family for enjoyment. Also read about The Great Warrior Shivaji Maharaj.
Please Open your EYES. Dont look at them as a sympathetically. When they get power they start again massacre just they did in Myanmar and every day do in some part of the world.
Accept Islam if you want to do official gangbang.
Perhaps, deep down, they know how unsupportable their ideology is when faced with the smallest of criticism.
Best to react with anger, insult, violence and Ad Hom attacks such as Vicachcoup demonstrates throughout this comment stream.
Critique the religion then. This man will answer 99.99% of your questions and misconceptions.
@@umairfarooq2466 Zakir Naik is a fraud, he can easily brainwash the already indoctrinated but actual intelligent freethinkers can see right through his lies.
I've tried looking in a number of Muslim videos hoping to see one response from a Muslim where they actually acknowledge that their religion isn't without fault.
But all you get is the same mass responses of people choosing to ignore, defend and shutdown any dialogue that challenges their beliefs and systems.
Their favourite line is 'Read the Quran' and 'Think'. That's their cop out to not awnser the questions directly, they dance around everything, just like the speaker in this video.
He couldn't give a straight awnser, he confused his audience with analogies and misdirections towards why everyone and everything gets offended there for Islam is offended also.
He knew the question wanted specifics, but proceeded to give a general awnser that left the listeners stupider than before they listened to him. Confirming that Islam isn't open to cristicism, cause it's afraid it may actually expose it's own hypocracies.
Criticism is not “abuse.” When muslims say I can’t have a dog, I feel the same way, because I love my dog more than I love myself.
I don't know why I clicked on this video at all. The cartoon version of this guy is slightly funnier it has to be said.
Then a Muslim can lash out in violence because of his hurt feelings? Come Zakir...you're talking nonsense now.
All ihear is pffffrrllllllll!!!!
no one has a right to take a life.. not even in the name of God - thats God's job to deal with ... not ours
Dr zakir naik best man in the world he tell 100% true I love dr zakir naik
" ISLAM IS THE RELIGION OF 'HAQ'(TRUTH) ".
great answer brother zakir !! may Allah give yu finest rewards!!
Allah guve rewarded to Zakir? You mean extra 72 virgins? Gross!
You know who is real Muslim? It's my muslim friend who is my classmate whose first priority is always for country not his religion. He says I don't know Allah offer me jannah or not but I am sure my country(India) will remember me.
I hope all Indian muslims become like my friend and other muslims I don't care.
A waste of time . To make his answer try to seem reasonable. I knew all along that he would simply refer to extremists as sensitive not about themselves or family of course but about the messenger They kill for the messenger I hate to tell them what the messenger told me when I got the news It's hard to keep calling them names because we shouldn't talk I'll about the dead good night
Naik wont debate ANY christian apologist. He's happy to debate an atheist , or Hindu but never a Christian. His knowledge of the BIBLE is embarrassing . He babbles on....
This guy is deceptive and uses slippery rhetoric, as any muslim apologist does.
Reframe "why are muslims so sensitive" to "why muslims love God so much" ROFL, way to dodge the question.
IF YOU’RE EARS FUNCTION PROPERLY, THEN U WILL REALISE THAT HE FIRST REPLIED TO THE QUESTION AND THEN STATED THIS LINE.
danielul05 Why Christians proclaimed love for Jesus and don't follow his teachings?
5:15 4-letter word "Father Uncle Cousin King" 😂😂😂
lmao
This extreme sensitivity we see in islam comes from extreme narcissistic vulnerability. They belive and have learned that they are the greatest, (grandiosity). When some one bring them back to reality they feel humiliated. What we have is a hole culture/religion og narcissistic vulnerable people. Som obviously are narcissistic disturbed.
+Rune Fardal A part why many muslims react the way they do is because until relatively recently they lived in a mono culture where everyone thought as they did and those who did not were beheaded as heretics. Because of this they have never had to question their own faith and thus are not actually ready for the onslaught of criticism from those that are ready.
U raised question and also answer urself.Interestingly both were wrong.Actuly muslims of wold facing ISLAMOFOBIA.
I've seen people criticize many other religions Islam shouldn't be any different of course someone can criticize a religion that a person follows.
What if one day he realized allah didn't exist
What if one day u realize allah exist what u gonna say that moment ?!
God has to exist for us to exist. If you look around you, you will realize that's everything around us is created by someone so why would the universe and humans be an exception?
Sure there is. Everything surrounding us is evidence. Everything from as tiny as an ant to as big as planet is working perfectly. Everything is in synchronisation to the smallest degree. If you look at an ant colony for example who taught them to behave in such a way? How do animals know what do. Instinct. It had to have been preprogrammed so to speak. The amazing machine that is the human body could not just come into existence randomly.
Exactly. When you think this over you come to the question of who is this someone who created all this?
And these "natural processes" How do they happen in such an amazing way.
If I told you the watch on your wrist just built itself you would scoff at it. Then how do you think all this world just existed from nothing with no creator?
Basically where did everything including the organs come from?
So, What is your explanation for the universe and humans? You did not share it yet.
The bigbang was mentioned in the Qur'an thousand years ago. Who could have mentioned that? That the earth has a shape of an ostrich egg was mentioned in the Qur'an thousand years ago. If you look at an ostrich's egg it isn't perfect a sphere, so isn' the earth. Who could have mentioned that? The Qur'an tells us about biology, how the embryo is made and many things. Who could have mentioned that?
Critisism - it's the biggest problem of muslim people. When they start to critise Islam (not GOD but ISLAM - the religion and it's rules) they will be ready do make big changes. God is not so cruel as islam is today.
Well explained by Zakir Naik.
The critics just have a great deal of hypocrisy.
dudurune
thanks for sharing the cliches that is so commonplace.
When you start thinking for yourself and when you develop a bit of civility, get back to me.
dudurune
you obviously specialise in straw men arguments. Bye
dudurune
Inappropriate use of uncommon words makes you sound desperate to come across as intelligent.
It isn't working my friend.
Good luck to you and your denial.
dudurune
blocked bye
didnt understand a single word
Says a lot about you
I like dr zakir naik he is told true
Great reply
I don't understand how someone can stay so stupid all the time?!
Why don't you ask yourself? That's a perfect question for you.
Bro at 5:09 has either: a) Converted to Christianity / b) Has fallen asleep
Hey Naik.... This is written in Quoran!
Surah 47: Verse 4 "When you encounter those who disbelieve, strike at their necks. Then, when you have routed them, bind them firmly. Then, either release them by grace, or by ransom, until war lays down its burdens. Had Allah willed, He could have defeated them Himself, but He thus tests some of you by means of others. As for those who are killed in the way of Allah, He will not let their deeds go to waste."
I guess I ain't "maligning" your religion or anybody. Just showing the truth about your religion. It's the most pathetic religion there is.
"So when you meet those who disbelieve [in battle], strike [their] necks until, when you have inflicted slaughter upon them, then secure their bonds, and either [confer] favor afterwards or ransom [them] until the war lays down its burdens. That [is the command]. And if Allah had willed, He could have taken vengeance upon them [Himself], but [He ordered armed struggle] to test some of you by means of others. And those who are killed in the cause of Allah - never will He waste their deeds." You missed out important details. "In battle". That changes the whole meaning. Don't misquote or misrepresent the translation of the Quran. Pathetic behaviour.
not showing the whole context of the verse... this is really shameful and disingenuous
@@umairfarooq2466 if you can't take criticism then why do you criticize other religions and their followers
@@GamingZone-ql4fi tf are you on about
When they insult and lie about Islam, it’s called Free speech or criticism But when we speak about you it’s called fundamentalism or extremism.
Great Answer!
You’re clearly not very smart