10 Reasons Why I Left the Roman Catholic Church (REBUTTED)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июл 2024
- In this video Trent rebuts the anti-Catholic arguments of seventh-day Adventist RUclipsr Greg Sereda.
Original Video: • 10 Reasons Why I Left ...
To support this channel: / counseloftrent
“There are not more than 100 people in the world who truly hate the Catholic Church, but there are millions who hate what they perceive to be the Catholic Church.”
-Venerable Fulton J. Sheen
The Venerable Fulton J. Sheen can't count or is living in a world of his own after all its done theres far than 100 people who truely hate the Catholic Church
@@ed7002 of course he can’t count everyone it’s just an example
@@ed7002 he’s saying there are few
@@corpuschristi.fiatmihisecu9841 No he didnt say a few people hate the catholic church. As per your quote he quite clearly said not more than 100. Not a few, he said as per your quote not more than 100. That is giving an upper limit of 100 people in this world who hate the Catholic Church. There's no room for interpretation here he is giving a value of between 1 and 100 people in this world who hate the Catholic Church. No if's, but's or maybe's. A number has been assigned. If you don't have the data to back it up don't go giving out stupid numbers. If you don't believe the numbers don't go quoting them, then trying to back track with it was an example when its pointed out its a stupid number.
@@ed7002 I believe that there aren’t 100 people who truly hate the Catholic Church but many more who hate what they perceive to be the Catholic Church
Funny enough, it's Fred's video that led me to the Catholic Answers channel. That's also how i found Trent Horn.
Awesome!
Amen brother 📖🗝️🗝️🛐💯 Catholic 🛐
Welcome home brother 🙏🏻
Praise God!
Welcome home King.
The part where he says "There's about 33 Hail Mary's in the rosary..." I just had to laugh out loud. Seriously? Makes me wonder if he was ever a properly learned Catholic.
Glad I wasn’t the only one who laughed. If ya only count the Mysteries, there’s a total of 50 Hail Mary prayers times the 3 OG Mysteries to get 150, which is meant to reflect the number of Psalms in the OT. Though technically if one prayers the 3 for Faith, Hope, and Charity, it’s 53 per Mystery and 159 total.
Then add the Luminous Mysteries and ya got 50 x 4 = 200 plus 12 for the initial trio. How wonderful for those who seek Mary’s intercession!
Also, the point about having more prayers to Mary and complaint about not having “repetitious prayer” would knock out not only the Lord’s Prayer, but the Psalms as they were often part of prayerful meditation and would have been repeated numerous times. Plus prayers the priests would have prayed to offer sacrifice, and for holy days and events.
Exactly. 5x10 plus 3 😉🙏
Christ be with you
Any one who learns Catholicism properly is either Catholic or becomes Catholic,
That goes for those who learn scripture properly also
God bless you
Don't tell him it's 53 he will post another video 🤣😂
53 hail mary's :)
Imagine if Trent used adrenaline pumping horror film music when speaking in his videos
@Bot are you Blammit? Same, it felt like I was in a horror film. If the content is sacred, the music should be too. Gregorian chant or something of the like seems more admissable/acceptable.
It has to be interesting somehow. All his arguments are boring and old.
😂 that comment made me smile!
That's like the background chanting and reverb Muslim apologists use. Even when they distort the Bible's meaning.
😁😁😁 no hype, no flashing lights needed....just the truth. Truth doesn't need anything added unto it. 👍
Trent's patience astounds me.
I think there are times when being understated is the right tact.
I believe he has his moments while editing..haha..after all, he is but human!
I personally have been waiting for this rebuttal!
I am here in my kitchen cheering Trent on!
I totally admire his calm, confident, truthful, educated rebuttals!
Check. 9 minutes into the video and my blood begins to boil. 😁
Lord have mercy.
@@anthonybuda3807 I lasted 10 xD then I had to check the comments cause I couldn't believe what this guy is saying.
@YAJUN YUAN You ever listen to protestants pray?
So he left Catholicism to go to Seventh-Day Adventist?? That's like going from a Rolls-Royce to a Yugo.
Ask him go to synagouge where Sabbath day in Saturday..You think he can come back home alive...If he did its a Miracle
Reminds me of that meme... "Slav car best car!".
In all honesty though, leaving the Catholic Church for some 19th century failed weird sect is indeed a very odd move. There's been some delusion here...
More like Model T. I wonder what they will do when the Pope is not the Anti-Christ. I am sure they will blame the Jesuits.
@DEUS VULT Haha, or a Daniel Wellington.
@DEUS VULT True!! but I still like my Fossil watch hahahah
It's amazing how he can speak with such confidence, and say nothing correct at all.
He's making things up them Seventh day Adventist which he is Believe we should just eat vegetables.God bless Love Trent Horn & Catholic answers 🗝️🗝️🙏🙏⛪⛪🛐📖💯 Catholic
There's a lot of ways people try to convey confidence (to put it as kindly as possible), but Talking. Like. A. Robot. can hardly be considered an amazing attempt.
It's a characteristic of the whole Protest movement...
It’s like he wants to make sure we don’t miss the absurdity of what he has to say. Something stupid said in a loud voice just makes it more stupid.
He’s a product of bad catechesis; a cautionary tale.
So true. Ignorance is a bliss
Why did he have to lie and say he was Catholic, when he didn't even know what the Rosary was?
I’m not inclined to assume lying, I would guess that he grew up in a poorly catechized Catholic home and was drawn away. Good example of “weak Catholics become Protestant, strong Protestants become Catholic”
I haven’t lived under communism but I sure as hell don’t want to and I understand why many Vietnamese people are against it. I happen to have adoptive family members who fled Vietnam.
What exactly are you trying to say and what does it have to do with my comment?
He's blind. He was a heretic when he claimed to be Catholic and he's a heretic now. He's on the road to hell without a doubt .
@@killianmiller6107 I dont understand that person either. But the reason Vietnamese people hate Christian is mostly because of the propagandas since the Nguyen Dynasty hitherto, the hatred toward Christian from Buddhist, and the anti-foreigner mindset which lie deeply in Vietnamese, which are much less in the South now, the North still. The communism party is welcomed because Ho Chi Minh made Vietnamese people believed that it is created by Vietnamese and for Vietnamese. If you travel to Vietnam, meet Northern people and think that they're friendly? No they're not, under those fake ass smile are the deep hatred toward non-Northern Vietnamese people.
@@evangallion1661 let’s pray for him then. Honestly I see a man who’s uneducated and confused. He fell into a trap that’s easy to fall into when you don’t have a good understanding of the Church and what she teaches. Let’s not condemn anyone, Christ asks us to pray for others, love them!
I was an atheist who after an encounter with Chrsit became Catholic. I always appreciated how calm and devout the Catholics were with an intellectual understanding of the faith that was very deep. They also had a great live and reverence for scripture. It was the beauty of the Catholic Christian faith and the depth of holiness within the Church that made me long to be Catholic. Jesus is present in the Eucharist Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity why would I chose any other Christian Church?
Thank you and welcome home.
Congratulations, Vivienne! Welcome home! God bless you.
Protestants also perform ritual Eucharist
I would disagree with the "intellectual" part. Only a small percentage of Catholics have any decent amount of knowledge of the Truth in the Bible. Now that only Increases some amongst the protestants. It is very critical that man study the Bible and fine the Truth in it. The Catholics, like some Protestant, are mislead by Man, such as the Pope. Only Jesus was to be revered as Holy and above all man. Not even his mother was equal or above him.
Catholics, like some Protestant, can pretend as they are not holding up the Pope to the Level of Jesus or sometimes above him. A preacher/pastor gives a sermon and the congregation needs to listen and analyze the words to see if they are True and not Twisted. No man is authorized to Change the Word of God.
May we all study our Bible ourselves and pray for Guidence from God to assist use in Finding the Truth and Peace that is found in Jesus Christ only. God Bless.
Welcome home brother in Christ ❤
The rosary converted me and has helped to convert my mother and girlfriend. Seems far from worthless to me.
Do I hear Wedding Bells tolling nearby?
The rosary is the only thing keeping me astray. Whenever I'm going to do anything bad, meditating with the rosary kept me from doing anything bad ot stupid.
I'm thankful that I do the rosary, because if I was raised in any household without it, I'd probably be in jail or dead.
@@johnnotrealname8168 Well I do
Having a solid devotion to the Rosary has also helped me so much in growing into my faith. While it’s not always easy, I love spending evenings meditating on the Mysteries. It’s especially satisfying during the Joyful during Advent and the Sorrowful during Lent.
It’s led me to seeking more knowledge of my faith, the history, and other devotions like the Divine Mercy and St. Joseph.
@@thefiringsquadtfs6392 the love of our mother Mary on beads (she really loves you!).
I don't know how old you are but my heart felt full of joy when I read your comment I CAN IMAGINE HOW OUR MOTHER FEEL ABOUT YOU.
People leave the One True Faith because they never had proper understanding or were given poor catechesis, or never bothered to dig deeper into the faith itself. They just accept regurgitated Americanized arguments because it's much more simple and easy to understand, even though it's false.
Exactly.
@Empyreal He just said "People".
That’s true
Couldn't have said it better myself!
@YAJUN YUAN Wow you really still believe that your Seventh Adventist Church is the One True Church which was founded in May 21, 1863 by Ellen G. White while the Catholic Church was founded in 1st CE by Jesus Christ? You really need to search in the internet that the early Christians and the early Church Fathers were Catholic and St Ignatius of Antioch add the name "Catholic" for Christianity so that we'll know the difference between Catholic and heretics
Regarding the Holy Eucharist, 1) Jesus did NOT say "this is a picture of my body" or "pretend like it's my body", He said, "This IS my Body; This IS my blood". 2)Everywhere else in the Gospels, Jesus explains to his apostles what he means by the parables. Here, Jesus has no explanation as to what he really meant by "This is my body, this is my blood", 3) This was Jesus' last supper. He knew he was going to die the next day. Now, if you knew you were going to die tomorrow, wouldn't you want to get your affairs in order? You wouldn't give your loved ones cryptic information for them to figure out what you really meant, would you? I seriously doubt that Jesus would either.
He must do a lot of mental brain work on the subject of the Holy Eucharist when in the bible it is mentioned about the Eucharist is turned into the Body and Blood. when Christ himself said quote "take this and eat for this is my body and Drink for this is my blood" unquote.
Yet this modern man supposedly studied scriptures and became Paul like. Yet He never served as an apprentice to any apostle .
"Why I left the Catholic Church: there are 30 Hail Mary's in the Rosary." After this obvious blunder, it's hard to say he was ever Catholic to begin with.
He didn't know there are 53 Hail Mary's in Rosary.It is hard to say he was Catholic if he didn't know the most simple thing
@@monkofthemxbc2235 It certainly speaks to a critical research failure, along with the "they hid some of the commandments in plain sight" argument, which I've seen more often.
Made me think he didn't really leave the Catholic Church, so much as maybe his parents became SDAs and these are the things they told him for why they don't go to the pretty church on Sunday mornings anymore.
@@edpie7759 Good point.It colud be that
In an alternate channel he says he was raised 'a good Catholic' going to Church every so often on Sunday. Its pretty laughable.
@@tony1685 There are no dead saints. Is God the God of the dead?
I was raised a Seventh Day Adventist - the pope can't be called Holy Father according to him but Adventists have a Prophetess, Ellen White, whom they treat way more reverentially than any pope is treated. They believe her word is revealed from God! Does he not see the irony?
@YAJUN YUAN as Trent has already explained that, Catholics didn't imply divinity when they refer to pope as "holy father". I'm not sure why you still insist that we're blaspheming.
Also, FWIW, the scripture passage you quoted is originally written in Hebrew/Greek anyway, so there's a high likelihood that the two "holy father" don't even mean the same thing.
Lastly if you wanna take bible literally without carefully considering the context, Jesus mentioned that we shouldn't call anyone on earth father (Matt 23:9) does that mean we should stop calling our biological parent father? Clearly it isn't what he means..
@YAJUN YUAN Matthew 23:9
9 And call no man your father upon the earth: for one is your Father, which is in heaven.
Why you call your father a father ?? Or answering in document who is your father??
You must be blind too😂
This guy's (Greg Sereda) arguments are
Many, many Protestants do. I've been to fundamentalist churches where their cultish devotion to their founder was far stronger than any Catholic's reverence for the pope.
Thank you Trent. As a cradle Catholic, I have never been taught apologetics. I do request the church teach apologetics especially to confirmation formation
completely agree, even just a short course at confirmation. I'm 46 and have learned more in the last 2 months from this channel and other catholic apologetic sources than i have in the last 46years as a cradle catholic.
Went to RCIA yesterday for the first time yesterday and got two papers with no Bible verses on them. Biblical literacy is very important.
Greg speaks like. he. has. periods. after. every. word. in. his. script.
Agreed....too cringy to listen too.
@@chuckmowry5951 and also the dramatic music in the background 😅
😁🙏🙏🙏Let us offer our Rosary for his conversion.🙏🙏🙏Ave Maria.🙏🙏🙏
@@mariateresa9965 yeah thanks for the reminder!
For a second I thought you meant he was having a menstrual cycle after each word. With that guy sounds plausible.
"no children baptized in the bible" Acts 16:33 - then he and his entire family were baptized immediately-- so the odds of no children being in this family is extremely unlikely // 1 Cor 1:16 " Now I also baptized the household of Stephanas " also not likely to have no children. just sayin
THANKS so much for taking time to dissect/ explain the error in his video. A couple years ago I came across one of that fellow’s videos and was so confused and seemed no one could help me. I was about to leave Catholic Church. God got me threw that ‘dark night’. hopefully your video will be bright light to others who are or get confused by these types of error filled messages.
Thanks for doing the homework for many,May God bless you 💐
Remember baptism is the point of conversion in Judiasm too... It is called a mikveh. The Didache which was written by Jewish Catholics used the same options for the mikveh for baptism. Now if you do a google search for mikveh most of the images you getting a mikveh are infants. Jews baptized babies in Judaism. I would like a pretty go tell a Jew he is performing the mikveh incorrectly...
It doesn’t say babies
@@deus_vult8111 IF whole household are mentioned, would that include babies?
Sure would if you understood Roman society
I find it interesting that he cited the Pharisees' objections to Christ as arguments against the Catholic Church.
Interesting indeed
10:08 made me chuckle a little
But seriously, it's quite sad how poorly catechized he and the past few generations of Catholics have been. I don't understand how someone who's been through the sacrament of penance can come away from it with the idea that the priest personally absolves you
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
Even if he was poorly catechized he did purchase a catechism and apparently didn’t even read it before posting many hour long videos posting misinformation that could be answered by simply reading it at some point a person is simply lazy at not looking into both sides of an argument
@@lilwaynesworld0 he’s one of those former Catholics that “knows what we believe” and in reality knows absolutely nothing or he wouldn’t have joined a heretical church such as the seventh day Adventists
No historical evidence of Peter being the pope?🤦♀️He needs to apologize to the early church fathers.
gotta make it to heaven first
I’m still semi Protestant (Anglican).
But I’m loving learning about my Catholic brothers from the horses mouth.
Undoing 30 years of misconception and straw man of the RC church.
Much love brethren.
Anglican Church is a sinking ship. Come home, brother.
@@sasquatchhunter86 Agreed. Only one good Anglican yet, and that's Calvin Robinson. He says he's going down with the ship. Good on him. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@sasquatchhunter86 I'm not going to claim the RCC is a sinking ship, but it has as many hallmarks of it as the Anglicans do. Plus it's going to make a much mightier splash if it were to sink.
Protestantism isn't the truth either.
@@MeanBeanComedy I would check out Rev. Brett Murphy. I may not be Anglican, but I have huge respect for his stance. He had to leave the splintered and infiltrated faction of Anglicanism, but he's starting an independent church based on his orthodox Anglican beliefs. He has huge support from Catholics and protestants alike, I even see Muslims in his comments, because he's taking a stand in such a loving and firm way.
Thank you for this wonderful informative video. I was a former JW and Protestant, I’ve been a Catholic for 6 years and met my wife through RCIA. . I love to learn and grow in my faith so thank Trent Horn.
I pray that they will be a round table discussion with people like How to Be Christian (funny as heck but don't know his name), Catholic Truth (not sure of his name but he also rebutted the same video)...
God bless you Trent.
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
Welcome home, Jose! Check out Reason & Theology too, Michael Lofton's channel.
So RCIA was more of a singles dance for you? Way to go! Congrats on meeting your Catholic wife there!
My husband and I left the Church after finding out a priest had molested our son. Though it seemed like a good idea at the time, we were motivated by feelings of grief, betrayal, disappointment and anger over the destruction of our son. When we first told Church officials what happened, they handled things badly. Fortunately, we returned about 10 years later, motivated by the death of our daughter.
Could someone have prevented our departure from the church ? I think so. After all, one big reason for our return was realizing that everyone in the Church isn’t alike.
God bless you! Sorry for what happened to your son. Very tragic.
Catholic Church was founded by Jesus Christ.... If a priest do against the church it doesnt mean the church pay for it ..just like in Any organization , in goverment, company if the member or employee committed serious acts against the company that person face the law.....
@@hyperloid2143 Correct!!!!!
@@hyperloid2143 You are right, of course. When we left, we felt betrayed. It wasn’t so much that it happened. You can have a bad apple in any organization, but the lack of concern for the damage done to our son, the unwillingness to help set things right, and the fact that it could have so easily been avoided. The priest had a long history of preying on children, and had been deliberately moved to protect him. People who placed him in the parish did so with full knowledge of who and what he was.
Our feelings of anger and betrayal were justified, but we were still wrong to leave the Church. It just took a long time to realize why.
It doesn’t matter how many were responsible for what happened or why. The fact is that we abandoned Our Holy Mother and Jesus, her Son, because we discovered wolves in the house. It took us years to realize that instead of leaving, we should have warned others about the wolves and started working to rid Our Lord and Lady’s house of them.
The Commandments about keeping the Sabbath Holy and loving God above all else don’t come with exceptions. Obeying God’s law isn’t letting guilty parties off the hook. God will deal with them in his own time. I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes! Committing a wrong yourself because you were wronged doesn’t fix anything. It just makes you guilty as well. We need to trust in God’s love AND justice. Though people frequently fail, God NEVER fails.
I think Satan was allowed to put this in our path because God saw the end result. He knew we would realize these things, and ultimately return with our hearts on fire for Him, strengthened in our faith and resolved to begin helping to set things right in His Church.
I should add that my son has had truly miraculous healing. He hasn’t found faith in God himself yet, but I can clearly see the influence of Our Lady and the Holy Spirit working in his life. It’s possible that this path was the only one that could have brought us all to this point together. If so, it was worth the pain.
Dasan, I am so sorry that you and your family suffered such horrific, crushing events. I pray you find healing now in Christ, our loving Lord. Still, the best place for His healing is the Church. You had courage in returning to it. May you be blessed in it and faithfully served by holy servants there from now on.
Greg's stupid "scary music" and his "groundbreaking" tone is so foolish. He's trying so hard to appeal to the emotion of people who are already suspicious of the church from a lack of understanding.
Let’s all pray Protestants learn the glory of Marian devotion.
Many already do.
@@wolfthequarrelsome504 many? Like who? Most I've come acrossed don't even want to mention her.
@Eucharist Angel god gave us the gift of salvation through faith, but are able to lose that gift? Imagine i give you present for Christmas. Did you earn this gift? No, you did not earn this gift. Can you lose this gift? Yes, yes you can lose this gift. Can you find this gift again? Yes, yes you can find it again.
Face it, protestantism makes no logical sense. It's just made up doctrine with circular arguments.
@Eucharist Angel talking about another gospel.... you lack self awareness following doctrines invented by men, especifically XVI century men
@Eucharist Angel just addressing your first claim that works are not necessary for salvation. Another Protestant false claim to allow themselves the right to believe that faith alone will save them thereby allowing them to do whatever they want and still be saved. But there is a problem, this is totally unbiblical. Keep reading Corinthians. “To those outside the law I became as one outside the law - not being without law toward God but under the law of Christ - that I might win those outside the law (I Cor. 9:21)”. This shows those outside the law are not won.
Maybe one from Romans 2:6-7 “For [God] will render to every man according to his works: to those who by patience in well-doing seek for glory and honor and immortality, he will give eternal life…”
These, among many other passages prove that your position is the false gospel that you claimed Catholics peddle (if you want more…)
Anyone else notice that when Greg is going over the 10 commandments and how they are different in the Catechism....he shows a picture of the Catechism which has all the information? I just found that amusing.
Haha, exactly! I was thinking the same.
That's because he didn't originate the argument. He's just regurgitating some old anti-Catholic talking point even though the answer to his objection is right in front of him.
I found it funny when he misunderstood what the website was saying about the rosary. We don’t say 33 hail Mary’s. It’s 53. He clearly was never very devout as a Catholic.
Yeah its a give away when "ex-Catholics" just lie about what they did in the Church such as 33 hail mary's.
Kinda hard to forget that there's 5 decades +3 if you've prayed it more than once
The guy is all mixed up.
This guy needs some rosary dedications especially since he claims he left the Church. Lucky for him it’s the day for sorrowful mysteries! Thanks Trent for some awesome content!
Y'all ain't doing 203 hail Marys?
I've always hold a high regard for Trent since i first saw him in his debate with Calvinist James White, his ability to stay cool and his patience to follow the other man's belief even though how misguided. Humility is a real virtue, but most apologists do not possess. Trent has a real gift of the Holy Spirit...God bless...♥️♥️♥️
Then he should be able to come up with a better argument for the catholic deification of Mary, because saying “ooh ooh the queen of England has a queen mother…. Therefore pray to Mary? Wtf? How does that follow?
@@bradleythebuilder8743 what's your comment has to do with mine 😂🤣😅😜
@@bradleythebuilder8743 How does that not follow?
@@bradleythebuilder8743 who said anything about deifying Mary. Ooh ooh
@@bradleythebuilder8743you should come up with a better argument against Mary instead of being a dumbass that repeats the same objections that have been destroyed.
Oh my God. On my screen the title of the video was cut.
"10 Reasons why i Left the Catholic Roman Church..."
My heart fell.
*Clicks the video...(REBUTTED)
What a relief!
no need for the blasphemy
@@leonardobeneventi8836 sorry what?
@@caioreis350 “oh my God”
@@leonardobeneventi8836 I believe the correct word should be "Vain Name Calling"
@@caioreis350 don't worry, it's not blasphemy. You're just calling out to God about something shocking to you
You are a blessing to the Church, Trent. The love of Christ be with you.
@Eucharist Angel You are wrong on all your points. God only saves! We believe it. But we can lose our salvation as our Lord Himself told us we could. So we work our own salvation with fear and trembling, as Paul told us to. What you have is lack of understanding, you need to study more.
You are misquoting Pope Boniface VIII horribly! I invite you to investigate deeply in the subject. Read the whole papal bull (Unam sanctam). Read the history surrounding the events, why was it written? who were involved? Don’t just believe for a fact something somebody else said because you feel it good when he said it. Don’t follow your feelings but follow truth. The heart is deceiving. Do a righteous investigation of the subject, don’t be so simple in your judgement but be throughly. Don’t judge before any serious investigation has been done. With the same measure you judge you will be judged. You better get in a right standard with God. Don’t fall for self righteousness, we have not been perfected in Christ yet. Don’t be prideful but humble yourself even on your understanding of the Word of God. Treat the Word of God with respect, but most importantly treat everyone else with respect, as if they were our Lord Himself.
Let’s pray our Father who is in heaven, in the name of His son Jesus Christ, to bring us understanding, and to bring His peace. God bless you!
@Eucharist Angel The Catholic view is that the Lord Jesus Christ alone gets worship.
serve god, not a church
@@thrustgamer7837 God the Father sent Christ the Son, Christ sent His Apostles, His Apostles sent their disciples, to raise up churches in the name of Christ, to spread the news to the whole world, believe, repent and be baptized in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit! To have one faith and one baptism and one mind. By following the ones Jesus sent, we follow Christ, and His Father’s will. Haven’t you read the Gospels were our Lord said “Amen, amen I say to you, he that receiveth whomsoever I send, receiveth me; and he that receiveth me, receiveth him that sent me.” By denying the Authority of the Church who claim to have Apostolic succession you are denying Christ Himself! Haven’t you heard the book of Acts where Saul was persecuting the Church, and our Lord appeared to him and said: “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?" "Who are you, Lord?" Saul asked. "I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting," read Church history, what the early church believed, How they worshipped together, we are 2000 years after Christ, do you think the early Church got it wrong? And 2000 years later we figured it out, and todays interpretation of scripture is the right interpretation? God bless you and keep you safe!
@@thrustgamer7837 serve in the Church built by Christ
Love to Trent from a Lutheran brethren. Love your videos and humility to provide catholic answers.
Love it!! Whenever I listen to debates among different denominations, I noticed that Catholics have a solid response to everything. I'm convinced Catholicism is true
They also don't seem to rely on framing devices like foreboding music and really grating vocal candence. Ooft that was hard to watch. Definitely going to pray that this kid comes to a a true understanding of the Catholic faith instead of the poor catechesis he obviously received as a child.
Catholicism is true!
Most definitely so that you too may believe.
Eucharist Miracle
ruclips.net/video/oezu-joNaPw/видео.html
This is why Lucifer rebelled against God.
ruclips.net/video/r8I8DDfewMU/видео.html
I have tried to follow very well about how he gives scriptures talking about 'father'...... there's no where any saints said clearly holy father..... Scriptures says father without combination of 'Holy father "
My neighbor is a SDA Church but they were unable to convert me nor my family nor my other neighbors because we held steadfast in our faith.
What irritates me so much about the video being reacted on is how he uses music and imagery to make viewers feel uneasy and fearful about whatever he is saying about Catholicism. His "reasons" aside, the way his video is presented is propagandistic in and of itself.
Seems like all fake documentaries about stuff. "Spooky" music and images to somehow make lies a truth. Pure sensation and pure nonsense.
this man can't even count the number of Hail Marys in a rosary
He’s going to lose his mind when he finds out how many we actually pray😂
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
@@MarioPoluan He's killing time in a field waiting for the Rapture.
@YAJUN YUAN There is the Apostle’s Creed, which includes the Trinity. There are 6 prayers dedicated to the Father, 5 dedicated to Jesus, and a final prayer dedicated to both the Father and Jesus. Additionally, while one prays the Hail Mary’s, they should be meditating on the mysteries of Jesus’s life. There is no “Hail Jesus”, but there are plenty of other prayers concerning him.
Edit: There are also 6 prayers that literally begin with “Glory be to the Father, and to Son, and to the Holy Spirit…” if the previously mentioned ones weren’t enough.
@YAJUN YUAN how many "hail Jesus " are in the bible?
based on his 10 Reasons, he left the Catholic Church because he is ignorant, period.
more like....gullible
I don't think Greg has read the Old testament when it comes to wars 😂😂
Maccabees..hold our wine please..🤣
The same goes for Abraham,Mozes,Joshua e.t.c yet these so called bible believers would demonize the crusades.
@@LycBren Maccabees isn't inspired it literally contradicts itself
@@karabuscemi217 source?
Greg, just leave us alone. Do not commit more sins by spreading hate. We Catholics are very proud of our Holy Catholic Church. Goodbye, Greg. May you find peace. But the door is always open.
You should know pride is a sin. And there's nothing holy about the catholic church.
So it makes alot more sense after reading the description of the video
"I was born and raised as a Roman Catholic and taught to revere the Virgin Mary and the Pope. I completed my First Communion, learned how to pray the Rosary, *_and even went to church from time to time_* "
Sounds like he was raised by lukewarm CEO parents.....I truly feel sorry for him, he obviously never had proper catechesis.
He clearly doesn't remember how to pray the Rosary. "33 Hail Marys" LOL.
The protestant in the video doesn’t sound like he knows a lot about the Catholic Church. He sounds like he is miss informed about the Catholic Church. I feel sorry for people who watch that protestant videos that they get miss lead in information. Thank you Council of Trent for Rebutted that misinformed protestant.
On Spanish we say "catolico ignorante futuro protestante"(an ignorant Catholic soon will be a protestant), that's what happened to this poor soul, he ignored what the Catholic Church is and teaches.
If there were a book called early church heresies that are still present today or poor protestant objections that are easy refutable, this video video's transcript would be the entire book
Worshiping mary is but one more false teaching of the catholic church …. Yet another hoax. This is more delusion and gimmick. Jesus Christ, the nail-scarred risen Savior is the sole emphasis of the Bible, God's Word, not sinners like this lady whom the catholic church has made out to be saint.
it is an absolute delight to hear how our LORD Jesus found and saved many of you who were born and raised catholics .... I too was lied to by the roman religion for over 2 decades and am eternally grateful for the saving grace of our God that was poured out through the blood of the cross of Jesus Christ
Yet another hoax. This is more delusion and gimmick. Jesus Christ, the nail-scarred risen Savior is the sole emphasis of the Bible, God's Word, not sinners like this lady whom the catholic church has made out to be saint.
MARY, the pope, the catholic church, and the myriad of other idols offered by this purely pagan organization are satanic substitute idols to cause the damnation of millions. They are antichrist which simply means “in place of” Christ.
God so loved the world that WHO did He give? mary? a so-called pope? the catholic church? NO! He gave His only begotten Son to redeem our sinful souls and outside of Jesus Christ, no one will be in Heaven ... oh and purgatory is a lie. Hell awaits.
@@johnm.1069 How many Churches did Jesus start in Matthew 16? Who did He give the keys to the church to and ask to lead, watch over His flock? That Church is still here. He didn't create 1001 denominations and give ALL of them authority. He didn't tell individuals they ALL have authority. The Holy Spirit can never be the author of confusion. There is only one Church which has the documented evidence linking it directly back to Matthew 16. All others are denominations. The Catholic Church is pre-denominational, it existed before the christian Bible existed. The Catholic Church chose the books of the FIRST christian bible at the Council of Rome in 382AD, the bible is a Catholic book and only the Catholic Church has the authority given to it directly by Christ to interpret it.
@@johnm.1069 the word saint means holy. Out of all the women who have ever lived God chose Mary to raise Him, to teach Christ the scriptures and how to pray. You don't believe the mother of Christ is holy?
We do not worship Mary, we honour her because for 9 months she had God Himself in her womb. If the land that Christ walked is holy, who is the woman in whose womb he spent 9 months, who raised Him and was one of the very few who was by His side during His passion, death, and resurrection?
The catholic church teaches that worship is for God alone, and no Catholic worships or has ever worshipped Mary.
As for the rest of your rant. It astounds me how someone can rant so long and be so incorrect
Thank you Trent you are a gift to our lives and the Church. I encourage everyone to support Trent financially. He is doing what I wish I had the time and the brains to do. Which unfortunately I don't but we can help by supporting Trent in his ministry. These "rebutted" videos are fantastic. Thanks Trent for helping me come home to the Catholic Church.
Tomorrow I will visit my first "conscious" Mass. I have been to some so far, but haven't paying attention. It has been a wonderful journey so far, and you - Trent - have been a part of that.
IT is funny when the smartest people come back to the truth in the Catholic Church, the ignorant keep leaving the Catholic Church.
Pretty much!!!!
actually, the membership of the Catholic Church is shrinking worldwide...especially in Europe, North America...the smartest leave that heresy.
@@TheSilverGlow stop giving yourself away soul man, you dont know shit about europe
So true
Man I remember watching this video when I was an anti-Catholic.
Ah memories
"this video"? This video was just uploaded Jun 11, so when were you an "anti Catholic"?
@@etrnlygr8tful I'm fairly certain they're speaking of the video being rebutted. It's a couple of years old I think.
@@etrnlygr8tful He's obviously talking about the anti Catholic video. This is a perfect example of why you need a teaching authority for the bible and Sola Scriptoria simply isn't a real thing. People can't even read and comprehend a basic RUclips comment.
This man condemns the sacrament of confession by affirming it. The stupidity is beyond the roof.
He also denied purgatory (or a strawman of it) by affirming it at the end of that argument.
Great video Trent as usual. You couldn't resist this rebuttal even on free for all Friday! I pray he sees his errors and returns to us.
the heresy about Mary he speaks about...... makes me wants to scream.
May God help him.... Ave Maris Stella... light on blindness pour.
Your husband is one lucky guy to have you.
@@mareeyo1 Indeed, it makes me happy to see women who have not/refuse to be blinded by the vices of the world. Amen Brethren
The older I get, the less patience I have for insults to the Blessed Mother. I used to be that way in my early twenties, but man!! Can you IMAGINE saying stuff like that in front of Jesus or St. Joseph?
' Great is Diana of the Ephesians !"
He seems to think Jesus is jealous of His Mother....
I'm so confused anytime a protestant says there is no biblical evidence for the pope or transubstantiation specifically. It's one thing to say you don't believe it. it is another thing entirely to say there isn't anything in the bible that support it.
@Empyreal ya the entire John chapter 6 is real flimsy.
@YAJUN YUAN how is that enjoining a crime or vice? It is the body of Christ, not a regular man.
For the record, Catholics believe it is figurative and literal. The figurative part is that he sacrificed himself once and we have communion in rememberence of that. The literal part is the transformation part.
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
@YAJUN YUAN my dude, if you think Augustine did not believe in transubstantiation, you're lost. You wrote what he said, but then interpreted a completely different way. Thats why I asked.
@YAJUN YUAN to much stupidity from ellen 🤣
you should do another one like this but find a Mormon who left the Catholic church instead.
That’s a really good idea! I hope he does this
I always do bible studies with LDS missionaries. One day they brought a catholic woman who is now LDS. She told me the main reason she joined the LDS was they were able to make sense of God the father, Jesus and the Holy spirit; the trinity never made sense to her.
@@jodibarrick2152 I hear the same thing bout about people who convert from Christianity to Islam. they always speak about how they never understood the holy trinity.
Disagree. Ex- "fill in the blanks" make good clickbait, but this guy being an ex catholic doesnt automatically lend him elevated expertise, does it? Its often a sign of ideological transience which should, by default, lower his spiritual madden player rating rather than raise it. Much more prudent to find a knowledgeable active member and have a productive discussion then to seek out the disaffected to confirm biases.
@@jodibarrick2152 We had a Catholic gentleman join the LDS church in our area a while back because the sisters in the LDS ward had been visiting and taking care of his wife while she was ill...cleaning the house, making her food, etc for nearly two years. At the funeral he verbally blistered the priest in public and said that the only time he ever heard from the priest for years was when he wanted money to set up the funeral.... And that he would never step foot in a Catholic church again. (I honestly didnt know it cost money to do a funeral in the Catholic Church)
Its a reminder to me that arguing over the doctrine and the history of churchs is secondary to remembering that Christs life was a life of service. He gave his life for others every day of his life before he died on the cross. He was about His Fathers business. A sign of his true disciples and priesthood leaders is that they will do likewise. God bless.
I would love to see you rebut one of the "Wretched" videos. That guy HATES catholics. Great videos Trent!
At least the name of his show accurately describes the quality of his preaching.
Taking the bronze in the youtube comment olympics of who can comment on a video first (because it's a sport aparently)
I wanted to thank you, Trent, for doing the world a great service by promoting wisdom, knowledge, culture and so much more to the www
It's an awesome service to the public and you almost can't be applauded enough for it, keep up the great work :>
@Eucharist Angel ruclips.net/video/sZ76ckSPSGE/видео.html
You're asking to be spared from something you chose to visit read and comment on. Love when the "E"vangelicals come to judge.
I wasn't there "when" that happened so I don't know all the circumstances. I don't need to refute you. That's all been done before. I have faith in the one true church. You are your own church.
@Eucharist Angel You are the one who went out of his way to come here and insult others. But it seems you can dish it out but not take it, eh? Not only are you a heretic, you also fall short of being a man.
The Roman Catholic Church caused the inquisition and sided with Hitler and will help the antichrist during The Great Tribulation. It is the beast with seven heads and ten horns. The pale white horseman in Zechariah 6 and Revelation/Apocalypse 6
My wife was seven day adventist, we married Catholic 14yrs ago, The only true Church the Catholic Church
First! Love the intellectual content Trent! You were pivotal in my own conversion
@Eucharist Angel clearly you did not read CCC 1821. “…heaven, as God’s eternal reward for good works accomplished with the grace of Christ.” How is that “GOOD WORKS” get you to heaven. No it’s the grace of Christ that fuels you to do good in the world and that heaven will be ones reward.
2 Cor 11:4 is not even saying what you think it is. It’s maybe implicitly saying that we should reject gospels that are contrary to Christ, (I mean duh obviously). But he’s only saying that the Corinthians too easily accepted other gospels. You are just doing the typical take one verse out of context that barely (if at all) makes your point.
Even so, Trent pretty much debunked everything you just said in his rebuttal to that Josh guy.
But as for the Unam Sanctam, yeah. Christ gave his apostles authority! To forgive and retain sins and to lead his holy Church! Of course one would have had to submit to the apostles after Christ’s ascension, because to not do so would be to disobey Christ. So yeah, I’m sorry, but believing that you don’t have to follow church authorities which were put in place by Christ and St. Paul, all because “you think you know better” is extremely arrogant.
Now the position of the modern Catholic Church is that salvation outside of Catholicism proper, is possible…
I’ve been a Protestant, I’ve tried the whole personal relationship stuff and the sola scriptura. It was confining. Embrace the vast and rich tradition of Christianity that spawns from its genesis, not from the 15th century by a mentally ill monk.
@Eucharist Angel yeah. Like I said, grace saves us but after that we are called to be paragons of his name. James 2:14-26
By the way, I love it that you are using the Bible, the canon of which was set by the early church. If somehow, the early church was Protestant, leaving interpretation of the Bible up to every individuals, there would be no set canon, there would be thousands of different canons and Bibles.
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
@YAJUN YUAN But Catholics do not call the Pope "Heavenly Father," we call him the Holy Father, which is different. We are calling him one of the spiritual fathers that possesses the most holy office. As trent says, it is not a claim of divinity nor does anyone really think it is, so why are protestants so concerned? This is simply one of the Catholic things that just "sounds" bad to Protestant ears but once you delve into the reasoning behind it and realize it is just a title that has no usurpation of Christ along with it, it's not really a big deal.
Even so, if God is the only one called Holy Father in the bible does that inherently mean that it cannot be applied to other humans? There really is no reason to believe that... (especially if you believe in Sola Scriptura and the Bible does not explicitly say "only give title x or title y to God")
Let me ask you this. Is then the Eastern Orthodox's "Ecumenical Patriarch," or literally "father of the church" also blasphemous?
@Eucharist Angel Here's the thing about Protestant grace theology. You use words like "FLATLY unbiblical" and then just cant explain James 2:14-26, which at least discredits your argument. Clearly, James says that the relationship between faith and works is complicated and they are closely connected (". That alone means that the idea that Sola Scriptura and Sola Gratia are incompatible, because in James it says that works "justify" our faith ("Was not Abraham our father justified by works when he offered Isaac his son on the altar? "). So which is it? Are we saved by grace alone (with absolutely NOTHING to do with works) or is scripture alone the source of authority, even though that means that James 2 disproves Sola Gratia?
Also I think you are reading too much into the word "help" in the CCC. Do you disagree that God's grace helps us become adopted children of Christ? All that paragraph is saying (and indeed if you read it in context it will help lol) that we have a role to play in our own salvation. We can reject salvation or we can respond to the call of God's grace.
It is ironic, because if I were an outside reader just reading through the New Testament, it would seem that between Romans, Ephesians, and James that the New Testament was contradicting itself in terms of the system of justification. Protestants simply ignore James, strict legalists ignore Romans, and Ephesians, but Catholics account for all the verses. We are saved by the grace from God, but we have to respond to that grace (i.e. make a very clear action of the will) and then go out into the world and do good. Its a beautiful balance between what seems to be contradicting thoughts.
"That's a total of 33 Hail Marys!"
ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Hi
Your dominican? I like your profile picture
@YAJUN YUAN revelation 4: 8
@YAJUN YUAN im not contradicting what sirach says, the verse means not to say prayers without your heart into it. It also proves that small prayers are as good as bigger ones
Thank you Trent Horn for defending the beautiful and true faith of the Catholic Church. Protestants seem to use only logic and reasoning to prove mathematically what they believe in the bible just like theorems are statically and clinically proven in Geometry - therefore x=y. I attended a Seventh Day Adventist church for three years and found that natural, dry faith lacking of spiritual juice. The Catholic faith is magnificent, more sensitive to people and makes more sense altogether. Praise be to God!
Always great content. This seemed a little too easy for Trent. I guess even Trent needs to play a little slow pitch softball. Thanks Mr. Horn.
I think he is responding on the basis of the video having almost 800,000 views rather than its quality.
He corrects the wrong statements of the original video so people can be saved from error. That's why he always adapts the depth of his arguments to the audience that could be lead astray by the original video he is rebutting. You can see this in the videos where he for example rebutts James White, who uses Church fathers and semantic arguments and whose audience is more used to more complex arguments (James White is a good but strongly misinformed debater. But if you compare James White to the seventh day adventist in this video you see there are whole universes of sophisticated arguments in between)
I’m never ceased to be amazed as a convert to Catholicism how little manyCatholics know about their faith. This guy took the lie hook line sinker.
I'm a "cradle Catholic", as it were, and as far as I'm concerned, people like you are EXTRA special for all of us. Angels personified.
In Confirmation we receive Graces and OBLIGATIONS. The Holy Spirit's touch upon you just may be one of those ETERNAL Graces for all of us.
@@williamf.buckleyjr3227 I feel very blessed to be Catholic. It is a treasure to me. when 70 % of Catholics deny the real presence in the Eucharist the source and summit of our faith there the ball has been dropped somewhere. I can’t name a single Protestant church that has more than half of it’s members deny something so fundamental to its teachings. Cultural Catholicism is a large and sad reality. How did we get to this point? Secularism? Relativism? I would love to know your perspective.
This video exemplifies why those who speak on religion should be very careful, and make sure they are well informed before trying to admonish others. The fact that not a single thing he said was an accurate or fair portrayal of the Catholic faith perfectly illustrates that, in order to reject the teachings of the Church, one must distort and misrepresent them. That in itself is a beautiful thing, and only makes me feel stronger in my convictions. Thank you Trent, and my God’s graces and the Gift of the Holy Spirit help continue to guide you in your journey to help inform Catholics and Christians alike 🙏
"The sacraments dont save you bc that is a works salvation..."
Oh, and, (based on the same logic), asking Jesus into your heart through the "sinners prayer" is not a work?
In both instances, either the sinners prayer and the sacraments, we are responding to the grace provided- via the grace's of prayer and the sacraments themselves. God doesn't need to be present in the Eucharist, but by His own will, He is.
"Yes Lord have Mercy on those who misunderstand and reject what God has revealed to the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Jesus Christ established upon the Apostles and there successors" Wow Trent what a way to end this Video we are truly blessed as Catholics to have you and for our SDA brother we pray that the Lord might open his eyes to this Truth.
His adventist vegetarian diet is affecting his common sense.
This made me chuckle out loud. 😂
@@marcihf217 I have a better one...
He also believes that in the end times Catholics . . Sorry "Roman" Catholics.. are going to decapitate the SDAs .. Because the SDAs are the chosen people .. since the 19th century anyway.
@@wolfthequarrelsome504 They think the CC has so much power but it can barely hold its own lol its awash in scandal and they think its gonna take over the world and kill everyone
@@wolfthequarrelsome504 Woooooah. Where do they come up with this stuff? 😖😂😂
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
0:45 1. Pope is not the Holy Father
5:20 2. Mary cant hear prayers
11:05 3. priests cant forgive sins
16:05 4. rosary is useless
21:45 5. the sacraments cannot save you
25:30 6. infant baptism will not help your baby
33:00 7. purgatory is not real
39:20 8. CC changed Gods law
47:15 9. CC has a bloody past
1:02:05 10. catholic mass violates Jesus
The Error of the Protestant Lie:
"But as for the cowardly and unbelieving, and abominable and murderers, and fornicators and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, their portion shall be in the pool that burns with fire and brimstone, which is the second death." Revelation 21:8, ignored by all liars. See Rev 21:27 also.
It is a foregone conclusion that Jesus Christ founded only one Church.
1) Why then, do Protestants ignore this fact and continue to splinter the Body of Christ?
2) There is no Protestant who can trace his or her church back any farther than the Protestant revolt of the early 16th century.
Where is the verse which authorized them to break from the true Church in the first place?
3) No Protestant can show that their church was founded by Jesus Christ, yet Scripture says there is only one Church, the one founded by GOD (Psalms 127:1, Matthew 16:18).
4) They deny that the Catholic Church is the Church which Jesus Christ founded, yet they cannot name the Church which He did found in its stead. Isn't it strange that Scripture has said that GOD's Church will last forever (Isaiah 2:2,59:21, Matthew 28:20, Ephesians 3:21), and yet Protestants refuse to name it? If Scripture can be believed at all, why then do they refuse to name GOD's one and only Church?
5) They cannot name the person who founded the Catholic Church while at the same time they deny that it was Jesus Christ. That is strange also, since every Church on earth was founded by a person with a name. Every single one of the tens of thousands of Protestant sects can be traced back to a human person with a name, as its founder. Why is it that Protestants refuse to name the founder of the Catholic Church?
Isn't that the epitome of arrogance as I touched upon in a previous segment?
6) Why do Protestants spread the lie that the Catholic Church apostatized soon after the last Apostle died, and therefore the Church of today is not the one that Jesus Christ founded?
This lie flies in the face of Matthew 16:18, as Protestants must then have to admit that the 'gates of hell' did indeed prevail, that the Bible was in error, and that all of the verses I have previously listed that promise the perpetualty of Christ's Church must be in error as well. This so-called "great apostasy" lie is then magnified a hundredfold since no Protestant can produce genuine historical documents which record such a "monumental, universe shaking event". Every writer who was alive at the time had to have witnessed that supposed "profound event", and those who have lived ever since (up until the time that the lie was invented by Protestantism), did not write about it either. What with the "greatest event since the crucifixion" at hand, why didn't they? It is because it never happened, that's why. Simply put, "No lie is of the truth", 1John 2:21, so therefore no lie can be proven.
Scripture does say that people within Christ's Church will apostatize, but not the Church itself. For you see, it is impossible, since Christ is the Head, and the Church is His Body.
How could the Body of Christ rebel against, and leave His Head? They are inseparable forever.
"Wives, be subject to your husbands, as to the Lord. For the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church, his body, and is himself its Savior." Ephesians 5:22-23
Okay Protestants, explain those verses? Is Christ really the Savior of His Body, or did He desert it as Protestantism would have us believe? Is Holy Scripture in error yet again according to Protestant false charges?
Are we to believe the Protestant lie, or the truth of the Word of GOD?
Do you recall the story of the wheat and the chaff, where the weeds will co-exist with the righteous up until the very end, and then they will be separated out and burned (Matthew 13:24-30)?
"For, in the first place, when you assemble as a church, I hear that there are divisions among you; and I partly believe it, for there must be factions among you in order that those who are genuine among you may be recognized." 1Corinthians 11:18-19.
From those two verses we have a perfect example of the apostasy of individuals within the Church, those who cause divisions and factions. Now from what I have shown in many places in this writing, just who is the cause of divisions and factions? It is none other than Protestantism. Protestantism has already created over 36,000 divisions and factions, and which number is still increasing unceasingly every week to this very day.
Who are the 'genuine among you'?
They are the faithful of the one and only Church that Jesus Christ founded and which is still with us after almost 2000 years of persecution. Read Acts 5:38-39 for the reason why this longevity.
For those who continue to spread the lie of the so-called, and non-existent, "great apostasy", please re-read Revelation 21:8, and endeavor to explain Ephesians 5:23-24?
7) How many verses have I shown in this writing that Protestants ignore? Isn't it a lie to say that you follow Scripture literally to the word, and yet ignore so many Scriptural verses?
8) Why do Protestants take the whole Bible literally except for John chapter 6, which they call symbolic? One chapter in the whole Bible is symbolic? How can that be true?
9) How can Protestants say that Sola Scriptura has been in use from day one, when for over 1400 years almost no one had a Bible, and even if they did, the great majority of the masses were illiterate anyhow?
10) Since Protestants believe that "all Scripture is inspired (2Tim 3:16)", then why aren't the gospels of Peter, Philip, Nicodemus, Bartholomew, Andrew, Thomas, etc, in their Bible?
11) Where in Holy Scripture did Jesus give instructions that the Christian faith is to be solely based on a book? How about the same question except for using the Apostles instead of Jesus?
12) Why do Protestants say it is the Bible which is the pillar and foundation of truth when the Bible clearly says it is the Church (1Tim 3:15)? Please give me the name of that Church?
13) Why do Protestants reject Apostolic Tradition when the Bible clearly says, "So then, brethren, stand firm and hold the teachings that you have learned, whether by word or by letter of ours."
2Thessalonians 2:15, yet another verse ignored, and taught against by Protestantism.
14) Why do Protestants deny that the Bible came from the Catholic Church when they cannot name a truthful and provable alternate source, and where there are literally hundreds of genuine historical documents which prove them to be wrong in their denial?
15) Protestants deny that Peter was given primacy in Matthew 16:18. Nothing in Scripture is done without a purpose. For what purpose then, did Jesus change Simon's name to Peter?
16) Why do Protestants deny that the Papacy is Scriptural, when in fact, it is very Scriptural?
17) Why is it that Protestants can never supply genuine historical documents to "prove" their false charges? Is it because the lie can never be proven, but the truth can be?
It is simple, if you have no truth, then you have no proof.
Catholics can, and do, supply genuine historical documents to prove what they teach.
Why then do Protestants refuse to read them? Romans 1:18, 2:8
18) Why do Protestants deny the unbroken line of succession of Popes down through the centuries from St. Peter to the present Pope, when the Catholic Church has given free access for anyone to research genuine historical documents to prove it to be true, but Protestants refuse to read them? Anyone can go to a secular encyclopedia and see the same succession of Popes.
19) Why do Protestants deny that the Catholic Church has existed from the first century, when hundreds of genuine historical documents, written by scores of Holy men and women, are freely available to prove them wrong in their denial? However, Protestants simply refuse to read them. As explained earlier, Protestants teach that history ended with Acts 28:30 and did not begin again until Luther came along.
20) I saved the worst Protestant lie as the last one on this list. When asked who founded the Catholic Church, there are some who answer correctly that it is Jesus Christ who founded it, but they quickly add that the Catholic Church fell into apostasy and is not the same Church today as the one founded by Jesus. Of course they have no documented proof of this world shaking event as to the who caused it and when and where it happened. By making this false charge they may have condemned themselves because they have just called Jesus Christ a liar. You see there are verses in Holy Scripture which they either choose to ignore or do not understand, and the verses show that Jesus in fact did promise that His Church would last for all time and so did St Paul:
@@teambible7803 Wow. What an inspiring and insightful comment! I’d have you on my debate team for sure!
@@patquint3291 I have you on the idiots list
@@teambible7803 Whoa! That seems to be a strange, unreasonable, and un-Christian response. Why are you adding heat instead of light?
@@chrisvandermerwe7111 look in the mirror
Amazing content ⭐️🙏👍
Just a word of advice from a former protestant. I do agree with you on basically every point. Appeal to scriptures to show people like this the error of their ways. They will not hear you unless you show them from the scriptures my friend.
I thought the same thing. Would definitely be more persuasive that way.
For some, your claim is correct. For others, there will be an endless round of rebuttals, with the claim that Trent doesn't correctly understand or represent the particular Scripture passages Trent cites in support of Trent's refutations. Patrick Madrid tells the tale of the occasion years previous when Patrick found himself on just such a treadmill, until he confronted his Protestant interlocutors with something unfamiliar that required them to think rather than parrot the prepared pat answers about particular Scripture passages.
@Empyreal Hi, Empyreal.
Thanks for your reply. I'm assuming that your reply was directed to my comment, and interpret your comments according to that understanding. If I have misunderstood your line of thought, please let me know.
I agree with your assessment that all roads lead to Rome. While I might challenge your claim that biblical evidence is scant, your claim operates with a still more fundamental assumption. That assumption is that the weight of biblical evidence is significant. Catholics view the matter in an entirely different light. Without any special claim for Scripture, evidence is adduced for its reasonable reception as accurate and reliable historical data. This yields the Resurrection, which yields Christ's divinity. Philosophical enquiry concludes to several implications concerning divinity, including authority, omnipotence, omniscience, truth. Scripture as reliable historical data establishes the Church. The Church exercises Her authority to recognize inspiration and thus the canon, but it is the Church which governs, whether canonicity, the meaning of certain passages, or the analogy of Faith.
Greg sounds like one of those robot voices some RUclipsrs use for their narration.
😂
I actually read the "big green book" (green cover) CCC before taking a vacation at a monastery. It shows a church that actually follows the bible. No protestant church I ever went to does that. As a protestant I was Baptist, United Methodist, AoG, and several others. Only the Roman Catholic. I have converted and am a happy Catholic :)
God bless
Welcome home.
Most definitely so that you too may believe.
Eucharist Miracle
ruclips.net/video/oezu-joNaPw/видео.html
This is why Lucifer rebelled against God.
ruclips.net/video/r8I8DDfewMU/видео.html
Praying for the dead it is in the Bible.
2 Maccabees 12: 44-46 says; “PRAY FOR THE DEAD SO THAT THEY MAY LOOSED THEIR SINS.”
That's true, but unfortunately Maccabees isn't in Protestant Bibles. They reject it and other books Luther took out
2 Maccabees isn't inspired by God,it literally contradicts itself.
@@karabuscemi217 could you give me an example?
@@cimoirine It’s an apparent contradiction because the Bible also says that damnation and salvation are permanent.
Praying for the dead makes no sense EXCEPT with the concept of a “purification” process like Purgatory.
And the men in Maccabees were simply worried for their dead brothers upon finding foreign lucky charms on their corpses, which they should not have taken.
Maccabees is not part of the original 66 books of the combined old & new testaments of the bible.. the Roman catholic hierarchy inserted it to justify their dogmas that we can pray for the dead.. the reality is, at the point of death, ones eternal destiny is confirmed..Read Luke16:19-31.🙏
Love these Rebutted videos. So glad to see a new one from you, Trent.
I’m a Lutheran reinvestigating Catholicism.
There’s a reason I departed only as far as traditional, high Lutheranism I think.
I’ll follow God’s truth where it leads me
@STONWALL I just read your comment post about 6 months ago, I'm in the middle of researching & learning about Catholicism from a Baptist foundation. I was taught my whole life how Catholicism was wrong but the more I dig and search the more I find how off my understanding of the Bible is. I am a Christian but on a new journey. What have you learned in the past 6 months? Thanks I hope you read this
@@Jeepjones85
I’m glad I saw your response. I’ve stayed at this Lutheran church. It is LCMS, traditional and reverent. Not bending with the times, very crucial.
It is important to take Christ at His word. The Body and Blood are true, Baptism is real and a blessed, faith from God is a gift. “None may come to Father but those whom He calls.”
All shared with Catholics, but that’s because the Reformation was never meant to destroy, it was meant to “reform” back to Christ as center, not Romish Authority.
Purgatory, and trying to cut down your time there, or going to confession so you don’t die with a “mortal sin” on your heart (and thus go to Hell, even as a believer) these things are not biblical, and seek only to keep people dependent on the institution of Rome for their hope.
There is no basis for singular authority centered in Rome, other than the Roman Empire which is where it finds its true origin.
Their appeal to their own authority is circular, and they offer gnostic, special knowledge and “holy relics” as proof of their claim.
Things like holy cloth touched to the bodies of incorruptible saints, or Mary’s Milk, or the liquifying saints blood, or even the Shroud of Turin are all hollow,
We don’t need them. They weaken the faith because Christ is attacked on behalf of this obviously foolish and fragile mysticism.
We only need Christ. I love reading the Epistles for this reason.
Read Acts and Romans. You will get so much out of them. Put yourself back in time, traveling with Paul during the establishment of these early churches.
That is our faith.
@@stonwall9065 Apparently, you did not do much investigating into the Catholic Church since you decided to stay with a man made one.
@@georgepierson4920 Well I follow Jesus Christ and these people seem to as well.
They actually read the bible at my church! So that was a relief.
@@stonwall9065 incorrect. Martin Luther left the Catholic seminary. Now show me how the twelve left each other like Martin Luther? How did Martin Luther die again?
The same old anti-Catholic objections that have been debunked over and over again. Why can't these people see just one Counsel of Trent video befor they post anything on RUclips? It would save them....well....a lot of time...first of all.
I have .
I use Trents videos to completely remind myself why I left the Catholic Church years ago.
You see. Man can never reveal TRUTH to you. Spiritual things can only be taught by the SPIRIT HIMSELF.
I encourage you to seek fully the COUNSELOR’s help before you go to Trent.
@@darkhorses5394 The Counselor's help tells me you don't know what you're talking about. Perhaps you should listen a little harder.
@@darkhorses5394 Tell me then, what did the spirit "reveal to you" that made you leave the Catholic Church?
Great, great job Trent! Thank ypu so much👏🏻👌🏼🙌🏻
That "dramatic" background music on Greg's video LOL
Also regarding the sin, He TOLD His disciples to forgive sins, cast out demons etc
THE CATHOLIC CHURCH SAYS: "The Pope has power to change times, to abrogate laws, and to dispense with all things, even the precepts of Christ". "The Pope has authority and has often exercised it, to dispense with the command of Christ." This is from Decretal, de Tranlatic Episcop. Cap. - Blasphemy!
NOTE...this is only "one" definition of blasphemy. Another is claiming to have the power to "forgive sins" Case in point = Mark 2:7, which states, "Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?" The "confessional" of the Roman Catholic Church is indeed yet another identifiable feature exposing the Vatican as Antichrist's dwelling. They openly declare a MAN dressed as a priest has the power to FORGIVE SINS!
@@johnm.1069 "When He had said this, He breathed on them and said, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 23If you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven; if you withhold forgiveness from anyone, it is withheld.” John 20:22
@@johnm.1069 then explain Pentecost? Why would JESUS give to the twelve those powers and then let them die and not have a line of succession?
I was waiting for this
I was raised a Jehovah's witness, and taught that having a cross *at all* was idolatry. It sounds like he is similarly iconoclastic
Trent you rock! Keep up the good work and God bless you!
Thank you very much Trent for this rebuttal!
You clearly have been given a grace, in which you are able to refute people who misunderstand Catholic teachings, with such humility, patience, respect, etc...and give a well formed, confident, educated answer!
May God continue to bless you! 💠
How about in the Transfiguration, meeting Moses and Elijah? Was it necromancy?
He say Moses caught up to heaven, were is that in the bible
This video should be mandatory at RCIA, CCD, Religious Ed class and Catechism.
Very respectfully rebutted!
Amen
Protestant: that's a total of 33 hail Mary's!
Catholic: Well the whole rosary is actually all 20 sets of 10 plus the 3 at the beginning so thats a total of 203 hail marys
Protestant: *faints
The Luminous Mysteries don't count.
@YAJUN YUAN Jesus is in every Hail Mary. "...and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus"
"Hail" is a greeting not worship if that's what you were implying.
@@billyhw5492 I second that.
@YAJUN YUAN That's sorta like asking why God used Mary to become incarnate in the first place. I don't know, but he chose her to be His mother and that's significant.
There's nothing wrong with honoring the mother of Jesus. The hail Mary also commemorate the most important moment of salvation history, the incarnation.
@YAJUN YUAN why you're in every comments? Don't you have something else to do? Like.... Hm...
Hide in Woods just like your false prophet Ellen told you.. 😄 hide well, cos we're coming for you... Booo... 🤣🤣🤣
Sereda really quoting the Pharisees and thinking that hes cooking🤣 he really not paying attention to who is talking when he is reading lol
Excellent job on the rebuttal, thank you!! Very articulate and to the point!
7th day Adventist’s think everyone is an apostate....
Yes! It must be everyone else!
So do Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, and so on.
@@argelbargel7680 yup, ...
These two Mormons were trying to get me to go to their temple, I ended up explaining to them why Joseph smith is a false prophet.
@@RGTomoenage11 What amuses me about Mormons (aside from some ludicrous beliefs) is the claim about "Reformed Egyptian". No such thing has been proven to exist. That gibberish doesn't match ANY of the Egyptian writings or historical stages of the Egyptian language. And even if it were somehow legit (which it isn't), one single attestation would still make it suspicious and it would require solid proofs (which it lacks).
Thank you for making this rebuttal video, Mr. Horn. May God bless you & your ministry.
"There is not more than 100 people that hate the Catholic church, but there are Millions that hate what they think is the Catholic church." = Fulton J. Sheen (I hope I quoted it correctly). I miss Futlon J. Sheen.....
I'm not gonna lie, I sent Greg's video to Michael Lofton for a suggested comedy hour...
But I always admire Trent's willingness to deal with simple arguments seriously because those kinds of videos have a lot of views (such as Greg's). This video is exactly what a Greg viewer needs to see.
Check out the video made by hope trough prophecy "the antichrist 10 proofs from the bible"
It has more than 1 mil
It is about catholic church and pope
People fall for that one and i was one of them for some time
The truth will set us free thank for Trent the truth
Will you do some of these videos in regards to Jay Dyer's videos against the RCC?
That would be great, especially since he has a big following!
I think the Reason and Theology channel does a good job addressing Eastern Orthodox objections to Catholicism. Jay Dyer's brand of Orthodoxy isn't very representative of the rest and his knowledge of St. Thomas has been proven to be faulty in his debates with Classical Theist.
@@pokezeldamaster39 yes, Reason & Theology is a great channel!
Reason & Theology is taking care of that ❤️
Personally I'd say to let the R&T videos speak for themselves, rather than inviting that kind of drama
Keep the videos going my brother in Christ God bless love you in Catholic answers also🙏🙏🗝️🗝️⛪📖🛐💯 Catholic
This has been a Trent Horn day for me. Listened to the free for all Friday (creepy stuff). Now we got this epic rebuttal video. God Bless Trent.
Same
@Abi Brown Lol I can understand it. I think it’s just the way in which he speaks.
Another good video. Keep it up my man
Thanks for the great video, Trent!
Hail Mary means hello Mary. Or in Hebrew Shalom Miriam-peace be to you, Miriam. These are things I learned when I stopped listening to people like this and doing my own research 🧐
Amen! Me too, I also stopped listening to people like this, and ever since, my faith has not wavered. The more I listened to him, I more I notice he's just shouting.
As soon as I found out he's a Seventh Day Adventist, I don't listen to him anymore. When I was a Protestant, SDA are considered sort of cult, the belief is soul sleep confirms that, it reminds me of JW.
In the Jewish tradition, there's this asking the tzadikim for their intercession, which is like the intercession of the saints, most Protestants don't know this.
If "Hail Mary" is a blasphemous phrase, I'll go to hell with the angel Gabriel.
@@twopoles11 🙏🙏🙏
שָׁלוֹם לָךְ מִרְיָם, מְלֵאַת הָחֶסֶד, ה' עִמָךְ,
בְּרוּכָה אַתְ בַּנָּשִׁים, וּבָרוּךְ פְּרִי בִּטְנֵךְ - יֵשׁוּעַ.
מִרְיָם הַקְּדוֹשָׁה, אֵם הָאֱלֹהִים,
הִתְפַּלְלִי בַּעַדֵנוּ (וּבַעַדוֹ גְּרֶג סֶרֶדָה) הָחוֹטאִים
עַתָּה וּבִשְׁעַת מוֹתֵנוּ. אָמֵן
@@coldfusionmusical what’s that
God bless you Trent!
This Greg is dangerous, we need to pray for him
B A S E D
A N D. T R E N T P I L L E D
A miserable faith he describes... A father who loves his children would never be so far from them.
@Prasanth Thomas the one who's lying knowing the truth.
@Prasanth Thomas Trent is lying
@@karabuscemi217only God knows the truth in heart
Thank you Trent for your rebuttal. thank you for your work in protecting the church.
Thank you for all you do !!
Hi Trent, excellent rebuttal! Here is one for you that I saw recently: History Buffs: Agora, with over a million views about the killing of the female philosopher and scientist, Hypatia. He does historical analysis of films, but I find that there are some misconceptions of the early Church and its Fathers and apologists, such as St. Cyril of Alexandria and Tertullian; he also leaves out some information that sides with Cyril in the matter. Also, on the other hand, I do find it interesting that my books on the Church Fathers ( by Mike Aquilina and Pope Benedict XVI) that cover St. Cyril leave out his political struggle with the Prefect Orestes and the religious tension in the city. The film does take some liberties with the events and so does History Buff with his analysis; he tries not to pin any blame on the city's issues on Christians, Jews or Pagans as a whole, but he does try to link it you Cyril for the most part, as well as paint religion and science being at odds as well as a fallacy that the Christians destroyed the last vestiges of the Great Library, which I know are not true.