How Evil is Every GTA Protagonist - Ranking
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- Ranking how evil is every gta protagonist based on their actions, character development. featuring all the protagonist from gta, gta vice city, gta sand Andreas to gta 4 and gta 5.
Protagonists included:
1. Claude - GTA III
2. Tommy Vercetti - GTA Vice City
3. Carl "CJ" Johnson - GTA San Andreas
4. Toni Cipriani - GTA Liberty City Stories
5. Victor Vance - GTA Vice City Stories
6. Niko Bellic - GTA IV
7. Johnny Klebitz - GTA IV: The Lost and Damned
8. Luis Fernando Lopez - GTA IV: The Ballad of Gay Tony
9. Huang Lee - GTA: Chinatown Wars
10. Michael De Santa - GTA V
11. Franklin Clinton - GTA V
12. Trevor Philips - GTA V
The scary fact is, you can reason with Trevor more so than with Claude. Claude is a psychopath, no morals, no emotion, nothing.
He doesn't talk to me reasoned with anyway
(That's sad, anyway) meme 😆
He's literally devoid of emotions like a robot
@MuhammadShaariq well, actually, Salvatore Leone organized an ambush for him and wanted him dead. So it’s not strange that he killed him, and besides, he received a reward for it
Claude is more like no RAM, no CPU cycles, no Video Memory. This is why he is mute and emotionless.
For those who think CJ doesn't belong in the evil tier, don't you forget that he drowned a man and a woman who did nothing to him and begged for his mercy just to please that buster OG Loc. He killed a lot of construction workers, destroyed their property and brutally murdered their foreman by burying him in a portable toilet under concrete and it's all because they allegedly called his sister a "hooker".
Also, he ruthlessly murdered hotel valet to get his uniform, random turist to steal his camera, and a random "pleasure-slave" just to replace him, seduce the casino worker, who he also used to get the heist done - and all of that without even smallest sign of remorse.
The same thing can be said about Vic Vance, who basically slaughtered an entire military base just to steal a helicopter.
And even his own brother agrees that his sister dresses like a hooker
He did all these for a reason. It was for his brother, dead mother and father. Tommy did these for power and revenge.
Idk i feel like san andreas was just a much crazier game overall then most of the others purely based on his loyalty and the reasons why he did things I'd call him sometime evil to reach his goals.
Toni blew up a whole city block just so that his buddy could get a real estate deal. And for only 5000$.
Killed Rival gangs too hey i'm not rooting him xD i agree he is way out of line
@@ardibetrayal3493 Toni literally committed an act of terrorism, imagine how many people died, including kids.
@@artiomvv569 that's why i'm not rooting him xD c'mon man read, i wouldnt root the guy not even if u paid me he killed a guy because he is jealous for his ma that aint right, but The bomb is not entirely his idea if i remember correctly Donald told him to bomb it he is like Claude i think only in it for the money but again not defending him what he did to Casa is proof that he is the most evil
@@artiomvv569especially near an hospital, a campus and a stadium 😂
And Giovanni Casa 🎉
The Most Evil GTA Character ever is The PLAYER
YES!
Totally.
ONLINE player 💀
I agree but depending on the Player cause I've seen some kill with a Chain saw for Fun and my character he just does a lot of missions for money and doesn't care about anyone but himself he ain't No hero but he aint a Villain either
Especially the Griefer characters.
Toni Cipriani is the only character that killed probably +5000 innocent people on the explosion of a complete district.
1000 innocents
Which mission
@@Tunioo Bringing The House Down
I'd switch Niko and Johnny because Niko eventually realises that he should find something better than killing for money.
Niko probably has PTSD,he realized that he's man that can't live without war.Wherever he goes,violence always follows him.
@@vincemaranzano4197 if roman's emails to niko are real, then niko won't have to kill anyone lol
@@Krisyydalor idk I let roman die lol
@@kazcav it's easy to judge when you've not been in someone's shoes.
y know i mostly agree but i doubt he chose to be a soldier@@kazcav
Niko is the perfect antihero, not evil.
At least by gta standards.
BUT if it's was real life, *all of them would be the devil himself*
@@HighOnZanot necessarily. Any random rampages outside of missions is non canon for almost every character but trevor
@@HighOnZadude if it was real life Niko wouldnt be doing this shit
i have no idea how niko is more evil than Michael, it makes no sense lmao
he's a ruzzian, he is evil
Niko is definitely not evil. He is probably the least evil main GTA protagonist fundamentally. Unlike most other protagonists, Niko goes out of his way to do small and good deeds for close people and complete strangers, and he genuinly cares for people.
Sure, he did vile things during his time at the war, however it's very evident that he regrets his past, but still accepts it and the responsibility that comes with it.
Everything that Niko did ever since he came to LC was for other people, mostly Roman.
In a twisted way, Niko is one of the most selfless characters, not just protagonists, of the entire GTA universe.
he still did horrible things... one of which is him assisting a serial killer and driving him around the city to kill ppl.... Niko is not good by any means... he sure has those qualities but that doesn't make him a good person
@@godzillazfriction of course not, but, once again, most of the shit he did was aiding others. The only thing he did for himself was search for Florian and Darko, and, later, make a deal or kill Dimitri, and he (and the people around him) were punished both times.
@@godzillazfrictiondon't be silly, he didn't know about that guy being a serial killer
@@faridagasiyev7042 wow imagine for reporting my comment for bullying and harassment even though it was a simple 'g1fo' i replaced the 't' in there so i hope that you're happy
@@godzillazfriction the fuck you're talking about? İt is not very smart of you to accuse random people. İ didn't report anyone's comments.
A lot of people try to use Trevor never betraying anyone as a reason why he shouldn’t be placed in evil, but keep in mind that while that may be so, he does have a history with assaulting and even killing innocent people (he even does so in some of the scenes where you switch to him)
He also doesn't value loyalty as much as people think he does. He goes on and on about the value of loyalty specifically to Michael, but treats Wade and Ron-the two people most loyal to him-like garbage and is clearly keeping them in line through fear & intimidation.
Trevor is extremely coodependant, not loyal imo.
He either idealizes people to the extreme (like Patricia) or treats them like shit when they do something that he doen''t like or hurts him. The problem is that literally anything can make Trevor mad or hurt. Even the people that he is "nice" too, has to suffer from his sociopathic behavior from time to time. He literally tells Patricia that he is going to chop her in little pieces, and only likes her since she is literally a nicer version of his mom, but people take it as Trevor being "good".
I feel like he may have BPD or bipolar disorder, somerhing like that
@@baphomex668Yeah it's weird how people try Their hardest to find the good in an evil person but once a good person does something a little wrong they throw them under the bus.
Yes, he literally eats human flesh.
rip trevor Phillips
The most evil protagonist of GTA is that weird kid that locks himself in his room and shoots and runs over literally every NPC in the game.
What did you just f** say to me?? *micheal de santa, 2013, after finding a huge piece of w*
That's what Trevor was, a reflection of the most dangerous GTA player
Vic and Niko are definitely the most moral characters in the entire GTA franchise. CJ is somewhere between anti hero and evil sometimes, while Michael is simply evil.
Vic is not a good guy. He could leave criminal world alone but he never did that and I hate how people thinks that Vic is so good guy because he protects Louise. Louise is toxic person as well.
And Niko kills people for money without any remorse.
@@starlaixystar have you played the game? There's a cutscene in which Niko talks with Mikhail's wife and he feels uncomfortable talking about his time during the war. Moreover there many random encounters when Niko helps strangers. When he kills the Albanian mobsters who harass Roman, Niko says: "I promised not to kill anyone here". And even if you choose to kill Darko, you'll hear Niko complaining how revenge didn't fill the the empty hole in his soul.
@@starlaixystar wrong. There many moments where Vic wants to run away from all the trouble but because of Lance's dumb moves he has to step in to protect his dear ones.
@@TheGreyPeregrine But he kills Ray just because he dislikes him and because Jimmy told him to do it. What he says is not important when his actions says otherwise and by the way I don't really care about boring female characters from Rockstar Games. And definitely I don't care about Kate who is toxic idealist and Niko was enough stupid to feel in love with her.
Claude is kinda like Michael Myers in a way. Doesn’t say a word and emotionless, doesn’t have morals what so ever. He’s evil incarnate.
Evil because he killed other scumbags? Get outta here
@@malletUsergaming you really must be insane defending a psychotic ,heartless killing machine like claude who would sell you without hesitation...
@user-lx4qn7mt8m all he ever did was kill other criminal scum? How does it make him psychotic and a heartless killing machine? You may as well call every silent protagonist a psyco lmao
@@malletUsergaming by that logic even michael myers is a good guy even if he kills children just because of that "slient protagonist" trophe ?
And if claude is innocent then every other gta and manhunt protagonists are innocent then by this logic.
@user-lx4qn7mt8m Hello, when did I ever say claude was innocent? He is a crimina like no shit of course he is bad, but stop making out his silence to be anything more than the idea that he is nothing more than a silent protagonist that a player can project themselves into, he isn't psychotic or heartless like your so desperately making him out to be as a whole so get over it lmao, plus play the game, I don't remember him ever killing for the heck or killing children so you bullshit you tried bringing up about Michael Myers doesn't even compare. Why you so upset about me defending a character that can't even defend themselves lol.
What bothers me most about Claude is the fact that you think he's making new friends and in the end he betrays them or doesn't feel any sadness about their deaths.
Especially when he killed Asuka's brother without hesitation... Even if she trusted in him and even was flirting with him in some of her missions. Besides, let's not forget when Claude cared less about her death.
@@otavianiluciano7397and even the potential implications of shooting Maria at the end of the game (I very much don’t think he did but they’ve left it in the air), Claude very much is the clear psychopath of the bunch
@@jonathanasencio9061 I believe he did. He found her annoying and capped her to cut all ties. Psychopathic drifter mentality.
@@jomckellanSame. She’s the only witness left too so him shooting her allows for Claude to cut his losses and go somewhere else and hide. I personally don’t see how people think he didn’t kill Maria you literally hear the gunshot and if he shot the air Maria would scream and start yapping even louder at Claude for doing that, instead it’s immediately followed by silence
@@josephstalin2606hey, my hand can't do all the work u know
I don’t get why people hate on Claude for not speaking. He’s just like our gta online characters
EXACTLY 😂😂
Cuz he's meamt to be an established character and not a customizable mannequin.
@@magicfish8213 so hate on our gta online characters too their exactly the same
@@Lessferr i do hate the online characters
1. Claude. I think even Trevor would be freaked out by this guy.
2. Toni. He literally committed terrorism to help out a guy he wasn't that friendly with to begin with. Though he was sympathetic towards Toshiko and being loyal to Salvatore and his mother but his actions in the game were often pretty vile.
3. Tommy. He only cares about himself, doesn't have much sympathy for anyone. Got rid of Rosenberg at the end of the game the guy who always defended him, helped start a war between the Haitians and Cubans for cheap change, also committed terrorism 2 times in the mall and the 1st biker mission which is a rampage.
4. Trevor. Even when he is in a "good" mood, he is only inches away from killing you. Has no respect for anyone other than Michael and his family, mistreats his real friends, has no problem torturing people for reasons he doesn't understand and his only redeeming quality is when he "defended" Tracy's dignity.
5. Michael. He is like a downgraded version of Tommy so he is less sociopathic... probably because he has a family but shares similar traits to him.
The others I don't really consider them evil at all. They had evil actions as expected in a GTA game but a lot of times it felt as a justified answer to what was happening in these games. I don't know how you can put Niko that high tbh.
I don't agree with your pov of Tommy. He doesn't cares only about himself, since he actually cared about Lance. He saved his butts multiple times and he was even sad after he killed him for his betrayal.
@@SupraSwordNot to mention he got rid of Rosenberg because he was a coke addict who proved to be a liability for business. No businessman wants that for a partner.
There already was a war between the haitians and cubans
Yea, and Tommy got rid of Rosenberg, sure but only because Rosenberg had a drug problem, he's a very reasonable boss as well, he yelled at lance because lance fucked up and lance got bitchy, so he said that if he ever fucks he can lay into him any time.
Tommy feels hurt when lance betrays him, the old man from the printing factory is like a father to him, when the old man gets hurt, Tommy is in rage.
And with the bomb in the mall, Tommy didn't start it, the boys did, he just had to end it because otherwise the cops would be after his ass.
Also about the gang war, he was always on the side of the cubans, if you haven't forgotten, auntie polet drugged him and made him do that stuff
Tommy is loyal. Don't touch my tommy
Claude used to be a good guy back in San Andreas. He was literally just some drifter who owned a garage and worked on vehicles. Because of a decade long relationship with Catalina, he is now the way he is 😥
No Claude was born evil
@@carreviewer6345Watch out he is saying this because he is the Claud speed
@MuhammadShaariq Exactly. If it wasn't for her, he'd be a better person
We actually don't know whether Claude's deeds were evil or not before the events of SA. Sure, we know he owned a garage in San Fierro, but what could we possibly know about what kind of activities he was involved in? We meet him in an illegal street race, after all...
@@Jack-md9bk Claude had gotten a lot worse than he already was. If catalina hadn't been there, he would've changed. Not being naive, just positive for the good
Toni went into a room, ambushed by 6 to 7 men with chainsaws and toni was the only one leaving the room alive.
6-7.. more like 20
@@deionhercule7097 Same thing happened to Tommy Vercitti that is why they called the Hardwood butcher
Wdym 6-7? There was way more, it was probably like 40 or something
Isn't that in Mission called The Portland Chainsaw Massacre?
I did remember Toni defeated some Vincenzo Cilli's Leones with chainsaw, later he killed Vinnie.
@@JackTheOfficeWorkerYeppers!!!
Toni still has some standards and respect that makes him admirable.He helped and felt bad about Toshiko for being stuck in an abusive and toxic relationship,he literally feel disgusted when Vincenzo phoned his mom while getting a blowjob at the same time and he's always been mistreated by his mother.
Claude however,is a straight up killer.He has no empathy whatsoever.He's a literal killing machine.
I mean, even Claude willingly walked into certain death and gave Catalina a lot of money to rescue Maria, so he must feel something with her.
Toni is a very evil you understand better because he talks. He is definitively twisted because he follows and respects a mafia code and his family thinking that sort of respect is what matters and the heinous stuff he does is just business and not a big deal.
Even someone like Vic Vance is very evil when we adhere to what we would realistically think about him if he was real and not fictional
@@GoofyCook He doesn't feel anything or even care about Maria lol.He gave those money to Catalina to lure her out so he can get a chance to ice her once and for all.The money was for revenge,not rescue.
In the end credits,you'll hear Maria and Claude being interviewed but seconds later,there's a gunshot that shut her up.Some people believed that it was Claude who killed Maria to cut off loose ends.
@@vincemaranzano4197 for some reason, that didn't actually count as a kill since the gun sound was a mistake of accident, we don't even see her body nor Claude killing Maria
@@vincemaranzano4197lol stop making stuff up if we have no idea what happened
Toni still has standards? The guy blew up an entire district for 5000 dollars killing tens of thousands of people. And thats just 1 event.
Claude is the definition of “he has no rules no boundaries he doesn’t flinch at torture human trafficking or genocide he’s not loyal to a flag or any set of ideals he trades blood for money” and this is why he is my gta online characters father lol I know some people choose Niko but I feel like Niko wouldn’t let his kid become a criminal Claude meanwhile would cheer his son or daughter every step of the way
I think the most cold-blooded and insane of all the protagonists is Claude. He is constantly silent, he agrees to any dirty work without understanding who is “good” and who is “bad”, how this will affect the relationship between him and other people, he works for all sides at once, before the events of GTA 3 all he did was kill, steal, broke the law and robbed banks, he can betray at any moment if it is beneficial to him or simply because someone raised tone at him, as was the case with Kenji, he felt disrespect for himself and then he believes that even such high-ranking personalities are obliged to respect him like yakuza bosses and be more "respectful". He doesn't care if he's being hunted all the time.
Of course, he is not without emotions and can understand who his ally is and perhaps treats someone warmly. But still, his emotions are often his grin, he constantly shows the fak finger when he is almost knocked down by car. He is always more than calm in critical situations.
Simply put, Trevor says this with humor, but there is a hint in it. Trevor, this is kind of a true hipster and a parody of what maniacs want to be seen as. Claude is what psychopath really are, without clowning, excessive grotesqueries and fetishes. Pure indifference and callousness. At the same time, Claude is a naive, everyone betrays him and wants to kill him. He agrees to absolutely anything and it was some kind of stupidity of the villains or luck that saved him more than once, not his mind. Most likely, because of some kind of psychiatric problems he is who he is. He is a man: “I see the goal - I don’t see the obstacles.”
Trevor is misunderstood. He never betrayed Michael despite all that he did to Trevor. He also saved Franklin and Lamar from being scammed by Ballas. Trevor is also not a psychopath by definition because we clearly saw that he loved Patricia.
Trevor betrayed Michael in Bury the hatchet
@@catweird. If that were true then Ending C wouldn't be canon.
And Trevor is cannibalism
Trevor may not be a physcopath, but I feel he’s a sociopath.
Trevor is more bloodthirsty than Michael and kills people needlessly. In the north Yankton robbery at the beginning of the game Trevor kills a security guard that grabs hold of Michael and Michael tells him he didn't have to do that. After robbing the gold bank near the end of the game Trevor is about to kill one of the security guards but Michael stops him and instead bribes the guard. Michael kills people as well, but he only does so when they get in his way or when ordered to do so. Trevor kills people simply because he wants to.
Trevor commits some of the most heinous crimes out of all the gta protagonists, but he’s not pure evil. He actually spares Mr K after being told to kill him by the FIB.
And even though he kidnapped Patricia, he still treats her with respect and makes sure Martin Madrazo takes care of her instead of treating her like rubbish. Trevor also takes out the border patrol guys because he sees how they ruined someone’s life.
Yeah, I honestly feel like Trevor took Patricia, not to get back to Martin, but to save her from him
Let's not forget about his mother. He still cared for her as well but when he comes back with the pills. She gone. Then he gos on his knees and yells mama! It was so sad
I think he hated the FIB more than that person they told him to kill, so it was just a way to stick it to Da Man™️, rather than the desire to be good.
He also sees how debra treated Floyd like shit and kills her
you guys are overrating Trevor to have some 'misunderstanding' to him even though he r3pes, eats and is uniquely able to kidnap ppl who need a ride to be eaten by the altruist cult who Trevor probably joins in at times since he eats ppl...
1st of all, the FIB agent didn't necessary or directly say to kill him... he suggested killing but then said do whatever...
Trevor doesn't like being told what to do and especially when the government tells him to do so...
he didn't spare Mr. K out of compassion towards him because the dialogue doesn't suggest it either elsewell...
Trevor took A LOT of enjoyment when torturing Mr. K and you can see him sadistically smiling when charging up the electrical wires for example...
and i doubt that Trevor took out some border patrol guys for ruining a guys life although i dont even know what bit in the story or side quest you're mentioning here...
Bro, Niko helped a lot of people in strange people like Marnie who was a homeless
That's why he isn't devil himself
@@avenautit doesn’t make evil bruh, this list is mid and this opinion, most of these guys aren’t even evil except Trevor, claude
@@its_joshua_14tony is more evil
@@target9180 nobody asked you
Ah yes he's helping women. What a good guy. Helps women. Kills most males in his way.
I feel like Niko wasn’t all that bad. It’s all based off a true story off the movie “Behind Enemy Lines” and the game’s info and storyline is from that movie. Niko did everything for a reason so I feel he should have been in an Anti hero category. 😊🙂
Selling people isn’t antiheroic
Niko's story is also based on the the Russian movie, _Brother_ (1997), which is about a soldier who went to St. Petersburg to help his older brother, who happened to be the gangster in that city that puts his young brother into the life of crime.
Not only does Claude never say a word but he also never shows any emotion whatsoever. Even when he appears with Catalina in San Andreas he was still the same way. The fact that Rockstar was able to build a whole storyline around this guy is remarkable
Niko Bellic is definitely more of an anti-hero. He was the ultimate product of his circumstances and he's more like Scarface than any other GTA character. CJ is also like an antihero as well. We already knew Trevor was a menace himself, Tommy is definitely evil and so is Toni Cipriani but to me the most evil GTA character is Claude... Claude is like Michael Myers. He isn't going to beckon or break. Once you cross him, he's vengeful and he won't forget. Plus him being a mute adds to his psychopathic nature perfectly.
Niko I can see some arguments but CJ he is fuckin evil . Just because he cares for his family and friends doesn't make him any less evil.
Cj killed people without remorse remember he screwed over Madd Dogg and only really helped him because he was there then he uses the guy as business venture he was only lucky og loc didn't snitch
Gta 2 Claude is the most devil himself character because in one mission he made humans into hot dog
Claude is the original GTA protagonist. In GTA 1,2 and 3. Each game taking place the year they were released. The first one taking place the The year it was made 1997. The second one taking place the year it was made 1999. And the 3rd one taking place the year it was made 2001. They all took place in the original GTA location Liberty City. Vice City and San Andreas both being prequels of the original 3 but with different protagonists and in different locations.
Toni cut up that one guy and delivered the meat to rhe butcher shop
Dude, Claude smiling during the cutscene just made my face in tears 😹
😂😂😂
*reads the letter*
"Hmm, Time to prepare my next lunch.", Claude thought to himself, grinning ear to ear.
Lol 4:40
Excuse me? Niko evil and Michael anti hero?
ahem, the mission “i’ll take her” absolutely puts him on that teir
Michaels ranking is justified, like yeah he betrayed Trevor and brad but it was either them or his family. Michael only returned to crime because he had to not because he’s some evil psychopath and loves to cause havoc
Claude: basically a mute human Terminator
Tommy: hungry for money and power
CJ: has done crazy sh*t, but he's loyal to his family and friends
Toni: Monster!
Victor: not a bad guy just had bad luck
Niko: A broken man who just wanted peace
Johnny: a criminal with moral codes
Luis: a tough guy with short temper
Franklin: homeboy
Michael: a former criminal who seeks redemption
Trevor: a terrifying psychopath but honest and loyal.
The mission where CJ straight up buries a dude in concrete made me very uncomfortable. Pure evil thing to do.
Yeah that's fucked up, but on WCTR you can hear that he survived after the mission.
Niko should have been an anti hero because he had to do all those bad things because of the war
Facts
After the war, Niko couldn't find a job so he had to do jobs for Ray Bulgarin like smuggling and selling people.
@@JuriSinseven in the game, he still does very bad things, one of which is him assisting a serial killer and driving him around the city to kill ppl
@@godzillazfrictionhe didn't even know he is a serial killer
@@godzillazfriction Eventually he kills him when he finds out he's a serial killer/rapist as well as the fact he attacked him.
As a guy who's interested in dnd alignment chart system, this is how I interpret
CJ is a textbook of Lawful Evil protagonist; he holds strict standard against drugs, devoted to his family and owns a several of legal businesses, but he also often did extremely heinous things, willing to eliminate everyone who betrayed him and get in his way, made his gang powerful and dominate Los Santos, took over the territories, rules Los Santos' underworld pretty much like a tyrant, has some machiavellian moments, and did some questionable things for his profits such as killing an innocent hotel valet to steal his uniform and career, and lied to Madd Dogg that OG Loc was the only one who ruined his life and career, then he becomes Madd Dogg's manager and his mansion becomes ones of his properties.
Claude is a textbook of Neutral Evil protagonist; he's completely cold, emotionless, opportunistic, willing to use any mean to get high paid and to pursue his revenge, and seems doesn't care about anyone much.
Trevor is a textbook of Chaotic Evil protagonist; he's a cannibal, unstable, impulsive, prone to be extremely violent when being angry or provoked, willing to torture the enemies and victims for fun, often did random and shameless things. Despite he has tough and broken childhood, and want true love.
You can choose to kill the valet guy, you can always knock him out
says that when CJ even bothered to save Denise when he burned the goddamn house, killing Valet is more unecessary as the game didn't have knock out mechanic like gta 5, beside you can choose between hit him barehand or use baseball bat or any staff weapon like as a hit instead of a bullet in a head or a knife, just becuz the game told you to kill him doesn't mean he has to, the same as those people the game told you to kill cuz they have camera for casino heist when only one of them have it
Cj had to work for many people just to free his brother, he blamed himself for killing his best friends, he tried so hard to please his brother after coming back to grove, cj has heart so I don't think he's pure evil
N.b: Iam aware of that one time he killed innocent people just for insulting his sister, but other than that he has good intentions.
@@Funkadelic_Zach4579 He's not pure evil but still evil and bad, and nothing really justify for all of the crimes he committed, killing a thousands including some innocents and some people who don't deserve to die. CJ has the most number of misdeeds and crimes in GTA series. CJ is not a Robin Hood just because he has some good intentions, other GTA protagonists also have some redeeming qualities and good intentions, some have more than he has. And I'd say Trevor arguably has more heart and emotions, even Michael betrayed him, he doesn't willing to kill him directly, and he spared more victims.
Claude is the Micheal Myers of the GTA series.
Trevor is a definiton of a gta player getting bored
Completelly agree with Claude being in Devil Himself tier. Also note that Claude seems to take pleasure making CJ incomfortable in "Farewell my love".
CJ called catalina a bitch right after he walked up.
He was a good and calm guy in san andreas. If he was evil, he would've killed cj for insulting catalina
@@mr.buttler1649 He wouldn't have had a reason to kill CJ in San Andreas, he was still the same evil person
All gta protagonists have killed and robbed countless innocent people and by extension probably ruined the lives of just as many. All of them are plain and simple evil.
Damn you are straight up cold. I like that
@@avenaut thanks bro
You are true for the most part, however, I would mark Michael and Nico as characters a bit more understandable. Nico had to get into crime due to his lack of choices, he had fought in a war in his homeland, and his only choice was to go abroad (USA) where he was a severely mistreated immigrant who couldn't get a job and also had PTSD from war. Michael never liked his lifestyle, you can see it throughout GTA V. He pushes Franklin to get out of crime, go to college, etc. At least he ends up being a movie director with a happy family as we see in GTA Online.
@@AhilleasAiefants oh yeah I'm not saying some of these characters don't have somewhat understandable reasons for their actions, but even so those actions are no less evil in my opinion.
You have an interesting perspective honestly. Completely stripping away all the bias protagonists get
I would put Luis and Vic in the Good tier. Vic didn’t even wanna be a criminal, and Luis made it perfectly clear that he wants nothing to do with that life anymore. He only does what he does in the game because of Rocco. And I’d put CJ in Evil sometimes. No doubt he’s done some terrible things, but he’s done a lot of good things too. He risked his life to save Denise. No one told him to do it, and nor was he paid to. That’s honestly the most selfless thing I’ve seen a GTA protagonist do. Lastly, I’d put Niko in Antihero I guess. Niko’s done some bad things, but I wouldn’t call him evil. He even wanted to abandon his life of crime at the end of the game.
To be fair about CJ it was him who start the fire in the house Denise was stuck
Dude, Vic basically slaughtered an entire military base to steal a helicopter. He's definitly not a nice guy.
@@faresfares-ultrawho was forced by Tenpenny to do it.
@@otavianiluciano7397 None of the protagonists are “nice guys” but as far as GTA characters go, killing a few soldiers and stealing a helicopter is fairly tame
Agree with all those changes
I like to think johnny aint dead and he just respawned back in liberty city at one of the hospitals
Johnny and Vic both are my most favourite gta protagonists.
But both died in tragic way 😢😭
No, he is permanently wasted
We all wish that was the case, but cutsceen deaths are cannon brotha
Thanks for getting straight to the points you wanted to make instead of prolonging the video past 10 minutes
Niko is at most Evil sometimes. He never wanted to be a criminal or hurt people. He came to America to get away from the death. If Roman were rich like he said, Niko would have driven a cab and lived a quiet life.
“He never wanted to be a criminal or hurt people. He came to America to get away from the death.”
What game did you play?
He starts his life crime after the war, gets arrested, then chooses to continue crime under Bulgarian. And no he did not come to America to get away from death, it’s the opposite . Half of the story is about niko killing who he has to to fuel his revenge
@@Jazz_Jacob Yeah but he didn't want to kill anyone else except the guy who betrailed his unit in the war. Niko also came to America because of the storys from Roman. Honestly it was Roman and his debts to the loan sharks and the russians that forced Niko back into his life of crime. There's even a mission, where he has to chase and kill one the loan sharks. You can see in this mission how pissed he was, because he wanted to leave the killing behind.
Ok you can still argue that his lust for revenge would also push him back into his criminal life, but that's another story.
@@Ralle-kv8rm “Yeah but he didn’t want to kill anyone else except the guy who betrayed his unit in the war” That sure stopped him from killing tons of people didn’t it?
And I know he also came to America because of Roman’s stories, that was the one reason OP didn’t forget to mention
@@Jazz_Jacob Niko only starts committing crime for Roman, then he starts doing it for money, because it's what he's good at and can't legally get a legitimate job. Again, he doesn't want to kill anyone, except a few people who wronged him and his family. He did come to America to get away from death. He literally states that in the game.
Vic Vance deserved to be in the good guy tier tbh. Everything he tried to do was for the people he cared about, hell even hesitating and questioning the morals of doing wrong things but still had to if it meant for getting money for his family like his brother with asthma.
Michael does deserve the anti hero rank. Sure he tried to kill Trevor but it was because he wants to raise his family in a place away from all the crime, although he is not an honest guy and sugarcoats a lot of things but deep down most of his intentions whether if it was for his family, friends or himself, was good.
Niko's character was molded by the tragedies he went through in his younger years, including the war where he saw his friends, family and people get killed. He never really had a choice in a lot of things or opportunities to start his life again so he resorted to being a hitman just for money. But in some of those missions he has a choice to spare people and that factors into his morality being questioned. I think anti-hero fits him.
I think Tommy Vercetti is borderline devil tier tbh. He can be pretty aggressive, will do anything to climb up the ranks and did a lot of bad things. At the same time he is a loyal character but he cares about getting bigger more.
Well CJ also does everything to people he cares about that and Louise and Lance are not good people.
@@starlaixystarCJ always opted the dark and evil route to punish innocent people like the construction site workers.
Vic never did such maniac things he killed people who were actually evil like marty.
You could always tell that Vic would reluctantly take on missions only if he knew that it would give him the money he needs to help his family
@@samyakmeshram3286 Louise is also evil. End of story.
Agree
Micheal being an anti hero has got to be a joke
Explain. Curious to hear your opinion
@@avenaut if you listen to Trevor’s story about him and Micheal when they were little you can see that Micheal was always a criminal, and actually he was the one who persuaded Trevor to join him then he didn’t try to ‘retire’ out of the goodness of his heart he was scared he’ll get caught eventually, furthermore Micheal has no problem killing/betraying his childhood best friend for his own interest and putting the other in jail , he doesn’t have a single redeeming quality,he does everything for his own gain, he might not be as psycho as Trevor but he’s definitely evil.
@@nimadadelahi8083I'd say a redeeming quality of his is his family. Yeah they had a rough start when we first saw them but he still cared about em
@@nimadadelahi8083And also Michael never understand that his problems are his own fault.
Michael has good reasons to betray Trevor and tried to have him killed. Michael want to quite a criminal life and be a family man with normal career instead but the financial issues made him return to be a criminal and mass murderer once more time.
Huang lee ranking is correct he is probably the nicest GTA protagonist also gta Chinatown wars is really underrated
AI-generated content
That explains why this list makes no sense whatsoever at some points
People have opinions, And try actually looking at "Ai generated content"
@@G.h.o.s.t-mi2dc People have opinions and AI does not. What is your point?
@@Stonezorz Where's the proof of this being Ai?
@@G.h.o.s.t-mi2dc You didn't notice the blatantly uncanny method of speaking that immediately starts at the beginning of the video? That is not a natural way of speaking, it is an artificial pattern that most AI of that time also used. Recognize it once and you'll notice all AI of that generation doing the exact same thing.
Beyond that, there are wildly incorrect statements being made throughout the video. This is another sign of it being AI-generated as in misinterprets the information it looks up in order to generate its spoken text. Anyone that either knows the games by having played them or has looked up the information themselves would know that at numerous points this AI states factually incorrect information that does not add to any conversation about the subject, it only detracts.
After the second mistake the AI made I rewound the video and closely listened to the aforementioned speech pattern to confirm that it is, in fact, lazily AI-generated content where the uploaders did not even bother to fact-check their own content.
This video only serves to bait clicks for views and discussions in the comments, which it has succeeded at spectacularly.
Actually the most evil GTA Character isn't even listed here, it's none other then the GTA Online Protagonist..
I’d put Michael in Evil Sometimes. This is a guy who ruined his family and even after retirement, still did some pretty crazy shit. Amanda says it like it’s so casual that it doesn’t even phase her super much anymore that Michael keeps killing people and then sits in the sun feeling guilty about it. Although Michael did go on to regret a lot of his choices, such as how he spent decades murdering people for money and robbing from others just to support his family and himself, he never truly lost that love for chaos. He’s a thrill seeker that enjoys chaos but doesn’t necessarily seek it. There’s also that messy betrayal back in North Yankton. Although Michael never wanted to betray Trevor, he did it out of a necessity. But at the same time, it also shows that Michael doesn’t really understand Trevor. If he just had a emotional chat with his feelings, Trevor would honestly understand Michael’s perspective and then maybe their relationship wouldn’t have been hugely strained the majority of V. There’s also that Michael was pretty fucking terrifying, perhaps even worse than Trevor before he had kids. Don’t get me wrong, Michael is a maniac but the guy has better standards than Trevor and he actually regrets his decisions and actually attempts to change himself and his life. He’s worse than Franklin though.
Michael is a manipulative psychopath who uses and abuses people with manipulation and pure selfish behaviour. He is the only GTA V protagonist who never does things that don't directly benefit him. He is Evil tier
@@Mathias.HansenI’d consider Trevor more of a Sociopath, since he’s definitely deranged and crazy, but he does show affection like with Patricia and his mom, and even Michael.
I’d definitely agree with Michael though. I feel like Michael is over hated because of the whole North Yankton thing, but let’s be real. I feel like most people would have done the same thing if given the opportunity. Michael says it himself. “When your legs just give, and you just can’t run anymore”
The thing is, Michael enjoys the criminal life. He talks about this with Dr. Friedlander, how he loves his family and doesn't wanna endanger them, but also loves the killing and stealing. His first heist after decades made him feel alive again and robbing the union depository still was his dream, so much that after his family got attacked by mercenaries by order of Devin Weston, his next decision is to start the Heist instead of not endangering his family any further. He enjoys the thrill and when he doesn't get it, he spirals down into depression.
Not to mention he also snaps occasionally like Trevor, though he can contain himself better. Also he tries to spare people when he can, like the cop in the Prolog, another cop in the final heist stealth approach, Devin Westons assistant, the tennis coach and Lazlow. So I'd say, an Anti-Hero it's the best description for him. It's also arguable if he's more evil than Franklin, who killed several people to manipulate the stock for Lester
Idk if Trevor belongs at the very top of the list.
Trevor is also pretty loyal as long as you don’t cross him. He’s crazy and has done a lot of bad things but he looked out for Frank and Lamar during their drug deal in the story and he was down with Michael until he found out the truth and realized he couldn’t trust him, which made him even more paranoid.
He also had feelings for some people, so he isn’t a complete psychopath.
there's always exceptions with Trevor that makes him hypocritical and i dont know why ppl don't see this regarding Trevor in the story... he somewhat belittles Wade for calling Ashley a b1tch but if i remember right, Trevor still called Ashley a b1tch but i might be misremembering things there however, Trevor did say 'b1tch wife' when Wade was supposed to find out where Michael Townley is and his 'b1tch wife' - Trevor is somewhat hypocritical especially when it comes to loyalty because he did say that he never liked Brad anyway even after he found out that Brad was dead... Trevor just doesn't like being lied to and you can see how that took an affect on him probably because of his mother who was a cheat and was constantly having s3x
@@godzillazfriction Yeah, trevor's 'loyalty' is bullshit given he treats Wade, Floyd, and Ron like crap, even though they work hard and don't even get paid for it
Trevor r*ped and slaughtered a couple in their home, for no reason, no reason at all.
Same can be said about Toni, he’s completely devoted to Sal and his mother. The difference is that Toni doesn’t torture people or kill them or eat them in his spare time for fun. Trevor is still a deranged human and his emotions overcome him which makes him even more unstable and dangerous even to his friends
He's got meth-head morals. He might mean well *occasionally* but its filtered through what would almost certainly be diagnosed as a serious antiscocial personality disorder. And I've known people like that, and yeah some of those folks are loyal as hell, but that doesnt mean they wont kill a man just to see them die. Trevs just not too bright. He's the criminal that ends up in supermax, not the criminal that ends up in a mansion.
Tommy should have been up there as the devil himself. he became a feared kingpin in vice city after killing thousands of people and even kicked down people in his own social circle when they were deemed a liability to him. Even Trevor still has a heart to those he cares about, but Tommy is cold-hearted and calculated.
He also went postal after the biker gang leader told him to stick it to the man. He indiscriminately killed who knows many civilians just to let some rage out. The cutscene before the mission made it apparent he was pumped about it as well.
Niko should have been antihero
Trevor deserves absolutely no sympathy, he's an unhinged maniac. Tommy is a pretty typical gangster.
"even kicked down people in his own social circle when they were deemed a liability to him." You mean Ken? He was a liability, he was a cokehead and wasn't much good in the first place, besides, he sent him to rehab.
Tommy Vercetti The King Of Vice City
Exactly. Imagine how many people’s lives were ruined by Tommy’s drug operations over the years. Even though Vic does deal in drugs, his drug operations ended very quickly despite being very successful. Unlike Luis, Armando, Henrique, Trevor and others who sell drugs, Tommy is a drug baron, meaning he is the main supplier and most powerful drug dealer in his area, doubling the amount of people who can get hurt by his drugs. Tommy just doesn’t care as long as it makes him money. In that sense, he’s no better than Sonny, as Tommy too dishonours the Mafia code by selling drugs, despite allegedly believing in “honour among thieves.” Tommy is very much a psychopath and has very few lines separating him from Sonny. He won’t betray his friends, but he’s also extremely selfish and narcissistic. He abandoned his best friend and left him for dead in the desert. That alone proves just how selfish Tommy is. Tommy definitely deserves to be on Devil Himself.
Michael throughout the whole game clearly shows that he hates when people get hurt or harmed for no reason or where he can avoid it. In most heists he’s the most passive to hostages and you’ll see it a lot
Yes, he really feels bad about their treatment of Mr. K and even gets upset and says "Hey, I promised him they wouldn't hurt him."
Michael is actually a very misunderstood character by the GTA community.
To me, theres 7 levels when I wanna define a characters moral stance by the plot:
- Straight Evil
- Villainous
- Anti-Villain
- Neutral / Survivor
- Anti-Hero
- Heroic
- A Real Sunshine
Claude Speed from GTA 2 should be above Trevor and Claude from GTA 3. He hijacked a bus full of innocent people and turned them into hot dogs😂. That is some devil shit.
Dead ass they cut the mission Trevor aint on that wicked shit like claude btw your wrong there was kids on the bus😭🙏🏽👿
Niko Bellic is literally just a normal good soldier with heavy PTSD, that's what war does to a man.
Trevor and Claude are my favorite GTA characters, especially Claude, he never speaks just shoots
Yeah lol
Claude is the definition of a psycho killer. Im sure he enjoyed doing all that stuff
I genuinely believe Niko is the most good a GTA protagonist could be. Something to note too is how often he is given choices, and just like Arthur Morgan, I choose the moral of the two because why would it be an option to go against instructions unless that’s characters moral compass speaking. As far as I’m recalling, the only GTA character to be given options at that. Plus there’s the little things that are 100% cannon and not just interpretation; saving that heroin addict for example.
Yeah you can choose to save like 3 people when you go on to kill dozens more for money. He is evil lol.
>notices Ai voice
>dislikes the video and leaves
I'd put Trevor at evil because he had a tough childhood that caused him to act like a maniac and also because he can still be good sometimes
He's not evil, he's misunderstood, in terms of loyalty, he can't go into evil at all
@@i0x37he’s more broken than evil ngl
Trevor is evil
@@yxrackman2397 we do live in a society
Trevor just has a bad entourage and had a rough childhood, Patricia is the only person who understands him
4:44 the smile😭
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He had too
Bro it's frickin' cursed
Toni and Claude are literally the definition of psychopath, they remind of Anton Chigurh with their lack of emotion and no moral struggle. While Trevor is undeniably insane, Toni is the worst, he literally blew up a part of the city because he was ordered to do so
Claude is by far worse than Toni. Claude would have done even worse with the right incentive and then clipped the guy who gave him the job, while Toni is at least a loyal man who will not betray others.
@@holypaladin4657 And understandbly both met with each others and caused the another 'Great War' in Liberty City directly and indirectly. Also both didnt clip each others.
Niko Bellic isn't evil, he's 100% anti-hero.
He ALWAYS does things for others, not for himself.
The most evil protagonist : Toni Cipriani, Claude, Trevor.
The most good protagonist : Franklin, Victor Vance, Huang Lee.
Trevor goes into Evil imo
Niko Bellic should be in the Anti Hero category
Claude’s silence is terrifying.
Same with our gta online protagonist
Like micheal myers
It's worth noting that Claude openly threatened CJ with violence and then clearly took humor from CJ obviously getting off put by it. So if nothing else is to be said it's that he has no problem with being imposing.
He only walked up to CJ. Cj welcomed violence and insulted Catalina in front of Claude.
CJ would dog walk Claude. I think even Claude knew that so he backed away
CJ wanted to kill Claude after he sold him that bs garbage CJ would dog walk him
great vid , I think people are recognizing that good videos are better than putting in filler for that 10 minute mark
1:37 nice gun handling
Thought you would include the Online Protagonist, that guy is a real deal supervillain, pits of Hell level Devil.
They have massive amounts of weapons to casually cause mass destruction all over San Andreas, kill relentlessly to the point where even the other characters that have committed or involved with homicide are concerned of the amount of murders they commit, all with a straight face. There are even events in the game where they compete in destroying property like cars or getting headshots on others, meaning they do this for fun. They run many operations for illegal activities, and commit numerous amounts of heist, robbing others of important stuff, and even robbed a man’s island so many times, they literally drove him insane. Their actions are why Lester never invited them to the story mode’s heists. Hell, in comparison to the main three from V, who can get arrested with 1-2 stars, the police opt to shoot to kill when it comes to the online protagonist, meaning he’s so dangerous, the concept of taking him in alive doesn’t exist.
They are so dangerous, Online removes animals from the Story Mode, pairs them only with other psychopaths like themselves, and the only people that they don’t kill are the people that pay them, indicating their greed.
ehhhhhh not really... the online protagonist is notably scared of Trevor Philips...
plus the online protagonist as well as others would get obliterated by The Boss aka playa from Saints Row
They also saved the world some times
The GTA V online protagonist could be good too though. My second created character is just a taxi driver and mere meth dealer on the side.
I would kill KJD or Sessanta... When they get together they're completely unbearable and KJD is a dick in general.
Don’t forget Franklin single-handedly investigate and return justice for Leonora Johnson. Basically he’s a good person caught up in the criminal world, that’s why he’s “evil sometimes”.
Highkey love Claude because even out of the Devil Himself category, he IS the Devil himself. Like not only did he betray most of the gangs in the game, he paid a $500,000 ransom when trying to save Maria... just to kill her at the end. He gives NO fucks😂
Who said that Claude killed her? I don't see how not fully pledging loyalty to scummy gangs makes him a devil lol
He litteraly goes on k*ll*** spree for fun and k*ll 25 gangsters at once, then goes on the street to shoot some more peeps. Then start over Again. More, he litteraly survived a fkg embush without any guns and revenge himself from his ex girl, Who is also psychotic. He doesnt speak, he is emotionnless, and betray almost every single person he made biz with. This guy is at another level😂
Ranked by how evil they are :-
1) Toni Ciprani
2) Claude Speed
3) Trevor Phillips
4) Tommy Vercetti
5) Carl Johnson
6) Michael De Santa
7) Johnny Klebitz
8) Franklin Clinton
9) Niko Bellic
10) Luis Lopez
11) Victor Vance
Claude should be 1
@@Swablu7024u never played lcs didn’t u?
For me Tommy is worst than Trevor, at least he's got a heart and is loyal despite all his psychotic behavior. Tommy is cold and only loyal to himself.
Tommy surprisingly shows to have empathy. He appears to have cared for his father and he forgave the old man who was beat up by Sonny's goons. The average GTA protagonist would've yelled at him, maybe even beat him themselves. But Tommy understood the circumstances and forgave him and even promised to get revenge. He was also hurt to be betrayed by Vance. Tommy is not a complete monster albeit being a very dangerous and violent individual.
Not true Tommy shows more compassion to Everest, Mercedes, her father, etc. than Trevor does to literally anyone, his way of showing respect to people is by belittling them and the way he treats Ron Wade and Floyd is straight up abusive and you can tell they only tolerate it out of fear and bc Trevor feeds them meth. Tommy was a fair kingpin even to Lance who was a complete liability was treated pretty good but Lance wanted to be equal to Tommy and Tommy said no bc Lance is too incompetent, and so Lance betrayed him and you can tell it hurt Tommy. Trevor is way more evil in comparison
@@josephstalin2606 well, if Stalin says so it must be true
I feel like the only reason for Toni being so high on the list is the mission with blowing up the entire discrict. It always felt so unfitting for his character.
I think not only that Toni also killed her mom's favorite butcher and sold his meat in that Butcher's shop is really chilling if all character put in his shoes most of them just walk and said this is silly but Toni would do it for his ma, Trevor too no doubt, Claude Will do it for the money xD
Which GTA game is that?
@@TheJwwinter GTA Liberty City
@@ardibetrayal3493Stories
My choices are close enough to this, except:
CJ is an anti-hero. A man with principles of loyalty, family and respect above all else, looking to have a life out of gang warfare and moving on to new things, he is a dreamer of a good life that actually fought to save and take with him those he liked, and even showed bits of emotional remorse when he killed his traitors. Still, his deeds for guys like Tenpenny and Jizzy put him in a unmoral position of humanity, along with building his garage business out of stealing vehicles. Overall, at beginning, Carl liked to be a hood, but in the end, he wanted better.
Niko is also an anti-hero. Even though he is not a remorseful person, he shows emotions and even heartbreaks with certain events. Not a totally cold blooded killer, Niko is a survivor with numerous physical and mental scars of his destructive past, and someone that never really learn how to forgive or walk on until he finally found Darko. He openly admits to Roman he ruined his life and was apologetic about it, and when he lost Roman, he felt he lost everything.
Michael is a complicated case of evil sometimes and indeed an anti-hero. While at times a maniac and complete loose cannon when the time came to act, he always made sure to be fair and square in his choices, and when he helps someone, normally it leads to a good thing. Yes, he is selfish, temperamental and ruthless when he is criminally acting, but he tries to be a good father and husband (even with spoiled rotting kids and a thot for a wife), acted as a friend/father in arm for Franklin and finally decides to accept Trevor back in his life to end this burden.
Tenpenny is about to Blackmail CJ, CJ had to do pimp shit for Jizzy to expose the Loco Syndicate, to learn about them
two different things as the ones for Tenpenny is to avoid getting blackmailed, can say the same for Smoke cus Tenpenny also gaves out errands to smoke but Smoke got deeper into the drug dealing
I personally think Niko is more of an anti-hero. He goes out of his way to help certain characters. And he does feel genuine remorse about his violent ways. Although, there is an argument to be made that it doesn't matter if you feel bad about the things you do if you keep doing them. But, I think he did change his ways in the end.
Lester referenced him in GTA V and said he "Went quiet." I always thought that meant he left the criminal life. Then again, he could have continued the criminal life and just gotten killed.
A well made video that was both informative and interesting. I hope you have a wonderful 2024 and make it to 10K subs!
I love these protagonists from a story perspective but it’s crazy to see the amount of excuses being made for the evil of some of these characters
You should've put Vic in the good tier because his plan was to make money to help his sick brother. And Niko in the Anti Hero.
Vic was too good for the gta world.
I think you forgot when Vic Vance basically slaughtered an entire military base just to steal a helicopter.
@@otavianiluciano7397 so you expect the soilders to welcome him like a celeb for breaking into their base ?
@@otavianiluciano7397 Are you forced to kill the soldiers to get the heli? If not then they don't count
Vic is forced to enter criminal world because of his family and Mendez tricked him and kicked him out the military.He is a decent guy and I bet he will never commit crimes if he is still in military.He became more broken when Louise died.
Rockstar Games did a good job creating Claude as the protagonist-villain you love to hate.
Well if you think about it all GTA protagonist are villains since what they are capable of doing
@@malletUsergaming claudes the worse
@@vicvega24 how? I don't think he killed any innocent people ever and is completely sane compared to everyone else
@@malletUsergaming Claude literally betrays everyone he works with, most definitely picked up as trauma from being with Catalina, she ruled his mind that much that he was willing to fuck over everybody he came across just so he could get to her and get revenge.
@wilaim8549 no he didn't, he didn't betray the Leone's plus its not like he pledged loyalty to them at all, he was literally being used by every gang in liberty city
This is totally bonkers. Michael is AntiHero?? Seriously!!?? Dude, the definition of AntiHero is someone who does morally questionable things but still has a glimmer of goodness in him and a somewhat justifiable goal of greater good. Michael is just a retired criminal whose only goal is self preservation considering his age, escaping punishment from his past deeds and living in luxury for the rest of his life. There is no glamour or any glimmer of greater good in his motivations.
As for CJ and Niko being evil, you are just announcing your lack of nuance and subtlety in thought process out to the world at this point. An evil person does things because it is just who they are as a person. CJ and Niko are both folks forced into a life of crime out of circumstances not because they enjoyed it. They do evil acts sometimes but in the larger picture, they are Antiheroes mostly.
Victor deserves good category
He never hurt anyone who didn't do shit to him, hes only problem was drugs
Michael at anti hero and niko at evil? Niko has a heart and acts like he does because all he knew was violence and war since he was a kid. Michael even though he also had a bad childhood, it couldnt be nearly as bad as nikos. Also hes a selfish prick, cheats hes friends and even his wife. Niko loves his family and only becomes a criminal again because of roman. Niko at good or evil sonetimes, Michael at evil.
I would say Haung can be sometimes evil because of all the drug dealing he does. Like the dude straight peddles all types of drugs and dealing crystal or snow could be morally questionable at best
He had to do some crazy shit like saving a guy in a ambulance keeping his heart beating only to use a knife and get his heart out
Under the Orders of someone else, not by him and he wasn't willing to so he's still kinda good... but he still did it
He never did something like that on his own, without getting ordered so I'd say Huang is kinda clean.
@@placyd yeah but massacre just to retrieve a sword is crazy
Tysm for adding mike, mike is a rlly underrated character and my fav gta protagonist! Please add him more in ur vids!
Everybody Gangsta, until GTA 2 protagonist kidnaps innocent people in a bus to make them hot-dog meat in a factory
Claude imo is the scariest. He just goes for the kill, gets the job done, no questions asked, he doesn't think anything through, he's an unstoppable force in a way. And I think he even killed Maria at the end after she said she loves him. He's completely deranged
@TaviousOliver-bg1wnMaria did nothing wrong. Salvatore insults and humiliates her, treats her worse than crap, she wanted to leave him, break out from his shackles, live just like she wants, become free and independent, be herself and find a better life for herself. It’s impossible to blame her.
She deserved so much better. If only she had just never met Salvatore, her life could be much better. But the fate decided otherwise…
@TaviousOliver-bg1wn that is a damn lie. She didn’t want to be with Salvatore. Salvatore was the person who wanted to marry this young girl, she didn’t like him anyways. She never liked him, she despised him from the beginning. She was too young, naive and trustful. And it was her biggest weakness. He never loved her, he looked down on her like on toy, trophy, property. He cheated on her with other young girls. And you blame Maria as a culprit of all evils? What a hypocrisy? Salvatore just manipulated her.
Where did you see that she worked as a usual waitress just to find a sugar daddy? There was written in her eyes “I’m looking for a sugar daddy”? Did she bewitch him? Did she seduce him? Did she blackmail him? No, she didn’t like him. What did this old decrepit stinky worthless and pathetic impotent wreck think when he decided to marry her? That he’ll be young forever? She’ll be his toy, trophy, property, obedient housewife? Bird locked in a golden cage? Was he so stupid not to realising that it will be unequal marriage where she’ll be miserable and cause so many troubles? Was he so stupid? He showed himself not only as stupid but as frivolous and shortsighted person.
What the hell does he care with a girl who’s younger than his own son?!
@TaviousOliver-bg1wn let’s not think that a man in his sixth-seventh decade of his life who achieved all kinds of successes in the criminal underworld, had all judges and politicians in his pocket, power, might, influence and billions of dollars, strong soldiers and capos like Toni Cipriani, who had a son and a lovely wife, but, unfortunately, she died… can’t think that a young girl old enough to be his daughter sincerely loved him and agreed to marry him. His marriage proposal was an offer she couldn’t refuse.
When Salvatore took control of the family after bloody power struggle in the mid 80’s being in his early 50’s, Maria was a teenager. She was only 12-13. It means that Salvatore is a pedophile. An old Sicilian pedophile. An old man chooses a very young girl, he sexually uses and manipulates her, and then, when she outlives her sexuality and attractiveness, he gets rid of her, changing her for other girls.
And what is bad in wanting money? Are you primitive? We live in modern world, in modern generation and in modern society where money values the most. Everyone wants to be in comfort. Or we all should die in misery, poverty and famine?
Maria is my favourite character for her bitter, anarchistic and rebellious character. She doesn’t hide behind a fake persona and she admits for who she is. She just shows a huge middle finger to Salvatore and the whole family, showing that she will not obey to anyone. She’s American, not Italian, not Sicilian. She’s a person of completely different generation. She will never be obeyed to this old Sicilian Don, but to his rules, traditions and orders. She will never be a bird locked in a golden cage. She wants to be free and independent.
@TaviousOliver-bg1wn what is wrong in being materialistic? It is great in being materialistic. It is perfect in being materialistic. We live in MODERN world, in MODERN generation and in MODERN society where money values THE MOST. Everyone wants to be in comfort and happiness. Or should we all die in poverty, misery and starvation?
@TaviousOliver-bg1wn I’m sorry but Maria wasn’t born as a gold digger. It’s not in her DNA. She could only raised like that but we don’t know nothing about her early life. We don’t know nothing about her childhood and upbringing, we don’t know nothing about her parents. And Maria isn’t the only one in the Latore family, she has an older sister, who’s married and has 2 kids. Maybe it’s her parents’ fault that they raised her like that, she wanted money (who doesn’t want). Or Maria’s biggest mistake is just for being born? Please, don’t forget, that Maria’s father was against her marriage with that old scumbag Salvatore, he fiercely hated Salvatore referring him as a fat slob. He knew that this relationship does NOT have a future, will NOT bring happiness and will NOT end up good. He knew that Salvatore will destroy her morally, emotionally and spiritually. Who knew that Maria’s father was right.
Did Maria’s father deserved the possible death of his daughter? Parents should not bury their children.
All should at least be evil. Each character kills at least 100 law enforcement throughout their stories
Agree. They're all villain protagonists same as Walter White and Tony Soprano.
Hey Police could've just walk away and no one gets hurt but Noooo they want to be one way -_-
@@ardibetrayal3493 That's stupid logic if you aren't joking
@@emin166 ofc is a joke.
bro, niko is the most empathetic protagonist in the list...
Is safe to say that the GTA online protagonst being a silent psychopath makes it feel like the fact of their father being Claude something plausible. Even though he's just a cameo like John Marston and Niko Bellic, and Claude being from the 3D universe and GTA Online the HD universe.
1:52 the floating shotgun 😭
I don't see why there's so many comments saying that Niko wasn't evil. He was. He was a Human Trafficker and had no problems helping out scumbags and psychos for money such as Jeff in that side quest where he killed his wife because he's insane and asks Niko to dispose of her body for 5k which Niko of course says yes without issue. his character is great but the people saying he is an anti hero or a good guy are deluding themselves because they like him as a character.
Exactly, if he wasn’t the protagonist I’m sure people would change their opinions
Also he killed hundreds of people because he wanted to kill one dude, that's crazy
Are we gonna ignore the fact trevor values loyalty, morned michaels "death", hates franklin if frank betrays him or michael, will kill anyone who wants to hurt stacey or jimmy, and gave michael a chance in the final mission in going quiet to see if michael cared to even check on him, and went to a point to beat the shit out of martin madrazo when martin was being terrible to his own wife?
Ya thats not devilish activities hes just evil, he did fucked up shit but he is absolutely not the devil
Franklin is a good person only wants to make it out of his life situations such as being poor, he doesn’t directly seem to want to kill, such as when they kidnapped strech(I forgot who) and they had to let him go or kill him but Franklin said we have to let him go at first reaction not even thinking of killing. If he could have made his money without killing I think he would have but that’s what he’s used to and was around and we see that as the game goes on he gets richer and doesn’t forget Lamar which is his best friend but doesn’t deal with any of the hood problems it’s Lamar that brings him back in and Franklin being a good person helps him out. And this is proven later on in the story with the O’neils and Franklin didn’t have to follow them it wasn’t even his problem and wouldn’t have bitten him in the ass it was Trevor’s problem but still looking out for his friend he follows them.
I don't do missions with Franklin anyway, i just free roam and i stop for red lights. My Franklin is a saint. Only when NPCs are threatening or fighting me, i fight back.
Niko is at the good category along with Vic. As for Vic, he never wanted to commit crime but he had no choice if he had to save his brother.
Johnny DID NOT DIE, technically...
If after the cutscene you put bullets in him then you will get the kill conformation red cross, so after the cutscene his NPC is technically alive
He's technically brain dead so he's not coming back and the state would probably pull the plug if he didn't bleed out by the time ems got there if they did
Michael is horrific... Hes an abusive murderer with major anger issues. The only difference better Trevor and Michael is that Michael has mental coping mechanisms
@@PedroCosta-zk8mb because an obligation to protect a group of people you hate and abuse makes things better 😂😂 I would argue Trevor never had a family, and so never forced other people to endure that dynamic with him.
You know, you might have changed my mind actually, Trevor is a better person than Micheal, by isolating himself from society more than Micheal does.
I think a better system would be: Chaotic Evil, Lawful Evil, Neutral Evil, and Neutral.
people forgot that niko made war crimes during his service, he feels regret sure but he still done very horribile things
vic on the other hand have tried many times to avoid the criminal world, he was literally pulled into it due to his and his family's bad circumstances, and in many situations he had no choice
why do rockstar make good/less evil people die like vic or johnny?
Trevor refuses to help Franklin kill Michael, whereas Michael is willing to selfishly kill Trevor to save himself. I’d argue Michael - who essentially creates the monster - is equally as evil as Trevor.
I disagree, as Trevor has been shown to kill people at the drop of a hat and is much more aid a liability than Micheal was, it makes more sense to take him out
Chaotic good: Michael, Niko, CJ
Chaotic evil: Trevor, Tommy
Passive idiots: Claude, Franklin
Claude should also be at Chaotic evil but i agree with others
"Tommy Vercetti is not a psychopath." To me he is a pretty definitive psycho in the series. :D
You totally misunderstood Niko's personality. He's an angel deep inside. The war destroyed him. Along with Vic, he's the most empathetic. Plus, he wanted to settle down and live a normal and peaceful life.