@Arthur de Lima Machado I like to believe they are the same character. Especially when you look at the Railway series lore and how it helps it all click together.
Yeah My version of Nia was abused by her controller in the past and suffers from PTSD because of it which would give kids a message that some people may have gone though a traumatic ordeal in the past and that we should be more accepting of those with disabilities
Fun Fact: Charlie is literally the CGI version of Billy. Billy was going to be in all of Charlie's S13 roles, but Miller decided to make a whole new character. Billy is even in the original versions of Hiro Of The Rails.
@@alexandraroman4121 Splatter, Dodge and Dennis were meant to be in Day of the Diesels and their models were mad but converted to Paxton, Norman and Sidney for more merch characters
I wonder if they made Charlie without realizing they already used the same basis for Billy. Since this was like five or so seasons apart and I’m assuming they hired new writers for the cgi seasons than the model seasons.
@@harrisonallen651 At least I can survive an episode with Rebecca or Nia. I doubt I can get through Billy's episode again without tearing my hair out in frustration.
I like the Community's take on these two a lot better. Billy, a snobbish engine who think the world should revolve around him. Charlie, a stand-up comedian
I have a more interesting theory D199 Bowler and Diesel 10 are the same Why?: D199 Was kicked out of sodor, he repainted himself and returned as Bowler, he got kicked out again, he crashed on his way back to the mainland (somewhere in barrow) and met Splatter and Dodge in the mainland dieselworks, they repainted him again, added a claw and removed his middle window
Here is my story about Billy. It will be titled as "Silly Billy's Redemption". This story will take place after the events of "Don't Be Silly Billy". Billy is beginning to feel remorseful and guilty about his disobedience and bratty attitude towards Thomas. But when the railway becomes busier than ever, Billy gets a second chance and Thomas decides to teach him how to shunt trains for the other engines. And instead of disobeying, Billy finally begins to learn to listen to advice and do as he is told. But some other engines do not trust Billy one bit, not even Percy, Mavis and Diesel. It soon changes when a runaway Diesel goes too fast with the troublesome trucks pushing behind him and it's up to Billy to redeem himself and save the day in order to prove himself a useful engine and that he has changed his ways!
I really had no problem with Nia or Rebecca as characters. I hated that they replaced Edward and Henry, but I felt that they were at least harmless with regards to their personalities and they seemed to exist for a reason beyond just selling toys or making bad jokes, something that can't be said about Charlie or Billy.
Billy had potential to be a well-rounded character. The problem is that this potential was shattered because the only episode ever to have Billy appear, just had to be written by Sharon Miller.
The thing is, the Manning Wardle L Class was a really nice looking engine, and are really interesting. They got shitty characters though. What we need is a Manning Wardle K Class to beat them back to the WW1. Like, these ingrates need a lesson they'll remember.
In my opinion, I actually like Billy. Billy may be annoying, but maybe if he had a better voice, he could be a better character. Billy did find Thomas bossy, which if you think about it, makes sense. If I was in Billy's shoes, I'd probably think Thomas was bossy too, but I wouldn't say that, and do what he told me to do. Billy isn't on my top favorites for sure, but at least at the end, he did change his ways and became a better character. Maybe if he had a better voice and arrived to the railway in the attitude he had at the end of Don't Be Silly Billy, he could be a likable character.
Maybe put Billy in a situation where he has to work with Bradford, and Billy takes is strict and uptight nature for being rude and unhelpful, only to later on cause confusion and delay and damage Bradford to the point where he needed to be taken to the works.
Headcanon: Billy's backstory involved being told around too mutch by the big engines that so he called "bossy engines" that they take advantage his small size and he ownly had a little chance to stand up against it alone
Brotha. His name. Is on his side. OHHHH NEVERMIND I GET IT! Very clever. You’re implying Percy can’t read as part of the intelligence removal(?) bestowed unto Percy as a result of the HiT era. That’s legitimately genius, you get a + to respect.
There actually kind of the same because in season 13 Billy was supposed to return, but replaced him with a new character, Charlie because they had to market a new character.
Interesting thing about Charlie is that his class is the oldest of manning wardle locos(plus one of the oldest tank engines with his class dating back to the 18somethings) but acts as if he was the youngest.
@@ukaszwalczak1154 It’s a similar thing that Mattel does. They’d rather have the designs of the locomotive be interesting and not their personalities. They just choose the locomotive that looks like it could sell the most toys, without looking up any information about it.
Is it bad that I don’t mind nia and Rebecca? I mean yes they replaced Edward and Henry which is a crime punishable by death, but I like the idea and potential each character has. Of course Mattel screwed it up because they’ll never understand why Thomas is what it is today, but you look at something like NWR53’s story “The West Country Runaway” and you see what I mean. Mattel didn’t handle the characters well, only caring about the surface value of representation, not characterization.
The way that they handled Rebecca was just completely disrespectful with Gordon's outburst. Technically it's Childish and would be so if literally any other character, but having the straight laced Dignified "Upper Class" character completely snap and go all over the place was a clear move from the writers that those that liked Henry need to go fuck themselves. Perhaps I'm not the biggest fan of Henry in the universe but you don't get away with doing that to Gordon or Henry without thinking I'm never going to show this to my kids, or recommend to anyone being a parent anything beyond like Season 11.
@@mmouse1886 I mean there is seasons 18 - 21. Now don’t show them ‘that’ episode, but I still think that season 20 especially should still be seen by kids and adult fans alike. However, season 12, the Shannon Miller era, and BWBA can be sidelined in my eyes. If I do show my kids Thomas, I want it to be what I think they should learn, not what others think they should know about certain topics. (That being the very stereotypical international episodes of BWBA)
I definitely think that Charlie and Billy are the same. It was basically confirmed when in one episode Billy was gonna return but they made a new character called Charlie. So basically there the same which is a cool theory
I grew up really liking Charlie, and I didn't even see the episode Billy was in I just knew he existed. Nowadays, I'm not a fan of either. There's a fan made engine named Wendell that I think should have replaced Billy, they are similar classes.
In my headcanon, the reason Billy didn't appear after season 11 was because he was on the mainland doing odd jobs, and then in 2010, he came back to sodor along with his brother Charlie. Charlie came to sodor in 2010 i think since season 13 came out in either 2009 or 2010. But anyway, Billy came back and he and Charlie had fun, they both like racing
Billy's existence baffles me, like they there's so many other characters they could've used for the same purpose as him. Bill and Ben, Rosie etc. He doesnt even look cool so it's not like he'd sell toys.
When you really think about it Charlie, Nia, Rebecca and Billy at least have more character than Norman who's one of the most pointless characters in the series
The problem with Nia and Rebecca is that they frickin replaced 2 original begginer characters, what they could’ve done is be like Ryan, or Murdoch, etc, have them on Sodor, just not the fucking CENTER OF ATTENTION.
To Larry Griffin, can you please stop being annoying with "first" comments.Their not fun or meaningful and they dont mean anything to any of us.Does it make you feel special to be first?If so then fine.Just dont be so rude like saying "So What, nobody cares about you're existence" you aint know my life.Neither do I, just want to be positive about a thomas video. With ❤ Leo Espinosa
@@sabertooth3studioshq838 He keeps commenting "First" on every Trainboy video.He keeps being rude to everyone just because they say, no one cares for First comments.
So that's why ryan was created, i didn't hate charlie that much, i sort of find him funny, i even questioned myself: what happened to charlie? ( i keep mistakening ryan for charlie ) but billy on the other hand: I HATED HIM! ( 1:21 ) WHY?! I Miss Edward & Henry!
I like to think that after his many accidents and incidents caused by his jokes, Charlie is now a much better engine, and only tells jokes to the others at the sheds when everyone is setting in for the night, or are getting ready for their first trains, as well as the trucks as a way to get them to behave, much like Salty and his singing.
The First time Thomas saw Charlie: Charlie: Hello Thomas I'm purple Billy but everybody calls me Charlie Thomas: Hello I've never seen you in my entire life
I don’t remember where on Twitter, but someone made a tweet saying what if billy had autism, and the show wanted to show that but with the engines, but then again they didn’t do it right
Gender equality guys. Even if it ruins the fans day. Introducing 'girl' engines with crap personality by replacing fan favourites is more important than saving a legendary franchise.
So we have Donald, Douglas, Oliver... then 13, then Charlie... Who’s the No.12? I mean, it just skips from Oliver to 13 ( magazine character :I ) So where’s the number 12?! Edit: Nevermind, now I know. Emily finally has a number. Now we need to fix Billy, Proteus, Smudger... Spencer... Bertram... Diesel... Arry and Bert, Paxton... basically the rest of the diesels... um... *Basically the rest of the cast that isn’t the Steam Team*
Charlie is better simply because he just seems to be that guy who wants to make people laugh but has a hard time knowing to pull it back. He means well but on the reverse it cause other people NOT to take him seriously when he's actually pretty good at his job. But Billy, wtf? He's just a straight up jerk.
These little editorials hit different. I think this show more than any other I've seen has so many one shot throwaway characters with wasted potential. I thought Billy was fine, really no more or less interesting than Season 9's Dennis. Charlie is just generic funny guy, much more annoying than Billy since he had a legit personality. Nia and Rebecca are terrible characters that show a lot of problems with the corporate takeover of the show, wheras previous ones were just merchandise one shots
Billy and Charlie are brothers so that makes sense, and the reason I don’t like Nia or Rebecca is cuz they replaced Henry and Edward On the Steam Team to “MAKE THE AMOUNT OF GENDERS ON THE TEAM EQUAL” Like wtf?
Billy will always be a terrible character, and nothing will change my mind. I can see why a lot of people don't like Charlie. I personally don't mind him. Sure he's annoying, but at least he wasn't a jerk-wad like Billy. Since I like bad jokes and puns I enjoyed hearing Charlie make them.
Billy has potential if they played on the fact he is an insufferable little shit and made that fun in writing. A lot of the engines are egotistical brats who think they should be giving orders instead of following them, but it's usually well written and meets a satisfying comeuppance. Billy being this loathesome prick accusing anyone who gives him simple corrections or commands as being some bossy Nazi could be funny in a classic-styled storyline where he always gets punished in a satisfying way, like say rather than everyone ELSE suffering because of him, HE gets screwed by his bad actions, and takes it out on his "oppressive" peers.
They re-designed the engines idk what season just to make them blend in with Nia and Rebecca, but it's fucking pointless because if Edward and Henry weren't redesigned was because Mattel chose two new characters to replace Wilbert's original number 2 and 3 engines, how shitty, Henry and Edward we're good characters! And they replaced them?! BULLFUCK!
Billy was a throwaway one-off character, Charlie was supposed to be a comedian but none of his jokes were funny, Nia is just sort of there and Rebecca i actually like.
Charlie actually has more character depth than Nia and Rebecca combined. Think about that for a moment....
pretty much although with Rebecca they could do more with her than what they did in the show.
@@sabertooth3studioshq838 they both can be more, some fanfiction had explored it. Mattel didn't to put it frankly.
@@A.i.r_K I know
Yes yes indeed.........yes
@Arthur de Lima Machado I like to believe they are the same character. Especially when you look at the Railway series lore and how it helps it all click together.
There's how many characters in thomas now? Remember when Henry James and Gordon made up 3/6 of the engines?
No when that was a thing it would have been 3/7
Remember when there was just Thomas, James, Gordon, Henry, and Edward?
@@WayneSmith4267 remember when there was also Percy and Toby too
the OGs from s1 are Thomas, Gordon, Henry, James, Edward, Percy, toby, and Annie and Clarabelle if you want.
@@aoiasahinashusband only a true Thomas fan would know that Thomas have a appeared a total of 139 times in the classic era
Fun Fact: Billy was going to be in Splish Splash Splosh, but they replaced him with Charlie. Which was fucking pointless since they're THE SAME CLASS.
It’s the Splodge fiasco from Day of the Diesels, and Journey beyond Sodor all over again!
@CoolPerson95 No they’re not they’re totally different Billys a bad ass
@@harrisonallen651 and speaking of dotd, Norman and Dennis
I wish Dennis came back
yes finally someone agrees
Honestly, I think they removed Billy because he was supposed to teach kids that they should not be spoiled but the kids didn’t actually realize that.
They actually removed Billy and replaced with Charlie to sell more merchandise.
No, they removed him for the same reason they added him, to make a new character and make a quick buck.
The problem with Nia is that Mattel intentionally label as the ethnic one.
Yeah
My version of Nia was abused by her controller in the past and suffers from PTSD because of it which would give kids a message that some people may have gone though a traumatic ordeal in the past and that we should be more accepting of those with disabilities
"Not Now, Charlie" is a Brenner era ep and most of Charlie episodes are in the Miller era.
that’s why he was actually good
Fun Fact: Charlie is literally the CGI version of Billy. Billy was going to be in all of Charlie's S13 roles, but Miller decided to make a whole new character. Billy is even in the original versions of Hiro Of The Rails.
I have a theory that like splatter and dodge are Paxton and sidney and Norman being Dennis I say lady is Mille and billy is Charlie
@@alexandraroman4121 Splatter, Dodge and Dennis were meant to be in Day of the Diesels and their models were mad but converted to Paxton, Norman and Sidney for more merch characters
I wonder if they made Charlie without realizing they already used the same basis for Billy. Since this was like five or so seasons apart and I’m assuming they hired new writers for the cgi seasons than the model seasons.
Apparently Billy was originally going to be in Splish Splash Splosh, but they replaced him with Charlie. So they must've known somehow.
They’re better than Nia and Rebecca any day!
@@harrisonallen651 Annoying characters are better than bland characters?
@@florenceb1031 exactly
@@harrisonallen651 At least I can survive an episode with Rebecca or Nia. I doubt I can get through Billy's episode again without tearing my hair out in frustration.
I like the Community's take on these two a lot better.
Billy, a snobbish engine who think the world should revolve around him.
Charlie, a stand-up comedian
I have a theory that I've had for like years now.
Billy = Charlie
bit like T1E2H3´s Smudger = Bertrum
I have a more interesting theory
D199 Bowler and Diesel 10 are the same
Why?: D199 Was kicked out of sodor, he repainted himself and returned as Bowler, he got kicked out again, he crashed on his way back to the mainland (somewhere in barrow) and met Splatter and Dodge in the mainland dieselworks, they repainted him again, added a claw and removed his middle window
Well when the show switched to cgi Charlie kind of replaced Billy instead of bringing him back
@@marinettedupain-cheng9930 Interesting idea, D261 and 199 are different BR classes though, 40 and 45 respectively.
D261 is still in the show to bad it’s hard for them to make it they have creater collective movies and den and d261 were in there I saw them
6:46: Is basically, "After the hydrogen bomb attack, the sewage flood and mustard gas leak don't seem so bad in comparison."
My girlfriend doesn't like Salty's teeth so her reaction to Billy was pretty funny.
Here is my story about Billy. It will be titled as "Silly Billy's Redemption". This story will take place after the events of "Don't Be Silly Billy".
Billy is beginning to feel remorseful and guilty about his disobedience and bratty attitude towards Thomas. But when the railway becomes busier than ever, Billy gets a second chance and Thomas decides to teach him how to shunt trains for the other engines. And instead of disobeying, Billy finally begins to learn to listen to advice and do as he is told. But some other engines do not trust Billy one bit, not even Percy, Mavis and Diesel. It soon changes when a runaway Diesel goes too fast with the troublesome trucks pushing behind him and it's up to Billy to redeem himself and save the day in order to prove himself a useful engine and that he has changed his ways!
I really had no problem with Nia or Rebecca as characters. I hated that they replaced Edward and Henry, but I felt that they were at least harmless with regards to their personalities and they seemed to exist for a reason beyond just selling toys or making bad jokes, something that can't be said about Charlie or Billy.
To be honest
Rebecca and Nia have more character that Stanley or Norman
(The latter being a pointless character)
Billy had potential to be a well-rounded character. The problem is that this potential was shattered because the only episode ever to have Billy appear, just had to be written by Sharon Miller.
The thing is, the Manning Wardle L Class was a really nice looking engine, and are really interesting. They got shitty characters though. What we need is a Manning Wardle K Class to beat them back to the WW1. Like, these ingrates need a lesson they'll remember.
Bro mattel disrespected thomas and friends by removing 2 OF THE FIRST ENGINES ON SODOR
Wow that's a lotta likes
Agreed
How dare they take Henry and edward away
how dare the take away two of
first engines on sodor those
bastards
@@adambasma4792 Wait they *WHAT*
Agreed
The intro was a call out cause Neville is underrated
Yep
In my opinion, I actually like Billy. Billy may be annoying, but maybe if he had a better voice, he could be a better character.
Billy did find Thomas bossy, which if you think about it, makes sense. If I was in Billy's shoes, I'd probably think Thomas was bossy too, but I wouldn't say that, and do what he told me to do.
Billy isn't on my top favorites for sure, but at least at the end, he did change his ways and became a better character. Maybe if he had a better voice and arrived to the railway in the attitude he had at the end of Don't Be Silly Billy, he could be a likable character.
Maybe put Billy in a situation where he has to work with Bradford, and Billy takes is strict and uptight nature for being rude and unhelpful, only to later on cause confusion and delay and damage Bradford to the point where he needed to be taken to the works.
"If he had a better voice"
Solution: watch the original, British version. It's superior in every way.
The uk billy is fine the us voice actor just sucks
Go watch "Isn't it funny" story you will not see charlie a same way again
At least Charlie isn't a ass like Gordon or spencer...
@@Diecast-pj1md well...
He is kinda a ass to Thomas tho
Headcanon:
Billy's backstory involved being told around too mutch by the big engines that so he called "bossy engines" that they take advantage his small size and he ownly had a little chance to stand up against it alone
Omg Coconut Mall is perfect for this
BILLY IS THE ONLY STEAM LOCOMOTIVE THAT VERY DESERVEDLY SCRAPPED
I'd say Lady, Salty, Spencer, Dennis, and Glynn are the best post Magic Railroad characters.
Except Lady only appeared in TATMR. Sadly.
She also appeared in Calling All Engines! Although it was only in Thomas's dream.
@@StephTHatt Yeah I know she appeared in that shitty special.
What about hiro, Victor and Stephen?
@@daansstuff2952 What about them?
4:05 how did Percy even know Billy's name in the episode? He was introduced at Brendam and Percy was not there, HiT Era writing...
Brotha. His name. Is on his side.
OHHHH NEVERMIND I GET IT! Very clever. You’re implying Percy can’t read as part of the intelligence removal(?) bestowed unto Percy as a result of the HiT era. That’s legitimately genius, you get a + to respect.
There actually kind of the same because in season 13 Billy was supposed to return, but replaced him with a new character, Charlie because they had to market a new character.
What If Charlie is billy in disguise bc billy feels silly
New salty can’t say shiver me axels without it sounding wrong
Billy when said his name for the first time made me laugh. Michael Brandon made me laugh.
Interesting thing about Charlie is that his class is the oldest of manning wardle locos(plus one of the oldest tank engines with his class dating back to the 18somethings) but acts as if he was the youngest.
HiT Entertainment were too stupid to realise that.
@@sirwelcome Yeah they sure did. They sure did........
@@ukaszwalczak1154 It’s a similar thing that Mattel does. They’d rather have the designs of the locomotive be interesting and not their personalities. They just choose the locomotive that looks like it could sell the most toys, without looking up any information about it.
@@sirwelcome Well what do you expect from a greedy nearly dead company only wanting money?
Is it bad that I don’t mind nia and Rebecca? I mean yes they replaced Edward and Henry which is a crime punishable by death, but I like the idea and potential each character has. Of course Mattel screwed it up because they’ll never understand why Thomas is what it is today, but you look at something like NWR53’s story “The West Country Runaway” and you see what I mean. Mattel didn’t handle the characters well, only caring about the surface value of representation, not characterization.
I don't mind Rebecca as a character but I hate nia
For me, Rebecca's alright ( even though she replaced one of my favorite characters ).
The way that they handled Rebecca was just completely disrespectful with Gordon's outburst. Technically it's Childish and would be so if literally any other character, but having the straight laced Dignified "Upper Class" character completely snap and go all over the place was a clear move from the writers that those that liked Henry need to go fuck themselves. Perhaps I'm not the biggest fan of Henry in the universe but you don't get away with doing that to Gordon or Henry without thinking I'm never going to show this to my kids, or recommend to anyone being a parent anything beyond like Season 11.
@@mmouse1886 I mean there is seasons 18 - 21. Now don’t show them ‘that’ episode, but I still think that season 20 especially should still be seen by kids and adult fans alike. However, season 12, the Shannon Miller era, and BWBA can be sidelined in my eyes. If I do show my kids Thomas, I want it to be what I think they should learn, not what others think they should know about certain topics. (That being the very stereotypical international episodes of BWBA)
"I mean yes they replaced Edward and Henry which is a crime punishable by death"
Even if this is satire, this is still too much to take seriously
I acctually like all episodes from thomas. Wanna know why?
*BECAUSE THESE ARE THE ONLY THINGS THAT I CAN WATCH AFTER DA REBOOT*
Yup James Jr..
I’m literally gonna put the Britt Allcroft era (Seasons 1-6) into a USB drive
@@thatadhdkid2009 its acctually s1 - s7
@@Sir2Edward that’s the classic series and not the Britt era
@@thatadhdkid2009 oh ok then.
I like rebecca, they could have done a TS extension ep for her while the others sleep in other areas like CAE, but have all the rest stay
Is it bad that when I see the NEW SERIES of thomas ANYWHERE I want to curl up into a ball and DIE?
not bad just a lil much
4:23 so no ones gonna talk about the points?
*I did not notice that*
I’m confused,what do you mean by ‘the points’ ?
@@yourfriendlyneighbourhoodb7585 I am not good at explaining but wikipedia has all the info you need
@@yourfriendlyneighbourhoodb7585 they’re not set for Charlie to go on the curve
@@nigelgresley87546 oh,k
"is grossed out by that country accent, and he's a farm"
Oh.
“Who does Thomas think he is taking lip when he has, those”
His teeth are literally as big as his nose.
“Theres plenty of.. friends on Thomas and Friends” lmaooo
I definitely think that Charlie and Billy are the same. It was basically confirmed when in one episode Billy was gonna return but they made a new character called Charlie. So basically there the same which is a cool theory
Ya, maybe Charlie lost his Buck Teeth over time
Just like Manning Wardle 1601 was once Arthur and is now Mathew Murray
I grew up really liking Charlie, and I didn't even see the episode Billy was in I just knew he existed. Nowadays, I'm not a fan of either. There's a fan made engine named Wendell that I think should have replaced Billy, they are similar classes.
I think Wendell is a Hudswell Clarke, who also manufactured similar locomotives for industrial applications.
“Billy and Charlie are the worst characters.” Charlie pretty much replaced Billy.
In my headcanon, the reason Billy didn't appear after season 11 was because he was on the mainland doing odd jobs, and then in 2010, he came back to sodor along with his brother Charlie. Charlie came to sodor in 2010 i think since season 13 came out in either 2009 or 2010. But anyway, Billy came back and he and Charlie had fun, they both like racing
Poor Billy, if it wasn't for bad writing and lack of character growth, you would have been something else
Billy's existence baffles me, like they there's so many other characters they could've used for the same purpose as him. Bill and Ben, Rosie etc. He doesnt even look cool so it's not like he'd sell toys.
I wish Murdoch and Molly and Mighty Mac and Derek could do more stuff
Billy, Charlie and Stanley are the 3 characters I despise the most. Funny how they're all the similar classes of engine
why Stanley?
My little brother loves Billy! I've always wondered why.
The dk summit music giving me nostalgia
It’s the Coconut mall theme.
But that being in there too is nostalgic.
@Fuck Everyone Then practice
@Fuck Everyone if you ever put anytime into it it’s not a “shifty game”
@Fuck Everyone
That’s nice
When you really think about it
Charlie, Nia, Rebecca and Billy at least have more character than Norman who's one of the most pointless characters in the series
can you do a top ten most favorite characters and least favorite
The problem with Nia and Rebecca is that they frickin replaced 2 original begginer characters, what they could’ve done is be like Ryan, or Murdoch, etc, have them on Sodor, just not the fucking CENTER OF ATTENTION.
To Larry Griffin, can you please stop being annoying with "first" comments.Their not fun or meaningful and they dont mean anything to any of us.Does it make you feel special to be first?If so then fine.Just dont be so rude like saying "So What, nobody cares about you're existence" you aint know my life.Neither do I, just want to be positive about a thomas video.
With ❤ Leo Espinosa
Calm down
@@nossta5242 tell that to Larry Griffin he keeps being rude to everyone.
Who is Larry Griffin?
@@sabertooth3studioshq838 He keeps commenting "First" on every Trainboy video.He keeps being rude to everyone just because they say, no one cares for First comments.
@@leoespinosa1570 oh I see.
So that's why ryan was created, i didn't hate charlie that much, i sort of find him funny, i even questioned myself: what happened to charlie? ( i keep mistakening ryan for charlie ) but billy on the other hand: I HATED HIM!
( 1:21 )
WHY?! I Miss Edward & Henry!
I like to think that after his many accidents and incidents caused by his jokes, Charlie is now a much better engine, and only tells jokes to the others at the sheds when everyone is setting in for the night, or are getting ready for their first trains, as well as the trucks as a way to get them to behave, much like Salty and his singing.
The First time Thomas saw Charlie:
Charlie: Hello Thomas I'm purple Billy but everybody calls me Charlie
Thomas: Hello I've never seen you in my entire life
I don’t remember where on Twitter, but someone made a tweet saying what if billy had autism, and the show wanted to show that but with the engines, but then again they didn’t do it right
Who remembers the first 15 episodes when it was just Thomas, Edward, Henry, Gordon & James?
Gender equality guys. Even if it ruins the fans day. Introducing 'girl' engines with crap personality by replacing fan favourites is more important than saving a legendary franchise.
Billy should have got a scolding from Sir Topham Hatt for being mean. Charlie maybe a goofy engine, but he does actually be serious at time
CAN be
When is the dark, darker, darkest side of day out of Thomas
The real question: when is the deepest, darkest, depths of hell side of day out with Thomas
im glad this came out on my birthday
So we have Donald, Douglas, Oliver... then 13, then Charlie...
Who’s the No.12? I mean, it just skips from Oliver to 13 ( magazine character :I )
So where’s the number 12?!
Edit: Nevermind, now I know.
Emily finally has a number.
Now we need to fix Billy, Proteus, Smudger... Spencer... Bertram... Diesel... Arry and Bert, Paxton... basically the rest of the diesels... um...
*Basically the rest of the cast that isn’t the Steam Team*
3:10 why we haven’t seen billy again
Charlie is better simply because he just seems to be that guy who wants to make people laugh but has a hard time knowing to pull it back. He means well but on the reverse it cause other people NOT to take him seriously when he's actually pretty good at his job.
But Billy, wtf? He's just a straight up jerk.
Literally just subbed today, what are the odds.
@Rideman Eyyy, how'd you know? :)
The one thing Charles is good at is getting his water tank striped of for the firebox of my big city engine custom.
4:20 bro the tracks weren't even switched but he turns.
Am i the only one who used to think that Billy and Charlie are the same engine?
No lol
That's because they are, in technical terms
These little editorials hit different. I think this show more than any other I've seen has so many one shot throwaway characters with wasted potential. I thought Billy was fine, really no more or less interesting than Season 9's Dennis. Charlie is just generic funny guy, much more annoying than Billy since he had a legit personality. Nia and Rebecca are terrible characters that show a lot of problems with the corporate takeover of the show, wheras previous ones were just merchandise one shots
The Mario Kart Wii music as background music is great.
Billy and Charlie are brothers so that makes sense, and the reason I don’t like Nia or Rebecca is cuz they replaced Henry and Edward On the Steam Team to “MAKE THE AMOUNT OF GENDERS ON THE TEAM EQUAL”
Like wtf?
Billy And Charlie Weren't Good Enough For The Reboot
Charley mouth had smoke in it.
Billy will always be a terrible character, and nothing will change my mind.
I can see why a lot of people don't like Charlie. I personally don't mind him. Sure he's annoying, but at least he wasn't a jerk-wad like Billy. Since I like bad jokes and puns I enjoyed hearing Charlie make them.
I miss these videos!
I still can’t believe they replaced Edward and Henry
And toby was just- gone-
Call Me Cyber So as older characters, like Charlie, Donald and Douglas, duck, Stanley, daisy, Rosie’s old design, Philip, and I think that’s it
I never realized that Billy and Charlie had the same design.
I never hated billy. I found him kinda cute. Idk why
What Happened to the Previous Upload?Anyways, great video as always
I mistakenly had some information and editing in there that wasn't correct, I ended up scrapping the idea. :/
@@ItsTrainBoy oh
Also do you know billy turns into a steam monster when it’s night and his teeth it counts
Billy looks like he is from lazy town
Billy has potential if they played on the fact he is an insufferable little shit and made that fun in writing. A lot of the engines are egotistical brats who think they should be giving orders instead of following them, but it's usually well written and meets a satisfying comeuppance. Billy being this loathesome prick accusing anyone who gives him simple corrections or commands as being some bossy Nazi could be funny in a classic-styled storyline where he always gets punished in a satisfying way, like say rather than everyone ELSE suffering because of him, HE gets screwed by his bad actions, and takes it out on his "oppressive" peers.
What a coincidence that billy and Charlie, the 2 most annoying characters are the same class
I Love this Channel, Definitely Subscribing!!!
Dang….enough with the hate with Billy and Charlie. Especially Billy. What happened with compassion and mercy yall
Another similarity is Norman is the brother of Dennis. They both have the same type of design of an old diesel engine.
Nailed the intro amazing
He ThInKs YoU aRe A vErY bOsSy EnGeRiNe 🤣🤣 Also, Why does Charlie BOUNCE when he goes along the tracks
Billy is a character that I loved. That's all I have.
Nobody needs to know that
great video. you changed my opinion on them
He thinks you’re a bossy boiler, me Harty!
These two are like Sodor's finest, but not Sodor's finest
Billy was fine to me and I also had a Wooden Railway toy of Billy so maybe that is why I like Billy.
I have a wooden railway Billy to I guess I didn't like him cuz he looked ugly
They re-designed the engines idk what season just to make them blend in with Nia and Rebecca, but it's fucking pointless because if Edward and Henry weren't redesigned was because Mattel chose two new characters to replace Wilbert's original number 2 and 3 engines, how shitty, Henry and Edward we're good characters! And they replaced them?! BULLFUCK!
There really was never a point to those characters
Well they were to be toys onscreen. However we can pretend that like Sam and Logan, they both returned to the Mainland.
I actually kinda like Billy
Billy was a throwaway one-off character, Charlie was supposed to be a comedian but none of his jokes were funny, Nia is just sort of there and Rebecca i actually like.
I still agree that Tomy did a better job than Mattel
Way better
I particularly enjoy Billy, very much actually, Charlie however
I hate him, very very much
Ya know the best thing you can say about billy and charlie? They didnt replace anybody. Their inclusion hurt no one. We lost nothing for having them.