Some mistakes had to be called out during editing, but I hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, maybe subscribe if you aren't already? Discord Link: discord.gg/z5WaQqv5cR Song: Tix Blasterz By Key After Key. Made for a cool Roblox game called Phighting.
I think the reason why tds might have done better is because tdx is a fairly new game and when tds has no new updates people play tdx but when there’s a event from tds people try to get tds even done and then move on to tdx.
I imagine that the reason why this could be is because that john realised that other games will have a christmas event so making the event shorter but still difficult to a degree makes it something where you arn't needed to spend alot of time on. This causes you to enjoy the event more and gives you more time to play other games christmas events. In my opinion i find this to be better overall as it respects the players time and other games. it also causes hard grinders to acctully celebrate the holiday instead of wasting the celebration day on a game. It also means casual players (like me) to not have to worry about the event and not to be like "oh i really want this skin but i need to grind for 10 hours for it so i wont bother as i can go have fun on something else" which means individual players can see the tower and use the tower or skins and still have the enthusiasm to use it rather then getting burn't out and not wanting to use it. Edit:just fixed some grammer issues
That’s actually what I loved about the evnt as well. I’m a causal player, I have never grounded for anything too ridiculous, so that’s why I have like only a couple battle pass skins.
I can totally understand what are you talking about. But you don't really have to grind for 10 hours to actually complete the event unlike the others. Just grind for it an hour per day and at the end of the day you will get a lot of those features. They already give you the time you need to grind and sometimes it can be longer than it was suppose to be aswell. So don't worry about it
Keep in mind that TDX has only 14~ devs while TDS has 22 devs, and most of the assets used in the TDS event were obviously reutilized from other events, so they had plenty of time to polish already-existent mechanics and had way more time to prepare since November, while TDX were focusing on QoL and small content updates since the game just released, hence why there is so little content and why the event is generally easy. John even confirmed this by stating, "wish i could've added more but given our time frame after releasing TDX, it was a small window." and "originally i was intending to add 2 versions, easy and hard (we went with an easy one for now so most players can enjoy it)." Also, I don't want to be that guy, but both of games are good on their own and doesn't need to be compared like this. Just because TDS or TDX had more players than the other at any point, it doesn't make the other "bad".
Yeah, that’s most of the reasons why tds event sorta did better. I feel like the comparison is unavoidable then being the 2 largest td games, but yeah, they are separate games. I’ll probably not make another video like this if that helps.
Em sorry? But they were working on 5 New towers, jester, necromancer, cryomancer, the 2 that we still dont know, 3 differents acts with differentes difficulties, this holiday event, the new gamemode thats supposed to be "chaos mode" with a lot of news skins, so now shut up tdx fanboy
@@Flame.xz29 The halloween event ended in the start of November, that gave them plenty of time to recover and start making a new update again, which was the quests update for the christmas event. What do you mean I'm a "TDX fanboy"? I just mentioned in the comment "both games are good on their own and doesn't need to be compared like this"?
stfu idiot tdx JUST RELEASED its actually impressive they made a whoel event in such a small time frame while TDS was already working months before setting everything up TDX is updating WEEKLY but will go to monthly WHICH IS STILL INSANELY GOOD Tds on the other hand updates every few months for like maps and bs or some new skins which nobody cares about and TDX has even better design then TDS and tds is way too grindy its become borderline unplayable now.Tds also manipulates children into FOMO(fear of missing out) just so they can get money with battlepass crap you either pay up or slave away at a game that isnt even fun and is repetitive I honestley wish TDS could be good again but i can't play the game without getting bored i only play it for beating the event testing it out and not playing it again stop meat riding TDS when in back of your head its fallen off and sucks ass now. i know how development works they work on events and stuffs months prior to their month for etc they were working on christmas update in august/september they dont fully start a event with nothing too it yet. not to mention TDX isn't as grindy and isnt just slaving away at fucking game also act 3 was ass tdx is a better game and you can't prove me wrong your just salty you wasted so much time on tds you feel like you cant escape it without it being a waste of money therefore spending more and more.thats what tds devs WANT. you prob haven't even tried TDx yet haven't you?@@Flame.xz29 dont mind bad grammar
My favorite thing is I spent a total of 4 days to get/complate every new thing in TDS (season,skins,quests...) but in TDX, it only took me 2 hours to get the all things. Seriously, only in TDX.
I think TDX is taking the player friendly path, which I think is absolutely correct. Too much grinding isn't fun. Majority of the playerbase of tower defense games are Kids and Teens. I dont think they have much time to grind so much. But I do have to say, TDS did revive their playerbase back with the reworks and all. Bravos to them
personally me i am loving the frost blaster rework and i like grinding for stuff, it makes me really feel like i earned it rather then it being given to me, that just me though.
Not gonna lie, it was much more fun for TDX event than the TDS event. So much so that I tried speedrunning it and used to hold the world record with a few group of friends. It could be that TDX is newer and thus I have less burnout from the game but still. Overall TDS has much more content than TDX and that’s what kept the player count stable.
i love how no one mentions this, but tds has legit been around since 2019, while tdx started being created around mid 2022. tds literally has time on there side.
Something i liked about the TDS event is that it was more... "exploitable" and out of the meta. Like it and frost invasion were one of the only events to actually make placing accel asap a not good strategy, specially because accel is too expensive early game and the enemies divide into two main paths, and when going further into the track their paths get more far, meaning that splash towers and long-range are the meta for that event. Secondly, the bosses there do have lots of health but it isn't something big enough to make splash-based towers do nothing against Krampus, you just need to put some dps at the later waves and you'll be fine. It really had a different experience from most other gamemodes because the normal meta wasn't as effective as using a loadout focusing with splash damage and/or high range. By the "exploitable" part i mean is that the challenges in the event had actual solutions that were very effective without being spamming accels, engis or minis
I also loved how it changed the freeze tower meta. All freeze toers now have a purpose, and sledger isn't just straight up OP. You need at least 2 freeze tower to simulate a effect similar to what sledger had back then.
@@joaoborgesrodriguesalves6554 engi detects flying and they only mention 4 towers so I think the 5th one is the tower that deals with them since engis flying is trash
totally agree lol. i really wish the tdx event had more content to it, but because of the lack of it, tds really pulled here with the event. tds's event was a pleasant surprise too!
Tdx is better because they were going to add a nightmare version of the event where when multiplier x makes contact with XO Santa he will duplicate xo Santa then you have two bosses to kill but they didn’t have time before the event launched so he announced that it will be added soon It will be a game mode so you could play it. On any map and it’s just the first event and that’s just the warm up for tdx they will make a comeback and tdx has a smaller team so it’s unfair
Alright, first of all. TDS is an older game than TDX and they already got the devs that know what to do for the future updates. TDS prepared quests, season pass and provided us with a lot of new skins that people would for sure grind for and keep replayability ongoing. TDX on other hands is like.."Beat an event multiple time for all skins" and thats it. And since TDX is such a boring game to grind and it has so much downsides what tds fixed a long time ago, TDX replayability is absolutely dog ####. They didn't add any content that could keep players playing it, the replayability is low and I can say that TDX event despite being easy, the wave layout of enemy was horrifying. Me myself beated TDX event 6 times for all skins and stopped playing it while in TDS i am still grinding and enjoying the updated the delivered to the community. I am not hating on any game, but the these reasons MIntGamng mentioned are so stubborn that my head hurts because of it.
Ngl i kinda agree with you as well. Also pretty funny that he said that he doesn't wanna hate on TDS yet does so anyway. Typical TDX Meatrider behavior mate. As for both events, yeah I enjoyed the TDS one far more than TDX, tho that's mainly due to reasons you already mentioned. What more can I add other than that I hope that TDS will continue with this pace. Perhaps Razuatix leaving the dev team + TDX's mid christmas event has graced TDS with good luck lmfaoo.
@@tdchad5894 in 2019 20k-40k was jailbreak levels. a roblox game that was made for a school project did NOT pass the giant that was jailbreak. in 2019 things like heck even meepcity had like 10k players. stop lying bro
Hm, now that i think about it.. People keep saying that cryomancer from tds was ripped from tdx WHILE tdx ripped that from tbz and cryo ranger is ripped from reworked freezer from tds and i have heard not one soul mention this. I love both games but i once agaim feel like people praise tdx wayy too much and therefore try to call out tds for basically anything.. i mean look at elite.
Another thing is that while both of the event were easy tdx is very easy and tds is a bit harder. Tdx allows you to beat the event in one attempt if your not going for the skins and tds it’s harder and has more content.
The tds and tdx event was alright. TDS rushed the event to not make their game collapse and the event tower is extremely unbalanced and the tdx event was too easy but the grind wasn’t too hard. However tds event makes you waste your time in that game for hours grinding for every skins, crates, and gadgets.
@@stone8519I saw some towers that are not creative we have a Skull tower that had a sharp thing at the tail of the gun and they even showed it can be used as a melee Agent don't know what he does War machine War factory Golden towers Grenadier Jet spawner it's more like a unit than a tower And alot
Yeah I agree, because TDS literally had a whole unstoppable monopoly on roblox tower defense games, but now TDX as a competitor causes them to try harder in order to not lose at their own game
well by the tower defense simulator's grindies for literally everything and for tower defense X's copiness of tower blitz.... I THINK THAT PHIGHTING! WINS IN THIS SITUATION
Theres still more to come for both games i really hope tdx starts doing better but as john said nightmare mode and many other things are in the works so im pretty confident
Here’s the thing… you have to be level 5 to play the tdx event which causes brand new players not being able to play, so they will go to tds sense they can be any level to play the event.
people keep crying about "WEEHHHHHHHHHH THE TDX EVENT TOO EASY TDS IS BETTER WEHHHHHHHHHHH" but he made it EASY BECAUSE EVERYBODY WAS NEW, if it was like their 2nd event, he would have made it near impossible
I enjoyed both to be honest, both have pros and cons, I do think tbh that the Santa robot thing is kinda dumb and wish there was more of an explanation on why all these Christmas themed enemies are attacking, but nonetheless both are worthwhile.
I think TDS's event was better because I like small details and in tds there were many details.The maps were cool and with that refund future and the map changing I like it a lot. And I liked the maps designs.
"Quest system, that would make so many players have so much stuff to accomplish in their event" last time i checked a normal game gave more then a singular daily.
Heres what happened for me - 1. Realise tds updated😐 2. Played the event. Game gud🤠 3. Died from a big black monkey🎅🏿. 4. Bad gaem😡😡 5. Realise tdx update🗣️🗣️🎅6. Play tdx event😮 7. Win😆 8. Tower gud yes yes💪💪🏿
Me personally I kind of like tdx's event a bit more. I can see why someone would like the tds one more and why someone could think why it'd be better. But I personally like tdx's more because it's... simple I am probably speaking out of nostalgia more than anything else. It was... simple, no multi paths, no defend the center, no several parts, and no super crazy gimmick enemies. The fact that there was no music or anything just really made me remember why I loved events like halloween 2019 so much. It wasn't trying to go above and beyond and I had some good fun with my friends like I did nearly 5 years ago.
Both were fun, however TDX’s doesn’t have much replayability while TDS has cookies and other features. Also, keeping a consistent story works for TDS incredibly well.
while i have quit tds a while ago, i can say the TDX eveent probably wins long-term, it was more enjoyable and wayy less grindy, leaving a good image for the layerbase of what to expect soon instead of a grindfest like tds
Its obvious how TDS pulled out something we never expected. A winter event which has 3 towers released (Freezer reworked,Frost blaster reworked and new event tower cyromancer.) Which was just released after 2 days of the trailer release and many much content so that they could finally deserve some respect from their community and no arguement or hate on it. It also wasnt delayed and phoqus absolutely carried the event with the music while destroying the enemies. TDX is also appreciable since it has much lesser devs and is in beta. I dont know any more about this but this is all i could comment
for some reason, i started tdx, played a bit, got pretty good, missile trooper, barracks, and some other stuff, but then i quit. i dont know why, but i just like tds more then tdx. im a level 250 with basically every troop (excluding commando) in tds, and from what i could tell, just from the first month of release, tdx is dying. on the first day it had 30k players, then the next day, it had 7k. they might make a comeback but who knows. but one thing is for sure: tds will never die. also regarding what you said at 2:00, no they delayed the event quite a bit for tds and couldnt add some content, this was due to the razuatix situation, as he left tds, will also not be coming back permanently, which slowed down production a bit. the player count for tdx however, may be because many tds players play tdx, giving a big roadblock for the player count of tdx.
Both events were amazing, the only reason why tds has more player count than tdx is the fact that it has a battlepass, a really grindy one too. Which keeps the player grinding the game until they complete it. Tdx on the other hand, you only needa win 6 times to finish everything the event has to offer.
I had so much more fun grinding the tds event. the quality is higher and the event was really good for a 2 week development period. I beat thew tdx event first try. Like you said, there is much more content in tds. TDX has potential but right now... TDS > TDX
Yeah, though as a casual player that ain’t my kinda thing. I don’t typically grind stuff, so the only thing that motivates me to grind is to grind on stream lol.
But I think overtime, TDX will start to gain popularity and might have the chance to overcome TDS. The probabilities of this happening is still pretty low because of the huge playerbase TDS has. TDX had just been released recently and it has outstanding potential to become one of the greatest tower defense games ever in roblox. It's realistic, It's balanced and It has everything you just want.
also bro i think its also because of the recent lunar overture event that tds is still gettting hate because tdx didint do the same mistake as tds did because he understands if he does this he will make a huge mistake so basically the player base love tdx because of how bad act 3 was and still even getting hate including elite ;-;
0:51 To be fair, Tdx is a new game so it will not have as many players for an event, and they probably did not do the event as well as tds which is an older and more bigger td game. So therefore the event may be better than tdx
the game it’s still really popular and the release hype for tdx was really big and people play it a lot because it’s a new game so players can play it a lot and not get bored (I still think tds is better)
Will also say that TDS has been around for much longer than TDX, so TDS is already really well established and a lot more people know about. Meanwhile, TDX is newer and not as many people know about it so it's not as popular as TDX, meaning that even if their event was better in every aspect compared to TDS's event TDS would still get more players. Also it's funny how it takes like 2 hours to get every TDX skin but it can (I believe) take more than 20 hours to get every skin in TDS
Although TDS is more popular rn, it feels like a level out, maybe mid-2024 TDS went through some kind of curve in players, peaking earlier in the years, frost invasion, the fun of the game, even for roblox in general. Games get grindier and less fun as they grow to be popular. TDX is walking the same path, so it will gain the players TDS had like in 2022, and foresee the mistakes. but TDS is better, but Lunar Overture 💀
TDX is a fusion of Tower Blitz and CTD I grinded both and saw what both had to offer. TDX seems to have grabbed the most barebones mechanics from both like tower hp from CTD and the two paths from Tower Blitz. It carryies no other unique mechanics and add ons from both like CTD's enemyies having unique interactions with other enemyies. Perks and more! In a nutshel TDX gets boring fast without quests and operations or daily challanges, also the grind is too tough i aien't got time for that. (Null chambers gives towers you dont use unique circumstances so they can shine bright again! Sacrificial hall is about YOU making the difficulty yourself with different you could say "modifiers" and at ublock the true difficulty!)
TDS : Pros: -More Content ( Skin Reviews , Frost Blaster Review , Gifts Review , Solo Strats , Balance Changea Review .... ) -More Stuff ( More Skins , Battle Pass ) -Reworks ( frost b and freezer ) -Quests ( Grindy but still cool ) -Unique Gameplay ( unique event , 3 dif maps and themea Cons: -Grindy ( Pyro Quest 💀 ) -Not that much skins , using old enemies and skins ( Every enemy except krampus was already made in past events ) TDX : Pros: -Fun ( idk but tdx gameplay was more fun than tds ) -Simple and Less Grindy ( less time ) -Event in such a short time ( Crazy ) -Hard Mode Coming.... ( ? ) might get more players i dunno Cons : -Not That Unique ( The Game is unique compared to other td games but event isnt that unique compared other modes in tdx ) -Players can leave the game once 6 matchs ( less Player Rate ) -Boss Is a bit simple ( still good in such a short time ) My Opinion as a 66 Lvl TDX and 238 Lvl TDS player
@@Flame.xz29 its a lot more grindy then tdx trust me , i already did all the quests + at 4.5k cookies rn and i can say that it requires a good amount of time
To be fair tdx content isnt that big the hype for the first release was too much for it. And tds has a bigger team and if tdx continues like this tds will just make better events. So tdx will maybe or never will come out on top.(I dont hate tdx I like the event and how easy it is but its just boring)
I completed the pyro quest and it was the most annoying quest I've done so far. It took me at least like 6-7 games, each game is about 23 minutes for solo. Not to mention, i'd still lose once about every 2-3 games when I was halfway through. Pyro is NOT a single target tower, and even though I had the gold perk it still took forever. 0/10 quest would not do again
TDX feels like its falling off with how anti-player it feels, first we got lootboxes with a 98% chance to just get recolors and now most updates just tend to be nerfing rewards to increase how grindy the game is (making modes reward less and moving grinding maps down in difficulty)
Idk about you but tds played it smart. Spending weeks on a project just for ppl to play it once, beat it, then immediately play another game isnt good Thats what happened with act 3
Tdx event was so boring, my first game we swept the event in a random trio, got bored and left and never played the event again. Btw John hired a really good dev team and also has over a million on RUclips providing him with enough money so there’s really no excuse, they also procrastinated and made the event in a week.
I mean somehow you are right with the grind but somehow I also deny ur decision because why should u gain so much cookies every hour? Wheres the grind? Basically what I mean u could complete the battlepass within 1 day and cmon its called battlepass and not dailypass its just because some kids are too lazy and also the 300k pyromancer quest isnt too grindy i did 50k dmg every round so i just did 6 rounds 💀under 2hours (It isnt hate just my opinion)
True, theoretically you could grind it out in one day. but that would be 10-12 hours of grinding, and I don't think anyone has plans on doing something like that. Idk, I'm just a casual tds player.
In my opinion, TDS just had more spectacle, more stuff going on that kept me engaged during the event. The map changing, the new enemies, all of it legitimately had me thinking of plans, where in TDX the Christmas event was still fun but it felt kinda average, Exp Santa was cool and the music and enemies were awesome, but it just felt inferior in quality to the TDS event.
{No hate involved] Do keep in mind that TDX has an inferior number of 12 Devs when compared to TDS with 22 along with the fact that they had probably made this event and polished it before making Lunar Overture by using the time given to them by pushing out skin crate updates [Hence the reason the Lunar Overture event was unfinished] and TDX had barely a month before having to release the event for people to enjoy since the game just released and they are focusing more on QoL updates and adding/programming the back-liners in [Already made towers but they haven't added yet since those towers needed balancing] rather than event and other mechanics as a whole.
yeah, these videos always get views, but are always too innacurate. I tried to stay away from them for a bit, but I just felt the need to make another, and it blew up. I'll try to see if I can do something different for my next video
Make some cool content so ur channel dont die. maybe something original like tdx challenges or tds. Example = try to win fallen mode in Trio *but you can use only golden scout* with random people@@Mint3a
I feel like another reason tds’s event did so well is because it’s more endgame-player friendly. This happens to all games, but there will be a time where the player does everything in the game, obtains all cosmetics and upgrades and basically beats the game as a whole. For tds, solo triumphing krampus’s revenge is a breath of fresh air, at least for the time being.
I quitted tds after they added the engineer, it wasn't worth it getting back to grind. Now i feel refreshed in tdx because its new, kind of nostalgic and beginner-friendly (easy is actually easy, intermediate is a bit hard if you do not have good units, and expert mode is actually really hard even with good towers.) Plus im kinda a a bit biased here but i enjoyed the tdx event more. Sure it has less content and not that hard, but that's what they want. They want to make the event friendly by making it not so difficult to finish unlike tds (god i hate battlepass only time i spent from it is the eclipse event) only thing i liked from the tds event is how they made it into three phases.. didn't knew tds devs were creative lol
TDS Is better in Difficulty and Quality while TDX Has Unique Enemies and Music, However This is only Part 1, John confirmed that there will be a TDX Part 2 Christmas event with the new HARD MODE and etc.
You sure are they better at difficulty? Like example normal is harder than molten hardcore is more easier than badlands and polluted wasteland 2 like hardcore is literally a soloable mode while badlands and pw2 didn't due to spam enemies
1:57 uhhh yeah the whole event was made in about 2 1/2 weeks or so pretty sure that includes all the skins and the boss (tds btw) also 2:40 this quest is much faster in solo compared to literally any other player count, especially if you have gpyro and jester it takes a minimum 2 games
tds would gain the attention of players but when the event is over the player count drop a lot and players would play tdx because they have nothing to do in tds
Tdx I beat it first try even if I have people who have the best towers I should not beaver to beat it first try while tds made me find out what’s good which made me make a solo strat which makes you feel good you did something
As John himself said, the event didn't have much time and was pretty rushed. I don't really hate the event, but obviously TDS was way better with the event
The TDX event was genuinely boring for me (Our whole team was over level 60 and it was a trio, we beat it first try with minimum effort so it was extremely boring)
Thing is, they didnt had time for event and they are actively adding new towers. I agree TDS did it alot better but TDX was alot more fun because it was easier and alot more fun
Personally I preferred the tds event since it was simple and easy and fun to replay but tdx event was hard maybe because the game did release not too long ago but I still can’t beat the event lol
Some mistakes had to be called out during editing, but I hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, maybe subscribe if you aren't already?
Discord Link: discord.gg/z5WaQqv5cR
Song: Tix Blasterz By Key After Key. Made for a cool Roblox game called Phighting.
how is it scummy just having more content tho?
Idk why you even compare since tdx don't even have 1 year of release while tds has around 5+ years
I think the reason why tds might have done better is because tdx is a fairly new game and when tds has no new updates people play tdx but when there’s a event from tds people try to get tds even done and then move on to tdx.
Why are we comparing events from deferent games instead of playing the events that we ACTUALLY enjoy?
Idk views
I imagine that the reason why this could be is because that john realised that other games will have a christmas event so making the event shorter but still difficult to a degree makes it something where you arn't needed to spend alot of time on. This causes you to enjoy the event more and gives you more time to play other games christmas events. In my opinion i find this to be better overall as it respects the players time and other games. it also causes hard grinders to acctully celebrate the holiday instead of wasting the celebration day on a game. It also means casual players (like me) to not have to worry about the event and not to be like "oh i really want this skin but i need to grind for 10 hours for it so i wont bother as i can go have fun on something else" which means individual players can see the tower and use the tower or skins and still have the enthusiasm to use it rather then getting burn't out and not wanting to use it.
Edit:just fixed some grammer issues
That’s actually what I loved about the evnt as well. I’m a causal player, I have never grounded for anything too ridiculous, so that’s why I have like only a couple battle pass skins.
Happy Christmas man thankyou thats what i thought too
this is true man, especially if you only have little time, you don't have to worry about the fear of missing out like i used to do on tds
I can totally understand what are you talking about. But you don't really have to grind for 10 hours to actually complete the event unlike the others. Just grind for it an hour per day and at the end of the day you will get a lot of those features. They already give you the time you need to grind and sometimes it can be longer than it was suppose to be aswell. So don't worry about it
1 hour per day to spend on a game its dificult for some peoples but i agree with you just 2 hours i think its a good time to spend
Keep in mind that TDX has only 14~ devs while TDS has 22 devs, and most of the assets used in the TDS event were obviously reutilized from other events, so they had plenty of time to polish already-existent mechanics and had way more time to prepare since November, while TDX were focusing on QoL and small content updates since the game just released, hence why there is so little content and why the event is generally easy. John even confirmed this by stating, "wish i could've added more but given our time frame after releasing TDX, it was a small window." and "originally i was intending to add 2 versions, easy and hard (we went with an easy one for now so most players can enjoy it)."
Also, I don't want to be that guy, but both of games are good on their own and doesn't need to be compared like this. Just because TDS or TDX had more players than the other at any point, it doesn't make the other "bad".
Yeah, that’s most of the reasons why tds event sorta did better. I feel like the comparison is unavoidable then being the 2 largest td games, but yeah, they are separate games. I’ll probably not make another video like this if that helps.
imagine if it became a harder event, would be really dope
Em sorry? But they were working on 5 New towers, jester, necromancer, cryomancer, the 2 that we still dont know, 3 differents acts with differentes difficulties, this holiday event, the new gamemode thats supposed to be "chaos mode" with a lot of news skins, so now shut up tdx fanboy
@@Flame.xz29 The halloween event ended in the start of November, that gave them plenty of time to recover and start making a new update again, which was the quests update for the christmas event.
What do you mean I'm a "TDX fanboy"? I just mentioned in the comment "both games are good on their own and doesn't need to be compared like this"?
stfu idiot tdx JUST RELEASED its actually impressive they made a whoel event in such a small time frame while TDS was already working months before setting everything up TDX is updating WEEKLY but will go to monthly WHICH IS STILL INSANELY GOOD Tds on the other hand updates every few months for like maps and bs or some new skins which nobody cares about and TDX has even better design then TDS and tds is way too grindy its become borderline unplayable now.Tds also manipulates children into FOMO(fear of missing out) just so they can get money with battlepass crap you either pay up or slave away at a game that isnt even fun and is repetitive I honestley wish TDS could be good again but i can't play the game without getting bored i only play it for beating the event testing it out and not playing it again stop meat riding TDS when in back of your head its fallen off and sucks ass now. i know how development works they work on events and stuffs months prior to their month for etc they were working on christmas update in august/september they dont fully start a event with nothing too it yet. not to mention TDX isn't as grindy and isnt just slaving away at fucking game also act 3 was ass tdx is a better game and you can't prove me wrong your just salty you wasted so much time on tds you feel like you cant escape it without it being a waste of money therefore spending more and more.thats what tds devs WANT. you prob haven't even tried TDx yet haven't you?@@Flame.xz29
dont mind bad grammar
tds event is better because u had more things to do
oh no, you summed up the entire video!
Yeah but battlepass too grindy...
@@JGames35 atleast they doulbed the drop rate.
@@Mint3a wikiacolors
Why are we comparing events from deferent games instead of playing something that we enjoy?
My favorite thing is I spent a total of 4 days to get/complate every new thing in TDS (season,skins,quests...) but in TDX, it only took me 2 hours to get the all things. Seriously, only in TDX.
I think TDX is taking the player friendly path, which I think is absolutely correct. Too much grinding isn't fun. Majority of the playerbase of tower defense games are Kids and Teens. I dont think they have much time to grind so much. But I do have to say, TDS did revive their playerbase back with the reworks and all. Bravos to them
personally me i am loving the frost blaster rework and i like grinding for stuff, it makes me really feel like i earned it rather then it being given to me, that just me though.
Not gonna lie, it was much more fun for TDX event than the TDS event. So much so that I tried speedrunning it and used to hold the world record with a few group of friends. It could be that TDX is newer and thus I have less burnout from the game but still. Overall TDS has much more content than TDX and that’s what kept the player count stable.
The tds one is also very easy
The tdx one is very easy to@@basskit_
i love how no one mentions this, but tds has legit been around since 2019, while tdx started being created around mid 2022. tds literally has time on there side.
@@Killer_the_exister mf literally everyone has said that
Something i liked about the TDS event is that it was more... "exploitable" and out of the meta. Like it and frost invasion were one of the only events to actually make placing accel asap a not good strategy, specially because accel is too expensive early game and the enemies divide into two main paths, and when going further into the track their paths get more far, meaning that splash towers and long-range are the meta for that event. Secondly, the bosses there do have lots of health but it isn't something big enough to make splash-based towers do nothing against Krampus, you just need to put some dps at the later waves and you'll be fine. It really had a different experience from most other gamemodes because the normal meta wasn't as effective as using a loadout focusing with splash damage and/or high range. By the "exploitable" part i mean is that the challenges in the event had actual solutions that were very effective without being spamming accels, engis or minis
I also loved how it changed the freeze tower meta. All freeze toers now have a purpose, and sledger isn't just straight up OP. You need at least 2 freeze tower to simulate a effect similar to what sledger had back then.
I soloed by spamming accel, engi and gpyro before discovering you could win without them
@@legendaryace2131how did you get through fallen angels (the flying enemies)
@@joaoborgesrodriguesalves6554 any cliff towers or any towers with flying dection. I would recommend Mortar
@@joaoborgesrodriguesalves6554 engi detects flying and they only mention 4 towers so I think the 5th one is the tower that deals with them since engis flying is trash
totally agree lol. i really wish the tdx event had more content to it, but because of the lack of it, tds really pulled here with the event. tds's event was a pleasant surprise too!
The main reason tdx event was not as good: it was a quickly devoloped event made to be begginer friendly, and it's a bit early to add crazy mechanics.
True, you dont just have an event on the level of expert mode when the game was released like 1 month ago
@FianYTreal They said there are going to be 2 difficulties you can choose for the event [Easy] and Hard hence, the cloned EXO Santa
@FianYTrealbeginner can still choose easy mode to play💀
Tdx is better because they were going to add a nightmare version of the event where when multiplier x makes contact with XO Santa he will duplicate xo Santa then you have two bosses to kill but they didn’t have time before the event launched so he announced that it will be added soon It will be a game mode so you could play it. On any map and it’s just the first event and that’s just the warm up for tdx they will make a comeback and tdx has a smaller team so it’s unfair
tdx is going into the replayability route john is added a (REDACTED) mode which is the nightmare mode in diffculty game
Alright, first of all. TDS is an older game than TDX and they already got the devs that know what to do for the future updates. TDS prepared quests, season pass and provided us with a lot of new skins that people would for sure grind for and keep replayability ongoing. TDX on other hands is like.."Beat an event multiple time for all skins" and thats it. And since TDX is such a boring game to grind and it has so much downsides what tds fixed a long time ago, TDX replayability is absolutely dog ####. They didn't add any content that could keep players playing it, the replayability is low and I can say that TDX event despite being easy, the wave layout of enemy was horrifying. Me myself beated TDX event 6 times for all skins and stopped playing it while in TDS i am still grinding and enjoying the updated the delivered to the community. I am not hating on any game, but the these reasons MIntGamng mentioned are so stubborn that my head hurts because of it.
Ngl i kinda agree with you as well. Also pretty funny that he said that he doesn't wanna hate on TDS yet does so anyway. Typical TDX Meatrider behavior mate. As for both events, yeah I enjoyed the TDS one far more than TDX, tho that's mainly due to reasons you already mentioned. What more can I add other than that I hope that TDS will continue with this pace. Perhaps Razuatix leaving the dev team + TDX's mid christmas event has graced TDS with good luck lmfaoo.
Fun fact: when tds was first released their first gladiator event actually attracted around 20-40k players which is where tds became a very huge game
no it didnt attract 40k lmao not sure hwere you got that info
@@trax6913 I got that info from my own brain since I started playing tds since its release so I know damn well the gladiator event was very popular
@@trax6913 you expect it to have 2k? Tds was already huge since its release
@@tdchad5894 in 2019 20k-40k was jailbreak levels. a roblox game that was made for a school project did NOT pass the giant that was jailbreak. in 2019 things like heck even meepcity had like 10k players. stop lying bro
thanks for actually having constructive criticism instead of just saying complete bullshit like photon did.
The 300k pyro damage quest can literally be done in only 2 solo rounds
@@RANDOM-GUY0987 I’ve legit done it in 2 using gpyro mortar + supports
WOW, lots of people have told me 2-3 duo rounds, but to think it was possible solo..
@@RANDOM-GUY0987i did 2
Hm, now that i think about it..
People keep saying that cryomancer from tds was ripped from tdx WHILE tdx ripped that from tbz and cryo ranger is ripped from reworked freezer from tds and i have heard not one soul mention this. I love both games but i once agaim feel like people praise tdx wayy too much and therefore try to call out tds for basically anything.. i mean look at elite.
People told me that they’d copied each others homework from each other, funny joke to describe a problem with Roblox itself
WE'RE MAKING TDX STANS HAVE A MENTAL BREAKDOWN 🗣️🔥🔥🔥
GREAT VIDEO
Braindead tds player
Simple answer: tdx had less time to make a xmas event with tds with the game just being released but they still did good for what time they had.
Eventually, we're going to have players have a civil war in the tower defense community between these two games.
It's kinda impressive that sucha young game like tdx got so many players in a short period of time
Another thing is that while both of the event were easy tdx is very easy and tds is a bit harder. Tdx allows you to beat the event in one attempt if your not going for the skins and tds it’s harder and has more content.
You can solo event with a strat.
It's not depends on how hard is it.
Just ppl are too lazy to do every single move on the strat
the tdx event will have a hard mode in a few days/weeks , the devs intentionally made it beginner friendly so that most players get the skins
thanki goodness, because I dont know if I can beat hardmode. I suck at tdx
i mean why they couldn't just delay the events for some days so hardmode and easy mode for Christmas can released at same time
I hope there is a reward for only hard mode
@@Tommy_Handsburger They had to release it on Christmas, people would obviously complain if they delayed it (the community is cancer)
This is TDX first event so of course it’s not perfect but that’s fine, i think in the future the events will be great
The tds and tdx event was alright. TDS rushed the event to not make their game collapse and the event tower is extremely unbalanced and the tdx event was too easy but the grind wasn’t too hard. However tds event makes you waste your time in that game for hours grinding for every skins, crates, and gadgets.
TDX is still beta and is doing way better than tds
@@emilyy86 tdx has 4k players when i just got a update and tds has 6k players with out an update. "TdX iS dOinG wAy BeTtEr tHaN TdS
TDX is still pretty new, and i can't wait for the future TDX events since kt will definitely get more mechanics and stuff
TDX devs are much more creative with their towers. I think this game is gonna skyrocket in popularity
@@stone8519I saw some towers that are not creative we have a
Skull tower that had a sharp thing at the tail of the gun and they even showed it can be used as a melee
Agent don't know what he does
War machine
War factory
Golden towers
Grenadier
Jet spawner it's more like a unit than a tower
And alot
also john said there are 60 towers actually planned for tdx
@@kcssi4662 😳
I honestly think that tds was threatened by tdx as an like a competitior which made them more motivated to make a better event
Tdx not only makes a good td game, but makes other td games better. Only in tdx.
@@Mint3a fr only in tdx
Yall are actully meatriding tdx so much
Yeah I agree, because TDS literally had a whole unstoppable monopoly on roblox tower defense games, but now TDX as a competitor causes them to try harder in order to not lose at their own game
well by the tower defense simulator's grindies for literally everything and for tower defense X's copiness of tower blitz....
I THINK THAT PHIGHTING! WINS IN THIS SITUATION
Still for a first event its pretty impressive, and making new models instead of using old ones is harder, I understand why TDS was better
The music in the tds event was banging too 👌
Dude you are absolutely right. The TDS quests are way to addictive for my mental health.
I mostly said that because most people feel that way, not me. I’ve done like 1, and that’s just beating the event itself lol.
Nah fr I just got my first golden tower and after completing all the quests I’m close to the second one
Nah lev 300 here beat event get my ass out of there I'm not doing that shit quest
to be honest tho, Tdx is the only TD game that released in a month and got an event also in a month which is highly impressive
No it isn't lol tds had a event less then a month before it's release
Theres still more to come for both games i really hope tdx starts doing better but as john said nightmare mode and many other things are in the works so im pretty confident
Here’s the thing… you have to be level 5 to play the tdx event which causes brand new players not being able to play, so they will go to tds sense they can be any level to play the event.
Yes but the difference is you can beat tdx event with beginner towers unlike tds
The event is not that hard you can beat with sniper
some people just got themselves carried to elite win to go straight to level 5 lol
bro i love your vids your editing is so good and makes me calm lol
Glad you like them!
Oh yeah I subbed too
Agree with most points
I do like the tds event better because I feel like it is cool that the boss can jump paths
tds also brought back nostalgia…
Bad nostalgia
people keep crying about "WEEHHHHHHHHHH THE TDX EVENT TOO EASY TDS IS BETTER WEHHHHHHHHHHH" but he made it EASY BECAUSE EVERYBODY WAS NEW, if it was like their 2nd event, he would have made it near impossible
this aged amazingly
I enjoyed both to be honest, both have pros and cons, I do think tbh that the Santa robot thing is kinda dumb and wish there was more of an explanation on why all these Christmas themed enemies are attacking, but nonetheless both are worthwhile.
tbh santa robot face looks goofy
I think TDS's event was better because I like small details and in tds there were many details.The maps were cool and with that refund future and the map changing I like it a lot. And I liked the maps designs.
"Quest system, that would make so many players have so much stuff to accomplish in their event"
last time i checked a normal game gave more then a singular daily.
Heres what happened for me - 1. Realise tds updated😐 2. Played the event. Game gud🤠 3. Died from a big black monkey🎅🏿. 4. Bad gaem😡😡 5. Realise tdx update🗣️🗣️🎅6. Play tdx event😮 7. Win😆 8. Tower gud yes yes💪💪🏿
TDX is not a serious grinding game so I enjoy playing casually.
same, when I get bored of grinding hard on tds, take a break with a quick intermediate round
Me personally I kind of like tdx's event a bit more. I can see why someone would like the tds one more and why someone could think why it'd be better. But I personally like tdx's more because it's... simple I am probably speaking out of nostalgia more than anything else. It was... simple, no multi paths, no defend the center, no several parts, and no super crazy gimmick enemies. The fact that there was no music or anything just really made me remember why I loved events like halloween 2019 so much. It wasn't trying to go above and beyond and I had some good fun with my friends like I did nearly 5 years ago.
Both were fun, however TDX’s doesn’t have much replayability while TDS has cookies and other features. Also, keeping a consistent story works for TDS incredibly well.
while i have quit tds a while ago, i can say the TDX eveent probably wins long-term, it was more enjoyable and wayy less grindy, leaving a good image for the layerbase of what to expect soon instead of a grindfest like tds
most people consider the tds event very good
Its obvious how TDS pulled out something we never expected. A winter event which has 3 towers released (Freezer reworked,Frost blaster reworked and new event tower cyromancer.)
Which was just released after 2 days of the trailer release and many much content so that they could finally deserve some respect from their community and no arguement or hate on it. It also wasnt delayed and phoqus absolutely carried the event with the music while destroying the enemies. TDX is also appreciable since it has much lesser devs and is in beta. I dont know any more about this but this is all i could comment
if you are wondering what the background music is it is tix blasterz by key after key from PHIGHTING thank me later
I credited now
oh ok@@Mint3a
well made video
WOOOOO CORSO CAME!!!!!
for some reason, i started tdx, played a bit, got pretty good, missile trooper, barracks, and some other stuff, but then i quit. i dont know why, but i just like tds more then tdx. im a level 250 with basically every troop (excluding commando) in tds, and from what i could tell, just from the first month of release, tdx is dying. on the first day it had 30k players, then the next day, it had 7k. they might make a comeback but who knows. but one thing is for sure: tds will never die. also regarding what you said at 2:00, no they delayed the event quite a bit for tds and couldnt add some content, this was due to the razuatix situation, as he left tds, will also not be coming back permanently, which slowed down production a bit. the player count for tdx however, may be because many tds players play tdx, giving a big roadblock for the player count of tdx.
yeah, very true claims we have here.
Both events were amazing, the only reason why tds has more player count than tdx is the fact that it has a battlepass, a really grindy one too. Which keeps the player grinding the game until they complete it. Tdx on the other hand, you only needa win 6 times to finish everything the event has to offer.
yeah, now we wait for hard mode
TDX winter event was straight ass, i have beaten them both, TDS was better in basically every way
Yeah, though I can't blame them since the game has only been out for a month and they've been doing bi weekly updates.
@@Mint3aI actually think TDS started developing faster, more intensely due to TDX being released
@@Mint3a (and has been in development for 1 year and a half)
Maybe, though I will say that the tds event has more quality. I just enjoyed tdx more because as a casual player I liked how non grindy it was lol.
I had so much more fun grinding the tds event. the quality is higher and the event was really good for a 2 week development period. I beat thew tdx event first try. Like you said, there is much more content in tds. TDX has potential but right now... TDS > TDX
Yeah, though as a casual player that ain’t my kinda thing. I don’t typically grind stuff, so the only thing that motivates me to grind is to grind on stream lol.
But I think overtime, TDX will start to gain popularity and might have the chance to overcome TDS. The probabilities of this happening is still pretty low because of the huge playerbase TDS has. TDX had just been released recently and it has outstanding potential to become one of the greatest tower defense games ever in roblox. It's realistic, It's balanced and It has everything you just want.
@@Mint3a make sense. Because you make money from it.
the tds event was actually only worked on in december while tdx was in the late october
so tds made better event in shorter time
huh. I dont have much else to say.
bro the devs said they got 2 weeks while tdx got like 1 month but event is nice
also bro i think its also because of the recent lunar overture event that tds is still gettting hate because tdx didint do the same mistake as tds did because he understands if he does this he will make a huge mistake so basically the player base love tdx because of how bad act 3 was and still even getting hate including elite ;-;
0:51 To be fair, Tdx is a new game so it will not have as many players for an event, and they probably did not do the event as well as tds which is an older and more bigger td game. So therefore the event may be better than tdx
the game it’s still really popular and the release hype for tdx was really big and people play it a lot because it’s a new game so players can play it a lot and not get bored (I still think tds is better)
@@MRDIVU91 yea that is true ig
If john makes a Halloween event they should add a ghost that chases players around like tower galatica or residence massacre
Will also say that TDS has been around for much longer than TDX, so TDS is already really well established and a lot more people know about. Meanwhile, TDX is newer and not as many people know about it so it's not as popular as TDX, meaning that even if their event was better in every aspect compared to TDS's event TDS would still get more players.
Also it's funny how it takes like 2 hours to get every TDX skin but it can (I believe) take more than 20 hours to get every skin in TDS
Although TDS is more popular rn, it feels like a level out, maybe mid-2024
TDS went through some kind of curve in players, peaking earlier in the years, frost invasion, the fun of the game, even for roblox in general. Games get grindier and less fun as they grow to be popular.
TDX is walking the same path, so it will gain the players TDS had like in 2022, and foresee the mistakes.
but TDS is better, but Lunar Overture 💀
TDX is a fusion of Tower Blitz and CTD
I grinded both and saw what both had to offer.
TDX seems to have grabbed the most barebones mechanics from both like tower hp from CTD and the two paths from Tower Blitz. It carryies no other unique mechanics and add ons from both like CTD's enemyies having unique interactions with other enemyies. Perks and more!
In a nutshel TDX gets boring fast without quests and operations or daily challanges, also the grind is too tough i aien't got time for that. (Null chambers gives towers you dont use unique circumstances so they can shine bright again! Sacrificial hall is about YOU making the difficulty yourself with different you could say "modifiers" and at ublock the true difficulty!)
TDS :
Pros:
-More Content ( Skin Reviews , Frost Blaster Review , Gifts Review , Solo Strats , Balance Changea Review .... )
-More Stuff ( More Skins , Battle Pass )
-Reworks ( frost b and freezer )
-Quests ( Grindy but still cool )
-Unique Gameplay ( unique event , 3 dif maps and themea
Cons:
-Grindy ( Pyro Quest 💀 )
-Not that much skins , using old enemies and skins ( Every enemy except krampus was already made in past events )
TDX :
Pros:
-Fun ( idk but tdx gameplay was more fun than tds )
-Simple and Less Grindy ( less time )
-Event in such a short time ( Crazy )
-Hard Mode Coming.... ( ? ) might get more players i dunno
Cons :
-Not That Unique ( The Game is unique compared to other td games but event isnt that unique compared other modes in tdx )
-Players can leave the game once 6 matchs ( less Player Rate )
-Boss Is a bit simple ( still good in such a short time )
My Opinion as a 66 Lvl TDX and 238 Lvl TDS player
Omg, this is perfect. I’m surprised people are spending so much time making these types of analyses
I mean,tdx is a new game
@@12davindrafeliziowigie-ir51 as i said , tdx releasing an event in such a short time is crazy.
"Grindy" 🤓, bro get better u can get that on 4 hours
@@Flame.xz29 its a lot more grindy then tdx trust me , i already did all the quests + at 4.5k cookies rn and i can say that it requires a good amount of time
1 millisecond in and i already hear phighting music, respect
Tds does have a better event than tdx but trust me in the future tdx will come out on top
Tdx is basically lacking tho I mean it's just starting off they been planning on a lot of towers in their devlogs
To be fair tdx content isnt that big the hype for the first release was too much for it. And tds has a bigger team and if tdx continues like this tds will just make better events. So tdx will maybe or never will come out on top.(I dont hate tdx I like the event and how easy it is but its just boring)
I took me only 3 solo matches in event to complete the quest (using gpyro. In my opinion hardest quest is kill 6 ripped and gatekeeper
I completed the pyro quest and it was the most annoying quest I've done so far. It took me at least like 6-7 games, each game is about 23 minutes for solo. Not to mention, i'd still lose once about every 2-3 games when I was halfway through. Pyro is NOT a single target tower, and even though I had the gold perk it still took forever. 0/10 quest would not do again
Too bad to TDS because xmas nightmare is on the way in TDX.
Well the game is still new no player doesn't know the game yet
theyre releasing a hard mode soon but its the most laziest they can do they just added a new multiplier to multiply exo santa while having no cash
I kinda agree , using mortal in the event is already the most eye candy thing I ever seen
yeah, accel is actually sorta not needed, at least for early game
TDX feels like its falling off with how anti-player it feels, first we got lootboxes with a 98% chance to just get recolors and now most updates just tend to be nerfing rewards to increase how grindy the game is (making modes reward less and moving grinding maps down in difficulty)
Tds winter event:bro this is fire!
Tdx winter event:blud the boss was walmart santa💀
fun fact.
It only took 2-3 matches to complete Pyro quest with just Gpyro
also about normal one could be 4 or 5
yea If only you have friend.
hmmm, aw4some, teh person who I asked how they felt about the quest, said they were on their 6th match. maybe a skill issue lol
Its not better, just more grindy. And thats all. So thats why i respect tdx event more this time, cause it respects my time
I’m not trying to say tds was better, just was successful. I honestly love that tdx wasn’t grindy, as I’m a casual player myself.
But it was infact better in terms of quality and gameplay, and the only aspect that tdx had over tds was it being less grindy
Idk about you but tds played it smart. Spending weeks on a project just for ppl to play it once, beat it, then immediately play another game isnt good
Thats what happened with act 3
@@Vanny1980limited ugc and pumpkin grind:
give TDX a break it literally came out like 1 month ago
I mean it just came out we should not compare these two until it had grown to it's golden age or prime stage
true, I definitely overlooked that
Tix Blasterz as background music 🥶🥶🥶, besides from this, idk what to say but both events are pretty good
they gave us 40 days so i think its reasonable for the quests to be grindy
Tdx event was so boring, my first game we swept the event in a random trio, got bored and left and never played the event again. Btw John hired a really good dev team and also has over a million on RUclips providing him with enough money so there’s really no excuse, they also procrastinated and made the event in a week.
I mean somehow you are right with the grind but somehow I also deny ur decision because why should u gain so much cookies every hour? Wheres the grind? Basically what I mean u could complete the battlepass within 1 day and cmon its called battlepass and not dailypass its just because some kids are too lazy and also the 300k pyromancer quest isnt too grindy i did 50k dmg every round so i just did 6 rounds 💀under 2hours (It isnt hate just my opinion)
True, theoretically you could grind it out in one day. but that would be 10-12 hours of grinding, and I don't think anyone has plans on doing something like that. Idk, I'm just a casual tds player.
another reason is probably because tds is ALOT more polished while in the other hand, tdx is rather just dry quality
I would say it is the opposite honestly.
I have everything in both games before you say anything and quit tds some time ago.
In my opinion, TDS just had more spectacle, more stuff going on that kept me engaged during the event. The map changing, the new enemies, all of it legitimately had me thinking of plans, where in TDX the Christmas event was still fun but it felt kinda average, Exp Santa was cool and the music and enemies were awesome, but it just felt inferior in quality to the TDS event.
{No hate involved] Do keep in mind that TDX has an inferior number of 12 Devs when compared to TDS with 22 along with the fact that they had probably made this event and polished it before making Lunar Overture by using the time given to them by pushing out skin crate updates [Hence the reason the Lunar Overture event was unfinished] and TDX had barely a month before having to release the event for people to enjoy since the game just released and they are focusing more on QoL updates and adding/programming the back-liners in [Already made towers but they haven't added yet since those towers needed balancing] rather than event and other mechanics as a whole.
I think the reason tdx didnt hit more than 40k players online because the game is just in beta. Dont judge it too much
Yeah maybe if but they are lacking updates tho just like what old tds did they are adding some special modes like endless,pvp and sandbox
yeah, these videos always get views, but are always too innacurate. I tried to stay away from them for a bit, but I just felt the need to make another, and it blew up. I'll try to see if I can do something different for my next video
Make some cool content so ur channel dont die. maybe something original like tdx challenges or tds. Example = try to win fallen mode in Trio *but you can use only golden scout* with random people@@Mint3a
@@EradicatorPenny coincidence, I'm doing a challenge rn lol. video gonna ake awhile though
I feel like another reason tds’s event did so well is because it’s more endgame-player friendly. This happens to all games, but there will be a time where the player does everything in the game, obtains all cosmetics and upgrades and basically beats the game as a whole. For tds, solo triumphing krampus’s revenge is a breath of fresh air, at least for the time being.
i still think tds is better i mean the game was with us for so long it like a childhood to us
I feel like it's also just TDX's first event so... it's just going to get better overtime.
spring event prob be a w sicne they have more time
@@Mint3ayeaaaa
The Pyro kill Krampus quest should be any tower tbh to make it more fun
Freezer 💀
NOOOOOO
my favourite part is when krampus skips one third of the track
I quitted tds after they added the engineer, it wasn't worth it getting back to grind. Now i feel refreshed in tdx because its new, kind of nostalgic and beginner-friendly (easy is actually easy, intermediate is a bit hard if you do not have good units, and expert mode is actually really hard even with good towers.) Plus im kinda a a bit biased here but i enjoyed the tdx event more. Sure it has less content and not that hard, but that's what they want. They want to make the event friendly by making it not so difficult to finish unlike tds (god i hate battlepass only time i spent from it is the eclipse event) only thing i liked from the tds event is how they made it into three phases.. didn't knew tds devs were creative lol
Nostalgic? 💀💀
TDS Is better in Difficulty and Quality while TDX Has Unique Enemies and Music, However This is only Part 1, John confirmed that there will be a TDX Part 2 Christmas event with the new HARD MODE and etc.
You sure are they better at difficulty? Like example normal is harder than molten hardcore is more easier than badlands and polluted wasteland 2 like hardcore is literally a soloable mode while badlands and pw2 didn't due to spam enemies
If check tdx difficult some of them make sense
1:57
uhhh yeah the whole event was made in about 2 1/2 weeks or so
pretty sure that includes all the skins and the boss (tds btw)
also 2:40
this quest is much faster in solo compared to literally any other player count, especially if you have gpyro and jester it takes a minimum 2 games
TDS Events gave me a headache but it's really cool, While TDX is kinda fun and easier.
John Roblox said that him and his team didn’t have enough time to make it a replayable event. But I get it it’s a new game .
the big reason is that tdx is a new game, right? the tower defence simulator team put together the winter event in a couple of weeks :)
music:
- Ten Pin Toss Up
i think the reason tds had over 75k is because it has been out for years whereas tdx hasn’t therefore hasn’t gained as much popularity
agreed
agreed
Exactly
For the quest on tds " deal 300.000 damage on krampus " its not hard too if you doing solo and golden...
tds would gain the attention of players but when the event is over the player count drop a lot and players would play tdx because they have nothing to do in tds
Tdx I beat it first try even if I have people who have the best towers I should not beaver to beat it first try while tds made me find out what’s good which made me make a solo strat which makes you feel good you did something
As John himself said, the event didn't have much time and was pretty rushed. I don't really hate the event, but obviously TDS was way better with the event
comparing a game thats 1 year old and it is it's first event to a 5 year old game with a shit ton of experience with events💀
This year was bad for TDX like they have alot of stuff to do but next crhistmas that next year will most likely be much better
The TDX event was genuinely boring for me
(Our whole team was over level 60 and it was a trio, we beat it first try with minimum effort so it was extremely boring)
yeah, mainly aimed towards beginners lol
@@Mint3a Main reason I found it boring 💀
Weird how TDS and TDX aim their events towards completely different audiences 💀
I think the tds event is for experienced players, whilst the tdx event is for new players
Thing is, they didnt had time for event and they are actively adding new towers. I agree TDS did it alot better but TDX was alot more fun because it was easier and alot more fun
Personally I preferred the tds event since it was simple and easy and fun to replay but tdx event was hard maybe because the game did release not too long ago but I still can’t beat the event lol