Battlefield 4 vs 2042 (Portal Guns included) - Weapons Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- 0:00 HANDGUNS
3:22 SHOTGUNS
6:50 SMGs
8:13 RIFLES
13:22 DMRs/Sniper RIFLES
16:41 LMGs
20:11 LAUNCHERS
Which one is which? - First, BF4, second BF 2042.
"Which is better" playlist:
• Which is better?
BATTLEFIELD playlist:
• Battlefield playlist
Call of Duty playlist:
• Call of Duty playlist
Rainbow Six playlist:
• Rainbow Six playlist
Far Cry playlist:
• Far Cry playlist
---------
All content from this video and this channel is recorded and edited exclusively by me. I NEVER use clips or any kind of content from someone else. 
Игры
![[DOKKAN BATTLE] August Producer's Letter](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JUTYpaV_4Ic/mqdefault.jpg)
BF4 all The way, better sounds and Better reload animations
Exactly
No contest needed.
Some 2042 models are more accurate, but still.
Yea
Robotic reload
16:48 Now that’s a perfect and satisfying M60 reload animation. BF4 may be old, but it’s still by far the greatest Battlefield game as of recently. Right next to Bad Company 2.
Except no ? Any animator would tell you that it’s not a good animation at all.
Also BF3 is a far superior game, the maps in 4 are some of the worst of the whole franchise.
@@melcorchancla9431 I disagree with all of your statements. First off, what’s wrong with the M60 reload animation in BF4? I think it’s smooth, decently timed, and more realistic than the M60 reload animation in BF3.
And no, I highly doubt every animator in the world is going to tell me the reload animation is terrible.
I also think BF4 has many enjoyable maps, especially in the expansion maps.
Although you claim BF3 to be a “superior game” to BF4, I need you to back up your subjective claim with evidence to convince me otherwise.
And yet the evidence never came…
@@lemoncandy2707 I can give a few reasons that I personally like 3 more than 4. Although not too different I like the TTK in 3 more than 4. Something I dislike about 4 is I think they went too crazy with all class weapons and blurred the lines between classes a little too much, not as bad as 2042 in that regard but still. Map wise a lot of BF4's vanilla maps can be very vehicle dominant (Golmud, Lancang, Rouge, hell even Paracel and Shanghai at times) as a lot of BF4's maps are big but lack cover. BF3 can have that same problem but never got to the point of BF4 where every time I seem to play 4 I find myself having to only play engineer.
@@melcorchancla9431 bf3 is meh.
With such a thumbnail of the video you realize the love that its original creators and other talent involved put into battlefield 4
yall were NOT saying this in 2014
@@relevant3773 because bf 2042 wasn't out in 2014
@@meilikino that doesnt change the fact in 2014 the game was literally unplayable at least 2042 u could log on and play
Wasn’t much to play if you could get onto 2042 lol
Игра 2013 года выглядит в 100 раз лучше, чем игра 2021 года. Браво, Dice!
Как по мне, эта "игра 2013 года" во всём лучше этой чуть ли не китайской копии новой колды. В плане графона у частей серии Battlefield до недавних пор с этим уж точно проблем не было, в пример можно взять пятёрку и первую часть, там графон был, как по мне, на высочайшем уровне. Смотря на некоторые карты BF2042, тон в целом, и сравнивая всё это с тем же из BF4, у меня создаётся впечатление, что по лору апокалипсис наступил именно что в BF4, а не иначе.
@NateZurlent xd ?
BF1, BFV and BF4 are pretty good in their own right, 2042 just felt like A MW mod
When it comes to animation only the base 2042 weapons and those that also re-used the base animation looked good. And yeah BF4 definitely won entirely when it comes to sound design.
Edit: Most sniper looked great in 2042 tho. Probably because they re-used one of my favorites animation in the game, the sws-10.
Bro Bf 2042 is like if COD and BF got married 😂
@@jonisalia15 the worst of each
In fact, all the animations on the sniper rifles are wrong in 2042. In real life most of the bolt action sniper rifles will not allow you to close the bolt on an empty magazine.
Most of you guys don't know battlefield 4 was unfinish and disappointment but after 3 years updates become the best battlefield game this gonna happen with 2042
@@fotis_sar._ hahahaha no.
I just don’t know how they made all the guns seem so large in 2042. Like the spas in BF4 looks like a good side and like the character can actually hold it but then you look at 2042 and it looks like the character is struggling to hold onto it
I think this has to do with two factors. The first is that 2042/Portal tends to put its guns closer to the screen than 4. This makes them seem bigger. The second is that 2042 uses a lot more movement, making the guns feel much less contained.
Sounds: BF4 ftw. They sound a lot more natural and realistic. 2042 has good sounds but some are considered bland to me.
Animations: BF4 again, i prefer floaty looking animations rather than having completely bad ones. (I know 2042's animations are made by a seperate studio but still)
Models: BF4 yet again.. I don't have to tell you why
Verdict: This will probably be my last comment ever as i'm dealing with life issues. But overall BF4 proves to be the superior one as usual. Tons of wacky memories here, i'll never forget it. Thank you all!
Update: Right now i'm doing pretty fine and thanks for all the people that cared for me. I'll still be around but my access to the internet is now kinda limited.
bye
Damn man hope you get better soon lad
Ah dont worry you'll be better. This wont be the last one pal. You'll be ok 👍
Who the fuck are you?
I'll miss ya, lad
Take a break from the internet, you've seen enough
And get better soon
As much as I dislike 2042, I will say that I do like the detail of the soldier taking their finger off the trigger when they stop firing.
Yes but In real life, soldiers are trained to take out their fingers anytime they are are not aiming and ready to fire on the target so the finger should be off much quicker than showed in those animations.
@@elenrad8023 At least it is even represented
by content and animation quality you'd never guess which one came out in 2013
Bf4 animations are nostalgic.
Though i will never be able to ignore one thing that always bothers me with bf4 pistol reloads.
the character never press the mag release.
Or save mags
@MTB
They also don't use the fire selectors. It's weird when you hear the selector click but the character doesn't even touch it and the selector doesn't change position either.
They should recruit you, MTB. You have become pretty good over the years. I'm sure that your animations would end up better than those in BF2042 Portal.
@@honzabalak3462 hey buddy, you don't need to copy the person name, you can just tap on their comment and you'll reply to them
@@EarthyTeddy I can't. For some reason there's a 50/50 chance of it working on android.
See? It worked in this case. But when I reply to MTB it doesn't.
@@honzabalak3462 yea just dont click on the reply, just comment ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
When you can't even surpass your own prehistoric games
Nice username
in this case, bf4 definitely won
yes
So did BF3 when compared to Portal.
It all come down to sound design
@@bambamShaun_YT And animations. And details.
Maybe sound design and some animations. But most of the animations are better in 2042
2042's animations are so awful. It looks like the soldier is having a seizure, spazzing and jittering constantly.
You are so, so unbelievably lucky that Mrbrightside didn't animate the DAO shotgun.
@E_S_Reloaded the man who animated several tactical games' reloads such as insurgency...he has a animation for a g3 with a drum that lasts 11 seconds...
Battlefield 4 animations are serviceable nothing crazy, bf2042 have more diversity in the movement of the anims, less recycles I'd say. We can say that some aspects of the newer games are ''better'' without saying the whole thing is guys. Animators have nothing to do with the rest of the game.
AN-94 Reload in BF4 still my favourite
i hope they add more vehicles to portal from the older titles
Reloading animation in BF4 : Simple, less exaggeration, effective.
Reloading animation in BF2042 : Hand Tremor.
Not gonna lie, I was pretty disappointed with the 93R in BF4. Not only did it perform worse in my opinion (it was literally my go-to sidearm in BF3, the second being the G18), but it also had a ridiculously incorrect model. Which is also weird, considering BF3 got it right. Despite being based on the Beretta 92, it still had a reinforced slide, a longer trigger guard so one can stick their thumb in there to help control recoil and an extended magazine. In BF4, it literally looked like a M9 with an extra metal prong in the front. Not to mention, the soldier does not use the metal grip on the front. BF2042 got it right too, though the game is a complete mess.
I can’t believe how stiff the MP412 animation looks in 2042
16:56 that punch is worth all of the bf2042 reload animations 😩.
11:54 The magazin release turned into an bolt release for a second there. What the hell.
Sks is the only one that matters. You can hear across the map when someone is using that
The p90 in 2042 has such a clunky firing animation, it looks so static like a doom 2 reload
BF4 wins. Case closed.
やっぱり銃声よな。最高すぎる4と1
Man, BF4 is my fav battlefield AND I’m an Xbox player, meaning I’ve only ever played the game in 720p with the horrible anti aliasing it has. I’ve always been so jealous of the 4K version PC’s have had this whole time. If I had the PC version I’d still be playing that game over any other battlefield.
When you fire the RPG while aiming in 2042, the rocket is not propelled.
BF4 sound design: ASMR
BF2042 sound design: regularly muffled wet farts
It still bugs me that you only use your thumb to press the bolt catch in BF4
I enjoy 2042 for what it is but the animations do look and feel especially janky.
Janky and feels unsettling.
These are unfinished, check the newest ones
@@alanproch Unfinished but shipped. That's just sad.
It's funny how the BSV-M of 2042 is better quality-wise than the Portal AS Val. Shame to the animator/s who did the Portal weapons dirty. They could have just reused the animations of BF3/BF4/BF1/BFV.
Oh and the M1 Garand in Portal is the most humiliating ever, it's like a middle finger to the Magnum Opus of the M1 Garand reload from BFV.
yea, people who did all the M1 animations in BF5 knew they stuff, like 14 animations not counting secret ones
@@iMost067 indeed. Fun fact the M1 Garand animator Oskar Wetterbrandt actually did a lot of the 2042 base weapons as well as the Ghostmaker crossbow, and even nailed trigger discipline for every weapon. He left the company already but he left a great legacy in BF animations.
When dropping magazines are faster than retention reloads
I think it depends the gun, for example, pistols and the M16 look better in 2042, but most of the other guns looks better in bf4, shotguns for example
Now for reality mod on BF3 to compare with- oh wait.... We're waiting for it, Right?
Didnt fixed SPAS-12 reload (you need to hold button on the side to be abble to reload it.)
Also SPAS-12 is semiautomatic shotgun and pump is used when rounds severely lowered in charge, so its undergassed can its not enough to gas operate.
Also SPAS-12 being any valuable in a year 2042 is a meme, its a heavy overmanufactured piece of history that is already outdated
2042 sound design was poor compared to 4. BC2 had the best sound design, imo. Wonder how its possible that dice team's ears didnt work properly on developing this.
Funny how the pre-alpha's Sound Design was way better and funny enough If you Go to settings to Sound you can now hear a Preview with gunshots that are way better and punchier than the ones in the actual game
Kinda sad that base 2042 doesn't even have the legendary 1911. Could've at least use the 9mm 2011
it does??
BF4 animations look robotic at times while BF2042 has some chracter. Sound design goes to BF4 almost every gun has a unique sound profile.
DAYUM the bf2042 reload animations are bangin, good on the animation team
Video suggestion: WW2 weapons in Modern setting games.
for a 10 years later game, not a significant changes :(
Hubieras ido al campo de pruebas de bf4 y hacer disparar las armas, ya que se vería un poco mejor que ese mapa que se te ocurrio XD
DAO-12 its wrong in both games
the Shell are expelled like a Colt Single Action Army revolver each one... its a really long reload time
Ejected*. You eject them with a rod one by one and reload them one by one too. Its a pos gun.
Without hesitation bf4 won here (animation in 2042 is just something)
Between a 2013 and 2021 game, BF4 really ahead of its time (my bad english)
GOL Magnum sounds like God in 2042 God damn!
Definitely think some sound design and the way some pf the weapons are animated in BF4 look better, but overall I do think that the revamped weapons look better overall. But they really need to step it up in the future, reloads have always kinda looked stiff in Battlefield, and other games are starting to pull them off way better. Hope they actually get time to develop the next time so the devs efforts can shine
A bit of a mixed bag in 2042, the models and details on the animations are much better but they lack any style that bf4 has. You can clearly tell that some higher up told the animation team to "copy MW2019". It honestly feels like they're unfinished/unpolished considering how fucking stiff they are compared to bf4.
The animations are not better in 2042 , as a matter of fact, they are, for the most part, worse.
It’s like they took the mw19 reloads and took all of the care and effort out of them
sounds and animations are way better in bf4
Exactly
Who would have guessed that we see a day where Call of Duty annihilates Battlefield for realistic gunplay. Even cold war had better animations than 2042.
at this point they should just remake BF4
I think that both of the animation styles are great there I said it you’re both on the same level yeah kill me help me string up by my face in ritualistic sacrifice
Firing the AN-94 on full-auto for longer than the 2-shot burst is, frankly, sacrilegious.
The burst is life.
#AN94MasterRace
Pp2000 and Ak74u reload from portal looks weird, like a mobile game xd
if they didnt gave ripple effect studio to care portal...
Is it just me or 2042 feels like more of Call of Duty rather than a Battlefield game
it definitely came from the mw19 influences (details that no one other than gresy gun nerds would give a shit, and realism in cod game) to fps games
If we never had mw19 then cod:cw could have been a great game without mw in the way
@@redactedgamersgd1788 "no one other than gresy gun nerds" *Cough cough* That's me
Nice
Why do have of these weapons look big in the player's hands in BF2042?
An 94 mag frikin disappeared br
how did they fuck the recoil animations up so much?
Pistols : BF4
Shotguns : BF2042
SMGS : BF4
Assault Rifles : BF4
DMRS : BF2042
Bolt Action Rifles : BF2042
LMGS : BF2042
Launchers : BF2042
They could have gone for an updated bf4 style of animation (like in 1 and V). But they went for a cheap knockoff of MW2019
nahh this comment ryt here is realer that most of the comments in the section
as val: portable silencer
People can't understand what brf 2042 was made to be fast and Competitive
Let’s hope the next BF entry is better than this one, 2042’s entire coding is CTRL C+CTRL V
I really hope they add BF4 content into BF Portal
I hope they add content to 2042
Dice's biggest mistake was not Put ALL portal content into the main game
As val - pdw\smg, not rifle
Wow... and battlefield 4 is almost 9 years old
Dice makes the goofiest gun animations
Weird, it's the Same Animator but He got worse as time Went on?
I don't get it.
Maybe He Had to Rush the Animations.
Odd how such an old game looks a masterpiece. And to add to that, the new game looks like some poorly pieced together mobile trash
Honestly I don’t like the “clickyness” for the reload and shoot animations for call of duty (new ones) and 2042. To me they sound a bit annoying. Battlefield 4 still looks really good. Only one that really is better than 4 is Battlefield 1. 2042, eh.
i hate it that they literally beat the shit out of the gun, or in some inspect animation they beat themself with the gun.
BF 5 by far had best reloads, you can feel that person is trying to be fast but its not possible to be faster
I really liked the original, but the 2042 is decent
ok but the shotguns do look a lot better on 2042
I dunno why Battlefield chose to go into this direction. There's no way they're able to make a better Battlefield game than BF4.
There are three things that I think Battlefield loses against Call of Duty, is the lack of weapons, maps, and realistic animations.
bf4 was the worst battlefield
Call of duty better than Battlefield for weapons? Maybe after 2019 lmao. Every CoD before that is hot garbage in terms of everything regarding guns.
8:40 looks like a reload that you’d find from an old PS2 game. Way to disrespect the M16A2 with that janky reload.
I fell asleep watching the DAO-12 reload zzZ
if you combined bf4's sound design and 2042's animations you'd have some decent guns
The only good part for BF2042 is the revolver reload...
Rounds that aren't fired yet are still heavy so when it's unloading time, the gravity will do the work and the fallen rounds are saved for later...
Everything else than that, it's shit :v
What gravity...Unfired shots fall easier because they didnt expand. Fired rounds expand that means they struggle more to come off the chambers. Fake gun expert.
@@IlNamelessKinglI I'm not a gun expert to begin with, you can ignore wrong information or correct it right ( you just did ), I never shot a gun since owning any weapon in my country is deemed illegal. All Knowledge I found is based on what I watched and understand on internet.
There’s some in BF2042 that so sound better.
They had all time they needed and they hired newbs to animate what's supposedly triple A game
Well One of it is a Battlefield Game and another one’s a COD
1911 sounds shitty in both games. It doesn't have that punch it had in bf3.
Dice clearly isnt Dice anymore
BT4 definitely
Say what you want, but I enjoy the reload on the 2042 Saiga 12. Just looks… nice.
تفوز 2042 في الريلود،
لكن تفوز bf4 في الإرتداد.
the base reload is kinda decent. portal ones? fuck ea for handing ripple effect animators those guns
Battlefield 4 Wins?
Да
O BF 2042 tem uma boa animação de armas, até quem não gosta tem que concorda mas os sons das armas o BF 4 é mais realista doque o 2042. No BF 2042 as armas não tem um som realista e sinceramente não parecem muito reais mas o BF 4 os sons e as armas parecem reais mais temos que admitir que no quesito animação de recagar da Arma do 2042 é melhor doque a do BF4
10:32 The right index finger is misplaced :) that shows that animation 2042 is very sloppy and sketchy, deserves such a failure!
BF4 one love
I think I've worn my disdain for 2042's animations out by now. Suffice it to say that despite its robotic nature and horrible overused default pistol animation, Battlefield 4 somehow manages to show more weapon detail, be more readable, and be more unique than 2042. That's sad.
The 2042 reloads look like their from pubg
20:39 wtf was that. That’s the definition of rushed
Rocket didn't even exit the gun in first person lmao
Aye noticed that myself absolute disgrace
I don't feel the gun in BF42
BF4 looks more natural than 2042 animation LOL