@@harithdanial141 I am absolutely right. Also what I know about you, Harith had named from indian language and danial is from foreign language. So you are also converted. Because Indian natives are hindu, jain, Buddhist and sikh. Ibrahim religion has no connection in India, they all are converted. That's why they don't follow sanatan culture, there Gods are all men.
@@shubhamlateWell sir there is nothing wrong even if our ancestors converted. Even the arbas of that who were not Muslims by birth converted to Islam when prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) asked them to believe in him it was their choice to believe in him. So I think Indians need to grow up and secondly even the Prophet himself said to his companions that your are just my companions and my brothers will be those who doesn't know me and they will stil believe in me and my religion. Even if today you accept Islam by your haert it means you are born today and you are true Muslim
@King James whoever talks truth is not the enemy but a friend who highlights the weaknesses but unfortunately people call him enemy or traitor. And by the way not only Indians but sane Pakistanis watch him as well.
I listened to the whole 25 minutes. It was worth it. I am thankful to you for giving me such a clear perspective on current issues, and most specially, a critical thinking ability lately which helps me understanding things better when I read or switch between news channels. Keep making these videos. They really help. You are doing a great job. These efforts from you will have a positive outcome eventually.
@@satyenpatowary6697you can't label a religion like that just becuz certain people lack critical thinking and they happen to be Muslims , same goes for most Hindus as well.
I am feeling as if you spoke on behalf of all Afghans around the world.. I salute you Sir for you are the 1st and only Pakistani i have heard in my entire life who speaks of truth even in Afg matter bcz all my life, I heard my classmates remind me that we should be indebted to Pakistan for they helped us in Afg-Russian war.. They label talibans as Afghans only.. they don't admit that the Taliban schools are actually established in here.. They remind me daily that we are blessed to have Talibans as our rulers cz now we have become an Islamic state as if earlier we were non-muslims How i wish Every Pakistani would have had the guts to look into reality.., study the actually history and not believe on the shit fed to them by Pakistan studies teachers in schools..
Well i am afghan... But your point is sick to me... U said as if we were non muslims..... Ofcourse we were... But as a nation... Do you even know whats in quraan... Its mentioned clearely... If your decisions are not based on shaira you are a fasiq.. Zalim and kafiroon... U know strict word kafiroon word is used... Without sharia law we have no value in the eyes of Allah jala jala lhu...
Even in my office , IT graduates and PhDs use to say that, pakistan also need Taliban kindov government , I'm like , "abu sai kahte thy kuch log parh likh k ghadey pa ladd dete han"
Maybe it’s the nature of people who think you can’t be civilised without strict rules? I know those graduates and PhDs would at the same time love to live in western countries like Canada and Australia, never quite understand this
Well they must know what Taliban's stance is on "pHDs, master's degree and even high school degree". Kindly check it. Cobrapost has a video on it. And don't let Cobrapost's name fool (not trying to insult brother) you. It has done sting operations in the past. So it is credible.
I am an Afghan and I appreciate your words in support of Afghans. You speak the truth about the real situation in Afghanistan and the desires of its people. This is despite the flawed thinking of some Pakistani people who view us as traitors (Namak Haram), while considering the Taliban to be good. But even they do not have the guts to look at the history behind what they really did to Afghans as neighbors and Muslims for Dollars
You explained the Afghan history far more better than my history teacher Thank you for the video I have corrected my perspectives over the issue to a greater extent now
The thing is we have so nicely brain washed that we have lost our inner insight and Muzammil is really trying to awake that back with his spectacularly knowledged reviews
Syed sahab it’s always a pleasure to hear your views, u r a progressive thought person and u r few of those journalists who talks about to awake the consciousness of common Pakistani people. Once again great video and great message. God bless u
As an Afghan myself, I have been lived there and know every bit about my history All his words are authentic and precise. I appreciate your work & efforts for teaching new generation
this video needs to share more and everyone who is supporting the Taliban should watch this video and well said "jo parosi mulk k liye chunnu wo apne liye bhi chunnu ,
you are a wise young man,you are the first pakistani youtuber that i have subscribed .Hope the whole world becomes more wiser with sane intellectual like you.May god be with you in this endeavor .Good luck
Brother your video gave me goosebumps i am becoming a doctor and i wish i had chosen your profession because there are very less number of people that have your level of knowledge and dignity to speak truth against anyone and anything thats wrong ❤️ More power to you 🙌 and i wish i can somehow meet you on day
Durand line is the area Maharaja Ranjit Singh captured from Pashtuns to teach them a lesson who were invading his territory again and again and most of the soldiers of Maharaja Ranjit Singh are the ancestors of todays Pakistani Punjabi.
KPK belongs to us Pakistanis. It’s the only Pashtun part which was apart of the Indus Valley, and we use that and Islam to unite us. Today there are more Pashtuns in Pakistan than afghanistan. Pakistan and Afghanistan can be Allies, but we won’t give away our land to you.
@@humzanafees9348Pakhtunkhwa is the lands of Pakhtuns, we speak Pakhto and our Capital is kabul. Pakhtuns are brave and courageous to choose whatever they want. A non Pakhtun can't decide the fate of Pakhtuns.
I saw how even cricketers like Afridi supporting Taliban, puri duniya dekh kar bhi koi change nahi hai attitude me. the day when Peshawar army school was attacked, in India we were glued over tv and my father's eyes were moist he said kitne ghatiya log hain inhone bachche maar diye. Today Pakistan is more at risk of terror, there is no good or bad terrorism, TTP is a frenchise of Taliban itself.
AoA,You are doing a wonderful job, keep it up bro.love from my side and many others like me. after a long time seeing an analyst presenting arguments based on logic. Learn alot from you.The power behind your voice is appropriate It not that squeeky that may hurt ears nor too dull. the knowledge that you give is ammazing after watching your videos I have decided to read books your knowledge has motivated me to decide. although I am a Mech engineer who has just graduated and is jobless but your videos have motivated me to read history. Respect from Rawalpindi
Thank God we have someone like Syed sir.....for the first time in my life I have been able to thread bare the Afghan issue and the credit goes to this video where the personal opinions are less and facts and data is more. You were among the few youtubers whose content is well researched and unbiased ....your analysis and research has helped the world understand the real politics which we as Indians might not have understood due to the finer nitty gritties involved....in the Afghan issue. Proud of you sir....your rhetoric, research and your overall demeanor speak volumes about the teachers, parents and researchers still living in a state like Pakistan where they have nurtured a person like you! I just pray that this universe must protect u at all costs as u r such a gem for our entire humanity! Blessings.....blessings and lots of blessings.....from India
Pakistan's Strategic Depth Policy started in the early 70s when ZA Bhutto invited religious extremists from Afghanistan. It was to sabotage Afghanistan's claim over the Pashtoon Territories in Pakistan and not accepting Durand Line as a permanent border. Zia just continued that policy and introduced and supported the Deobandi brand of Islam. After the widrawl of USSR and stoppage of USA funds, Pakistan kept that policy active and Hamid Gul invaded Jalalabad with the approval of Benazir Bhutto. When the interim Aghan government was formed after the resignation of Dr. Najib, they put the Durand Line issue infront of Burhanuddin Rabbani, which was refused. As a reaction Pakistan unleashed Gulbadin Hekmatyar on Kabul. In the mean time a trade convoy was organized to go through Chaman into Afghanistan all the way to Central Asia. Colonel Imam was leading that convoy, but it was intercepted by a Commander Mansoor (Uncle of General Raziq). Mansoor refused to let the convoy, and even put a pistol on Colonel Imam's head and told him to take it back. The convoy was turned back and at that time with the approval of Benazir Bhutto, General Naseerullah Khan Babar assembled a new brand of mercenaries from the old Mujahideens and named them Taliban. They were given full tactical and material support by the ISI all the way to Kabul. They assassinated everyone from the Past (Dr. Najeeb) and at present who opposed them. Taliban was never an indigenous force, they were raised, brainwashed, trained, and armed in the state sponsored seminaries. The same seminaries you mentioned, but they belong to Sami ul Haq not Fazal ur Rahman. Fazal ur Rahman made his faction in JUI when he refused to support the USA sponsored Jihad in Afghanistan. Javed Ahmed Ghamdi also parted his ways from JI when Qazi Hussain Ahmed supported the USA sponsored Jihad in Afghanistan. When USA attacked Afghanistan after 9/11, the Taliban and ISI officials were cornered in Kunduz. Pakistan requested for an air corridor to evacuate only their officials, but after that was granted they Airlifted all the terrorists in C-130s and brought them and settled them in FATA. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_airlift?wprov=sfla1 For 20 years when the world was busy in Afghanistan rebuilding, ISI was busy training and army of mercenaries that is why PTI was given two time governments in Pashtoonkhwa. PTI even gave funds to Darul Uloom Haqqania (Sami ul Haq) from it's provincial budget and even from school funds. www.dawn.com/news/1475323
Yes, sir. You are right. In my childhood, I was fond of reading travelogues. We had Hem Kumar Baruah, who was an Indian Parliamentarian and he used to travel all around the world. In one of his book, he described how he was surprised to find broad, well laid roads in Kabul, a modern airport and higher standard of lives in compared to then India. When I compare those pictures with the present day pictures of Afghanistan, it pains to see that while others have progressed beyond recognition, Afghanistan has moved backward. Why?
Its strange afghanistan established as a free state before pakistan and india and had a,liberal government in its early times but its has worse infrastructure and more undeveloped country then pakistan india and bangladesh
There was never any liberal government in Afghanistan until Hamid karzai in 2004. Prior to that Afghanistan had either an islamist or Communist government
Slight correction: Though Jimmy Carter did offer some aid ( it was in the few hundred million dollars which Gen Zia termed ‘peanuts’, insulting Carter because he was once a peanut farmer in Georgia), it was really Ronald Regan who upped the ante and started giving about $1 billion a year ( and singers later as well) which was matched by Saudis. Great show 👍
22:11 wow ..Man you are spot on A good student of political science study the past Analyse the present and extrapolate his findings and predict the future..your prediction about TTP was soo spot on that I despite being from India really wish that you are a security nd politician advisor to Pakistan PM or some of South Asia security groupings this guy is a true gem of a person.
Speaking as an American of Pakistani descent, it is an incredibly convincing argument to the average American citizen to hear successive presidents of different political parties make the same argument that - “we’ve spent over a trillion tax payer dollars and helped create an army of over 300,000 with an equipped Air Force. It’s time for Afghans to fight for their own future.”
@@qurratulainzehra8760 yeah but the people and the social structure was very peaceful and far better than today poor people of afganistan hope they will get freedom tailiban
@@sohailsky5581 It's not only Afghanistan whole Muslim world was peaceful before 1980, even Pakistan Iraq Libya yamen Syria every Muslim country used to be Laboural and peaceful its Russia USA who destroy every thing
British had upper hand over Afghanistan. They controlled their foreign policy, signed treaty of Durand Line in which Afghanistan waived off its claim over KPK!
Afghanistan's president Aman Ullah Khan was honoured in his visit to US in JF Kennedy era, they had great artellary system weapons and fighter jets having the same role of female in their army and air force, Kabul university was amongst the very few university in muslim world for which foreign students come to study. kabul university students were used to wear skirts and do parties in the time when there were no name of Pakistan or India but Hindustan, but the policies of some destroy all 😔
The whole video is worth watching but one thing you didn't mention is the name of Muhammad Najibullah, Al Qaeeda was basically created by Al Zarqawi (zarhavi) and Osama Bin Laden.
Sir, your research and hard work being out in behind these videos is inspirational. I want to learn history, could you please suggest some unbiased historians? God bless
You are partially right about our freedom from British. But I kindly suggest you to learn about INA & Subhash chandra Bose role that is actual reason why we🇮🇳 and you 🇵🇰 got independence from british we actually fight military with british and achieve our objective to get independence.
Jab koi kehta hai hum taliban ko support krty hn toh mujy APS ke martyr yaad ajatee hn. As a country humn bohat suffer kia hai inki wja se or agar phir b kehty inhe support krty hn to we deserve everything that we are facing in this country na roti na kapra na makaan na jaan ki hifaasat na izzat ki na maal ki.
@@mehreenbukahri6118 American army was killing afghan people. Taliban were retaliating. In this war innocents were being killed. It was the presence of the American army that resulted in this war. TTP was not fighting against an army that was taking over their country, ttp was committing acts of terrorism on our soil while the afghan taliban were defending themselves against the American army. I'm not saying the afghani taliban are not extremist. They are. Or rather they were since they seem to be promising change and we can always hope that they mean it. But to say that ttp and afghan taliban are same? No you are wrong in that.
@@mehreenbukahri6118 it's very simple, ttp is funded and supported by America, India and the Northern alliance. While afghan taliban detest the northern alliance, India and America. Let's not forget that the afghan taliban have stood with Pakistan always. Ttp only adopted the name "taliban". They are in fact kharijites
Syed Muzammilbhai a gem of a human being.....Please keep enlightening us with your amazing wisdom
Absolutely right brother.
Please be careful about your security
You are speaking absolute truth
I have been telling same in all videos, be careful, sometimes speak about positive side too, atleast it might help you, telling this as a well wisher
Bro what is the history of your surname Shah. 😶🌫🙄 it is not muslim surname. When you converted into islam
@@shubhamlate so islamic name only Arab name? Totally wrong
@@harithdanial141 I am absolutely right. Also what I know about you, Harith had named from indian language and danial is from foreign language. So you are also converted. Because Indian natives are hindu, jain, Buddhist and sikh. Ibrahim religion has no connection in India, they all are converted. That's why they don't follow sanatan culture, there Gods are all men.
@@shubhamlateWell sir there is nothing wrong even if our ancestors converted. Even the arbas of that who were not Muslims by birth converted to Islam when prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) asked them to believe in him it was their choice to believe in him. So I think Indians need to grow up and secondly even the Prophet himself said to his companions that your are just my companions and my brothers will be those who doesn't know me and they will stil believe in me and my religion. Even if today you accept Islam by your haert it means you are born today and you are true Muslim
You deserve 10 million subs, the only sane Pakistani who has the guts to talk about the country's atrocious and hypocritical state.
@King James so why are u here ?
@King James whoever talks truth is not the enemy but a friend who highlights the weaknesses but unfortunately people call him enemy or traitor. And by the way not only Indians but sane Pakistanis watch him as well.
@King James don't be jealous of his wisdom and intelligence.
@King James offcourse i haven't seen any gem like him
@King James offcourse iam Muslim Alhamdulillah
everyone has different opinion
i can relate to syed muzamil, its your choice you can vary with him.
I listened to the whole 25 minutes.
It was worth it.
I am thankful to you for giving me such a clear perspective on current issues, and most specially, a critical thinking ability lately which helps me understanding things better when I read or switch between news channels. Keep making these videos.
They really help. You are doing a great job. These efforts from you will have a positive outcome eventually.
Sir, critical thinking is a trait alien to your mazhab.
@@satyenpatowary6697you can't label a religion like that just becuz certain people lack critical thinking and they happen to be Muslims , same goes for most Hindus as well.
I am feeling as if you spoke on behalf of all Afghans around the world..
I salute you Sir for you are the 1st and only Pakistani i have heard in my entire life who speaks of truth even in Afg matter bcz all my life,
I heard my classmates remind me that we should be indebted to Pakistan for they helped us in Afg-Russian war..
They label talibans as Afghans only.. they don't admit that the Taliban schools are actually established in here..
They remind me daily that we are blessed to have Talibans as our rulers cz now we have become an Islamic state as if earlier we were non-muslims
How i wish Every Pakistani would have had the guts to look into reality.., study the actually history and not believe on the shit fed to them by Pakistan studies teachers in schools..
what are your thoughts now
Well i am afghan...
But your point is sick to me...
U said as if we were non muslims..... Ofcourse we were... But as a nation... Do you even know whats in quraan... Its mentioned clearely... If your decisions are not based on shaira you are a fasiq.. Zalim and kafiroon... U know strict word kafiroon word is used... Without sharia law we have no value in the eyes of Allah jala jala lhu...
@@CryptoAddiction 🤣
@@CryptoAddiction a gya kufer kay fetway bantnay wala kutta
@@CryptoAddiction oh wow Afghanistan me beth k pant shirt kese pehni huyi hai
Even in my office , IT graduates and PhDs use to say that, pakistan also need Taliban kindov government ,
I'm like , "abu sai kahte thy kuch log parh likh k ghadey pa ladd dete han"
Jo baat hai
Maybe it’s the nature of people who think you can’t be civilised without strict rules? I know those graduates and PhDs would at the same time love to live in western countries like Canada and Australia, never quite understand this
نظریات کاتعلیم سے کویی تعلق نھیں ھوتا
Well they must know what Taliban's stance is on "pHDs, master's degree and even high school degree". Kindly check it. Cobrapost has a video on it.
And don't let Cobrapost's name fool (not trying to insult brother) you. It has done sting operations in the past. So it is credible.
@Nisha chambiyal exactly 👍
Excellent 😊 fact and figures displayed from Early 1920's Afghanistan till now. Thanks for the information Muzzamil Bhai
I am an Afghan and I appreciate your words in support of Afghans. You speak the truth about the real situation in Afghanistan and the desires of its people. This is despite the flawed thinking of some Pakistani people who view us as traitors (Namak Haram), while considering the Taliban to be good. But even they do not have the guts to look at the history behind what they really did to Afghans as neighbors and Muslims for Dollars
You explained the Afghan history far more better than my history teacher
Thank you for the video I have corrected my perspectives over the issue to a greater extent now
He's An Asset
He Should Be Your Leader
He Should Be Your Hero
He's A Jewel💎
Protect This Man!
Protect This Man At Every Cost Pakistan🙏🏼
Thanks for yours kind words about Afghanistan 🇦🇫. 😍love from Peshawar.
Feeling sad for my afghan brothers
You mean taliban ?
@@rashidaquil5284 Taliban in power and Afghan civils... these two are totally different entities..We indians are not confused like you all...
Mai ek hindu hu ...ye aadmi mujhe secular bana diya 😀💓🇮🇳 thank you so much Syed Bhai 🙏🙏🙏
waah..ab tu pakistan mein jaa ke secularism failaa..whan teri jyaada jaroorat hai
@indian lion it kehna chahte ho ki hindu secular nhi hota h
Agar Aisa h to tum narrow minded hoge
Hindus are inherently secular irrespective of locations they are in.
Fir iske jihadi bhai aayenge aur aapko isis bana denge , yahi to cycle hai
Evil always exists. Religion always exists, Hinduism is the least evil of all, stick to it.
Man, you deserve more subscribers Allah bless you, you are spreading true history and fact.
here is your subscriber from Afghanistan
do you like india?
The thing is we have so nicely brain washed that we have lost our inner insight and Muzammil is really trying to awake that back with his spectacularly knowledged reviews
Syed sahab it’s always a pleasure to hear your views, u r a progressive thought person and u r few of those journalists who talks about to awake the consciousness of common Pakistani people. Once again great video and great message. God bless u
Syed Muzammil bhai❤️to gem💎h he,inke videos dekhte huye mujhe 7-8 month's ho gye unbiased honest❤️kash 50% Pakistani🇵🇰 v aise he soch aur progressive mentality ke hote ya hukumat mein hote to jitne v masle h peacefully solve ho jaate & frndshp hoti achi khaasi progress ki TRF hmara dhyn hota, science,education,technology,AI, robotics,jspe sari duniya aage bdh rhi h..,bt afsoos yhsb nhi ho payega kbhi😒😟 spcly in Pakistan🇵🇰kher tc stay healthy bro❤️luv frm India🇮🇳
As an Afghan myself, I have been lived there and know every bit about my history
All his words are authentic and precise.
I appreciate your work & efforts for teaching new generation
I wish each n every Pakistani should hear you carefully. We are leading towards our own destruction.
We people are highly illetrate in these matters 😪
We really are. The idea of "Good Taliban" taking control of Pakistan is my biggest fear.
Abbe terako kya jarurat h enhe suggest krne ki
India m rehta h to indian pr dhyan laga na
I really appreciate the content that you're putting out
I'm amazed why you are even here, believe me u deserve much more may god bless u
بہت شکریہ سر اتنی بہترین تاریخ ہم تک پہنچانے کا ❤
Thank you so much for highlighting our hypocrisy as a nation. Jazakallah and much appreciated.
God bless you
Legends know that it has been reuploaded
I know
Why
Yes ,I have seen it earlier .When I tried show to my brother, it was removed
@@vanshstalin1402 Shows that they dont want to listen to him. He is really speaking my voice bro!!
Greetings from Afghanistan and thank you brother for your honest views.
GOD BLESS YOU BROTHER SYED MUZAMIL SAHIB YOU DOING GREAT JOB FROM PAKISTAN AND YOU SPREADING TRUTH ABOUT NEWS IN PAKISTAN
He's the only guy that i listen to
this video needs to share more and everyone who is supporting the Taliban should watch this video
and well said "jo parosi mulk k liye chunnu wo apne liye bhi chunnu ,
waqiyan
What a brilliant rundown on history and its analysis!! 👏🏻 👏🏻
you're amazing!! what an eloquent perspective. Grateful for your content, sir!
you are a wise young man,you are the first pakistani youtuber that i have subscribed .Hope the whole world becomes more wiser with sane intellectual like you.May god be with you in this endeavor .Good luck
Brother your video gave me goosebumps i am becoming a doctor and i wish i had chosen your profession because there are very less number of people that have your level of knowledge and dignity to speak truth against anyone and anything thats wrong ❤️
More power to you 🙌 and i wish i can somehow meet you on day
Durand line drawn by British Empire was a conspiracy against Afghans it was an unfortunate defeat of pashtoons(Afghans)
İ read somewhere they deberately lost the 3rd afghan war to make a Durand line a permanent border.
Durand line is the area Maharaja Ranjit Singh captured from Pashtuns to teach them a lesson who were invading his territory again and again and most of the soldiers of Maharaja Ranjit Singh are the ancestors of todays Pakistani Punjabi.
@@siddeshnaik2296 Do you any proof for it?
KPK belongs to us Pakistanis. It’s the only Pashtun part which was apart of the Indus Valley, and we use that and Islam to unite us. Today there are more Pashtuns in Pakistan than afghanistan. Pakistan and Afghanistan can be Allies, but we won’t give away our land to you.
@@humzanafees9348Pakhtunkhwa is the lands of Pakhtuns, we speak Pakhto and our Capital is kabul. Pakhtuns are brave and courageous to choose whatever they want. A non Pakhtun can't decide the fate of Pakhtuns.
I have not watched this video till now but for me this is the most awaited video. I watch your videos on my every meal. 😜
Great Personality you have..
I literally watched this guys' all vodeos
Great Ideology he has
I saw how even cricketers like Afridi supporting Taliban, puri duniya dekh kar bhi koi change nahi hai attitude me.
the day when Peshawar army school was attacked, in India we were glued over tv and my father's eyes were moist he said kitne ghatiya log hain inhone bachche maar diye.
Today Pakistan is more at risk of terror, there is no good or bad terrorism, TTP is a frenchise of Taliban itself.
eagerly waited for this vedio. thanks muzammil bhai
Thank you for making this video
AoA,You are doing a wonderful job, keep it up bro.love from my side and many others like me. after a long time seeing an analyst presenting arguments based on logic. Learn alot from you.The power behind your voice is appropriate It not that squeeky that may hurt ears nor too dull. the knowledge that you give is ammazing after watching your videos I have decided to read books your knowledge has motivated me to decide. although I am a Mech engineer who has just graduated and is jobless but your videos have motivated me to read history. Respect from Rawalpindi
T
Good job Muzammil.. People like you can bring sense to people of our sub-continent
You're a great analyst.
Please keep making more videos ❤️👍
Thank God we have someone like Syed sir.....for the first time in my life I have been able to thread bare the Afghan issue and the credit goes to this video where the personal opinions are less and facts and data is more.
You were among the few youtubers whose content is well researched and unbiased ....your analysis and research has helped the world understand the real politics which we as Indians might not have understood due to the finer nitty gritties involved....in the Afghan issue.
Proud of you sir....your rhetoric, research and your overall demeanor speak volumes about the teachers, parents and researchers still living in a state like Pakistan where they have nurtured a person like you!
I just pray that this universe must protect u at all costs as u r such a gem for our entire humanity!
Blessings.....blessings and lots of blessings.....from India
Pakistan's Strategic Depth Policy started in the early 70s when ZA Bhutto invited religious extremists from Afghanistan. It was to sabotage Afghanistan's claim over the Pashtoon Territories in Pakistan and not accepting Durand Line as a permanent border. Zia just continued that policy and introduced and supported the Deobandi brand of Islam. After the widrawl of USSR and stoppage of USA funds, Pakistan kept that policy active and Hamid Gul invaded Jalalabad with the approval of Benazir Bhutto. When the interim Aghan government was formed after the resignation of Dr. Najib, they put the Durand Line issue infront of Burhanuddin Rabbani, which was refused. As a reaction Pakistan unleashed Gulbadin Hekmatyar on Kabul. In the mean time a trade convoy was organized to go through Chaman into Afghanistan all the way to Central Asia. Colonel Imam was leading that convoy, but it was intercepted by a Commander Mansoor (Uncle of General Raziq). Mansoor refused to let the convoy, and even put a pistol on Colonel Imam's head and told him to take it back. The convoy was turned back and at that time with the approval of Benazir Bhutto, General Naseerullah Khan Babar assembled a new brand of mercenaries from the old Mujahideens and named them Taliban. They were given full tactical and material support by the ISI all the way to Kabul. They assassinated everyone from the Past (Dr. Najeeb) and at present who opposed them.
Taliban was never an indigenous force, they were raised, brainwashed, trained, and armed in the state sponsored seminaries. The same seminaries you mentioned, but they belong to Sami ul Haq not Fazal ur Rahman. Fazal ur Rahman made his faction in JUI when he refused to support the USA sponsored Jihad in Afghanistan.
Javed Ahmed Ghamdi also parted his ways from JI when Qazi Hussain Ahmed supported the USA sponsored Jihad in Afghanistan.
When USA attacked Afghanistan after 9/11, the Taliban and ISI officials were cornered in Kunduz. Pakistan requested for an air corridor to evacuate only their officials, but after that was granted they Airlifted all the terrorists in C-130s and brought them and settled them in FATA.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunduz_airlift?wprov=sfla1
For 20 years when the world was busy in Afghanistan rebuilding, ISI was busy training and army of mercenaries that is why PTI was given two time governments in Pashtoonkhwa. PTI even gave funds to Darul Uloom Haqqania (Sami ul Haq) from it's provincial budget and even from school funds.
www.dawn.com/news/1475323
Yes, sir. You are right. In my childhood, I was fond of reading travelogues. We had Hem Kumar Baruah, who was an Indian Parliamentarian and he used to travel all around the world. In one of his book, he described how he was surprised to find broad, well laid roads in Kabul, a modern airport and higher standard of lives in compared to then India. When I compare those pictures with the present day pictures of Afghanistan, it pains to see that while others have progressed beyond recognition, Afghanistan has moved backward. Why?
Wow....May Allah protect yourself.
Very informative n concise as always.
Its strange afghanistan established as a free state before pakistan and india and had a,liberal government in its early times but its has worse infrastructure and more undeveloped country then pakistan india and bangladesh
it was underdeveloped even then. Liberal government just looted people and increased its power at the center instead of fixing the tribals
@@WaddiaS then whats the diffrent between liberal govt and taliban they both was harfull for a common person
There was never any liberal government in Afghanistan until Hamid karzai in 2004. Prior to that Afghanistan had either an islamist or Communist government
@@Jiyaa220 Idk lol ask Afghans who allow morons to rule over them
@@anuragpoddar8631 the monarchy was kinda liberal
Great Muzammil, Thank you.
Pakistanis have good and bad Taliban concepts.
All this information have proved wrong just after two years .The great analyst
ہمیں پہلے کچھ اپنے ملک کے لئے کرنا چاہیے
لیکن نہیں اپنے ملک کی حالت خراب سے خراب تر اور پاکستانیوں کو دوسروں کی پڑی ہے 🤦🏻♂️
Slight correction: Though Jimmy Carter did offer some aid ( it was in the few hundred million dollars which Gen Zia termed ‘peanuts’, insulting Carter because he was once a peanut farmer in Georgia), it was really Ronald Regan who upped the ante and started giving about $1 billion a year ( and singers later as well) which was matched by Saudis.
Great show 👍
22:11 wow ..Man you are spot on
A good student of political science study the past Analyse the present and extrapolate his findings and predict the future..your prediction about TTP was soo spot on that I despite being from India really wish that you are a security nd politician advisor to Pakistan PM or some of South Asia security groupings this guy is a true gem of a person.
I appreciate your narrative, keep it up 👍
Speaking as an American of Pakistani descent, it is an incredibly convincing argument to the average American citizen to hear successive presidents of different political parties make the same argument that - “we’ve spent over a trillion tax payer dollars and helped create an army of over 300,000 with an equipped Air Force. It’s time for Afghans to fight for their own future.”
Best and truth lecture from pak first time ever....
Keep it up muzammil bhai
You are such an intellectual person you make a person see a situation through different lenses
ap itna acha kese analysis kr lete hain❤
You are absolutely right 👌🏾
WoW thanks for this didnt know what was happening gain so much knowledge in shortspan
I love the way you explain
Hats off to you, messenger of truth 🙏🙏🙏
We need such gems in our society!
Read or watch the kite runner you will know how afganistan was back in the day
it was still quite depressive, they had to go to Iran to buy a colour tv.
@@qurratulainzehra8760 yeah but the people and the social structure was very peaceful and far better than today poor people of afganistan hope they will get freedom tailiban
@@sohailsky5581
It's not only Afghanistan whole Muslim world was peaceful before 1980, even Pakistan Iraq Libya yamen Syria every Muslim country used to be Laboural and peaceful its Russia USA who destroy every thing
@@comradehasnainkhan1247 well in case of Pakistan I think it's zia ul haw fault for the destruction of Pakistan social and economical down come
So glad I found you sir! 🇮🇳
Your video is addictive, Love from Bangladesh ❤️
Eye opener wisdom
Imran khan ka ye kehna ki Aaj afganistan gulami se aazad hua h bahut hi gair zimmedari se bhara statement tha.
Keep on spreading awareness,messenger of truth 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you sir, lots of love from India.
Wow! Amazing analysis
Appreciate your work
love you sir..... ❤ from delhi (india)
Well put. Keep up the good work.
Too Good analysis 👋🏻
Bhai jaan, you are the voice of reason. Otherwise, listening to our media makes me think that everyone in Pakistan has become pro Taliban.
Too Good .The perfect eyeopener.
Thankyou so much Muzammil
British had upper hand over Afghanistan. They controlled their foreign policy, signed treaty of Durand Line in which Afghanistan waived off its claim over KPK!
Afghanistan's president Aman Ullah Khan was honoured in his visit to US in JF Kennedy era, they had great artellary system weapons and fighter jets having the same role of female in their army and air force, Kabul university was amongst the very few university in muslim world for which foreign students come to study. kabul university students were used to wear skirts and do parties in the time when there were no name of Pakistan or India but Hindustan, but the policies of some destroy all 😔
Brillient, brother please add refrences of your arguments and facts in your videos
Well said... respect
Best discussion. 👍
The whole video is worth watching but one thing you didn't mention is the name of Muhammad Najibullah, Al Qaeeda was basically created by Al Zarqawi (zarhavi) and Osama Bin Laden.
Keep up the good work❤.
بہت خوب ماشااللہ
Great Analysis
Commendable 💕
We should stand with Afghan people
Sir, your research and hard work being out in behind these videos is inspirational. I want to learn history, could you please suggest some unbiased historians? God bless
Take care brother.
Informative ❤
A big thank you to you
You are partially right about our freedom from British. But I kindly suggest you to learn about INA & Subhash chandra Bose role that is actual reason why we🇮🇳 and you 🇵🇰 got independence from british we actually fight military with british and achieve our objective to get independence.
Nhi pta hoga inko unke baare mein..
@@anonymous-yl3pdI know but we also know the narrative of Congress non violence, the virus of non violence destroyed Pashtuns.
muzammil bhai is my fav8 pakistani history teacher.
Good job veer g 👍👍
Very well spoken. 👍
Jab koi kehta hai hum taliban ko support krty hn toh mujy APS ke martyr yaad ajatee hn. As a country humn bohat suffer kia hai inki wja se or agar phir b kehty inhe support krty hn to we deserve everything that we are facing in this country na roti na kapra na makaan na jaan ki hifaasat na izzat ki na maal ki.
Ttp and afghani taliban are not the same
@@ashesanddust262 they kill afgah people, ttp kill Pakistani people nationality is different deeds are same
@@mehreenbukahri6118 American army was killing afghan people. Taliban were retaliating. In this war innocents were being killed. It was the presence of the American army that resulted in this war. TTP was not fighting against an army that was taking over their country, ttp was committing acts of terrorism on our soil while the afghan taliban were defending themselves against the American army. I'm not saying the afghani taliban are not extremist. They are. Or rather they were since they seem to be promising change and we can always hope that they mean it. But to say that ttp and afghan taliban are same? No you are wrong in that.
@@mehreenbukahri6118 it's very simple, ttp is funded and supported by America, India and the Northern alliance. While afghan taliban detest the northern alliance, India and America. Let's not forget that the afghan taliban have stood with Pakistan always. Ttp only adopted the name "taliban". They are in fact kharijites
@@ashesanddust262 let wait and watch how they gonna support us in future. I don't expect any good from afghan taliban, ttp and from America.
very well said thanks
Very very good explanation
Very nice video ❤
Love you sir yahan inn logo k bech Reh k depression hoti ha sans ghutne lagti ha aur pata nahi kab tak kando pa Jo sar ha wo salamat rahe