Sentencing | Jeremy Goodale | Bad Grade Murder Trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2023
- Jeremy Goodale was given his sentence for his role in Nohema Graber's murder. Goodale and his classmate Willard Miller confessed to planning the attack and murder of their Spanish teacher over a bad grade. The State recommended he be sentenced to life in prison with a chance of parole after 25 years. The judge agreed and said he was a good candidate for rehabilitation.
#CourtTV What do YOU think? ⚖️
#nohema #JeremyGoodale #BadGrade
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE www.courttv.com/trials/
WHERE-TO-WATCH www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
Catch up on the FACTS here: www.courttv.com/news/ia-v-jeremy-goodale-sentencing/?
If these kids didn't get caught, they'd be laughing about killing their Spanish teacher Nohema Graber until the day they died. Nohema Graber was murdered because Willard Miller was upset over a bad grade she gave to him? World's Gone CRAZY.
I honestly don't think we can assume this. I remember doing some really stupid things at his age, although I never killed anyone. However, I did feel guilty about many things as I matured. Some that I may never forgive myself for. So I don't think we can honestly say they would laugh about this forever had they gotten away with it.
I believe you are right. He is only remorseful that he is going to prison!! Hitting someone with a bat 5 times is evil!!!
Yep. That's exactly who they are.
He lost that innocent puppy dog look in his eyes real fast when he found out he's going to spend at least the next 25 years in prison.
They are remorseless thugs. This poor woman and her family devastated and destroyed by their violent, senselessly actions.
The excuse of an immature brain as far as murder goes should be disregarded. Teenagers know right from wrong.
In the video, the judge acknowledged that Goodell expressed remorse.
Killing someone over bad grade is just crazy. I feel so sorry for the victim.
To kids out there, getting bad grades in middle/high school is not the end of the world!
And don't blame teachers and others for your bad grades! It's all YOU! You got to study harder if you want to get good grades!
Exactly, but these kids today are something else I'm telling you. They really need to pay teachers more. To me I feel a real good and educated teacher should get what they pay say a nurse or the administrator of schools. Children lack of respect today is scary! This teacher from what I researched was an amazing and fair teacher who did not deserve such a brutal and disrespectful murder!!!
This has happened before, unfortunately. Look up Barry Grunow. It’s heartbreaking in both cases
For college algebra I had a horrible instructor and he told us all 1/2 the class would drop out and the rest would mostly get C’s and D’s. Having gotten and A in intro to algebra I thought I could get through his class. His tests had nothing to do with the previous weeks lessons and I did indeed get a D.
While he was a jerk and would have deserved a beating I chose instead to retake the class, over the summer with another instructor. I got an A.
Or get parents to give help to these kids that need it . Know ecuse how they would think of doing such a thing wonder how there family life is . Sad
@@babyofmyfamily This sort of thing has been happening since the dawn of time, numb nuts.
25 years is NOT ENOUGH 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
He's 16 years old....&...KNEW exactly what he was doing👍👍
ADHD....is NO EXCUSE🤬
He deserves NO possibility of PAROLE!!!!
Actually sentencing -->19:21
💚💚
Thank you. Holy cow this judge didn’t shut up.
Thank you!
Thank you, because I was about to go to another channel. Maybe the news who say what they got to say in 3 minutes or less lol!!!
@@bethanywhite877Right, he has litterly worked my nerves. His talk was very very boring.
Why didn't he put a stop to It! He had every opportunity, from the time he was told it was going to happen, to the day it did happen. He deserves a sentence that is just as harsh as the other kid!
Because he's mentally unstable. He's saying all the right things at sentencing to get a lesser sentence than his buddy, which he got. I don't believe for a second he's remorseful, he's remorseful that he got caught and has to go to prison. That's what upsets him.
Judge gave him the ultimate BAD GRADE !
Right F+ 😶🌫️. Along with being completely expelled from society!!!
Grade 10 Gauge. That's what the size of his orifice will be in prison
Sentence is at 19:08. Life parole after 25.
Thank you, your comment needs to be pinned.
Thank you! 19:08 Glad I read through the comments before I waisted my time listening to the useless talking!
He still got off though to beat someone to death and still have time to live his life in his 40s is a win
This judge could've summed it up in less than 10 minutes. I literally skipped every 10 min ahead and he was saying the same thing. What the family must've gone through.
I did the same thing…lol
Lol
Likes the sound of his own voice too much probably enjoys his own farts too
Yeah he's a talker
These sentencing procedures are dictated by Supreme Court, as the judge stated. Nothing to do with liking the sound of his own voice, you pillocks. (British slang for simpletons. So ditto for spell check..)
I am seeing the comments of only 25 years. Keep in mind he has to serve 25 before going to the parole board but that doesn’t guarantee he will be out.
I believe this defendant is remorseful but it doesn't excuse the brutal murder...
Yes, he seems remorseful. I hope he will make something positive and study well and make good joices in his future!
they always cry and feel bad for themselves when they get sentenced.
How do you rehabilitate someone with no empathy?
This💯 the crying was also fake. Didnt even blink when the judge sentenced him. We saw with other serial killers how they don't have any sort of emotional reaction to hearing they'll be rotting in jail.
He can learn impulse control. There are many who walk among us with little or no empathy.
This judge likes to hear himself talk.
😅😅😅
Oh please a mother leaving had nothing to do with choosing murder... Nothing
Agree
Neglectful mothers DO contribute to the creation of a psychopath. That said, no mercy should be given just because his mother left. He’s dangerous.
Really can’t believe the judge just said his “ADHD could have effected this crime “
ADHD and smoking some weed isn’t going to make someone kill someone 🤦♀️
I’m sure the family felt insulted after having to hear this
My friend has ADHD and never got into any physical confrontation in his life with anyone. The judge is a disgrace
Yes
Adhd is not even a disease.
Many of us have lived with it and have managed to obtain higher education and successful careers !
It’s challenging but there are worse things out here that people suffer with !
Someone with ADHD had poor impulse control.
I had ADHD and smoked weed at 16. Never in a million years would I even think about murdering someone.
Sounds like judge was making excuses for him yet theres millions of minors who dont murder there teacher over grades. This is completely unacceptable and barbaric behavior the judge just goes on about “rehabilitation” wheres the rehabilitation for the family to get their deceased family member back?
You expressed my thoughts exactly
For sure
For gods sakes just sentence him don’t candy cote it . The victim families are being tortured
Yeah holy crap that judge is a tool
Yea, the judge's sermon is too long.
@@taoismyname The judge is required to put the things on the record that he did, aggravating and mitigating factors and his reasons for his sentence. Nice to see you'd rather the defendant have an opportunity to appeal.
Agreed
Judges need to go over ANY & EVERY detail when sentencing a minor to life. To avoid an appeal or overturned conviction
😤I literally left watching the rest of this video to go and check for his sentencing elsewhere! This judge just rambled on for what?!
Lol, lol.....so many of us here thoughts exactly 💯!!!
@@babyofmyfamily
😂😂
Because if you know anything about the LAW he has to read it slowly and carefully
Because your damaged brain thinks 25 minutes is a long time. Life isn't a RUclips short
Imagine if they got a bad review at work, probably 💣 the whole company. Sad, but true: the judge is probably saving several people’s lives with 25 and 35 year minimum sentences this week.
The judge has to be finite. These cases are challenged all the time. Sentecing for youth under 18 is sticky and limited by the SC ruling. If the judge screws the sentencing the entire case could be thrown out.
Exactly. This isn't uncommon, most sentencing hearings are like this. The judge don't enjoy it, but it's part of the process.
We are what we learn to be. There is an immense argument for NO violence in video games and NO violence in movies. Nobody listens.
I have been saying that forever. People are desensitised to violence.
The tears and droopy lips are all for show. He is a sociopath with no remorse. He didnt blink once when the judge sentenced him to 25 years to life!! Like every other sociopath no reaction to sentence!! He figured might as well stop acting now since I'm rotting in jail anyway. Cannot reabilitate someone like that..
Murder for low grade is the dumbest reason if there is reason for murder. I listened to the father's testimony. His son's video gaming and pot smoking desensitized him to the feelings of others. He wasn't a deprived teen. At some point we try to understand how he committed this horrendous act and then brag about It. Un rhe end this teacher loss the most precious gift of life . His actions has consequences.
Why is the judge sugercoating it, get on with it.
Weed and being abandoned by his mom is his explanation…. Ffs. What a waste of life. Hope he never sees the sun again for taking that innocent woman away from her loved ones. This judge is a clown for building him up so much.
Weed and being abandoned or ignored by our parents is as American as apple pie.
It’s a darn shame that they did this, throwing away their lives for something they should have known they wouldn’t get away with 😢😢😢
They didn’t give a damn
A darn shame for whom? They're not ashamed. Murderous narcissistic monster teens. And all you care about is them not "getting away with it"
Your statement seems to support violence and to suggest that better planning to ensure secrecy is needed🙄😳. What’s a “darn shame” is that an educated woman was stalked,horribly attacked and murdered because two entitled, immoral disgusting examples of today’s youth were “upset” about getting a bad school grade. What this young man choose to do was horrific and requires suitable punishment. Actions have consequences. She is dead. His freedom is the consequence.
What is the judge rattling on about...ridiculous!
Right, trying to keep from fast forwarding 😅!!!
I believe he’s addressing all the points that are required BY LAW to be addressed when giving life sentence to a juvenile.
I was 16 at one time and I most definitely didn’t think about consequences of my actions . I did a lot of wrong things and Thank God assisting a friend in harming or murdering someone wasn’t one of them . Prayers and condolences to the families and I pray this young man comes out better on the other side .
This was a disgustingly racist, murder and the racial slur tells it. I hope they pay for more than 25 years, this kid Godell is done and the other one will come to reality when he has to deal in prison with real danger.
This judge couldn't keep it short and sweet kept repeating the samething for like 40 mins lol
Kid looks menacing
This kid looks like he’s about to break into tears at any second. It’s sad. A waste of 3 lives over something so stupid. I do believe he did not think of the consequences.
But he sure thought of the consequences of an F and it wasn’t even his grade. He deserves to be locked up for the rest of his life.
He said that he didn't
He had a horrible mom shame on her
@@shadowwalker777 This is why children are treated differently as per the supreme court, they can be easily influenced and severely impacted by events in their lives that can cause irreparable or at least long lasting emotional and cognitive disfunction. Your statement demonstrates that you don't comprehend that.
@@nadershadani2854 she didn’t make her son murder this woman so apple must not fall far from the tree
The judge should be more concerned for the victim’s family, not the defendant.
Bad grades??? There are consequences in all things in life. Decency? This kid obviously has none. His remorse is only because he got caught!
The judge is speaking too close to the microphone.🎤
That poor teacher. Horrible act of violence. Nothing can bring back the life lost.
I am impressed by the judge's deep thoughts. As a developmental scientist, I am quite impressed.
He is a threat to society , he is just as guilty.He thought it was funny .
No pity.... and trying to use ADHD as an excuse is a pathetic grab. My son has ADHD and he is empathic....he would never be involved in such a plot.
Every parent says that about their kids.
No, If my son was involved in such a crime, I would be the one to turn him in. He was raised to respect the law. @@bravebeard6225
He's just better at not getting caught
Such a handsome young man, he has ruined his life..😪
PLEASE FIRE THE CAMERAMAN!!!
He drank too much coffee. And his phone kept going off. And he gets distracted. Give the guy a break.
He knew right from wrong. He should get as much time as the other boy.
Hearing this judge try to read is excruciating!
Kudos to this judge.
Omg the lip smacking judge
If he was that remorseful he would not put it on snapchat and laugh about it.If they had not got caught they would not have lost a nights sleep.
Great job Judge‼️
Something is terribly wrong. You have to be a real sicko to kill a teacher over a bad grade. Americans kill people over anything nowadays. It's getting so bad. No one talks anymore. They just inflict pure violence on each other.
When I got a bad grade on my French assignment, I asked her for extra help. I asked for some little exercises I could take home. My grades got better as a result. I'm 23 now, and I am pretty good in French, but my pronounciation is not the greatest, and it's what every French teacher in elementary and high school complained about. That was their biggest issue with me and many ridiculed me in front of the class for it. On top of that I had anxiety disorder which made it all the more hell like for me. French class was the worst because the teachers were assholes to be honest, except for one that was actually kind. She was the one I asked for help. I had a professor who would "lose" students' work and fail them long after the term finished. I handed in my work and found out during my summer break that I failed her class. She did this twice to me. She is the worst prof in the school and the lowest rated professor on rate my professor. She made me feel an anger I never felt towards someone. I wanted to yell at her and curse at her with every bad word in existence, I wanted to rob her the amount I paid for that class. It was a punch to the gut. I put effort into a class which I hated. I literally paid her to fail me on purpose. Not once did I think of frickin killing her.
I have no idea what has possessed these kids, but no sane person thinks the most logical thing to do after receiving a bad grade is to end their teacher's life. Even if the teacher was an ass - which doesn’t sound like she was.
The judge is repeating himself in his speech. Maybe he is trying to drive the point home to this kid to understand the consequences of this horrible crime.
Somewhwre between the 12 min and 35-50 second mark, you could see Jeremy had a tear that wanted to come down, but it at least appeared that his efforts to brace himself... had prevented such an expression of sadness display. He perhaps could be even a very changed individual, even this soon after Nohema's unfortunate death..
The motive behind it makes no sense.
I have never heard such a senseless speech for verdict that could of taken 2 minutes max..
DID THEY ACTUALLY KILL THEIR TEACHER OVER A BAD GRADE?!!!!
Yes
Yes watch the trial
Nah nah nah nah
Nah nah nah nah
Hey hey hey
Goodbyeeeeeeee
😂😂
Peer pressure is bs. If someone crosses the line, it's of their own free will. Nobody can make you do anything you know is wrong. Try screaming, NO!
Whoever heard of a kid going to school one day and killing their teacher? Killing your teacher wasn’t even thought about when I was in school or even when my own kids were. The kids knew bad grades were their own fault. What is wrong with kids today?
I just watch the testimony of Jeremy‘s dad, and he had taken him into counseling and trying to find somebody to help his boy. Literally his mother abandoned him when he was seven years old and the dad was trying to find help for the boy ! That doesn’t excuse the horrendous crime that Jeremy did But I hope he gets the help that he should’ve gotten! in prison!
Children all over this world throughout history have lost their mother through accidents, Illness, was, famine, childbirth and choice. This young man had a supportive, loving family. He has chose violence because it felt good to him.
@@jarcha4200says the psychologist
Lack of feelings 😢says it all ! No compassion for other people, if they had that quality this never would have happened! Prayers for her family and friends 🙏 never let people like him out of jail
Skip to the 19 minute mark to actually get to the sentence. You're welcome.
Teens dont consider consequences? Tell that to all the teens who DO get home at their curfew or do their jobs or homework.. because they dont want to get grounded the next day.
The judge believes that he did not consider the consequences of murder? Ok.
This judge needs to be off the bench. He’s too free to be me free to be you BS. Way too liberal way too soft get him off the bench.
Why the judge keep repeating himself and what mental help? My heart goes out to the victims family to have to listen to this judge BS! 😢
Poor judge, this guy should of got life without the possibility of parole
He should get the same punishment and sentence that he gave to the innocent Spanish teacher!! Period!!
I don't believe in letting kids off because their kids......if anything it's easier for them to do the right thing because the incents is still there.....unlike adults where it's easier to get mad as our braincells die away...and such.
Give him the same sentence that he gave his teacher!
Hopefully, Jeremy Goodale overtime will become totally rehabilitated, and that he will spend his time in prison participating in programs to help him to become a much, much better person, and as well, to help him to better understand the mistakes he made on that saddened fateful day that Mrs Gaber was murdered, and that her life was cut short, because of a bad decision that 2 young men made a bad decision to commit a crime . It is never someone else's fault for the mistakes that one makes.. we all are responsible for our own actions, or bad decisions we make in our lives. There is always going to be consequences to pay whether it be good or bad. There's always rewards when we have the will to do right, but there's always an ultimate consequence when we do things that are wrong, or when we commit a crime against someone else, or when a crime is committed of any kind. Hopefully, Jeremy Goodale will spend his time participating in programs to help him to become a better young man, and suitable for release from prison, and to be able to re-enter into society as a rehabilitated young man. Hopefully, he will sincerely accept his punishment, and in Dooley taking responsibilities of his participation that he committed a murder along with his friend, and classmate Jeremy Goodale could have been sentenced to equal time behind bars, like his friend Willard Miller, except that the honorable Judge Shawn showers sounds that he is deemed to be rehabilitated, and so therefore, hopefully, Jeremy Goodale will prove himself dimmable to be rehabilitated, and that he will be able to successfully, and without ceasing prove to not only to himself, but to society in general, and above all to his family, and to Mrs Gabbert's family that he has successfully become rehabilitated, and can we enter into society a new man years may be long, but occupying oneself, and participating in programs to better oneself, time in prison can go by real fast.. but if one stands still, and refuses to accept responsibilities, and continues in his or her slump position, time can be long Karma and never ending. Determination to overcome a error in judgement can be successful. So therefore, Jeremy Goodale needed to be punished for having participated with his friend Willard Miller in the murder of their Spanish teacher Mrs gabber. However, because Jeremy Goodale has shown remorse in recent days for his actions taken, this is the reason why the honorable Judge showers sentenced him to 25yrs, instead of sentencing him to the same sentence of 35 yrs, as like the co-defendant, Willard Miller.
even if he rehabilitates and participating in programs to help him become better, to understand what he did; he still should never walk. does the victim get a second chance? does the victim's family get a second chance? no, so why should he get one. his reward for rehabilitation should be better prison conditions, low security; but should never be released.
The prison systems, both state and federal, are dysfunctional, and the probability is that Willard and Jeremy
are going to be at risk. America needs to look towards Western Europe, the Nordic countries in particular,
for guidance in its approach to criminology.
You talk to much
Damn, shoulda thought of this back in 1981 for Mrs. Clark, my awful geometry teacher. I guess I was a little obtuse back then.
He is a big fkr for his age. He is towering over the bailiffs.
The video begins at 19:00
This is a great judge!
How do prisoners pay for court fees that they are charged for when they are in prison?
sheiladiaz ... IF he is lucky enough to get "work" in prison an amount will be deducted to start paying any dues...
Holy cow, this judge made me feel like I have ADHD. Too much talking.
I had to check that it wasn’t my 9 yr old son as the camera man😂
I wouldn't even have said a bad word to a teacher over a bad grade
He has a face like Chad Daybell. Very villain like...
Should never be released.
What an absolute tragedy !
A life thrown away at just sixteen years old....
If I'd been the judge, I'd have sentenced this fine young man too ten years combat service in the USMC; with a two year reduction for every medal earned for valour under fire.
This judge is dragging 🤯
Let´s pray for the mourning family and friends. And let ´s pray for Jeremy and his family. 🙏🏼
Murder? Yes, they should pay. However, a CALL OUT to those really interested in changing the narrative of children committing crimes based on their upbringing. How is a child to know right from wrong when their own childhood is in question? Let that sink in.
Lamento mucho mis terribles acciones que provocaron la muerte de mi profesora de español. 😢
me to my college professor... lmao
Yeah you don't have the right to kill someone no matter how much they wrong you. When someone wrongs you, you need to get the law involved. That is how things are supposed to work in a civilized society even if the court system doesn't seem that effective in giving people the justice they truly deserve.
Awesome
He looks like Beavis.
What’s the sentence ? Holy Cats! On & on repeating & rerepeating over & over … ???!!!!!
There is no end !
Sad sad sad.
Sad times when you can,t just change a subject you have little ability to cruise through. Too much pressure on young violent minds.
Monster
What’s up with the camera?
These days the kids don't have remorse. They are angry and just want revenge!
Ok so why was his life in prison and the other kid 35 years?? What did I miss here
The other kid got life with possible parole at 35 yrs. He got life with possible parole at 25 yrs.
@@KevinMiller1992 ok thats what I missed thanks
Too easy, in my opinion. It should have been the same as for his partner.
Without his help he couldn't have done it? What!
Life should mean life.
So the entitled bully gets life with parole in 25 years. If he can have parole, why did the judge bother saying life? They will let him out years before 25 have passed for "good behavior" even though by then he'll be a hardened criminal, to be unleashed on society again.
if you dont want to hear the fluff, start at 19 minutes
If remorse begins right after the act, it’s probably true remorse. If it comes when the consequences come, usually it’s self centered.
25 yrs BS