I was a bit disappointed that we didn't get Andy as a survivor for Chucky, but it's really a tremendous blessing that he didn't end up in the Realm. When I was little, Chucky was scary because he was a killer doll. As an adult, he's scary because there are real people like him in the world. Anyone who manipulates a child's heart with no remorse, letting them think that the trauma that happened was their fault or deserved, is unforgivable. The Child's Play theme song itself gives off a really haunting feeling of innocence being lost and that's exactly what happened to Andy. 💔
A few of them should be in a neutral tier, like demogorgon and xenomorph. They’re basically animals or insects, they don’t have any sense of morality or understand concepts like good or evil, they’re just living.
True , they mostly just act out of orders / survival , they dont have to be in any redeemable or ireedemable tier since they basically dont have any reasons to redeem themselves. They are like any animals and cant have this sense of redeeming , bad or good , i think they cant be good but also cant be evil when you think about the fact that they dont even know if what theyre doing is wrong and technically cant really think if its wrong (sorry if this was long btw its my opinion also)
Actually due to how a xenomorph is created (the facehugger alters the subject to make their body grow the Xeno out of them like a tumor) they have intelligence comparable to the species they came from. So sometimes they’re more doglike, and sometimes they’re near person/predator smart, setting traps/ambush, holding grudges, etc.
@@BlindCoyoteGodintelligence is just problem solving capabilities, it doesn't give the xenomorphs the ability to start philosophising or thinking about their actions
Totally agree. Nemesis will be in this tier too. He dosnt feel or think anything. Its like a biorobot. A parasite controle his body. And the parasite is programmed to find the stars
Spoiler for Ringu 0: Sadako technically has a good side. When she was alive, there was the "normal" girl Sadako (still with her powers) and an evil entity Sadako that killed whoever she felt wronged her. The "good" Sadako could heal people and warned others from potential danger, even tho they ignored her warnings and died for it. In the end, the "good" Sadako was blamed for everything, the death of the people she tried to warn and the death of the people the evil Sadako killed, this led everyone present to start hunting her with the goal to kill her. After some running away, Sadako just couldn't take being blamed and hunted anymore, she merged with her evil side and went on her first rampage (technically out of self defence) killing everyone that hunted her. Then her "good" side took over again and she cried while talking to her father, who proceeded to poison her, slash her head open and throw her down the well while Sadako tried to run away, pleading with him instead of defending herself. She healed herself instantly once she was down in the well and survived down there for 20 years. I do think that she is in the right tier being irredeemable but she arguably does have a good reason to believe that seemingly the whole world is against her.
Yo as another thing, the two Sadakos were seperated btw. The evil Sadako entity would stalk the good Sadako. I didn't make that clear in the original comment.
You also forgot sadako's entire story only happened to her because her mother had a child with a demon, she didnt have any choice to have evil sadako and actively tried to help people evade it, even when she fused evil sadako was in control, her curse exists because people constantly harmed her emotional and physically which made her an onryo seeking vengeance upon humanity for her being wronged so much, and even then its mostly evil sadako not good sadako, otherwise there wouldnt be a 7 day warning, theres still a bit of good in sadako even if its overall pointless trying to help since most people wont believe it and die, the ones that heed her warning more commonly survived.
@@coma2726 well that's a lot of speculation which is why i didn't say it in my initial comment. I wanted to stick with what we know for sure. We think that her father is a sea demon but we don't actually know. Considering the duality of japanese mythology, her father could very well also be a sea god or the sea itself. The 7 days are very much depending on interpretation. It could be a warning or it could be 7 days of her tormenting you. She does after all stalk you like evil Sadako used to stalk good Sadako and she tries to influence the people around you into watching the tape as well in those 7 days. In the japanese movies, there isn't even a call telling you about the time you have left, it is mentioned as part of a urban legend but turns out to be false. They only knew the timer because the people that were cursed before them died after 7 days. It could also just be a way for her to spread the curse, they are after all creating more cursed tapes and have to curse someone else to prevent themselves from dying. I personally think neither good or evil Sadako are in "control", they are both part of the same person now. We also have to take into account, that the last dominant personality we saw after they merged, was "good" Sadako. Edit: also DbD should add a "good" Sadako skin.
19:06 I wouldn’t say Naughty Bear is simply evil,he’s like Billy,all of the other bears in the game thought he was ugly because he looked different,they made fun of him,bullied him and excluded him from everything,he tried to be nice and bring a fellow bear a Birthday Present for his birthday and they laughed at him and smashed his gift,the voice in his head convinced him to kill them all,this could also describe Naughty bear’s mental state (Etc)
If I were this RUclipsr I rather put naughty bear in the actually good spot, and it’s the bears fault for making him a killer bear because he just wants to have friends ( poor thing )
It gets worse than that. The other bears literally called in Police, Ninjas, Soldiers, S.W.A.T, Robots, literal X-Men, Pirates, even Vampires trying to kill him even when Naughty didn't do anything in some times. In one of the cutscenes in the game, he had a nightmare where he was shown having the hair and horn from the most friendliest creatures called Unibears but Naughty Bear had his horn cut off by that same bear who had his birthday. People made theories that he used to be a Unibear but became the way he is by one of the other bears. It was never proven true, nobody said what that cutscene was really about.
@@twinzzlersbillys lore is sorta like Frankensteins Monster, he wasn't evil but suffers abuse and became a brutal murderer, torturing animals and his parents then brutally murdering them and anyone who enters his farm
tbh wraith to me is the killer with the most promise of coming full-circle, character-wise. he has all the makings of a tragic hero. sure trapper is sort of the “protagonist” of the killer cast, but there’s a lot more going on for wraith that could make for a good story within the fog imo, if bhvr ever tries to do a “kill the entity” arc lmao.
I’ll say Doctor is much more vile than Myers. Myers at least has the decency to kill you in a short amount of time, Herman on the other hand probably doesn’t even want his victims to die. He’d rather them stay alive for millennia and the reason he officially offs them is so he isn’t found out. All I can say about Doc is that he’d feel right at home with the Cenobites.
Though I agree on your perspective of Herman aka doctor, Myers isn’t any better and could be considered worse as there’s really no point to his killing as he almost seemed to have the perfect life plus as the movies go on it just gets worse even going after what family he has left trying to kill his niece plus not all of Michael’s kills are fast and painless some are slow and painful almost like he knows what he’s going to do and chooses weather to make it fast or as painful as he likes most of the time it’s based on the situation but most of the time when he catches people alone he makes it slow and painful
@@RedCommunistDragon I could still see doctor consider worse though, even if I don’t fully agree with it as I do see that doctor’s pure enjoyment of not just killing but torturing experiences very evil idk if it is worse then Myers though I do agree that he deserves evil incarnate
Killers like Demogorgon shouldn’t be in the “redeemable “ category, it’s a beast designed to kill beings for their survival. Maybe you should make a “mindless” category for the likes of Demogorgon, Xenomorph and so on.
I was thinking the same. It’s kind of just an extreme carnivore. You wouldn’t call tigers evil because they eat other animals (and very very rarely humans)
Well...an animal is an animal, they cant help it with what they are. They kill for instinct. Being evil means you choose to do bad things because you enjoy them. Im with you in that one.
@@Veldazandtea They do everything by instincts, it’s not about if they speak or not, which’s very accurate to the word “mindless” but it’s funny you said “If they were mindless they wouldn’t be so dangerous” when lions and other predators exists in real life lol how ignorant of you
At most, you could put the queen in the redeemable since she is more intelligent than her children. That being said she does what she does to propagate her species.
I think slinger is redeemable because he never went after those who were innocent or did him no wrong. I think that the entity does make him view the survivors as people that wronged him so that's why he "enjoys" the trials (his laughs for every snipe and m1).
i think that his tier is because even tough he doesnt end completely innocent people,when he does kill people it is brutal.he is pretty sadistic but i do think he should be a little lower on the tier,he isnt that bad
18:57 As someone who knows a bit about naughty bear; he isn’t a bad guy to a fault. The other teddy bears on the island are jerks like when they had a celebration for naughty only to throw a cake in his face and make fun of him. On different occasions there were evil teddy bear aliens, deadly robot teddy bears, the secret service, super heroes, the military, zombies, ninjas and even vampires. Hell, teddy doesn’t try to actively kill the other bears on the island only when they try to mess with him. So he’s more bad but redeemable.
I think Huntress belongs in the 'redeemable' category. She doesn't seem to recognize other humans as people, except for young girls, who she shows compassion (if not actual care) for. So I'd call her redeemable on the grounds that, if she actually were to understand what she was doing, she would stop. She simply seems to be incapable of it.
I agree with your interpretation of her character-in that she'd stop if she fully understood what was happening-but still say she's Irredeemable *_because_* she's incapable of understanding; the knowledge she needs to earn her redemption is outside of her reach, and impossible to obtain.
Deathslinger should be on good or neutral as he was severly mistreated on his chilhood by bullies, used and developed anger issues, then he got used by henry bayshore, then he thought he could redeem himslef by working as a bounty hunter hunting, criminals and not hurting innocents, and then he got used again by the warden, then when he got his revenge, the entity shows him the survivors as the people that used and wronged him.
I don’t think Wesker was that bad of a guy before the Progenitor virus, he was simply an ambitious scientist like Birkin. The progenitor virus was described to have made him obsessive and narcissistic so I think that was a major factor in his disregard for life and god complex
@@deathslingermain7467 I think theres a fair bit more lore in the Wesker Files you can find floating around on YT. IIRC he wasnt a good guy from the start with his God complex always being a part of who he was
True, and also his upbringing probably has a lot to do with who he is. Him being taken from his parents and basically forced to participate in Project W definitely took a toll on him.
I'll admit,HUNK,The Look-See,Nemesis,and Pyramid Head aren't evil in a sense that they kill for the enjoyment,they do it because it's their job in HUNK'S case,or their purpose in the other's,but the ones that kill because they want to (basically all of them) are all evil IMO
The Warhammer killing for survival was not really meant how you interpreted it. The only time the Warhammer ever did anything, it was to defend a country from an attack and it killed nobody while doing so. (sry for always commenting about stuff you got wrong, i think you do an amazing job. I just want the videos to be the best they can possibly be, by clearing up some stuff)
Here's a fun thing to do: let's discuss which deadly sin the killers each embody the most. Gluttony: Probably the Clown, due to both being the thiccest boy on the roster, and his bloodthirst being insatiable. Wrath: While it can go to many killers, I think Oni embodies it, as he is driven to kill by the Entity simply taunting him. Lust: Even if we were to disregard his child predator ways in the reboot, the Nightmare takes the most pleasure in his methods. Envy: This may be a bit of a stretch, but I think Hag gets this distinction because she started using her charms to get ahead. Pride: It seems like the Mastermind has the biggest god complex, as he boasts in the final boss of Resident Evil 5. Sloth: Maybe the Shape, which is strange because he is among the more efficient killers. But that may play into the reasoning. His Mori animation is among the more lax of the killers and an add on makes it even easier to do use it. He doesn't put much effort into killing cause he doesn't need to. Greed: None of the killers seem primarily motivated by money, but I think Trickster comes closest to it, turning his crimes into a career. Darwin: This award will be given to the killer with the least intelligence. I'm thinking Dredge since he is seen as just a force of nature controlled by the Entity. But what do you think? Do you think other killers embody some of these crimes more? Feel free to give your own thoughts on this topic.
Saying the Xenomorphs are bad and irredeemable is kinda like saying any human that eats meat is bad and irredeemable. Both kill organisms to further their survival with no malice behind it. Actually it makes even less sense to call Xenomorphs evil because they don't seem smart enough to even choose a different option nor do they seem to enjoy having to kill, unlike a hunter or fisherman. I think Xenomorphs should be in a neutral category
In the original movie, the xenomorph was practically delaying killing Lambert(I believe was her name?) It was feasting on her fear and practically sexually assaulted her with the tail 💀
Humans kill other beings with no malice behind it. We've been doing it for thousands of years and put "animals" in factories to be turned into food. The xenomorphs are just more honest about it. We are the animals too. Only a human would be stupid enough to pretend animals don't think. They do. They pause. They think. They consider. They plan. Thought is simply delayed instinct and instinct is rapid thought put into action. And as Sekiro states, "Hesitation is defeat". The xenomorph is faster. Smarter. Stronger. It's coming. For. You.
For some reason, I see Hillbilly liking Pichu or Diddy Kong cause he likes machines and little animals Twins are Ice Climbers Zero Suit: Skull Merchant, she seems like she would like it Knight: Belmonts Trickster: Jigglypuff, fast and musically-inclined Ridley: Demogorgon, would remind him of the upside down creatures Olimar: Blight, he would be fascinated by their biology Wario: Clown, emits gases that are hard to breathe in Rob: Singularity Kirby: Alien, strong extraterrestrial creature that takes on aspects of their prey Sephiroth: Legion, edgy as hell Sheik: Nurse, teleporting masked lady who kills in secret
as a chucky fan I AM OFFENDED (I'm kidding btw don't take it seriously tbh I didn't even notice that you made the mistake at first because I read it wrong)
I don't feel like it's right to call the xenos bad or dredge evil either. They seem bestial, no role of morality within them. Dredge isn't evil by choice, but by origin. All I've ever read of him in lore is that he just seems to eat anything he comes across, he's more akin to a wild boar than a villain.
Dredge is the most evil thing on this list. It's created LITERALLY by evil. It's COMPOSED of evil itself, hence the ranking of evil incarnate. Committing evil out of instinct and design is still evil, but it's even worse since it's an amalgamation and manifestation of the evil of humanity.
I’d argue that Leatherface and Hillbilly are bad but redeemable. Leatherface was born into a bad family and is manipulated by them due to his mental illness. Hillbilly was abused as a child and was chained to a chair, only to watch tv all day and kill animals under the duress of his parents and the sheriff. Leatherface and Billy don’t know any better, it was more of the circumstances and not their own conscious decisions.
i think bubba and billy are both just cases where if they were given a proper upbringing, they wouldn't be killers. bubba kills out of fear, he doesn't get any enjoyment out of it.
He can't move the armor it is in a fixed position. This doesn't mean he is literally smiling when doing killing or anything. Doesn't mean he isn't either I guess, but his actions aren't out of a love to kill he is doing a duty and I believe typically doesn't really enjoy it. @@StopWhiningManguideCultists
@@StopWhiningManguideCultists If you watch the anime the plate can shift down to expose his mouth. He has a constant look of anger. Titans usually aren’t capable of showing much more than 1 emotion. Plus if you know the person who is the Armored Titan, they don’t enjoy it, or are serious the whole time.
I think that Sadako is redeemable. She definitely has humanity. The whole "curse" isn't actually real, she can kill people who never touched the tape but she and the reason why she waits 7 days before she kills is because she gives people a chance to survive. If someone passes the take to someone else Sadako can still kill that person but chooses not to. Her actual goal is to share her sad story with people and make them sympathize with her. That's the main purpose of the tape and that's why she only kills people who don't pass the tape in 7 days. If she wanted to kill as many people as possible she could simply make a bunch of clones and send every clone after people and kill everyone . If people keep passing the tape to others and understand her story/sympathize with her there is a food chance that she would stop killing because her goal would be fulfilled.
Dr Berkin in resident evil is just a coward he’s not evil, in his game he’s fighting to keep control of his mind, he will say sorry and tell you he is around the area and to stay away and when you fight him he will rip open the eye on his arm so you can shoot it
Hello, AZHY, very interesting video. It was good to know something new about the ferryman and some other characters👍, also could you please make a video : if killers and survivors were not forced to trials, but simply were able to communicate, who would be friends with who, or who would hate someone
I don't think naughty bear is evil but instead bad but irredeemable because the only reason he started killing the bears is because the narrator was telling him to.
actually, in recent marvel comics it was said that the xenomorphs exist to punish the races that get to the stars and their objective is to keep sppecies in their planet
I find it crazy that Huntress doesn’t know how to take care of the little girls she kidnaps. She had a mother that took care of her, surely she would remember how her mother fed and took care of her. Sounds more like she viewed the girls as disposable pets.
I doubt she knows how to cook, or nurse sickness, I'm not even sure if treating wounds beyond bandages. Hell, she'd barely know how to speak, a vocabulary of a child, plus some insanity from being in the woods alone for decades.
@@YanramichI would think even a child would understand that people need to eat and die to the cold, given that they themselves are exposed to this phenomena...
@@dumblenutz5561 she does try, as seen from her backstory, it's just that she's so tough and used to the elements that a frail child doesn't even compare to her. She's trying to model them in her own image, which they can't clearly bear.
I’m commenting this a bit early on, but I think an additional category of animalistic would have worked. A few of the killers are pure instinct, so categorizing them as good or evil would be difficult. But maybe that would have been boring because of how many could be placed in this category idk…
20:08 why is Doctor so high on the list? his "psychopathic personality" is not that different from other characters like Clown and Trickster, I always thought they were exactly the same but in other situations or contexts lmao
Doctor uses much more violent and horrific methods to torture his victims, electro shock therapy is downright cruel and much worse than anything clown or trickster have done
@@therealdeadpoolLOL Aren't you confirming what I said with that statement? What you said he does is exactly what Clown and Trickster also did (this is more obvious with Trickster but Clown's lore also mentions that he drugged and tortured his victims). And yep I have seen all the cinematics of the tomes, so I already saw the Doctor's one
@@matias_dbd I would also put them in evil incarnate as well. I think the reason that Doctor is in evil incarnate is that his lore implies he tortured people for years and was never truly caught, meaning he's at least cunning and maniacal enough to continue his deeds if the fog never captured him
ok first off you clearly didnt understand that those bears were absolute jerks too naughty bear all the time for no reason,and being full on bullies,going to drill over his home for oil,getting the literal military by strapping cameras to birds to stalk him,not to mention they were going to vote for someone to get him off the island,they brought full on super bears after him,AND EVEN FULL ON VAMPIRES i mean come on they had it coming,naughty bear isnt evil the bears that were on the same island as him were,he did want to get along with them he really did but they didnt want to but instea treat him like utter garbage,every single one of those bears treated him like trash even after he saved the island from being taken over by aliens,naughty bear isnt evil he was just miss treated if he met different bears maybe he would not be like that,but he isnt full on evil he just wanted some friends but all those bears did was treat him like utter garbage
I'm glad you got the armored titan's mindset pretty much on the nose this time. The description of the war hammer titan is still wrong but I think the category you placed it in is accurate considering the very small amount of screen time it has.
I'd say Naughty Bear is Bad, but redeemable. He wanted to do good before dbd, he wanted to be accepted. But the other bears didn't, and they treated him like trash. Even after he saved them all. Understandably he'd break and decide to kill them, i bet if anyone treated him with genuine niceness he'd be a good guy. But he also might think they'd turn on him like how the other bears turned on him when he saved them.
How the hell is william berkin less evil than Hunk?! 4:538:02 Berkin was trying to save his "lifes work" and sell it to the US government and was a traitor to umbrella who causes the entire raccoon city incident which in the end gets nuked and wiped off the map Clearly having rage and tries to kill any human in his way Hunk is a private contractor, trained in rockfort island 🪨 He does have sections of his own game and its strictly fighting B.O.W's and in his original mini story as the 4th survivor He has to logistically avoid killing so that he has enough to get through what he has to fight Only to secure his word and the operation as a success The only parts where I see an issue is that he doesn't much care what happens to his fellow operators in the field Yet that isn't true Operation raccoon city and other games shows and RE2 and remake show him as a competent leader that only wants to get the job done and doesn't want anyone get hurt Even understanding fuck ups and accepting the losses ans moves on He is more so a victim of his circumstances and the clearances of operations he is assigned to He is paid to survive and he does that Which oddly makes me wish he had a survivor skin as the 4th survivor His current dbd skin sounds like frank Check out operation raccoon city or RE2 RM wish he had the voice lines, music, and more to go with him but that will be the day (The day they will take my wallet rightfully)
12:33 As Deathslinger is my favorite killer in DbD, it does make me sad that he's considered too far gone to be redeemable. 😔 I do understand your decision to put him in this tier, though.
I feel you my man. But I honestly think our man Caleb isn’t too far gone! If you really think about, he’s a bounty hunter meaning he’s not going after innocent people. And he only beat the shit out of the people who actually wronged him. There’s still hope yet for our favorite yeehaw man… But badass vengeful cowboy is still pretty cool 😂
Personally, I have to disagree with Huntress and Amanda. Huntress just need the right environment to be a better person and Amanda just needs someone to help her and I feel like they would’ve been good people and even in the state they’re in if they were put in the right direction they can be good people.
4:54 I think Birkin should probably be higher because if I remember correctly he conspired with Wesker to murder one of his colleagues who was also doing research for Umbrella so that he wouldn’t compete with them
yea Birkin is 100% evil, even IF he was protecting Sherry out of paternal instinct(there are doubts) he done plenty of evil stuff in the name of his research
I think Wesker should fall under evil incarnate because he out of all the killers should have the highest kill count via those infected with the various viruses released
I get putting the whole Legion there, but honestly I feel like I’d still slightly argue for Susie being potentially redeemable. Though that’s mostly down to how you interpret her. For the most part she just comes off to me like a girl with little sense of self-identity or confidence or just all of that really, so she latched on to this group of people, more specifically Julie I think, who accept her and encourage her (unfortunately in her violent impulses). It’s why she threw herself so much into stuff like the name of the group and the friendship bracelets and BFF hearts, but also why most of her mask don’t even have faces; the Legion is her entire identity. I don’t think this diminishes her crimes or anything, like if she hadn’t actually killed someone before that store incident, her cosmetics indicate she’s done stuff the others probably weren’t even involved in, so no matter invested she is in the groups persona she’s legally adult who made those choices, but I do think she’s the closest to being actually reformed after MUCH psychological help. I get going with Joey though as the most likely, he does seem the most stable in a sense, really just in the gang for the sake of hanging out and enjoying the violence and general mayhem they cause (really the only reason I still hold to Susie is that she seems less inclined to violence without being spurred on by something) while still it took him a bit to jump to murder.
20:29 i know this was technically redacted with the release of the dredge, but what herman did to otto stamper in his release lore is, to me, what puts him on the evil incarnate tier. without that specific incident i would place him somewhere between trickster and oni. but that bit of lore, i wish they had kept that, because it really shows how evil doctor truly is
My main complaint would be with the placement of the xenomorphs, animals aren't capable of evil. A lion doesn't eat the zebra because it's evil. It just has to.
A few corrections: -The Charon in this game is a much more sinister character than the one from actual mythology. His cosmetic pieces reveal that instead of leaving the ones without coins to wander the shores, he'd drown them in the river with his oar. -The Minotaur in-game isn't the minotaur from Greek myth. Rather, it's a sort of manifestation of every survivor's memories and fears of the monster made manifest by the Fog. This doesn't lend well to characterization, though, so I'm not going to say your placement was wrong. Aside that, excellent job. I really hope my Titan comment helped you out.
i'm pretty sure there's a charm which depicts the minotaur and 4 other people cowering before it in ancient greek style so this basically means that the entity snatched the minotaur so even if the oni minotaur isn't the actual minotaur, a minotaur does exist within the realm so we might as well treat this cosmetic as a spearate character too bad the devs didn't replace the kanabo though
@@spaceacepl4636 It is a separate character, yes, but the pieces' flavor text specifically states it was created by the Fog, so. And yeah, the lack of new sounds or a change to the kanabō sucks.
@@dredgenwar2375 just a simple club would've worked they did it for the hillbilly also the aforementioned depiction of the minotaur might imply that the ancient greeks knew about the trials in some way i think
i don't think it's right to say that hillbilly is bad and irredeemable, considering all of the reprehensible things that happened to him. he no doubt became a monster, but that really wasn't a choice of his by any means, and even the slightest but of comfort could have changed it. he could be redeemed if somebody were to show him the life he deserved to have
I would put HUNK in bad but redeemable. You see him risk his life to save people for no gain, takes the fall for his underlings mistakes and even tells his squad to leave him when he thinks theres no way for everyone to make it out alive. You could make the case hes just duty-bound but i dont think I'd buy that. To me it seems theres a human not too far under that armor.
One correction for you, Willian Berkin is one of the most evil characters in the history of Resident Evil. He's debatably worse than Wesker and was only held back by his short life span.
I would maybe put tiffany in the same place or right below Chucky, in Seed of Chucky she did talk about not wanting to kill, but at the end of the movie she immediately goes back to it. She cuts off all of Nica's limbs and keeps her almost as a human pet. She is probably considered to be crazier then chucky, he may be more violent with more kills, but Tiffany has a high body count too and even now still kills. IMO she is pretty evil, but I could see why you put her in that spot.
True, with the new seasons and everything they have really confirmed tiffany to just be crazy. I think even in interviews for the show Jennifer Tilly was suprised by how simply insane Tiffany is, but she really goes there. Also their flashback shows that she has been bad forever.@@wonderfulrose477
Hi Azh, last time you did a ranked ugly sweaters video was 2 years ago. think it's time to update it? we got so much now and i'd like to see your opinion on it
Needs a nonsapient category for Xeno, Demo, and maybe even Dredge. Slinger should not be irredeemable due to only attacking in revenge, and sparing the innocent outside the realm. Anna would probably be better if hou could just sit her down and teach her how a human functions, hard as that would be. And Max used to love superman and want to emulate him, but got pushed too far. Part of the reason I like fanfics about all of these (the few good ones). Just my thoughts.
Man naughty bear is not simply evil, the other bears are always bullying him even when he Is just trying to be nice yet he enjoys killing in very violent ways but I think the only thing he wants Is some friends 🐻
Are we not counting Grid as its own character? I understand not putting the failed clone, since it was likely never alive and is just a creation of the entity from ripley-8's mind, but grid is definetly a different xeno than the drone from the first. Also, since the queen is likely the one from 2 (since its pictured with Ellen from 2 and that was its first appearance) further support of your labelling of them as bad, since the queen negotiates with ripley before betraying their deal in an attempt to kill her and newt.
During the events of Resident Evil 0, William Birkins was one of the 'Co-Murderers' of Doctor James Marcus - he didn't shy away from openly mocking the dying umbrella exec about taking over his life work before he and wesker unceremoniously dumped his body in the training facilities sewerage department. definitely more in the scale of "evil and likely irredeemable" honestly! though his wife tried to do the right thing towards the end of RE2... ya'know before she died
Chucky is definitely evil incarnate, he was born that way and there is nothing redeemable about him at all, but even he has his weird standards like with how disgusted he was at Lexy, Jake's dad or Dr Foley. Tiffany is less evil than Chucky but far more deranged. Chucky is pure evil but never did anything as awful as what Tiffany did to Jennifer Tilly or Nica (I love Tiffany to bits but yeahhh she's nuts)
To be fair, Naughty Bear was pushed to his breaking point over years of taking the other bears' abuse and ample encouragement from The Narrator, which is the closest thing Naughty has to a friend. The birthday party was just the straw that broke the camel's back. So I think Naughty could be listed as bad, but redeemable, given that he likely wouldn't rampage so much if 1) he was shown genuine kindness and 2) he didn't let The Narrator guide him to violence so often.
I was a bit disappointed that we didn't get Andy as a survivor for Chucky, but it's really a tremendous blessing that he didn't end up in the Realm. When I was little, Chucky was scary because he was a killer doll. As an adult, he's scary because there are real people like him in the world. Anyone who manipulates a child's heart with no remorse, letting them think that the trauma that happened was their fault or deserved, is unforgivable. The Child's Play theme song itself gives off a really haunting feeling of innocence being lost and that's exactly what happened to Andy. 💔
And no one believing you when you really know what happened
Yeah no, they would not bring a child to DBD where you can actually kill the child as a killer, they're not gonna go down that road
Exactly or at least Kyle
Andy with a Kyle alt skin
They wouldn't add him with 2010 Freddy being in the realm
A few of them should be in a neutral tier, like demogorgon and xenomorph. They’re basically animals or insects, they don’t have any sense of morality or understand concepts like good or evil, they’re just living.
True , they mostly just act out of orders / survival , they dont have to be in any redeemable or ireedemable tier since they basically dont have any reasons to redeem themselves. They are like any animals and cant have this sense of redeeming , bad or good , i think they cant be good but also cant be evil when you think about the fact that they dont even know if what theyre doing is wrong and technically cant really think if its wrong (sorry if this was long btw its my opinion also)
Both of you make good points
Actually due to how a xenomorph is created (the facehugger alters the subject to make their body grow the Xeno out of them like a tumor) they have intelligence comparable to the species they came from. So sometimes they’re more doglike, and sometimes they’re near person/predator smart, setting traps/ambush, holding grudges, etc.
@@BlindCoyoteGodintelligence is just problem solving capabilities, it doesn't give the xenomorphs the ability to start philosophising or thinking about their actions
Totally agree. Nemesis will be in this tier too. He dosnt feel or think anything. Its like a biorobot. A parasite controle his body. And the parasite is programmed to find the stars
Spoiler for Ringu 0:
Sadako technically has a good side. When she was alive, there was the "normal" girl Sadako (still with her powers) and an evil entity Sadako that killed whoever she felt wronged her.
The "good" Sadako could heal people and warned others from potential danger, even tho they ignored her warnings and died for it. In the end, the "good" Sadako was blamed for everything, the death of the people she tried to warn and the death of the people the evil Sadako killed, this led everyone present to start hunting her with the goal to kill her.
After some running away, Sadako just couldn't take being blamed and hunted anymore, she merged with her evil side and went on her first rampage (technically out of self defence) killing everyone that hunted her.
Then her "good" side took over again and she cried while talking to her father, who proceeded to poison her, slash her head open and throw her down the well while Sadako tried to run away, pleading with him instead of defending herself.
She healed herself instantly once she was down in the well and survived down there for 20 years.
I do think that she is in the right tier being irredeemable but she arguably does have a good reason to believe that seemingly the whole world is against her.
Yo as another thing, the two Sadakos were seperated btw. The evil Sadako entity would stalk the good Sadako.
I didn't make that clear in the original comment.
That's a pretty hardcore origin story
You also forgot sadako's entire story only happened to her because her mother had a child with a demon, she didnt have any choice to have evil sadako and actively tried to help people evade it, even when she fused evil sadako was in control, her curse exists because people constantly harmed her emotional and physically which made her an onryo seeking vengeance upon humanity for her being wronged so much, and even then its mostly evil sadako not good sadako, otherwise there wouldnt be a 7 day warning, theres still a bit of good in sadako even if its overall pointless trying to help since most people wont believe it and die, the ones that heed her warning more commonly survived.
@@coma2726 well that's a lot of speculation which is why i didn't say it in my initial comment. I wanted to stick with what we know for sure.
We think that her father is a sea demon but we don't actually know. Considering the duality of japanese mythology, her father could very well also be a sea god or the sea itself.
The 7 days are very much depending on interpretation. It could be a warning or it could be 7 days of her tormenting you. She does after all stalk you like evil Sadako used to stalk good Sadako and she tries to influence the people around you into watching the tape as well in those 7 days. In the japanese movies, there isn't even a call telling you about the time you have left, it is mentioned as part of a urban legend but turns out to be false.
They only knew the timer because the people that were cursed before them died after 7 days.
It could also just be a way for her to spread the curse, they are after all creating more cursed tapes and have to curse someone else to prevent themselves from dying.
I personally think neither good or evil Sadako are in "control", they are both part of the same person now. We also have to take into account, that the last dominant personality we saw after they merged, was "good" Sadako.
Edit: also DbD should add a "good" Sadako skin.
i would be pretty angy if i was her tbh
19:06 I wouldn’t say Naughty Bear is simply evil,he’s like Billy,all of the other bears in the game thought he was ugly because he looked different,they made fun of him,bullied him and excluded him from everything,he tried to be nice and bring a fellow bear a Birthday Present for his birthday and they laughed at him and smashed his gift,the voice in his head convinced him to kill them all,this could also describe Naughty bear’s mental state (Etc)
Yep, Naughty was more of a victim who never have his peace because of other bears
I think your right i also seen his secret before now i understand it all
If I were this RUclipsr I rather put naughty bear in the actually good spot, and it’s the bears fault for making him a killer bear because he just wants to have friends ( poor thing )
It gets worse than that. The other bears literally called in Police, Ninjas, Soldiers, S.W.A.T, Robots, literal X-Men, Pirates, even Vampires trying to kill him even when Naughty didn't do anything in some times. In one of the cutscenes in the game, he had a nightmare where he was shown having the hair and horn from the most friendliest creatures called Unibears but Naughty Bear had his horn cut off by that same bear who had his birthday. People made theories that he used to be a Unibear but became the way he is by one of the other bears. It was never proven true, nobody said what that cutscene was really about.
Naughty try’s to give up his selfish ways like Tiffany did but failed
I stand by Wraith having the best lore
I feel like he's one of the only characters that could truly redeem himself
The poor guy would deserve some sort of redemption too
Counter point: Billy
And he bagged Nurse. What an absolute chad.
@@twinzzlersbillys lore is sorta like Frankensteins Monster, he wasn't evil but suffers abuse and became a brutal murderer, torturing animals and his parents then brutally murdering them and anyone who enters his farm
tbh wraith to me is the killer with the most promise of coming full-circle, character-wise. he has all the makings of a tragic hero. sure trapper is sort of the “protagonist” of the killer cast, but there’s a lot more going on for wraith that could make for a good story within the fog imo, if bhvr ever tries to do a “kill the entity” arc lmao.
I’ll say Doctor is much more vile than Myers. Myers at least has the decency to kill you in a short amount of time, Herman on the other hand probably doesn’t even want his victims to die. He’d rather them stay alive for millennia and the reason he officially offs them is so he isn’t found out. All I can say about Doc is that he’d feel right at home with the Cenobites.
Plus it feels worse for someone to be evil and enjoy it rather than being apathetic.
Though I agree on your perspective of Herman aka doctor, Myers isn’t any better and could be considered worse as there’s really no point to his killing as he almost seemed to have the perfect life plus as the movies go on it just gets worse even going after what family he has left trying to kill his niece plus not all of Michael’s kills are fast and painless some are slow and painful almost like he knows what he’s going to do and chooses weather to make it fast or as painful as he likes most of the time it’s based on the situation but most of the time when he catches people alone he makes it slow and painful
@@megalabite1013 Fair point.
@@RedCommunistDragon I could still see doctor consider worse though, even if I don’t fully agree with it as I do see that doctor’s pure enjoyment of not just killing but torturing experiences very evil idk if it is worse then Myers though I do agree that he deserves evil incarnate
@@megalabite1013eh I wouldn’t compare the two. They’re both evil in it’s evilest forms in different ways
Killers like Demogorgon shouldn’t be in the “redeemable “ category, it’s a beast designed to kill beings for their survival. Maybe you should make a “mindless” category for the likes of Demogorgon, Xenomorph and so on.
I was thinking the same. It’s kind of just an extreme carnivore. You wouldn’t call tigers evil because they eat other animals (and very very rarely humans)
Well...an animal is an animal, they cant help it with what they are. They kill for instinct.
Being evil means you choose to do bad things because you enjoy them.
Im with you in that one.
If you think they're mindless just because they can't speak a language then you're ignorant. If they were mindless they would not be so dangerious.
@@Veldazandtea They do everything by instincts, it’s not about if they speak or not, which’s very accurate to the word “mindless” but it’s funny you said “If they were mindless they wouldn’t be so dangerous” when lions and other predators exists in real life lol how ignorant of you
At most, you could put the queen in the redeemable since she is more intelligent than her children. That being said she does what she does to propagate her species.
I think slinger is redeemable because he never went after those who were innocent or did him no wrong. I think that the entity does make him view the survivors as people that wronged him so that's why he "enjoys" the trials (his laughs for every snipe and m1).
Same thoughts here. Was surprised to see him on the "not redeemable" list. He's one of a few decent guys out there...
i think that his tier is because even tough he doesnt end completely innocent people,when he does kill people it is brutal.he is pretty sadistic
but i do think he should be a little lower on the tier,he isnt that bad
18:57
As someone who knows a bit about naughty bear; he isn’t a bad guy to a fault. The other teddy bears on the island are jerks like when they had a celebration for naughty only to throw a cake in his face and make fun of him. On different occasions there were evil teddy bear aliens, deadly robot teddy bears, the secret service, super heroes, the military, zombies, ninjas and even vampires. Hell, teddy doesn’t try to actively kill the other bears on the island only when they try to mess with him. So he’s more bad but redeemable.
I really think that if Artist retained her tongue, she would be saying a whole dictionary of insults at Entity
Y'know, considering she's Chilean
3:06 that dwight 💀
I've heard he is still hiding there to that day😂
this is a dwight with prestige 101
That's some Blair Witch shit LOL
Had to triple check 💀
Always a dwight
I think Huntress belongs in the 'redeemable' category. She doesn't seem to recognize other humans as people, except for young girls, who she shows compassion (if not actual care) for. So I'd call her redeemable on the grounds that, if she actually were to understand what she was doing, she would stop. She simply seems to be incapable of it.
I agree with your interpretation of her character-in that she'd stop if she fully understood what was happening-but still say she's Irredeemable *_because_* she's incapable of understanding; the knowledge she needs to earn her redemption is outside of her reach, and impossible to obtain.
Deathslinger should be on good or neutral as he was severly mistreated on his chilhood by bullies, used and developed anger issues, then he got used by henry bayshore, then he thought he could redeem himslef by working as a bounty hunter hunting, criminals and not hurting innocents, and then he got used again by the warden, then when he got his revenge, the entity shows him the survivors as the people that used and wronged him.
I honestly like that you used the Cosmetic ones. Hopefully you will continue to do so, but I don't mind if you don't.
Hunk cared about his crew and he did take the blame for one of his crew members shooting William
Very true. The uploader probably doesn't have an extensive knowledge of the franchise to be honest.
H.U.N.K. is a significantly better person than Billy Berkin ever was, the dude was "German" scientist levels of evil.
I don’t think Wesker was that bad of a guy before the Progenitor virus, he was simply an ambitious scientist like Birkin. The progenitor virus was described to have made him obsessive and narcissistic so I think that was a major factor in his disregard for life and god complex
I forget, did he have the progenitor virus before the events of Re1?
@@mr.lifebrain1891after tyrant plunged his big ol claw through wesker then birkin injected him with a virus
@@mr.lifebrain1891 yes pretty much anywhere he wears sunglasses he had it. He had it injected before joining STARS
@@deathslingermain7467 I think theres a fair bit more lore in the Wesker Files you can find floating around on YT. IIRC he wasnt a good guy from the start with his God complex always being a part of who he was
True, and also his upbringing probably has a lot to do with who he is. Him being taken from his parents and basically forced to participate in Project W definitely took a toll on him.
I'll admit,HUNK,The Look-See,Nemesis,and Pyramid Head aren't evil in a sense that they kill for the enjoyment,they do it because it's their job in HUNK'S case,or their purpose in the other's,but the ones that kill because they want to (basically all of them) are all evil IMO
That makes hunk worse
@@tfordham13 A job is a job and money is money,do what you need to survive,which I find not so bad
@@AngelOfDC he probably gets paid a lot for the work he does, so I wouldn't go so far as to say he does it to "survive"
@@TheNeteenhu When I say survive I just mean make money to get food and shelter etc.
@FourByteBurger expect he does his job for fun also killing other humans for a job is evil
The Warhammer killing for survival was not really meant how you interpreted it. The only time the Warhammer ever did anything, it was to defend a country from an attack and it killed nobody while doing so.
(sry for always commenting about stuff you got wrong, i think you do an amazing job. I just want the videos to be the best they can possibly be, by clearing up some stuff)
Aint she also like... hardcore racist as well?
I agree
Here's a fun thing to do: let's discuss which deadly sin the killers each embody the most.
Gluttony: Probably the Clown, due to both being the thiccest boy on the roster, and his bloodthirst being insatiable.
Wrath: While it can go to many killers, I think Oni embodies it, as he is driven to kill by the Entity simply taunting him.
Lust: Even if we were to disregard his child predator ways in the reboot, the Nightmare takes the most pleasure in his methods.
Envy: This may be a bit of a stretch, but I think Hag gets this distinction because she started using her charms to get ahead.
Pride: It seems like the Mastermind has the biggest god complex, as he boasts in the final boss of Resident Evil 5.
Sloth: Maybe the Shape, which is strange because he is among the more efficient killers. But that may play into the reasoning. His Mori animation is among the more lax of the killers and an add on makes it even easier to do use it. He doesn't put much effort into killing cause he doesn't need to.
Greed: None of the killers seem primarily motivated by money, but I think Trickster comes closest to it, turning his crimes into a career.
Darwin: This award will be given to the killer with the least intelligence. I'm thinking Dredge since he is seen as just a force of nature controlled by the Entity.
But what do you think? Do you think other killers embody some of these crimes more? Feel free to give your own thoughts on this topic.
I think you should have put demo, xeno, and blight in a seperate category saying "basically just animals"
Saying the Xenomorphs are bad and irredeemable is kinda like saying any human that eats meat is bad and irredeemable. Both kill organisms to further their survival with no malice behind it. Actually it makes even less sense to call Xenomorphs evil because they don't seem smart enough to even choose a different option nor do they seem to enjoy having to kill, unlike a hunter or fisherman. I think Xenomorphs should be in a neutral category
I mean we're tiering them from a human pov based on human concepts of good and bad. So of course anything that hurts humans is bad
In the original movie, the xenomorph was practically delaying killing Lambert(I believe was her name?) It was feasting on her fear and practically sexually assaulted her with the tail 💀
Humans kill other beings with no malice behind it. We've been doing it for thousands of years and put "animals" in factories to be turned into food. The xenomorphs are just more honest about it. We are the animals too. Only a human would be stupid enough to pretend animals don't think. They do. They pause. They think. They consider. They plan. Thought is simply delayed instinct and instinct is rapid thought put into action. And as Sekiro states, "Hesitation is defeat".
The xenomorph is faster. Smarter. Stronger. It's coming. For. You.
New idea: who all the killers/survivors would main in smash
I read this as "who they would smash"
For some reason, I see Hillbilly liking Pichu or Diddy Kong cause he likes machines and little animals
Twins are Ice Climbers
Zero Suit: Skull Merchant, she seems like she would like it
Knight: Belmonts
Trickster: Jigglypuff, fast and musically-inclined
Ridley: Demogorgon, would remind him of the upside down creatures
Olimar: Blight, he would be fascinated by their biology
Wario: Clown, emits gases that are hard to breathe in
Rob: Singularity
Kirby: Alien, strong extraterrestrial creature that takes on aspects of their prey
Sephiroth: Legion, edgy as hell
Sheik: Nurse, teleporting masked lady who kills in secret
New idea: All killers ranked on their smashability
Actually Chucky is Evil Incarnate due to the fact that before he transferred his soul into a Good Guy doll, he was known as "The Harwood Strangler".
It’s actually “lake shore strangler.”
@@rainoffire1233 My Bad
as a chucky fan I AM OFFENDED (I'm kidding btw don't take it seriously tbh I didn't even notice that you made the mistake at first because I read it wrong)
Evil incarnate is a physical manifestation of the force of evil, I don't think this applies here.
@@Bckgroundguy101In that case I would put doctor to simply evil because he’s not a literal embodiment of evil unlike Myers or The Dredge
I don't feel like it's right to call the xenos bad or dredge evil either. They seem bestial, no role of morality within them. Dredge isn't evil by choice, but by origin. All I've ever read of him in lore is that he just seems to eat anything he comes across, he's more akin to a wild boar than a villain.
Dredge is the most evil thing on this list. It's created LITERALLY by evil. It's COMPOSED of evil itself, hence the ranking of evil incarnate. Committing evil out of instinct and design is still evil, but it's even worse since it's an amalgamation and manifestation of the evil of humanity.
I’d argue that Leatherface and Hillbilly are bad but redeemable. Leatherface was born into a bad family and is manipulated by them due to his mental illness. Hillbilly was abused as a child and was chained to a chair, only to watch tv all day and kill animals under the duress of his parents and the sheriff. Leatherface and Billy don’t know any better, it was more of the circumstances and not their own conscious decisions.
i think bubba and billy are both just cases where if they were given a proper upbringing, they wouldn't be killers. bubba kills out of fear, he doesn't get any enjoyment out of it.
Didn't know there were that many killers (with cosmetics)
The armored Titan isn’t smiling. Its armored face plate covers its mouth, but it’s shaped like a smile.
It could be smiling? The proof against it?
He can't move the armor it is in a fixed position. This doesn't mean he is literally smiling when doing killing or anything. Doesn't mean he isn't either I guess, but his actions aren't out of a love to kill he is doing a duty and I believe typically doesn't really enjoy it. @@StopWhiningManguideCultists
@@rocketjet5813 it probably likes the lack of thunder spears and stuff though
@@StopWhiningManguideCultists If you watch the anime the plate can shift down to expose his mouth. He has a constant look of anger. Titans usually aren’t capable of showing much more than 1 emotion. Plus if you know the person who is the Armored Titan, they don’t enjoy it, or are serious the whole time.
@@sibsart2039 oh I fogar about that
I feel like Tiffany's actions in the second season of the show move her up there with Chucky.
I think that Sadako is redeemable. She definitely has humanity. The whole "curse" isn't actually real, she can kill people who never touched the tape but she and the reason why she waits 7 days before she kills is because she gives people a chance to survive. If someone passes the take to someone else Sadako can still kill that person but chooses not to. Her actual goal is to share her sad story with people and make them sympathize with her. That's the main purpose of the tape and that's why she only kills people who don't pass the tape in 7 days. If she wanted to kill as many people as possible she could simply make a bunch of clones and send every clone after people and kill everyone . If people keep passing the tape to others and understand her story/sympathize with her there is a food chance that she would stop killing because her goal would be fulfilled.
Nah she is pretty evil
3:06 finds Dwight, had to triple check
5:33 goes to Dwight again, still just as confused
6:40 - 6:50 double perk reference is crazy
Dr Berkin in resident evil is just a coward he’s not evil, in his game he’s fighting to keep control of his mind, he will say sorry and tell you he is around the area and to stay away and when you fight him he will rip open the eye on his arm so you can shoot it
I feel like the Cenobites aren’t evil, they’re kind of neutral. They’re just doing their job.
“We have such sights to show you”
No there just plain evil, cenobites are literally demons now and their leader pinhead and his leader the engineer are all evil.
Hello, AZHY, very interesting video. It was good to know something new about the ferryman and some other characters👍, also could you please make a video : if killers and survivors were not forced to trials, but simply were able to communicate, who would be friends with who, or who would hate someone
I don't think naughty bear is evil but instead bad but irredeemable because the only reason he started killing the bears is because the narrator was telling him to.
Spirit may be the most innocent killer lore wise but her players are not
Much love
@@Alizudo I respect you without a doubt tho
Oh hey, that's me!
Hope you reported the guy abusing the locker bug in your 2nd game, sucks that bug is back…
even if he didn't, we still got the guy's name
I did
@@AZHYMOVS good.
actually, in recent marvel comics it was said that the xenomorphs exist to punish the races that get to the stars and their objective is to keep sppecies in their planet
I find it crazy that Huntress doesn’t know how to take care of the little girls she kidnaps. She had a mother that took care of her, surely she would remember how her mother fed and took care of her. Sounds more like she viewed the girls as disposable pets.
I doubt she knows how to cook, or nurse sickness, I'm not even sure if treating wounds beyond bandages. Hell, she'd barely know how to speak, a vocabulary of a child, plus some insanity from being in the woods alone for decades.
She still has a mind of a child so it's not unbelievable
@@YanramichI would think even a child would understand that people need to eat and die to the cold, given that they themselves are exposed to this phenomena...
@@dumblenutz5561 she does try, as seen from her backstory, it's just that she's so tough and used to the elements that a frail child doesn't even compare to her. She's trying to model them in her own image, which they can't clearly bear.
Love that the logo is wearing a little hat
I’m commenting this a bit early on, but I think an additional category of animalistic would have worked.
A few of the killers are pure instinct, so categorizing them as good or evil would be difficult.
But maybe that would have been boring because of how many could be placed in this category idk…
20:08 why is Doctor so high on the list? his "psychopathic personality" is not that different from other characters like Clown and Trickster, I always thought they were exactly the same but in other situations or contexts lmao
Doctor uses much more violent and horrific methods to torture his victims, electro shock therapy is downright cruel and much worse than anything clown or trickster have done
Doctor doesn't just kill, he tortures his victims
He tortured people for hours out of pure enjoyment and fascination in their pain, the tome scenes show how twisted he is
@@therealdeadpoolLOL
Aren't you confirming what I said with that statement? What you said he does is exactly what Clown and Trickster also did (this is more obvious with Trickster but Clown's lore also mentions that he drugged and tortured his victims).
And yep I have seen all the cinematics of the tomes, so I already saw the Doctor's one
@@matias_dbd I would also put them in evil incarnate as well. I think the reason that Doctor is in evil incarnate is that his lore implies he tortured people for years and was never truly caught, meaning he's at least cunning and maniacal enough to continue his deeds if the fog never captured him
Hey AZHY keep up the awesome dbd videos they mean a lot and help me through rough times thanks a lot!! 😎👍🏼❤️
I wonder where michael will be placed 🤔
Bro knew what he did there with using Doctor as "Evil Incarnate" 😂
Great video as usual tho
The Twins have the saddest story. I have the most empathy for them
Bro forgot
Artist, wraith, hag, 💀
It’s a good always day when AZHYMOVS uploads
ok first off you clearly didnt understand that those bears were absolute jerks too naughty bear all the time for no reason,and being full on bullies,going to drill over his home for oil,getting the literal military by strapping cameras to birds to stalk him,not to mention they were going to vote for someone to get him off the island,they brought full on super bears after him,AND EVEN FULL ON VAMPIRES i mean come on they had it coming,naughty bear isnt evil the bears that were on the same island as him were,he did want to get along with them he really did but they didnt want to but instea treat him like utter garbage,every single one of those bears treated him like trash even after he saved the island from being taken over by aliens,naughty bear isnt evil he was just miss treated if he met different bears maybe he would not be like that,but he isnt full on evil he just wanted some friends but all those bears did was treat him like utter garbage
I'm glad you got the armored titan's mindset pretty much on the nose this time. The description of the war hammer titan is still wrong but I think the category you placed it in is accurate considering the very small amount of screen time it has.
you forgot to add nea in the evil incarnate tier
I'd say Naughty Bear is Bad, but redeemable. He wanted to do good before dbd, he wanted to be accepted. But the other bears didn't, and they treated him like trash. Even after he saved them all. Understandably he'd break and decide to kill them, i bet if anyone treated him with genuine niceness he'd be a good guy. But he also might think they'd turn on him like how the other bears turned on him when he saved them.
How the hell is william berkin less evil than Hunk?!
4:53 8:02
Berkin was trying to save his "lifes work" and sell it to the US government and was a traitor to umbrella who causes the entire raccoon city incident which in the end gets nuked and wiped off the map
Clearly having rage and tries to kill any human in his way
Hunk is a private contractor, trained in rockfort island 🪨
He does have sections of his own game and its strictly fighting B.O.W's and in his original mini story as the 4th survivor
He has to logistically avoid killing so that he has enough to get through what he has to fight
Only to secure his word and the operation as a success
The only parts where I see an issue is that he doesn't much care what happens to his fellow operators in the field
Yet that isn't true
Operation raccoon city and other games shows and RE2 and remake show him as a competent leader that only wants to get the job done and doesn't want anyone get hurt
Even understanding fuck ups and accepting the losses ans moves on
He is more so a victim of his circumstances and the clearances of operations he is assigned to
He is paid to survive and he does that
Which oddly makes me wish he had a survivor skin as the 4th survivor
His current dbd skin sounds like frank
Check out operation raccoon city or RE2 RM wish he had the voice lines, music, and more to go with him but that will be the day
(The day they will take my wallet rightfully)
12:33 As Deathslinger is my favorite killer in DbD, it does make me sad that he's considered too far gone to be redeemable. 😔 I do understand your decision to put him in this tier, though.
I feel you my man. But I honestly think our man Caleb isn’t too far gone! If you really think about, he’s a bounty hunter meaning he’s not going after innocent people. And he only beat the shit out of the people who actually wronged him. There’s still hope yet for our favorite yeehaw man…
But badass vengeful cowboy is still pretty cool 😂
@@Xman-0124 True!
Personally, I have to disagree with Huntress and Amanda.
Huntress just need the right environment to be a better person and Amanda just needs someone to help her and I feel like they would’ve been good people and even in the state they’re in if they were put in the right direction they can be good people.
4:54 I think Birkin should probably be higher because if I remember correctly he conspired with Wesker to murder one of his colleagues who was also doing research for Umbrella so that he wouldn’t compete with them
It's just business
yea Birkin is 100% evil, even IF he was protecting Sherry out of paternal instinct(there are doubts) he done plenty of evil stuff in the name of his research
I knew you’d put Michael in Evil category. 20:52
I think Wesker should fall under evil incarnate because he out of all the killers should have the highest kill count via those infected with the various viruses released
I get putting the whole Legion there, but honestly I feel like I’d still slightly argue for Susie being potentially redeemable. Though that’s mostly down to how you interpret her.
For the most part she just comes off to me like a girl with little sense of self-identity or confidence or just all of that really, so she latched on to this group of people, more specifically Julie I think, who accept her and encourage her (unfortunately in her violent impulses). It’s why she threw herself so much into stuff like the name of the group and the friendship bracelets and BFF hearts, but also why most of her mask don’t even have faces; the Legion is her entire identity.
I don’t think this diminishes her crimes or anything, like if she hadn’t actually killed someone before that store incident, her cosmetics indicate she’s done stuff the others probably weren’t even involved in, so no matter invested she is in the groups persona she’s legally adult who made those choices, but I do think she’s the closest to being actually reformed after MUCH psychological help.
I get going with Joey though as the most likely, he does seem the most stable in a sense, really just in the gang for the sake of hanging out and enjoying the violence and general mayhem they cause (really the only reason I still hold to Susie is that she seems less inclined to violence without being spurred on by something) while still it took him a bit to jump to murder.
Thanks again for another thought out and well put together video Azhy 👍🏻
20:29 i know this was technically redacted with the release of the dredge, but what herman did to otto stamper in his release lore is, to me, what puts him on the evil incarnate tier. without that specific incident i would place him somewhere between trickster and oni. but that bit of lore, i wish they had kept that, because it really shows how evil doctor truly is
if you don’t know what i’m talking about you can look it up on the wiki but be warned it is nightmare fuel, with extreme body horror
"Honey, wake up! AZHYMOVS remade his "Killers Ranked Least to Most EVIL" video!"
Great video as always! Keep up the good work! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
HUNK's not a merc, he's an Umbrella soldier, he looks down on the UBCS as mercenaries
WHAT HAPPENED IN THE BACKGROUND AT 16:25 LMFAO
Ok so good video, but i just wanna say wtf during that wraith gameplay. That dwight being glitched in a locker was wild af.
My main complaint would be with the placement of the xenomorphs, animals aren't capable of evil. A lion doesn't eat the zebra because it's evil. It just has to.
5:55 im sorry but the bugfed out locker dwight us funny
A few corrections:
-The Charon in this game is a much more sinister character than the one from actual mythology. His cosmetic pieces reveal that instead of leaving the ones without coins to wander the shores, he'd drown them in the river with his oar.
-The Minotaur in-game isn't the minotaur from Greek myth. Rather, it's a sort of manifestation of every survivor's memories and fears of the monster made manifest by the Fog. This doesn't lend well to characterization, though, so I'm not going to say your placement was wrong.
Aside that, excellent job. I really hope my Titan comment helped you out.
i'm pretty sure there's a charm which depicts the minotaur and 4 other people cowering before it in ancient greek style
so this basically means that the entity snatched the minotaur
so even if the oni minotaur isn't the actual minotaur, a minotaur does exist within the realm so we might as well treat this cosmetic as a spearate character
too bad the devs didn't replace the kanabo though
@@spaceacepl4636 It is a separate character, yes, but the pieces' flavor text specifically states it was created by the Fog, so. And yeah, the lack of new sounds or a change to the kanabō sucks.
@@dredgenwar2375 just a simple club would've worked
they did it for the hillbilly
also the aforementioned depiction of the minotaur might imply that the ancient greeks knew about the trials in some way i think
Judith Barsi suffered the same fate as Spirit. Poor, poor Ducky
I came out of a coma just recently about a week ago, I played dead by daylight back in 2018 (it was a 5 year coma) there’s 51 killers?
Some are skins
Through
i don't think it's right to say that hillbilly is bad and irredeemable, considering all of the reprehensible things that happened to him. he no doubt became a monster, but that really wasn't a choice of his by any means, and even the slightest but of comfort could have changed it.
he could be redeemed if somebody were to show him the life he deserved to have
I would put HUNK in bad but redeemable. You see him risk his life to save people for no gain, takes the fall for his underlings mistakes and even tells his squad to leave him when he thinks theres no way for everyone to make it out alive. You could make the case hes just duty-bound but i dont think I'd buy that. To me it seems theres a human not too far under that armor.
One correction for you, Willian Berkin is one of the most evil characters in the history of Resident Evil. He's debatably worse than Wesker and was only held back by his short life span.
couldn't help not thinking about that locker glitching survivor... that pissed me off xD
Azhymovs casually name dropped two perks in Nemesis' section
The flashlight glitch returned once again. And I wasn't even there to use it totally cause I'm a good person and didnt just take a break.
I would maybe put tiffany in the same place or right below Chucky, in Seed of Chucky she did talk about not wanting to kill, but at the end of the movie she immediately goes back to it. She cuts off all of Nica's limbs and keeps her almost as a human pet. She is probably considered to be crazier then chucky, he may be more violent with more kills, but Tiffany has a high body count too and even now still kills. IMO she is pretty evil, but I could see why you put her in that spot.
I was thinking the same thing. She’s at least at the “simply evil” level.
True, with the new seasons and everything they have really confirmed tiffany to just be crazy. I think even in interviews for the show Jennifer Tilly was suprised by how simply insane Tiffany is, but she really goes there. Also their flashback shows that she has been bad forever.@@wonderfulrose477
Why is the GOOD GUY not in the 'actually good' section?!
Because he's changed into the "not so good guy"
Hi Azh, last time you did a ranked ugly sweaters video was 2 years ago. think it's time to update it? we got so much now and i'd like to see your opinion on it
Reiner the Armored Titan regrets the things he did in season 1-3, so in Season 4, he is full of regret even wanting to un alive himself
We don't know if it is Reiner
the fact i forgot naughty bear was in DBD and hearing him come up made me do a double take XD i loved that game
Xenomorphs have a sense of sadism, as they prefer going for victims that are terrified of them (their primary priority are hostile victims though)
The don't have priorities
This is really interesting and all, but I'm still wondering WTF happened at 16:23
Needs a nonsapient category for Xeno, Demo, and maybe even Dredge. Slinger should not be irredeemable due to only attacking in revenge, and sparing the innocent outside the realm. Anna would probably be better if hou could just sit her down and teach her how a human functions, hard as that would be. And Max used to love superman and want to emulate him, but got pushed too far. Part of the reason I like fanfics about all of these (the few good ones). Just my thoughts.
You are a really good at the lores keep up the good work
The wraith lore can be resumed in one prase: *my people are dead, but so are those bastards*
During the Nemesis section, AZHYMOVS cites three perk names. Accidental or no?
Great tier list, but I think I would’ve placed Chucky as evil incarnate tier. That’s just my opinion though lol.
Pyramid is a good guy, he's just a therapist with less talking and extra steps. Like the Look-see.
Didn’t realize that the dbd Ghostface was the best one ever
I’d say wraith could be argued as good (from what you said) as he’s more so a chaotic good (correcting wrongs but in a violent way)
Man naughty bear is not simply evil, the other bears are always bullying him even when he Is just trying to be nice yet he enjoys killing in very violent ways but I think the only thing he wants Is some friends 🐻
No it's been completely twisted now, he loves the realm and loves violence
@@StopWhiningManguideCultists I mean if the realm makes him happy good for him I'm just saying he Is a little more complex than just evil
Are we not counting Grid as its own character? I understand not putting the failed clone, since it was likely never alive and is just a creation of the entity from ripley-8's mind, but grid is definetly a different xeno than the drone from the first.
Also, since the queen is likely the one from 2 (since its pictured with Ellen from 2 and that was its first appearance) further support of your labelling of them as bad, since the queen negotiates with ripley before betraying their deal in an attempt to kill her and newt.
Tf was that dwight doin in that locker during the wraiths segment?
During the events of Resident Evil 0, William Birkins was one of the 'Co-Murderers' of Doctor James Marcus - he didn't shy away from openly mocking the dying umbrella exec about taking over his life work before he and wesker unceremoniously dumped his body in the training facilities sewerage department.
definitely more in the scale of "evil and likely irredeemable" honestly! though his wife tried to do the right thing towards the end of RE2... ya'know before she died
Chucky is definitely evil incarnate, he was born that way and there is nothing redeemable about him at all, but even he has his weird standards like with how disgusted he was at Lexy, Jake's dad or Dr Foley. Tiffany is less evil than Chucky but far more deranged. Chucky is pure evil but never did anything as awful as what Tiffany did to Jennifer Tilly or Nica (I love Tiffany to bits but yeahhh she's nuts)
Can you be less evil but more deranged? XD how does that work
3:06
bro caught him in 4K lol
To be fair, Naughty Bear was pushed to his breaking point over years of taking the other bears' abuse and ample encouragement from The Narrator, which is the closest thing Naughty has to a friend. The birthday party was just the straw that broke the camel's back. So I think Naughty could be listed as bad, but redeemable, given that he likely wouldn't rampage so much if 1) he was shown genuine kindness and 2) he didn't let The Narrator guide him to violence so often.
Half of these killers I didn’t even know about. Are these exclusive killers for some reason?
Sorry you're gonna have to redo the whole video. I was thoroughly distracted by the absolutely clean Wesker gameplay.