JOY DIVISION IN A LONELY PLACE FULL LENGTH VERSION
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- CHECK OUT IN A LONELY PLACE COMPLETE VERSION MARK SEVEN !!!!!! CONTAINS UNEDITED FULL LENGTH TRACK AND ALSO VERSION SIX WITH ADDITIONS AND OTHER VERSIONS FROM APRIL AND MAY 1980!!!!! in a lonely place, probably the heaviest track in the history of 'rock'. Ian curtis's final and greatest masterpiece, where he tells the world he will soon be dead, the lyrics are told as is if he is already dead, 'caressing the marble and stone', and he even tells us how he is going to do it, 'hangman looks round as he waits 'cord stretches tight then it breaks' . This song has only been available (not counting the superb new order seven inch version) as a 2 and half minuites on heart and soul. Last year a (deliberately messed up) 30 second clip appeared on the net for one day then disappeared. So ive stuck the clip in between two slices of heart and soul, and given it a bit of a spruce up, the result is a flawed but very worthwhile 5 minuites plus version of IALP. I will try to improve the sound quality in coming months . happy listening MARK FOUR NOW UP PROBABLY BEST ONE YET.
This song is part of a trilogy of Joy Division's most beautiful and haunting songs: 'Atmosphere', 'Decades', and 'In a Lonely Place'. This song being recorded just 4 days before Ian hung himself-making his lyrics even more chilling.
Jesus fucking Christ... and we all thought 'Decades' was deep.
Absolutely terrifying. I never knew Ian wrote a song where he sang so explicitly about suicide.
This song has a physical effect on me. It's like someone punching me in the throat. How easy it would be to end it all....
I can actually say something ive never said about any music before. This song truly frightens me.
this song is so morbid, and we can feel the anguished heart of Ian... R.I.P.
Caressing the marble and stone,
Love that was special for one,
The waste in the fever I heat,
How I wish you were here with me now.
Body that curls in and dies,
And shares that awful daylight,
Warm like a dog round your feet,
How I wish you were here with me now.
Hangman looks round as he waits,
Cord stretches tight then it breaks,
Someday we will die in your dreams,
How I wish we were here with you now.
Yup i had a co worker who was the last person on earth you would think would kill himself. He didn't have depression or any other mental illness that i or anyone else could pick up on. The guy had everything going for him and was certainly not morbid or depressed. One day we said goodbye to each other and cya tomorrow. The next day i went to work everyone was crying and i didn't know what was up. Turns out he went home and shot himself in the head that night. That was a shock to say the least.
birdandthe Thanks for being the best human on youtube. My God, thank you for doing this. Heaviest track of all time, no question. At once terrifying and soothing.
Holy damn that was some Joy Division.
cheers for putting this on mate as a joy division fan since 1978 and having seen them live twice I think I'm qualified to say that it's nice to hear this version even if it's not the full rehearsal version which we will probably never hear .instead of moaning about the why do this and why don't you do that blah blah blah as a joy division fan at least it's good to hear so thanks for taking the time and trouble to actually put it on
You were always magnificent. One could only imagine what you would of shared with us.
You can't blame them in that way. Of course Ians' situation was awful, and of course they were aware of what was going on with him, but they were just some young boys dealing with a quite tough situation, dealing with a depressed person is not any easy, dude. And I'm quite sure they painfully remember his death everyday. "Pretending not to see his gun.."
People certainly know how to judge about situations they were not in or part of.
That reminds me.Of the handfull of suicides I've known,none gave any recognizable indication.They were successful in conventional terms,seemed happy enough.A lot of morbid and "mopey" are still going strong.Don't feel bad,the mentally ill are tough.I've worked with them,they've survived what other people can't even imagine.That said,Ian Curtis was a huge loss.
I think you did an excellent job no matter what anyone says.
How I wish you were here with me now.
Bernard once said in interview, that he had no power in changing Ian's decision whether to die or not...guy had it all figured out. he wanted to be dead before 25 and he succeeded. no one really could stop him
@birdandthe Men & women of very age are self-centered, it's a truth I'm come to learn even more and more as I grow older. As a result, I had to become self-centered myself just to survive. The human race & the times are all a huge disappointment & it leaves me wondering why were even here. Ian Curtis had issues and it's a tragedy that he didn't get the right help, but I can certainly understand some of what he must have been thinking. RIP Ian.
It sounds like they were starting to write Martin Hannett´s psychoacoustics into their written music by the end, in anticipation of going into the studio.
HAUNTING us still,touching from a distance
@ProjectFlashlight612 the band knew he made 2 attempts but probably dident think he would go all the way, promises WERE broken, like the plan to take 6 months off from touring because of his worsening fits, only to organise a tour of the US. Still ian would go on as he dident want to let the side down, bernard especially asked if he was ok and even tried hypnotherapy, gigs in april were well spread and many cancelled but still had a big fit at moonlight and blackouts at derby, tragic.
@DeadSouls6 IF THE LYRICS ARE TOO HEAVY FOR YOU GO LISTEN TO FLEETWOOD MAC
wow !!!!!!! amazing never thought id live to hear this !!!!!!!
so emotional
@Useless2112 i largely agree, a friend of mine killed himself in the early eighties aged 23, everyone was shocked as he seemed the happiest person out....... to almost everyone......... generally men in their early twenties dont pick up on that, they are mostly self centred. Although In ians case he did have two attempts in three months, the slashed wrist and overdose, maybe more should ahve been done, but ian was a master of disguise, except ironically in his lyrics.
Yeah, I know what you mean! Love Silent Hill.
RIP Ian Curtis
No comments now? What is this? I just wanna say good job and Godspeed Ian! I miss the guy. Sure, after his demise it gave us New Order, which are pretty damn good...but it still ain't no Joy Division! :-D
This sounds like a Silent Hill song at the beggining xD
LOVE IT
STOP PRESS !!! MARK SIX OUT BY WEEKEND 30 APRIL BEST QUALITY YET/ MORE ORIGINAL MATERIAL !!!!!!!
MARK SEVEN OUT NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! CONTAINS COMPLETE UNEDITED VERSION FROM MAY 14 1980 !!!!!! ALSO MARK SIX WITH ADDITIONS, AND OTHER VERSIONS FROM APRIL AND MAY 1980 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Not easy to spot?! Not in this case. Curtis made two attempts to kill himself in the last six months of his short life, the first by slashing his wrists and the second in April 1980 via pills, and you're saying there were no signs?! OK, you can't always tell, and Curtis didn't confide in Sumner et al, but the probable reason he *didn't* was that Bernie and co. didn't give a shit. They were ANGRY when he killed himself. Not sad, like friends would be. ANGRY. What does that tell you?
MARK FIVE IS NOW UP CONTAINING MORE ORIGINAL MATERIAL.
full song was released.. on 12 inch 1 or 2 years ago.
did you add in the thunder sound effect?
Quick question... why was the full length version of this song not included on the Heart and Soul box set? Because of the allusion to Curtis hanging himself?
Bernard even admitted in an interview he knew that "[Ian] had his mind made up about it".
@birdandthe No worries Man! I totally understand. There are to many idiots on RUclips who just seem to want to post stupid, insane, and out right problem starting comments. My deal is, if ya got nothing good to say then don't say it at all. :-D Look forward to the new version(s)!!!
mt bet friend killed himself...sometimes you just cant tell
heaviest thing ive heard in awhile. probably ever.
@LoomVideos ONLY THE CUT VERSION (2 AND A HALF MINUITES) ON HEART AND SOUL
where is the
someday we will die in your dreams
how we wish we were here with you now
part.. i can t hear it.
+tom jones this was before i got the full length version, i only had a 30 second segment, try versions five and higher much better and complete
CHECK OUT UPDATED VERSION
so there is no released version of Curtis singing this available to buy? sorry - im new to them.
@DeadSouls6 Oh grow up !! i have head that so many times ' if he hadent killed himself you wouldent like this song ( or joy division so much)' i went to there gigs and bought unknown pleasures as soon as it was released, and so helped the band to keep going, you were still in short trousers, would you even know about joy division in the united states if they had packed it in during 1979 and ian went back to social services ? no, you wouldent.
@ProjectFlashlight612 I think ur right! I mean Ian tried to be pleasant and crack jokes or whatever and he didnt show signs of melancholy or anthg but come on,I mean listen to his bloody lyrics!!!!Cant u feel the negativity,the despair,the pain???Its fucking obvious!!!!!If they had cared they would have understood...but they were young and in their own world obviously and didnt pay attention...and an angel was gone....:(
UPDATE IS LIVE.
@Paulph04 then where did the 30 seconds extra come from ? when you run out of tape it ends suddenly, what are the odds that hookys tape ran out at 2.30 just before 'hangman ? (as most doubters say) obviously it DIDENT!!!! as the extra words and music prove, so are you now saying the tape ran out at around 3.05 ? after much abuse from different sites the word is there is a full superior quality 5 minuite version which will never be released. so if its never released this is the best.
@DeadSouls6 can someone explain this 30 second business? was it leaked? different to the 2 minute version on still? where did the uploader got the 5:31 version?
dont waste your time with the 'opposition' versions of this track, all theyve got is the bit of heart and soul and thats it !!! as j.d fans weve already got that, theyve all thrown their dummies out of there prams and blocked me and removed my comments when ive pointed out the simple truth. All they are interested in is collecting points and stopping people from listening to the full song, because they are tiny minded and jealous. happy listening folks.
6 months or more AFTER i released this
@birdandthe also if its never going to be released whats the point in having it ? if they say its in bad taste why dont they destroy it ? because they know its a classic peice of music history, muddled thinking all round.
@danwolski it does now danny boy
@DeadSouls6 please send me the URL of a better ian curtis painting. take your time.
30 years today, im sure ian appreciates this and not the joke versions of IALP LIKE mrfuckwit (some bloke with hairy armpits in a bus shelter) and ninedosus irrelevant WAR footage. (both 2.30 secs ) happy remembering folks and im working towards an improved version, might be 3 weeks might be 8 weeks.
much better versions folks!! (by me) try 2, 3, 5, 6,7, 8 and walking away from the stars !! happy listening !!
@ i do
would you like to say why ?
@birdandthe I wouldn't have heard of them.
@JEZZENHAIGHT sorry jezze i sometimes put the filters on from time to time, to keep down the idiots and christian fundamentalist insane comments !!! !! happy xmas etc version 3 should be out between new year and jan 10.
@DeadSouls6
one segment does not make a whole orange
Honestly i dont think they were completly insensitive to the whole thing but this song is really fuckin clear in his intentions...but then again new dawn fades the infamous loaded gun segment, he didnt shoot himself...u cannot stop the inevitable. but to be completely surprised i don't know about that so much...but this song is 100% death oriented.whether ian killed himself or not, this song would still sounds like death. if it doesnt then what does it sound like?????
@ProjectFlashlight612 there is no turning back the clock. so let the reticent poet be heard - and watch him dance his one of a kind dance...
never heard of silent hill
they began to play JD songs many years later. your argument is invalid.
@DeadSouls6 obviously you dont like joy division.
eeeerrr what ?
@ProjectFlashlight612 yep i think u hit the nail on the button. it is no co incidence that he killed himself just before the usa tour. his bandmates were pissing him off. this was his response. his death. like saying lads sod off!!
Curtis and Division are fascinating subjects. Seems that the remaining three collapsed right away after Curtis. In a Lonely Place is a perfect one but the first New Order records are quite lame. Not to mention the later ones.
And till this day they do "tribute concerts" theyre just sick using his name as a excuse to make money :c
ridiculous.
This is the last song IC recorded, and Sumner and co can claim with a straight face that they had no clue he was going to kill himself?! Don't try and pass that nonsense off as truth, Bernard, especially since you were there at his side when he tried to top himself with pills earlier in 1980. That coulda been seen as a hint of his mood, no? The fact is, his bandmates were not really his pals and simply did not care that he was in pain. Not that they were required to....still callous as hell.
This song is part of a trilogy of Joy Division's most beautiful and haunting songs: 'Atmosphere', 'Decades', and 'In a Lonely Place'. This song being recorded just 4 days before Ian hung himself-making his lyrics even more chilling.