Both teams played pretty good Parents ruin the game lol not every contact is a foul or card The straight red was a bit much, a yellow wouldve been fine
I agree with you up to the last sentence. In real time it doesn't look like much (especially because the angle of the camera isn't all that good on this play), but there was an elbow thrown towards the green players head, and it looked more cocked than not, so straight red there is for violent conduct.
@@notfounder285 difficult to see with the camera angle. I agree, even the attempt to strike an opponent like that is violent conduct and is a sending off.
@@ClergetMusicI find it funny how soo many parents have tried to argue with me before when I sent their child off cause they threw a punch at someone 😭😭
Well, the standard set forth in the LOTG is “careless, reckless, or with excessive force.” If in the opinion of the referee, the challenge does not meet those criteria, it is not a foul. This also means that even if a player “gets the ball,” with a challenge that is “careless, reckless, or with excessive force,” it IS a foul.
imp green's defensive was pretty good but the rest of the team was not doing it. they couldn't really get the ball up the field because they werent using their teammates. same with white on the offense. white's mid was doing pretty damn well. they were able to get the ball back, turn it, look for one of their forwards, and be able to get the ball to them.
I love the Karen in the background, "They collided, it's normal...". Clearly they didn't see the girl in white throw the elbow purposefully into the green players neck area. Straight red is the right call here.
If I was officiating, most of those wouldn’t have been called. There weren’t many actual fouls in this video. However, I DID miss the elbow to the face that earned the sending off. On the field, I would NOT have missed it, so the angle these videos provide is not always ideal for judging the calls on the field. It also seems like the two officials have different ideas of what constitutes a foul, at least at the detailed level.
This is a bit late but I coach high school girls and the hardest thing to do is to coach smart physicality. Both sides are playing physical, but not in a violent way. Constant whistles for contact is the single easiest way to hinder development. When shoulder to shoulder contact is called a "foul" you start getting really slow, all around poor play, and then at the college level where the referees are much better about calling real fouls and not contact, the girls are punished because the ones that come from areas with good refereeing are making contact while the ones who had refs like these are not going to be as physical. The red, I do think that's probably better as a yellow. I can see it's an elbow kind of towards the head in a way that makes the Hilltop player react, but I don't think it was deliberate enough to justify a straight red, especially when there's not been another card all game. It's more of a defense mechanism as the player had already won the ball and the green was barreling towards her still. A yellow for both was probably the right call, however I think the ref was starting to think they were losing control of the game (more because they're calling contact than the actual level of aggression on the pitch). It's not an unjustifiable red, but it definitely was harsh. On another note, both teams played absolutely brilliantly, I wish that my team would play more like this!
Спорт
These refs and parents are so soft😂
Both teams played pretty good
Parents ruin the game lol not every contact is a foul or card
The straight red was a bit much, a yellow wouldve been fine
No if you look in slow mo you can see(it’s hard Bc of camera angle) she throws the elbow towards the face
She throws a blatant elbow to the face. Thats a straight red, I just would not have given a yellow to the other player.
I agree with you up to the last sentence. In real time it doesn't look like much (especially because the angle of the camera isn't all that good on this play), but there was an elbow thrown towards the green players head, and it looked more cocked than not, so straight red there is for violent conduct.
@@notfounder285 difficult to see with the camera angle. I agree, even the attempt to strike an opponent like that is violent conduct and is a sending off.
@@ClergetMusicI find it funny how soo many parents have tried to argue with me before when I sent their child off cause they threw a punch at someone 😭😭
these fouls r so soft and the parents are complaining for even softer ones
These parents don’t know what body is or 50/50 balls smh
Well, the standard set forth in the LOTG is “careless, reckless, or with excessive force.” If in the opinion of the referee, the challenge does not meet those criteria, it is not a foul. This also means that even if a player “gets the ball,” with a challenge that is “careless, reckless, or with excessive force,” it IS a foul.
That should have been a straight red card to the turf at 9:24. Pure carnage.
Ong 🤦🏾♀️ idk how the ref didn’t see that
That number #4 foot work was good asf
imp green's defensive was pretty good but the rest of the team was not doing it. they couldn't really get the ball up the field because they werent using their teammates. same with white on the offense. white's mid was doing pretty damn well. they were able to get the ball back, turn it, look for one of their forwards, and be able to get the ball to them.
“You can use that whistle homie”🤓
Tbh 18 and 4 for the green team they help the team win
Can someone clarify what the sending off was for? I didn’t see anything wrong with the challenge.
There was nothing wrong it was a stupid call
It looked like white threw an elbow into greens chest
Ref had some good calls. Only bad one was the offside
Bro how're 85% of those straight reds 💀
I love the Karen in the background, "They collided, it's normal...". Clearly they didn't see the girl in white throw the elbow purposefully into the green players neck area. Straight red is the right call here.
This was hard to watch 💀
Is this the freshman game?
There’s like no one in the stands
how was that a red.....
5:57 bugs bunny? 😂 what was that?
White team makes up for being bad at the game by playing dirty lmao
Green team was just as bad.
if it was boys none of those would’ve been called
Yeah it would of its school soccer everything is called
If I was officiating, most of those wouldn’t have been called. There weren’t many actual fouls in this video. However, I DID miss the elbow to the face that earned the sending off. On the field, I would NOT have missed it, so the angle these videos provide is not always ideal for judging the calls on the field. It also seems like the two officials have different ideas of what constitutes a foul, at least at the detailed level.
I’m 99% sure it depends on the ref, not the gender
This is a bit late but I coach high school girls and the hardest thing to do is to coach smart physicality. Both sides are playing physical, but not in a violent way. Constant whistles for contact is the single easiest way to hinder development. When shoulder to shoulder contact is called a "foul" you start getting really slow, all around poor play, and then at the college level where the referees are much better about calling real fouls and not contact, the girls are punished because the ones that come from areas with good refereeing are making contact while the ones who had refs like these are not going to be as physical. The red, I do think that's probably better as a yellow. I can see it's an elbow kind of towards the head in a way that makes the Hilltop player react, but I don't think it was deliberate enough to justify a straight red, especially when there's not been another card all game. It's more of a defense mechanism as the player had already won the ball and the green was barreling towards her still. A yellow for both was probably the right call, however I think the ref was starting to think they were losing control of the game (more because they're calling contact than the actual level of aggression on the pitch). It's not an unjustifiable red, but it definitely was harsh.
On another note, both teams played absolutely brilliantly, I wish that my team would play more like this!
If this is brilliant then my little brothers youth games when he was 7 were brilliant too!!
Pretty clean game. Not much here.
Yeah these parents let their girls play soccer 😂 no deal
White team plays so dirty
the game was pretty entertaining but those parents are so soft
second
first
Third
Fourth
#20 doesn’t know football
This was hard to watch
😐😐😐😐😒