Modi's Election Speeches are 'Immoral, Unethical, Unacceptable', He Owes Indian Muslims Apology
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июн 2024
- In an interview about Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s election speeches, N. Ram, the former Editor-in-Chief and Publisher of The Hindu, has said they are “immoral, unethical and unacceptable”, adding that Modi owes Indian Muslims “many apologies”.
In an interview to The Wire, Ram says the Election Commission should punish Modi by barring him from campaigning, as they did during the 2014 election in the case of Amit Shah, who was then president of the BJP. Ram adds that because Modi is prime minister, the punishment meted to him should be more severe than would be given to a normal minister or politician for a similar infringement of the Model Code of Conduct and the Representation of People Act.
Speaking about the Election Commission, Ram said it has “ceased to be an independent body” and called it “servile”. He said the Election Commission has got “worse and worse” over the last three elections.
Ram said that after three days the Election Commission’s silence about Modi’s Rajasthan speech and Aligarh speech is “shocking”. He said “he can’t find words strong enough to deplore and condemn”.
Asked if the present situation is a test of the credibility of the Election Commission, Ram replied: “Yes, to put it mildly”. However, Ram added he’s “not confident at all” the Election Commission will act.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
![BETA SQUAD vs AMP FOOTBALL MATCH [OFFICIAL STREAM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ChEmvP52p0U/mqdefault.jpg)
It’s shame that majority hindus supporting such a party and PM.
Remember they r getting something from the 15 lacs promised to you
Indeed true..
No Sir, it's not true that the majority is supporting them, in India as a whole, or within Hindus for that matter.
In fact, there is a new minority in the country these days and that's andhbhakts, modi/bjp supporters.
All other citizens out of this minority group are neither supportive nor afraid of bjp/modi.
@@I_support_Secular_INDIAyou are right.
This election is the real test of Hindu voters. May be now they will realise their misjudgment in 2014 (falling for Development Masquerade) & in 2019 ( falling for Nationalism Masquerade).
Wait for June 4 th ; There will be justice
Mr Ram is correct...all the blame should go to election commission also...
Thank you so much...sarojini...Mysore
All the blame shud be on the shoulders of the EC who don’t have the courage to speak up shame on you EC
Election Commission has proved itself to be no more a puppet dancing to the tunes of Modiji!
He owes all of India an apology, not just muslims
Thank you Bhai...
Agree
Diffidently he should ask apologize himself with out peoples pressure. Sarojini Mysore
Who owes an apology for atrocities against Hindus, Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists happened in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and even in Kashmir ????
❤
The PM has let the country down - I am not a Muslim but a Hindu. I too am ashamed, amazed, disgusted.
You must be proud of Mani Shankar Aiyar and all congies who have used all the foul words from Oxford dictionary !
If all Hindus say this, we are likely to have good governance
@@SadguruPrernaTrustusne ekdam sahi kaha tha bekuf neech hai ye modi
Yes. Hindus are growing increasingly disgusted by the fascist Hindutva communal and corrupted party of BJpee
Atleast we still have intellectual Hindus like u in this country good to noe Madam.
We are very unfortunate to have such a PM
WE ARE PROUD OF OUR MAHARAJA
'Maharaja' who have no guts to visit Manipur? 😂😂😂
Least literate.
Most Arrogant,Narcissistic, Megalomaniac & Polarising PM of Independent India.
As if we very ever fortunate to have a good one (itaian puppet laughing in the corner)
Speaking against one community by top leader is shocking..
10 saal ho gaye not shocking anymore.. Now if he starts acting like a respectable PM that will br shocking!!
Absolutely true
@@junaidmohammed280Well said.
@@bw8026everywhere shame😂😂😂
What the F is Stalin's chums doing ??
Apology is not in the dairy of Mr Mody. Such genocide happened in Gujarat under the nose of Modi then CM, but never apologized.
Modi ji is much kind hurted and so stiil Muslim do not face any ethnic clinging in Gujarat even after Godhra Incident.
Your message clearly shows that you have attended the same university as Modi! No wonder Modi is blindly supported by millions of ignorant, uneducated, and uncouth RSS members.@krishanuadityapandey4414
Because Modi is coward and not a good leader.
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 Stop doing Chaatukaarita... whole world knows who was the main culprit...
It was a riot because of Godhra train carnage by Islamists
Prime monster he is
He is serial offender since the last six decades
India needs more bold journalists like N. Ram
To promote muzzie interests
I totally agree PM statement on Muslims is reprehensible , he should be punished for this crime of all the other crimes he has committed since 2002! I am ashamed about my PM!
@sydmohe How much do you get paid by BJP? I have been seeing you replying in every comments.
Modi's quality of discourse itself shows his report card is full of zeroes and he has nothing to talk about his 10yr performance and he has no plan for the next 5yrs. He needs to be kicked out...giving this man another 5yrs will be a monumental blunder.
Couldn't agree more
*Whatever Modi said is absolutely blunt and TRUE*
Modi is the most popular leader and he is far ahead of any Pappus
So absolutely true. V all should vote him out by voting For the Congress ❤😂
@@bw8026 good one so if he says anything it must be accepted as the truth and if Rahul says the same thing then disciplinary action is taken against him what nonsense is this
Vajpayee Ji was ready to dismiss Modi after Gujarat riots. It was RSS who came to the rescue of Modi. Now he has even grown above RSS and has become a dictator. After this election, if Modi continues there is every chance that India will become the largest autocratic country in the world.
yes true, that is what we fear.
Along with RSS it was Mr Advani also who was conferred Bharat Ratan shamelessly. I don’t see any contribution of Mr Advani apart from creating monster of hindutva.
Certainly true dear !!! 😢
SO BE IT. GOOD FOR PROUD PATRIOTIC HINDUS.
Modi is digging his own grave.
Sleeping of Supreme Court is also questionable
How did you forget EC ( & EVM) ?
All are answerable .With the moral thought,no body had been brought up...Even though they knew,those were atrocities, they're fueling the fire...They have to pay for it.
Thank you Karan for your bold and straightforward discussion with Mr.N.Ram.
It's shameful and dangerous Cong planning to redistribution my hard-earned money and wealth to musilms if Cong comes to power what happened Hindus pandits in Jammu Kashmir
@@kumarram3477 Then?🤣🤣🤣... Did you ever think about why Modi brought this topic today instead of his achievements in last 10 years, Do you have any sense to think about this?... He is using his last tool to polarize the votes, now he is in pathetic condition, expect many more divisive or polarization speech will come from him🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@veeramanipalanivel8478 we already knows Cong getting support form geroge Soros jousha project Indian Mujahideen PFI Al-Qaeda ISISI Indian Mujahideen Pakistan ISI CCP, redistribution is communist ideology they planning looting wealth and money from Hindus given to musilms clearly shows Manmohan speach Sam pappu Priyanka i am Hindu to safeguard my society and country i am not vote for Congress
@@kumarram3477 The fact is there is nothng in Cogress manifesto stating they will give wealth of hindus to muslims. Modi is twisting the truth and speaking it without any shame. The problem is he is confident that people are not going to read the congress manifesto to check his statement and going to assume his statement as truth
@@kumarram3477 Get well soon & be better informed.
The PM appears to be incapable of telling the truth, it can be about his achievements, educational qualifications or about the opposition leaders. As an exemplary punishment he should be barred from contesting the 2024 elections. The SC should intervene and take action against the CEC, it should also be severe punishment.
Joker56” should be disqualified for life
Our PM is not eligible for PM. Morally... Indian citizen not allow hatred among any type of discrimination...
What is not immoral , unethical and unacceptable, in a way come to think of it ? The whole era of his rule whether in Gujarat or Delhi is filled with uttar negativity and nonsense.
Always love Mr. N.Ram. He is very Indian, secular and always speaks the truth, facts and reality
Jay Shree Ram.
@@krishanuadityapandey4414 I meant the hindu former editor 😂😅😆😁😄
I have been reading N Ram articles since I was a child
EC is spine less
It's a shame we have such a Prime Minister...
Why does he not speak about his achievements
Because he has none
Doesn't have good achievements.
@bernadettedease2099, you shot with a single bullet. He has none to show.
Except hate and divide what has he done ?! 😢
There is no achivement..
So he speaks such nonsense
Many thanks to sri Karan Thapar for a very impactful meaningful and important interview with sri ram on the most relevant subject .
It is unfortunate that India have a PM like Modi. He lost his stature as Head of the biggest Democracy in the world. History will record that his election was the biggest mistake the Indians did.
Happy to see the senior journalists start criticizing the monarchical king of India. Hope this pillar will not let the Democratic pillar fall.
Why can’t the Supreme Court rebukes ECI and ask explanation as to why no action is being taken against modi by them?
Vote for the I.N.D.I.A alliance
Save the country
Save the Constitution
Save democracy
Jai Hind 💪🏿🇮🇳💪🏿🇮🇳💪🏿🇮🇳💪🏿🇮🇳
🔱🔱🔱🔱 back again on 4th June💪💪💪💪💪
No chance of that happening for the fascist Hindutva communal party of BJpee
Game over for Modi!
That would be when HE decides to retire.
@@SadguruPrernaTrust he will be retired by the RSS soon
Keep dreaming 😂
This fox should be punished absolutely in full accordance with law or he has to confront his fate in the hands of public as happened in libya.....
The interview was extremely important explosive and fearless as well as meaningful . many thanks .
Why is no one filing a severe case against Modi and suspend his candidature...it's possible in law
All are afraid as any charge could be slapped on them
You too can then. Or Mr.Karan & Mr.Ram can also file, instead of sitting and talking. They at least have the financial ability and supporting man power. They even have one of the biggest, senior most lawyers on their side - Mr.Sibal. Actually, two advocates...if you add Mr.Chidambaram.
VERY CORRECT COMMENTS BY MR THAPAR. I THANK HIM
Why EC has completely ignored the people, and is fearless of the common people absolutely . How is that tolerable to the Indian People ?
Exactly, All Indians should rise against this unconstitutional and tyrant "leader", and in this regard hindus or muslims don't matter because not only is he insulting muslims, he is also killing the morals and values of hinduism bu using the religion as a tool to promote blind fanaticism, something that is against the teachings of ancient scriptures.
EV is fearing Modi
EC fearing the boss
Is the Supreme Court sleeping or does not understand the violation of law by Modi
Apologies not only from Indian Muslims but from all Indians.
Typo:
It should be apologies not only to Indian Muslims but to all Indians.
From turns around the apologies as coming from Indian Muslims and all Indians to the PM. 😂
Apologies from bootlicker ideology will never be accepted, he needs to face courts and be punished accordingly and disqualified forever.
@@WerewolfAshyes he couldn't have meant that .that was surely a typo😊
One of the
Most respected editor . Thank you Mr Ram for your service
Congratulations to Karan and Ram for timely bold wise straight forward questions and very clear,clarity answers.The people of India must remember this kind of fact when they cast their thumbs.It is our and the nation's future.
Election commission shown like culprit of the ruler....
Greatly welcome and super views of N.Ram( Former Editor-in-Chief of THE HINDUSTAN TIMES news paper)
Salute to you THE WIRE for involving and inviting such a great human being like N.Ram for interview.
Former editor-in-chief of "The Hindu"!! As a journalism student in the 70's had the good fortune of attending sevral lectures by him!!🎉
Not Hindustan Times. It is The Hindu newspaper
@@felixissac322 Yes .
Written as mistake.
It is 'The Hindu' n not 'The HT'.
This interview is highly relevant in the present scenario . I highly appreciate the meaningful deliberation on the subject matter under discussion with the substance and logical reasoning and justification . your meaningful and fearless journalism with the substance always enlighten your viewers with the truth . many thanks for your sincere and hard work . shree ram is the legend and genius of journalism undoubtedly . satyamev jayate . vande matram . jai hind .
Immoral is he with his unacceptable Greed for Money And Power And always Blame the scapegoats
The silence of election commissioner speaks a lot about the nexus between modi and election commissioner, EVM manipulation!
I salute your bold journalism, Mr. Karan. God bless U & Ur family. Best of luck ❤
As an Irish person we shares some the same experience of the post-colonial struggles to True Independance and truly Democratic Institutions, specifically in the historical context of Britain's "Divide and Rule" methodology of Empire, I would respectfully like to add this: in such an historical setting we have to pay attention and indeed great vigilance toward the fact that many of those that seek power within such independant post-colonial states will have a tendancy to exploit historical divisions to gain power. You may respond "Yes but that history is nearly 100 Yrs ago now!" but I would say that such deep seated divisions remain dormant for many years and have to be addressed or will be divisive for many many years to come. And it is no coincidence that those with Authoritarian tendencies are exactly the ones who grasp the opportunity for such exploitation.
Supreme court should intervene this issue
Cant believe such word coming out of mouth from a PM
A butcher's hands are tainted with blood of innocent Gujaratis.
@@santanodcosta3360 yeah
I wonder Palki Sharma is 'Modified' and seemingly convincing her audience. May I request Mr. Thapar to interview her!
Palki is not worth a rupee.. ever since bought out , log stock & the barrel by NDTV ..
She has fallen in the Stit hole ..Adhani channel.. shameless money bath..to me she has turned a W.... all the respect while she was in
WONG is gone.. thooo 💦
In another interview, Mr. Thapar had expressed that most BJP politicians had been told to boycott him.
Nothing can be expected from the EC with bonded labourers of Gujarat Mafia in-charge of EC !
Modi speech is going to all voters but INDIA alliance speech is not allowed to go to the voters. Some time voters fade up hearing one sided news.
Yes, unethical and condemnable.... Most hurting to the core of the heart coming such statements from the head of the nation....Rightly said owes apology to the Muslim community.....
Ajit Anjum was almost in tears 😢
The courts are duty bound to convict him and put him behind bars. They owe it to the nation.
Appreciate your concerns Mr Ram and Mr Thapar. We hope that this dark era will end soon.
Thanks Karan you brought again Mr. Ram for disecting Modi speech in Rajasthan.
ECI has proved to be utterly shameless and impotent and remain subservient to the ruling dispensation. It is nightmarish to imagine to what levels the leader will stoop to as he conquers a new low on a daily basis. 😢
Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa ' s relatives were raided ( Was Pegasus used ? ).Election Commissioner Arun Goel who was " in perfect health".resigned just before elections unable to bear the burden of his office . The present Chief of ECI is wise enough to foresee what will happen if he takes ' strict & appropriate action ' against the party in power .
Correct 👍 However, doesn’t anyone in the ruling dispensation or the bureaucracy have a conscience? Is everyone morally bankrupt?
Once the government changes, there is an urgent need to free the institutions like ED, EC, RBI, SC etc from Union Government's influence. It should become illegal for office holders in these to become ministers or MAs for 5 years after their retire. There should be seperate body to review any actions taken against office holders in these bodies (independent of government control).
Agree with your views. However, if the current government is voted to power, which they will try to win by hook or crook, one can foresee a total collapse of the democratic structure.
Imagine politicians under him will be crossing line in worst possible way.
Not just Indian Muslims, he owes India an apology, because his speeches are an assault on India as a whole, not just Muslims.
Why the president of India is so silent ? Why are we not discussing this ?
who is that and what is that?
You mean the rubber stamp president of Modi?
she is just servile..
Kran Thapar is best playing his role positively jago aur jagau
Election commissioners appointed by Modi and bjp. No wonder they have said no comments
Modi is such manipulative man. Asking him to apologise or banning him from election ralies is playing with fire. Because all these bhakts would see it their vishwaguru bending for no fault. He was telling truth for them. In my opinion this should be answered in opposition's political campaign not by covering up rather than questioning Modi's own intentions.
We can't let a player to play on even after breaking rules of game again and again....
Any civilised country would have sacked/dismissed this person. Not fit to lead a country like India which consists of different races, cultures, languages, customs. He is the pm of the whole population of India elected to serve the population, not be partisan or biased.
No apologies. Case should be registered by elections commision against sahab for inciting communal hatred and creating enimity between two communitues.
❤
Not only Muslims, he owes an Apology from the Entire Country for his Divisive Politics.
To and not From.
Ram Sir...As usual Honest & Truthful...
Modi owes an apology to the entire nation of India
Thank you for your bold journalism.
Most honest worldclass journalism
N Ram is excellent as ever.
Congrats for clarity and honesty 👍
मोदी ऐसा कभी नहीं करेगा। हां एक सूरत है। सुप्रीम कोर्ट के सामने हथकड़ी लगाकर पेश किया जाये तो वह ऐसा स्टेटमेंट लिखित में दे सकते हैं। कृपया मोदी जी के खिलाफ प्रथम सूचना रिपोर्ट दर्ज करायें और मुकदमा दर्ज करायें तभी कुछ हो सकता है।
He doesn’t owe anyone anything. That’s his strength. COMPLETELY inhuman.
These intellectuals voice is very rarely being seen on media.
Absolutely right sir
Remove BJP government totally not acceptable.
We have never seen such a leadership in this country which instigates the public on different lines creating hatred and that doesn’t believe in maintaining a cordial atmosphere in the country amongst all sections of the public. All that is very unfortunate situation that causes a serious concern about the future of this country.
❤❤❤❤ my heroes....Karan sir and N ram ji the last few secular outspoken fearless people left in our country❤❤❤❤
It's funny ..Election commission is not even listning..& here we are are talking about why ECs not punishing Modi😢..
Good conversation during thr interview. Enjoyed lot. Thank you very much
Sir, PM speeches, where is election commission? EC became 'B' team of BJP.
Someone should write the obituary of EC of India..what is the point of existence of such independent institution, when their conduct is nothing more than slaves of the ruling regime!!!
We are ashamed of Modi
❤
Thanks so much to Ram & Karan both great luminaries in Journalism, for this great show. Ram has very succinctly and clearly described the way and standard of talk of our PM. We Indians bow our heads in shame to have such a leader. The godi media is completely silent on this issue. why ? They are not true to their profession. Everything is sold out, then where is the democracy? The power that Modi has been having or rather having had the support of the majority of people who are uneducated, ignorant, and stupid. But now this tide is slowly changing with time. The time is now ripe to think to first educate the backward people first on this political issue. Jai Hind !
Sir,E.C.appointed by p.m within 24 houres.e.c will not say a single word against p.m
It has taken 10years that finally the real Modi is caught out some may say it is more than 20years since his CM of Gujarat brutal day’s.
Spread his speech all over the world.
As of now we are undone since ECI is in deep slumbering.
Dangerous for the Nation to give him 3rd term. Not even worthy of a CM Post.
Mr Ram spoke well 🎉
चुनाव आयोग चाहे तो सभी मुख्य चुनाव अधिकारियों को निर्देश जारी कर सकता है कि नरेन्द्र मोदी को प्रचार नहीं करने दिया जाए। लेकिन ऐसा करेगा नहीं। डरते हैं।
The PM needs to be held accountable and a harsh punishment needs to be handed down by the Supreme Court or Election Commission
I think the script was missing and so had to depend on Man ki bath. Definitely this will be remembered for a very very long time . So much of hatered is real danger to all even for Hindus. He has put the Hindus too in a very dangerous position.
A PM elected by the people had to ve unbiased and very diplomatic will all issues of all citizens of this country.
A devil's place is hell.
Agree
Please don’t go the way of Pakistan. Keep India secular and stay proud. - A Pakistani
❤
❤
The PM owes India an apology, not just Indian Muslims.
He shows himself he is not well educated, and we are all worse for electing him
INDIA should file cases against Modi in Court
How can this PM to be a head of 140 crores people?? He doesn't deserve to be a PM.. hungry for power...shame..
The gentleman doesn't conduct and behave like a cultured and educated one. It doesn't behove a P M to speak like this. No person who is a good human being will not speak in this kind of language.
Dr. N Ram is a visionary. It can be recalled what he wrote in the news paper The Hindu in 2014 during election time. He felt the pulse at that time and asked indian electorate not to make any party with absolute majority so that they can not break or toy the Constitution of India. Unfortunately indian did not pay heed to you sir. Pray for your good health and long life sir.
Indian people deserve Mr. Modi as PM. That is what Indians, a nation that is going downhill will get.
Your best support is from your workmanship sir! Continue in the same manner.
Mr Thappar, my suggestion to you is …plz have similar journalism like the wire in Hindi too so that masses get to see & know .Everybody is into internet & mobiles now a days but many do not understand English , so plz have it in Hindi as well too.I love the bold journalism in ‘The Wire’.Congratulations & keep it up👍
WORSE PRIME MINISTER EVER INDIAN EVER SEEN AFTER INDIAN INDEPENDENCE