Dan: Definitely shows progression of JD's sanity, Sounds more innocent and as musical proceeds you can here his insanity growing, and on parts that hit close to home for JD like "don't open a vein" his voice gets more tense, more smooth. Ryan: Hardier, Crisp, But stays the same without character development shown in voice, more strong.
tesla's pigeon I agree. I was listening to this while scrolling down the comments and when I heard the laughter I was like WTF? But then I remembered about Veronica's reaction
They sound so similar, but I can pick out Dans voice anywhere so that all i hear, but who gives a damn they are both so fucking amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@carreteraishere9876 ??? i don't remember watching this vid hello ?? this notif just came out of nowhere omg.. not at how it took TWO YEARS to get a response tho lmaoo heck i don't even remember who the hell ryan is 😭 anyway yeah so uhm it's dave thomas brown and NOT ryan, kk gotcha, thanks (??) kashsj
AlarteAscendare7 So, I know it's been a year and you probably forgot about this or figured it out, but you can just put on earbuds (if you weren't already) and take off the one on your left ear for just Dan.
I'm sorry but the right, which you say to be Ryan, isn't. It's Dave Thomas Brown. I know their voices a little too well but I know that's Dave and not Ryan.
In my opinion Ryan was better because Jd is supposed to be like dark and Dan sounds to light and high even though he can hit those high notes. second thought that isn't Ryan someone else idk who.
You are right Ryan is a baritone and Dan a high tenor, that why he can hit those high notes. But I worked my whole life with people like JD and I can say that Dan is more realistic. Also I prefer his voice. But I can see why people like Ryan (I don't hate him eighter)
Dan: Definitely shows progression of JD's sanity, Sounds more innocent and as musical proceeds you can here his insanity growing, and on parts that hit close to home for JD like "don't open a vein" his voice gets more tense, more smooth.
Ryan: Hardier, Crisp, But stays the same without character development shown in voice, more strong.
Amelia C. Yup
That's a pretty perfect description
Thought everyone would be debating down here who they think is better 😆 seems like we mostly prefer Dan...he's my favorite JD personally
stitchsixtwosix same
Dan Damenech is my favorite JD! He did even better than Christian Slater! It's pretty impressive when you surpass the original!
Thank you! Finally!
Same
Samee
DAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love Dan so much 😱❤️
I agree!
SAME! He's my favorite J.D.!
Can I just say that the laughing after "When mom was alive" sounds TERRIBLE without context?
tesla's pigeon I agree. I was listening to this while scrolling down the comments and when I heard the laughter I was like WTF? But then I remembered about Veronica's reaction
Yes , they laugh because of Veronica’s face of WTF
Fun fact: Dan sent me a few messages on instagram.
-he probably replies to everyone who texts him but I feel special anyways-
He followed me and liked some of my posts and responded to my dm
I love Dan so much
I feel like Ryan gives more a psychotic feeling and acting vibe, and Dan’s vain part makes it amazing
I feel like two people are yelling in my ears, but I don't mind because this is my favorite song in the musical
They sound so similar, but I can pick out Dans voice anywhere so that all i hear, but who gives a damn they are both so fucking amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ryan is a baritone and Dan is a tenor, which is why the latter could do that high trill at the end.
I'm pretty sure that left ear is actually Dave Thomas Brown, Ryan's voice is lower and fuller. so sorry if this sounded rude
Omg my two lovely JD's are here!
Dies of happiness P:S That's not Ryan.. where is Ryan tho?
Is dave thomas brown, not ryan
@@carreteraishere9876 ??? i don't remember watching this vid hello ?? this notif just came out of nowhere omg.. not at how it took TWO YEARS to get a response tho lmaoo heck i don't even remember who the hell ryan is 😭
anyway yeah so uhm it's dave thomas brown and NOT ryan, kk gotcha, thanks (??) kashsj
@@cornzzn well dave was jd at a certain point in off broadway, and I can recognize him. Ryan was the original jd in the broadway cast
This is only one example of why I love this musical!
And now I want a slurpee
Example of My ears
Right ear:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Left
Ear:aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Only one side of my headphones work, so I have to listen to Ryan.
Remarkable! I've never heard anything like this before. Very good! As to who is the best singer, I still don't know. Both sounds pretty good.
Do you think you might be able to put up the isolated version of Dan's? (Pretty please with a bag of corn nuts??? 🙈)
AlarteAscendare7 So, I know it's been a year and you probably forgot about this or figured it out, but you can just put on earbuds (if you weren't already) and take off the one on your left ear for just Dan.
I don't need slurpee this hurts your brain enough it confuses me
this is real cool, because if you take off certain earbuds you can only hear one voice aAaa,, *don't mind me, i'm dumb rip*
I've been blessed, thank you
Listens in one ear, then the other, then both
I don't know why I love this so much but it's awesome
this is actually really cool!
This was amazing
I'm sorry but the right, which you say to be Ryan, isn't. It's Dave Thomas Brown. I know their voices a little too well but I know that's Dave and not Ryan.
Left*
This is actually Dave Thomas Brown & Dan Domenech, not Ryan McCartan & Dan Domenech
I noticed that too. As I listened, I noticed how it didn't sound like Ryan's voice, cause I recognize his voice anywhere.
I love Dan's JD. But Ryan singing Freeze your Brain is the best. I love when he does the "dont open a vein"
Ik I’m late but it’s not even Ryan it’s Dave
this is great! do you think you could possibly do meant to be yours?
Dan is better
You should do this again, but with the videos side by side so we can see what they are doing!
Where did you get the music from Ryan's version?
You can download Ryan's version on iTunes's, because Dan was his understudy (I think). Hope that helps!
In my opinion Ryan was better because Jd is supposed to be like dark and Dan sounds to light and high even though he can hit those high notes. second thought that isn't Ryan someone else idk who.
doggo lol Ryan was dark but Dan was dark but sounded more insane
@@lemonwater7169 Agreed, Dan is better
You are right Ryan is a baritone and Dan a high tenor, that why he can hit those high notes. But I worked my whole life with people like JD and I can say that Dan is more realistic. Also I prefer his voice. But I can see why people like Ryan (I don't hate him eighter)
how did you do this
Using Vegas Movie Studio! It has a nice audio editor :-)
Omfg
was barrett wilbert weed the veronica in both?
Isabelle Russek I think she was
yes
I hear Dan on my left and Ryan on my right. ????
Why does the slurpee top look like when you ate too much food coloring and then you shit it all out?
can u make it for iTunes?
Dan is better in heathers than Ryan xx Love Dan
Problem solved.
That isn't Ryan
Am I the only one who prefers Ryan?
xLaLaLucyLaLax The funny thing is neither of these voices are Ryan
Yes
Wait nooo!! My earphones are broken and i can only hear Dave's (It's Dave not Ryan ok) voice Nooo Dan!!
*Borrows brother's earphones*
You should do this again, but with the videos side by side so we can see what they are doing!
You should do this again, but with the videos side by side so we can see what they are doing!