Shahrukh, you have gone an extra mile in educating people. I'm so happy to see a rise in intellectualism in Pakistan. You are indeed, one of them, spear-heading the change. True wishes.
m nay apko 2 mah pehly follow kia tha nd i am the student of CSS after waisal warraich you are the first who become my favourite your videos are very useful keep it up ALLAH BLESS YOU
I am so glad that you cross refer your books to Quran, Its a great service to the youth especially when they see how advanced and accurate is the knowledge of Quran.
That's litterally false propagating where people like him would show Qur'an as socialist and you who knows shite would think "wow". Imagine a religion who follows socialism supporting slaves and concubines while taking special taxes and persecuting non beleivers
It doesn't matter what's written in any book. Society only judge the community based on their behavior & scientific contributions & technological advancement, which Muslims clearly lack except for 2 3 OIC countries like UAE. When Covid hit the world, none of the 56-57 OIC countries could indigenously make their own vaccine . So, rather than going after books, you should focus on scientific temperament. 🤷🤷
Well defined sir ❤ You mentioned all the "ism" but what about "Islamism"? i.e Shariah Law. I would request you to make an analysis on that form of governance as well.
Islamism is self proclaimed method of economics. Just a sort of branching of capitalism. i.e Zakat is for poor so it clearly describes that it always wants a class distribution in the society to have poors to get zakat.
what an amazing masterpiece and bomb of a knowledge this video is , with so little views and likes. I wish to see your channel grown in millions of views and subscribers. Keep enlightening us shahrukh. You deserve a great applause and appreciation
Sir you have to tell us what political party is toward socialism and what political party is towards Capitalism or communism so that in the next upcoming elections we will choose the socialist party. ❤ Please make a video on that please
I understand why you might perceive Sweden as a socialist country, but it's crucial to recognize that it is, in fact, a social democracy with a mixed economy. Sweden upholds private ownership, economic freedom, and a market-oriented economy, which sets it apart from being a socialist country.
تمام انقلابات میں گھمبیر ترین جامع تریں انقلاب حضرت محمد رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کا تھا جس میں انفرادی اور اجتماعی زندگی کے ہر گوشے میں بنیادی تبدیلی آٸ دنیا کے دوسرے انقلابات جزوی تھے کسی میں معاشی تبدیلی آٸ کسی میں سیاسی
Shah rukh bhai apka jaaiza aur tajzya kafi had tak theek hey . lekin meri naakis soach k mutabik dunya me koi bhi nzarya .aqeeda . ya soach hamesha aur mustaqil nhe q k ye insan fitrat k against hey . haan albata koi bahter nizam dair tak chal sakta hey . . lekin for ever nhe . . . ye insani fitrat ziyada dair tak kisi ek jaga tikti nhe tabdeli k sath chalti hey . .aur laal inkalab ko bilkul kharij nhe karasktey albata mustaqil qareeb me to bilkul nhe aaega. .
the Islamic system of the distribution of wealth is different from Socialism and Capitalism both. The distinction between the Islamic economy and the Socialist economy is quite clear. Since Socialism does not admit the idea of private property, wealth under the Socialist system is distributed only in the form of wages. On the contrary, according to the Islamic principles of the distribution of wealth, which we have outlined above, all the things that exist in the universe are in principle the property of Allah Himself. Then, the larger part of these things is that which He has given equally to all men as a common trust. It includes fire, water, earth, air, light, wild grass, hunting, fishing, mines, un-owned and uncultivated lands etc., which are not the property of any individual, but a common trust. Every human being is the beneficiary of this trust, and is equally entitled to its use. On the other hand, there are certain things where the right to private property must be recognized if only for the simple reason that without such a recognition it would not be possible to establish the practicable and natural system of economy to which we have alluded while discussing the first object of the distribution of wealth. If the Socialist system is adopted and all capital and all land are totally surrendered to the state, the ultimate result can only be this: we would be liquidating a large number of smaller Capitalists, and putting the huge resources of national wealth at the disposal of a single big Capitalist - the state, which can deal with this reservoir of wealth quite arbitrarily, thus, leads to the worst form of the concentration of wealth. Moreover, it produces another great evil. Since Socialism deprives human labor of its natural right to individual choice and control, compulsion and force becomes indispensable in order to make use of this labor, which has a detrimental effect on its efficiency as well as on its mental health. All this goes to show that the Socialist system injures two out of the three objects of the Islamic theory of the distribution of wealth namely, the establishment of a natural system of economy, and securing for everyone what rightfully belongs to him.
Bro I appreciate your hard work and good will done to make awareness in the nation, but I suppose app bhens ke agey beem baja rahe hain, people are happy with there worst condition belive me.
Sir, With all due respect I have some serious objections about your content. You have defined the socialist system of Sweden and then compared it with Ccmmunist system of Cuba and made your conclusion that Red Revolution is neither possible nor a solution. Whereas, the most appropriate example of Red Revolution or Communist System is not Cuba, it's China. Which is still governed by a single party system i.e. Communist Party and at the same time it is the fastest accelerating nation of this world in each n every discipline including its economy. As we know geographically Cuba is located right at the border of most influential Capitalist country i.e. USA. This has created many hurdles for Cuba (for example foreign policy, economy, defence etc.) and indeed it is a major factor due to which communism didn't made such an impact in there, like China. How can you conclude that Communism or Revolution is not an ideal solution? when factually, fastest emerging country of the world is following it successfully? To make an unbiased conclusion I think it is necessary to consider each and every factor of every system.
In the age of empires, power ran in the family. This was changed by democracy. Now, wealth also need to be separated from family and distributed fairly. Just like the distribution of power via democracy in the past. Socialism can distribute wealth more fairly based on merit.
good forum... pak badly needs this. Question: all these isms started in the west kabhe muslim world nay bhe ksi system ko as a society study? ya bas muslims world is just filled with only kings and their raaya
If the most illiterate society can groom in the sweltering desert of Bedouin Arabs, then why this modernised era can't be mushroomed by the laws of glorious Islam.... I believe you will go through thoroughly within the divine, scientific and astonishingly philosophical teachings of Islam.
But what about Islam which also talks about state responsibilities , wealth equality ,human rights, etc so blame churches and their artocratic system and their king but when democracy came? I think it's not about any system it's about humans how good you are , you will make a good country if you are honest loyal corporating without curoption, every systems in the world all system have worked or failed USSR north Korea communism failed Cuba is poor country still yes they might had good few years still they ran to US cubans how Oleg ards made money in communism in USSR? But china is a success story but not in a decade
But conclusion is not ideal! Red Revolution is still possible, in contemporary world. If Taliban could do that in their own style why can't communism? 🤔
I can write this post in English as well. آج بھی کِسی بھی مُلک یا عِلاقے یا پاکستان کے مسائل کا حل: (خود لوگوں کے اپنے ہاتھوں میں ) قدیم قبائلی سرداری نظام (جیسے بلوچستان ،کے پی ، گلگت اَور فاٹا) جاگیردای نظام ( جَیسے سِندھ و کے پی وجنوبی پنجاب , پاکستان ) پرو۔سرداری نظام و جاگیرداری نظام ، سرمایہ داری نظام اِن سب کے سچّے جُھوٹے چمچے (جُھوٹے سے مُراد ہے اِن کے وانابیِز wannabes) کا خاتمہ! (بَر بِنائے جدلی و تاریخی مادّیت)
He was not a socialist but rather a socialist scammer. The foundation of socialism is land reforms, that is no private property on mass scale ie no feudalism. Bhutto never ended feudalism as he himself was the biggest feudal in Sindh.
Not at all, he never even tried, He was a nationalism, confine to his own Village disregarding any other rules but to promote his own ‘Sindhi’ please look at his policies , he implanted Sindhi language as compulsory in primary and secondary school, very narrow minded Leader😩
Now democracy capitalism is the worst system so far in poor countries but the best system for west again in my past comments humans or people if they are not good people or humans than bring any system including caliphates dictarship whatever we are in living dictarship since 1958 even Pakistan was richer middle eastern even in dictarship since curoption started we are poor getting poorer in so called democracy yes capitalism flourished by curoption still this country is run by Army our bad started the day we shook hands well our case totally different we are Islamic country we were going well until 1971 or you can say 1977 but problem for west was Islamic country oops make it curropt how they did everybody knows
Shahrukh, you have gone an extra mile in educating people. I'm so happy to see a rise in intellectualism in Pakistan. You are indeed, one of them, spear-heading the change. True wishes.
m nay apko 2 mah pehly follow kia tha nd i am the student of CSS after waisal warraich you are the first who become my favourite your videos are very useful keep it up ALLAH BLESS YOU
I am so glad that you cross refer your books to Quran, Its a great service to the youth especially when they see how advanced and accurate is the knowledge of Quran.
That's litterally false propagating where people like him would show Qur'an as socialist and you who knows shite would think "wow". Imagine a religion who follows socialism supporting slaves and concubines while taking special taxes and persecuting non beleivers
It doesn't matter what's written in any book. Society only judge the community based on their behavior & scientific contributions & technological advancement, which Muslims clearly lack except for 2 3 OIC countries like UAE. When Covid hit the world, none of the 56-57 OIC countries could indigenously make their own vaccine . So, rather than going after books, you should focus on scientific temperament. 🤷🤷
Sir you are doing really great work you always enlight us with your awesome ideas and information thanks a million . Live long sir.
Well defined sir ❤
You mentioned all the "ism" but what about "Islamism"? i.e Shariah Law. I would request you to make an analysis on that form of governance as well.
Islamism is self proclaimed method of economics. Just a sort of branching of capitalism. i.e Zakat is for poor so it clearly describes that it always wants a class distribution in the society to have poors to get zakat.
What an underrated channel he is managing. Keep it up. 😊
ZABARDAST
need more informations on same subjects.
Great job
Thanks book buddy for super content. Appreciate if you can do english subs. Specially this one as I'd like to share with one of my foreigner friend.
very informative video as usual. Last minute message is very good
what an amazing masterpiece and bomb of a knowledge this video is , with so little views and likes. I wish to see your channel grown in millions of views and subscribers. Keep enlightening us shahrukh. You deserve a great applause and appreciation
thank you Farah...appreciate it
amazing addition to youtube .. thank you for being here. good luck .
Islam is the best way the best principle for a happy and advance society
So much happy to see you and your vedio
very well explain...
Great sir Allah apko esse hi humaray liye video bnanay ki tofeeq ata farmaye, ameen, sir agar Islamic economic system pr video bna de plz
Well explained sir g
Kindly, make another video discuss democracy it's types and fall of democracy ❤
What's mean two hand cross symbol in your video cover?
So Nice Sir
My beloved peer... You are the actual concept gainer and narrate as if you were present there. 😅❤... Love you ❤
Great
Zabardast Shahrukh Bhai! ❤
Sir, you are great. You make every topic simple.
Sir please make a video about Islamic system for running a society, we know that there is a system but we don’t know the ABC of it😞🤔
❤
Behtreen
Well explained sir
Always waiting for your videos ❤
Sir you have to tell us what political party is toward socialism and what political party is towards Capitalism or communism so that in the next upcoming elections we will choose the socialist party. ❤ Please make a video on that please
Best. We need more people like you in Pakistan. We need passive education.
Good job keep it up brother
Sir you should also make a video on liberalism.
Great sir
Very informative sir g❤
Sir, please make a book review on 'How Democracy Ends'.
I understand why you might perceive Sweden as a socialist country, but it's crucial to recognize that it is, in fact, a social democracy with a mixed economy. Sweden upholds private ownership, economic freedom, and a market-oriented economy, which sets it apart from being a socialist country.
Where in the entire video did I said Sweden is a Socialist country? I said Sweden is based on Socialist Principles
Intro. Is amazing 😍
Brilliant
Sir please suggest some reading materials for us.
What do you think about Islamic System, please explain? Or what is your opinion?
Bhai plz guide me… i want to study the history of pakistan …just tell me which author is best😊
Good job my bro❤
God bless you 🙏
Sir please have a current affairs channel ,
JazakALLAH sir
Appreciate sir
Great. Make a video how and why socialism was equated with Islam in competition by Mullas
Thank u sir..
Carry on
Good work
The Ottoman Secret By Raymond Khoury.
Plz review
👏👏👏👏
Khilafat pr video banayen
تمام انقلابات میں گھمبیر ترین جامع تریں انقلاب حضرت محمد رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کا تھا جس میں انفرادی اور اجتماعی زندگی کے ہر گوشے میں بنیادی تبدیلی آٸ دنیا کے دوسرے انقلابات جزوی تھے کسی میں معاشی تبدیلی آٸ کسی میں سیاسی
Lol... it's not revolution it's enlightenment of your prophet. Go learn something don't equite everything with Islam.
❤
Shah rukh bhai apka jaaiza aur tajzya kafi had tak theek hey . lekin meri naakis soach k mutabik dunya me koi bhi nzarya .aqeeda . ya soach hamesha aur mustaqil nhe q k ye insan fitrat k against hey . haan albata koi bahter nizam dair tak chal sakta hey . . lekin for ever nhe . . . ye insani fitrat ziyada dair tak kisi ek jaga tikti nhe tabdeli k sath chalti hey . .aur laal inkalab ko bilkul kharij nhe karasktey albata mustaqil qareeb me to bilkul nhe aaega. .
Great job, Man❤
the Islamic system of the distribution of wealth is different from Socialism and Capitalism both. The distinction between the Islamic economy and the Socialist economy is quite clear. Since Socialism does not admit the idea of private property, wealth under the Socialist system is distributed only in the form of wages. On the contrary, according to the Islamic principles of the distribution of wealth, which we have outlined above, all the things that exist in the universe are in principle the property of Allah Himself. Then, the larger part of these things is that which He has given equally to all men as a common trust. It includes fire, water, earth, air, light, wild grass, hunting, fishing, mines, un-owned and uncultivated lands etc., which are not the property of any individual, but a common trust. Every human being is the beneficiary of this trust, and is equally entitled to its use.
On the other hand, there are certain things where the right to private property must be recognized if only for the simple reason that without such a recognition it would not be possible to establish the practicable and natural system of economy to which we have alluded while discussing the first object of the distribution of wealth. If the Socialist system is adopted and all capital and all land are totally surrendered to the state, the ultimate result can only be this: we would be liquidating a large number of smaller Capitalists, and putting the huge resources of national wealth at the disposal of a single big Capitalist - the state, which can deal with this reservoir of wealth quite arbitrarily, thus, leads to the worst form of the concentration of wealth. Moreover, it produces another great evil. Since Socialism deprives human labor of its natural right to individual choice and control, compulsion and force becomes indispensable in order to make use of this labor, which has a detrimental effect on its efficiency as well as on its mental health. All this goes to show that the Socialist system injures two out of the three objects of the Islamic theory of the distribution of wealth namely, the establishment of a natural system of economy, and securing for everyone what rightfully belongs to him.
❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bro I appreciate your hard work and good will done to make awareness in the nation, but I suppose app bhens ke agey beem baja rahe hain, people are happy with there worst condition belive me.
Doesnt socialism limit competition and motivation to progress
No
Yes lots
Sir, With all due respect I have some serious objections about your content.
You have defined the socialist system of Sweden and then compared it with Ccmmunist system of Cuba and made your conclusion that Red Revolution is neither possible nor a solution.
Whereas, the most appropriate example of Red Revolution or Communist System is not Cuba, it's China. Which is still governed by a single party system i.e. Communist Party and at the same time it is the fastest accelerating nation of this world in each n every discipline including its economy.
As we know geographically Cuba is located right at the border of most influential Capitalist country i.e. USA. This has created many hurdles for Cuba (for example foreign policy, economy, defence etc.) and indeed it is a major factor due to which communism didn't made such an impact in there, like China.
How can you conclude that Communism or Revolution is not an ideal solution? when factually, fastest emerging country of the world is following it successfully?
To make an unbiased conclusion I think it is necessary to consider each and every factor of every system.
Why can’t we have Sweden’s socialism in pakistan?
because we can't
Bring capitalism to this country like america
In the age of empires, power ran in the family. This was changed by democracy.
Now, wealth also need to be separated from family and distributed fairly.
Just like the distribution of power via democracy in the past. Socialism can distribute wealth more fairly based on merit.
❤🇧🇩
good forum... pak badly needs this.
Question: all these isms started in the west kabhe muslim world nay bhe ksi system ko as a society study?
ya bas muslims world is just filled with only kings and their raaya
If the most illiterate society can groom in the sweltering desert of Bedouin Arabs, then why this modernised era can't be mushroomed by the laws of glorious Islam.... I believe you will go through thoroughly within the divine, scientific and astonishingly philosophical teachings of Islam.
They were illiterates till they found oil and earned money.
Social democracy ftw.
But what about Islam which also talks about state responsibilities , wealth equality ,human rights, etc so blame churches and their artocratic system and their king but when democracy came? I think it's not about any system it's about humans how good you are , you will make a good country if you are honest loyal corporating without curoption, every systems in the world all system have worked or failed USSR north Korea communism failed Cuba is poor country still yes they might had good few years still they ran to US cubans how Oleg ards made money in communism in USSR? But china is a success story but not in a decade
But conclusion is not ideal! Red Revolution is still possible, in contemporary world. If Taliban could do that in their own style why can't communism? 🤔
Definition k hisab se Pakistan Mai Socialism lazmi hona chahiye
No sir you are wrong
Isamnism is the best system.
سوشلزم اور اسلام کا اشتراک کیا ھے
I can write this post in English as well.
آج بھی
کِسی بھی مُلک یا عِلاقے یا پاکستان کے مسائل کا حل:
(خود لوگوں کے اپنے ہاتھوں میں )
قدیم قبائلی سرداری نظام (جیسے بلوچستان ،کے پی ، گلگت اَور فاٹا)
جاگیردای نظام ( جَیسے سِندھ و کے پی وجنوبی پنجاب , پاکستان )
پرو۔سرداری نظام و جاگیرداری نظام ، سرمایہ داری نظام
اِن سب کے سچّے جُھوٹے چمچے (جُھوٹے سے مُراد ہے اِن کے وانابیِز wannabes)
کا خاتمہ!
(بَر بِنائے جدلی و تاریخی مادّیت)
Islam is enough for an islamic nation
ruclips.net/video/mWkH3CxvOb4/видео.html
We were given the glory through Islam and it was taken away when it became just a lip service.
Admi by nature social h samaj usko capitalist bnata h
long live socialism long live AWP
Bro you look like Bilawal Bhutto🙂😁
Sorry this is a 100%male
we also had a socialist leader by the name of zulfiqar Ali Bhutto😅.
He was not a socialist but rather a socialist scammer. The foundation of socialism is land reforms, that is no private property on mass scale ie no feudalism. Bhutto never ended feudalism as he himself was the biggest feudal in Sindh.
@@zeerakkhan1230 indeed it was scam, i was just being sarcastic.
Not at all, he never even tried, He was a nationalism, confine to his own Village disregarding any other rules but to promote his own ‘Sindhi’ please look at his policies , he implanted Sindhi language as compulsory in primary and secondary school, very narrow minded Leader😩
@@yy5123 apko sindhi zuban nahi pasand kya?
In his party only land lords who exploit the workers are present
Humy Pakistan ma islamic nizam Chahye or Is Foj ki dehshatgardi se bachna ha
Shriat+ presidential system ❤
Inqalab in Pakistan coming soon blood is inqalab inqalab is blood Pakistan zindabad imran khan zindabad
اسلام مکمل ضابطہ حیات ھے
باقی ازم خیالی باتیں، کمیونزم کی موت۔ صرف اسلام مظلوموں کی اشک جوئی کر سکتا ھے
Khilafatism
Allah hu Akbar
Now democracy capitalism is the worst system so far in poor countries but the best system for west again in my past comments humans or people if they are not good people or humans than bring any system including caliphates dictarship whatever we are in living dictarship since 1958 even Pakistan was richer middle eastern even in dictarship since curoption started we are poor getting poorer in so called democracy yes capitalism flourished by curoption still this country is run by Army our bad started the day we shook hands well our case totally different we are Islamic country we were going well until 1971 or you can say 1977 but problem for west was Islamic country oops make it curropt how they did everybody knows
U will be a crusader for. Change
Islamic system is best only.
❤
❤