That claim is absolute nonsense, how many graduates are sitting at home or working at Mcdonalds. The other thing is that you can't say that selling phones and being a waiter or uber driver is a special skill. Stop the gas lighting
Exactly 💯 This govt thinks we stupid. We all listens to Dr S and the D.G presentation he addressed these as issues and concerns. And they don't these people..... ANC people think we school children who listen to nonsense
There are so many qualified white people artisans engineers sitting at home 🏠🏡 doing nothing because of evil Mandela starting affirmative action then Bbe Who can work at Eskom SAA to fix it
Just the other day, nurses in KZN went to submit they CVS demanding jobs at DOH, yet his saying theres a shortage of nurses. These people living in a castle 🏰 that dont see clear.
Go see private hospitals medic clinic ONLY FOREIGNERS as nurses and doctors, S.A people sitting at home. Why do they give them work visas when S.A have nurses and doctors.
@matrix0085 I think DOHA is also pushing some kind of narrative towards this whole scarce skills saga. I fail to understand why they say we have scarce skills of Doctors, nurses, teachers, and IT people it's mind-blowing. Our biggest problem is also these private sectors that do as they pleases that makes it more difficult. Private sectors are more corrupt than or government, but remember, because they are "private," no one have a say in what they do in this country, or they will back up and leave. Thousands of nurses, teachers, and doctors are sitting at home, and they are busy recruiting foreigners. My best friend's husband used to work in the trauma department at the hospital, which makes him not to be a general doctor his sitting at home for years because the government didn't renew his contract. Let's hope that while we fight for this country and the rights of the people within this country , we will 1 day be able to have peace and enjoy this country without any fights. It was first apartheid now that we have to fight illegal foreigners for our own country.
That has always been the plan from the White man. Don't trust what they say. Same people who claimed for years no foreigners are not taking jobs, look now. Watch them like hawks, see if they advertised those skilled posts, if they didn't, report them to labour department and spread it on social media. They need to be stopped in their tracks this time.
There's so many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela bringing in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can overnight fix Eskom SAA
What happens when our skilled people come back? And, they are coming back. Also, what about all the skilled young people graduating from universities and other institutions. And as a matter of fact, please let us be clear. WHAT SKILLS ARE WE SHORTING? Please tell us Michael Bagraim and the SABC so we can get in on the racket.
Please could they enlighten us on those specific skills that are "short"?? If the excuse is that the SA Critical skills bearers are lured abroad by better working conditions... then there's your answer. Better our working environments, Labour Department and more competitive packages. You are paid the big money to make the creative solutions work, STOP BEING LAZY as a HIGHLY PAID government official
But how many of those now qualified university people who studied overseas are ANC cadres children being paid by taxpayers money from South Africa,let them look for in the country they studied in 📯📯 there's enough degree graduates in South Africa
🎉🎉❤❤Fellow Zimbos,,,, Zimbabwe is ❤❤❤now open for business too many Chinese Company in Zimbabwe.Zimbabweans must leave South Africans in Peace please ❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉
@@jameskillu9171 Fix Zimbabwe 1st, you have big mouths here in SA but your mothers dont have sanitary towels and toilet papers back home ftsek kwerekwere
Many people don't understand the meaning of critical skills. It simply means there's demand on that particular skill even teaching can be critical especially in South Africa so many teachers are going to countries like China, U A E for more money and someone have to fill in the gap and not only that even Nurses are going to the UK.
If more than 35% of our people are unemployed , exactly what critical skills , or I should ask , what jobs are available for these so called critical skills shortage
Just go look at Eskom SAA and see why it's bankrupt, because qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela starting affirmative action and BEE, why bring in people from other countries, these qualified artisans engineers can fix Eskom SAA overnight
The problem is people are not responsible and they don't want to take ownership where foreigners have that ability. Look at what's happening at our SOE's and hospitals. A company which my wife worked for employed students for the holidays but they never completed their work for the day because they were on their Cell phones the whole day.
All those “critical skills” you mention, I know personally individuals who have those skills but are unemployed and don’t even get a reply from job applications 😂😂 ffs I have two cousins who are qualified medical doctors but I chill with them on weekends because they are unemployed 😂😂just stop lying to us and say that you prefer foreign workers😂😂😂
@@studylive99there is how many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home because evil Mandela brought in affirmative action and BEE,these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight
Most of the Nurses are not leaving this country for better salaries..it simply because they don't get jobs in their owncountry, am a nurse..short staffed yet they're foreigners are being employed in our public hospitals...I've got more than 5 Professional nurses i know that are sitting at home 😟
But again other way around there are so many ANC cadres children are studying in Europe on taxpayers money not because they can't study in South Africa but because they think and feel they are better than black 🖤 kids from townships, it's a sick story
What are you saying? Zimbabweans mustn't study in South Africa? If we can apply at SA universities get accepted, apply for study visa section 13 of the Immigration Act of 2002 get it pay fees come through the boarder and study.... what's wrong with that if I may ask? Any violation of laws?
@@nimrodmapuranga2889 if it's done legally and the person studying in South Africa is paying for it yes no problem 👍👍👍 it works other way around for a South African studying overseas, only problem is that most kids studying overseas are ANC cadres kids and taxpayers money 🤑💰 is being used,
Ah, what an inspired approach-overlook thousands of unemployed, skilled Black graduates within our borders, and instead focus on recruiting talent from overseas. It is almost as though local potential is an afterthought. Surely, with exploitation still prevalent in certain industries like restaurants, we can expect a sudden, genuine commitment to diversity when recruiting from abroad? One has to wonder when we, as a country, will recognise the talent we have right here. Perhaps it is time to reconsider where our priorities truly lie.
😂😂😂😢😢. It's so heartsore for allowing people from other countries yo work in South Africa while thousands of qualified people born in South don't have work
So S.A is telling us, that these Zim & Indi currently in S.A, cell phone shop, saloons, Gardeners, maids, tree cutters have these qualifications and chose to be the above. Please nonsense. Dr S called the above economy immigrants. He said he wants to attract productive people to contribute to S.A economy.
There are so many white qualified artisans engineers technicians sitting at home due to evil Mandela fault because he brought in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight if they are allowed
You missed the point... You already have your own knowledge and not willing to listen what this interview is addressing. You will be left behind complaining, the world and those that read and research for themselves and not wait to be spoon-fed propaganda, will be let behind...
This man is talking a lot of shut! we got more than enough skilled people in SA. Companies just hire foreigners because they pay them peanuts. I think your idees are a lot of shut!
Yes so many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela bringing in affirmative action and BEE Who could fix Eskom SAA overnight
😢😢😢 as long as ANC cadres allow a 30 % pass rate nothing will be fixed,how many qualified white artisans engineers technicians are sitting at home due to evil Mandela who brought in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight
Why does south africa not have training homes for nurses in our country? Rather to import lets train our very own? Get high skilled people to train our very own. Auditing? We have many auditors in this country who has open doors towards students serving their time completing their articles
Please could they enlighten us on those specific skills that are "short"?? If the excuse is that the SA Critical skills bearers are lured abroad by better working conditions... then there's your answer. Better our working environments, Labour Department and more competitive packages. You are paid the big money to make the creative solutions work, STOP BEING LAZY as a HIGHLY PAID government official
Its ridiculous there are millions of highly qualified sa'ns with and without experience...and to hire foreign people while having such high unemployment rate in sa is crazy
@@siyabongakhumalo6841 DON'T ALLOW IT. COMPANIES HAVRE TO PROVE THEY HAVE ADEVERTISED AND COULD NOT FIND A SA WITH THOSE SKILLS. IF YIOU FIND OUT THEY DID NOT DO THIS, REPORT THEM TO LABOUR DEPARTMENT. SANS WORKING IN SUCH PLACES WHISTLEBLOW ON THEM.
I was going to disagree and say we have those skills and are unemployed, but its true we don't get employment and we ourselves have to start looking outside SA.
😂😂 it looks like the stress is really getting to you that you can't even think straight anymore. Your brain is wasted. What is your president saying in your country you don't even know what to share with anyone in your own country. 😂😂
We not in the business of taking care of others and neglecting ourselves. South Africans have been excluded by the White man in this country once again and this time we fighting back.
We have international labour organisation's.....which advocate for labour rights so here in south african workers have rights ...South Africa is not a jungle like Zimbabweans where you can't question anything ......when you question you are sjambokked ......
We have international labour organisation's.....which advocate for labour rights so here in south african workers have rights ...South Africa is not a jungle like Zimbabweans where you can't question anything ......when you question you are sjambokked ......
There is a critical skills list that was published. There is also documentation explaining how the list was arrived at. There is a list from DHET also that does research on such skills and DHA uses that list to arrive at the critical skills. Don't just listen to news, read and research for facts by yourself.
It is absolutely rubbish to to pull some skills from Zimbabwe, really? Does Zim not need those skills, what is it that Zimbabwe can produce that we can't? Bullshiiiìit!!!!
That claim is absolute nonsense, how many graduates are sitting at home or working at Mcdonalds. The other thing is that you can't say that selling phones and being a waiter or uber driver is a special skill. Stop the gas lighting
Exactly 💯 This govt thinks we stupid. We all listens to Dr S and the D.G presentation he addressed these as issues and concerns. And they don't these people..... ANC people think we school children who listen to nonsense
Foreigners ..mabahambe
There are so many qualified white people artisans engineers sitting at home 🏠🏡 doing nothing because of evil Mandela starting affirmative action then Bbe Who can work at Eskom SAA to fix it
Just the other day, nurses in KZN went to submit they CVS demanding jobs at DOH, yet his saying theres a shortage of nurses. These people living in a castle 🏰 that dont see clear.
Go see private hospitals medic clinic ONLY FOREIGNERS as nurses and doctors, S.A people sitting at home. Why do they give them work visas when S.A have nurses and doctors.
@matrix0085 I think DOHA is also pushing some kind of narrative towards this whole scarce skills saga. I fail to understand why they say we have scarce skills of Doctors, nurses, teachers, and IT people it's mind-blowing. Our biggest problem is also these private sectors that do as they pleases that makes it more difficult. Private sectors are more corrupt than or government, but remember, because they are "private," no one have a say in what they do in this country, or they will back up and leave. Thousands of nurses, teachers, and doctors are sitting at home, and they are busy recruiting foreigners. My best friend's husband used to work in the trauma department at the hospital, which makes him not to be a general doctor his sitting at home for years because the government didn't renew his contract. Let's hope that while we fight for this country and the rights of the people within this country , we will 1 day be able to have peace and enjoy this country without any fights. It was first apartheid now that we have to fight illegal foreigners for our own country.
DA messing us around they looking for a, way to employ cheap labor,
He is a DA member.
How do you know??
@@RobertEarlMylroie he used to be a shadow deputy minister for the DA in the department of labour, and DA MP.
Stop exploiting foreigners
@@MasayitiMathebula They are not victims, they are part of the problem.
Don't take him Sirius he's lost
South Africa needs to train their own than just importing foreigners because this leaves South Africans unemployed
That has always been the plan from the White man. Don't trust what they say. Same people who claimed for years no foreigners are not taking jobs, look now. Watch them like hawks, see if they advertised those skilled posts, if they didn't, report them to labour department and spread it on social media. They need to be stopped in their tracks this time.
Nonsense...no logic at all on what you're saying 🤮
There are busy on pianos 😊😊😊
There's so many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela bringing in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can overnight fix Eskom SAA
What happens when our skilled people come back? And, they are coming back.
Also, what about all the skilled young people graduating from universities
and other institutions. And as a matter of fact, please let us be clear.
WHAT SKILLS ARE WE SHORTING? Please tell us Michael Bagraim and the
SABC so we can get in on the racket.
Please could they enlighten us on those specific skills that are "short"?? If the excuse is that the SA Critical skills bearers are lured abroad by better working conditions... then there's your answer. Better our working environments, Labour Department and more competitive packages. You are paid the big money to make the creative solutions work, STOP BEING LAZY as a HIGHLY PAID government official
Exactly. We want to aquire those skills too and work.
google it, It is you, to find what skill is in demand.
But how many of those now qualified university people who studied overseas are ANC cadres children being paid by taxpayers money from South Africa,let them look for in the country they studied in 📯📯 there's enough degree graduates in South Africa
South Africans should always be hired FIRST before foreigners.
skills FIRST.
@@jameskillu9171 South African skilled workers FIRST before foreign workers!!
@@jameskillu9171 If those skills are in SA, you must go practice your skills in Zimbabwe.
🎉🎉❤❤Fellow Zimbos,,,, Zimbabwe is ❤❤❤now open for business too many Chinese Company in Zimbabwe.Zimbabweans must leave South Africans in Peace please ❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉
@@jameskillu9171 Fix Zimbabwe 1st, you have big mouths here in SA but your mothers dont have sanitary towels and toilet papers back home ftsek kwerekwere
Many people don't understand the meaning of critical skills. It simply means there's demand on that particular skill even teaching can be critical especially in South Africa so many teachers are going to countries like China, U A E for more money and someone have to fill in the gap and not only that even Nurses are going to the UK.
many people coming from poor low value countries thinks that SA is an employment agency of Africa
If more than 35% of our people are unemployed , exactly what critical skills , or I should ask , what jobs are available for these so called critical skills shortage
Frying chips ,admin,it,police
Just go look at Eskom SAA and see why it's bankrupt, because qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela starting affirmative action and BEE, why bring in people from other countries, these qualified artisans engineers can fix Eskom SAA overnight
The problem is people are not responsible and they don't want to take ownership where foreigners have that ability.
Look at what's happening at our SOE's and hospitals. A company which my wife worked for employed students for the holidays but they never completed their work for the day because they were on their Cell phones the whole day.
We know from past experience what happenned in zim hospitals. Is this the reason our provincial hospitals have deteriorated? This makes no sence?
All those “critical skills” you mention, I know personally individuals who have those skills but are unemployed and don’t even get a reply from job applications 😂😂 ffs I have two cousins who are qualified medical doctors but I chill with them on weekends because they are unemployed 😂😂just stop lying to us and say that you prefer foreign workers😂😂😂
You are lying and you know it
@@studylive99there is how many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home because evil Mandela brought in affirmative action and BEE,these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight
People are unreasonable. He is giving you reasons, what more do you want ? 😂
Same people who told us foreigners don't take jobs but now we have the proof. Nothing unreasonable about not trusting them.
Most of the Nurses are not leaving this country for better salaries..it simply because they don't get jobs in their owncountry, am a nurse..short staffed yet they're foreigners are being employed in our public hospitals...I've got more than 5 Professional nurses i know that are sitting at home 😟
Zimbabweans are studying here. Please don't fool us it's enough. This is Helen Zille plan.
They don't pay school fees at all 😅😅😅
But again other way around there are so many ANC cadres children are studying in Europe on taxpayers money not because they can't study in South Africa but because they think and feel they are better than black 🖤 kids from townships, it's a sick story
What are you saying? Zimbabweans mustn't study in South Africa? If we can apply at SA universities get accepted, apply for study visa section 13 of the Immigration Act of 2002 get it pay fees come through the boarder and study.... what's wrong with that if I may ask? Any violation of laws?
@@nimrodmapuranga2889 if it's done legally and the person studying in South Africa is paying for it yes no problem 👍👍👍 it works other way around for a South African studying overseas, only problem is that most kids studying overseas are ANC cadres kids and taxpayers money 🤑💰 is being used,
Ah, what an inspired approach-overlook thousands of unemployed, skilled Black graduates within our borders, and instead focus on recruiting talent from overseas. It is almost as though local potential is an afterthought. Surely, with exploitation still prevalent in certain industries like restaurants, we can expect a sudden, genuine commitment to diversity when recruiting from abroad? One has to wonder when we, as a country, will recognise the talent we have right here. Perhaps it is time to reconsider where our priorities truly lie.
The question is: they are graduates in what?
😂😂😂😢😢. It's so heartsore for allowing people from other countries yo work in South Africa while thousands of qualified people born in South don't have work
Zimbabwe it be comes an example of all this.
So S.A is telling us, that these Zim & Indi currently in S.A, cell phone shop, saloons, Gardeners, maids, tree cutters have these qualifications and chose to be the above. Please nonsense. Dr S called the above economy immigrants. He said he wants to attract productive people to contribute to S.A economy.
Soo you telling me South African are not capable of being trained and be competent in those critical skills
My reasoning as well.
There are so many white qualified artisans engineers technicians sitting at home due to evil Mandela fault because he brought in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight if they are allowed
You missed the point...
You already have your own knowledge and not willing to listen what this interview is addressing.
You will be left behind complaining, the world and those that read and research for themselves and not wait to be spoon-fed propaganda, will be let behind...
This man is talking a lot of shut! we got more than enough skilled people in SA.
Companies just hire foreigners because they pay them peanuts.
I think your idees are a lot of shut!
Yes so many white qualified artisans engineers sitting at home due to evil Mandela bringing in affirmative action and BEE Who could fix Eskom SAA overnight
As long Melusi produce poor mathematical student ,the IT industry will have problem especially coding
😢😢😢 as long as ANC cadres allow a 30 % pass rate nothing will be fixed,how many qualified white artisans engineers technicians are sitting at home due to evil Mandela who brought in affirmative action and BEE these skilled people can fix Eskom SAA overnight
Why does south africa not have training homes for nurses in our country? Rather to import lets train our very own? Get high skilled people to train our very own. Auditing? We have many auditors in this country who has open doors towards students serving their time completing their articles
Thers no ict modules in public sculs ...they only teach history
The zimbabweni,why don't they use these skills to lift their country
What bs!!!!
Please could they enlighten us on those specific skills that are "short"?? If the excuse is that the SA Critical skills bearers are lured abroad by better working conditions... then there's your answer. Better our working environments, Labour Department and more competitive packages. You are paid the big money to make the creative solutions work, STOP BEING LAZY as a HIGHLY PAID government official
Just imagine.
Its ridiculous there are millions of highly qualified sa'ns with and without experience...and to hire foreign people while having such high unemployment rate in sa is crazy
He gave an example of auditors, computer analysts, software developers, systems analysts, trainers for auditors.
@@siyabongakhumalo6841 DON'T ALLOW IT. COMPANIES HAVRE TO PROVE THEY HAVE ADEVERTISED AND COULD NOT FIND A SA WITH THOSE SKILLS. IF YIOU FIND OUT THEY DID NOT DO THIS, REPORT THEM TO LABOUR DEPARTMENT. SANS WORKING IN SUCH PLACES WHISTLEBLOW ON THEM.
@@fm86-08 I KNOW ENGINEERS, IT SPECIALIST WHO ARE WORKING IN THE UK, BECAUSE THEY COULD NOT FIND JOBS IN SOUTH AFRICA WHAT DOES THAT SAY!!!
I was going to disagree and say we have those skills and are unemployed, but its true we don't get employment and we ourselves have to start looking outside SA.
sharing is caring, give more to neighbours, no need to cross oceans and contiinents.
😂😂 it looks like the stress is really getting to you that you can't even think straight anymore. Your brain is wasted. What is your president saying in your country you don't even know what to share with anyone in your own country. 😂😂
We not in the business of taking care of others and neglecting ourselves. South Africans have been excluded by the White man in this country once again and this time we fighting back.
sharing with monkeys?
You again...go and make Zim Great Again🪰
DA don't forget that we can fight neh don't play with us ABAHAMBE!!!!
Just hope they talking special skill
Critical Skill - Selling Drugs
The problem here in this country is, some of the locals here purposely make it difficult for the employers, go on a go slow purposely, acteeism etc.
That's not grounds for hiring foreigners. Maybe if Employers were not such exploiters people would not this way.
Then go to a country that is favourable to you. You're opinion means nothing
We have international labour organisation's.....which advocate for labour rights so here in south african workers have rights ...South Africa is not a jungle like Zimbabweans where you can't question anything ......when you question you are sjambokked ......
We have international labour organisation's.....which advocate for labour rights so here in south african workers have rights ...South Africa is not a jungle like Zimbabweans where you can't question anything ......when you question you are sjambokked ......
South African couldn't work for employers enrichment and paying peanuts, period
Computer analyst, am I hearing him.
Nonsense we have it people in sa..mabahambe
Please tabulate these special skills that we don't have.
There is a critical skills list that was published.
There is also documentation explaining how the list was arrived at.
There is a list from DHET also that does research on such skills and DHA uses that list to arrive at the critical skills.
Don't just listen to news, read and research for facts by yourself.
It is absolutely rubbish to to pull some skills from Zimbabwe, really?
Does Zim not need those skills, what is it that Zimbabwe can produce that we can't? Bullshiiiìit!!!!
Zimbabwe can produce it's own cars and helicopters and the make their own TVs while we import those things
@shilboyletsoalo3912 hayi rhaa suxoka, Mnangagwa was bribed with maize helicopter helicopter etc by Russia
😂😂🤣 😂😂😂😂😂
SA first ...ppl say unions are the cause of major unemployment ...they have too much power ...FREE our rainbow nation
Unemployed people looking for jobs don't have unions. Its Apartheid no. 2 , keep Black people unemployed.