Should Left-handed Players Play Right-handed?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2021
- Link to Left handed Glarry Semi-Hollow Electric Guitar:
bit.ly/2WCLllS
Know Your Gear T shirts
teespring.com/stores/know-you...
Want to have your product reviewed on this show? Contact us here
pmcknight7@gmail.com
You can become a Patreon and support more videos like this
www.patreon.com/phillipmcknig...
If you want to support the channel and not sign up with Patreon you can make a one time pledge here. www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_...
Here is a affiliate links that help support the channel
imp.i114863.net/c/2224555/791...
D addario tool kits
imp.i114863.net/3P7Wdn
Snark tuner
imp.i114863.net/N1e5O
The strings I use
stringjoy.com/partner/phillip...
The mic I use for this and my podcast
imp.i114863.net/yRrAmG
KYG Merch
teespring.com/stores/know-you...
iTunes: smarturl.it/KYGitunes
Spotify: smarturl.it/KYG-Spotify
RUclips: smarturl.it/KYGyoutube
iHeart Radio: smarturl.it/KYGiheartradio
I'm left handed and for me it just makes more sense to have my dominant hand on the fretboard. Most of us Lefties are fairly ambidextrous, so picking and strumming are not an issue. That's what works best for me.
Same here. Most lefties fret with their left hand.
Same here!
same here. I'm almost ambidextrous. I can write with both hands, but my left is the dominant. I started playing left-handed then I decided it would be easier to be a right-handed player. heve you ever tried developing your right hand in writing, for example? I found out it helps me even more with my picking on guitar!
It was weird at first, but in no time playing right handed felt natural. My left-handed dad (who played guitar for a couple of years as a kid) encouraged me to learn right-handed as a leftie, and I’m glad he did. My guitar teacher actually liked that I was a leftie playing right-handed because I had better dexterity in my fretting hand. Props to the lefties playing righty!
I will also say that having played right handed, I think righties should be playing left handed.
Another good way of deciding if a person should play left or right handed guitar is to check which way they naturally play Air Guitar - especially if they are asked to try to play Air Guitar the wrong way round (for them) and they are uncoordinated and it feels awkward. There are a lot of myths about guitar playing orientation, with some people (not you Phil) presenting less than true statements as fact. The main thing to realise is that everyone is different, so what works for one person may not work for another person. Some people are completely ambidextrous and can do pretty much anything with either their left or right limbs. Other people are completely “one-sided”, and can only perform tasks to a competent level with either their left hand/leg or their right arm/leg. A third set of people are cross-dominant, and perform some tasks with their left side and other tasks with their right side (which tasks are performed best by which side will differ from person to person). When we say that a person is left or right handed, we usually refer to the hand they write with but that is misleading as they may write with a certain hand but perform other tasks with the other hand. That is why when someone says everyone should play guitar right handed because either they, or a famous player, play guitar right handed but they are left handed (meaning they write with their left hand) is based on a misunderstanding. Some people will naturally write with their left hand but their natural orientation for playing guitar is to play right-handed. Another irrelevant comment made is that there are no left handed Pianos or Saxaphones (or whatever). Those are all completely different instruments to the guitar, and the hands operate in a different way to guitar playing. Interestingly there are left-handed Cellos and Violins (Charlie Chaplin played violin left-handed), and Thomanns in Europe sell some left handed classical stringed instruments. Then there is the old “learn to play right handed as your dominant hand will be fretting” chestnut. If this were a factor then most right handed players should learn to play left handed. In reality the picking hand performs highly complex tasks the more you progress with guitar, and the coordination between left and right hand is very important and made more difficult if a person is forced to learn guitar the wrong way round (for them). The next reason people give for saying everyone should learn to play right handed is that you will struggle to buy a left handed guitar. While it is true that there are more right then left handed guitars in the world, the situation for getting left handed guitars at every price point is much better than it has ever been. Even if you do not live near a music shop you can order online, and return the guitar if you try it and it is not right for you (always best to play a guitar before deciding whether or not to keep it). The guitar is a great instrument and is so adaptable being easily manufactured in both left and right handed versions, and there are no problems in stage positioning when left and right handed guitar and bass players feature in the same performance. Please remember that a minority of people will only reach their full potential as guitar players (and indeed will only keep playing) if they learn and play using their dominant orientation for guitar playing. Finally, what way round do I play guitar? I can play both left handed and right handed, and have put in the hours practicing and developing muscle memory on the instrument in both orientations. However, I am a better player performing left-handed as that is my dominant orientation for playing the guitar. Thank you for reading and apologies for the long post.
The air guitar preference is the most obvious way
@@cb-ez7pz eh it’s actually not so simple, I’m a lefty who’s intro to guitar was rockband as a little kid and those were right handed, I remember hating it at first but after a while I got used to it and played air guitar ever since right handed bc of it, fast forward to now I’m two years in to playing right handed and am considering switching bc of limitations, I just feel like I’m still praying for the best rather than confidently picking each note, my left hand muting do be on point tho😂
THANK YOU. I'm left-handed and play right-handed and the "well, it must give you an advantage to fret with your dominant hand" thing irks me to no end. It's like, okay then go get a left-handed guitar and play that way (and of course no one does). And you just kinda blew my mind because the ONE thing I've struggled with more than anything else in my playing is hand synchronization. I believe this is why I've never been able to nail sweep picking.
I'm left-handed, but have always played right-handed. It just came natural to me. My oldest sister is left-handed and learning guitar. She went to a music store and the only LH guitar they had was a ESP Kirk Hammett guitar. She bought it anyway and tried playing on it and ended up selling it. She practices on a LH acoustic and a LH Gretsch electric.
im the same.
Left-handed guitars can be difficult to come by in local areas. That was my experience growing up. I'd keep an eye out on sites like Sweetwater. They generally have a great selection of inexpensive left-handed guitars. I've bought two guitars from them in the last 5 years and they've both been great experiences.
Me too, for me it makes more sense to have our dominant hand fretting.
Same here, being more articulate on the fretboard off the bat made for quick learning
Same here. I’m left handed and playing a right handed guitar seemed the natural way to play for me as well since the left hand is doing the complicated fretting, it just makes sense to me.
I’ve been playing left handed for almost 40 years. In the beginning I heard salesman after salesman try to sell me right handed guitars using the flimsiest of logic, which I always called them out on. Then I would hear the old line “why don’t you just restring a righty guitar like Jimi Hendrix?” It was really annoying.
Ugh the salesperson pressure. Lefty playing lefty over 20 yrs. The great thing is nobody asks can they try your guitars 😆
@@Ottophil that’s the bullshit they would try first. Their logic of “well if you’re left handed you should play a right handed guitar” always got the reply from me of “so why don’t you play a left handed guitar?” That shut them up on that tactic.
@@Ottophil No you take a long walk off a short pier!
I'm a leftie who played right-handed for 3 decades, and it took years and years to "get good." I just switched to left, and after 6 weeks, I'm already almost to the level of playing I was the last time I played right-handed. So my advice for beginners: play with your dominant hand from the get-go!
I agree, I have been playing right handed but am a leftie. The hand that makes all the difference as far as a song is concerned is the strumming hand and if you cant do the quick micro rhythm movements needed its just not going to work. There are millions of songs with the same sequence of chords gut the strumming hand is what differentiates them.
Even if you don't play with your Dominant look at Eric Gales the Paul McCartneys from the Beatles Tribute Bands even though they're right handed they learn to play left handed, and some of them are left handed.
Many don't know but, Jimi was actually right handed. Signed autographs with his right hand as well as threw a baseball with his right hand.
That stellar guitar player Jesse Johnson of Prince/The Time fame is actually left handed.
It's all about what feels "right" to YOU.
Another weird example would be those that play with the strings reversed i.e. low E on the bottom of the neck.
Eric Gales comes to mind. Phenomenal player!
He wrote with his right hand because his father believed that left handed people were from the devil. That was a common experience at that time. My great grandpa was one of these people. He wrote with both hands because his teachers pressured him to. Everything else was left handed.
As for throwing baseballs, that's not really a good indicator. I know a pitcher who is left handed and throws right handed, and there are a lot of opposite throwing and kicking people who play sports.
I'm left handed and play ping pong and tennis with both hands, throwing the paddle between hands depending on which side is better. (that's apparently really rare and difficult for most people)
I'd be willing to bet he did a lot of other things left handed.
Mark Knopfler is another notable example. He's a lefty but plays right handed. He said he did it because his bends were better with his stronger hand.
Or Dick Dale, who is a lefty but plays a RH guitar flipped but strung normally, so he's playing with the strings upside down like you mentioned.
I mean Ringo Starr was forced to be Right Handed even though he was a Leftie and still uses his Left hand a lot when playing Drums, and other tasks but not on Guitar or writing.@@BoomTexan
For people who do some things with one hand and others with the opposite (ex write left, throw right), that is called being cross dominant. I never knew the term for it growing up, so I always want to put that out there in case it helps others realize they aren't alone or 'weird'. I feel like a lot of natural lefties end up this way simply because we have to adapt to a world designed for righties but thats just my theory and there are definitely people who use their right hand more that are also cross dominant so thats obviously not the exclusive cause.
Thanks for the videos Phil, this is a question that I see on forums and such a lot and it'll be great to be able to link to this video to help people figure out what works for them.
Same here but the other way around ;-)
Write right. Play right. Throw left. Wank left. (No joke 🙂)
Today I learned there's a name for what I do
I had wondered if my strabismus/lazy eye issues played into why I do right handed things sometimes (my strong eye is my right), but now I know I'm not the only one. My dad is super left handed and he was the only other lefty I've known for a long time.
Thanks Andrew! there had to be a word for that. I throw right, bat right, slap shot right, punch right, kick right, but still write with my left hand and play guitar left handed - oh never leave the wife walking 'right' either
Right handed but have to use left handed bow for archery
many many moons ago, my teacher tried to get me to play right handed, said I'd regret it if i didnt, so i tried for several weeks and just couldnt do it. Finally he gave in, helped me string one of the class guitars left, and there was no going back. I regret nothing. i love the instrument and it feels very natural and well, 'right'.
Oh, so you CAN string a righthanded guitar to be a left? What about the thickness of the strings which isn't the same? Do you carve a deeper pocket on the bridges of the guitar or change bridges too?
Tried to learn right-handed with my brand new Hardtail Strat in 1964..... it didn't work..... so my machinist Uncle fashioned a brass lefty nut.... and I have played lefty ever since....even before I'd heard of Jimi...... I still have it.... just wished I'd kept the original nut..... It would be worth a mint.... but I'll never sell it
Oh please, it's all about how you first pick it up and what is comfortable to you. I am very right handed, I only do two things left-handed..play guitar and fire a rifle... I an also pretty ambidextrous...the clapping bit is horseshit.
@@stephenwalton1234 .... In 1964 there were very few lefties available to try in the store..... and that hasn't changed....
@@davelate4148 ...mate, I'm 68 years old, I know the problem, my first guitar was a Barney Kessel copy, and I had to have it changed to lefthanded, but my point is it's how you first pick it up not how you clap your hands.
I have grand kids that are learning to play and that's how we found out which hand they play....just hand it to them... simple.
Great video Phil, thank you for all the great content. You have been a valuable asset to my guitar & accessories education. I write with my right hand but cut food with my left. About 30 years ago, I picked up a right handed guitar. It never felt right & I lost interest. In February of 2019, I purchased a used left handed guitar & borrowed a right handed guitar. 12 left handed guitars later & I'm having a blast. Due to limited options for lefties, huge fan of buying inexpensive guitars & upgrading them myself. It blows my mind how a good set of pickups & pots with proper set up & intonation can not only improve sound & tone. Additionally it changes the way the guitar feels & plays.
Thanks so much for this video, Phillip. As a lefty guitarist, I've always been annoyed by people encouraging lefties to "just learn right handed" (60 Cycle Hum, I'm looking at you). Every person is different and this subject should be treated on a person by person basis, as you eloquently demonstrate. How much great music have we possibly lost because new players were discouraged by their options? I'm old enough to have heard stories of kindergarten age children that were forced to learn to write right-handed even though they clearly favored their left. There's no place for that kind of behavior in the 21st century. And we are living in a golden age of lefty guitar availability: when I started 30 years ago, lefties were rare and usually expensive. Now I have a collection of nearly 20 guitars that span the spectrum of cheap to expensive and (almost) all of them are great players.
That 60 Cycle Hum video was one of the douchiest, most unnecessary things I’ve ever seen come out of a guitar “expert’s” soapbox. Listening to someone be THAT wrong, AND that insufferably smug, is worse than listening to ACTUAL 60-cycle hum.
Yeah that 60 cycle video is incredibly stupid. Telling aspiring players to basically go against their natural preference and conform to societies accepted way of playing is just wrong
@@eddiequinones3396 Couldn't agree more (I'm a lefty). And the second part of your statement is so true it makes my head want to explode. At least we have Phil, right?
@@eddiequinones3396 True, that 60 Cycle Hum dude is a total douchebag but there another guy out there. I think he only made one video on this but the hate he received is incredible...and justified. Play how you feel. Screw anyone who tells you how to play.
In contrast, as an extreme lefty and guitar hoarder, I would highly recommend learning right handed. I don't have the strongest right hand picking skills, but it's not because it's my weak hand, it's because of not enough focused practice. The world of guitars is wide open if you play right handed and you will almost definitely overcome any awkwardness that you feel early on playing the non-dominant way. There are sure to be people who are exceptions, but they will definitely be a tiny minority of left handed people.
Phil, you're such a Saint. I don't see other channels doing this for the fans. Not only are you simply trying to help people, but you're not selling anything! Take a lesson Beato.
Thank you. I'm a lefty and you're one of the few guitar RUclipsrs who didn't have a stupid "hot take" on this topic.
I agree totally! So annoying! Let me play my lefty guitar in peace without your stupid judgment.
@@dancompton1728 Yeah, they always end up with the "bUtt tHeRe r nO lEfTy piAnOs" chestnut, without thinking about how hands and pianos actually work. And some of them seem so angry that we exist, too.
@@arthurpiccio7906 Yeah I don't get it. People actively troll in the comments about it. I don't understand why it's so threatening or offensive that someone would play a guitar the opposite way. It's just a guitar. Quit taking it so seriously.
Thank you for this video. It confirms my choice to switch to left handed guitar. As a kid, I always picked up guitars left handed. However, I first studied piano, and later moved to double bass and electric bass. I was taught bass right handed. When I decided to learn guitar, I tried to learn right handed, but I found using a pick difficult. If I flipped the guitar, picking and strumming were much easier. So, I traded in the right handed guitar for a lefty. It is taking a little time to get my right hand up to speed for fretting, but it feels so much more comfortable overall. Makes me wonder how different my journey on bass would be if a left handed double bass had been an option.
Thank you
Thank you
Thank you!
Finally someone has addressed the left handed Dilemma. I’m a lefty and have had limited choices because of it.
Hopefully manufacturers will watch this video and the responses to start making more left handed guitars.
I’m sure many people have quit guitar playing because they are natural lefty’s and they were forced to play right handed.
When I was about 13-14, I started playing guitar. I'm left-handed myself, but I started out playing right-handed. As I learned more about the guitar and rock bands like Black Sabbath and Jimi Hendrix, I found out left-handed guitars were a thing. While I was learning to play right-handed, I always felt like something was... off. I couldn't put my finger on it, but I could once I started playing left-handed. Playing lefty just felt "Correct" to me, way back before anyone told me that there was a right or wrong way to play. Maybe it's just an instinct thing, I don't know. I switched to left-handed guitars after about 6 months to a year of playing right-handed, so starting over wasn't too big of a deal. I made more progress as a left-handed player in 6 months than I did right handed for a year.
My main point is, whatever your dominant hand is, give it a try. If you're left-handed, give a left-handed guitar a try and you may like it. It may even feel better for you given you're strumming with your dominant hand. Some left-handed people do still play right handed because they use their dominant hand to fret the guitar. You can really do it either way, it's all up to user preference. I do like to advocate for playing left-handed if that is your dominant hand just because it came to me so easily and it has served me well for over 15 years. With companies like Glarry making lefties now, it's easier than ever to get entry level guitars left-handed, something that was a challenge for me as a teenager but not so much these days. Epiphone has some nice selections too.
Left-handed or right-handed, they all play the same notes in the end.
Edit: After you explained the test, it makes sense to me now. I've always clapped primarily with my left hand making all of the movement. Never even thought about it. That's really cool.
You made the correct choice! I switched to leftie (my dominant hand), recently, which I should have years ago! But better late than never!
Wow, this matches my own experience so well that I could have written this. It was when I discovered Hendrix that I realized I was being taught wrong. And like you, I accomplished more in six months that I did in over a year of playing right handed.
Funny that I told this story to my kids when they were young. When I moved to Seattle, I had to go visit Jimi's grave. My kids, around 4 to 6, jumped out the car and went running to his grave yelling "That's the man that taught daddy how to play guitar." Wasn't a dry eye around, but I guess they were right. He was my inspiration.
Now if we could just get guitar manufacturers from wiring the pots backwards. Jimi's weren't. I don't buy production guitars anymore because of that idiocy. I build partscasters made from Warmouth parts.
Thank you for actually treating this subject with respect and not “JuSt pLaY RiGhTy”…
That phrase makes my blood boil.
Hey Phil , thanks for the lefty video, as a lefty I appreciate the video , we don't get the selection in guitars that rightys get, I love your channel and all the information you share, hope to see more lefty guitars on you're show ! Thanks 🍻🤘💪🎸😎
I’m a lefty, and have played lefty from day one. I picked guitar up relatively easy in the first 2 weeks, and I’m certain that wouldn’t of happened if I would of learned righty. If you’re going to give up playing guitar it’ll be in the first few months, so every advantage you can get to succeed early
is a good idea. I also can tell if people should learn lefty by just asking them to play air guitar- that gives it away in seconds.
As for the ‘if you play lefty you’ll have less choice for high end instruments’ argument, I own lots of rarer lefties including a Gibson Flying V, an EVH Wolfgang, a Custom 22 10 top PRS, and A Gretsch Bo Diddley, and have a Gibson Explorer on the way. I probably wouldn’t have bought as many guitars if I wasn’t for being left handed because the search is greater.
Thanks Phil for a great video that sees the problems lefties had from our position. I’ve gotten way too angry at several Righty Guitarist RUclipsrs who entirely dismiss the concept of lefty guitar because they’ve never had to experience what being left handed is actually like.
Oh man, the hunt makes it so much better! I love canvassing every music and pawn shop in the area when I go on vacation somewhere, I've picked up Chapman ML1, a Gibson 70's Tribute SG with Dirty Fingers pickups, and a Dean Custom 550FR with EMGs, the latter of which retailed over $1,000 when new. High end and even really solid mid-level guitars are out there, and it's more fun for me (and better for my wallet) for it to be a treasure hunt than to just be able to walk into guitar center and have a pick from 600 guitars instantly. I do wish more signature guitars and special finishes came lefty though.
Thank you phill for being soooooo honest your the first person truly address this important issue
I was told to play right-handed guitar when I first started playing back in high school, but the whole year I tried to play it just felt funky and off-balance somehow. I ended up dropping guitar thinking I just wasn't any good at it. Fast forward ten years later when my father passed, who had played guitar his whole life, and I felt inspired to pick it up again in his honor. This time around I bought a lefty and playing it just came SO naturally. I fell into rhythm and picked up complex fingerpicking in days where I had struggled for months to no avail on the righty guitar. Needless to say, I am so so glad I switched to lefty and feel I am using my full potential now using my dominant hand for the picking/strumming. I would recommend to try both out at the store and just see which feels more comfortable and go with that. I had known the lefty guitar always felt more comfortable but bypassed my intuition at the advice of an "expert" who thought I would struggle finding lefty guitars and tabs. Buying lefty guitars is a bit of a pain but it is 1000% worth it!
Thank you so much for showing some love to the Lefty players! My son who is 29yo has been playing the guitar along with other instruments since he was 12. I have tried playing his guitars with zero success as he is a right-handed player. I am a true Lefty and I own a beautiful electric black Yamaha Pacifica (112J) lefty. I have been learning and playing it with ease and at 48yo! So, yes I'm a late bloomer, partly because I am an RN[16yrs] and also was discouraged by the small selection of quality left handed guitars! Can you please recommend a quality left handed acoustic guitar [a smaller than dreadnought please!] Would love to see a video of that! Thanks again for your great information and I'm addicted to your podcasts! So informative and honest! Hope the Mrs. is doing well!
I love music and playing the guitar has helped me immensely during this difficult time.✌🏼🤘🏼✌🏼
Great video and really informative, phil. This is the first video I've seen concerning this subject matter.
Hope you and your family had a great Thanksgiving.
Very interesting video Phil.
I am left handed( write, throw, grab with) however I play guitar right handed.
For me that may have been influenced by the posters I had on my wall of Clapton, Michael Schenker, Ace Frehley and even Hendrix. Right handed always felt "normal" to me. My chord and lead hand is my left.
Thanks
I have a friend who is a very left-handed person, but taught himself to play guitar right handed so he could find guitars.
When I got into hockey my dad bought lefty sticks, but I only felt normal shooting/playing righty. When I picked up guitar around the same time, lefty was the only way I could play. Right handed feels nearly impossible for me to do.
I'm a lefty that has played right handed for 40 years but I am fairly ambidextrous. I'm very fortunate I can play right handed, most lefties I've met cannot. I still can't play left handed though...lol
Exactly my deal though I've only been playing righty for 34 yrs. Still can't play lefty either.
This video really needs to go viral.
My take on the guitar is both hands can get lots of technical use. I am right handed, and when I try to write left handed, it's awkward--as if I just don't have the finesse to make the fine motions needed . But then when I play guitar, which I play right handed, the left hand is really doing some intricate and precision work. IMHO, the fretting hand has the more technically demanding job much of the time.
I’m left handed and learnt to play back in the early 70’s.
In those days there was very little choice for lefties!
I therefore learnt to play right handed and have played that way ever since!
I would say that it initially gave me better dexterity on the fingerboard but the trade off was more difficulty playing a smooth rhythm with my right hand/arm.
I don’t regret learning right handed as it has provided a variety of guitars to me that would not have been available had I played left handed!
Good tip about the clapping test. My granddaughter sometimes seems interested in learning guitar, so I'll try it on her the next time she and her brother come over to visit. I'm a little ambidextrous for many things, but definitely right-handed when it comes to guitar. I have that same Glarry model, and I also have a Squier Affinity. I like modding inexpensive guitars, and got fret jobs done on both, put different pickups in both, different pots, switches, etc. They still ended up costing only about $500 each, with all the parts and labor from modding, and they're now genuinely custom instruments, built to my specs, that play very well and sound great.
Fascinating! I do everything right handed, at least I thought I did. But, when it came to clapping, both hands moved the entire time, and the left hand is on top. I'm pretty well coordinated, and can do some things left handed if I need to.
Phill, I'd love to see you partner with glarry to see how cheap you can make an excellent guitar, decent alnico magnet pickups, with decent hardware, with the nut filed right with decent tuners, but maybe don't spend as much time polishing fret ends, or the tops of frets. Mostly how cheap can you make a fairly excellent guitar whilst skimping on the things a lot of us can do at home. For less than $30 dollars we can all polish frets and fret ends. We can round a headstock and neck and fretboard with the left over material. Maybe this would be something fender does where they offer a partscaster, where we can choose which pickups we want, and only pay for each individual pickup, and maybe charge a bit less because we still have to build the guitar ourselves, that way we are not paying for huge labor cost.
I always suggest that people try to play right handed because I know how frustrating it is to be left handed. We get to watch all the reviews and think "that looks great, too bad I can never have one" because we don't get many options. So many times I've seen guitars that I would love to have but aren't available for lefties. I've always modified my guitars because the things I want don't really exist. I resorted to going the custom route last year because of this. I don't wish this upon anyone so if you can, play right handed.
Yep, that's the biggest reason I would suggest right handed. That being said, I've always wondered if you can get better deals on left handed used guitars because the market is smaller?
That's the exact reason I switched my handedness 2 months ago
@@RogerThat902 Typically it's the opposite from what I've seen as a lefty/cross dominant person playing righty who kept an eye on the market just in case going righty didn't work out. The guitars are harder to come by, so they're typically listed for a bit more.
I am very left-handed and when I began taking guitar lessons as a kid, the instructor told my mother that because the guitar would initially be awkward in either direction, he was going to begin teaching me right-handed. It felt normal to me and 40 years later, I've never looked back- and I am SO glad he did this.
@@profane_kvetch Yeah I never had lessons when I started playing in 2004. I didn't know proper chords and things until a few years later. I was young and stubborn and just wanted to play. So naturally I picked up guitars the wrong way and now here we are. 😂
I've played right handed since I was a teen. At 50, nerve damage is making me learn to play left handed. May I suggest you try both, if possible, and see what feels more right to you?
I'm a left-handed man with a trace or more of ambidexterity. I have always tried new tasks both lefty and righty to see which one felt or worked better. I did the same when I first tried playing guitar. I might mention that I borrowed a guitar from a friend from high school, and that that guitar was a Strat copy of unknown manufacture. Naturally, the ergonomic shape of the guitar's body influenced my choice of orientation. It just felt more comfortable, so I went with it. Of course, this choice worked well in my favor, since I can buy pretty much any guitar and play it with confidence.
Please note, though, that I'm not coming out of my comfort zone, so I recommend this choice to no one but myself.
Thanks for this Phil. Y’all gained a lot of respect from me for not prescribing to people how hey need to play and just go with their hands say.
That is so cool. There’s always something to learn on this channel. Phil’s awesome. He’s just a dude
Nice looking guitar 🎸. The natural color and gloss finish make it look like it costs more than it does.
And a huge thanks to Phillip for doing this.
I'm a born lefty, when I started playing I naturally air guitared lefty. The guitar I had was my grandfather's acoustic and needed the bridge replaced because it was broken. Asked to have a left handed bridge put on it, ended up the shop didn't have one and put the right handed bridge on. So I began learning right handed and found that fretting and fingering was much easier. From playing baseball my right hand is pretty useful so it was fairly easy to strum and pick right handed and gets easier the more I practice. Plus there are a lot more choices of finishes and styles right handed. Now my brother is left handed too and he plays lefty but builds his own because of it. So in the end it worked out for me and haven't looked back since.
That was way more interesting than I was expecting!
A left hand PRS ES is a great deal. I have one to practice on and it's a very versatile instrument that you can grow with.
Bruce Dickinson from Iron Maiden was ranked in the top few hundred in British competitive Fencing, then one day they were at a Shooting Range, and the instructor noticed he used the gun sight ‘lefty’. Dickinson did some research and then relearned to fence left handed, and was ranked in the top 50. Very Princess Bride.
Another aspect is, not only the orientation of the guitar but also setup of the strings . All right handed players have the same orientation of the strings. But some left handed players like myself, Eric Gale and countless others. Set up the strings like a right handed player.
Same here
Thanks for the clap test, Phil! I'm a leftie who plays rightie and I sometimes regret learning this way as I feel like my right hand lags behind the left. According to your test, I'm a both-hand clapper, so I guess I just need to practice more!
As a child, my first grade teacher tried to make a righty out of me by taping my pencil into my right hand. It backfired on her when she forgot to take the tape off one day. Mom was P-O'ed. I was about 7, Dad strung up a Kay flat top lefty for me but it wasn't working out. He put it back to righty, I never looked back. BTW, I'm left dominant ambi.
I am another one of these lefties playing right handed. I think it honestly helped me, left hand came easy to me, and because I was used to using my right for a lot of things, I was really able to quickly pick up the right hand stuff.
Don't forget how cool a backwards strung guitar can be. Any guitar can be correct if you string it right! Also, Phill, you just gave me a great idea for an offset reverse tele design! Lol thank you Phill, you have really turbocharged my 35 year nerd lust for guitars!
Or play upside down. Low e at the bottom
I know. I was hoping the second half of this video was going to be cutting a new nut for this guitar so it could be played right handed.
Thanks for making this video. I'm right handed in pretty much everything, but I've always been somewhat ambidextrous. My mom is the same way, but she's super ambidextrous. I recently took an interest in playing guitar. We had an old acoustic right-handed one in the house, so I tried it. My dad brought to my attention that I was holding it upside down. However, it just feels natural to me to play guitar, air guitar, and guitar hero with my dominant hand on the neck. (This may be because I play piano, so playing the melody on the right hand feels similar to that). I can play with either hand, and I do strum better with my right, but the feeling of holding it lefty feels better. I just can't decide what to do, because I don't want to ignore my brain pushing me towards being a lefty. Interesting enough, when doing the clap test, my left hand kept moving while my right hand stopped. It's strange because I really don't do anything lefty. Do you have any suggestions for how to know for sure?
A group. Of my friends started playing like around 1980 and we all got guitars and my one buddy was left handed and his mom picked him up a old 1966 fender music master guitar right handed. We all played constantly . Well in 3 months my left handed buddy past us all up.
You play which ever way is most natural and comfortable for you.
Hi Phil. Love your videos! Like others, I’m left handed but play right. The basic rule for me has always been one hand (write or throw) … I’m left. Two hands (bat, shoot, golf) …. I’m right. Based on your test … left. Based on how badly I play … maybe I should switch:) Tx!
The clapping test indicated I am very right handed (left hand stationary and right hand moving), and I do write right-handed, but when i throw, I use my left hand. Also, when I tried to play right handed, it didn't feel natural to me, and I then realised when I turned it upside down, that felt more natural, so I was quite hesitant in my teens in getting a guitar, and didn't get a guitar until I was 21, and it was a left handed guitar. The frustrating part comes when you look online at a guitar store, and the models you want are only available in right-handed versions, or in the case of Sire, they advertise on their USA website that they sell left handed models, but you have to go to an international distributor to pick one up outside the US, and when I go to Andertons, Thomanns for example, I see only the right handed versions available in stock, so I ask myself the question, do I wait for the LH version to become available, or buy a RH version, turn upside down and restring? Or go the Doyle Bramhall route and learn the positions upside down, which i have tried, but to me doesn't sound the same even when you upstring.
I saw the title and said to myself,” Uh Oh, Phil’s about to piss me off!” But it turned out to be a nice video! Thanks for the lefty love Phil! It really does make a difference.
I bought one of these in a right hand did a little work put in a Seymour Duncan in the neck and really liked it so much I bought a G & L thinline and put in the same pickup in the neck and I’m luke warm. I miss my Glary
I'm mostly left handed, first times I picked up a guitar I held it left handed, but since the guitar that we had at home was right handed I went ahead and learned it right handed, after two weeks it felt natural. I think people over think this too much, as Paul Reed Smith said ... "We also sell left hand guitars to people who play left hand pianos" 😅
You are part of the problem. Read others comments about how your type of response is disrespectful. A piano and guitar are nothing alike 🤬.
I am left handed & learned to play right handed. I started playing when I was ten and I wanted to learn left handed but I didn’t know how to switch the strings around so I learned right handed. I see a lot of comments on people finding it so much easier to play once they switched to left handed but I don’t know if that would have been the case for me since I never tried. Now I’ve played for twenty years so even though I’m not the best musician it would be a lot of work to try starting over again.
As a strong left handed person I began bass playing a Right handed bass. There are definite advantages and dis advantages. For me, my left hand managed the fret board very easily and I developed my fretting quickly. My right hand was a bit f a different story. It took me a while to learn to finger pick and keep good tempo. Eventually I overcame this. Popping and slapping are easier in my opinion, for a lefty playing a right handed bass. In fact I can do a few things with my strong left hand, slapping/popping, that other right handed people can not do easily. John Patitucci is left handed and I stuck with overcoming my weaker right hand troubles with simple hard work and regular practice. Now that I am a pretty good bassist I am glad I learned on a right handed instrument.
TIP: Learn at least one new thing every time you practice. This tip came from a lecture from the late Jaco Pastorius.
Your presentation validates all of my thoughts over the years. Left handed or right handed. You can learn to play. Simply practice and learn. List your weaknesses and OVERCOME them. Well done and well thought out presentation. Thanks Very much.
I liked that first lick you played "I got my first 6 string, Bought it at the five and dime".
I'm lefty and tried learning guitar righty, and for years I just couldn't get it, and I kept going back trying to learn but it just never clicked, it was the most frustrating thing in the world. And then one day I was listening to Van Halen and playing air guitar lefty and had an epiphany. I ran to my guitar flipped the strings, and everything clicked, I was playing Fade to Black a week later! 😁
I think you should use the pick with whatever hand you right with, same motor skills.
Not me. I need my dominant hand to fret.
As a left handed person, it always struck me as odd that other left-handed people would limit themselves by selecting a left-handed guitar. The fact is, BOTH hands have an awful lot of learning to do regardless of which way you choose to play. Most new players struggle the most with their fretting hand technique. In my case, as a lefty playing a right-handed guitar, I struggle with my strumming technique, but regardless, struggle is struggle and it's not going to be easy no matter what. Maybe my perspective is skewed because I'm mostly ambidextrous, but I think that most lefties are out of pure necessity. Most of us are very used to living in a right-handed world.
We 'limit' ourselves because we are left-handed. Why on earth would I play right handed when playing left handed plays so much more comfortable? I sound like crap right handed. Playing guitar is about fun and expressing yourself...not doing something unnatural just to have more choice of guitars
It's not so much the struggle as it is doing what feels natural. I'm right hand dominant but forget about strumming with it. Can't fret with my left hand either. Lefty FEELS righty when I play guitar.
@@phile5437 understood, but frankly, what does that natural feel actually gain you? I've been playing for 15 years and I still do my "air guitar" left handed because I suppose it still feels more natural, but so what? That doesn't translate into any benefit when learning or playing.
Interesting subject matter, Phil. Love the new and interesting content!
Hi Philip, I am left handed and I only play right handed. When my parents sent me to a Nashville player, whom taught guitar in 59, there were no left handed players to teach me, at 6 years old. I cannot even hold a guitar left handed as it feels too strange. Interesting video.
I bought a new, left-handed American Standard Strat from your store in Chandler back in 2011 and we chatted about this very subject. I miss that store ...
Great video, you really nailed it. Being right or left-handed is not a choice, when I was young my guitar teacher advised me to start playing right-handed, "You will adapt to it quickly" but guess what, I didn't work out, after almost a year of trying to trick my brain into play right-handed I gave up on playing guitar.
I am sooooo glad that I'm not crazy.... I did his with new students back in the 90s.
Im left handed and started with a right hand guitar. I play the guitar for almost a year by now and im struggling with my picking hand. My left hand on the fret board is fast and it feels just right, but my right hand just wont geht some motions right like for example tremolo picking. I can barely pick fast and it hurts. Is it possible to get the right hand like my left hand? I feel like i wasted a Year full of hard practicing...
I'm left-handed. I would be inclined to have my right hand on the fret board. My problem is deciding which way to string the instrument. Do I just leave the strings as they are for a right-handed player or do I re-string? Any help appreciated.
It’s each to their own .. I like being a lefty .. it makes sense to me. I write and guitar lefty, but I play golf, baseball and do everything else righty 👍👍
I watched a interview with Nick Johnston and even though hes left handed he plays a right hand guitar. He said when he was a kid it made more sense to fret with his dominant hand.
I’m a lefty. I’m left hand dominant but left arm dominant. I play guitar, write, eat left handed. Throw,, bowl, and shoot right handed. I learned on a right handed guitar playing left handed so the guitar was upside down. I played that way for 20 years. I fell better with lefty guitars though.
You're whats known as cross dominant. I am too. Left hand is typically more precision stuff, right is more power stuff for me. Learned right handed guitar though and so far its been going pretty well.
I thought i was mostly right handed until few years ago when I injured my left hand and I noticed that I couldn’t do much with my right hand, basically writing and eating. I’m most likely ambidextrous and next time I replace the strings on one of my guitars I definitely wanna try playing left handed
another test of handedness: which wrist movement is more controlled and faster. the weak hand can basicaly only sustain moving with elbow. Forearm can be supported for such a test
I had the same issue as that person did back when i started in 1988, i got so fustrated trying to play right handed i quit 3 weeks in, then 1 year later i tried again but this time found a left handed series 10 in pawn shop that got me to where i was able to get my number 1 a 1990 left handed charvel metallic black 475 guitar. I say any guitar store who blatantly tells a left handed play to play right handed should be put out of business. i can see guitar companies back in the day before CNC machines having issues making left handed models, THEY DON'T HAVE AN EXCUSE TODAY, neither does Tremolo companies like floyd rose who limits left handed versions to just the original model and the cheapo base models. Here is the fact if left handers would stand united and not learn to play right handed but learn to play left handed, there would be alot more left handers out there to where these companies would have to cater to us as well but, these people cave in and these companies see that and get away with this you play right handed or go to another brand or don't play at all attitude. This is why i supported that person, almost every guitar company hated and alot of people attacked Ed Roman for they claim he was making counterfeit versions of brands models for left handed customers. I don't see no issue in that if the brand won't make it for you go to a great luthier and have them make it and it probably will end up 1000 times better as well. So if these companies don't want to make left handed versions of all their models, then do a deal with a ghost builder, luither where the person can specifically build custom left handed versions of all models of all brands. Both can benefit from this. But anybody who tells a left handed person to go play right handed. GO TRY TO PLAY LEFT HANDED AND SEE HOW WELL YOU MAKE OUT. See how frustrated you get and i can say this 90 percent of you would quit probably in the few hours, you would not make it a week. I am talking a real left handed guitar not a right handed strung left handed. Go try see how far you get then come back and try to state left handers need to learn to play right handed. Sorry but this is a topic that gets me pissed off. Especially when it's these music stores responsibility to guide the people who is just starting out to help them. thank god for schecter, dean who makes alot of left handed models. but i would stay away from the cheapo brands like series 10 (If they are still around) and those on the same level of series 10 guitars. They are on the basic bottom level of quality control, i know i had a series 10 guitar for year 1989-1990. Thank god Charvel made the 1990 model 475 left handed model or i would probably been stuck with it.
I feel ya brother lefty!
I have a telecaster that’s a right hand reverse neck, great for reducing string tension.
I am a leftie and been playing left handed guitars since I was 15, now 59! I would say that as you become more proficient, the sophistication and subtleties of what you do with your strumming / picking hand becomes increasingly important. You can learn all the fretboard with your less dominant hand but for all the creativity, I think your dominant hand contributes more if it is the strumming / picking hand. All that is less important if all you want to do is learn to strum a few chords , in that case there are a lot more right handed guitars in guitar stores!
I'm another lefty who has always played right handed. On fretting vs picking I would definitely say I struggle more with the picking hand, which shouldn't be a surprise. My sense is that lends to a more legato playing style. Play to your strengths, etc. But I have been investing more time in the right hand lately, as I have always held the pick between the thumb and middle finger, which is pretty unconventional (you should see how I hold a pencil with my dominant left hand; think caveman with a big fat crayon, but flipped over), and am trying to coerce it to a thumb-and-first finger approach. As soon as I stop thinking about it, or start playing for fun rather than practice it 'just goes back' to the way it has been done for 30 years. Conditioning or hand clapping test result? Who knows. Good vid as always, Phillip.
For me I could immediately tell I was more comfortable playing left handed. I started with an acoustic I played upside down until I bought myself a left hand schecter. Trying to play right handed just felt so wrong to me
One advantage I found I bought a Squier Strat and a Squire PBass back in the 90s specially ordered specially made it’s the only way I could get them then recently I’ve had both guitars to tech to check out as they are getting old now the PBass has proper fender P bass pickups but the rest of electronics weren’t. The Strat has proper fender electronics but cheap pickups so for not that much money I have two reasonably high standard left handed guitars The tech reckons the Strat is a proper fender apart from badge and pick ups
I'm lefthanded and following a beat, clapping or rocking the foot along to the beat of a song, definitely comes natural to me with my left side. I'm still a complete newbie, but the strumming gives me a lot of hardship and I seriously struggle with keeping up a steady beat or even make another beat other than straight down and up, down up, down up etc.
But I live in a community of righthanded guitarists so I HAD to learn playing righthanded otherwise I would never be able to use other guitars than my own and it would be super challenging copying chords others are playing and learn new tunes and vice versa, they would have a hard time copying my chords to a new tune... I learned to open cans with a righthanded can opener as a child because I had no choice, and with scissors I can use both hands but prefer the left... Soo I'm thinking, time, practice and a whole lot of patience with myself... unfortunately I don't have much of the latter... 3 months in, practicing daily, my strumming still really really really sucks and I can do the down, down up, up, down strum, but the moment I try to sing at the same time my brain totally crashes 🤯🤯🤯
Hey Phil, Now that you have both Right & Left Glarry's; you can throw them together and start busting out your Michael Angelo Betio shred. Take the channel in a whole new direction, you could start a Nitro cover band. 🎸
My son is left handed (actually ambidextrous...writes, eats, brushes teeth lefty, throws, swings, kicks, righty). I started teaching him guitar right handed, just so that he could use my guitars at the beginning. He struggled a lot. He could make chord forms with his left hand, but rhythm with the right just wasn't working. So, I got a lefty nut for one of my guitars, restrung it, and voila, he plays lefty. I built him 3 guitars, that he can play now. My only issue is....teaching him. I never actually thought it would be so difficult to teach a mirror image, but it is. I'll try showing him chord fingerings and it just looks "weird" to me, so I think it's wrong, but it's not. It's not a problem with him, but rather with me, looking at a lefty play, while I'm sitting across from him. Right now, he mainly just uses Rocksmith on the Xbox to learn what he wants to learn. It's not really a "passion" for him to learn guitar, so he just noodles with them for now. I've actually wondered if it would be easier to teach him how to play bass, since the left hand (right hand in his case) is much simpler than on a guitar.
The clap test doesn't work for me from the second grade of elementary school (50 yrs ago). Many thanks to the teacher who told the children about it. In recent years, my eyes have been disturbed by pawnshop models of guitars especially made for the wrong hands. =)
Oh yeah I had the same thing, as a kid I got a right handed guitar at the earnest report of the guy at the local shop that my life as a guitarist would be so much better later on if I just learned right handed. I Just couldn't do it and taking that one back and getting a lefty literally felt like a relief and was so much more natural. He was "Disappointed I didn't stick with it" But I've grown to be a competent guitarist with a decent collection of solid medium to high end guitars, and his shop went out of business 5 years ago lol.
I'm left-handed who play right handed, and the whole "learning scales are easier" is a myth, it all comes down to just practicing really, in fact we're kinda inferior now when it comes to right handed techniques, like fingerstyle stuff and whatnot since our right hand is weaker, I still struggle with doing funk style rhythms and whatnot, in the end if you're left-handed I highly recommend playing right handed instead, since you'll have more options for guitars and whatnot and not having to adjust guitars and whatnot.
This video brings to mind somebody that I've met a couple of times who played a lefty Tom Anderson Stratocaster with a righty neck in a lefty position and strung righty. If that doesn't knock your socks off, I don't know what will.
I'm left handed and when I first picked up a guitar, it was as if I would play it left handed. I was told to flip it over and get an RH guitar. I can't for the life of me get any rhythm strumming with my right hand and subsequently I hung the guitar up out of frustration. I picked my guitar up last night after years and my left hand has remembered thr chords but my right still can't strum. Has anyone else had this issue? Do you have any advice or know of any RUclips videos? I'd rather try to work with it than have to get a new guitar. Or should I just bite the bullet? 😄
A note about the Glarry bridge, rather the individual barrel saddles they are using. Normally, there are 2 strings per bridge. If you look at it in the video (5:48), you see every string hangs to one side, touching the height adjustment screw. I wouldn't think this is good for the strings. In a recent Trogily Show video, he also points out that the high E string is closer to the edge of the fretboard than the low E.
As a left-handed player guitar bass and drums with drums being my main instrument always try to get away playing right-handed, but like me if you can’t get away with it the main problem he will get is a lack of choice on instruments, when I’m playing drums in festival type venues I’ve been asked many times to play at the drum kit that has already set up which I’ve had to decline it is awkward being left-handed but nothing you can’t get over
So I’m right handed but clap with my right hand still and my left hand moves to clap. What does that mean?
I'm left handed and through childhood people tried to train it out of me. So as a result I am very awkward with anything that requires physical coordination. When I picked up my first guitar (bass, actually), it was a righty, and I kinda felt like it was already left handed. The fingers of my left hand can walk the fretboard a lot easier and more naturally than my right. Fingering the bass righty always feels natural, but using a pick feels like I'm playing with my foot. I never got to be very good, so maybe I've always been playing the wrong instrument.
I am left but for me its just seems no problem using right because I also can do a lot of things with my right hand bc i had to learn it when i grew up
I want to get some instruments for my twins. Of course one is left handed and one is right handed. Thank you sooo much for this!
i am Left Handed but i swing a Bat throw Darts and a Ball right handed but if i play Pool or use a Long Bow or pick up a Rifle or play Guitar i am Left Handed, probably because at School in the late 50's and 60's in the UK i was forced to use my Right Hand,my Son was born in 1975 and is Left Handed but by then he was allowed to use his Left Hand at School was it the same in the USA or did they let you use whatever Hand you wanted
I want to learn to play the guitar and I write left, throw right and I'm about 60/40 lefty, so I'm trying to decide which way to play.
I'm left, learned righty. It feels so natural. I'm surprised righties don't play lefty.
I'm right handed and play lefty :)
I am ambidextrous the issue being that my left hand was broken and my middle finger is crooked…. I feel more comfortable strumming with my right.
Excellent video. Fun fact: Benjamin Burnley from Breaking Benjamin is left-handed but plays guitar right-handed due to, as he claims, the greater availability of right-handed guitars that suit his preferences.
I'm left handed and this test shows my left hand is heavily dominant but I have played right handed for 30 years. My first guitar teacher (classical) just handed me the guitar on the first lesson and asked which felt more comfortable. I can't play a thing left handed now! :)
Fender Mod Shop, though it could be called expensive, will let a lefty customize a guitar like nothing else I've seen. Most stock Lefties usually have just 2 colors to choose from or none at all. I got my seafoam Green Tele that way.
Honestly, Phil, I wish more guitar sales people bothered to do this test with customers comming in to their store. It would have saved a lot of guitarist. Insted they will push a right handed on you at any cost. I’m a lefty that have tried to learn guitar for well over 20 years. I have probably quit more times than I started. 3 years ago I got my frist lefty. In the frist year I had more progres that the former 20 years combined. It is hard to learn to play guitar. Don’t make it harder than nessecary. -Get the right instrument from the get-go!