As a friend of Indians. I would like to say this: As long as you buy into democracy , you won't succeed. Democracy has never worked. I am a Taiwanese. Our country grew under martial law. Law and order created the "Taiwan" miracle. Some of us the went to China, as China asked for our help to rebuild China. However, suddenly, we bought into democracy as the west spread it all over. We then saw our wages not increase in 20 years. China had always knew democracy didn't work. And has never fallen into the trap. It kept its dignity , sucked in its pride and worked from the ground up. China is a pragmatist. A scientist. It experiments and admits its faults, when they see wrong, they corrected it. Democracy is imperialist way of dividing and conquering. Democracy made sure people believed that to have a healthy country, people must argue all day. A politician must attack the other side making it impossible to build anything quickly. Since ancient Greece, Rome, democracy has never succeeded. Democracy=rule by demons. Ask yourself , during the history of the US, when did people get to vote? in the 1960s? So they weren't democracies. UK was an imperialist who stole from their colonies, US used slaves to build their country . Their wealth came from stealing and robbing. Today, they can't rob anymore and it is showing all sorts of problems. India is not an imperialist country. Majority rule sounds romantic. However, mob rule are barbarian's way. If majority rule is correct. then We should just be barbarians , shouldn't we? The truth is, the educated are the minority. When building a road, it is best to ask engineers, when governing a state , it is best to ask people with experience. Not pick rulers by popularity. For the past 50 years. China has already proven, even though it started later than India, the scientific way made China grow faster. So wake up! It is easy to look at someone wealthy and follow their ways. But what if the wealthy guy is a thief and got its riches by stealing? Now that it can't steal anymore, would he still be rich? Trust the Chinese way. China invented paper currency. Do you trust a thief or the nation who invented money? Capitalism is the reason why a nation is rich. Not democracy. "Tyranny naturally arise from Democracy, and extreme form of liberalism is the worst form of tyranny" -Plato . When people abuse freedom of speech, morality is lost and all you do is argue with trolls. A nation then falls.
+Truthseeker Agree on most of your points. China is bashed almost on a daily basis. I just let the haters enjoy themselves. The truth is they can do nothing else about China, so whining and feeling morally "superior" should be the compensation they deserve.
+Prakash Prateek oh yea? try to replicate Japan's Lost Decade, then more power to you. www.google.com.hk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwi6mpyN1ODMAhUCzoMKHeM-Av4QFggdMAE&url=%68%74%74%70%73%3a%2f%2f%65%6e%2e%77%69%6b%69%70%65%64%69%61%2e%6f%72%67%2f%77%69%6b%69%2f%4c%6f%73%74%5f%44%65%63%61%64%65%5f%28%4a%61%70%61%6e%29&usg=AFQjCNFa9AEOgCiSRKSfqAWeHDkGZgdrxg
Ah I know. But let me tell you my personal experience. I have lived in about 5 countries now so it does give me some right on this matter. Falling GDP is due to falling population which does not mean the quality of life is poor in Japan. And the quick growth thing still holds true because I am not talking about 1990s or 2000s. Americans usually feel bad about Japan but it should be the other way around. Japan's standard of living still much higher. Social Structure still remains. Education and health is way better and certainly better than any Asian nation, Singapore might compete in some ways. So its not all about falling GDP and falling populaiton. Yh it is not the same good Japan of 1980s but the situation is not as bad as we believe it to be.
China and India both have started their journeys together towards becoming a Sovereign country. But today China is much ahead than India in the field of GDP, Defense, sports and technology. We are having one plus point and that is " Our Democracy" but in other fields we have to learn many things from China.
A very beautiful and interesting presentation. After watching this it is not difficult to think why 'made in China' is seen everywhere. Indian businessmen purchasing cheap goods there for sale in India but good quality products are also available in the same market if the money spent is right. We can understand why many things from toys to machines to tools that are told to be not durable and without warranty at many shops. The shopkeepers say derisively that they are 'China made' and are totally unreliable. But people buy phones and computers of branded company, also made in China, and say they are classy.
Only English to communicate. Each language has their own scripts. As per my knowledge though China has two writing system, i.e. Traditional and Simplified but their dialect is different e.g. Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien etc But in Indian language e.g. Hindi, Bengali, Marathi, Gujrati, Tamil, Telugu has their own language as well as script. So major places it is written in both English and Hindi, two official languages of india.
Thanks for ur information. Are these language completely different even in grammar? Cuz although Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien etc pronounce differently, but they all share the same words and grammar. Is there any common between the languages in India?
Not that much different as the language family is same. Just like English, French, German etc are different but belongs to same family. Marathi, Hindi, Bhojpuri these couple of North Indian language which sounds similar and follow same script. अ आ इ ई... - This is the script they follow.
there is also many things in which china should learn from india....chinese city is full of pollution...i think we r living better than that china...jai hind
just for fun hahahahahaha. .. Only stupid and idiot like you will feel that Chinese cities are polluted than Indian Cities. .... hahahaha. ... ass hole never visited China in there life and just barking what there media is telling ... pathatic. ...
indiyako chiana jaisa bananeke liy pahelaa yahaka dalal neta ko isolate karna padegi curuption ko jad se khatam karnaa padta hai british ne lade huy kaanun ko samapt karna chahiy sistem strong huna jaruri hai sab log me nationality hona chahiy jamin energy traspotation aur develope me kadaiki sath government ko nigarani hona sath hi loktantr ke nam par bikas birdhi party pablic ko tahe lagaya to chin ki 40% bikas barabar ho sakta hai.
As a friend of Indians. I would like to say this:
As long as you buy into democracy , you won't succeed. Democracy has never worked. I am a Taiwanese. Our country grew under martial law. Law and order created the "Taiwan" miracle. Some of us the went to China, as China asked for our help to rebuild China. However, suddenly, we bought into democracy as the west spread it all over. We then saw our wages not increase in 20 years. China had always knew democracy didn't work. And has never fallen into the trap. It kept its dignity , sucked in its pride and worked from the ground up. China is a pragmatist. A scientist. It experiments and admits its faults, when they see wrong, they corrected it. Democracy is imperialist way of dividing and conquering. Democracy made sure people believed that to have a healthy country, people must argue all day. A politician must attack the other side making it impossible to build anything quickly. Since ancient Greece, Rome, democracy has never succeeded. Democracy=rule by demons. Ask yourself , during the history of the US, when did people get to vote? in the 1960s? So they weren't democracies. UK was an imperialist who stole from their colonies, US used slaves to build their country . Their wealth came from stealing and robbing. Today, they can't rob anymore and it is showing all sorts of problems. India is not an imperialist country. Majority rule sounds romantic. However, mob rule are barbarian's way. If majority rule is correct. then We should just be barbarians , shouldn't we?
The truth is, the educated are the minority. When building a road, it is best to ask engineers, when governing a state , it is best to ask people with experience. Not pick rulers by popularity. For the past 50 years. China has already proven, even though it started later than India, the scientific way made China grow faster. So wake up! It is easy to look at someone wealthy and follow their ways. But what if the wealthy guy is a thief and got its riches by stealing? Now that it can't steal anymore, would he still be rich? Trust the Chinese way. China invented paper currency. Do you trust a thief or the nation who invented money? Capitalism is the reason why a nation is rich. Not democracy. "Tyranny naturally arise from Democracy, and extreme form of liberalism is the worst form of tyranny" -Plato . When people abuse freedom of speech, morality is lost and all you do is argue with trolls. A nation then falls.
+Truthseeker Agree on most of your points. China is bashed almost on a daily basis. I just let the haters enjoy themselves. The truth is they can do nothing else about China, so whining and feeling morally "superior" should be the compensation they deserve.
作为一个中国人，我对于你的看法十分不以为然。不是在说“民主与专制哪一个更促进社会经济的成长”，而是觉得这种讨论的本身就是错的。根据中国当代的思想家们所总结出来的“递弱代偿”思想逻辑，从不是说哪种制度会有更好的经济成长，而是恰恰相反，而是一种制度需要有与其相应的哪一种的经济状况才可以稳定运行。一些个成熟的发达国家之所以表现出十分发达的经济和文化，并不是因为他们的制度，他们的经济和文化才发达，而是因为他们想要持续一个稳定和有效率的现行制度，他们的经济和文化必须要发达才可以，否则就无以为继，这社会就会动荡。同样的，中国的经济之所以发展的很快，也是因为想要维持中国现状的一种稳定，就必须要有一个很快的经济发展状况才可以，作为执政的共产党想要他们的执政就必须努力下去，玩命的发展经济。如果达不到，就和许多的南美国家一样，政治动荡，经济不前。而印度不同的是，印度现在的制度对于经济发展的要求其实并没有中国所要求的那么高。而这个状况的产生有很多历史和文化的原因包括宗教方面的，这是和中国是显著不同的，这不全是民主的错。对了，对于我来说，两者之间经济发展速度的差别最关键因素，我想说的就是--欲望，因为印度人没有欲望，要是印度人有想要赚钱的欲望的话，早就站出来打碎它的这个国家的体制的僵固了。
台湾人总爱把经济的不前和正好赶上的民主化联系了起来，其实在于我来说这完全是巧合而已，真正的原因是，台湾的新的一代人失去了他们祖辈人的欲望，对于经济的发展来说，他们其实并没有更高的要求，只是在存量当中追逐什么正义的分配，玩起了政治，以为只有“正义”了才会有经济的长足发展。似乎也有道理，因为他们的眼中那些发达的都是“正义”的，他们看不不到的是“正义“的但不发达的都死翘翘或半死不活了。
所以说台湾省的经济不是说换一届政府，换一个政党就可以的，这在印度也一样，如果不焕发出民众对于经济的、对于钱的更多的欲望合追求，是没有任何办法解套的。这也是我认为中国最终会赢的原因，中国大陆太多的人，不论是有钱的、没钱的，他们的眼睛里面都充斥着欲望。
+Truthseeker Japan has somewhat grown very quickly even as a democracy. I as an Indian want to replicate that in India but looks hard and far fetched.
+Prakash Prateek oh yea? try to replicate Japan's Lost Decade, then more power to you. www.google.com.hk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwi6mpyN1ODMAhUCzoMKHeM-Av4QFggdMAE&url=%68%74%74%70%73%3a%2f%2f%65%6e%2e%77%69%6b%69%70%65%64%69%61%2e%6f%72%67%2f%77%69%6b%69%2f%4c%6f%73%74%5f%44%65%63%61%64%65%5f%28%4a%61%70%61%6e%29&usg=AFQjCNFa9AEOgCiSRKSfqAWeHDkGZgdrxg
Ah I know. But let me tell you my personal experience. I have lived in about 5 countries now so it does give me some right on this matter. Falling GDP is due to falling population which does not mean the quality of life is poor in Japan. And the quick growth thing still holds true because I am not talking about 1990s or 2000s. Americans usually feel bad about Japan but it should be the other way around. Japan's standard of living still much higher. Social Structure still remains. Education and health is way better and certainly better than any Asian nation, Singapore might compete in some ways. So its not all about falling GDP and falling populaiton. Yh it is not the same good Japan of 1980s but the situation is not as bad as we believe it to be.
China and India both have started their journeys together towards becoming a Sovereign country. But today China is much ahead than India in the field of GDP, Defense, sports and technology. We are having one plus point and that is " Our Democracy" but in other fields we have to learn many things from China.
Indian needs land reform and caste system reform.
R u frm mss
or laye ramrajiy ke program. selud abp news.....wha sochne ko majbur kar diya.....wha.....slam all the tim sir
A very beautiful and interesting presentation. After watching this it is not difficult to think why 'made in China' is seen everywhere. Indian businessmen purchasing cheap goods there for sale in India but good quality products are also available in the same market if the money spent is right. We can understand why many things from toys to machines to tools that are told to be not durable and without warranty at many shops. The shopkeepers say derisively that they are 'China made' and are totally unreliable. But people buy phones and computers of branded company, also made in China, and say they are classy.
right Bro!
बहुत सुंदर जानकारी भाई साहब आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद
शानदार कवरेज
हर भारतीय को देखना चाहिए
खास तौर पर सरकार को
Why These type of video can't streamed now ??
awesome episodes
very nice presentation
good stuff
Lesson for India - kaam karne se aage badte hain not english seekne se.
mudit jain nice brother
usefull information...........
Or banayena....sir.....ramrajiy. ....episode. ......thank you sir...wha....
Bullet train ki bat kar rahae ho
Mere district Arwal mae to local train bhi nahi chalti hai.
right
love ,respect, and brotherhood with china from india
Really great Show
Most knowledgeable "
ye aawaz to jani pehchani h but aapko pehli baar dekh rha hu achha lga
Radio par sunaa hoga
Kabhi nahin aa sakta
Nice...
Lagging at least 30 yrs
Because in india we have reservation law
and CHINA don't
The only difference
-don't- *doesn't* .
China has reservation for its tribal and rural population, research it buddy before commenting.
Wah china wah
Abp news ka gk kam hain
Great wall space se nhi dikhti
its not true that the great wall of china visible from space
Did you reach in space and you try to look the great wall of china?😂😂
yes， that's right
oh youre up. THis is goooood. We're gonna rob a bank
Sir eye sab dekhne se hume lagta ki hum yahan kyu janm liye
India needs at least 50 years to reach to the level of china in 2015. NO jokes..
SSMART Chinese workers are working 50000% harder than Indian workers..face the reality ...really no jokes..
***** YOU ARE POOR WITH NO TOILET. YOU ARE A FUCKING SMELLY INIDAN SHIT
SSMART 你真无聊
zhang lei what?
+SSMART you are SO NAIVE.
采访的这个人似乎是我大学国际政治选修课的教授，同济大学的。Small world indeed
中国两千多年前就实施车同轨书同文政策，这真是许多现代新国家正在做的事情。中国两千多年前就发出---王侯将相，宁有种乎？的呐喊，废除世袭贵族，种姓制度，这正是美国今天大谈特谈的美国梦和印度正要做的事情！中国两千多年前就废除分封制实行郡县制，防止地方政治割据主义和经济地方保护主义，这正是欧盟在做的事情！中国一千多年前就发明科举制度面向社会甄别选举贤能，连近代英国都学习借鉴，中国上台下台多少朝代，而现代当代许多国家才换个几个总统，中国几千年前就知道敬鬼神而远之，早就跳脱虚无缥缈没有现实意义的宗教意识形态，这比欧美国家政教分裂原则早千年，而伊斯兰世界更是奢谈，中国几千年前就发出狄入华则中华的文化立国原则，这比当代的一些民族国家以民族立国，教族国家以宗教立国更包容！一个文明没有经历上千年的辉煌和黑暗再到爆发的磨炼是没有生命力的，考验一个国家的内力不是在它最辉煌的时候能扩张多少，而是他最柔弱的时候能凝聚多少，否则蒙古帝国昙花一现，罗马帝国灰飞烟灭，大英帝国缩回英格兰，巨大苏联分崩离析。今天的美国如日中天，大家都来美国追寻未来，但如果美国某一天不在一枝独秀变得平庸我不知道还有多少人眷留
凭这段原创总结提炼的话，我可以当你导师吗？
We should change our political & education systems first.Then we can grow up.
Democracy katam karo freedom kam do
不是在说“民主与专制哪一个更促进社会经济的成长”，而是觉得这种讨论的本身就是错的。根据中国当代的思想家们所总结出来的“递弱代偿”思想逻辑，从不是说哪种制度会有更好的经济成长，而是恰恰相反，而是一种制度需要有与其相应的那一种的经济状况才可以稳定运行。
一些个成熟的发达国家之所以表现出十分发达的经济和文化并不是因为他们的制度他们的经济和文化才得以发达，而是因为他们想要持续一个稳定和有效率的现行制度，那他们的经济和文化就必须要发达才可以，否则就无以为继，这社会就会动荡。
同样的，中国的经济之所以发展的很快，也是因为想要维持中国现状的一种稳定，就必须要有一个很快的经济发展状况才可以，作为执政的共产党想要他们的政权稳定就必须要坚持不懈努力下去，玩命的发展经济。如果达不到，就和许多的南美国家一样，政治动荡，经济不前。
而印度不同的是，印度现在的制度对于经济发展的要求其实并没有中国对经济发展程度所要求的那么高。当然这个状况的产生有很多历史和文化的原因包括宗教方面的，这是和中国是显著不同的，这不全是民主的错。
所以，对于我来说，两者之间经济发展速度的差别最关键因素，我想说的就是--人的欲望，因为印度人没有欲望，要是印度人有想要赚钱的欲望的话，早就站出来打碎它的这个国家的体制的僵固了。
台湾人总爱把经济的不前和正好赶上的民主化联系了起来，其实在于我来说这完全是巧合而已，真正的原因是，台湾的新的一代人失去了他们祖辈人的欲望，对于经济的发展来说，他们其实并没有更高的要求，只是在存量当中追逐什么正义的分配，玩起了政治，以为只有“正义”了才会有经济的长足发展。似乎也有道理，因为他们的眼中那些发达的国家都是“正义”的，他们也看不到是“正义“的但不发达的都死翘翘了或半死不活了。
所以说台湾省的经济不是说换一届政府，换一个政党就可以的，这个在印度也一样，如果不焕发出民众自身对于经济的、对于钱的更多的欲望和追求，是没有任何办法解套现在的问题的。这也是我认为中国最终会赢的原因，中国大陆太多的人，不论是有钱的、没钱的，他们的眼睛里面都充斥着欲望。
+Eric Lee 不错的观点，我倾向于同意你的观点。同时我觉得欲望和幸福感有联系，在当下的中国幸福感来自于物质金钱，因为不堪过去贫瘠的物质生活。但我预测当物质生活满足了，即中国成为中等发达国家后，中国国民对物质的欲望会降低点。
***** 谢谢，中国成为发达国家，我也不知道我是应该期盼还是应该对这一天保持敬畏。
我觉得世界上有两种幸福感存在，第一种的幸福感来源“对比”；第二种的幸福来自“享受”（enjoy）。一个是与别人的互动，一个纯是自己的事情。
希望中国人更多的是为了“享受”而不是参与到盲目的“对比”中来得到自己的幸福感。
如果，喝拉菲的人是真的能喝出美妙的感觉才买的酒，看歌剧的人是真的喜欢它才买它价格不菲的票的。这同样是对物质的追求，就是更高的层次的追求。也是极好的变化。
我觉得，要追求这种变化，但千万不要降低对高端物质的要求，因为这才是社会发展的原始动力，而且，也只有物质上的充盈，才可以供给精神更茁壮的成长。
***** 你的意思是：只有保持一定的欲望，才是社会进步的动力。我觉得是有道理的。
+Tony G plz translate
你大爷的，见解独到深刻，可以认为你的见解是从文化角度，难得有人跳脱西方意识形态和中国自己迷思框架！我早就说过十年发展靠政策，百年发展靠科教，千年发展靠文化！中国文化系统下的人民勤劳，节俭，重视教育加上又没有宗教政治意识形态禁锢，只要没有政治动乱，作为世界上最实干的民族不崛起没有道理！
Laal salam
I love India
India ko grow karna hai to China ki tarah soch na ho ga modi government ko
China ke 1percent bhii nhii h india
Watching on 24 may 2024 tomorrow will be election in Delhi.....
India ke ghatiya netao kuchh to sharam karo...
This country is our enemy but I always feel jealous from china. LAL salaam
India has any common language used in all the country? It is heard they have 200+ languages, how do they communicate with each other?
Mostly by the help of Hindi (north India) and English (all over India).
Is north and south India write in the same way? or they could only use English to communicate?
Only English to communicate. Each language has their own scripts. As per my knowledge though China has two writing system, i.e. Traditional and Simplified but their dialect is different e.g. Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien etc But in Indian language e.g. Hindi, Bengali, Marathi, Gujrati, Tamil, Telugu has their own language as well as script. So major places it is written in both English and Hindi, two official languages of india.
Thanks for ur information. Are these language completely different even in grammar? Cuz although Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien etc pronounce differently, but they all share the same words and grammar. Is there any common between the languages in India?
Not that much different as the language family is same. Just like English, French, German etc are different but belongs to same family. Marathi, Hindi, Bhojpuri these couple of North Indian language which sounds similar and follow same script. अ आ इ ई... - This is the script they follow.
China politics ko nhi development infrastructures sudharne mein vishwas rakta hai aur ham hai ki politics mein samajvadi
there is also many things in which china should learn from india....chinese city is full of pollution...i think we r living better than that china...jai hind
just for fun hahahahahaha. .. Only stupid and idiot like you will feel that Chinese cities are polluted than Indian Cities. .... hahahaha. ... ass hole never visited China in there life and just barking what there media is telling ... pathatic. ...
Sorry but India happens to be one of the most polluted country, juast as China, though less industrialized than China.
China is not a totally ramarajya their is also poverty in China
indiyako chiana jaisa bananeke liy pahelaa yahaka dalal neta ko isolate karna padegi curuption ko jad se khatam karnaa padta hai british ne lade huy kaanun ko samapt karna chahiy sistem strong huna jaruri hai sab log me nationality hona chahiy jamin energy traspotation aur develope me kadaiki sath government ko nigarani hona sath hi loktantr ke nam par bikas birdhi party pablic ko tahe lagaya to chin ki 40% bikas barabar ho sakta hai.
...........
Ab to hamko dusare janam me ana padega kyuki India Ab asa desh nahi raha hai India me anth sradha bahoot hai
Kya malum bharat khud kab khada hoga hame bharat ko sudharna sahi neta chune varna gaya phir
Kon kon 2024 mai dekh raha hai
India is now in that position where china is in 1990
I love china .kash main china main peda hota
Modi ji sikh lo
right
China is a secular country.