Best Smart Scale - Withings Cardio, QardioBase, Xiaomi Mi Body Scale
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июл 2024
- Xiaomi Mi Body Scale: www.gearbest.com/body-scale/pp...
Withings Cardio US: amzn.to/2q2f6ay
Withings Cardio Int: amzn.to/2p1ZYLF
QardioBase US: amzn.to/2q2hqyk
QardioBase Int: amzn.to/2qbQr2j
I've selected my favourite scales to test out and find the best one, including Withings Cardio, QardioBase and the new Xiaomi Mi Body Scale. The benefits of quantifying yourself are clear and scales are probably one fo the oldest methods of doing that as it goes back to the 18th century. It helps one understand how well they're progressing towards the goal, i.e. lose weight, gain weight, change body composition, gain muscle, lose fat etc. Scales have involved a lot and show you much more than just weight, including fat, muscle, water, bone mass etc.
In this video:
00:00 Intro
01:40 User Experience
03:54 Measurements/Accuracy
06:37 App / Integration
08:06 Conclusion and recommendation
More info and all the results: ibelieveintechnology.com/best-...
Story/Camera/Editing: Sander Saar
Facebook: / ibelieveintech
Instagram: / ibelieveintechnology
Snapchat: / sander.saar
Twitter: / ibelieveintech
April 2017, London 
Наука
You should compare the three scales with one credible/high end/expensive/professional scale to see if the parameters and measurement are correct or not..comparing those three among themselves will not tell the accuracy of the measurement
Azwan Azli right, he measured precision, not accuracy
You are 100% correct.
Body composition cant accurately be measured through electrodes in a scale. Its a gimmick at best.
@@drkastenbrot It's not a gimmick, it is an estimated measurement like so many things.
terbaik la diva AA
You make such great comparisons! This has helped me so much in order to choose a scale!
uff you save me. I dont know why but you are the one who is clear giving information about the smart scales. Thanks, 1 more sub
thank you! very thorough. you've just helped me reach my conclusion for the smart scale.
I admire the effort you put in this review. Keep it up!
Thank you so much for this review and your honesty. I really appreciate that.
Great clip. Thanks dude. I just want an updated version of this 2019
what a great comparison video, really detail and right into the point
Good review! Very informative! I'm gonna get the xiaomi scale!
Damn, a very well made video with an excellent review. I'm going with Xiaomi.
I subbed as well because I was very impressed of your knowledge. Good stuff mate!! 👍
How is this comment relevant to this video
Thank you VERY MUCH for this awesome video!
Great video subbed!
However you could have cleared the air by taking an actual test of the said parameters to check the credibility of the scales
This is a great review bro. Nice that you compare the with actual weighing and touch on the subject of apple healthkit.
Good jobs dude. thank you for the detailed review with data. keep it up. love from India
Super helpful! Thank you!
Subscribed and liked, you have put in a lot of effort thanks for the review. Just one thing i would have liked in this video is a comparison between a medical grade bmi machine to these scales to know which scale was the closest
Great review.. Hard to find review for mi scale 2 out there..
Thanks for your review! It is very useful!!! I'm going to buy Xiaomi!
I was struggling between Xiaomi and Nokia, Very nice review, thanks for your work
Nice review! I'm gonna buy the Xiaomi Mi Sclae, thanks!
Excellent review, thanks!
Thank you Sander for the excellent review of the 3 smart scales in your video from April this year. Very helpful and helped me make up my mind on what scale I should purchase...I went for the Xiaomi Mi. ;)
So after 6 month what's your opinion on Xiaomi mi scale?
yeah tell
tell us please
Tel me? Hows it?
How did you like it?
What a great review. Subscribing!
Great comparison! Thanks for that!
Great review! Really nice job! :)
xiaomi for the win !
Please do an update on scales of 2019 and if you could please include the yunmai smart scale thanks
Great review. The xiaomi scale is on sale ao i was wondering if it's any good. Bought a digital scale some time ago and it's way too inconsistent.
Great Video and good Review!
excellent review. thank you
Beautiful review, great work, do other gadgets and electronics. You're a natural in staying objective!
Thank you so much for your video it helped me a lot!! I will buy a Xiaomi one, but the 2º version!
How is it now?
I just bought the Xiaomi one for 28 euros. Best bang for the buck. I don’t need the extra features offered by the super overpriced withings scale
great review! Thank you, sir.
Thank you :)
Now thats what I call a real review!!! Meticulous work!
Oh, BTW, is it true that Mi gets dirty really quick & is difficult to clean? Thx in adv.
i don’t know because i don’t have one but you can go with the socks to measure yourself but my problem is how good is xiaomi with apple for example many times my band disconnected automatically and is with bluetooth… so i guess is not good ……
What a great review! I was set on getting the withings, but now i am rethinking it. Maybe Xiami is the way to go
xiaomi is a chinese company. nothing against the people of china, but businesses in china are required to share the data they have with their government. the apps made by chinese developers harvest your data and report back to the CCP. even moreso now, as the US may be entering a cold war with china (or, according to some experts, we already have) you don't want this stuff on your phone or in your house.
What are you using now? I’ve got whitings and I love it.
excellent review 👍
Just bit on the xiaomi, hope it it's useful
Hey! Liked ur review! M about to buy one! But I need a confirmation on to how accurate mi scale is! Is the body fat percentage almost accurate to as u take in a dexa scan(which indicates your fat percentage)
Thanks for this amazing review! This helps a lot.
hey nice video! but i have one question. i know that you need the mi app to see your results, but do you need to have the app open during the measurement? thanks
Good video sir>>>very helpful.
excellent review. very dense. subscribed.
did you ever use weight scale from brand like Yolanda, yunmai? if yes how is it in comparison of mi?
Great review. Thanks for your effort.
Why you stopped making these? 🔥🔥
thanks for this excellent comparison review. Exactly as you said, consistency is the key. I've been looking at body fat scales for hours and all I wanted was 3 things: 1) consistent 2) easy to use app 3) price Xiaomi tics all these boxes. I considered getting a Xiaomi phone earlier this year, ultimately went for S8, but in researching phones I found Xiaomi to be a solid chinese tech company - so I know there will be no major issues with the app - they have the resources to make it work :)
Consistency without accuracy has no value! What's the point of consistency of the readings are not accurate? And since he did not compare the readings to an accurate reference we can not tell for sure which one is accurate, however I would assume that Withings Cardio is the more accurate since it is a company known better in the medical health sector.
@@yassersaeed2010 Actually, I've owned that scale a lot longer now, so if anyone happens to read this, it turned out to be rubbish. After a while I realised the "body fat measurements" where entirely bogus and based entirely on its BMI estimate. The scale also stopped working after about a year. I'm now using a Renpho scale and much happier both with it and its app.
@@jeremywright5036 are you talking about withings or xiaomi here?
@@veroxiq2424 Xiaomi. I was suckered into getting one. The scale itself stopped working but the app was useless long before that.
@@jeremywright5036 😭 i literally ordered one like 8 hours ago
Could you test the Qardio base 2? From what I've searched it's consider the best in some cases..
Nice elaborated good review brother .
Good review
It's pretty cheap here - for 41.99 USD with coupon code: XMSCALE
www.gearbest.com/body-scale/pp_615115.html?wid=21&lkid=10621913
Sweet
ruclips.net/video/yazXK259c0E/видео.html
Great very helpful
supprinsingly good review for an small channel.. you got an new subscr. here.. keep the info comming +1.
Very good overview. You seem to be a smart dude :-)
Thanks
Great review, clear and to the point
best review ever!
cool, help me make up my mind
thnx for the great review. I purchases the Xiaomi after I watched your video
Joey Nguyen please tell how is scale working , any problems , I will buy if you suggest
How is it ,
well done mate, nice review, i will buy the cheapest xiaomi scale, vfm! Thanx!
Thank
good review thanks. In China the xiaomi one costs merely $20.. at this price it's a nobrainer :)
Hola aun te funciona bien la bascula de xiomi ,los datos de peso general son confiables,y los de uso con la app seran confiables tambien.
Can you tell me if they were both accurate bodyfat? Like I feel that people say Xiaomi is not accurate enough, so now I'm willing to buy withings or rephon
This is a really good review, exactly what I was looking for.
BUT one thing that is missing, is a comparision to a professional scale. You can often find those in gyms and probably many different doctors.
I have the Mi Smart Scale 2, great value but I am not yet sure how well it compares to a professional device. When my gym opens back up after Corona I'll have values to compare it.
Did you compare them? May I know how is it?
@@dahliagunawan7942 sadly I was not yet back in the gym... 😅
@@janred94 And now?
and now?
did you make it to the gym?
Can you sync to Fitbit from Xiaomi though? I know you can with the Withings which for me as a Fitbit person is Important
How does it measure body composition just by stepping on it? Whats the methodology?
Isn't there a way to compare theses scales results with some professional equipment? I've always heard that electricity takes the shortest way, and the shortest way from one leg to the other is missing a lot of body parts...
do we have to manually enter our height in the app or does the machine find out when we step on it?
You have to manually add the height in the app (I have the Mi scale)
weel done
What about the honor scale 2?
bro Lenova is god or bad with heating because my friend buy Lenora mobile but that is so much heat
can i connect it to Garmin?
Hi, I just wanted to let you know that someone else has stolen this video and has posted it in their channel, along with many other stolen videos. I have already flagged it.
Collabo
with the xiaomi.. when you connect with Bluetooth.. does it download all your history?? seems a hassle to connect everytime.
Cool.. you just answered :).. it syncs cheers! great vid.
What is the use of your video if you can not which one is correct working correct.
You don't have to stand on the withings and wait for it to show all the data. I don't have the cardio model. But the body+ is done when it's done with the weight
And you can just change what data you want to see on the scale
Hello my name is Yadira We're cant I get one scale
the Xiaomi Mi is showing me my protein intake amount how the heck does it do that
Do you know you have just taken Blockhead's intro music, right?
Scales are from the 18th century?
Xiaomi Mi Scale 2... "Value for Money" (Y)
Nice vid. Would've been more helpful if you had gone and got your measurements taken by a dietician so we could have a target when comparing the devices accuracy
Seems like this guy works for Xiaomi
Compare it with Huawei Smart Scale
2021 update please
Tanita and Omron and Garmin is Accurate
I stood on the scales and it said i was 100% awesome.
The heart and pulse was removed with an update from the withings Cardio. Apparently it wasn't accurate enough anyway the cheaper body+ is a better buy.
Which scales removed it?
Can someone tell me if the display can be changed into lbs?
I have a Xiaomi scale and I can set it on imperial units through the mi fit app. Don't know about other two scales.
My xiaomi scale has 2 option - lbs and kgs
Even the non smart cheap body scale have those option...(well atleast the two i have different brands has them) so smart should have them.
Cool presentation to the product
But lot of information 😅
Well I Guess il just subtract 4% of BF% if I get the Xiaomi😆
Get a GARMIN scale. Forget the rest.
Great review. I just bought a Mi Body right now thanks to you (as I wanted to know about user experience instead of getting advice from someone technically less informed than I am: think CNet and others). I'm not into consumerism so I won't subscribe at this point. But please keep it up and don't deviate from being informative and agreeable!.
For my use this video is completely useless. Neither do I use Apple Health nor Google Fit Apps. Indeed the App environment is a very important point. But that's also very individual and you should devide it into scales for user groups (my idea).
Second there is indeed a medical correct scale for bone, fat, water and muscles percentage. Those very expensive scales use 4 points for measuring those percentages! All your three scales mesure only the lower part of the body and calculate then those percentages (fat, bones, water and muscles). That cannot be very percise! :P
For my use I'd need either the (too expensive) Garmin scale or (what I prefer) a cheaper scale where I add the body weight manually. However in a separate app I see all those (not percise details). As long as there is no standard that allows apps where you track your calories to add those scales (or your fitness app) this is the compromis I use!
Withings body + weight tracks ok. But! - fat, water, bone, muscle monitoring is inaccurate. Variations of 5 to 7 kgs daily is not even close to accurate. worst purchase in a very long time.
Xiaomi is terrible im male 5.10ft 36 years old fairly good shape the app says i have a BMI of 32% obese only have a tiny bit of puppy fat around belly and my ideal weight should be 115 pounds / 8.2 stone that sounds pretty dangerous. the hydration level always show dehydrated never changes protein too even when im bulking with high protein meals , and the app only works after i hold the power reset trick trash product.
Got a new one from Inevifit ruclips.net/video/eh7bYZG5kDY/видео.html looks good not sure if you can recommend
Whoa 14 % body fat, you should be six packs then....
Withings was spelled 'Withigns' in the beginning of the video. 😒
Haha sweetheart well said ❤️😃😃