I loved this movie as a child, and... I still do to this day as an adult. I miss Robin Williams. World's not the same without his amazing spirit and ability to truly move audiences, inspire people, and to entertain. RIP Robin. 2nd star to the right and straight on 'til morning. :/
This was definitely one of my top favorites as a kid. I've probably seen it hundreds of times by now. I always loved pirates so that was probably the main reason, lol, but Robin Williams was also awesome and it's just overall a fun movie. This move has a huge nostalgia factor for me now XD I still watch it at least once or twice a year.
...In all these years...All this time of Peter Pan being my favourite children's story...Hook being my favourite reimagining...I never knew...I never knew Phil Collins was the lead investigator in the case of the missing Banning children.
+Nezara Before the Honor thing though, he became the hip young American Dragon, who fell in love with a Dragon Hunter, which fueled the Zutara Ship in AtLA. Then participated in Antonio Bandera's experiment in teaching ghetto kids the passion of Ballroom Dancing. Then a mutated Mummy in Generator Rex. And finally becoming a General of the United Forces in Legend of Korra...who has a voice that sound too young for the age of the character.
+Nezara And then all the honor, all his hard earned glory got thrown away by one crazed lunatic when he created an insect based alien replica from his dark days as Rufio, creating the terrible, dishonorable, Rufioh, one of the many components of the largest trash community known to man.
"THE F*CKING WALLS ARE GASHED AND KIDS ARE MISSING. NEVER HIRE PHIL COLLINS TO DO INVESTIGATIVE WORK." That's my favorite CinemaSins line, ever, of all time.
Also: if the window opened and its implied the pirates came through it, why is the hallway stairs gashed? And Hook says "who stole into the other world and grabbed Pan's children": How, exactly?
3:43 Bits of dialogue imply Hook has been by at least once because he's the one that took Jack's baseball. But he's actually been coming to London and abducting random children from random houses because he actually has NO FRIGGING CLUE where to look for Peter Pan or his children. This is why, at the end of the movie, Maggie is locked in a room with a bunch of other children. They're the kids he abducted BEFORE he took Jack and Maggie, and they're the reason why Glen Close!Pirate was betting he'd never find them. Because he's been colossally screwing up at finding these people for possibly decades now.
Dante Basco characters always get a raw deal. Zuko had the whole backstory and honor thing, Rufio got stabbed for the sake of character development while wearing eyeliner, and Jake Long got canceled.
+CinemaSins the time on the watch was eight o'clock, but that clock was peter's, so it would most likely be on American time, meening that it was actualy much later. Remove that sin!
i always thought the most obvious sin of this movie was that if Peter was brought to Neverland as a baby, and people don't age in Neverland, how did he grow up to a 10 year old boy? did Tinkerbell get sick of taking care of a baby and bring him back to earth long enough for him to grow into a not-baby?
+Brian Griffin I swear he wasn't brought to Neverland as a baby. I remember that when he was 10, he ran away to...Maybe not Hyde's park, but to a famous park in London and Tinkerbell found him and picked him up. But your nitpick still stands; I think that's what happened with the Lost Boys, and it still doesn't make much sense. Rolling out the prams as babies, then filed under "lost" for a few days and sent to Neverland if no one claimed them.
+Goku x Sephiroth In the original novel The Little White Bird by J. M. Barrie where Peter makes his first appearance, there is no Neverland or Wendy Darling (the famous thimble kiss scene actually occurs between Peter and a girl named Maimie). He grows up among birds and fairies in the Kensington Gardens in London and an island in a lake called the Serpentine just outside the gardens after flying away from home. The story says that his ability to fly simply comes from his confidence in his ability to fly and that anyone could do it if they also believed (no fairy dust or happy thoughts needed). He is described as a "Betwixt-and-Between", see; not quite human and not quite bird (because all babies are birds before they are human in this story). During the entire timeline of the novel (which spans over several decades) Peter is a week old. Here is a quote about his age from the book: "Of course, it also shows that Peter is ever so old, but he is really always the same age, so that does not matter in the least. His age is one week, and though he was born so long ago he has never had a birthday, nor is there the slightest chance of his ever having one. The reason is that he escaped from being a human when he was seven days' old; he escaped by the window and flew back to the Kensington Gardens." Obviously this isn't what the play, the Disney film or this film is based on (apart from the thimble scene), but it is the only appearance of Peter Pan where his age is explicitly stated, although he is described as still having his baby teeth in the novelisation of the play.
Sam Loen Oh, nice! I didn't know about that novel. I just have a book of the same name- maybe it's a later release, or a re-write or something, even though it has JM Barrie's name on it. Well, I should really check out the Little White Bird, then. It's strange that that of all things slipped my radar- I usually adore all things Peter Pan. ...Except for this piece of shit movie. [Also, Kensington! I knew it was a famous London park! Why'd I think Hyde? Oh, well.]
It's never quite explained in the book or movies but I think it's something along the lines of you stop growing up when you want to. So as he grew up I guess he wanted to stop at 12
12:29 - Three moons wouldn't play hell with Neverland's gravity, but they WOULD make the cycle of tides rather complicated. Something that would be massively inconvenient for, say, anyone who owned a ship. No wonder Captain Hook's cranky all the time.
The narrator missed some. For instance, I remember when they were about to serve the imaginary food, Peter acted like he was smelling a wonderful aroma exciting his appetite. What was he smelling if there wasn't any food? He didn't learn to imagine the food yet, so his sense of smelling anything shouldn't have been affected.
+supercyberfunk Or just the general concept of is someone thinks they are hungry, the brain can actually produce the feeling of smelling or tasting something even though you aren't smelling or tasting it. Just like how you can mentally have the same feeling playing a song in your head, as listening to the song (of course with chances of errors due to gaps in the actual memory of the song)
Linkxsc Right, but when Peter first smells the "food", he can't see what the kids are doing; they are messing around in the kitchen and look like they are seriously prepping for dinner. This series of clips didn't show what I'm talking about. You'd have to go through and watch the movie.
supercyberfunk I vaguely recall someone shouting about dinner before that, but its been a good 5 years since I saw the movie (coincidentally, since my VHS tape player died) Point taken.
Nice. I got the chance to talk to some members of the swordplay choreographers that worked on Hook. They said Robin Williams was the best person they ever had to work with. The most skilled and picked things up the fastest. Told me the way to tell how good an actor is at sword fighting is how far away the camera shots are. The better they are, the farther away the camera. He also said Charlie Sheen was the worst they ever worked with, and he put two extras in the hospital making The Three Musketeers.
Just occured to me that Robin Williams is quite a hairy chested/armed fellow. That slingshot scene with the paint; he was waxed. That's dedication to a role. Kudos, Robin x
also in the novel fairies are actually very short-lived creatures...so by the end of the novel tinkerbell was already dead and peter didn't even remember tinkerbell when wendy asked about her
Did you know that at one point in the script when tinker bell was dying and Peter was clapping to save her it was going to ask the audience to clap and help save her. But Spielberg thought that it sounded weird so they took it out
+Han Solo Dies *no the movie sucked, i hated it even as a kid, its so horrid i found it pathetic, i'm sad that peter never get to bang wendy and had to opt for a ugly grand daughter, the pg13 ending was too much for me even as a kid and hoped hooks plan of brainwashing peters son would work. Also stabbing the asian? so racist*
its funny how no other kids got stabbed except rufio AND why is an adult stabbing a kid acceptable anyways?? its a pg13 movie? can't they wish him back to life or some shit??
+DirkAustin He never said they didn't. He just said that his love of the movie and honestly probably a heavy helping of nostalgia goggles means he is incapable of perceiving sins in the movie. And I could agree with that mostly. But at the same time whenever I think of this movie it is NOT of any point pre-neverland. :P
I just wanted to mention that a kid being tired or going to bed at 7:40 is not unreasonable when you factor in the time zone change from the flight and jet lag. So I'd count that as closer to a win than anything.
James Barrie didn't take the copyright to the bank; he gave it to the Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital, which is clearly supposed to be the same charity that honours Wendy at the dinner in the movie. Now you know how she raised so much money for them.
+T.A. Grant Even if that's true, their motto is "No movie is without sin". They LOVE Rise/Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and claimed The Incredibles to be sinless and the best Pixar movie. But not only did they manage to sin all three, but gave Toy Story, Finding Nemo, and WALL-E less sins then The Incredibles when that statement suggests that even if the "sinless" thing was false, The Incredibles should have had less sins. So yeah. They'll find something wrong in Coraline.
The 8 o'clock thing got me thinking (3:19). If they're in bed at ~20:00 and the streetlights are on when they arrive at the house then they probably landed around ~17:00 or so. Add an hour or so to get baggage and travel from Heathrow/Gatwick, maybe a bit more. A bit of time in the house, maybe some food, then an early bedtime. The thing is they flew from California - a 10 - 11 hour flight. So they'd have taken off at around 07:00 GMT. Factoring in the time difference that's 00:00 in San Francisco. Generally international flights don't go from San Francisco though - they go from LAX. That's either an hour and a half on a plane or a seven hour drive from San Francisco. Peter Banning doesn't strike me as the seven hour car ride with the wife and kids type of person so they probably flew. He probably worked a full day and then travelled, after all, he's a workaholic. So by the time they arrive in London the kids have at least been up since the middle of the night and then spent the whole day on a plane. I could have got my maths wrong, of course, but it feels about right. I'm amazed the adults are as awake and coherent as they are, frankly!
I have ALWAYS been impressed with Maggie smiths makeup AND her acting in this movie. When I was young I though she really was just an old lady , but then when Harry potter came out I was like gee I know that voice and now all these years later that they pretty much nailed EVERY wrinkle on her face ... amazing
#93 & #121 = In reference to the “Gene Hackman Superman Map”, the Pirates knew where the Lost Boys' camp was. Tinkerbell told Peter that Hook burned down Hangman's Tree some time after Peter's disappearance. The Lost Boys made a new camp around the tree. It was a very big camp. It overlooks the cove, with a clear view of the Jolly Rodger. The Captain knew exactly where the Lost Boys were. He didn't bother to kill them because Peter is the only person that he considered a worthy adversary. He had killed a few Lost Boys (and Indians), but annihilating the entire group would have left him and the pirates nothing to do. #115 = Although it is true that Peter did not fix a plate for himself, Rufio tossed a plate of food to Peter as he began to the insult battle. You could sin the lack of continuity of Rufio tossing a plate but Peter scooping from a bowl. However, you can't make a lack of food sin. You didn't get one over the movie. #136 = Sexualizing the relationship between Tinkerbell and Peter was not really the film's idea. I never read the original source material, but most presentations of the Peter Pan story has Tinkerbell with a huge crush on Peter. If Tinkerbell was attracted to Peter as a boy, then it only makes since that she'd be even more attracted to him as an adult. Plus you said in a later sin (#145) that Tinkerbell arrived “right at that moment to witness the dude she loves kiss someone else.” You know the common lore of Tinkerbell, so the romantic tension wasn't out of left field. By the way, Peter's sexual region would have been larger than Tinkerbell's region no matter what age he was. #148 & #149 = Peter cut off Rufio's belt to make the pants fall down in retaliation for Peter losing his pants during his earlier time with the Lost Boys. Peter didn't do that just to be “a dick.” The same thing for Peter hitting the Lost Boys with a ball and saying “Play.” He was teasing the Lost Boys as they teased him earlier. #159 = The movie explained the memory loss. As Maggie was being taken away, she yelled to Jack “Don't Forget! Neverland makes you forget!” Neverland magic is like the Force in Star Wars (if we ignore the midiclorian crap). There are no real rules to the magic. They're more like concepts and ideals instead of rules. Neverland is fueled by imagination. Children are much more in tune with their imaginations. That is why imaginary food can actually keep the Lost Boys nourished. Maggie believed in Neverland, but her feelings of her real home and family were strong and positive enough to protect her memory. She made sure to hold on to her past. Jack was angry and resentful. He was swayed by the charm of a father-figure that finally gave him attention, like a person being seduced by the Dark Side. He quickly forgot his true history. When Peter got his happy thought back, his decades suppressed Neverland-version was finally unleashed. Peter forgot his Banning-version, and was able to do all of the things that used to do: Fly, Fight, & Crow! When Peter kissed Tinkerbell, his mind reset itself. Real kisses are magical too. When Peter kissed young Moria, he forgot his Neverland-version. Long story shorter, Neverland can alter people's memories because... MAGIC! #165 = In reference as to why Maggie remembers her father, please review my previous explanation. #170 = Peter Banning didn't remember his Neverland-version. That is why the Lost Boys had to train him. That's had to re-learn his happy thought and to channel is imagination. Once his Neverland-version resurfaced, all of his talents and skills returned. Fly. FIGHT! Crow. It's on a similar line of many movie memory loss badasses, like American Ultra, Jackie Chan's Who Am I, and the Bourne franchise.
+Lance Snead "Long story shorter, Neverland can alter people's memories because... MAGIC!" ‘…and that’s why I don’t like magic, captain. ’Cos it’s magic. You can’t ask questions, it’s magic. It doesn’t explain anything, it’s magic. You don’t know where it comes from, it’s magic! That’s what I don’t like about magic, it does everything by magic!’
Robert William Hoskins. I have the DVD of Hook. I totally love that film. I also love Sweet Liberty, a cautionary tale about, be careful what you ask for, you might get it. LOL And don't forget poor Tootles. Arthur Malet (1927-2013), Dr. Fields Don S. Davis (I) (1942-2008) also in SG-1, Bill Jukes Tony Burton (I) (1937-2016), Growling Pirate Gary Epper (1944-2007), Woman Kissing on Bridge Carrie Fisher (1956-2016)
I remember back at my old school, we were putting a movie on. We had 3 choices, I didn't want to watch Hook but they put it on, I was moaning like a little brat and one of the teachers yelled at me and told me to quiet and watch the film. At first I thought it would suck but by the end of it, I ended up loving this movie!
The rip-off, if it is one, is the angel line in "It's A Wonderful Life", not the other way around. The original line was Barrie's, "Every time a child says 'I don't believe in fairies' there is a fairy somewhere that falls down dead". One of the few lines in "Hook" straight out of the original play.
4:15!!! He didn’t mention the lady that should have won an oscar for her performance in any scary movie! “THE CHILDREN ARE SCAR-REEMING THE CHILDREN ARE SCAR-REEMING!”
Actually, I think Return to Neverland is much better, only because that was the first version of a Peter Pan story, I ever heard of when I was younger. And, the other movie with Johnny Depp is just as good, if not better. It gives a certain beauty to it.
Me(an evil big brother), with my more than evil older cousin: used to stick my younger brother in a wicker chest, shut and lock the lid, and then proceed to kick it around, place it on it it's lid, make it hell in the chest, etc; and it was forever known as the "boo" box... (yup, kids can be horrible, but to this day my little brother is my best friend, and we have forgiven all the transgressions against each other.
@@Rickrolled88 I did worse. My brother threw a comb at me since I needed it to comb my hair in the morning before school. It hit me in the head and I got super pissed. I took a belt and hit him with the metal end and it put holes in his legs. Felt bad about it ever since. Use to have a really bad temper when I was little. We forgave each other though.
Rickey Roll my sister had been insulting me all morning and then kicked me in the nuts after I shouted at her, so later that day while she was walking around our grandparents ranch I sniped her with my bb gun, my parents didn’t accept my excuse and were pissed
Damn, History Man. If they’d known I hope they’d have understood a bit more. I’d rather get pelted with BB’s than nailed in the balls, and I don’t even have any. All’s fair in love and war, and between siblings.
4:11 - Hook's hook is on his left hand. So if he broke in downstairs and walked up to get to the kids, he must have awkwardly held his left hand across his body to make that gouge. 5:24 - Tinkerbell assassinates a fairy. 9:17 - Smee uses British version of "assf*ckers" that gets by US ratings board.
+masterYoshimistsu This one had a lot of sins for being similar to things that came out /after/ it (or came out after Peter Pan for some sins that referenced the book), which bugged the hell out of me.
Every time someone says "Every time someone says "I don't believe in fairies", a fairy dies", a fairy dies. Because they said that "I don't believe in fairies" as well, meaning they just killed a fairy, like the person before them.
George Hamilton Look at 5mart2n's comment, specifically the quote. You cannot use double quotation marks inside a quote that uses double quotation marks. He has to replace the double quotation marks inside the quote with single quotation marks. On another note, I took Advanced Placement (AP) Language and Composition and got a five out of five in the College Board AP test. In simpler words, I know my shit when it comes to English grammar (and Spanish grammar).
I love how the narrator says that Tinkerbell crashing around the children's room should have woken everyone up since the children were recently kidnapped but then as SOON as Tink leaves to take Peter to Neverland we immediately see Tootles in the window watching them even though he had not been there until that point and he didn't bother to come to Peter's aid or alert the rest of the family that a ball of bright light was kidnapping him out the window. lol.
I don't know, I feel like the sin count on this one is a touch unfair. You seem to assume that whole "this is all in Peter's head" thing, and assign sins based on it. At the end you acknowledge that the movie itself directly establishes everything in Neverland ACTUALLY HAPPENED, so why the sins based on it being a dream?
HistoryBuff117 I hate to sound argumentative, but there's a reason there's a counter in the upper left. Sometimes he does note things that aren't sins, but for example, he pointed out that IF this was a dream, he was seriously egotistical for Rufio wanting a dad like him AND Jack apologizing at basically the same moment. That was a sin, it was dinged, it was counted. BUT, it wasn't a dream, that really happened in the plot. So, I don't feel like that should have been a sin. I get your GENERAL point, that the sin counter doesn't mean good movie or bad movie, but I can say I've watched these videos having not seen movies and going "Wow, that seems pretty bad."
***** What i meant was in an episode of talking to himself (cant remember which one) he explained the sins have no value and are just things he notes down while watching. Je likes alot of the movies he sins. Also remember 'Were not critics, were assholes - Cinemasins
+HistoryBuff117 Yeah, you can say that, but I don't even think he'd deny that people do assign value to them. And since there's a clear difference between a sin and an observation (whether the counter goes up 1 or more and ding), I just didn't feel like some of the sins were fair. Don't worry, not losing any sleep over it, just observing.
***** Yeah no problems, I just see him as a nitpicker and never question any sin, since they're basically his own opinon on the matter. But whatever each to his/her own
I'm surprised there was no Cinema Sin mentioning how Hook actually knew the exact location of Granny Wendy's house, and how he got up to the window to begin with. And, Phil Collins was actually in "Hook?" WHOA!
+Rawk4Life Re: Phil Collins -- ikr? Guess that proves how good his makeup job was... ...wait for it... *...so take a look at him noo-ooow!* (Note to CS -- you started this with the "Against All Odds"-reference. :) :) :) LOL...)
"I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, Can you feel him comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord... Well if Gran told Peter he was drowning, Hook would not lend a hand But the 'gator came and bit it off, but I don't know if Hook has PTSD Well Peter was there and he rescued his kids, Hook thereon swore revenge So Disney can shove off that shit, we know this is the hit, Credibility has been avenged "I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord Well Peter saved them, you remember, how could you ever forget It's the first time, that Disney ever told the story But I know the reason why Steven Spielberg's is good, oh no Walt don't fool me Well the redface doesn't show, but the pain still grows Stereotypes' no stranger to you and me I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord, oh lord I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord..."
So am I the only one that thinks it's a bit predatory-ish of Tink to have wanted to kiss the child she apparently kidnapped? Saved? Adopted? Coz the whole thing about Tink is that she's in love with Peter. If in Hook she's his caregiver then isn't that a bit... 🥴😬 Still love the film lol
2:05 Take in account Harry Potter's books locates its temporal space between 1991 and 1997. Thus we can conclude that's Minerva McGonagall's masquerade as "muggle" and she and Wendy are the same person.
I usually agree with you but Smee's line "I've just had an apostrophe" and Hook's reply "You mean 'epiphany' Smee; you've had an epiphany" deserves TWO sins off! I often quote that to my wife, and after 16 years, we are still married and I am not stabbed in my sleep.
Something very few people know about this movie is that Gutless the Pirate who sells out Hook and gets put in the Boo Box with the scorpions is, and i shit you not, Glenn Close. That is one serious make-up team...
+Jimmysauce109 Not many people also know that when Tink is flying Peter to Neverland, the couple that fairy dust hits is George Lucas and Carrie Fisher.
No this movie is trash. I hate it and I prefer all of the other versions of Peter Pan. Most and Least favorite versions of Peter Pan: Peter Pan Disney=amazing, Peter Pan broadway=awesome, Peter Pan 2003=interesting, Peter Pan Live =brilliant, and Hook=boring trash.
No this movie is trash. I hate it and I prefer all of the other versions of Peter Pan. Most and Least favorite versions of Peter Pan: Peter Pan Disney=amazing, Peter Pan broadway=awesome, Peter Pan 2003=interesting, Peter Pan Live =brilliant, and Hook=boring trash.
James Hook is a great character. Him and his crew were marooned on an island where lord of the flies children, taunted him, dismembered him, and he lived in immortality, as an old man. What a cruel fate for James Hook.
+Rowan J Coleman Wow someone on the internet owing up to a mistake? You didn't even try for the "lol you fell for it guys" excuse. Well played my good sir.
+DanceGameGuy Actually, I always loved that. Disney ran a tv show called Adventures in Wonderland around that time and I always enjoyed the video for Don't Come Around Here No More all the more because Alice got eaten XD
csgrambauer The point of it is to show some of its flaws (albeit also making fun of the times it was in). Like that flashback scene of Peter's origin story, one big plot hole made up of smaller ones.
+Jake Seager whats interesting about the boo box scene is that the pirate in that scene isn't a man but a woman its glen close that woman who was Cruella'de'vil in the 101 Dalmatians live action movie plus the couple kissing on the bridge were George lucas and carrie fisher.
How about a sin for the parents' blatent disregard when the kids mention some creepy man hanging l, stealing baseballs. Oh thats right, if they were responsible parents, this movie wouldnt happen... nevermind.
and Peter should have suspected something cause it's mentioned that their own house has bars on his window, so some kind of instinct was telling him to be weary and all of a sudden nothing.
What no sin for what the heck happened to hook. Oh come om!!!!!!!!! Even as a five year old I remember asking my parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles what happened when ever I watched the film and that scene played.
I had a VCR of this a movie (yes a VCR) when I was 6 and I remember exactly zero of it. Now I re-watch it and it seems like I am watching an entirely different movie. Thanks brain.
I had this movie on VHS and I absolutely hated it. I thought that it was stinky boring trash. I smashed my VHS tape of this movie. Peter Pan Disney-Amazing Peter Pan 2003=Wonderful Peter Pan Broadway with Cathy Rigby and Mary Martin=Brilliant Peter Pan Live with Christopher Walken=Exciting Pan 2015=Also Exciting Hook= Stinky Boring Trash
Is Maggie Smith frozen in time or something? This film came out 14 years ago and she looks the same now, in fact she looks younger today than she did back then.
Here's a list. Everything wrong with: SYNC A Trip To The Moon (1902) Silence of The Lambs Parallels Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005) Fringe S1, E1: Pilot Birdemic: Shock and Terror Back to The Future 1 Back to The Future 2 And Zathura
I feel like the movie would have been better off if they used American Football as Jack's sports. Then they could use a little joke about Tempa Bay Bucaneers or Oakland Raiders.
No I'm pretty sure planned with Stuckmann. This Is like 10 movie sins where Chris did a review right before it. They even did the mission impossibles around the same time
I loved this movie as a child, and... I still do to this day as an adult.
I miss Robin Williams. World's not the same without his amazing spirit and ability to truly move audiences, inspire people, and to entertain.
RIP Robin. 2nd star to the right and straight on 'til morning. :/
This was definitely one of my top favorites as a kid. I've probably seen it hundreds of times by now. I always loved pirates so that was probably the main reason, lol, but Robin Williams was also awesome and it's just overall a fun movie. This move has a huge nostalgia factor for me now XD I still watch it at least once or twice a year.
bangarang
Novastar (SaberCombat)
Don't forget about Bob Hoskins!
Novastar (SaberCombat) "The world is still the same. There's just less in it." ~Captain Jack Sparrow.
'How does this help me get my kids back?'
'It doesn't, shut up.'
LMFAO
Hook is one of my all time favorite movies. I still love you, Hook, sins and all.
+Heather Feather ASMR Ah funny, I just finished this video and am on my way to your channel to relax and go to sleep, irony :)
+Heather Feather ASMR Agreed!!!
+Heather Feather ASMR The sins are silly and petty, only a few of them were actually mildly annoying, little alone a big deal.
+Heather Feather ASMR Totally agree. This movie is my childhood. I watched it like a billion times. Good old times.
+Heather Feather ASMR If you're a 90's child then u love this money simple as that
...In all these years...All this time of Peter Pan being my favourite children's story...Hook being my favourite reimagining...I never knew...I never knew Phil Collins was the lead investigator in the case of the missing Banning children.
Kou Izumi And Glenn Close plays the pirate sent to the Boo Box.
Kou Izumi And George Lucas and Carrie Fisher play the flying kissing couple during the fly to Neverland scene. Not kidding by the way.
And Gwynneth Paltrow is young Wendy :)
@@mattcyr2022 That's a theory, there are no facts to prove it. Same with Lewis Carroll.
Also David Crosby is a pirate.
And after this movie, Rufio never tolerated shit from people ever again....he also became very obsessed with honour.
+Nezara Before the Honor thing though, he became the hip young American Dragon, who fell in love with a Dragon Hunter, which fueled the Zutara Ship in AtLA. Then participated in Antonio Bandera's experiment in teaching ghetto kids the passion of Ballroom Dancing. Then a mutated Mummy in Generator Rex. And finally becoming a General of the United Forces in Legend of Korra...who has a voice that sound too young for the age of the character.
+Nezara He had to regain the honor he lost filming in this movie by capturing the Avatar.
+Nezara And then all the honor, all his hard earned glory got thrown away by one crazed lunatic when he created an insect based alien replica from his dark days as Rufio, creating the terrible, dishonorable, Rufioh, one of the many components of the largest trash community known to man.
+J. Louie Dinorog He was also Pinball in Blood and Bone.
+J. Louie Dinorog
*claps* Magnificent..... Magnificent
This video REALLY makes me miss Robin Williams.
+TheRaellz no need to be angry, this video made me miss Robin too
+TheRaellz Maybe it didn't take much. I get a lump in my throat just when I see him or people mention his name.
I watched jumanji yesterday
that did to
And Bob Hoskins
+SkulShurtugalTCG Hey I know you. from the pokemon movie sins videos :)
"THE F*CKING WALLS ARE GASHED AND KIDS ARE MISSING. NEVER HIRE PHIL COLLINS TO DO INVESTIGATIVE WORK." That's my favorite CinemaSins line, ever, of all time.
Did Wash tell you that?
Hire Sting. Obviously.
I like that he said that Phil Collins solving this case is "against all odds" 🤣
Also: if the window opened and its implied the pirates came through it, why is the hallway stairs gashed? And Hook says "who stole into the other world and grabbed Pan's children": How, exactly?
3:43 Bits of dialogue imply Hook has been by at least once because he's the one that took Jack's baseball. But he's actually been coming to London and abducting random children from random houses because he actually has NO FRIGGING CLUE where to look for Peter Pan or his children. This is why, at the end of the movie, Maggie is locked in a room with a bunch of other children. They're the kids he abducted BEFORE he took Jack and Maggie, and they're the reason why Glen Close!Pirate was betting he'd never find them. Because he's been colossally screwing up at finding these people for possibly decades now.
Hmm. Interesting
Makes so much freaking sense when you put it like that
MorriganAtwood, the REAL FilmTheorist
PAN(2015) is drastically different from the usual Peter Pan movies, but it explains the kidnapping point.
Well, his sister mentions she like caught him doing it too
Rufio really got a raw deal.
FIRST. dont kill me.
+CinemaSins You mean Zuko?
Is everything thing wrong avengers she of ultron coming soon?
Dante Basco characters always get a raw deal.
Zuko had the whole backstory and honor thing, Rufio got stabbed for the sake of character development while wearing eyeliner, and Jake Long got canceled.
+CinemaSins the time on the watch was eight o'clock, but that clock was peter's, so it would most likely be on American time, meening that it was actualy much later. Remove that sin!
i always thought the most obvious sin of this movie was that if Peter was brought to Neverland as a baby, and people don't age in Neverland, how did he grow up to a 10 year old boy? did Tinkerbell get sick of taking care of a baby and bring him back to earth long enough for him to grow into a not-baby?
+Brian Griffin I swear he wasn't brought to Neverland as a baby. I remember that when he was 10, he ran away to...Maybe not Hyde's park, but to a famous park in London and Tinkerbell found him and picked him up. But your nitpick still stands; I think that's what happened with the Lost Boys, and it still doesn't make much sense. Rolling out the prams as babies, then filed under "lost" for a few days and sent to Neverland if no one claimed them.
+Goku x Sephiroth In the original novel The Little White Bird by J. M. Barrie where Peter makes his first appearance, there is no Neverland or Wendy Darling (the famous thimble kiss scene actually occurs between Peter and a girl named Maimie). He grows up among birds and fairies in the Kensington Gardens in London and an island in a lake called the Serpentine just outside the gardens after flying away from home. The story says that his ability to fly simply comes from his confidence in his ability to fly and that anyone could do it if they also believed (no fairy dust or happy thoughts needed). He is described as a "Betwixt-and-Between", see; not quite human and not quite bird (because all babies are birds before they are human in this story). During the entire timeline of the novel (which spans over several decades) Peter is a week old. Here is a quote about his age from the book:
"Of course, it also shows that Peter is ever so old, but he is really always the same age, so that does not matter in the least. His age is one week, and though he was born so long ago he has never had a birthday, nor is there the slightest chance of his ever having one. The reason is that he escaped from being a human when he was seven days' old; he escaped by the window and flew back to the Kensington Gardens."
Obviously this isn't what the play, the Disney film or this film is based on (apart from the thimble scene), but it is the only appearance of Peter Pan where his age is explicitly stated, although he is described as still having his baby teeth in the novelisation of the play.
Sam Loen Oh, nice! I didn't know about that novel. I just have a book of the same name- maybe it's a later release, or a re-write or something, even though it has JM Barrie's name on it. Well, I should really check out the Little White Bird, then. It's strange that that of all things slipped my radar- I usually adore all things Peter Pan.
...Except for this piece of shit movie.
[Also, Kensington! I knew it was a famous London park! Why'd I think Hyde? Oh, well.]
It's never quite explained in the book or movies but I think it's something along the lines of you stop growing up when you want to. So as he grew up I guess he wanted to stop at 12
+Goku x Sephiroth The Little White Bird was in fact written by J.M. Barrie. It doesn't just have his name on it.
Hook gets sinned for having harry potter parallels? Isn't that a sin for harry?
you're right
+Jesse Pinkman But the books don't matter
+Aidan Bolton >taking an obvious joke sin seriously
Not really becuase this came first,meaning he basically reused the same score for two different movies
You think people can just come on the internet and make jokes? You are sorely mistaken.
12:29 - Three moons wouldn't play hell with Neverland's gravity, but they WOULD make the cycle of tides rather complicated. Something that would be massively inconvenient for, say, anyone who owned a ship. No wonder Captain Hook's cranky all the time.
It only has two. Because the one people think is a third moon is the sun setting on the horizon. Xx
weren't those moon cresent moons just the scene before?
The narrator missed some. For instance, I remember when they were about to serve the imaginary food, Peter acted like he was smelling a wonderful aroma exciting his appetite. What was he smelling if there wasn't any food? He didn't learn to imagine the food yet, so his sense of smelling anything shouldn't have been affected.
+supercyberfunk
Or just the general concept of is someone thinks they are hungry, the brain can actually produce the feeling of smelling or tasting something even though you aren't smelling or tasting it. Just like how you can mentally have the same feeling playing a song in your head, as listening to the song (of course with chances of errors due to gaps in the actual memory of the song)
Linkxsc Right, but when Peter first smells the "food", he can't see what the kids are doing; they are messing around in the kitchen and look like they are seriously prepping for dinner. This series of clips didn't show what I'm talking about. You'd have to go through and watch the movie.
supercyberfunk
I vaguely recall someone shouting about dinner before that, but its been a good 5 years since I saw the movie (coincidentally, since my VHS tape player died)
Point taken.
+iamihop Or, someone farted.
+supercyberfunk this is correct, but the placebo effect is a possibility.
That reference to " Dead Poet's Society" in the final video edit was perfect!RIP Robin...
Fun fact: my aunt actually helped design a lot of the costumes in this movie! (I am aware most of you do not care)
Olivia Willis I do.
That's cool!
Nice. I got the chance to talk to some members of the swordplay choreographers that worked on Hook. They said Robin Williams was the best person they ever had to work with. The most skilled and picked things up the fastest. Told me the way to tell how good an actor is at sword fighting is how far away the camera shots are. The better they are, the farther away the camera. He also said Charlie Sheen was the worst they ever worked with, and he put two extras in the hospital making The Three Musketeers.
Samuel Vincent
Lol...way to go, tiger blood man.
That's really cool!
Just occured to me that Robin Williams is quite a hairy chested/armed fellow. That slingshot scene with the paint; he was waxed. That's dedication to a role. Kudos, Robin x
Why did Tinkerbell plop Peter right in the fucking middle of a pirate dock!? Did she think immediate and gristly death would jog his memory?
+IggyTthunders sink or swim, bitch.
+IggyTthunders You might not be aware, but faeries are vindictive and fickle little bitches.
Dylan Staats Oh, I forgot.
+IggyTthunders "I thought fairies were supposed to do nice things - like granting wishes." - Sarah
"Well, shows what you know, don't it?" - Hoggle
*****
It's just called "Labyrinth" here in the U.S. :)
Ok. That last outtake had me laughing and crying at the same time.
Curse you, CinemaSins!
+Rahsaan Footman YESSSSSSSSSSSSS
"Sit down! I said sit down, all of you!" XDXDXD
Jack smashed the clocks since Peter always had time for work but not for him
And since Hook is afraid of clocks, I don't think he wanted to do it himself.
Fairies dying when someone says they don't believe in them was a thing in the original story.
Damn, that's dark
also in the novel fairies are actually very short-lived creatures...so by the end of the novel tinkerbell was already dead and peter didn't even remember tinkerbell when wendy asked about her
Did you know that at one point in the script when tinker bell was dying and Peter was clapping to save her it was going to ask the audience to clap and help save her. But Spielberg thought that it sounded weird so they took it out
Damn, all this Robin Williams stuff is hitting me hard, CinemaSins #OCaptainMyCaptain
+FaZe Gentoes smooth bro
The Bandog
So? The picture still has big boobs. I don't care if it's a dude with a dick, still nice boobs and eyes
+Hannah Ward i feel you, that last bit really got me. dammit cinemasins!
deer
Excuse me, this thread is dedicated solely to comment on her physical appearance. Please take your valid points elsewhere, Thank you
+FaZe Gentoes Perv.
it has its flaws, but i still love the shit out of this movie. lol
+Han Solo Dies It's a sarcastic comedy channel....
+Han Solo Dies NO movie is without sin. No matter how great a movie is, there WILL be sins.
+rockbass It's Robin Williams and Dustin Hoffman, you can never go wrong with them
+Han Solo Dies *no the movie sucked, i hated it even as a kid, its so horrid i found it pathetic, i'm sad that peter never get to bang wendy and had to opt for a ugly grand daughter, the pg13 ending was too much for me even as a kid and hoped hooks plan of brainwashing peters son would work. Also stabbing the asian? so racist*
its funny how no other kids got stabbed except rufio AND why is an adult stabbing a kid acceptable anyways?? its a pg13 movie? can't they wish him back to life or some shit??
I love this movie too much I am blinded to its sins! :)
+Ellthom Not another one. They love the movie, thats why the sinned it.
+DirkAustin He never said they didn't. He just said that his love of the movie and honestly probably a heavy helping of nostalgia goggles means he is incapable of perceiving sins in the movie. And I could agree with that mostly. But at the same time whenever I think of this movie it is NOT of any point pre-neverland. :P
***** Well, i nit pick movies as much as they do maybe even more, thats what makes them even more fun to watch after the 50th time. :P
Lol
+Ellthom same here ,. i cant even look at the entire story in a objective manner, i am just too drawn in by every individual scene
I was VERY hesitant to watch this ... Hook is absolutely one of my favorite childhood memories
8:46
Okay but-
This kid melts my heart everytime I watch this
Rosemary Fire ME TOO!! This scene makes me cry as an adult, that kid and Robin Willams are so moving and the flute music is perfection ❤️
I remember thinking as a kid that food spread was so epic.
Omg! Me too! I L0VE the food scene
I just wanted to mention that a kid being tired or going to bed at 7:40 is not unreasonable when you factor in the time zone change from the flight and jet lag. So I'd count that as closer to a win than anything.
Yeah but was that pocket watch even synched to England time?
@@sundeepkuntimad5339 It was dark outside so unless the UK has sunset at 3:40, probably
2:40 actually. On EST the most favorable timezone
James Barrie didn't take the copyright to the bank; he gave it to the Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital, which is clearly supposed to be the same charity that honours Wendy at the dinner in the movie. Now you know how she raised so much money for them.
Easter egg
The boo box scene was fucking terrifying when i was a kid. It like emotionally scarred me
+rbradt1 If it makes you feel better: Scorpions aren't actually that dangerous...being in a box like that would still be a bummer though
+personM4N Claustrophobia is a bitch tho .-.
Rom Kin Oh...yeah...seemed like a pretty warm day too :-\
It was the scorpions that terrified me lol
+rbradt1 I think the scorpion got the raw deal considering that any movement from the human 5000x it's size would squash it.
Everything wrong with Coraline or Paranorman please! I love these movies!
+Jane Doe there is NOTHING wrong with Coraline. I saw it 7 times in theatre. Truth.
+T.A. Grant i always thought it was a bad movie watched it it was eh
+T.A. Grant Even if that's true, their motto is "No movie is without sin". They LOVE Rise/Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and claimed The Incredibles to be sinless and the best Pixar movie. But not only did they manage to sin all three, but gave Toy Story, Finding Nemo, and WALL-E less sins then The Incredibles when that statement suggests that even if the "sinless" thing was false, The Incredibles should have had less sins. So yeah. They'll find something wrong in Coraline.
ParaNorman in honor of Halloween would be awesome.
uhhh yeh, i was being facetious...
The 8 o'clock thing got me thinking (3:19). If they're in bed at ~20:00 and the streetlights are on when they arrive at the house then they probably landed around ~17:00 or so. Add an hour or so to get baggage and travel from Heathrow/Gatwick, maybe a bit more. A bit of time in the house, maybe some food, then an early bedtime.
The thing is they flew from California - a 10 - 11 hour flight. So they'd have taken off at around 07:00 GMT. Factoring in the time difference that's 00:00 in San Francisco. Generally international flights don't go from San Francisco though - they go from LAX. That's either an hour and a half on a plane or a seven hour drive from San Francisco.
Peter Banning doesn't strike me as the seven hour car ride with the wife and kids type of person so they probably flew. He probably worked a full day and then travelled, after all, he's a workaholic. So by the time they arrive in London the kids have at least been up since the middle of the night and then spent the whole day on a plane.
I could have got my maths wrong, of course, but it feels about right. I'm amazed the adults are as awake and coherent as they are, frankly!
I have ALWAYS been impressed with Maggie smiths makeup AND her acting in this movie. When I was young I though she really was just an old lady , but then when Harry potter came out I was like gee I know that voice and now all these years later that they pretty much nailed EVERY wrinkle on her face ... amazing
#93 & #121 = In reference to the “Gene Hackman Superman Map”, the Pirates knew where the Lost Boys' camp was. Tinkerbell told Peter that Hook burned down Hangman's Tree some time after Peter's disappearance. The Lost Boys made a new camp around the tree. It was a very big camp. It overlooks the cove, with a clear view of the Jolly Rodger. The Captain knew exactly where the Lost Boys were. He didn't bother to kill them because Peter is the only person that he considered a worthy adversary. He had killed a few Lost Boys (and Indians), but annihilating the entire group would have left him and the pirates nothing to do.
#115 = Although it is true that Peter did not fix a plate for himself, Rufio tossed a plate of food to Peter as he began to the insult battle. You could sin the lack of continuity of Rufio tossing a plate but Peter scooping from a bowl. However, you can't make a lack of food sin. You didn't get one over the movie.
#136 = Sexualizing the relationship between Tinkerbell and Peter was not really the film's idea. I never read the original source material, but most presentations of the Peter Pan story has Tinkerbell with a huge crush on Peter. If Tinkerbell was attracted to Peter as a boy, then it only makes since that she'd be even more attracted to him as an adult. Plus you said in a later sin (#145) that Tinkerbell arrived “right at that moment to witness the dude she loves kiss someone else.” You know the common lore of Tinkerbell, so the romantic tension wasn't out of left field. By the way, Peter's sexual region would have been larger than Tinkerbell's region no matter what age he was.
#148 & #149 = Peter cut off Rufio's belt to make the pants fall down in retaliation for Peter losing his pants during his earlier time with the Lost Boys. Peter didn't do that just to be “a dick.” The same thing for Peter hitting the Lost Boys with a ball and saying “Play.” He was teasing the Lost Boys as they teased him earlier.
#159 = The movie explained the memory loss. As Maggie was being taken away, she yelled to Jack “Don't Forget! Neverland makes you forget!” Neverland magic is like the Force in Star Wars (if we ignore the midiclorian crap). There are no real rules to the magic. They're more like concepts and ideals instead of rules. Neverland is fueled by imagination. Children are much more in tune with their imaginations. That is why imaginary food can actually keep the Lost Boys nourished. Maggie believed in Neverland, but her feelings of her real home and family were strong and positive enough to protect her memory. She made sure to hold on to her past. Jack was angry and resentful. He was swayed by the charm of a father-figure that finally gave him attention, like a person being seduced by the Dark Side. He quickly forgot his true history. When Peter got his happy thought back, his decades suppressed Neverland-version was finally unleashed. Peter forgot his Banning-version, and was able to do all of the things that used to do: Fly, Fight, & Crow! When Peter kissed Tinkerbell, his mind reset itself. Real kisses are magical too. When Peter kissed young Moria, he forgot his Neverland-version. Long story shorter, Neverland can alter people's memories because... MAGIC!
#165 = In reference as to why Maggie remembers her father, please review my previous explanation.
#170 = Peter Banning didn't remember his Neverland-version. That is why the Lost Boys had to train him. That's had to re-learn his happy thought and to channel is imagination. Once his Neverland-version resurfaced, all of his talents and skills returned. Fly. FIGHT! Crow. It's on a similar line of many movie memory loss badasses, like American Ultra, Jackie Chan's Who Am I, and the Bourne franchise.
that was awesome.
+Lance Snead "Long story shorter, Neverland can alter people's memories because... MAGIC!"
‘…and that’s why I don’t like magic, captain. ’Cos it’s magic. You can’t ask questions, it’s magic. It doesn’t explain anything, it’s magic. You don’t know where it comes from, it’s magic! That’s what I don’t like about magic, it does everything by magic!’
+RaptorNX01 Magic is a mcgcuffin... deal with it.
+Larry Jake it was a quote....
RaptorNX01 I know my precious possession...I know
R.I.P. Robin Williams
you will be missed!
Don't forget Bob Hoskin's!
I forgot Bob was in this.
Robert William Hoskins. I have the DVD of Hook. I totally love that film. I also love Sweet Liberty, a cautionary tale about, be careful what you ask for, you might get it. LOL
And don't forget poor Tootles. Arthur Malet (1927-2013), Dr. Fields Don S. Davis (I) (1942-2008) also in SG-1,
Bill Jukes Tony Burton (I) (1937-2016), Growling Pirate Gary Epper (1944-2007), Woman Kissing on Bridge Carrie Fisher (1956-2016)
Clicks on video, gets an ad for Pan...
lol
+TheMrJaker ad blocker. youre welcome.
uBlock Origin. Ad blocker sold to an unknown buyer.
+TheMrJaker >2015
>not using adblock
+R619ification2011 Maybe he like Cinemasins...
I remember back at my old school, we were putting a movie on. We had 3 choices, I didn't want to watch Hook but they put it on, I was moaning like a little brat and one of the teachers yelled at me and told me to quiet and watch the film. At first I thought it would suck but by the end of it, I ended up loving this movie!
the teacher should have put you in the boo 📦
HELP I CAN'T STOP WATCHING THESE
Me too, but I like this movie so they dropped the ball on this one.
That's how CinemaSins farms views...
Me 2. Dont try and stop me Smee!!!
It's like watching the movie again real quick
if every time someone says "i do not believe in fairies" a fairies dies then i'm surprised tinkerbell said it??
MURDERER
My sentiments exactly. I caught that "my-carriage-rolled-down-the-hill-but-I-consider-it-running-away" blooper too.
Say it and mean it maybe?
That's what I'm assuming, especially because Peter says it in the original book, when he knows Tink is the room.
The rip-off, if it is one, is the angel line in "It's A Wonderful Life", not the other way around. The original line was Barrie's, "Every time a child says 'I don't believe in fairies' there is a fairy somewhere that falls down dead". One of the few lines in "Hook" straight out of the original play.
Dude the "No." thing gets me every time
God fucking dammit Jeremy
"A species famously unimpressed with _how_ you land in the water." Lmao
Take away 182 sins for Robin Williams just being in the movie. RIP Robin, you are greatly missed.
I say add 1,000 sins for it. The only movie that Robin Williams was in that I liked was Aladdin.
Cathrope1 excuse me.
@@Cathrope1 That is disrespectful
Rip Robin Williams! Great movie back when I was a kid!
Why was it a sin for Maggie Smith's makeup? That's a sin reduction right there if there ever was one.
It's not makeup. She was that old in 1991
95% of the sins in this, or most of this channel's videos aren't actually sins
@@histguy101 Usually, but in this case, a majority of these sins are legitimate mistakes and illogical points. Still a good movie though.
4:15!!! He didn’t mention the lady that should have won an oscar for her performance in any scary movie!
“THE CHILDREN ARE SCAR-REEMING
THE CHILDREN ARE SCAR-REEMING!”
This movie's still better than "Pan" "Finding Neverland" and "Return to neverland"
And I forget just why I taste oh yea I guess it makes me smi-sorry, that was in Pan
Actually, I think Return to Neverland is much better, only because that was the first version of a Peter Pan story, I ever heard of when I was younger.
And, the other movie with Johnny Depp is just as good, if not better. It gives a certain beauty to it.
Yea, it still kinda wrecks the peter pan story, but the original play is the best, i found the disney animated movie totally screwed up the ending.
Especially Pan
The 2003 version is the best
The Boo Box lmao. I still love this movie.
What's the boo box from
It seems to be something they made up for this movie. It's what Hook calls the trunk he has the other pirate locked in with scorpions.
fun fact... the pirate they put in the boo box was Glenn Close
Another fun fact: those are emperor scorpions, so she's not gonna die... which makes it worse, come to think of it, since she'll suffer longer.
Fun fact: this traumatised me as a kid
I was expecting a sin for the "boo box"
That scene terrified me as a kid.
Me(an evil big brother), with my more than evil older cousin: used to stick my younger brother in a wicker chest, shut and lock the lid, and then proceed to kick it around, place it on it it's lid, make it hell in the chest, etc; and it was forever known as the "boo" box... (yup, kids can be horrible, but to this day my little brother is my best friend, and we have forgiven all the transgressions against each other.
@@Rickrolled88 I did worse. My brother threw a comb at me since I needed it to comb my hair in the morning before school. It hit me in the head and I got super pissed. I took a belt and hit him with the metal end and it put holes in his legs. Felt bad about it ever since. Use to have a really bad temper when I was little. We forgave each other though.
Rickey Roll my sister had been insulting me all morning and then kicked me in the nuts after I shouted at her, so later that day while she was walking around our grandparents ranch I sniped her with my bb gun, my parents didn’t accept my excuse and were pissed
That was Glenn Close, you know.
Damn, History Man. If they’d known I hope they’d have understood a bit more. I’d rather get pelted with BB’s than nailed in the balls, and I don’t even have any. All’s fair in love and war, and between siblings.
4:11 - Hook's hook is on his left hand. So if he broke in downstairs and walked up to get to the kids, he must have awkwardly held his left hand across his body to make that gouge.
5:24 - Tinkerbell assassinates a fairy.
9:17 - Smee uses British version of "assf*ckers" that gets by US ratings board.
He could have slashed the walls with a dagger
That or he did it on the way down the stairs
Sin: the fairies dying if you don't believe in them is from Peter Pan, not from Its a Wonderful Life.
+masterYoshimistsu This one had a lot of sins for being similar to things that came out /after/ it (or came out after Peter Pan for some sins that referenced the book), which bugged the hell out of me.
+BardicLasher Like that Harry Potter one. Shouldn't that kinda "remove" a sin because Harry Potter needs to get one because of that?
Yeah but Its a Wonderful Life is a much better movie then any Peter Pan story.
That "sin" bothered me too. It's in the book... that was written 100+ years ago!
Also, Peter Pan is LIFE! =]
+TriggerGirl007 BOOKS DO NOT MATTER.
Every time someone says "Every time someone says "I don't believe in fairies", a fairy dies", a fairy dies.
Because they said that "I don't believe in fairies" as well, meaning they just killed a fairy, like the person before them.
+5mart2n Dead Fairy-ception
+5mart2n Get acquainted with grammar before commenting.
+5mart2n hardly. the words don't kill a fairy. lack of belief does.
+Dronic X Actually, his grammar is about as good as yours.
George Hamilton Look at 5mart2n's comment, specifically the quote. You cannot use double quotation marks inside a quote that uses double quotation marks. He has to replace the double quotation marks inside the quote with single quotation marks. On another note, I took Advanced Placement (AP) Language and Composition and got a five out of five in the College Board AP test. In simpler words, I know my shit when it comes to English grammar (and Spanish grammar).
Nice Arrested Development sound clip!
+Shane Logan Yup.
+Shane Logan I proper laughed at that.
youre a crook captain hook!
I love how the narrator says that Tinkerbell crashing around the children's room should have woken everyone up since the children were recently kidnapped but then as SOON as Tink leaves to take Peter to Neverland we immediately see Tootles in the window watching them even though he had not been there until that point and he didn't bother to come to Peter's aid or alert the rest of the family that a ball of bright light was kidnapping him out the window. lol.
Wait I just realised something - Did Tink murder another fairy when she said I do not believe in fairies?.
+29gish no because she didnt mean it
+Brandon Thompson But she did murder one by goading Peter into doing so.
CasualNotice maybe
I don't know, I feel like the sin count on this one is a touch unfair. You seem to assume that whole "this is all in Peter's head" thing, and assign sins based on it. At the end you acknowledge that the movie itself directly establishes everything in Neverland ACTUALLY HAPPENED, so why the sins based on it being a dream?
+OrangeRangerVideos The sins have no represent value, they're all just things he noted down as he watched the movie.
HistoryBuff117 I hate to sound argumentative, but there's a reason there's a counter in the upper left. Sometimes he does note things that aren't sins, but for example, he pointed out that IF this was a dream, he was seriously egotistical for Rufio wanting a dad like him AND Jack apologizing at basically the same moment. That was a sin, it was dinged, it was counted. BUT, it wasn't a dream, that really happened in the plot. So, I don't feel like that should have been a sin. I get your GENERAL point, that the sin counter doesn't mean good movie or bad movie, but I can say I've watched these videos having not seen movies and going "Wow, that seems pretty bad."
***** What i meant was in an episode of talking to himself (cant remember which one) he explained the sins have no value and are just things he notes down while watching. Je likes alot of the movies he sins.
Also remember 'Were not critics, were assholes - Cinemasins
+HistoryBuff117 Yeah, you can say that, but I don't even think he'd deny that people do assign value to them. And since there's a clear difference between a sin and an observation (whether the counter goes up 1 or more and ding), I just didn't feel like some of the sins were fair. Don't worry, not losing any sleep over it, just observing.
***** Yeah no problems, I just see him as a nitpicker and never question any sin, since they're basically his own opinon on the matter. But whatever each to his/her own
I'm surprised there was no Cinema Sin mentioning how Hook actually knew the exact location of Granny Wendy's house, and how he got up to the window to begin with. And, Phil Collins was actually in "Hook?" WHOA!
+Rawk4Life
Re: Phil Collins -- ikr? Guess that proves how good his makeup job was...
...wait for it...
*...so take a look at him noo-ooow!* (Note to CS -- you started this with the "Against All Odds"-reference. :) :) :) LOL...)
Hook was popular with Jack since the pirate captain actually gave him the time of day
Tink being in live with Peter is in both the Disney version AND the stage version
+DeathGodRiku
It is still a sin.
+DeathGodRiku but this treats it as a real issue and a side story. In the Disney version it a bit like character flow, and tinkerbell had no chance.
+DeathGodRiku but Disney does not have Robin Williams Rip
+Benjamin Jones They got him for Aldadin.
+Codysir oh yeah 😆 forgot about that
"I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord,
Can you feel him comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord...
Well if Gran told Peter he was drowning, Hook would not lend a hand
But the 'gator came and bit it off, but I don't know if Hook has PTSD
Well Peter was there and he rescued his kids, Hook thereon swore revenge
So Disney can shove off that shit, we know this is the hit,
Credibility has been avenged
"I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord,
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord
Well Peter saved them, you remember, how could you ever forget
It's the first time, that Disney ever told the story
But I know the reason why Steven Spielberg's is good, oh no Walt don't fool me
Well the redface doesn't show, but the pain still grows
Stereotypes' no stranger to you and me
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord,
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord,
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord, oh lord, oh lord
I can feel Hook comin' in the air tonight, oh lord,
He's been waitin' for this moment for all his life, oh lord..."
RUFIO NOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!
Orange Blur No.
Hussie:kisss
yes
So am I the only one that thinks it's a bit predatory-ish of Tink to have wanted to kiss the child she apparently kidnapped? Saved? Adopted? Coz the whole thing about Tink is that she's in love with Peter. If in Hook she's his caregiver then isn't that a bit... 🥴😬
Still love the film lol
Just watched Chris Stuckmann's review yesterday!
Thought the same thing!
+Logan Adair I'm very, very sorry.
RUFIO!!! RUFIO!!!
+TheUndefeatedMagician RU-FI-OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH!
Love this movie + homestuck =D
+TheUndefeatedMagician Ru-fi-oooooooo!
*homestucks cry in the distance*
+TheUndefeatedMagician *"I must capture the avatar to regain my honor!"*
+Syllwin Hobbie my life
2:05 Take in account Harry Potter's books locates its temporal space between 1991 and 1997. Thus we can conclude that's Minerva McGonagall's masquerade as "muggle" and she and Wendy are the same person.
But Maggie Smith was in the films, which are set in the 2000's.
I usually agree with you but Smee's line "I've just had an apostrophe" and Hook's reply "You mean 'epiphany' Smee; you've had an epiphany" deserves TWO sins off! I often quote that to my wife, and after 16 years, we are still married and I am not stabbed in my sleep.
OH CAPTAIN MY CAPTAIN!!
Something very few people know about this movie is that Gutless the Pirate who sells out Hook and gets put in the Boo Box with the scorpions is, and i shit you not, Glenn Close. That is one serious make-up team...
+Jimmysauce109 Haha wow I'll have to watch the movie again sometime to check that out.
+Jimmysauce109 Not many people also know that when Tink is flying Peter to Neverland, the couple that fairy dust hits is George Lucas and Carrie Fisher.
That scene really fucked me up as a kid. Still get mad every time I think about it.
Are we not going to sin the fact that tink basically was in love with Peter even when he was a child?
Even with all of the sins I love this movie.
It's not a "sin" against this movie, that came out ten years before the first Harry Potter film, had a similar score.
Hook is amazing. No Sins. :P
Same composer - John Williams
Not to mention he was giving sins for the special effects. The movie cannot help the year it was created.
No this movie is trash. I hate it and I prefer all of the other versions of Peter Pan. Most and Least favorite versions of Peter Pan: Peter Pan Disney=amazing, Peter Pan broadway=awesome, Peter Pan 2003=interesting, Peter Pan Live =brilliant, and Hook=boring trash.
No this movie is trash. I hate it and I prefer all of the other versions of Peter Pan. Most and Least favorite versions of Peter Pan: Peter Pan Disney=amazing, Peter Pan broadway=awesome, Peter Pan 2003=interesting, Peter Pan Live =brilliant, and Hook=boring trash.
LoveShiaGDSN don't spam ur shit
Just to refute the calumny at 2:46, Barrie donated the rights to PETER PAN to a London Children's hospital.
When Peter Pan would have come out of copyright the UK government passed a law that the royalties still go to Great Ormond Street Hospital.
That Dead Poets Society outtake at the end was golden. Damn.
The last sound clip. OH CAPTAIN MY CAPTAIN
The boo box moment brought to you by Glen Close.
James Hook is a great character. Him and his crew were marooned on an island where lord of the flies children, taunted him, dismembered him, and he lived in immortality, as an old man. What a cruel fate for James Hook.
Should've removed a sin or two for the Meryl Streep cameo
+Rowan J Coleman Do you mean Glenn Close?
Jasmine Mallet Oh bollocks, yes I did mean Glenn Close, thank you
+Rowan J Coleman I got excited for a second thinking I missed something! lol
Jasmine Mallet Nah, just me being daft
+Rowan J Coleman Wow someone on the internet owing up to a mistake? You didn't even try for the "lol you fell for it guys" excuse. Well played my good sir.
I miss Robin Williams...
The boo box traumatised me as a child.. and always had to imagine how it would feel like trapped in there dying slowly.. It was a horrifying scene :o
+Jo He It was scary, but not as much as Tom Petty turning Alice into a cake and eating her alive.
+DanceGameGuy Actually, I always loved that. Disney ran a tv show called Adventures in Wonderland around that time and I always enjoyed the video for Don't Come Around Here No More all the more because Alice got eaten XD
War Machine Different personalities
War Machine :D How old were you then?
Jo He
Not sure; the show ran back in the late eighties/early nineties - same time as Fraggle Rock - but I'm an eighties baby, so pretty young.
Well ... While watching the Harry Potter movies, with Maggie Smith in the scene and the score playing, all I could think of was Hook. So BOOM.
This movie is 100% perfect and so is Robin William. Miss you Robin.
csgrambauer 100%? Did you NOT watch this video?
Centaur Man15
Yes, and?
csgrambauer The point of it is to show some of its flaws (albeit also making fun of the times it was in). Like that flashback scene of Peter's origin story, one big plot hole made up of smaller ones.
Hey, free baby
+Lieutenant Tentacles
Yeah, I loved that!!!
Maggie Smith looking that old isn't a sin but an amazing makeup job.
"In darkest day, and darkest night, no moive will escape sin."
+Joe Schmoe nearly there but i think you intended to say : In darkest day, and darkest night, no moives sin will escape my sight"
*brightest day
+Scott Mantooth Sounds better to say: In darkest day and darkest night, no movies will go unsinned tonight.
now to convince the reviewers to possibly use that phrase and give you the credit
+Joe Schmoe I would be happy with either of them. :)
Its a fun idea.
Everything wrong with JAWS
+Samuel Walker
One of the best movies ever! But I'd still like to see a video of it!!
+Samuel Walker Yes, Please!
That scream cut-off at 7:48 is so damn funny
17:05 - Well, honestly, I'm kinda disappointed the board decided not to co-operate with the all too easy slapstick moment in the making.
16:23 literally just noticed all the makeup put on Rufios face
The Boo Box.
+Denver Marks NOT THE BOO BOX!!! NOOOO! lol
+Jake Seager whats interesting about the boo box scene is that the pirate in that scene isn't a man but a woman its glen close that woman who was Cruella'de'vil in the 101 Dalmatians live action movie plus the couple kissing on the bridge were George lucas and carrie fisher.
Murgin omal you know I really have a hard time believing that, but if its true, damn that's awesome xD
+Jake Seager im not bullshiting you look it up i was just as balls tripped as you.
Murgin omal that's awesome :P
Normally I laugh at These videos but not this.
This is a classic great Movie
How about a sin for the parents' blatent disregard when the kids mention some creepy man hanging l, stealing baseballs. Oh thats right, if they were responsible parents, this movie wouldnt happen... nevermind.
around*
Because he was a "window washer"?
and Peter should have suspected something cause it's mentioned that their own house has bars on his window, so some kind of instinct was telling him to be weary and all of a sudden nothing.
Oh come on Jack, when you're that bad at baseball - do you really want your dad to witness your failure?
Omg I didnt even notice Phil Collins was in this movie 😂😂😂😂 RUFIOOOO
What no sin for what the heck happened to hook. Oh come om!!!!!!!!!
Even as a five year old I remember asking my parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles what happened when ever I watched the film and that scene played.
+JediSpectre117 The croc statue burps. So he was eaten.
That's what they told me, time and time again.
But I thought the Croc was dead, how the heck could it have eaten him
Movie has magic. Things that are statues have to be assumed "alive".
+JediSpectre117 As Mr. Bean put it, "Magic."
+E. Chadwick Hey +cinemasins requesting EWW Bean
I had a VCR of this a movie (yes a VCR) when I was 6 and I remember exactly zero of it.
Now I re-watch it and it seems like I am watching an entirely different movie.
Thanks brain.
Ahaha do you mean a VHS ?
I had this movie on VHS and I absolutely hated it. I thought that it was stinky boring trash. I smashed my VHS tape of this movie.
Peter Pan Disney-Amazing
Peter Pan 2003=Wonderful
Peter Pan Broadway with Cathy Rigby and Mary Martin=Brilliant
Peter Pan Live with Christopher Walken=Exciting
Pan 2015=Also Exciting
Hook= Stinky Boring Trash
Is Maggie Smith frozen in time or something? This film came out 14 years ago and she looks the same now, in fact she looks younger today than she did back then.
+Andrew Jackson Spielberg might make messed up movies sometimes but at least he hires the best of the best to help make them.
+Andrew Jackson That's magic for you
+Andrew Jackson 24 years ago....
Jack Mann Oh dear god....
Makeup
Everything wrong with Mulan!!!!!!
+Amber Foster Allons-y!
i loved this movie as a kid...still do
I hated this movie as a kid...still do
Here's a list. Everything wrong with:
SYNC
A Trip To The Moon (1902)
Silence of The Lambs
Parallels
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
Fringe S1, E1: Pilot
Birdemic: Shock and Terror
Back to The Future 1
Back to The Future 2
And Zathura
+RetroGamer7200 They already did BtTF 1.
Ziggy Zaggy Gaming they didn't do Silence of The Lambs yet
+RetroGamer7200 There's only one Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. What you were probably thinking of is Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.
I feel like the movie would have been better off if they used American Football as Jack's sports. Then they could use a little joke about Tempa Bay Bucaneers or Oakland Raiders.
Buccaneers*
Kurloz Makara In Baseball, They Have The Pittsburgh Pirates!
I love how Phil Collins was just kind of there lol
God i miss Robin. He was a great actor that we lost too soon
You and Chris stuckman plan on making similar videos? Or crazy coincidence?
Well Pan is coming out, so it's likely more than one channel would do something about a Peter Pan film.
+ray p Pan is coming out this weekend and Chris is making a series review of Spielberg movies, so... coincidence(?)
oh really, im a bit out of the loop
No I'm pretty sure planned with Stuckmann. This Is like 10 movie sins where Chris did a review right before it. They even did the mission impossibles around the same time
I honestly doubt Chris and Cinemasins are buddies tho