Victor Davis Hanson | The Dying Citizen

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 май 2024
  • Victor Davis Hanson sits down with a Hillsdale College student to discuss the current state of America and the content of his new book, The Dying Citizen.
    0:00 "You're headed toward poverty."
    1:36 Farming & Academia
    2:34 The Dying Citizen
    9:34 The Loathing of American Exceptionalism
    12:14 The Woke Movement
    17:58 Taking the Constitutional System for Granted
    23:42 Advice for 20-year-olds
    Victor Davis Hanson is a Senior Fellow in classics and military history at Stanford University's Hoover Institution and Distinguished Fellow at Hillsdale College.
    Visit our website: hillsdale.edu
    Learn from our online courses: online.hillsdale.edu
    Hillsdale College is an independent institution of higher learning founded in 1844 by men and women “grateful to God for the inestimable blessings” resulting from civil and religious liberty and “believing that the diffusion of learning is essential to the perpetuity of these blessings.” It pursues the stated object of the founders: “to furnish all persons who wish, irrespective of nation, color, or sex, a literary, scientific, [and] theological education” outstanding among American colleges “and to combine with this such moral and social instruction as will best develop the minds and improve the hearts of its pupils.” As a nonsectarian Christian institution, Hillsdale College maintains “by precept and example” the immemorial teachings and practices of the Christian faith.
    The College also considers itself a trustee of our Western philosophical and theological inheritance tracing to Athens and Jerusalem, a heritage finding its clearest expression in the American experiment of self-government under law.
    By training the young in the liberal arts, Hillsdale College prepares students to become leaders worthy of that legacy. By encouraging the scholarship of its faculty, it contributes to the preservation of that legacy for future generations. By publicly defending that legacy, it enlists the aid of other friends of free civilization and thus secures the conditions of its own survival and independence.

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @chucklesthered2338
    @chucklesthered2338 2 года назад +688

    This guy is an American treasure!

    • @tomfrommichigan
      @tomfrommichigan 2 года назад +8

      I agree. We are lucky to have him.

    • @mackone8035
      @mackone8035 2 года назад +3

      Right. He's the kind of treasure a cat buries in the litter box.

    • @tompain2751
      @tompain2751 2 года назад +13

      @@mackone8035 What do you have a problem with? everything he said, was100% correct.

    • @kimobrien.
      @kimobrien. 2 года назад

      @@tompain2751 What was correct his fear of immigrants who arrive on a schedule? What did people do before the cops had computer tracking and photo ID? How many of the 9/11 hijackers didn't have photo ID? Any reason to believe photo ID stops any real crime?

    • @tompain2751
      @tompain2751 2 года назад +9

      @@kimobrien. Photo ID, would sure make elections more secure, and so would in person voting. Illegal immigrants are a problem. Your mischaracterizations, of what he said, are pathetic.

  • @markwilliams974
    @markwilliams974 2 года назад +408

    This kid is a better interviewer than 90% of the TV hosts.

    • @bettywhite8407
      @bettywhite8407 2 года назад +12

      Rightly so. My opinion, Professor hand picked this highly intellectual reporter. Hope to see/ hear more from him.

    • @paperclip612
      @paperclip612 2 года назад +18

      Agree 👍. Letting the guest speak, what a concept!

    • @Mr05Chuck
      @Mr05Chuck 2 года назад +8

      I was glad to see he had notes in front of him. At first I thought he was going off the top of his head. I was feeling very inferior. Lol which is probably true anyway.

    • @lukasmiller486
      @lukasmiller486 2 года назад +10

      TV hosts do all the gabbing. The “interviews” are all about themselves and the “person of interest” is supposed to just “enjoy the same space with him/her.”

    • @wwrussell180
      @wwrussell180 2 года назад +5

      Indeed!

  • @MrKnoxguy101
    @MrKnoxguy101 2 года назад +391

    You’ll notice that when Mr. Hanson gives his lectures that not only is he very knowledgeable and seems like he could be someone that lives next door. But in such a laid back tone, he speaks to the audience the same way he would if you were sitting down with him somewhere one on one , having a cup of coffee… like he is here. This is why I’ve always enjoyed hearing his lectures.

    • @DigitalBridge.
      @DigitalBridge. 2 года назад +27

      If you watch his lectures he never or hardly ever looks at his notes because he knows the material inside and out. Genius!

    • @nitasheehan2704
      @nitasheehan2704 2 года назад +9

      My words exactly.

    • @nitasheehan2704
      @nitasheehan2704 2 года назад +10

      @@DigitalBridge. I noted that as well.

    • @jerryhurd9534
      @jerryhurd9534 2 года назад +1

      @@DigitalBridge. fcccff

    • @jerryhurd9534
      @jerryhurd9534 2 года назад +1

      From

  • @scandallpower
    @scandallpower 2 года назад +280

    This student is much more mature and well-spoken than I was at that age. Well done dude.

    • @hugh-johnfleming289
      @hugh-johnfleming289 2 года назад +7

      I hated teenagers when I was one. Finding good company among my peers was a difficult endeavour and I, this is the 70s mind you, tended toward the company of adults.

    • @maureenbernardy222
      @maureenbernardy222 2 года назад +3

      That's a Hillsdale student. :)

    • @andrewtungsk2762
      @andrewtungsk2762 2 года назад +2

      Totally Agree 22/2/22singapore

    • @domingofernandez789
      @domingofernandez789 Год назад +1

      That tells you the mind formation of those kids, like the interviewer, when they go to Hillsdale Colleqe. One of the few good institutions that remain in our country. Hope that they can continue for many more years.

    • @RorkesDriftVC
      @RorkesDriftVC Год назад

      The kid fails to point out Hanson's inconsistencies and falsehoods.

  • @bryanoldenburg9870
    @bryanoldenburg9870 2 года назад +108

    This man was born for such a time as this; he's someone who understands the theoretical and the practical, and can communicate with both intellectuals and the common man. He has (to quote Joni Mitchell) looked at life from both sides now, and probably has enjoyed how hands-on labor and intellectual enlightenment have played off each other throughout the years; e.g., he's probably enjoyed all the breaks from academia, by getting on his tractor, breathing in the fresh air, and taking in the good earth. In a world that too often looks down on the working class as being beneath them or unsophisticated, VDH has emerged to show (in my mind) a superior synthesis of the ideal and the real. He is a TRUE genius for our time! Beautiful presentation Hillsdale, with a very timely and vital set of messages. Bravo!

    • @karenmorey4929
      @karenmorey4929 2 года назад

      LOVE.

    • @sascotttx5145
      @sascotttx5145 2 года назад +4

      There's something quite therapeutic about operating a tractor. I used to think it was just the amount of power underneath you that you were controlling. Over time I realized it was the focus on the tractor that would cause the worries of the day to slip from my mind. I never thought about how much braces for the twins were going to cost me when I was on the tractor. I never tried to remember what the last date for making an estimated tax payment, before being penalized was, when I was on the tractor. I never worried about whether or not my loan application would be approved at the bank, when I was on the tractor. I didn't even think about how I preferred great taste over less filling. To be honest, I just focused on the tractor. It was really quite peaceful, because if I had lost that focus there are at least five different ways that that tractor could have killed me.

  • @wfmcfp1
    @wfmcfp1 2 года назад +96

    Excellent, as always. This gentleman needs to somehow be heard by the masses beyond conservatives who naturally enjoy listening to him.

  • @tsumnerbmw
    @tsumnerbmw 2 года назад +194

    Awesome! I cannot tell how blessed I feel we are for this man being on RUclips and listening to his cogent, down to earth responses to the issues of today. I usually feel much better about our current predicament after listening to Dr. Hanson. True gem of America. Perhaps the best we have!

    • @martinliehs2513
      @martinliehs2513 2 года назад +8

      Dr Hanson is like a verbal anti-depressant for me. This interview with this student gives me hope.

    • @tomluciani3723
      @tomluciani3723 2 года назад +3

      The comments are how I see Americans. Hearing of people like you too gives hope...

    • @andrewtungsk2762
      @andrewtungsk2762 2 года назад +1

      Totally Agree 22/2/22singapore

    • @eslimprinted
      @eslimprinted Год назад

      Yes!

  • @michaelthomas366
    @michaelthomas366 2 года назад +50

    Never get bored or tired listening to the professor.

    • @playthemannotthepuck_748
      @playthemannotthepuck_748 2 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/gz3PGpMftZc/видео.html&ab_channel=RightTurnClyde

    • @LTrotsky21stCentury
      @LTrotsky21stCentury Год назад

      Probably because he just says things you want to hear. Its the legitimization of bias and oppression.

  • @garysmith789
    @garysmith789 2 года назад +90

    VDH is so wise. I am always amazed by how he can explain the most difficult subjects with such ease and everyday language that anyone can understand. An Absolutely fantastic man. God bless you dear sir.

    • @andrewtungsk2762
      @andrewtungsk2762 2 года назад +1

      The mar of a master teacher is to mae the most complicated lesson simple to understand 22/2/22singapore

  • @rich8304
    @rich8304 2 года назад +237

    Smart man,lets hope more citizens listen.

    • @buttebears6108
      @buttebears6108 2 года назад +1

      Here Here ...The Real Progressives are here

    • @parnpichate
      @parnpichate 2 года назад +4

      @@buttebears6108 - The problem with progessivism is that it has no reverence for wisdom. There is an old adage that comes to mind that is most applicable to western cultures current degredation - "If it aint broke, dont fix it"

    • @foxtrotjulietbravo5536
      @foxtrotjulietbravo5536 2 года назад +1

      Hear-hear @Rich. Share, share, share!

    • @DDGVET4
      @DDGVET4 2 года назад

      Let's hope they take more of the free online courses at Hillsdale College. Sign up!

    • @RorkesDriftVC
      @RorkesDriftVC Год назад

      The young man fails to point out Hanson's inconsistencies and factual inaccuracies.

  • @happymotoring4674
    @happymotoring4674 2 года назад +189

    Mr. Hanson reminds me of a history teacher i had at Msgr. Bonner High School back in the early 70's....he got me to love history and the study of it God Bless you for all you do Mr. Hanson.....your the man!

    • @jeffmccoy1700
      @jeffmccoy1700 2 года назад +10

      Mr, Hanson does not march to the beat of the times, he's not politically correct, he's 'woke' deficient completely lacking in leftist neo-marxist wisdom - and that's a superb thing.

    • @johnmeckel2319
      @johnmeckel2319 2 года назад +3

      @@jeffmccoy1700
      Definitely The Source of
      His Intellect! 👍

    • @maryrocha4542
      @maryrocha4542 2 года назад

      r r

    • @BestIsntEasy
      @BestIsntEasy 2 года назад

      HOW MARITIME ruclips.net/video/N7CvEt51fz4/видео.html LAW WORKS.
      Islam is a GROUP in submission.
      🐄 *MU'MEN are BELIEVERS* 🐄
      👣💔👣 EVERY group out there has made your beloved labels a CURSE WORD to others.
      6 Men can only reproduce human life, but the Holy Spirit gives new life from heaven; 7 so don’t be surprised at my statement that
      🔥🐍🔥 *you must be born again!* 🔥🐍🔥
      26 But our mother-city is the heavenly Jerusalem, and she is not a slave to Jewish laws. Galatians 4:26 Living Bible 🔱🔥🔱
      TRANS AGENDA = ⚖
      🤜💥💩♂️🔺️🔯🔻♀️ 💥💩🤛

    • @kevinbreslin8659
      @kevinbreslin8659 2 года назад

      WE SMELL B.O. NNER!!!

  • @rondail5675
    @rondail5675 2 года назад +29

    Thank you Hillsdale College and Victor Davis Hanson. Maybe there is hope. God help us even though we can't seem to help ourselves.

  • @jakewalklate6226
    @jakewalklate6226 2 года назад +75

    I took the dying citizen course! Dr Victor Davis Hanson please upload more of your lectures online!

  • @oceanhome2023
    @oceanhome2023 2 года назад +54

    This what all of us dream about ! Sitting down and having coffee with VDH while we have a no holds barred conversation with him. !

  • @coupedeville
    @coupedeville 2 года назад +28

    Words cannot adequately express how important VDH is to the global conversation. He is my hero.

  • @patriciagraham4529
    @patriciagraham4529 2 года назад +67

    An extraordinary man and a fine citizen

    • @catsaresocute650
      @catsaresocute650 2 года назад

      A about 8:20 he taks about womans right to vote (suffragettes), to me implying that would be up to debate (a state issue), why do you seem to agree?

    • @user-qb8iy3tx2r
      @user-qb8iy3tx2r 2 года назад

      @@catsaresocute650 says nothing about that

    • @catsaresocute650
      @catsaresocute650 2 года назад

      @@user-qb8iy3tx2r at about 8:20

    • @catsaresocute650
      @catsaresocute650 2 года назад

      He mentions it only in passing, but what you thinking logicaly over what he's saying IS saying that wether or not woman have the right to vote shoud be state issue? What to me too makes no sense, what's why I actually asked this

    • @tompain2751
      @tompain2751 2 года назад

      @@catsaresocute650 To paraphrase: States should determine election laws, "except in cases like when women want to vote"..." they want to scrap that". He is saying, that is a Constitutional issue, for the SCOTUS. This is safely determined. State's right to set voting rules, is essential, for power distribution, rather than, centralized power control over everyone! State's rights, are in danger!

  • @jamescole1786
    @jamescole1786 2 года назад +83

    1/7/22; Thank you Hillsdale for making this informal 'coffee' talk at student union Cafe with VDH. Easy to listen & learn by comparisons of many political, economic & social issues as Dr.Hanson speaks about his career experiences. His new/latest book The Dying Citizen is being discussed via 1-on-1 interviews all over YT in more formal settings..but your presentation in this video was very enjoyable! Young student with VDH at Cafe Coffee table was just great!👍👍👍😊☕

  • @jacquelinevanderkraats6938
    @jacquelinevanderkraats6938 2 года назад +26

    So refreshing to listen to a wise, humble and well educated man talking.....unfortunately so rare anymore...his words are like medicine for the soul!

  • @CRAIG672004
    @CRAIG672004 2 года назад +36

    A true patriot , so articulate & knowledgeable. Impressive video.

  • @geofflybeck3525
    @geofflybeck3525 2 года назад +75

    Great interview! Hats off to this young man for asking pointed questions and then sitting back and listening to the wisdom of one of the world's greatest thinkers. Outstanding work----keep it up!

    • @andrewtungsk2762
      @andrewtungsk2762 2 года назад +1

      one of the world's greatest thinkers.22/2/22singapore

  • @Llyrin
    @Llyrin 2 года назад +29

    Lucky you, Nick. I would love to meet my favorite professor. Too many people need entertainment to keep them interested. Dr. Hanson doesn’t go through histrionics, his voice doesn’t go up and down for dramatic effect, no dramatic pauses. Whether it’s Classical history, modern history and war, or current politics, he holds me in rapt attention every time.

  • @andycheek766
    @andycheek766 2 года назад +82

    Would be a lot more like this man as a society if we all started reading more and turning off the cell phones and television

    • @bettywhite8407
      @bettywhite8407 2 года назад +10

      100% correctly stated. Losing family/ togetherness holidays . Electronic rule . back, 88 yrs of my own life, our conduct was pretty much lived as VHD explained. Charity was a no no. Work ethics were taught early in life. You can become anything yout want , if YOU work. I'm happy l was born / raised during that Era.

    • @gomes2151
      @gomes2151 2 года назад

      And maybe stopping doing jerk commnents like this one.

  • @sdbassin1143
    @sdbassin1143 2 года назад +41

    I genuinely appreciate listening to our American elders.
    Truly an amazing generation not cut from the same mold.
    🇺🇸💪🇺🇸💪🇺🇸💪🇺🇸💪🇺🇸💪🇺🇸💪🇺🇸

  • @nolan9221
    @nolan9221 2 года назад +63

    An old school traditional man who worked hard on the farm and was a college professor. He articuled everything here, he knows the futures going in a dangerous projection, America's falling and its sad.

    • @narcodium
      @narcodium 2 года назад +2

      Not just America but all 1st world nations

    • @cgmat7804
      @cgmat7804 2 года назад +4

      If you think of what was said, we have bred a generation of graduates who are fed convenience and cannot fix or control anything that is not handed to them, therefore they can be easily controlled in future

    • @tomluciani3723
      @tomluciani3723 2 года назад

      @@cgmat7804 Then I see injured wounded heroes that have never been laid back. We are here...

  • @oldsalt8011
    @oldsalt8011 2 года назад +32

    If I have trouble relaxing before I go to bed this is the guy I listen too. Clear and to the point all summarized for an easy understanding.

    • @darlenefoster3379
      @darlenefoster3379 2 года назад +1

      i agree. try Thomas Sowell also.

    • @oldsalt8011
      @oldsalt8011 2 года назад

      @@darlenefoster3379 Yep, I listen to him as well.

  • @vernan1982
    @vernan1982 2 года назад +3

    Dr Davis Hanson is by far one of the best minds in this country.

  • @krystalklear7793
    @krystalklear7793 2 года назад +2

    A GOOD, gorgeous, honest, humble, kind, loving, soulful, strong MAN.

  • @dianeoliveira6780
    @dianeoliveira6780 2 года назад +2

    Loving my Country as he speaks..
    But I also pray...please....🙏
    God Bless America.. 🇺🇸

  • @viramandybur4915
    @viramandybur4915 2 года назад +12

    VDH, a true national treasure.

  • @arthurfoyt6727
    @arthurfoyt6727 2 года назад +27

    It's seductive to be a "progressive" since everyone else is always wrong and you never are responsible for your decisions. This old man is preaching hard work and responsibility.

    • @urbanabrandon
      @urbanabrandon Год назад +4

      76 here, grew up on a farm where the age of work began age 6. We are now strangers in our homeland. I don’t recognize the overwhelming majority as being actually ‘American’.

    • @njnjhjh8918
      @njnjhjh8918 10 месяцев назад

      It's seductive to be a religious zealot since everyone else is always wrong and you never are responsible for anything you do or vote for because it's hurting the right people

  • @chriswertz1438
    @chriswertz1438 2 года назад +2

    Love you and your work Victor!!

  • @soniajulie6465
    @soniajulie6465 2 года назад +1

    We need VICTOR DAVIS HANSON to teach courses in all of our schools !!!

  • @zpclosangelesgraffiticafe
    @zpclosangelesgraffiticafe 2 года назад +3

    "Dying Citizen" -- this Professor is very spot-on Accurate !!

  • @ashenden1928
    @ashenden1928 2 года назад +3

    Dr. Hanson is a universal treasure. I am a chilean that lives in Chile and I always listen to him. His believes, experience and culture applies to many people around the world like me. God bless him.

  • @TheOpenSociety777
    @TheOpenSociety777 2 года назад +9

    EXCELLENT !!! What a remarkable, level headed, and impressive look at our country today.

  • @6663000
    @6663000 2 года назад +2

    VDH is the wisest man in the world.
    I've listened to him speak for hundreds of hours, never heard him have a conversation with a young person.
    Very interesting.

  • @joshnic6639
    @joshnic6639 2 года назад +57

    Also I want to say thank you Victor Davis Hanson! Finally someone gets it! I’ve been saying for a long time now that I hate this BLM crap but at the same time I hate where this country is economically. things are so unbalanced, meaning…we need more of a middle class.
    The fact that mr. Hanson (who is someone with credibility) is able to articulate that, gives me great pleasure because finally someone like him is saying what I’ve been trying to say now for almost three years!

    • @MLP88
      @MLP88 2 года назад

      You believe BLM is crap? You're insane.

    • @brucehutchinson9527
      @brucehutchinson9527 2 года назад +5

      @@MLP88 . BLM is communism

    • @highlightning6693
      @highlightning6693 2 года назад +4

      @@MLP88 BLM doesn't care about black people. They're an advancement of the Black Liberation Movement, which was also communist and funded by the Soviet Union. They are not good people at all.

    • @marcothehammer
      @marcothehammer 2 года назад +3

      @@MLP88 I believe the commentary is referring to the FACT that the founders of BLM have taken the vast majority of the donations and used them for personal gain.
      I can see value in the statement, I simply don’t believe someone who shouts “All lives matter” should be murdered (As has happened).

    • @joshnic6639
      @joshnic6639 2 года назад +1

      @@MLP88 Fighting racism with racist rhetoric is insane! Common sense should point that out to you clearly!

  • @danielh2610
    @danielh2610 2 года назад +11

    VDH - one of the greatest minds of our time. An intellectual, each word has the weight of gold.

  • @jefftokaji6460
    @jefftokaji6460 2 года назад +1

    Victor Davis Hanson is brilliant. It's a shame that those who are corrupting our country won't listen to this man. God Bless you sir.

  • @no59do56
    @no59do56 2 года назад +1

    Hats off to this Young man. To sit and listen without interrupting Victor davis Hanson is remarkable...this young man has a future

  • @buzzries2040
    @buzzries2040 2 года назад +133

    Victor davis Hanson is awesome! He’s truly an amazing intellectual and the primary reason to watch Fox News, just to hear his wisdom for 3-5 minutes.

    • @ripmurdock232
      @ripmurdock232 2 года назад +8

      And he has calluses on his hands and dirt under his fingernails which adds more IQ points for him, in my opinion.

    • @peterharris4386
      @peterharris4386 2 года назад

      Intellectual, real? Examples?

    • @ripmurdock232
      @ripmurdock232 2 года назад +8

      @@peterharris4386 did you listen to anything he said?

    • @peterharris4386
      @peterharris4386 2 года назад

      @@ripmurdock232 Yes... but can you answer my question?

    • @ripmurdock232
      @ripmurdock232 2 года назад +7

      @@peterharris4386 who are you that I need to answer to you? I'm not here playing questions and answers with someone who doesn't understand anything out of his comfort zone.
      Why don't you act like an adult and answer my question. If you don't agree with what Dr. Hanson had to say then feel free to speak your mind. Does that make sense to you?

  • @janemackenzie6061
    @janemackenzie6061 2 года назад +10

    I always stop to listen to any of the podcasts and/or videos in which Victor Davis Hanson is participating, conducting or interacting in any way. From conversations to speeches to interviews, he never fails to impress me with his knowledge of history, countries, peoples, events, or comments that enrich, engross, enlighten, compell, all of the above! He stimulates ideas, compelling you to listen and to think! I admire his life and contributions to education, rational thought, provocative and evocative discovery whether through his books, lectures, conversations, always exuding humility and grace!
    I wish someone would name him Man of the Year!! It may be 2022!!! Thank you for your generosity in sharing your work, thoughts and life experiences, always profoundly interesting! God bless you and your family!🌍🌎🌏👏❤💓💓🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @catsaresocute650
      @catsaresocute650 2 года назад

      Not that he is not sometimes interresint, but would you maybe explain to me what his apperent proposition that womans voting rights/citicenship (suffragettes) would be up to debate (a state issue) would mean to you?

  • @FrenchieFrench1555
    @FrenchieFrench1555 2 года назад +1

    Victor Davis Hanson excellent as usual.
    I would listen to him all the day long

  • @francoonoorto9974
    @francoonoorto9974 2 года назад +8

    Excellent, Dr Hanson! You are truly a national treasure!

  • @peterrichards1058
    @peterrichards1058 2 года назад +21

    Dr Hanson is a complete thinker like Jordan Petersen and his ability in conveying his thoughts are considered and clear. The western world needs these people to educate our young and undo the damage that’s been done by those who want a globalists agenda.

  • @carliusanders
    @carliusanders 2 года назад +8

    Great to listen and reflect on. I’m based in Sweden.

  • @verycrankyperson
    @verycrankyperson 2 года назад +2

    Love Victor Davis Hanson. A great American!

  • @beaupierrebondurant5651
    @beaupierrebondurant5651 Год назад +1

    Victor Davis Hanson is an American treasure.

  • @1942rambo
    @1942rambo 2 года назад +4

    Achingly wise man. Powerful.

  • @jimsjacob
    @jimsjacob 2 года назад +5

    God, this national treasure of knowledge and history needs to somehow be spared the rigors of time. We can’t afford to lose someone with this ability to explain things for how they really are. God Bless Victor Davis Hanson!!

  • @rockahbilly76
    @rockahbilly76 2 года назад +4

    As we coast onward to an inevitable train wreck, it is comforting to see a youth appreciating one of grand experience and resolve. This should be "Must see, T.V."

  • @lucyalmiranez5367
    @lucyalmiranez5367 2 года назад +4

    How I wish I could sit in his class. But it's great I could listen to him over and over again. What a privilege!

  • @garywebb1673
    @garywebb1673 2 года назад +13

    VDH hit nail on the head. We need people who can fix an work on things. I myself have trained myself to build an fix anything. I grow a garden. I work on my trucks an tractors. I can build a house from ground up. We need folks like that. Can do attitude.

    • @kimochkaks
      @kimochkaks 2 года назад

      You are one of the guys VDH talked about. My husband and I are in your bushel basket!

    • @crawford323
      @crawford323 Год назад

      Along those lines, as we progress in technology, less people are trained or skilled enough to maintain the products we buy. The right to repair must be protected. I believe John Deere is being sue perhaps by successfully. I am worried about programs which are essential to gain functionality of the product which requires a monthly fee to keep it moving. I am as you are and trained myself to maintain the products I own but my career was vastly different. I feel we are rare and I also feel industry does want us to be this way. Sorry to drift off topic.

  • @joyceplattner7679
    @joyceplattner7679 2 года назад +36

    Thank you both, I enjoyed this discussion between you two, very relaxed and yet profound

  • @dnormore1814
    @dnormore1814 2 года назад +9

    Loving this talk from Canada. This knowledge and insight applies here as well. Could listen to VDH all day and hope young people tune in to hear this.

  • @EdD-ym6le
    @EdD-ym6le 2 года назад +8

    VDH is the man . I unmute the TV and listen to what he has to say when I'm otherwise busy on the computer .

  • @lisaletto7337
    @lisaletto7337 2 года назад +9

    Just started Hanson's new book. Very interesting

  • @theresemarie9569
    @theresemarie9569 2 года назад +8

    Nick, you did a great job with this interview. You asked a few intetesting questions then sat back and let VDH share his brilliance with us. Thank you.

  • @gclass1395
    @gclass1395 2 года назад +8

    A legend

  • @richardredseal3993
    @richardredseal3993 2 года назад +36

    Beautifully done.

    • @Qtsm5784
      @Qtsm5784 2 года назад

      This is one of the most intellectually and smoothly worded "fear of the loss of American white supremacy." The dying old man passes down his fear and hope to the next generation boy. The perpetuation of white extinction is scary and promotes the us vs. them narrative, but man if this interview isn't impressively executed.

  • @milostone6498
    @milostone6498 2 года назад +6

    That *was* good, Nick 🤝👏👏👏👏👏 🍻 delightful conversation. God bless 🇺🇸❤️✌️🙏

  • @dixxinyoface
    @dixxinyoface 2 года назад +32

    This style of interview is very interesting. Its shot like a scene in a 90s sitcom as a conversation between two written characters except it's non fiction

  • @michaelmead2496
    @michaelmead2496 2 года назад +5

    This man is worth his weight in gold. I'm proud to say he lives literally down the street from me in Central California although I've never had the pleasure to meet him. Perhaps one day.....

  • @user-uk7ls1iy9k
    @user-uk7ls1iy9k 5 месяцев назад +1

    Victor Davis Hansen is the real deal. So smart, and so approachable. American treasure! 22:25 22:31

  • @bransky
    @bransky 2 года назад +11

    This was excellent! May there be more!

  • @bradbarnett5464
    @bradbarnett5464 2 года назад +14

    Always encouraged to see a member of a younger generation gleaning wisdom from a fellow that's been around the block a few times,... then sharing. Goodwork!

  • @ednovasak4077
    @ednovasak4077 2 года назад +1

    I can listen to Victor for hours.

  • @marcwalker9610
    @marcwalker9610 Год назад +1

    Dr Hanson never disappoints!
    His perspectives and deliveries are always so insightful and using his wealth of knowledge and ability to instantly clarify his points using practical examples, makes him both a teacher's teacher as well as a pupils teacher who can appeal to basically anyone at any level of education.
    Bravo Dr, Professor, Historian, and Friend 🇺🇸

  • @joanmsmith5561
    @joanmsmith5561 2 года назад +31

    When I get all upset about things, Mr Hansen always calms me down, with his cool , reasoned outlook. But I still think this country is in trouble.

    • @DDGVET4
      @DDGVET4 2 года назад

      You think this country is in trouble because ....IT IS.

  • @davidbundesen5867
    @davidbundesen5867 2 года назад +11

    This is such a thoughtful interview. So many nuggets I can’t list them all. VDH is one of the most thoughtful minds of our time.

  • @garymiller2536
    @garymiller2536 Год назад +2

    I do love this man. He’s Tops. Excellent talk and interview.

  • @TheAlly04
    @TheAlly04 Год назад +1

    Both VDH, as well as the interviewer, are incredibly impressive. Young and old…everyone needs to be paying attention to wisdom like this.

  • @boomerang_911
    @boomerang_911 2 года назад +7

    So excellent! This helped me understand what is happening around me and this moves me from hopelessness to hope for America.🇺🇸

  • @gold4every1
    @gold4every1 2 года назад +3

    When I see a young man like this, I am less worried about our future.

  • @johnvannewhouse
    @johnvannewhouse 2 года назад +7

    Might be the COOLEST interview I've ever seen with VDH...good job!

  • @tekis0
    @tekis0 2 года назад +6

    It would be great to have VDH and Thomas Sowell together in discussion. This presentation was, by the way, excellent!!

  • @SkyKing2052
    @SkyKing2052 2 года назад +7

    Outstanding, informative conversation! Thank you, Nick and Dr. VDH

  • @GeorgeSemel
    @GeorgeSemel 2 года назад +15

    Well when I was 16 years old, I got my driver's license. I already knew how to drive because my Uncle Felix taught me how by driving a tractor during hay season and other things along the way. My first car was a 1971 Chevy Pickup V-8 and standard transmission, I drove it and it was time to do a tune-up and I was going to take it to where I bought it. My uncle said you will do no such thing and gave me a list of tools to buy- sears craftsmen are good. And then to Mark's auto parts for well the parts, I would need. They are still in business and I still buy stuff from them. My uncle talked me thru the whole process. It took about two hours. After that, I could do the job myself with no issue. That was then my current car you need a scan tool and not just a code reader you need specialized tools and about 6 hours to do the plugs. The old chevy would need to tune every 20 thousand miles or so, the car I have now well I had the work done last winter and by the time I will need to do it again in 100K I will have junked the car. Yeah, the world war two guys could work on the Shermans the Studebaker's, and the jeeps because they were pretty much the same as what they wrenched on as kids. In some ways, we lost that, but we are Americans and it's not like we never reinvented ourselves. I can do a lot of things on a car even today. I am thankful for the time my Uncle Felix took to show me how to do things and then watch over me doing those things. The nod of approval was the best thing because it was earned. Too many of our young people don't have that, and it's a shame. There is no room for failure these days and if you do you're done. That was not always so. I am teaching myself Russian, I learn more from the mistakes than I do when I get things correct.

  • @davidnoot4995
    @davidnoot4995 2 года назад +2

    Beautiful. My wife is being force fed wokism (gender and diversity studies) at the university. This video is like a breath of fresh air away from those repressive ideas of retribution and victimhood. Feels good and right to listen to him.

  • @Nick-nm8om
    @Nick-nm8om 2 года назад +1

    If I could I would sit and listen to him for days without a break.
    I would love to attend a lecture with him and Thomas Sowell speaking just about anything.

  • @goodyeoman4534
    @goodyeoman4534 2 года назад +10

    I've ordered Professor Hanson's book The Second World Wars. I cannot wait to read it.

    • @christinamjp
      @christinamjp 2 года назад +2

      Me too
      I believe Victor Davis Hanson is a treasure sure but I am not sure with this US citizen rushing headlong into volcanism yeah you're welcome that even he at even heat will be able to survive to survive the demolition.

    • @christinamjp
      @christinamjp 2 года назад +3

      I meant WOKISM! The US is losing their leadership by dumbing down their education, their reqiurements

  • @wally1452
    @wally1452 2 года назад +8

    Mr. Hanson is a remarkable man for many reasons. He is so richly informed on all important issues, his being a historian shows very clearly why all of us, especially politicians should be always life long history students. He is clearly understandable and I listen to him anywhere I may see him on my pc. I have some writings of his and they are as he...so easy to grasp what he says. If I was much younger and very well off I'd like to see that FOX or some TV/Internet had him on with at least MWF evenings on current things that need to be addressed, and so much more. This man should be running for office or in a very important position of influence in the WH or Congress. By the way, where is the other fine, solid, sensible Republicans or sound Democrats...I have not seen nor heard anything from the several we still have in U.S. that are men/women who we need to have out in public, battling this WH and etc, that is doing awful things to America.

  • @richardmacculloch253
    @richardmacculloch253 2 года назад +1

    Wise words Dr. Hanson. Thank you for the food for thought that gives me the energy to exercise my brain.

  • @elishevaborenson4609
    @elishevaborenson4609 2 года назад +2

    Thank you Dr. Hansen for your clarity in defining American Exceptionalism.

  • @OkTxSheepLady
    @OkTxSheepLady 2 года назад +4

    “There is a freedom of expression. That’s very rare.” This brought to mind a conversation I had around 2001 or 2002. I was knocking on doors to passing out campaign literature. The man answering the door was obviously of middle eastern heritage and from his speech I guessed he was a recent immigrant. He was visibly frightened and distraught when I asked him if he had chosen who he intended to vote for. I assured him that the choice was his to make without fear, gave him some literature and wished him well. Today he would have more grounds for his apprehension.

  • @goodtalker
    @goodtalker 2 года назад +5

    Dr. Hanson reminds me of many of my teachers as a kid growing up here in Imperial County who also farmed or ran cattle. They had to be businessmen, weathermen, mechanics, laborers, bilingual, electricians, vets, etc., etc. No wonder we learned so much.

  • @jimjefftube
    @jimjefftube Год назад +1

    Hey Victor Davis Hanson, My Uncle farmed 25-40 acres of Almonds for the last 40 years and taught Ag Classes at MJC for the same period. He is one of the most honest and hard working men with a passion for both teaching and farming and reminds me of you. Thank you for your opinions and common sense!

  • @billearl9394
    @billearl9394 2 года назад +2

    VDH sums it all up so eloquently, with such basic common sense/intelligence. After listening to the racial whiners in the mainstream media, he is a breath of fresh, clean, life giving air.

  • @bettywhite8407
    @bettywhite8407 2 года назад +13

    Phenomenally insightful.

  • @buzzries2040
    @buzzries2040 2 года назад +74

    I have “the dying citizen” in audiobook. It’s awesome! But I wish it was read by VDH. Just brilliant regardless.

    • @MarkFugel
      @MarkFugel 2 года назад

      i have same...disappointed he didnt read it also

    • @mjschoensee93
      @mjschoensee93 2 года назад +1

      💯

    • @jakebredthauer5100
      @jakebredthauer5100 2 года назад +1

      Mr. Hanson is wrong on the issue of civic nationalism versus ethnic nationalism. America would have never become a great nation if it were multicultural. It is one reason for the conflict and decline.
      Think, people, if you still are able. Didn't he say that no country in the world has ever done it successfully? He was implying that the US has done it successfully, but it has not.

    • @tompain2751
      @tompain2751 2 года назад

      @@jakebredthauer5100 By what measure, has it not?

    • @jakebredthauer5100
      @jakebredthauer5100 2 года назад +1

      @@tompain2751 The disunity statistics are in the book. There was a colored guy in Wisconsin who was using his vehicle to chase white people in a parade and run over them. That is just the surface of the racial conflict. The Communists are using the conflict to divide and conquer. It is a mess that will be very difficult to remedy.
      The guy said it was an experiment. It is now time to give the results of the experiment.

  • @user-og9gx6vj8z
    @user-og9gx6vj8z 2 месяца назад

    Hanson is a sage. Love him and can listen to him all day talk about history and politics👏🇺🇲

  • @SanjayThuraisingham
    @SanjayThuraisingham Год назад

    Victor Hanson is a Great American. I have nothing but the highest respect for this man. God bless him and those on the side of the Constitution.

  • @lynnetx5521
    @lynnetx5521 2 года назад +9

    This was so much fun to watch. Love this format. Love VDH

  • @billwolff3763
    @billwolff3763 2 года назад +10

    I’m older than he is but I wish had his wisdom in my teen years.

    • @jackmorgan8931
      @jackmorgan8931 2 года назад +1

      Bill...
      Think back over your life. How did it all play out? Are you licking your wounds in self-pity and regret of maybe rather living your own version of "happy ever after"?
      My point is you were probably, as I hope "they" still say, "wise beyond your years".
      In that context, now look around: How many people, young or old, that would say are truly "wise"?
      Bill, stay safe and be well.

  • @FoxcHoney
    @FoxcHoney 2 года назад +1

    Victor Davis Hanson with the TRUTH BOMBS! NICE!

  • @macedon4049
    @macedon4049 2 года назад +2

    Pure wisdom from Mr. Hanson

  • @huyalung
    @huyalung 2 года назад +4

    Wish more people listen to what VDH has said.

  • @darsalp403
    @darsalp403 2 года назад +12

    You can not fix a flat tire with a flat tire!
    Transfer of hate is not fixing what we can not control our color. We are humans that's what we are all fighting for the same thing. Peace, equality, and freedom.

    • @johnmeckel2319
      @johnmeckel2319 2 года назад +3

      And Definitely NOT The Equity GARBAGE Currently Being Forced In Our Faces Daily!

    • @rowanaforrest9792
      @rowanaforrest9792 2 года назад +4

      @@johnmeckel2319 Equity is calculated, targeted discrimination with the goal of "evening out" everyone's achievement, but the inevitable result is limiting everyone to no better than the lowest achievers. A prime example is the "dumbing down" of education: Don't allow the motivated and brighter students to learn more faster and excel, because that will result in unequal school achievement, so lower the expectations so that even the most disinterested, laziest, and least bright students can enjoy the illusion of achieving just as much as everyone else. Never mind that they've learned practically nothing, as long as there is "equity."

    • @Lytton333
      @Lytton333 2 года назад +2

      Ethno-cultural nationhood as political or social preference does not necessarily have to imply 'hate' as a principle of existence. Multicultural lands or nations are often the most strife-ridden. Forcing it on nations that do not wish it and never sanctioned it politically is obviously going to cause endless trouble and division.

    • @rowanaforrest9792
      @rowanaforrest9792 2 года назад +1

      @@Lytton333 Very true. I think that's a large part of the reason for the intensifying anger in society. The Marxists and those wanting to, er, "blend and homogenize" the nations and cultures of the world would have the effect of not allowing any nation or society to keep their own distinct culture and values, their own distinct identity. I can't blame any nation or society for fighting back against that tooth and nail, hammer and tongs.

  • @murrayclarke2171
    @murrayclarke2171 2 года назад +2

    Victors tone and demeanor are just so engaging.

  • @Ch4os4ever
    @Ch4os4ever 2 года назад +2

    As a German trying to move into US, I agree with all his points. The reason I am yearning to leave is because the problems he describes are ahead of the curve here in Germany.