God, I miss the days when you could come home from work late in the night, fix something to eat or drink, put on MTV and just chill out to songs like this one. The 90s were so fkn great!!!
Well, it almost certainly is nostalgia, but MTV used to be a good channel back then and that's an objective fact, hehehehe. MTV should do a Reality Show about MTV in those days, xD. D.R.
Вчера был на ее концерте (27.06.24) - она, конечно, уже не молода (ей 57+), но по-прежнему с сильной энергетикой и мощнейшим вокалом. Почти 2 часа отфигачили - мама не балуй.
I met her a long time ago and hung out with her backstage for a while with my daughter. They are so nice! Offered us food and gave us autographed photos. Never forget them!!!💕
@@svetastrezeva4521 Shirley couldn’t have been nicer. She talked to us as if we were friends. We stayed for quite a while. The food was just a spread of different things. This was back in 2001. I don’t remember exactly what there was. But this was at Mt. Holyoke College in Amherst, Massachusetts. We were friends with a young guy that helped them set up their equipment so he knew my daughter belonged to her fan club so we were the only ones invited backstage. It was quite an honor!!🥰
Chris Stratton A-f’ing men to that statement. The music of AIC was essentially the soundtrack of my adolescent years. People really forget how influential their music was in the “grunge” world. And lest we not forget the vocalization harmony between Jerry and Layne....it just cannot be replicated.
This is one of those songs that you only neeed to hear once for it to lodge its self deep into your brain for the rest of your life. So haunting, so captivating, so melancholically beautiful. As an adult now, I also appreciate the lyrical content too. "I am lost, so I am cruel, but I'd be love and sweetness, if I had you".... I GET that now! I really get it!
Shirley Manson sings in the key my soul wants to hear. Fucking love this band. when we old farts sit around saying "what happened to the music you kids listen to, its not good stuff like back in my day," Garbage is one of the bands we're talking about.
Your parents must have said that about Garbage. Don't limit your own enjoyment, there is plenty of great music nowadays, just gotta look for it. I would love to share with the modern music I enjoy, but you and I probably don't like the same stuff.
There's dreck because it's a commercial industry. The key is supporting acts you like through their personal pages, websites, etc, rather than propping up the profit driven industry. Tons of great artists are taking their music directly to us, or through independent labels that give them more creative control and better payouts than the major labels that are there to prop up aging Disney radio stars.
@@katerinadicamella NO DONT GET IT TWISTED SISTER, NO PUN INTENDED, BUT THIS ISNT LOVE, ITS SICK AND TWISTED AND UN HEALTHY "LOVE"........ WE GOTTA STOP ACCEPTING MALFUNCTION AS ORDER..... CAUSE NOBODY CAN MAKE U TRULY HAPPY DEEP DOWN INSIDE YOUR SOUL TRULY, ONLY YOURSELF AND GOD AND INNOCENT ANIMALS 😇 🙏 ✨ ❤ ♥ 💖 CAN TRULY GIVE YOU TRUE LOVE. ONCE AGAIN WE GOTTA LEARN TO LOVE OURSELVES CAUSE TRUST ME FROM MUCH EXPERIENCE, IF U DONT U CANT LOVE ANYONE ELSE. IT NEEDS TO COME FROM A DEEPER AND HIGHER SOURCE THAN OURSELVES. ❤✌
I'm truly a 60's and 70's rock lover. However, this song is just wonderful. Garbage is just such a great band with very high production levels. Awesome stuff. Really one of my favs
I love melancholy yet powerful songs with an underlying synthesizer (or violin in some cases) that give you an ethereal feeling of floating through outer space. This song is easily one of my 90s favorites.
Thank you..love what you wrote and love connecting with people who love this stuff..i feel like such a loner space alien or something -so much of the time any more- having to listen to music on other people's radios etc..that usually sounds like crap. This stuff melts into my soul and lights the incense of God.
I'm 23. I was fortunate enough to grow up with this band since I was about four years old. I saw them live in 2012 with my first true love. This band will always be part of who I am.
@@psychedlicsouljam1995I get what you mean. To me when you grow up with somethings it means you was present while it was happening. That's like saying you grew up with England while they won the world cup in 66 and you was born in 2005 lol I saw Garbage multiply of times as there 1st 2nd and 3rd albums was released, that's growing up with them.
@@Deadassbruhfrfryea connecting the dots is hard for some people 😂😂😂😂. It’s evident what you meant, some ppl just like to show off how dense they are I guess. Anyways, my kids also grew up listening to them. I was 15 when they started playing Garbage on my local radio station, the World Famous KROQ, and I‘ve been a fan ever since. And they’re still killing it, just saw Garbage play last night, it was amazing! Garbage is amazing!! Absolutely love Shirley!!! ❤ ✌🏼
milk spoils when you wait too long. some things in life are worth waiting for and other things spoil while you wait. for example, sometimes an opportunity or relationship may turn sour if you wait too long on it.
I love Garbage's first album (and third) and this is, for me, their most beautiful song (and possibly one of the most beautiful songs in rock history). Shirley's vocals are so great.
Hello everyone from the 90s. I think it was the best time for music and movies. The clips could be watched all day for every taste. You can't say which band or clip is better. They were all insanely cool at the time.
I've just listened to it for about the 4th time in a row..on this dark quiet drizzley Spring night in 2020..aching for my youth..back when this song was created.
Hey, if you like this kind of songs check out: Life in Mono by Mono Miracle by Olive Heaven by Lamb Trigger Hippie by Morcheeba Paraffin by Ruby Joy and Pain by moa Two to Tango by Vanessa Daou Fall in the Light by Lori Carson any songs featuring Hope Sandoval
Hooverphonic - inhaler; Slowdive - so tired; Scala - hold me down; Ciccone Youth - g-force; Curve - cherry; Chromatics - into the black; A.R. Kane - green hazed daze; SIANspheric - this window; The Emerald Down - heavier than ether, lighter than air
I am milk I am red hot kitchen And I am cool Cool as the deep blue ocean I am lost So I am cruel But I'd be love and sweetness If I had you I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you [repeat 2x] I am weak But I am strong I can use my tears to Bring you home I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you [repeat 3x] I am milk I am red hot kitchen And I am cool Cool as the deep blue ocean I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you I'm breaking, I'm aching for you I'm waiting I'm waiting I'm waiting for you
95-96 was a pretty good time for alt-rock. I apologize, but I'm going to wax-nostalgic for a second, and say aside from a horrible (turns out prophetic) occurrence in my life, it was at once one of my better periods. I love this song, not a huge garbage fan but I like them a bit. Milk is one of my favorite songs from that time. It's an underrated classic imo.
I never knew there was this side to Garbage. It's absolutely beautiful as well as having that dark mysterious Trip Hop tone to it that I absolutely love.
Most hypnotic & haunting song ever. But here are some others that might touch some of the same buttons and might be worth a try: Rolling Stones "Heaven;" Bliss: "Wish You Were Here;" Fleetwood Mac "Brown Eyes;" Heather Nova "Winter Blue;" Loreena McKennitt "Night Ride Across the Caucasus" & "Prologue;" Wasis Diop "Everything Is Never Quite Enough;" Mazzy Star "Into Dust;" Leonard Cohen "By the Rivers Dark" & "A Thousand Kisses Deep" & "The Darkness;" Metisse "Nomah's Land;" Touch & Go "Tango in Harlem." Hope at least some of these do the trick for you
@@skurinski Portishead and Hooverphonic I know of. Wasn't aware of Massive Attack or Lamb; I will check those out. Thank you very much for the rec's. [bows deeply in appreciation]
I've found a ton of podcasts with interviews and odds and ends featuring Shirley. Just a ton, on different subjects. So there is a way to have more of her in our lives.
Love the chord changes in this song as well. And the final gothic-looking image of Shirley, after all the previous close-up lush beauty, is very effective, underlining the dark feel of the song.
All of their tracks are works of genius But this is still the standout, the one I always come back to The pinnacle of their achievements, auditory and poetic perfection Most haunting and hypnotic song ever put to vinyl... or tape... or digits.
Her beauty, while undeniable, is the least of her! Shirley has been a steadfast champion for the rights of the downtrodden since the early 90's. She's a fucking marvel of a human being. I adore her, as should we all. Beauty is fading, marvelous is forever.
A la vez me emociona y al mismo tiempo me trae una enorme nostalgia la gran canción Milk de Garbage. Unos de mis tantos recuerdos es cuando me sentaba frente a la TV y esperar a ver a la hermosa Shirley Manson. Me encanta esta canción. Mil veces es mejor la música y artistas de los 90's. Estoy feliz de haber sido parte de aquella época de oro. Saludos desde Argentina.
Amo esta canción. Es mi favorita de Garbage... No cabe duda que la música actual está en decadencia, joyas como esta difícilmente se encontrarán; Milk me produce el mismo placer de escucharla el primer día hasta hoy, diario la escucho por las mañanas y me conecta con mi YO interior
there are no words to describe how this song makes me feel...fell in love with this in my teenage years and until this day, this band has shaped who I am am.... xoxo
I consider her a timeless phenomena she transcends any era in my opinion.Just a true rare artist that holds nothing back.The whole band.And not to mention very beautiful inside and out. Aware highly conscious just brilliant
"Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you" (I read that in a Book once) I assume u already know abt "No Gods, No Masters," released last yr -- right back to their brilliance of the '90s & '00s.
except for maybe i dunno, charlotte wessels, elize ryd, floor jansen, anette olzon, sharon den adel........... just too name a few!!!!!!!! manson is a pop singer no where near the range nor power of ANY of these ladies.....
One of my favorite songs..memories..nostalgic.. hard times from the past that this song always hugged..every time I hear it feels like my heart is talking..thank you.
First heard this song in the late 90s, sitting at a Taco Bell at 10pm eating a late dinner consisting of a Taco Supreme and Burrito Supreme. I was a full time student studying electrical engineering and a part time DJ at the university across the street. I was the first person to play VOW in the Central Valley of CA. I recall tearing open the wrapper of the promotional packaging. The CD was in a olive green metal capsule. Garbage had that different sound.
Thank you Shirley. You and I had a brief moment in 1999. Last Vegas. House of Blues. I was up on the front rail. During the show a mosh pit broke out. I helped a girl from being pummeled and you pointed at me. I pointed back. That one second and a half has never left me. 20 years later and I recall it vividly. Thank you. My man cave has posters of you as a tribute. It was a great show,and I saw you many times after that. Pure respect. No objectification. You and the band- Keep f**kin rockin!!
I feel like a total tool being such a troll, but this is the one of the lamest remarks I've ever seen on a video. Image is such a waste of mentality. Sorry such a dickhead, but I couldn't let it go. No Shade, as the kids say these days...
Me pone extrañamente melancólico esta canción, que no tiene época. Es como si extrañara a un amor que no tengo todavía. La belleza y la voz de Shirley es increíble, es como una diosa nostálgica.
This song never got the attention it deserved. I remember (back in the day) hearing this on the radio for only just a couple weeks, and then #1 Crush came out, and I never heard this song on the radio again as #1 Crush blew up. Does anyone else remember that?
God, I miss the days when you could come home from work late in the night, fix something to eat or drink, put on MTV and just chill out to songs like this one. The 90s were so fkn great!!!
Greatest1979 80s even beter :D
Greatest1979
You miss your youth. That's it.
Probably so yeah....BUT even still, the 90s were fkn great!
Well, it almost certainly is nostalgia, but MTV used to be a good channel back then and that's an objective fact, hehehehe.
MTV should do a Reality Show about MTV in those days, xD. D.R.
+Greatest1979 So that isn't just an urban legend.......
There's nothing like melancholic 90's songs ..... it's just a pure perfection
Да, это Лучший уход от действительности!...
There's nothing like labeling everything...it helps one to keep thinking for oneself. Who says this is to be categorized as "melancholic" (only)?
Шикарная....2024 продолжаем балдеть под неё
Точно!
сейчас она уже не очень и песни тоже.
@@MrMaksim85rwтак 28 лет прошло
Вчера был на ее концерте (27.06.24) - она, конечно, уже не молода (ей 57+), но по-прежнему с сильной энергетикой и мощнейшим вокалом. Почти 2 часа отфигачили - мама не балуй.
и еще красивая песня! ❤
This is one of Garbage's most magical songs in my opinion. It transports me to another world, it's wonderful!
I agree
Лучший альбом.Музыка,пение,видеоклипы.😊
❤❤❤❤😊⚡✨
Agree
"You look so fine" is another one that does that, for me.
I met her a long time ago and hung out with her backstage for a while with my daughter. They are so nice! Offered us food and gave us autographed photos. Never forget them!!!💕
Wow!! What kind of food did they offer you? What was Shirley like?
@@svetastrezeva4521 Shirley couldn’t have been nicer. She talked to us as if we were friends. We stayed for quite a while. The food was just a spread of different things. This was back in 2001. I don’t remember exactly what there was. But this was at Mt. Holyoke College in Amherst, Massachusetts. We were friends with a young guy that helped them set up their equipment so he knew my daughter belonged to her fan club so we were the only ones invited backstage. It was quite an honor!!🥰
As Shirley Manson said... "Is the darkest, most hopeless of the songs...". Just an amazing song
Where, when did she say this? I need to find this interview
my darknees on my life.
@@davidleon5422 Darkness*
"a stroke of luck" as well.
Darkness of my life*
Is love
This pains me....makes me miss the 90's something fierce... such a wonderful time for music.
I feel the same, I pretty much use You tube as a nostalgia machine
Actually no the 90's pretty much sucked @$$ for music. j/s
Same here! Lol
@@cara1111 The 80s were good too but the 90s... All I need to say there is AIC.
Chris Stratton A-f’ing men to that statement. The music of AIC was essentially the soundtrack of my adolescent years. People really forget how influential their music was in the “grunge” world. And lest we not forget the vocalization harmony between Jerry and Layne....it just cannot be replicated.
1997..in the car .. listening to this song with a person I just met...tears rolling down our faces. We finally found eachother. Together since then.
Omg that sounds amazing. You are so lucky!
This is straight out of a movie.. and SO lucky
Damn brother... In nomine Patris, et Filii, et Spiritus Sancti - Ave!
Her music looks in to your soul and drags out feelings you didn't even know you've buried.
U dig
Alluring.............
Garbage 2.0 was my MAIN CD!
Fucking A-
This is one of those songs that you only neeed to hear once for it to lodge its self deep into your brain for the rest of your life. So haunting, so captivating, so melancholically beautiful. As an adult now, I also appreciate the lyrical content too. "I am lost, so I am cruel, but I'd be love and sweetness, if I had you".... I GET that now! I really get it!
This is definitely my favorite Garbage song. It is incredible and Shirley's vocals are haunting. She looks absolutely beautiful in this video.
My favorite is Paranoid :)
So ethereal and mystic. Those blurred and flashy with the beans are beautiful too
@@stevenf5902 that & push it
Milk, push it and Vow are my 3 fabs
SO haunting. The perfect last song for their album at the time. Leaves you wanting more.
Shirley Manson sings in the key my soul wants to hear. Fucking love this band. when we old farts sit around saying "what happened to the music you kids listen to, its not good stuff like back in my day," Garbage is one of the bands we're talking about.
Your parents must have said that about Garbage.
Don't limit your own enjoyment, there is plenty of great music nowadays, just gotta look for it.
I would love to share with the modern music I enjoy, but you and I probably don't like the same stuff.
amen, thing is why the hell is there so much dreck &
oh & ofc, "De gustibus non est disputandum" -.-'
not much work goes ino makin oneself a decent playlist tho.
There's dreck because it's a commercial industry. The key is supporting acts you like through their personal pages, websites, etc, rather than propping up the profit driven industry. Tons of great artists are taking their music directly to us, or through independent labels that give them more creative control and better payouts than the major labels that are there to prop up aging Disney radio stars.
Lipzig Schweitzer luckily garbage are still going. You should check out their most recent album "Strange Little Birds."
"I am lost so I am cruel, but I'd be love and sweetness if I had you."
Shaine MacDonald lol that’s my favorite lyric
Simple but right to the point if you are in love!!
'I am rust, so I am cruel'
Wonderful lyrics
@@katerinadicamella NO DONT GET IT TWISTED SISTER, NO PUN INTENDED, BUT THIS ISNT LOVE, ITS SICK AND TWISTED AND UN HEALTHY "LOVE"........
WE GOTTA STOP ACCEPTING MALFUNCTION AS ORDER..... CAUSE NOBODY CAN MAKE U TRULY HAPPY DEEP DOWN INSIDE YOUR SOUL TRULY, ONLY YOURSELF AND GOD AND INNOCENT ANIMALS 😇 🙏 ✨ ❤ ♥ 💖 CAN TRULY GIVE YOU TRUE LOVE. ONCE AGAIN WE GOTTA LEARN TO LOVE OURSELVES CAUSE TRUST ME FROM MUCH EXPERIENCE, IF U DONT U CANT LOVE ANYONE ELSE. IT NEEDS TO COME FROM A DEEPER AND HIGHER SOURCE THAN OURSELVES. ❤✌
I'm truly a 60's and 70's rock lover. However, this song is just wonderful. Garbage is just such a great band with very high production levels. Awesome stuff. Really one of my favs
Lies again? Breast Feeding
"Not everyone is born smart", and that's a shame!!!
@@NazriB WTF? 🤣
I love melancholy yet powerful songs with an underlying synthesizer (or violin in some cases) that give you an ethereal feeling of floating through outer space. This song is easily one of my 90s favorites.
Thank you..love what you wrote and love connecting with people who love this stuff..i feel like such a loner space alien or something -so much of the time any more- having to listen to music on other people's radios etc..that usually sounds like crap. This stuff melts into my soul and lights the incense of God.
You're welcome! You're definitely not the only one who likes this sort of music. There are others of us out there.
Any song suggestions that would fit in that description?
@@kuppikahvikeisari9120 Nights In White Satin by The Moody Blues is a good one
@@stephp5616 I actually listen to both of those quite often! Especially Gotye, so very on point suggestions, thank you anyway! :>
One of the best female vocals of the 90's, coolest song ever ¡¡¡
omar m xlzksj&hehjjsjfhhdhfhrr
Uuugh today vocals I can only go for lady gaga.. the rest is just on records these days
listen to 2.0.....it gets even better .
It’s ‘90s. Not 90’s. It’s not possessive. The apostrophe up front let’s the reader know the 19 is missing.
Still sounds the best in 2022
Yes!!
Absolutely!
2023
In 2022 beautiful. In 2023 even more beautiful.
in 2023 too
This is such a gorgeous example of Shirley's singing. I have absolutely loved this song since it was first released
me too! I have also loved garbage's Siren remix of Milk. Love the synths and vocals are hauntingly beautiful
Still their greatest song. A timeless classic.
This here's pure 90s magic. Shirley Manson sings this so dreamily. This is truly breathtaking.
I'm 23. I was fortunate enough to grow up with this band since I was about four years old. I saw them live in 2012 with my first true love. This band will always be part of who I am.
That means u didn't grow up with them.if u were born in 98
@@psychedlicsouljam1995 math is hard for you, isn't it?
@@psychedlicsouljam1995Music is timeless. You can grow with older music than you are.
@@psychedlicsouljam1995I get what you mean. To me when you grow up with somethings it means you was present while it was happening. That's like saying you grew up with England while they won the world cup in 66 and you was born in 2005 lol I saw Garbage multiply of times as there 1st 2nd and 3rd albums was released, that's growing up with them.
@@Deadassbruhfrfryea connecting the dots is hard for some people 😂😂😂😂. It’s evident what you meant, some ppl just like to show off how dense they are I guess. Anyways, my kids also grew up listening to them. I was 15 when they started playing Garbage on my local radio station, the World Famous KROQ, and I‘ve been a fan ever since. And they’re still killing it, just saw Garbage play last night, it was amazing! Garbage is amazing!! Absolutely love Shirley!!! ❤ ✌🏼
milk spoils when you wait too long. some things in life are worth waiting for and other things spoil while you wait. for example, sometimes an opportunity or relationship may turn sour if you wait too long on it.
That's brilliant!
doll367 true
How true that is.
ayan don’t act surprised if it ends up being poisoned ;)
and then some things are rushed into and fail instantly like everything in my life. might as well get a tattoo on my forehead that spells out “FAIL”.🤪
Still shivers down my spine when I listen to this beautiful song.
Same. If I had to describe this song in one word, it would be:
Operatic
Always
I love Garbage's first album (and third) and this is, for me, their most beautiful song (and possibly one of the most beautiful songs in rock history). Shirley's vocals are so great.
it gives me an art rock vibe lol see also Dead Can Dance, peace out :)
Hello everyone from the 90s. I think it was the best time for music and movies. The clips could be watched all day for every taste. You can't say which band or clip is better. They were all insanely cool at the time.
This song has a mysterious dreamy like allure to it. I can definitely veg out to music like this.
I've just listened to it for about the 4th time in a row..on this dark quiet drizzley Spring night in 2020..aching for my youth..back when this song was created.
I have an obsession with this heavenly and nostalgic sound
Hey, if you like this kind of songs check out:
Life in Mono by Mono
Miracle by Olive
Heaven by Lamb
Trigger Hippie by Morcheeba
Paraffin by Ruby
Joy and Pain by moa
Two to Tango by Vanessa Daou
Fall in the Light by Lori Carson
any songs featuring Hope Sandoval
Hooverphonic - inhaler; Slowdive - so tired; Scala - hold me down; Ciccone Youth - g-force; Curve - cherry; Chromatics - into the black; A.R. Kane - green hazed daze; SIANspheric - this window; The Emerald Down - heavier than ether, lighter than air
I am milk
I am red hot kitchen
And I am cool
Cool as the deep blue ocean
I am lost
So I am cruel
But I'd be love and sweetness
If I had you
I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you [repeat 2x]
I am weak
But I am strong
I can use my tears to
Bring you home
I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you [repeat 3x]
I am milk
I am red hot kitchen
And I am cool
Cool as the deep blue ocean
I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you
I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you
I'm waiting, I'm waiting for you
I'm breaking, I'm aching for you
I'm waiting
I'm waiting
I'm waiting for you
I thought so too, but at 2:27 you can clearly see her lips don't come together to make the 'p' bilabial plosive sound. So it can't be "top".
red top ketchup...says
the lyric insert of the original release.
Slow Jazz
Slow Jazz k
Shes Pregnant and waiting for her baby
Listening to this amazing timeless song in 2024 ..
July 2024 ❤
Still favorite in 2024❤
I Ageee She is Rad.
20 years song and still rock!!!
Od
95-96 was a pretty good time for alt-rock. I apologize, but I'm going to wax-nostalgic for a second, and say aside from a horrible (turns out prophetic) occurrence in my life, it was at once one of my better periods. I love this song, not a huge garbage fan but I like them a bit. Milk is one of my favorite songs from that time. It's an underrated classic imo.
And she still beautiful...love her face and voice...heavenly
what? are you saying that time de-rock songs? pff
Nope, i said that she still beatiful like her songs..like they music band`s...salute!
You can just get lost in her eyes and her voice is hypnotic
Amen
Суперская песня зачаровывает... 👍😍
One of the best albums ever made. Still in my heavy rotation after all these years.
Beautiful song... beautiful melody. I love Manson' s voice. Its like velvet
I love this song. It's so magical... so dark... so hypnotic...
I never knew there was this side to Garbage. It's absolutely beautiful as well as having that dark mysterious Trip Hop tone to it that I absolutely love.
Most hypnotic & haunting song ever. But here are some others that might touch some of the same buttons and might be worth a try: Rolling Stones "Heaven;" Bliss: "Wish You Were Here;" Fleetwood Mac "Brown Eyes;" Heather Nova "Winter Blue;" Loreena McKennitt "Night Ride Across the Caucasus" & "Prologue;" Wasis Diop "Everything Is Never Quite Enough;" Mazzy Star "Into Dust;" Leonard Cohen "By the Rivers Dark" & "A Thousand Kisses Deep" & "The Darkness;" Metisse "Nomah's Land;" Touch & Go "Tango in Harlem." Hope at least some of these do the trick for you
@@smartalek180 i'd recomend trip hop artists Massive Attack, Portishead, Lamb, Hooverphonic
@@skurinski Portishead and Hooverphonic I know of.
Wasn't aware of Massive Attack or Lamb; I will check those out.
Thank you very much for the rec's. [bows deeply in appreciation]
Who else misses the 90s? I do. 😢
Wow. Those chords in the first chorus still give me goosebumps
Diciembre 2019!!!!
Esto si es música, no la porquería que está saliendo!
20 years?
Wowza
Still a great song.
I'll put this song up against any song out in 2016
agree
Forgive my blasphemy. Is and always will be a great song.
No one could sing like them. Absolutely unique music.
Gods it's a crime there's not more Shirley Manson in my life...her presence is powerful and radiant.
I'm sure she feels the same way, about you!
I've found a ton of podcasts with interviews and odds and ends featuring Shirley. Just a ton, on different subjects. So there is a way to have more of her in our lives.
Holy cow. They killed it. I am such a huge fan but wow. And Shirley sounded so great. One of my favorite voices to listen to. Wow
Love the chord changes in this song as well. And the final gothic-looking image of Shirley, after all the previous close-up lush beauty, is very effective, underlining the dark feel of the song.
Very moving song that brings up unique memories
Toujours aussi bon en 2024 et je ne m'en lasserai jamais ! 🥰
Смотю из россии. Поймите меня правильно! Без политике.
The vocal and musical masterpiece.
Эта песня - шедевр на все времена!
И исполнение и сама композиция гениальны!
My husband passed in 2017. I feel this. Miss him every single day. Still waiting for him.
Stay strong friend
I hope you're doing okay!
haunting yet another beautiful song by Garbage.
All of their tracks are works of genius
But this is still the standout, the one I always come back to
The pinnacle of their achievements, auditory and poetic perfection
Most haunting and hypnotic song ever put to vinyl... or tape... or digits.
This is one of my top 5 favorite garbage videos
I love how she can shred in one song and then do something like this.
ufff devastadoramente bella canción de Garbage , pasan los años y es una joya.
Shirley Manson is most beautiful rock star of all time.
specially in this video
She is not! She's the most beautiful political woman on Earth! If she ran for president she'd have my vote!💯
I agree
Her beauty, while undeniable, is the least of her! Shirley has been a steadfast champion for the rights of the downtrodden since the early 90's. She's a fucking marvel of a human being. I adore her, as should we all.
Beauty is fading, marvelous is forever.
70-s aren't that ancient man. Haven't seen Blondie? Cheers!
A la vez me emociona y al mismo tiempo me trae una enorme nostalgia la gran canción Milk de Garbage. Unos de mis tantos recuerdos es cuando me sentaba frente a la TV y esperar a ver a la hermosa Shirley Manson.
Me encanta esta canción. Mil veces es mejor la música y artistas de los 90's. Estoy feliz de haber sido parte de aquella época de oro.
Saludos desde Argentina.
Amo esta canción. Es mi favorita de Garbage... No cabe duda que la música actual está en decadencia, joyas como esta difícilmente se encontrarán; Milk me produce el mismo placer de escucharla el primer día hasta hoy, diario la escucho por las mañanas y me conecta con mi YO interior
2022 and this song came into my mind again from my deepest memories. Still waiting for you.
The ultimate siren song.
there are no words to describe how this song makes me feel...fell in love with this in my teenage years and until this day, this band has shaped who I am am.... xoxo
This sounds like a James Bond song to me, but I know that Garbage did World is Not Enough for a James Bond movie.
My thoughts exactly. Would have been a perfect Bond song.
That theme was easily the best part of the movie. (The World Is Not Enough, I mean. Great track, but not a great film.)
I think Untouchable from Beautiful Garbage is a perfect Bond theme
Exactly...no wonder they did a Bond theme song...they have the sound
her voice is sublime - only she can 'produce' a "YOU" the way she does.
so nice, it's a drug...
i wish i were the you for someone like this ;-)
Gaëtan Bonny ...and not the "you" in stabbing westward's "shame"?
not sure i get your point. sorry
Gaëtan Bonny :') your comment is beautiful.
What about Soldja boio "You"?
Great Band to bring back great times. Aaaah the 90's
I consider her a timeless phenomena she transcends any era in my opinion.Just a true rare artist that holds nothing back.The whole band.And not to mention very beautiful inside and out. Aware highly conscious just brilliant
Loved this song. It was the last track on the 1995 album..beautiful ❤️❤️
My favourite female rocker in the world. Shirley is just incredible I hope she makes a 6th album someday.
"Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you"
(I read that in a Book once)
I assume u already know abt "No Gods, No Masters," released last yr -- right back to their brilliance of the '90s & '00s.
I love this band, Shirley has the best range and power of any modern vocalist, they have never done a bad album, love em
except for maybe i dunno, charlotte wessels, elize ryd, floor jansen, anette olzon, sharon den adel........... just too name a few!!!!!!!! manson is a pop singer no where near the range nor power of ANY of these ladies.....
The song,her hair,her make up😍❤❤
Shirley's incomparable voice
Cada vez que la escucho es como una primera vez. Comienza el viaje por "utopía". Embriagadora, fascinante. Obscénamente bella.
Every song she performs is amazing
This song is just priceless... And it will always be.
Love this tune
Haunting beauty.
Shirley Manson, Alanis and Dolores O'Riordan are the best female singers of the 90s
idle1337 Fiona Apple as well! And a kickass piano player
Don’t forget Tori Amos
Where have all the Rock Goddesses gone?
How can you forget about pj Harvey?!?!?!
idle1337 Björk too
Great band! Great song! And Shirley is drop dead gorgeous!
Uno de los temas mas tristes y melancolicos de Garbage, me encanta
One of my favorite songs..memories..nostalgic.. hard times from the past that this song always hugged..every time I hear it feels like my heart is talking..thank you.
15.1.2023~🎧 Une magnifique chanson d’amour♥️♥️et la merveilleuse voix d’une sublime Chanteuse qui vous ensorcelle.💎🥀🇫🇷
Gerade seit Jahren wieder gehört und eine Gänsehaut bekommen. So ein tolles Lied!
Garbage is one of my favorit bands. 😘
One of our favourites in the 90s!!! And still is!
Yes! June 2024. Barcelona. In 10 days will be a concert of Garbage.😊❤
I can't believe I still love it as much😁😌🕯️🫶
My 12 year old self had exquisite music taste. So proud of myself, patting my back lol
Agreed🙂
I'd like to think my 12 year old self would have been that cool... but I was 28 lol
First heard this song in the late 90s, sitting at a Taco Bell at 10pm eating a late dinner consisting of a Taco Supreme and Burrito Supreme. I was a full time student studying electrical engineering and a part time DJ at the university across the street. I was the first person to play VOW in the Central Valley of CA. I recall tearing open the wrapper of the promotional packaging. The CD was in a olive green metal capsule. Garbage had that different sound.
I thank my ears for understanding good music.
Thank you Shirley. You and I had a brief moment in 1999. Last Vegas. House of Blues. I was up on the front rail. During the show a mosh pit broke out. I helped a girl from being pummeled and you pointed at me. I pointed back. That one second and a half has never left me. 20 years later and I recall it vividly. Thank you. My man cave has posters of you as a tribute. It was a great show,and I saw you many times after that. Pure respect. No objectification. You and the band- Keep f**kin rockin!!
I still love this song as much as I did when it first came out.
Still a haunting song. She has that essence of Harley Quinn madness to her.
She was roughly 30 in this song.
Indinsong
I feel like a total tool being such a troll, but this is the one of the lamest remarks I've ever seen on a video. Image is such a waste of mentality. Sorry such a dickhead, but I couldn't let it go. No Shade, as the kids say these days...
What image would that be?
More like Poison Ivy.
Me pone extrañamente melancólico esta canción, que no tiene época. Es como si extrañara a un amor que no tengo todavía. La belleza y la voz de Shirley es increíble, es como una diosa nostálgica.
BIEN PAJA
Listado Top 5 de satanica no tiene ni un pelo
Ayahuaska Pop Exactamente 🙁😔😓
Una belleza escocesa!!!me encanta su voz
La letra dice que espera por alguien
Omg I fell in love Shirley!
This song never got the attention it deserved. I remember (back in the day) hearing this on the radio for only just a couple weeks, and then #1 Crush came out, and I never heard this song on the radio again as #1 Crush blew up. Does anyone else remember that?
Shirley ...... that Sea Siren Voice ... Just Heaven Sent !
I love this song. . . so dreamy.
I will always love this band. Much, much love to Shirley and the boys. 💙💖💜
She has such a haunting voice and EYES, just wow
90s the music and a million different individual voices. The free youth of the 90s was nothing short of a beautiful gift to us from the music God's.
She is a straight up siren