@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 Y’all always have something to complain about her 💀 She was amazing! She was the one who sounded like the studio version and the most stable. Also she did hype the crowd maybe not as mush as the others but she did. Still I do agree that she needs to improve her stp a little more but in general she did her best! So let’s be happy about that :)❤️
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 how you know she did not enjoy the performance, you can read her like a book or what. Did you really watch her fancam up close, if not, i find your cmt about stage presence really unsound. Not everyone has to yell, to look like being hyped up to "trully" enjoy sth. Out there, there are people like her and me who are just calm, and have the balance. Finally, we have Karina, Ning Ning and Giselle, they are the center of the festival.
Winter vocals is so crazily stable.She’s really the daughter of yyj.People said that her stage presence was bad but actually you can clearly see that she was smiling enjoying herself and also hyping the crowd sometimes.People always want to find a way to hate her.Why don’t we just praising her
Ikr, Some people reply on comments complimenting Winter's stability and say "but she's boring" "she had the least stage presence" "She's lacking" and blah blah Can't we just compliment Winter in peace?
She sounded exactly like the studio version and the also the way she sang the last chorus of next level She really meant when she said I am on the next level
@@mybmyacc yeah we’re just complimenting and praising her in peace but they ruined it.We just want the best for our winter if they don’t like her just be quiet
@@bad_kmj2467 True... She's really a walking studio. Her voice sounds so clean. There were a lot of times I thought she wasn't singing live, because she sounds so much like the studio version. But she was actually singing live. In other videos, I thought her mic had some kind of echo or some effects, but it didn't have any effect, it was really just her raw vocals. Her raw vocals sounds like a studio version.
Omg, finaly someone have the same point with me. From the first ningning debut teaser, i notice that she has the same vibe with tiffany. Her smile, and i never imagine she will this similiar with fanny.
Weird for me Karina has so much confidence when she is on stage like really confident and charismatic person when she is performing but as well is subjective taste when it comes to stage presence
@@tayloristhemusicindustry3283 well but we can be a main dancer if karina hadn't debuted but karina can't be a main vocalist even without winter winter is a lead vocalist but her main capability is singing which she is phenomenal at but karinas main capability, dancing, people often prefer winter's dancing
@@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965 How can Karina not be main vocalist when she is literally better than a lot of main vocalists of 4th generation, and Karina have definitely better dancing skills, it's not about people's preference it's about who is more skilled technically, Karina have better rapping skills and better stage presence than Winter
The girls did good despite being tossed to Coachella out of the blue without any good experiences in interacting with live audiences. Just imagine how nervous they must’ve been on stage. People are quick to judge without considering how new they really are into the Kpop world and during the pandemic too, they just want to put them down and sing high praises to their fav group.
Lol I’m actually touched that Karina’s vocal got appreciated somehow 😭 I also hope she can have more confidence and less nervous when singing cos when she relaxes and sings on bubble causally, those sounded so nice actually. Though it also seem different from the way she sings in Aespa songs?
Yea because shes not the main vocal in aespa n aespa music is kinda diff from what karina best at n before she debut as idol. Shes good n she got really soothing warm voice/vocal
So tired about people complaining about Winter's energy. While everyone appreciates the other members, ya'll always have something to say to her even though she excelled in her own way. SHE WAS THE MOST STABLE, of course, she needs to compensate for that not to move much around. Think like Taeyeon, she conserves her energy to hit her high notes live too. For me Winter was really charismatic here idk about yall but Winter shines in her own way.
Actually people have something to hate about each member like someone was not looking pretty, someone was nervous, someone didn't shine etc. Instead of praising what they excel at ,people are just hating on them
"While everyone appreciates the other members," Ningning was literally criticised so much by korean ( because they are xenophobic ). Winter was praised so much by the koreans.
@@mariahlol2488 really? I mean even in the recent comeback "girls" fans were hating on Winter for getting high notes as if she don't deserve it? She might be more biased in korea but international fans don't really appreciate her that much. I mean she's the visual but fans will even choose Karina over here. She's always been treated like a "filler" member even though she has a lot to offer.
Karina has my favorite voice tone while singing in the group! Her voice is so unique and addicting. Their energy at coachella was crazy. I can't wait to go to an AESPA concert.
actually aaron have two bias in aespa winter and ningning. He said in his previous reaction video in Aespa Savage MV that he don't consider ningning as bias wrecker because ningning is her one his bias alongside with winter.
Winter, Karina, Giselle, Ningning just keep slaying girls🔥 I mean we all know Aespa is still new and there is always room for improvement which our girls are always open to..they even said they practice every day to improve and become better.. i hope people would be kinder or mindful on their words because constructive criticism is always welcomed but not pure jealousy and hatred...
It's nice to see comments full of positivity and support because it's getting tired reading people dragging aespa down when they really did a great job. I'm just super proud of them. They've always been criticized for "lipsync" but they proved they do capable to sing live, to 3 energy drowning songs, in a big stage & outside of South Korea, this itself already is a great achievement. I hope regardless the negative news, Aespa girls could see too that so many more people actually praising and loving their performance💕
Ikr i didn't expect these comments to be positive. Since the day they announced that they are going to Coachella, people have been dragging them a LOT on twitter. Whenever i watch their performance, people keep mentioning Blackpink and bring down aespa. It's just a music festival but k-pop fans make everything a competition 😭
@@baralsujal2004 exactly.. i'm so not a competitive person, so seeing as if everything is a match or something is better than the other is so tiring. I get that when a group reach some milestone on their career it's amazing, and they need to do something like that sometimes so they can stay popular especially to avoid disbandment. But seriously tho, because of the "competition" people starting losing sight of the main point which is the musics and performances. Music is to be enjoyed not to be compared to one another, just because one song got more popular/viral than others doesn't mean the others have no talent or have no good songs. If you look closer you'll see there's so much more to offer, some just don't get the same spotlight as the others
Gosh yes I'm so over it! Why can't we just praise them for the fact that they got this opportunity and then did so amazingly, especially considering all the crap they've had to face since debut. Why does it always have to be about who has the best stage presence or the best vocals? WHO CARES??!!! Just enjoy the music and the performance, and if you didn't like it then move on and watch something that you do like. It's not that hard.
What's more amazing is the fact that the girls were trying their best to overpower the loud backtrack and they actually managed to do it well. It's not a 100% perfectly live performance but in my opinion they might be one of the best KPOP group to perform live.
REACT TO - WINTER - ~ Secret Garden ~ All about you ~ Yours GISELLE - ~ ZOO (with NCT)【Self-written】 ~ SECOND (with hyoyeon)【Self-written】 ~ SYNK【Self-written】 ~ Did You Wrong ~ Tia Tamera KARINA - ~ Childish Adult ~ Bola Rebola ~ Mr. Simple NINGNING - ~ Mariah ~ If I ain't got you ~ Way (with ONEW) ~ That Summer when we Graduated【Self-composed】 ~ Rolling in the deep INTERVIEWS: Song Association, Harper Bazaar, Allure Korea, 24 Hours with VOGUE
Winter sounds so stable but her energy did not match the energy of the other three but that's fine. Giselle and Ningning stood out and their energy really carried all of their performances. I can't wait to see more of their live performances, and for sure all of them will do better. ❤
@@부채-i8h it isnt always about being perfectly on pitch on the stage but about the stage presence or probably them too enjoying their own performance like the girls did.❤
You were so invested in that reaction, that was so wholesome to see! Thank you for all your work on this channel man, I feel like I have someone who I can watch kpop with
Yeah . The first time I heard Savage, that was exactly my reaction to Karina's riffs and runs. Her voice is flavorful. Idk if I can have a permanent bias to Aespa 😂 I keep changing overtime every comeback or performance. Oh, I like them.
imo they had the best stage presence during next level, it was the last song they performed and you could tell they loosened up more after getting comfortable on stage
giselle's rapp was soo good, winter persistant vocal, and ningning whose got a chance to slap haters with her live vocal, and that "naAAAiiiSSeehh" are my fav part of this reaction video XD
Tụi nó nhắm vào fancam cuối Next Level đó.... Mong anh ấy reaction Next Level để xem ảnh nhận xét như thế nào..... Vì bài này là bài cuối nhóm hát rồi nhưng rõ ràng giọng hát vẫn ổn chứ đâu có tệ như anti phán
i really really like your reaction, thank u so much always appreciate karina's vocal~ please stay healthy aaron! can't wait to see more your reaction to aespa. please reaction to LA Vlog aespa at coachella, once again thank you
Hello aaron I came to tell you that the new and the first girl group of HYBE has already debuted, the song is so good can you react them all with the debut album please (LESSERAFIM fearless)
Hello aaron I came to tell you that the new and the first girl group of HYBE has already debuted, the song is so good can you react them all with the debut album please (LESSERAFIM fearless)
Tbh they were trying to hype it up because if you can compare it to their mv or encore it's way more louder and they modulated some parts like on Giselle's part (everybody look at me) there but it's just that the arrangements are so poor.
![NOSFERATU - Official Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters December 25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nulvWqYUM8k/mqdefault.jpg)
winter was never out of pitch during the whole performances. she's THAT good.
yes, but she was so focused on the vocals that she forgot about her stage presence, and most importantly, enjoying the performance and feeling herself
Yeaah, also i love her cute smile during life's too short💝
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 did we watch the same winter?
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 Y’all always have something to complain about her 💀 She was amazing! She was the one who sounded like the studio version and the most stable. Also she did hype the crowd maybe not as mush as the others but she did. Still I do agree that she needs to improve her stp a little more but in general she did her best! So let’s be happy about that :)❤️
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 how you know she did not enjoy the performance, you can read her like a book or what. Did you really watch her fancam up close, if not, i find your cmt about stage presence really unsound. Not everyone has to yell, to look like being hyped up to "trully" enjoy sth. Out there, there are people like her and me who are just calm, and have the balance. Finally, we have Karina, Ning Ning and Giselle, they are the center of the festival.
Winter vocals is so crazily stable.She’s really the daughter of yyj.People said that her stage presence was bad but actually you can clearly see that she was smiling enjoying herself and also hyping the crowd sometimes.People always want to find a way to hate her.Why don’t we just praising her
Ikr, Some people reply on comments complimenting Winter's stability and say "but she's boring" "she had the least stage presence" "She's lacking" and blah blah
Can't we just compliment Winter in peace?
She sounded exactly like the studio version and the also the way she sang the last chorus of next level
She really meant when she said I am on the next level
@@mybmyacc yeah we’re just complimenting and praising her in peace but they ruined it.We just want the best for our winter if they don’t like her just be quiet
@@anubhav9868 her new nickname the walking studio.Her live vocals is out of this world
@@bad_kmj2467 True... She's really a walking studio. Her voice sounds so clean. There were a lot of times I thought she wasn't singing live, because she sounds so much like the studio version. But she was actually singing live. In other videos, I thought her mic had some kind of echo or some effects, but it didn't have any effect, it was really just her raw vocals. Her raw vocals sounds like a studio version.
the energy of ningning it really reminds me of Girls generation stages , especially Tiffany was really ON FIRE and energetic on stage
SM vibe
Yeaahh!! I agree I'm a SONE, her energy like Tiffany💗
6:40 even the way she walks here xD
I really dont know about tifanny level but she was good
Omg, finaly someone have the same point with me. From the first ningning debut teaser, i notice that she has the same vibe with tiffany. Her smile, and i never imagine she will this similiar with fanny.
and NingNing 'sexy' vibe like Yuri and of course, her 'laugh' definitely copy paste from Sunny 😂💜🌶
Weird for me Karina has so much confidence when she is on stage like really confident and charismatic person when she is performing but as well is subjective taste when it comes to stage presence
yeah i really like her😭
Karina was dancing hard and still hitting those runs/riffs! That's why she is the ACE of aespa, I'm very happy that you appreciate her voice ^^
aespa has naur ace but an all rounder which is winter
@@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965 i like winter but she can’t dance or rap as good as karina, sorry
@@tayloristhemusicindustry3283 well but we can be a main dancer if karina hadn't debuted but karina can't be a main vocalist even without winter
winter is a lead vocalist but her main capability is singing which she is phenomenal at but karinas main capability, dancing, people often prefer winter's dancing
@@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965 How can Karina not be main vocalist when she is literally better than a lot of main vocalists of 4th generation, and Karina have definitely better dancing skills, it's not about people's preference it's about who is more skilled technically, Karina have better rapping skills and better stage presence than Winter
@@thatssuspicious279 babe I didn't say winter is better . I just stated that winter can be a main dancer and please read my comment clearly
The girls did good despite being tossed to Coachella out of the blue without any good experiences in interacting with live audiences. Just imagine how nervous they must’ve been on stage. People are quick to judge without considering how new they really are into the Kpop world and during the pandemic too, they just want to put them down and sing high praises to their fav group.
their literally FIRST live performance omg
Lol I’m actually touched that Karina’s vocal got appreciated somehow 😭 I also hope she can have more confidence and less nervous when singing cos when she relaxes and sings on bubble causally, those sounded so nice actually. Though it also seem different from the way she sings in Aespa songs?
Yea because shes not the main vocal in aespa n aespa music is kinda diff from what karina best at n before she debut as idol. Shes good n she got really soothing warm voice/vocal
So tired about people complaining about Winter's energy. While everyone appreciates the other members, ya'll always have something to say to her even though she excelled in her own way. SHE WAS THE MOST STABLE, of course, she needs to compensate for that not to move much around. Think like Taeyeon, she conserves her energy to hit her high notes live too. For me Winter was really charismatic here idk about yall but Winter shines in her own way.
Actually people have something to hate about each member like someone was not looking pretty, someone was nervous, someone didn't shine etc. Instead of praising what they excel at ,people are just hating on them
"While everyone appreciates the other members," Ningning was literally criticised so much by korean ( because they are xenophobic ). Winter was praised so much by the koreans.
u seem very biased ur saying people hate winter and only winter but guess what the other members gets twice the hate while shes more appreciated
@@mariahlol2488 really? I mean even in the recent comeback "girls" fans were hating on Winter for getting high notes as if she don't deserve it? She might be more biased in korea but international fans don't really appreciate her that much. I mean she's the visual but fans will even choose Karina over here. She's always been treated like a "filler" member even though she has a lot to offer.
@@jbonceu2457 yes giselle been more hated and ningning is more hated bc of her race
So glad you're appreciating Karina's voice too 😭😭
Karina has my favorite voice tone while singing in the group! Her voice is so unique and addicting.
Their energy at coachella was crazy. I can't wait to go to an AESPA concert.
Aespa's vocals are no joke❤
Next level and lifes to short nextt 🥺💜💜
Aarón forever 💜👏🥰
*Aaron We really want you to react to “Aespa (re: MASTERPIECE) dreams come true”! You will love the vocals* 🥺❤️
YAASSSSSSS
He already reacted to it
@@joselyneaparicio7012 when?? over on patreon?
YESS PLSSS
YESSSS
Aespa’s live vocals really are insane
Ning ning so active but still sing good. Dance hard and sing hard. Cool
Karina sounded so good. You are right
Giselle and Karin's voice and energy really surprised me, they really shined!
Seems like aaron got bias wrecked by ningning.She’s something else at coachella.I almost got wrecked too by her
actually aaron have two bias in aespa winter and ningning. He said in his previous reaction video in Aespa Savage MV that he don't consider ningning as bias wrecker because ningning is her one his bias alongside with winter.
@@remelyalamis742 oh yeah because in next level I think he said that winter was her bias and ningning his bias wrecker
Winter, Karina, Giselle, Ningning just keep slaying girls🔥
I mean we all know Aespa is still new and there is always room for improvement which our girls are always open to..they even said they practice every day to improve and become better.. i hope people would be kinder or mindful on their words because constructive criticism is always welcomed but not pure jealousy and hatred...
Karina is an ace and all rounder in the group
Just all rounder
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 she is a ace too.
@@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 KARINA IS AN ACE. WINTER IS AN ALL AROUNDER.
@@xoenthusiast6477 Both of them are all rounder and Karina is Ace....
Both of them are Ace
Winter this time kill it✨💗
She is so amazing
@@eulalia3468 not for us. Duh.
@@eulalia3468 stop complaining cuz stage presence isn't only shouting and stuff
It's nice to see comments full of positivity and support because it's getting tired reading people dragging aespa down when they really did a great job. I'm just super proud of them. They've always been criticized for "lipsync" but they proved they do capable to sing live, to 3 energy drowning songs, in a big stage & outside of South Korea, this itself already is a great achievement. I hope regardless the negative news, Aespa girls could see too that so many more people actually praising and loving their performance💕
Ikr i didn't expect these comments to be positive. Since the day they announced that they are going to Coachella, people have been dragging them a LOT on twitter. Whenever i watch their performance, people keep mentioning Blackpink and bring down aespa. It's just a music festival but k-pop fans make everything a competition 😭
@@baralsujal2004 exactly.. i'm so not a competitive person, so seeing as if everything is a match or something is better than the other is so tiring. I get that when a group reach some milestone on their career it's amazing, and they need to do something like that sometimes so they can stay popular especially to avoid disbandment. But seriously tho, because of the "competition" people starting losing sight of the main point which is the musics and performances. Music is to be enjoyed not to be compared to one another, just because one song got more popular/viral than others doesn't mean the others have no talent or have no good songs. If you look closer you'll see there's so much more to offer, some just don't get the same spotlight as the others
Gosh yes I'm so over it! Why can't we just praise them for the fact that they got this opportunity and then did so amazingly, especially considering all the crap they've had to face since debut. Why does it always have to be about who has the best stage presence or the best vocals? WHO CARES??!!! Just enjoy the music and the performance, and if you didn't like it then move on and watch something that you do like. It's not that hard.
Yall know that alot of toxic channel been grown since this choachella ......
What's more amazing is the fact that the girls were trying their best to overpower the loud backtrack and they actually managed to do it well. It's not a 100% perfectly live performance but in my opinion they might be one of the best KPOP group to perform live.
REACT TO -
WINTER -
~ Secret Garden
~ All about you
~ Yours
GISELLE -
~ ZOO (with NCT)【Self-written】
~ SECOND (with hyoyeon)【Self-written】
~ SYNK【Self-written】
~ Did You Wrong
~ Tia Tamera
KARINA -
~ Childish Adult
~ Bola Rebola
~ Mr. Simple
NINGNING -
~ Mariah
~ If I ain't got you
~ Way (with ONEW)
~ That Summer when we Graduated【Self-composed】
~ Rolling in the deep
INTERVIEWS: Song Association, Harper Bazaar, Allure Korea, 24 Hours with VOGUE
Winter ate and left no crumbs.
ningning slayed as expected
Winter sounds so stable but her energy did not match the energy of the other three but that's fine. Giselle and Ningning stood out and their energy really carried all of their performances. I can't wait to see more of their live performances, and for sure all of them will do better. ❤
Giselle and Ningning are more like the performers so yea
dont get me wrong coz i love OT4❤
Stage present from me
Ningning
Giselle
Karina
Winter
while ningning did not even sound stable, and shaky , they are vocalist for f*ckin sake, lol not some hyping round girls
@@부채-i8h it isnt always about being perfectly on pitch on the stage but about the stage presence or probably them too enjoying their own performance like the girls did.❤
@@부채-i8h haha ikr
I think aaron like ningning’s visual and winter ‘s vocals since that’s the thing that he point out in most of their videos
THEY DID SO GOODDDD!!!
man, for me the bests performers in this coachella
1. Ning Ning
2. Giselle
3. Karina
4. Winter
the background music was fucking loud and you can hear how they had to yell.
I have to say that Winter's live vocals r so gooooodddd it's well maintained and satisfying. They all did great 🤩🤩😭😭
THE HIGHNOTES!!!
yass karina vocal good too
next level was my fav stage of that night, pls react to that one next! and also life's too short was so good!
looking forward to react to NEXT LEVEL AND LIFES TOO SHORT! 🙏🤩
You were so invested in that reaction, that was so wholesome to see! Thank you for all your work on this channel man, I feel like I have someone who I can watch kpop with
We need next level and life it's too short
i'm sorry, but your expression is so funny🤣
Yeah . The first time I heard Savage, that was exactly my reaction to Karina's riffs and runs. Her voice is flavorful. Idk if I can have a permanent bias to Aespa 😂 I keep changing overtime every comeback or performance. Oh, I like them.
Karina is a vocal queen
And winter hitting those notes is the end of the conversation
Karina is capable to sing LIVE!
Next level and life to short
Their live vocals were insane 😭
NINGNING
Karina queen)))
Ofcourse their sounds so good, no one can beat SM when it comes to vocals.
WAITING FOR LIFE'S TOO SHORT AND NEXT LEVEL REACTION💗💗💗
NingNing really carried the whole group
I really appreciate the part of Giselle she hyped gurl if only the beat as good and they did a remix it would've been better
Karina reminds me of Dua Lipa's voice so good and addicting.
live singing and slaying
Ningning pisa tantooooo🛐🦋
Giselle is my Spirit Animal
I never thought this day would come that Savage would be sung live, this song is dang hard to sing!!! omz
Next level and Life is too short for hate please 🥺
next level pls!!
imo they had the best stage presence during next level, it was the last song they performed and you could tell they loosened up more after getting comfortable on stage
Next Level Coachella too
Aaron Dancing with Facial expressions Is lit❣
Please watch the "Next Level" Coachella performance.
Next Level next!!!
I'm so proud of aespa
Aespa vocal insane🔥🔥🥺
Aaron's face is looking so proud of our girls. 😊
3:16 enjoying the song way too much ♡♡
giselle's rapp was soo good, winter persistant vocal, and ningning whose got a chance to slap haters with her live vocal, and that "naAAAiiiSSeehh" are my fav part of this reaction video XD
I hate that they used so loud backtrack that we couldn't hear our girls sing clearly.
No one is taking about how good ning ning is
When i see blackpink and Aespa i feel aespa vocal more strong and blackpink just winner for the stage but they vocal looks tired then aespa.
Ningning is so good
Next level plis
Ningning own the show
NEXT LEVEL 🔥
Please do "life's too short" 🙏🏽
Live tốt thật sự. Mấy video kiểu này thì anti auto mù nhé, live dở là dở, diễn chán là diễn chán, không nói nhiều. Hề chúa!
Tụi nó nhắm vào fancam cuối Next Level đó.... Mong anh ấy reaction Next Level để xem ảnh nhận xét như thế nào..... Vì bài này là bài cuối nhóm hát rồi nhưng rõ ràng giọng hát vẫn ổn chứ đâu có tệ như anti phán
never seen Aaron this excited
Next Level toooo!!!
i really really like your reaction, thank u so much always appreciate karina's vocal~ please stay healthy aaron! can't wait to see more your reaction to aespa. please reaction to LA Vlog aespa at coachella, once again thank you
ningning ate
Aespa ❤️🔥
you look so fun throughout the vdo haha
i was literally watching your face the whole time😆
their vocals is sooo stable!
First
3:30 the moment i fell in love with her more
Life is too short next plsss
fiirst
wth arron is soo cutee
Please react to Le sserafim 'Fearless'
Reaction new song please
3 years of debut
NingNing🤟🤟🤟😘😘😘
Hello aaron I came to tell you that the new and the first girl group of HYBE has already debuted, the song is so good can you react them all with the debut album please (LESSERAFIM fearless)
Hey can you react to winter and ningning's ost please.its so good😎😎
Reaction Next Level too pls
Hello aaron I came to tell you that the new and the first girl group of HYBE has already debuted, the song is so good can you react them all with the debut album please (LESSERAFIM fearless)
Tbh they were trying to hype it up because if you can compare it to their mv or encore it's way more louder and they modulated some parts like on Giselle's part (everybody look at me) there but it's just that the arrangements are so poor.
I would like to hear Karina sing with Felix, I wondered what would it sound like..
Ooh, that's interesting! Makes me curious too.
Mau ra tiếp Life's too short và Next level nhé!!