Robin's voice is so velvety with a natural vibratto.I just love the BeeGees.Robin and his son R.J.did a song called "Don't cry alone "a little before he died. So sad but so beautiful. Maurice spoke about Barry and Robin's voices sometimes sounding as one voice when they sang together.
Thanks, DaX - Robin has always been my favorite (do you notice how often Robin is holding his "ear" - either with his hand or a headset? I love that he is so concentrated)- yeah, Barry is good & all, but I don't think the Bee Gees would have been what they were without Robin - and also Maurice (he could hit some high notes)... Robin was the most unique... and beautiful... look forward to more from you...
@@GinMae I agree that what made the Bee Gees the Bee Gees were all three of them together. But why was the dig on Barry necessary? You know, that little sly cutting Barry down to size things Robin fans are so good at. I actually suspect that it’s neither Barry, nor Robin, who are the real key to what makes them work, but Maurice. Barry and Maurice sounded really good together when Robin was gone-you don’t miss Robin in those particular songs at all, like Tomorrow Tomorrow. There’s a nice color to them, despite. Then I heard Barry and Robin together after Maurice died, and they sounded good, but it was lacking something. Depth maybe. I need to hear Robin and Maurice together to complete my study. Somehow Maurice’s voice makes the other person’s voice pop. I think Mo deserves a medal for being the forever forbearing and cooperative Bee Gee who never got his just dues. I also notice that when Barry and Robin sing in unison it’s almost impossible to tell their voices apart, except Barry has a pronounced tremolo at the end. In between, though, they sound like one voice.
I like their earlier songs as well. But Robin sings a beautiful song that he wrote for his brother Andy called For Whom The Bell Tolls. Robin is my favorite as well.
Trudy.....For Whom the Bell Tolls was written by all 3 brothers, & wasn't written for Andy. Wish You Were Here was written & dedicated to him in 1989 though.
Hello and thank for this reaction "Massachusetts" was their first #1 in UK Charts 1967 in my Top 5 of all BEE GEES songs: Massachusetts Lamplight My world Mr Natural Nights on Broadway GOD bless you Best regards from Argentina
Glad you had Lamplight in there. An absolute classic which never quite made it. The group broke up for a short period because the preferred single release from the Odessa album was 1st of May which was very successful. Cheers.
I remember this song well. Massachusetts came out in 1967 when I was 13. Grew up in the upper Hudson River Valley, just across the border from Western Mass..........
Three brothers, natural born three-part-harmony. And it's all leading to the chorus, whoever sang the verse. Blessed singers! Unique in a very special way. Unbeatable good. I'd like to bring near to you, three songs, with different leads of them: 'The Change Is Made' (Barry), 'And The Sun Will Shine' (Robin) and 'On Time' (Maurice). To me, they've always been equal, don't like to prefer one of them. Yaknow, that's a unit. Fact is, Barry(1.) and Robin (2.) got many leads because of more abilities. But Maurice was the one, that braught it to perfection in many choruses.
Actually Robin is still 39 here. This was recorded in Oct. and the twins birthday is Dec. 22. He is as hot as he ever was during this period (imo). I don't think he looks older than 40. I apologize for not adding a thing to the conversation at hand but I pretty . much never post anything that is not stupid shit about Robin Gibb.
Please react to IT DOESN'T MATTER MUCH TO ME By the Beegees... Robin sings the falsetto in this song. There is a song from the movie west side story called Somewhere...Robin sang this song when he was 16 years old. Other good songs that are older are While I play and Close another door....please react to these songs by the Beegees.
Hello, I see you for first time I prefer the songs from the first times of BEE GEES and Masachussets is one song I hope sing songs like In the morning Melody fair First of May Lampligth Wakking back to Waterloo Remembering My world Run to me Charade Come on over all of greatest ballads and I agree with you I love so much the emotional voice of Robin I hope to see you in more reactions Stay safe and be care
The Everly bros. Had great two-dude harmony. The blend with the barber shop style of the Osmond bros. was Remarkably well done. And the lead vocals of Michael along with his four other Jackson bros. made them pop legends. That said, No other group held my ear to the radio as did the Brothers Gibb.
Please react to ROBIN GIBB ELLAN VANNIN FEATURING KING WILLIAM’S CHIOR. (It’s the Isle of Mann’s national anthem with added verses by Robin, and filmed on the Isle of Mann for his Christmas album.) There is also a live version that he did at a Bee Gees appearance, but the official video is really special.
@@daxmusix - Ellan Vannin is beautiful. The version he did with the choir is very sad because he knew he was dying at the time and it was his final tribute as a Manx man.
Hey, you're going to notice a group of us RGs, aka Robin's Girls here👋 and I think I speak for the group when I say we liked those *ahem* tight jeans. Am I right? Where all my RGs at? Q? J2? J3? LJ?
daXmusiX - May I please request a couple of Bee Gees song reactions? "I can't see nobody" on "The Midnight Special". Soulful Robin solo - ruclips.net/video/ZYO4KQ4s0II/видео.html "She keeps on coming", a fun song - ruclips.net/video/QZHIUsL8oq0/видео.html Thanks, if possible. :)
What is this concert? I wonder if it’s the one you can buy. BTW, you’re wrong about Barry’s falsetto. He didn’t discover his falsetto until mid 70s, for Nights on Broadway. I prefer Barry’s voice. His voice just gets me every time. It’s so amazing and delicious. I also prefer him as a performer. To each their own.
It's from their 1989 One For All Melbourne concert. The tour began shortly after releasing their One album, which was dedicated to Andy. One of their best concert & one everyone should own!🎶
This is my favourite performance of this song. The ovation he got at the end was beautiful. He was so humble acknowledging it.
It’s awesome to see someone who loves and appreciates the BeeGees!
“There’s just something about his voice that gets me every time.”
My sentiments exactly.
I love this song and I love Robins voice. Thank you.
Barty discovered his falsetto recording nights on Broadway in 1975. All three have beautiful voices. Love this song
Great reactions! My favorite of Robin’s is I Can’t See Nobody live at Midnight Special 1973.❤️. So much emotion!!
Robin's beautiful voice and gorgeous face ❤❤❤❤❤🥰😍😘
Robin is so special. I'm not one for getting too sentimental over musicians when they die...but when he left the planet it broke my heart.
I cried for Mo, Robin and Meat Loaf.
Like your reaction a lot and thank you. Robin is always the best to me. Bee Gees 👍🤟
Didn’t realize it was a competition.
I teally like Robin's voice too..
They are so talented
Never truer words said than "there's just something about Robin".
Robin's voice is so velvety with a natural vibratto.I just love the BeeGees.Robin and his son R.J.did a song called "Don't cry alone "a little before he died.
So sad but so beautiful.
Maurice spoke about Barry and Robin's voices sometimes sounding as one voice when they sang together.
Holy smokes. U got it. Emotional voice. He puts his wrong heart and soul into every note. Actually they ALL do!!
Robin Gibb had a very unique voice that I love.
This whole concert is awsome.
Yes!
Robin's voice is very unusual to the point of unique 👌
Robin Gibb was my favorite voice of the three. So unique and vulnerable and lovely. It’s like a fine priceless violin played by a virtuoso.
I always favored Robin. he always did the soulful or sadder songs.
I love BEE GEES still.^^
Robin never got over molly
Thanks, DaX - Robin has always been my favorite (do you notice how often Robin is holding his "ear" - either with his hand or a headset? I love that he is so concentrated)- yeah, Barry is good & all, but I don't think the Bee Gees would have been what they were without Robin - and also Maurice (he could hit some high notes)... Robin was the most unique... and beautiful... look forward to more from you...
🙄 Just had to get that dig in on Barry, didn’t ya?
@@BGWhisperer ahh.. not really a "ding".. I love Barry, too... but you can definitely feel my preference, right? lol
@@GinMae I agree that what made the Bee Gees the Bee Gees were all three of them together. But why was the dig on Barry necessary? You know, that little sly cutting Barry down to size things Robin fans are so good at.
I actually suspect that it’s neither Barry, nor Robin, who are the real key to what makes them work, but Maurice. Barry and Maurice sounded really good together when Robin was gone-you don’t miss Robin in those particular songs at all, like Tomorrow Tomorrow. There’s a nice color to them, despite. Then I heard Barry and Robin together after Maurice died, and they sounded good, but it was lacking something. Depth maybe. I need to hear Robin and Maurice together to complete my study. Somehow Maurice’s voice makes the other person’s voice pop.
I think Mo deserves a medal for being the forever forbearing and cooperative Bee Gee who never got his just dues.
I also notice that when Barry and Robin sing in unison it’s almost impossible to tell their voices apart, except Barry has a pronounced tremolo at the end. In between, though, they sound like one voice.
Great Robin: For whom the bell tolls.
Love this song. It was special to me because I was born in Lowell, Massachusetts. Your right they seem to be just as good live as on recordings.
i'm here for the Bee Gees. I was into this group before disco. I love your reactions!
I like their earlier songs as well.
But Robin sings a beautiful song that he wrote for his brother Andy called For Whom The Bell Tolls.
Robin is my favorite as well.
Are you sure he wrote it alone? Hmm. Barry’s listed first.
Trudy.....For Whom the Bell Tolls was written by all 3 brothers, & wasn't written for Andy. Wish You Were Here was written & dedicated to him in 1989 though.
Hello and thank for this reaction
"Massachusetts" was their first #1 in UK Charts 1967
in my Top 5 of all BEE GEES songs:
Massachusetts
Lamplight
My world
Mr Natural
Nights on Broadway
GOD bless you
Best regards from Argentina
Thanks for the heads up, Eduardo!
Glad you had Lamplight in there. An absolute classic which never quite made it. The group broke up for a short period because the preferred single release from the Odessa album was 1st of May which was very successful. Cheers.
My favorite!!!❤❤❤
Watch the Beegees medley from 1963. They started performing as kids around the ages of 6/7 and Barry would have been 9/10.
I remember this song well. Massachusetts came out in 1967 when I was 13. Grew up in the upper Hudson River Valley, just across the border from Western Mass..........
Three brothers, natural born three-part-harmony. And it's all leading to the chorus, whoever sang the verse. Blessed singers! Unique in a very special way. Unbeatable good. I'd like to bring near to you, three songs, with different leads of them: 'The Change Is Made' (Barry), 'And The Sun Will Shine' (Robin) and 'On Time' (Maurice). To me, they've always been equal, don't like to prefer one of them. Yaknow, that's a unit. Fact is, Barry(1.) and Robin (2.) got many leads because of more abilities. But Maurice was the one, that braught it to perfection in many choruses.
Actually Robin is still 39 here. This was recorded in Oct. and the twins birthday is Dec. 22. He is as hot as he ever was during this period (imo). I don't think he looks older than 40.
I apologize for not adding a thing to the conversation at hand but I pretty .
much never post anything that is not stupid shit about Robin Gibb.
Please react to IT DOESN'T MATTER MUCH TO ME By the Beegees... Robin sings the falsetto in this song. There is a song from the movie west side story called Somewhere...Robin sang this song when he was 16 years old. Other
good songs that are older are While I play and Close another door....please react to these songs by the Beegees.
Hello,
I see you for first time
I prefer the songs from the first times of BEE GEES
and Masachussets is one song I hope sing
songs like
In the morning
Melody fair
First of May
Lampligth
Wakking back to Waterloo
Remembering
My world
Run to me
Charade
Come on over
all of greatest ballads
and I agree with you
I love so much the emotional voice of Robin
I hope to see you in more reactions
Stay safe and be care
Please react to FOR WHOM THE BELL TOLLS LIVE by the BEEGEES thanks
The Everly bros. Had great two-dude harmony. The blend with the barber shop style of the Osmond bros. was
Remarkably well done. And the lead vocals of Michael along with his four other Jackson bros. made them pop legends. That said, No other group held my ear to the radio as did the Brothers Gibb.
Amen to this. Well said!!
Please react to ROBIN GIBB ELLAN VANNIN FEATURING KING WILLIAM’S CHIOR. (It’s the Isle of Mann’s national anthem with added verses by Robin, and filmed on the Isle of Mann for his Christmas album.) There is also a live version that he did at a Bee Gees appearance, but the official video is really special.
That actually sounds quite interesting. I might just do that one. Thanks very much
@@daxmusix - Ellan Vannin is beautiful. The version he did with the choir is very sad because he knew he was dying at the time and it was his final tribute as a Manx man.
A beautiful song, beautiful ending
bee gees too much heaven
New York Mining Disaster is another Robin lead song.
Hey, you're going to notice a group of us RGs, aka Robin's Girls here👋 and I think I speak for the group when I say we liked those *ahem* tight jeans. Am I right? Where all my RGs at? Q? J2? J3? LJ?
You just can't get better than sibling harmony... The Bee Gee's r amazing. and just to let you know... it's not Maurice it's pronounced Morris
This is the best I've heard this
Please do Maurice’s song Man in the Middle.
I will get around to that, Sean. Thank you
Hi please...try love so right live 1976
That’s one of my favorites, Artie. I will definitely get to it. Thank you
Maurice is pronounced Morris. Just thought u may want to know😊
4 lads? Youngest Andy was born in Manchester. They left for Australia when he was a baby.
I misspoke on that. Thank you
Robin and Maurice are twins. Their family moved to the Queensland from Ise of Man in late 50s.
@@nakamura007 they moved to Queensland from Manchester, not the Isle of Man.
three part harmony💪
I read they never been to Massachusetts.
Isn’t it sad, he and his twin Maurice, was born a year later than me, and both are gone by now???
daXmusiX - May I please request a couple of Bee Gees song reactions?
"I can't see nobody" on "The Midnight Special". Soulful Robin solo - ruclips.net/video/ZYO4KQ4s0II/видео.html
"She keeps on coming", a fun song - ruclips.net/video/QZHIUsL8oq0/видео.html
Thanks, if possible. :)
👌👏
There was a song in Fever where Robin went into Falsetto and I cannot remember which it was. Maybe you do. It was the only song he did falsetto on.
daXmusiX.... it's pronounced Morris... pls
What is this concert? I wonder if it’s the one you can buy.
BTW, you’re wrong about Barry’s falsetto. He didn’t discover his falsetto until mid 70s, for Nights on Broadway.
I prefer Barry’s voice. His voice just gets me every time. It’s so amazing and delicious. I also prefer him as a performer. To each their own.
It's from their 1989 One For All Melbourne concert. The tour began shortly after releasing their One album, which was dedicated to Andy. One of their best concert & one everyone should own!🎶