It is only official native treaty borders which are similar to a total de facto depiction but not exactly, there are significant differences in various places
Never ask A woman: her age A man: his salary The internet: to be intellectually honest about Mormons Given that there were only around 100 black people in Utah at the time and, while most were slaves, they were also brought in by non-Mormon immigrants.
Would be a lot more complicated because the definition of Jim Crow law is kind of vague. You'll find a lot of people today who think Voter ID laws are in essence a Jim Crow law.
Respect for mentioning the modern continuation of slavery. You could've also mentioned that there's an exception in the 13th Amendment which allows penal slavery
This is such a good video, it deserves more views! Although I do wish the pace was a bit slower so I didnt have to pause every second to read the text lol
It's really impressive to see how slavery was not only a losing issue, but also a very polarizing hot issue in America between the late-1840s and early-1860s, and yet, the abolitionists get a way of abolish this cruel institution by the middle-1860s after America surviving a Civil War and thanks to the efforts of abolitionist figures like Thaddeus Stevens, Frederick Douglass, Horace Greeley and Samuel Chase to convince President Lincoln of the necessity of immediate abolition of slavery.
Yeah its crazy but once you really dive into the history it starts to really make you think how it took so LONG for war to break out with extreme tension events like the missuri compromise, compromise of 1850, bleeding kansas, spreading of the uncle toms cabin book, and the outcome of the dredd scot case. In pretty much every single one of these events we were on the brink of civil war, and some were decades before it actually happened.
As an independent republic, slavery was abolished in Vermont's constitution in 1777. I can see not including that in the map, since Vermont didn't join the United States until 1791, but it's worth noting.
Interesting. Nice job! I had no idea it was this convoluted. To this day in Alabama, and I'm sure many other southern states, the Civil War is referred to as "The War of Northern Aggression" or "The War for States' Rights". Many insist the slaves were better off than if they stayed in Africa. They consider MLK a "troublemaker", hate Lincoln and revere the Confederate generals. These attitudes are carefully and passionately passed down from generation to generation. The KKK still collects in the streets from time to time.
You know, the south generally fought against the northern states rights, such as the fugitive slave act, and wanted those states laws abolished, so it's kind of funny it's known as the war of states rights when the south was against state rights.
@@WeegeeSlayer123 Why him of all people? He was one of the worst generals in the war, being aggressive to the point of self-destruction. The Battles of Franklin and Nashville, and the Atlanta campaign, were massive failures. There are plenty of better Confederate generals to fanboy on.
People say that prisoners today being forced to do work with little to no pay is slavery and therefore should be illegal, except that the 13th Amendment explicitly abolishes slavery “except as punishment for a crime”.
For that, penal slavery has been formally abolished in Alabama, Colorado, Nebraska, Oregon, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Utah, and Vermont, in most cases within the past 6 years.
@@zed381no5 Back in the VHS rental '80s, me and my gal would rent the U kno what tapes and would peel off all the juicy parts onto another tape and add soundtracks like Disney's stuff (except it was progressive rock stuff), and you would be amazed at some of the match ups. I wish I still had that tape. Just talking about it brings back fond memories of my long since passed soul mate. Your reply triggered my memories. Thanks.
Also Missouri was one of the very first states to ratify the 13th Amendment already in January, 1865, and the Amendment would be completely ratified and passed only by December, 1865. The Great State of Missouri is a really great example of a former slave state that got rid of this inhumane institution alongside with Maryland, Delaware and Kentucky.
Keep in mind that Missouri was still a pro-Union state at the start of the war while also being a slave state. Along with Delaware, Maryland, and Kentucky.
New Jersey did not abolish slavery until Dec 31, 1865. It was the very last state to still have slaves though there were less that a 100 slaves in total at the time.
Abolition is complicated because the U.S. government was formed by the Articles of Confederation in 1777 then created a new gov't in 1789. Generaly states that came into the union under the U.S. Constitution (1789) came in as free states. The 3/5 compromise acknowledged slavery as a legal institution. 5th amendment (1791) reguired compensation to owners when their property was taken. So some states passed laws that children born after 1789 would be free but the children before that date were not and neither were the parents. Slaves could not be bought or sold in Ohio but slaves brought into the state were not freed until a law was enacted in 1841.
It wasn’t it was Lincoln and the Yankees that made the war later on about slavery. Yes the south had slavery but that was not there reason for leaving the union slavery of course played a part but was not by any means the main reason. The reasons why the South seceded was because we believed that we was too different from the northern Yankees. For example we were Baptist y’all were Catholic, we were small government yall were big government. And of course there’s more and that didn’t apply to everyone but in general. ( and the confederate flag down here represents our culture not racism, like me and a lot of other southerners we despise the Klan and all racism )
It is true that Lincoln's initial goal was not the abolition of slavery, but the preservation of the union, and only after seeing the death toll he decided to make it about slavery, as in, abolishing slavery was seen as a more righteous cause after so much blood. However, slavery was BY FAR the main cause of the Civil War. Even PragerU agrees with that in one of their vids.
I am actually currently working on a history of reservations in the Lower Penninsula of Michigan and Eastern Wisconsin post 1836 right now actually. Assuming the research goes well it will be the next video.
A North-South divide on slavery only became a reality in the 1820s. With states like NY or Pennsylvania only having adopted a gradual abolition approach it wasn't yet an issue that could unify a clear bloc around it at the national level. Once NY abolished it entirely then you had a clear North-South divide forming. Its also not an accident that it still took more than 20 years until this divide started to paralyze the country. A divide on paper still needs some time to filter through in society.
Not to mention extreme tension events like the missuri compromise, compromise of 1850, bleeding kansas, uncle toms cabin, and the outcome of the dredd scot case. All of those really helped solidify the division between the north and the south and drive hatred against one another.
I roughly understand Slavery but Racism would be an even interesting conversation, like in Boston the upper top of a teather isn't known as a nose bleed but the n-word by racist.
There was slavery in Southern Illinois in Gallatin County in what was known as The Crenshaw House or also the Old Slave House. Used to get salt from the salt wells near the Saline River.
This is wrong. New Jersey had about 20 slaves left in 1865. De Jure, they were indentured servants. De Facto, they were elderly slaves still owned by their masters.
This map wasn't a de facto, but a de jure map. In New Jersey, they were indentured servants as you said (even if they totally were still slaves in reality).
Looking at this map, it seems that slavery abolishion took a huge boost during 1861-65. I am glad that a peaceful, lasting solution was found for this issue.
Depends on what you'd consider a slavery. I'd rather view Irish forced labour (and cannon fodder in civil war) that northern states thoroughly used and abused as slaves too.
Excellent video! Especially liked the handling of the status of slavery during the civil war. Slavery was illegal in the "confederacy," but in practice the local regime was not obeying the law
*_ALL_* slavery and involuntary servitude is illegal unless seen as proper punishment for a crime, according to the 13th amendment. For the sake of simplicity, that basically means slavery is done with. Although yes, that does not mean slavery is gone and all is fine. Human trafficking is a big example, and is a big problem. It's a serious issue we need to tackle.
@@celavetexthe definition of human trafficking is absurdly broad though so those stats are skewed when you think of what the common person considers trafficking. Human trafficking is literally picking up a prostitute in a vehicle and transporting her for even one foot. Those stats are often skewed because of prostitution stings where the suspect is charged with human trafficking… but it isn’t Liam neeson style. The stats on involuntary servitude involving sexual exploitation in a,Erica is actually extremely small. Eastern Europe, parts of Asia and much of Africa have a big problem with that issue though
You completely left out the fact that slaves were brought to America BEFORE there was an America. Slaves arrived in 1619, and eventually became the Democrat-controlled plantation south. Whereas the first colonists (first hint of the USA) arrived one year later in 1620 and eventually established a constitution and abolished slavery.
@@CarpeVerpa , Spanish and English (and even a few black men in the Caribbean) bought them and transported to the USA. Eventually the Democrat party (d)evolved and nearly all owners (buyers/sellers) of slaves (property) were white Democrats.
Schrödinger's bleeding kansas
i dont know if kansas wants slaves or not until i look inside the polls
"This is not a de facto map."
Makes a better de facto map than anyone else's.
It is only official native treaty borders which are similar to a total de facto depiction but not exactly, there are significant differences in various places
New Jersey had about 20 slaves left in 1865.
Imagine being a slave in the Native American nations right after the civil war ended and silently waiting for them to abolish it
Never ask
A woman: her age
A man: his salary
A Mormon: the status of African-Americans in their state in 1861
African Americans never got treated normally till around 2020s now it’s reverse Jim Crow
Pls explain
@@microwave512No
Never ask
A woman: her age
A man: his salary
The internet: to be intellectually honest about Mormons
Given that there were only around 100 black people in Utah at the time and, while most were slaves, they were also brought in by non-Mormon immigrants.
Now, cover Jimcrow laws every year.
Be grateful and polite with your request and perhaps he will.
does he know?
Say please
Would be a lot more complicated because the definition of Jim Crow law is kind of vague. You'll find a lot of people today who think Voter ID laws are in essence a Jim Crow law.
Ah yes, *the Gamer Laws*
I am against slavery
So much for the tolerant left!
hahahaha@@zalqert
What a hot take!
I am not a big fan of slavery
Slaves should be free
Respect for mentioning the modern continuation of slavery. You could've also mentioned that there's an exception in the 13th Amendment which allows penal slavery
It does say that. 1:49 "excluding as a punishment for a crime"
This is such a good video, it deserves more views! Although I do wish the pace was a bit slower so I didnt have to pause every second to read the text lol
It's really impressive to see how slavery was not only a losing issue, but also a very polarizing hot issue in America between the late-1840s and early-1860s, and yet, the abolitionists get a way of abolish this cruel institution by the middle-1860s after America surviving a Civil War and thanks to the efforts of abolitionist figures like Thaddeus Stevens, Frederick Douglass, Horace Greeley and Samuel Chase to convince President Lincoln of the necessity of immediate abolition of slavery.
Yeah its crazy but once you really dive into the history it starts to really make you think how it took so LONG for war to break out with extreme tension events like the missuri compromise, compromise of 1850, bleeding kansas, spreading of the uncle toms cabin book, and the outcome of the dredd scot case. In pretty much every single one of these events we were on the brink of civil war, and some were decades before it actually happened.
@@PappyP Indeed, you're right
1780:
Pennsylvania: gradual abolition
Neighbors: why abolishing?
1845:
Pennsylvania: gradual abolition
Neughbors: why still not fully abolished?
As an independent republic, slavery was abolished in Vermont's constitution in 1777. I can see not including that in the map, since Vermont didn't join the United States until 1791, but it's worth noting.
"inside is a provision abolishing slavery in the new territory. It is unknown why it was included or who wrote it."
Strange and fascinating.
Live long and prosper by not being a slaver.
Interesting. Nice job! I had no idea it was this convoluted. To this day in Alabama, and I'm sure many other southern states, the Civil War is referred to as "The War of Northern Aggression" or "The War for States' Rights". Many insist the slaves were better off than if they stayed in Africa. They consider MLK a "troublemaker", hate Lincoln and revere the Confederate generals. These attitudes are carefully and passionately passed down from generation to generation. The KKK still collects in the streets from time to time.
I'm sure the Crimson Tide is more popular than the KKK in Alabama.
You know, the south generally fought against the northern states rights, such as the fugitive slave act, and wanted those states laws abolished, so it's kind of funny it's known as the war of states rights when the south was against state rights.
I like John Bell Hood because he was a gallant general despite his shortcomings.
@@WeegeeSlayer123 Why him of all people? He was one of the worst generals in the war, being aggressive to the point of self-destruction. The Battles of Franklin and Nashville, and the Atlanta campaign, were massive failures. There are plenty of better Confederate generals to fanboy on.
@@aaronTGP_3756 Not everyone is born to experience success. He was still a galant man, and I'll fanboy for whoever I feel like.
People say that prisoners today being forced to do work with little to no pay is slavery and therefore should be illegal, except that the 13th Amendment explicitly abolishes slavery “except as punishment for a crime”.
For that, penal slavery has been formally abolished in Alabama, Colorado, Nebraska, Oregon, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Utah, and Vermont, in most cases within the past 6 years.
This is a freaking amazing map!!! Great work!!
Just a notice but why do you always use this music from Yan Xishan's "History of Tibet during the 20th century Every Day"
I like that piece a lot, it’s short and it matches the events fairly well when I use it
@@zed381no5 Back in the VHS rental '80s, me and my gal would rent the U kno what tapes and would peel off all the juicy parts onto another tape and add soundtracks like Disney's stuff (except it was progressive rock stuff), and you would be amazed at some of the match ups. I wish I still had that tape. Just talking about it brings back fond memories of my long since passed soul mate. Your reply triggered my memories. Thanks.
The music goes hard asf
fr
Missouri abolished slavery in 1864, not 1865.
Also Missouri was one of the very first states to ratify the 13th Amendment already in January, 1865, and the Amendment would be completely ratified and passed only by December, 1865. The Great State of Missouri is a really great example of a former slave state that got rid of this inhumane institution alongside with Maryland, Delaware and Kentucky.
@@elionlima9055
Do not forget West Virginia, which abolished slavery in 1864 as well, a year after it became a state.
@@italia689 Indeed.
🤓🤓🤓🤓
Keep in mind that Missouri was still a pro-Union state at the start of the war while also being a slave state. Along with Delaware, Maryland, and Kentucky.
New Jersey did not abolish slavery until Dec 31, 1865. It was the very last state to still have slaves though there were less that a 100 slaves in total at the time.
American civil war(1861-1865)🇺🇸✝️🕊️☮️
make the texts larger
Can't believe, Ohio, of all the states, is the first one to arise with slavery already abolished
Abolition is complicated because the U.S. government was formed by the Articles of Confederation in 1777 then created a new gov't in 1789. Generaly states that came into the union under the U.S. Constitution (1789) came in as free states. The 3/5 compromise acknowledged slavery as a legal institution. 5th amendment (1791) reguired compensation to owners when their property was taken. So some states passed laws that children born after 1789 would be free but the children before that date were not and neither were the parents. Slaves could not be bought or sold in Ohio but slaves brought into the state were not freed until a law was enacted in 1841.
“The civil war wasn’t about slavery”
It wasn’t it was Lincoln and the Yankees that made the war later on about slavery. Yes the south had slavery but that was not there reason for leaving the union slavery of course played a part but was not by any means the main reason. The reasons why the South seceded was because we believed that we was too different from the northern Yankees. For example we were Baptist y’all were Catholic, we were small government yall were big government. And of course there’s more and that didn’t apply to everyone but in general. ( and the confederate flag down here represents our culture not racism, like me and a lot of other southerners we despise the Klan and all racism )
It is true that Lincoln's initial goal was not the abolition of slavery, but the preservation of the union, and only after seeing the death toll he decided to make it about slavery, as in, abolishing slavery was seen as a more righteous cause after so much blood. However, slavery was BY FAR the main cause of the Civil War. Even PragerU agrees with that in one of their vids.
great video
can you do a history of michigan and the defacto control of Indian lands compared to us controlled lands
I am actually currently working on a history of reservations in the Lower Penninsula of Michigan and Eastern Wisconsin post 1836 right now actually.
Assuming the research goes well it will be the next video.
The amount of detail is incredible
Uh oh here come the pro slavery trolls here to call you a fanatic just for opposing it
One month later....
Nope
Whats wrong with slavery> Genuine question
A North-South divide on slavery only became a reality in the 1820s. With states like NY or Pennsylvania only having adopted a gradual abolition approach it wasn't yet an issue that could unify a clear bloc around it at the national level. Once NY abolished it entirely then you had a clear North-South divide forming. Its also not an accident that it still took more than 20 years until this divide started to paralyze the country. A divide on paper still needs some time to filter through in society.
Not to mention extreme tension events like the missuri compromise, compromise of 1850, bleeding kansas, uncle toms cabin, and the outcome of the dredd scot case. All of those really helped solidify the division between the north and the south and drive hatred against one another.
which one of you mfs gonna say “wish we could turn back time”
awesome video bro
I roughly understand Slavery but Racism would be an even interesting conversation, like in Boston the upper top of a teather isn't known as a nose bleed but the n-word by racist.
Now do Barbary and Muslim slave trades
There was slavery in Southern Illinois in Gallatin County in what was known as The Crenshaw House or also the Old Slave House. Used to get salt from the salt wells near the Saline River.
wish we could turn back time
to the good old daaaaayzzz
among us
It surprised me that half of today USA was still Indian lands even at 1850. Such a conquering lol
This is wrong. New Jersey had about 20 slaves left in 1865. De Jure, they were indentured servants. De Facto, they were elderly slaves still owned by their masters.
This map wasn't a de facto, but a de jure map. In New Jersey, they were indentured servants as you said (even if they totally were still slaves in reality).
Looking at this map, it seems that slavery abolishion took a huge boost during 1861-65. I am glad that a peaceful, lasting solution was found for this issue.
You are being sarcastic, right?
Uh...
As a slave I would like to say great job!
sTaTeS riGhTs
damn i coudlve ebeen rich by havin monke farm
green based
Depends on what you'd consider a slavery. I'd rather view Irish forced labour (and cannon fodder in civil war) that northern states thoroughly used and abused as slaves too.
This video is about chattel slavery, where the person is legal property. This was not the Irish situation.
Tell me you are from south of the Mason-Dixon without telling me you are from south of the Mason-Dixon.
Don't cry because it's over smile because it happened
?
*Excuse me?*
this is wrong, I still have a girlfriend
Team Brown #inclusive 🤎
Oh the old gold times
This is proportionally minuscule to nearly every other culture/race on the entire planet
Wish we could turn back times 😣
slay
Excellent video! Especially liked the handling of the status of slavery during the civil war. Slavery was illegal in the "confederacy," but in practice the local regime was not obeying the law
Not slavery. Obvious forms of slavery. Slavery still exist at USA.
This video specifically talks about Chattel Slavery
it does say that in outro
*_ALL_* slavery and involuntary servitude is illegal unless seen as proper punishment for a crime, according to the 13th amendment. For the sake of simplicity, that basically means slavery is done with.
Although yes, that does not mean slavery is gone and all is fine. Human trafficking is a big example, and is a big problem. It's a serious issue we need to tackle.
@@celavetex That also means legal slavery is still allowed for those convicted of crimes, which is maybe not good and worth addressing as well.
@@celavetexthe definition of human trafficking is absurdly broad though so those stats are skewed when you think of what the common person considers trafficking. Human trafficking is literally picking up a prostitute in a vehicle and transporting her for even one foot. Those stats are often skewed because of prostitution stings where the suspect is charged with human trafficking… but it isn’t Liam neeson style. The stats on involuntary servitude involving sexual exploitation in a,Erica is actually extremely small. Eastern Europe, parts of Asia and much of Africa have a big problem with that issue though
You completely left out the fact that slaves were brought to America BEFORE there was an America.
Slaves arrived in 1619, and eventually became the Democrat-controlled plantation south.
Whereas the first colonists (first hint of the USA) arrived one year later in 1620 and eventually established a constitution and abolished slavery.
He talked about it in the beginning
Who brought the slaves in 1619? Did they just bring themselves and start voting Democrat?
@@CarpeVerpa , Spanish and English (and even a few black men in the Caribbean) bought them and transported to the USA. Eventually the Democrat party (d)evolved and nearly all owners (buyers/sellers) of slaves (property) were white Democrats.
@@joeydutton8074 yea
white
with a big undercurrent of jews
@@through-faith-alonetf